Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
It seems you forgot to read much of the recent discussion. I am practically begging others to provide relevant data, as I am finding nothing else solid here.

No, you're not. You have been provided with loads of relevant data, and have handwaved away all of it.
Moreover, it is your claim that the Australian system does not work. It is therefore up to you to provide evidence for that claim. Burden of proof, remember?

On first hearing about the underage worker story, it was stunning to hear that she had not been cleared to work by the State. It simply didn't occur to me that Oz would work that way. Perhaps it's because I live in NJ USA, and you can't be a legal contractor without registering your ass up one side and down the other.

If it is your claim that no-one in NJ is working without a licence, it is up to you to prove it.
Yes, I know that's an impossible thing to prove: it just shows what a ridiculous argument you are making here. In every aspect of life, there will be people who slip through the cracks, who game the system, who break the law and get away with it, or who fail to do their jobs properly. I have no doubt whatsoever that New Jersey is no exception to this.

Wait: is that the problem, here? I'm trying to get a handle on how the Australian model works in practice, then see how it could be applied here.

No, you aren't. You are desperately trying to invent reasons not to apply it to America, because icky.

But I may be making assumptions about how they generally do business. To an American ear, a "regulated industry" does not mean that rules are simply in place. It means they are freaking enforced (or at least major efforts made to verify compliance at all levels). The child sex worker couldn't have even begun working in the States; she would have been red-flagged for failing the age verification before starting work. I'm beginning to see that this is not how Oz rolls?

Rubbish.
Since 2015, the [Washington] department’s Wage and Hour Division has seen increases in child labor investigations and violations. In fiscal year 2021, the division found 2,819 minors employed in violation of the law and assessed employers with nearly $3.4 million in civil money penalties.

Tragically, the division also investigates the deaths of young workers, including three in 2021, and a May 2022 fatality where a 16-year-old worker doing construction fell more than 160 feet to the ground after trying to jump from a roof to a nearby powered lift in Nashville, Tennessee.
https://www.dol.gov/newsroom/releases/whd/whd20220729

Several other examples of the employment of minors in other hazardous areas are listed in this source.
America is not the tightly-regulated paradise you claim it to be. Nowhere is. Did someone mention the 'perfect solution' fallacy?

I didn't remotely suggest that they were, nor do I think they are. Please don't lie.

Firstly, I was not lying, and please don't make personal attacks.
Next: if you are not claiming that sex workers outside brothels are being abused and exploited, and you are also not saying they aren't paying their taxes, then what exactly are you so het up about?
Be precise. What, specifically and exactly, is your issue with the 90% of sex workers not being in legal brothels?

Not that I advocated that, but to answer anyway: coerced people tend to be coerced into doing what they wouldn't want to, usually under threat or other duress.

An assertion for which you have precisely ZERO evidence. Indeed, in the only case we have seen so far, of the underage dominatrix, there was no suggestion of coercion at all.
What evidence do you have for your claim that abuse is happening, and not being reported, because of coercion?

Yet again, I am practically begging for other relevant evidence. I get only crickets.

No. It's your claim, so it's your burden of proof. It's not up to anyone else to support your claims.

Eta: oh, and "my repugnance"? I have none, and as I have already said directly to you, I favor decriminalization. I'm just not sure how to make it work here. Please stop lying and putting words in my mouth.

Sorry, but it is you who are lying here. Read your own posts, and try to find any actual evidence for your dogged opposition to what's happening in Australia and New Zealand.

Yet again, I am pleading for more data. I'm not finding any.

Yet again: your claim, your burden of proof.

Oh, and perfect solution fallacy? Bull ****. I am actually proposing a working modification (individual licensing/registration tied to a database), which is the opposite of that fallacy. Please, please stop lying.

I will ask again that you stop the accusations of lying. I will report you next time. Don't make this personal.
And you are not answering my point. You have taken one case of illegality, and extended it to encompass- and damn- the entire industry. If you dispute that, please explain why you are so invested in using this one example.

If you can't honestly answer that for yourself, given my above replies, you are committing to living under the bridge with some of the others ITT.

In other words, you are unaware of how many instances of illegality have been missed by the authorities. Not one word of your post here addresses my question, and so my inability to answer that does not make me a troll: it makes me a good reader.
Once again: what evidence do you have for your claims? If you have none, why are you assuming it is a widespread problem? If you are not assuming it is a widespread problem, why are you making such a big deal out of this one instance?
 
If it is your claim that no-one in NJ is working without a licence, it is up to you to prove it.

<snipping a little for focus>

I absolutely made no such claim, and that is the heart of our repeated conflicts in our exchanges. You are reading in three times more than I am posting.

America is not the tightly-regulated paradise you claim it to be. Nowhere is. Did someone mention the 'perfect solution' fallacy?

You are making an example of it with your example here. Of course no environment will be free of abuses; that's practically impossible. But we can numb out widespread abuse with minimal efforts. Simple registration works wonders to that end.

Firstly, I was not lying, and please don't make personal attacks.

Fair call, my apologies. Frustration gets the better of me on occasion.

Next: if you are not claiming that sex workers outside brothels are being abused and exploited, and you are also not saying they aren't paying their taxes, then what exactly are you so het up about?
Be precise. What, specifically and exactly, is your issue with the 90% of sex workers not being in legal brothels?

I refuse to repeat it anymore. If you and others won't listen the first dozen times, I expect nothing different the next dozen repetitions.

You have taken one case of illegality, and extended it to encompass- and damn- the entire industry. If you dispute that, please explain why you are so invested in using this one example.

OK, I'll repeat this one yet again for the last time:

Because this one example exposes a flaw that myself and others would not have even expected, and appears to be baked in. The State doesn't verify age for working in the sex industry. It is left to the employer, or in this case, some shady middleman son/"manager" who clearly didn't give a ****, as long as the child gave a literal ****. That is outrageous to my ears.

It's not the one case; it's what the case reveals about the honor system-style regulation, in an industry that should require more oversight than simply trusting the exploiters to follow the rules.
 
So the prostitutes in my neck of the woods are almost entirely streetwalkers, or streetwalkers funneling through an escort agency.

...are you able to provide a cite for that? Because the research and the evidence tells us that only about 10-20% of sex workers are streetwalkers.

Physical brothels aren't really a thing around here. So how do we keep criminals, underage hookers, and STI riddled workers out of the game? Registration.

Can you provide some information on places that have mandatory registration for sex workers that have both 1) the majority of sex workers will register and 2) registration is responsible for keeping criminals, underage hookers, and STI riddled workers out of the game?

Anonymity is where our criminal element thrives, and they rely on it. Take it out of the equation, and they are playing above board just like any other respectable and law-abiding self-employed contractor. They can contract through a house for convenience, or go solo and keep all the loot. But what they can't practically do is defy the regulations. It would be hard-wired into getting registered.

How do you "hard wire" this? The way you've described this registration process as working is that sex workers would have to pay a fee, they would have to be registered with the state, their data would be accessible by third parties. There is already significant mistrust of the authorities in America, with the research telling us that sex workers experience more harassment and abuse from the agents of the state than they do from their clients. So how do you turn that around?

Banquetbear posted that it didn't work in Germany, but that seems to be related to some weird requirement to register with the local town.

It's actually related to the fact that they register their profession, they provide their registered address, the places they work, that they have to carry around a special ID card that has been dubbed "the Whore Card." It has driven much of the industry back underground, meaning that they are more likely to end up working with criminals, less likely to seek help from the police, all the things that you are imagining that registration would fix would lead to the absolute opposite of outcomes.

I don't see a need for that. A brothel would have to, as it is a semi-permanent business, but not a freelance sex contractor.

So who would freelance sex contractors register with then? How are you imagining that this would work?

I get the impression from our Oceanic posters that you guys find any kind of identification as really invasive.

If you think that Oceanic posters find any kind of identification as really invasive, wait till you hear about First Amendment Auditors.

Because this one example exposes a flaw that myself and others would not have even expected, and appears to be baked in. The State doesn't verify age for working in the sex industry. It is left to the employer, or in this case, some shady middleman son/"manager" who clearly didn't give a ****, as long as the child gave a literal ****. That is outrageous to my ears.

Then you are gonna be absolutely horrified at who is responsible for verifying and keeping the records of people who work in the porn industry in the US.

It's not the one case; it's what the case reveals about the honor system-style regulation, in an industry that should require more oversight than simply trusting the exploiters to follow the rules.

Until you present more than just one case: it is just one case.
 
I hear what you're saying, and I get it. It's conceptually a pretty straight-up thing. What I'm thinking about for the States is based on my experience with my fellow Americans: they're just not nice people.

When you break it down, I don't think there's that much in it. Plenty of Kiwis are revolting *****.

I get the impression from our Oceanic posters that you guys find any kind of identification as really invasive.

Too spoiled by it never being compulsory to carry ID unless you're driving. The irony that everyone carries a phone isn't lost on me.
 
I think it should be legal everywhere. It is ridiculous in the US.
I agree.

I get the impression from our Oceanic posters that you guys find any kind of identification as really invasive. Smartcooky just posted about the "hoops" he had to jump through to get a bank account, and what he described is pretty much the same procedure we have gone through for years in the States. Maybe your general population is more socially cooperative than ours. Ours is a bunch of ******* mad dogs waiting for their next legal loophole to exploit. See Trump, life of for more information on that..
See also Collectivism vs. Individualism. The United States is widely regarded as a highly individualistic society. In Australia and New Zealand, ordinary people are more prepared to work for the collective good. We are more willing to accept a little personal inconvenience if the benefits to society are clear. Hence we're okay with very strict identity requirements like Smartcooky has described.
 
I agree.

See also Collectivism vs. Individualism. The United States is widely regarded as a highly individualistic society. In Australia and New Zealand, ordinary people are more prepared to work for the collective good. We are more willing to accept a little personal inconvenience if the benefits to society are clear. Hence we're okay with very strict identity requirements like Smartcooky has described.

Off Topic but just sayin' - there is nothing in recent history that demonstrates this fact more clearly than our response to the Covid-19 pandemic.

In NZ and Australia, with a very few exceptions, pretty much 97% of the population accepted that measures the government took were necessary and apart from a few right-wing extremists, bigoted religious cultists and antivaxxer nutcases, we mostly complied. In the USA, the response was a literal **** show - political infighting, Governors and a President lying and making stupid decisions that literally killed people!
 
Off Topic but just sayin' - there is nothing in recent history that demonstrates this fact more clearly than our response to the Covid-19 pandemic.

In NZ and Australia, with a very few exceptions, pretty much 97% of the population accepted that measures the government took were necessary and apart from a few right-wing extremists, bigoted religious cultists and antivaxxer nutcases, we mostly complied. In the USA, the response was a literal **** show - political infighting, Governors and a President lying and making stupid decisions that literally killed people!
Right now we're seeing communities coming together to help each other get through catastrophic flooding. But yeah, a little off-topic. :)
 
<snipping a little for focus>
If it is your claim that no-one in NJ is working without a licence, it is up to you to prove it.
I absolutely made no such claim, and that is the heart of our repeated conflicts in our exchanges. You are reading in three times more than I am posting.

Yes, you did:
It seems you forgot to read much of the recent discussion. I am practically begging others to provide relevant data, as I am finding nothing else solid here. On first hearing about the underage worker story, it was stunning to hear that she had not been cleared to work by the State. It simply didn't occur to me that Oz would work that way. Perhaps it's because I live in NJ USA, and you can't be a legal contractor without registering your ass up one side and down the other.

That's what you said. Your words.

You are making an example of it with your example here. Of course no environment will be free of abuses; that's practically impossible. But we can numb out widespread abuse with minimal efforts. Simple registration works wonders to that end.

1. It has been explained to you over and over and over again why 'simple registration' does not work. You simply refuse to listen.
2. Your claim of 'widespread abuse' is asserted yet again without any supporting evidence. Why do you keep saying this?

Fair call, my apologies. Frustration gets the better of me on occasion.

Thank you.

Next: if you are not claiming that sex workers outside brothels are being abused and exploited, and you are also not saying they aren't paying their taxes, then what exactly are you so het up about?
Be precise. What, specifically and exactly, is your issue with the 90% of sex workers not being in legal brothels?

I refuse to repeat it anymore. If you and others won't listen the first dozen times, I expect nothing different the next dozen repetitions.

Then please link to at least one post in which you did explain it, because you seem to be the only participant in this thread that believes you have done so. No-one else- AFAIK- has seen these multiple explanations.


OK, I'll repeat this one yet again for the last time:

Because this one example exposes a flaw that myself and others would not have even expected, and appears to be baked in. The State doesn't verify age for working in the sex industry.

Baked in? Really? How have you concluded this, based on a single instance?

It is left to the employer, or in this case, some shady middleman son/"manager" who clearly didn't give a ****, as long as the child gave a literal ****. That is outrageous to my ears.

My understanding is that, in any profession, validating a potential employee's details is primarily the responsibility of the employer. I have linked to examples of failures of this responsibility in the US. I note you have ignored them.
Is it your wish that the government directly supervises all personnel recruitment nationwide? Is that what you believe happens in the US?

It's not the one case; it's what the case reveals about the honor system-style regulation, in an industry that should require more oversight than simply trusting the exploiters to follow the rules.

To repeat what I said above: what level of regulation would satisfy you? Are you calling for all businesses to be state-controlled? What level of state interference and control over private enterprises would satisfy you?
And yes, it is about that one case because you aren't aware of any others. Extrapolating that single instance to claim that it represents widespread abuse (your words) is not founded on facts.
It would be beneficial if you could address my other points, especially the one about non-reporting of abuse due to coercion. Do you have any factual grounds for making this allegation?
 
Yes, you did:
That's what you said. Your words.

I'm going to harp on this in more detail than is necessary, because as I said, it's at the heart of our repeated conflicts.

I said, as you quoted, that to be a legal contractor, you have to be registered. Did you notice that highlighted, bolded, and italicized word, in there? It's rather important. It means that if you are going to be a law-abiding, above-board contractor, you must be registered. This says absolutely nothing about illegal contractors, and whether or not they exist (which they obviously do). My statement was true and accurate in every conceivable sense.

Then you extrapolate that I say there are no contractors working without a license in NJ. Your extrapolation does not in any sane way follow from my statement.

Before we continue, you need to address this, as you are doubling down on extrapolating an unrelated Y from my statement X. You've been doing this repeatedly, and we will see more below.

1. It has been explained to you over and over and over again why 'simple registration' does not work. You simply refuse to listen.

It has not. Banquetbear cited some Germans who didn't like a different version of registration, mainly relying on "they don't trust The Man". If you are a legal worker doing legal contracting, it doesn't matter if you personally trust The Man and prefer a criminal lifestyle. That's what every criminal says to justify doing illegal stuff.

At no point has anyone else ITT "explained why simple registration does not work". No one. Anywhere.

2. Your claim of 'widespread abuse' is asserted yet again without any supporting evidence. Why do you keep saying this?

Yet again, you extrapolate Y from X. I don't think there is widespread abuse in the Oceanic models. No one has any idea, really.

What I am slowly and clearly repeating is that the proposed model I am kicking around for the States would prevent widespread abuse.

What do I mean by that? The average age that an American hooker gets into the trade is 15 years old. That's the average. Some, obviously, would be even younger. Underage hooking is an indisputable problem in the States.

You and others here may think that is not a big deal. I do, and I think that a solution has to be baked into any model of legalization. Registration would seem to work, assuming Johns prefer the legal model over continuing with the criminal, which I'm sure many would.

Then please link to at least one post in which you did explain it, because you seem to be the only participant in this thread that believes you have done so. No-one else- AFAIK- has seen these multiple explanations.

Jesus Christ, you're going to demand I recite the thread to you again? We did this earlier, remember? I did so, after much argumentation about whose burden it was, and you were satisfied with my response. Remember? Now you ask the same goddamned thing again. No. It is not now, nor was it then, my responsibility to read the thread back to you.

Baked in? Really? How have you concluded this, based on a single instance?

Jesus Christ. In the same way I have described repeatedly. The story says the manager didn't verify the girl's age. There is no mention of the State having somehow failed. That would imply that the State takes no role in verifying the age of workers, which is, as I have said repeatedly, shocking to an American ear, as the US redundantly verifies a worker's ID before they can begin employment.

I have asked repeatedly if anyone has other data on how age verification works in Oz, as I can't find anything. Lacking anything else, I'm going with the reporting. If you have better information, it is most welcome.

My understanding is that, in any profession, validating a potential employee's details is primarily the responsibility of the employer. I have linked to examples of failures of this responsibility in the US. I note you have ignored them.

I have indeed ignored them because they seem utterly irrelevant. Do you see the highlighted word above? Employees. Sex workers are considered contractors, not employees. Apples and oranges. An employer is responsible for their employees in many different ways, while a contractor is mostly responsible for themselves.

Interesting sidebar: Australian sex worker advocate groups are trying to change their designation. They claim that although they are independent contractors (which gives them the freedoms to choose/refuse clients, and how much they charge, and their hours, etc), they are closer to being employees, and want the benefits that an employee would reap. Basically, they want the best of both worlds. In the States, we call that being a "statutory employee", and it's a difficult grey area to negotiate. I've been involved in contractor litigations where this issue comes up, and judges hate it. It's insanely difficult to prove that someone falls into this category, and which treatment they are entitled to.

Is it your wish that the government directly supervises all personnel recruitment nationwide? Is that what you believe happens in the US?

No, and no. You are extrapolating and reading in, again.

To repeat what I said above: what level of regulation would satisfy you? Are you calling for all businesses to be state-controlled? What level of state interference and control over private enterprises would satisfy you?
And yes, it is about that one case because you aren't aware of any others. Extrapolating that single instance to claim that it represents widespread abuse (your words) is not founded on facts.

Addressed above.

It would be beneficial if you could address my other points, especially the one about non-reporting of abuse due to coercion. Do you have any factual grounds for making this allegation?

I have the factual grounds of what "coercion" means, and that it exists. Do you deny that coercion exists? Recall that I did not say it is demonstrably happening in Australia, but that I'm confident it probably does, and certainly can. Yet again, you are extrapolating far more than I am actually saying.

My interest in possible/probable coercion is to bake a remedy into the model I am kicking around for the States. That's it.
 
When you break it down, I don't think there's that much in it. Plenty of Kiwis are revolting *****.

My kind of mother *******, then. :)

Too spoiled by it never being compulsory to carry ID unless you're driving. The irony that everyone carries a phone isn't lost on me.

Off topic, but man, they are getting crazy with the ID thing over here. Just to make a deposit at my local bank, they now want you to scan your debit card. They still want the paper slip filled out, but they want the card for "additional verification".

At my wife's bank (different because her paycheck is direct deposit), you cannot make a cash deposit unless you are the account holder. I mean, WTF? it's a deposit, not a withdrawal.

My favorite is in one of my kid's bank. To make a cash deposit in her account (dad does this on request sometimes), i have to be thumbprinted. Literally, with the ink pad for your right thumb, like being arrested. To make a small cash deposit.
 
I'm going to harp on this in more detail than is necessary, because as I said, it's at the heart of our repeated conflicts.

I said, as you quoted, that to be a legal contractor, you have to be registered. Did you notice that highlighted, bolded, and italicized word, in there? It's rather important. It means that if you are going to be a law-abiding, above-board contractor, you must be registered. This says absolutely nothing about illegal contractors, and whether or not they exist (which they obviously do). My statement was true and accurate in every conceivable sense.

Then the law is irrelevant. Your constant hammering on about how super-perfect US law is is utterly irrelevant. It doesn't matter at all how good the laws are, or what model of law is in place, if people are going to break the law.

Then you extrapolate that I say there are no contractors working without a license in NJ. Your extrapolation does not in any sane way follow from my statement.

I am not insane: again, stop the personal attacks. This is becoming tiresome.
Let's get this straight, then:
You don't approve of the Australian laws because some people there may be working without licences.
You contrasted this with the US, where you said it was impossible for people to work without licences.
You are now saying that it is possible for people in the US to work without licences.
You have thus shot down your own argument, such as it was.
Correct?

Before we continue, you need to address this, as you are doubling down on extrapolating an unrelated Y from my statement X. You've been doing this repeatedly, and we will see more below.

No. What is happening is that you say something, I ask you to supply evidence, then you angrily proclaim that you never said any such thing, and only a madman could possibly have read your words to mean exactly what they say, and round we go again.
You have been doing this repeatedly, and I have no doubt we will see more in the future.

It has not. Banquetbear cited some Germans who didn't like a different version of registration, mainly relying on "they don't trust The Man". If you are a legal worker doing legal contracting, it doesn't matter if you personally trust The Man and prefer a criminal lifestyle. That's what every criminal says to justify doing illegal stuff.

That is a totally dishonest version of what banquetbear told you. Naughty.

At no point has anyone else ITT "explained why simple registration does not work". No one. Anywhere.

Apart from when they did. Over and over and over again. :rolleyes:

Yet again, you extrapolate Y from X. I don't think there is widespread abuse in the Oceanic models. No one has any idea, really.

And yet you keep saying there is. If you stopped saying there was widespread abuse (and I am quoting your own words exactly here), perhaps I could believe that you don't believe there is widespread abuse. Simples.

What I am slowly and clearly repeating is that the proposed model I am kicking around for the States would prevent widespread abuse.

You can patronise me all you like. It will change nothing. You have yet to show how your proposal would be more successful in the States than elsewhere. If you did that, it might help your case.

What do I mean by that? The average age that an American hooker gets into the trade is 15 years old. That's the average. Some, obviously, would be even younger. Underage hooking is an indisputable problem in the States.

Again, if you could demonstrate that your registration proposal could in no way be circumvented by unscrupulous or careless operators, it would help your argument immeasurably. Thus far, you have not done this- not even close.

You and others here may think that is not a big deal. I do, and I think that a solution has to be baked into any model of legalization.

Now you're accusing me of accepting child abuse? Are there no depths to which you will not sink to try to win this argument?
if you tried instead to explain, rather than frothing at the mouth and hurling insults, it might lead to a more productive discussion. Right now, this is just nasty.

Registration would seem to work, assuming Johns prefer the legal model over continuing with the criminal, which I'm sure many would.

As this is the opposite of what has happened when this was tried, I would like to know on what grounds you are making these assumptions.

Jesus Christ, you're going to demand I recite the thread to you again? We did this earlier, remember? I did so, after much argumentation about whose burden it was, and you were satisfied with my response. Remember? Now you ask the same goddamned thing again. No. It is not now, nor was it then, my responsibility to read the thread back to you.

No. It is your responsibility to provide evidence for your various claims and assertions. Your indignant failure to do so does not lend any credence to your claims. Quite the opposite, in fact.

Jesus Christ. In the same way I have described repeatedly. The story says the manager didn't verify the girl's age. There is no mention of the State having somehow failed. That would imply that the State takes no role in verifying the age of workers, which is, as I have said repeatedly, shocking to an American ear, as the US redundantly verifies a worker's ID before they can begin employment.

You know this is not true: I linked you to several examples of that not being true. Ignoring facts that contradict your claims rather undermines your attempts to speak with authority, don't you think?

I have asked repeatedly if anyone has other data on how age verification works in Oz, as I can't find anything. Lacking anything else, I'm going with the reporting. If you have better information, it is most welcome.

Nope. You claim that no-one checks the age of potential sex workers, and that the state is not involved at all in this process. Your claim, your burden of proof.

I have indeed ignored them because they seem utterly irrelevant. Do you see the highlighted word above? Employees. Sex workers are considered contractors, not employees. Apples and oranges. An employer is responsible for their employees in many different ways, while a contractor is mostly responsible for themselves.

You are arguing against yourself here. If they are independent contractors, they have no requirement to work in licenced brothels. You have made a big point about how 90% of the work goes on outside these premises. Now you are saying it's OK for that to happen. Get back to me when you get your story straight.

No, and no. You are extrapolating and reading in, again.

So having just said you want the state to check all potential employees, you are now opposing your own suggestion. :rolleyes:
You also said that in the US, the state does, and does not, check employees IDs. :rolleyes: :rolleyes:


Addressed above.

By contradicting yourself. I'm not sure that helps you.

I have the factual grounds of what "coercion" means, and that it exists. Do you deny that coercion exists?

Strawman.
You claimed that no-one was reporting abuse because of coercion and duress. I asked you for evidence for this assertion. That cannot honestly be construed to mean I am denying that any coercion exists anywhere. Don't do this: it's wrong.

Recall that I did not say it is demonstrably happening in Australia, but that I'm confident it probably does, and certainly can. Yet again, you are extrapolating far more than I am actually saying.

IOW: "I don't have any evidence this is happening, but I'm sure it does, because my argument rests on it, so you're wrong ner ner!" :rolleyes:

My interest in possible/probable coercion is to bake a remedy into the model I am kicking around for the States. That's it.

And what remedy would that be? You are very vague on the details of this so-called model.

As a final point, any more personal attacks and I will report you. You are not one of the hyenas, so you have no immunity from mod action. OK?
 
At no point has anyone else ITT "explained why simple registration does not work". No one. Anywhere.

The following has all been explained previously at various times, so here we go again :rolleyes:

Firstly, your idea of simple registration resulting in some kind if national database of sex-workers would be a non-starter - it would fail right out of the gate. Why? Because there have been far too many data breaches over the years, many of them government ones, with people's personal data such as medical records and social security records getting into the clear. I can't see sex-workers trusting officials with their personal data. Most of them would rather work illegally and unregistered for cash, than register with the government and risk their personal details being revealed.

Secondly, some kind of special registration for sex-workers is not necessary anyway, at least in New Zealand, because it would be entirely redundant. EVERY income earner who pays tax, regardless of whether they are an employee, self-employed, a contractor, a business owner/manager/executive etc is compulsorily registered with...

a. The Inland Revenue Department and therefore, they have an IRD number, and

b. The Accident Compensation Corporation and they have an ACC account and a BIC (Business Industry Code) that applies to the nature of their work... and it is finely detailed. EVERY different type of work comes under a BIC number and is listed. Even if you are the only person in the whole country who is doing some specialist type of work, your work will be listed under a BIC. (They have something similar in Australia called "WorkCover")

WARNING: 1MB Pdf
https://www.acc.co.nz/assets/business/acc7686-levy-guidebook-2021-2022.pdf

Check out pages 12 to 136, and pay particular attention to page 130, BIC 95300

So the government already has you registered as to what you do for a living by virtue of the fact that you have an ACC account number, that you have been assigned a BIC number and both you and your employer pay ACC levies (if you are self employed you pay both).

Its worth noting that ACC has had the odd data breach too, but never a mass hack like some other departments where whole databases have been published.

https://www.acc.co.nz/newsroom/stor...haring-client-information-has-been-completed/
 
Last edited:
My kind of mother *******, then. :)



Off topic, but man, they are getting crazy with the ID thing over here. Just to make a deposit at my local bank, they now want you to scan your debit card. They still want the paper slip filled out, but they want the card for "additional verification".

At my wife's bank (different because her paycheck is direct deposit), you cannot make a cash deposit unless you are the account holder. I mean, WTF? it's a deposit, not a withdrawal.

My favorite is in one of my kid's bank. To make a cash deposit in her account (dad does this on request sometimes), i have to be thumbprinted. Literally, with the ink pad for your right thumb, like being arrested. To make a small cash deposit.

Dude, you need to consider getting a new bank.

At my credit union, I don't need ID to make a deposit. Neither on my account nor my (adult) daughter's. Nor do I fill out a deposit slip. A withdrawal doesn't require a form either. (I do have to show my driver's license.) Hell, a driver's license was all my daughter needed to apply for a car loan. And all you need to open an account as well.
 
When you break it down, I don't think there's that much in it. Plenty of Kiwis are revolting *****.



Too spoiled by it never being compulsory to carry ID unless you're driving. The irony that everyone carries a phone isn't lost on me.

This is true in the U.S. as well. No requirement to carry an ID unless you are doing certain things, like driving. Your driver's license pretty much serves every ID function you will need from cashing a check to boarding a plane. If you don't drive, you can get a state ID card that serves the same purpose. I guess if you start a new job, you might need to show a copy of your social security card to prove authorization to work and for income tax withholding purposes, but I'm not sure the actual card is needed. And very few people carry the card with them.

Oh, and in Illinois you need your Firearms Owner's ID (FOID) card. Again, I don't think it has to be on your person. Concealed Carry card might be different.

There are some jobs that require an ID to be displayed. Taxi driver is one. When my wife worked security, she had to get a "PERC" card ("permanent employee registration card"). Illinois require this for a number of professions, but it doesn't need to be carried or displayed.

For those who wonder why a sex worker might not like to need to register, think of the cab driver model. They have prominently displayed a card that lists their profession and identifying information. Now, who cares if anyone sees you drive a cab? But maybe sex workers don'tr want their clients to know their real names. Or maybe they don't want the card in their purse when they go visit friends/relatives etc. because it would out their career. (Yes, there is a stigma on sex work.)

There are already legal sex workers in the US. Strippers and porn stars. I've never known any porn stars, but I've known some strippers. They all use fake names. Most of the ones I've known commuted to work from other towns 50 miles away so that they didn't run into their customer in the grocery store. I believe they had to register or get some sort of adult entertainer license, but I've never seen one as it wasn't on display. I think it's actually more of a benefit for the club than anything else.

I'd like to say sex work is like any other job. But if I'm honest, I'd rather my daughter work at Wal Mart or MacDonald's that be a stripper. I know it's hypocritical, but I have no problem with people I don't know being sex workers. It occurred to me a few years ago that my daughter was now of the age where if I went to the local club, one of the dancers might be one of her friends I've known since she was in grade school. Which I would find...awkward.

There is still a stigma regarding sex work.

Another thing about individual contractors. Most places I've lived, there have been limits on running a business out of your home. And most hotels would try to prevent their rooms being used for sex work. So some sort of brothel makes a lot of sense. But I can see it being a problem if the house gets too much of a cut. (This already happens at strip clubs and VIP rooms/lap dances.)

I don't think it's any more of a front for money laundering than many other businesses. All it takes is a place that regularly takes cash as payment without a solid audit trail for the transaction. So literally anything in the service industry. Around here, the rumored launderers are restaurants.

Sex work should be legal. I'm undecided about licensing and brothels. However, as it stands now, since sex is regarded as intimacy, sex work has a stigma. And it would not be regarded as just another job. Just as stripping and starring in porn are not seen as just another job.
 
Off topic, but man, they are getting crazy with the ID thing over here. Just to make a deposit at my local bank, they now want you to scan your debit card. They still want the paper slip filled out, but they want the card for "additional verification".
Your bank still uses paper? Jeez. I haven't had to fill out a withdrawal slip since the ATM was invented.
 
Your bank still uses paper? Jeez. I haven't had to fill out a withdrawal slip since the ATM was invented.

Yep. Same here. Banks no longer take cheques or issue chequebooks, or deposit slips. Many ATMs are capable of taking cash deposits, and its all done with your ATM card, BUT you can only deposit cash at you own bank ATM, not at any other.
 
Yep. Same here. Banks no longer take cheques or issue chequebooks, or deposit slips. Many ATMs are capable of taking cash deposits, and its all done with your ATM card, BUT you can only deposit cash at you own bank ATM, not at any other.
I haven't even used cash in any significant way for... oh, probably about four years now. Cash has this inherent problem in that it necessarily multiplies the number of small round useless pieces of metal that you either have to carry around, or stick in a jar and ignore for ten years at which point you take it to the coin counter at the bank and discover that you've accumulated $700 worth.
 
Dude, you need to consider getting a new bank.

At my credit union, I don't need ID to make a deposit. Neither on my account nor my (adult) daughter's. Nor do I fill out a deposit slip. A withdrawal doesn't require a form either. (I do have to show my driver's license.) Hell, a driver's license was all my daughter needed to apply for a car loan. And all you need to open an account as well.

Continuing the OT blitz:

My bank is TD, based out of Canada, but consistently voted best big bank in the USA. Open 7 days/week, open late (7-8PM some branches), free checking w/$100 min balance, free debit cards printed on the spot if you lose yours, branches in every state I go, from Massachusetts to Florida. Very convenient, lifestyle dependent, of course.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom