Cosmic Yak
Philosopher
It seems you forgot to read much of the recent discussion. I am practically begging others to provide relevant data, as I am finding nothing else solid here.
No, you're not. You have been provided with loads of relevant data, and have handwaved away all of it.
Moreover, it is your claim that the Australian system does not work. It is therefore up to you to provide evidence for that claim. Burden of proof, remember?
On first hearing about the underage worker story, it was stunning to hear that she had not been cleared to work by the State. It simply didn't occur to me that Oz would work that way. Perhaps it's because I live in NJ USA, and you can't be a legal contractor without registering your ass up one side and down the other.
If it is your claim that no-one in NJ is working without a licence, it is up to you to prove it.
Yes, I know that's an impossible thing to prove: it just shows what a ridiculous argument you are making here. In every aspect of life, there will be people who slip through the cracks, who game the system, who break the law and get away with it, or who fail to do their jobs properly. I have no doubt whatsoever that New Jersey is no exception to this.
Wait: is that the problem, here? I'm trying to get a handle on how the Australian model works in practice, then see how it could be applied here.
No, you aren't. You are desperately trying to invent reasons not to apply it to America, because icky.
But I may be making assumptions about how they generally do business. To an American ear, a "regulated industry" does not mean that rules are simply in place. It means they are freaking enforced (or at least major efforts made to verify compliance at all levels). The child sex worker couldn't have even begun working in the States; she would have been red-flagged for failing the age verification before starting work. I'm beginning to see that this is not how Oz rolls?
Rubbish.
https://www.dol.gov/newsroom/releases/whd/whd20220729Since 2015, the [Washington] department’s Wage and Hour Division has seen increases in child labor investigations and violations. In fiscal year 2021, the division found 2,819 minors employed in violation of the law and assessed employers with nearly $3.4 million in civil money penalties.
Tragically, the division also investigates the deaths of young workers, including three in 2021, and a May 2022 fatality where a 16-year-old worker doing construction fell more than 160 feet to the ground after trying to jump from a roof to a nearby powered lift in Nashville, Tennessee.
Several other examples of the employment of minors in other hazardous areas are listed in this source.
America is not the tightly-regulated paradise you claim it to be. Nowhere is. Did someone mention the 'perfect solution' fallacy?
I didn't remotely suggest that they were, nor do I think they are. Please don't lie.
Firstly, I was not lying, and please don't make personal attacks.
Next: if you are not claiming that sex workers outside brothels are being abused and exploited, and you are also not saying they aren't paying their taxes, then what exactly are you so het up about?
Be precise. What, specifically and exactly, is your issue with the 90% of sex workers not being in legal brothels?
Not that I advocated that, but to answer anyway: coerced people tend to be coerced into doing what they wouldn't want to, usually under threat or other duress.
An assertion for which you have precisely ZERO evidence. Indeed, in the only case we have seen so far, of the underage dominatrix, there was no suggestion of coercion at all.
What evidence do you have for your claim that abuse is happening, and not being reported, because of coercion?
Yet again, I am practically begging for other relevant evidence. I get only crickets.
No. It's your claim, so it's your burden of proof. It's not up to anyone else to support your claims.
Eta: oh, and "my repugnance"? I have none, and as I have already said directly to you, I favor decriminalization. I'm just not sure how to make it work here. Please stop lying and putting words in my mouth.
Sorry, but it is you who are lying here. Read your own posts, and try to find any actual evidence for your dogged opposition to what's happening in Australia and New Zealand.
Yet again, I am pleading for more data. I'm not finding any.
Yet again: your claim, your burden of proof.
Oh, and perfect solution fallacy? Bull ****. I am actually proposing a working modification (individual licensing/registration tied to a database), which is the opposite of that fallacy. Please, please stop lying.
I will ask again that you stop the accusations of lying. I will report you next time. Don't make this personal.
And you are not answering my point. You have taken one case of illegality, and extended it to encompass- and damn- the entire industry. If you dispute that, please explain why you are so invested in using this one example.
If you can't honestly answer that for yourself, given my above replies, you are committing to living under the bridge with some of the others ITT.
In other words, you are unaware of how many instances of illegality have been missed by the authorities. Not one word of your post here addresses my question, and so my inability to answer that does not make me a troll: it makes me a good reader.
Once again: what evidence do you have for your claims? If you have none, why are you assuming it is a widespread problem? If you are not assuming it is a widespread problem, why are you making such a big deal out of this one instance?