Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
But you want a perfect system, and if that perfect system cant be found, you want to do nothing... its the "perfect solution fallacy"

And guess what, while there is no such thing as a perfect system,

I have not the foggiest idea where you are coming up with that.

What I am kicking around is a different model for use in the States, that follows an existing framework that is well-tested. The rest you just made up out of whole cloth for whatever reason.


...the models we use here and in Australia are excellent and have worked very well for 30 years there and 20 years here. So far, we have ONE adverse case in evidence. Until you present a lot more, you will not convince me there is a problem here to debated in any honest fashion..

Great. Glad to hear it. But it relies heavily on the honor system, and let's face it: my country is full of criminals, from my boys on the site to our last Chief Executive. So we would benefit from a tighter model, with less room to continue criminality.

Basically, direct worker registration would negate the need for the brothel to be holding the cards and calling the shots. It would put that power shared between the State, who verifies and issues registration, and the workers who could work inside or outside a brothel, but they wouldn't need to give half their take to the house, as the house isn't nearly as important anymore. The physical brothel is not much more than a hotel room in my proposed system, and a hotel room doesn't nab half the worker's hard earned proceeds.
 
Basically, direct worker registration would negate the need for the brothel to be holding the cards and calling the shots. It would put that power shared between the State, who verifies and issues registration, and the workers who could work inside or outside a brothel, but they wouldn't need to give half their take to the house, as the house isn't nearly as important anymore. The physical brothel is not much more than a hotel room in my proposed system, and a hotel room doesn't nab half the worker's hard earned proceeds.

...allowing sex workers the freedom to work from the privacy of their own home would negate the need for a brothel or a hotel room. In fact, it even negates the need for direct worker registration.
 
I of legal employment is a valid passport, or else two other forms of ID (foreign workers have other documentation they must provide).
And this works 100% of the time does it?

It doesn't in Australia either.
 
...allowing sex workers the freedom to work from the privacy of their own home would negate the need for a brothel or a hotel room. In fact, it even negates the need for direct worker registration.

Doesn't that sound great? Why, you might even find yourself as a man who just paid to **** a 15yo girl. Viva la freedom!
 
Doesn't that sound great? Why, you might even find yourself as a man who just paid to **** a 15yo girl. Viva la freedom!

...you do understand that this would be illegal, right? It's probably illegal where you live, it's illegal in Australia, it's illegal where I live.

Direct worker registration wouldn't make any difference here.
 
...you do understand that this would be illegal, right? It's probably illegal where you live, it's illegal in Australia, it's illegal where I live.

Please take a moment to think about what you just posted.

Direct worker registration wouldn't make any difference here.

If you genuinely, honestly don't understand that registration would virtually eliminate the chances of a client unknowingly banging an underage girl, I am literally not able to talk to you as if you were an adult.
 
You're a liar. I have repeatedly argued in favor of legalization, and have applauded sex workers being safer. You are a bald faced liar to say otherwise.

And I am not trying to "demonize" a system. I am trying to find out what worked, what didn't, and how to torque it to hypothesize how it might work in my country. I think individual registration ticks the boxes for an effective approach. That you want to spin fairy tales about my postings (while repeatedly slinking away when your BS is repeatedly called out) is entirely your problem, between your own ears.

Even in this very response, you don't have the character to admit you were wrong about how the child dominatrix was discovered. And I'm still waiting for your evidence that "brothels that employ addicts lose their licenses" and the other steaming piles of BS you refuse to address.



Absolutely right.

Er, this is you not making a moral stance against prostitution? Asking parents about their adult daughters making a legal decision?


To our Aussie and Kiwi parents: did you discuss prostitution as a good way to make screaming good money working part time, with little to no experience at all? The Atheist, to his credit, has acknowledged that he did not.

And no weaseling, please. I'm not asking if they showed an interest in that line of work as a career. I'm asking if you suggested to your teenage daughter or son that sucking a few strangers' cocks a week is a stellar way of getting yourself off to a good financial start. I mean, since it is no big deal and all. You can sell your labor as a burger flipper for minimum wage in near sweatshop conditions, or casually get boned on your own terms for many times more. If you are sincere in your assertion that it is no big deal, why not suggest it as a valid opportunity (and no, I don't mean to advocate it any more highly than any other possibility, but simply mention it as a viable possibility if they might be ok with it)?

There’s plenty more of your posts like this.
 
Last edited:
Please take a moment to think about what you just posted.

...sure. Done. Now what?

If you genuinely, honestly don't understand that registration would virtually eliminate the chances of a client unknowingly banging an underage girl, I am literally not able to talk to you as if you were an adult.

"Virtually eliminate" is a mighty big claim that remains un-evidenced. And considering that 90% of sex workers in Germany remain unregistered, and that you have already talked about putting databases of sex workers into private hands, the chances that you could get even a fraction of that number of sex workers to register in the United States would be very slim.

You are talking about a scenario that is more likely to happen in a nightclub. Do you support compulsory registration there as well?
 
I have not the foggiest idea where you are coming up with that.

Christ on a ******* Pogo Stick!!

You have just spent the last two+ pages criticizing a system on the basis of ONE adverse case, and you wonder why most of us think you are wanting a perfect solution.

What I am kicking around is a different model for use in the States, that follows an existing framework that is well-tested. The rest you just made up out of whole cloth for whatever reason.

You have been presented with models that work well in NZ and Australia. You might think your country is special, but its not. Its just another western country, inhabited by humans. What works here WILL work there, especially on a state-by-state level. All it takes is the will and the attitude.

I can't speak for Australia, but I can tell you that our law was bloody difficult to get through. It only passed by a narrow margin and it has required of the New Zealand general public a significant adjustment in their attitudes toward sex-work. Kiwis have seen the crime rates around prostitution plummet, and they have seen how the criminal gangs have been completely shut out of the picture. If for some reason it were ever to come up for a review, it would fly through now virtually unopposed.
 
Er, this is you not making a moral stance against prostitution? Asking parents about their adult daughters making a legal decision?

There’s plenty more of your posts like this.

Damned straight it's not. What I was doing (and with sledgehammer clarity) was showing that this was not work like any other job, as some were pushing. It falls solidly in the Vice category, and accordingly needs special treatment.

Your laws don't even disagree with that. No solicitation near schools, hospitals, or churches, among other restrictions I was reading. Why not? Because you have a practical morality wound up in there too, and it needs to be acknowledged and dealt with in a practical manner.

Did you see that up there? That's called "not slinking away from a challenge". Take the tip.
 
Damned straight it's not. What I was doing (and with sledgehammer clarity) was showing that this was not work like any other job, as some were pushing. It falls solidly in the Vice category, and accordingly needs special treatment.

Your laws don't even disagree with that. No solicitation near schools, hospitals, or churches, among other restrictions I was reading. Why not? Because you have a practical morality wound up in there too, and it needs to be acknowledged and dealt with in a practical manner.

Did you see that up there? That's called "not slinking away from a challenge". Take the tip.
Yes, it's a special case. That's why there are laws and regulations that treat it differently from other gig jobs. Specifically they prevent the kinds of abuse that you have claimed are inherent to sex work.

Smarter legislators than you or I have looked at the inherent risks of sex work, and set up the system to mitigate or, in most cases, completely eliminate them. I'm not sure why you're having so much trouble with this.
 
Prostitution is legal in England and has been for many years. It is legal to participate in commercial sex if both parties are over 18. It is legal to advertise services via escort agencies. It has not solved the problem of e.g. sex trafficking of people to work in illegal brothels.

I think what is being talked about is legalising pimping. Legalising commercial sex is not the difference between England and NZ, it is being able to legally make a profit from sex workers. In most cases it still seems to be the owners / managers who make the big money. Street workers still exist despite brothels being legal. Even in NZ there are migrants who enter the country to work in the sex industry and are not protected by the law and so vulnerable to pressure. The nice stories of well paid workers in well run brothels with contracts does not represent the entirety of the trade.

What the Australian case demonstrates is that the sex trade is associated with exploitation. I know people say it was just one case, but one case proves exploitation occurs. We do not know how widespread the issue is. I also suspect it is at high risk of involvement in criminal systems such as money laundering, a cash based anonymous business.

I do think bringing the sex trade into a legal structure is better than criminalising it. Clearly the NZ model was an improvement, but that does not mean it cannot be improved.
 
What I am interested in is what has worked in each model, and if it could be implemented here. the frustration comes up when we can't really tell even what the system is.

Mate, I'll play on that, and I think it's a case of the answer being simpler than you think.

Legalisation is all it takes. Pretty well everything else is covered by existing laws. Child exploitation is still a crime; employment conditions are guaranteed by employment laws; tax laws apply; legalisation brings prostitution under the umbrellas of those laws. There really isn't anything else.

The only extra change I can think of is immigration not allowing people on visas to work as hookers and I don't even think there was a law change required, it just got added in to Immigration Dep't rules.
 
What this entire diversion has never addressed is how criminalizing prostitution somehow stops child exploitation in sex work.

At least in countries where prostitution is legal sex workers can go to the police and report abuse or suspect situations without themselves being arrested.
 
Prostitution is legal in England and has been for many years. It is legal to participate in commercial sex if both parties are over 18. It is legal to advertise services via escort agencies. It has not solved the problem of e.g. sex trafficking of people to work in illegal brothels.

If you're expecting the legalisation of sex-work to be a 100% solution to the world's human trafficking problems, you're barking up the wrong three.

I think what is being talked about is legalising pimping. Legalising commercial sex is not the difference between England and NZ, it is being able to legally make a profit from sex workers. In most cases it still seems to be the owners / managers who make the big money.

Wrong!

Firstly, most brothels in NZ are SOOBs "small, owner-operated brothels". They can have a maximum for four sex workers who collaborate together, with no boss, In a SOOB, no-one is in charge of another sex worker, and each person is in control of their own earnings. People working in SOOBs don’t need an operator’s licence.

Secondly, in the larger brothels, the sex-worker sets their own fee - the brothel owner/manager adds their margin (usually around 35% of the fee) but out of that margin comes all the costs involved in running managing the brothel - rates/property taxes, room rental, telephone, advertising and ACC levies.

Street workers still exist despite brothels being legal. Even in NZ there are migrants who enter the country to work in the sex industry and are not protected by the law and so vulnerable to pressure. The nice stories of well paid workers in well run brothels with contracts does not represent the entirety of the trade.

Wrong!

Firstly, to be a sex-worker in New Zealand, you have to be a New Zealand Citizen, or Permanent Resident, or an Australian Citizen or Permanent resident. If you are on any kind of temporary visa, even a work visa, doing sex work is illegal and you are likely to be deported if caught.

Secondly, brothel-keeping in New Zealand is self-policed. It is in the nature of the business that an unlicenced brothel will not be able to operate for very long without being noticed, and licence brothel operators and their sex workers do not want them cutting into their bottom line, so they WILL report them to the Police who WILL raid them.

Thirdly, every worker in NZ is protected by the Operational Safety and Heath laws. They are also covered by ACC - registration with ACC, and the payment of ACC levies is compulsory for all businesses, contractors and employee, including Brothels and sex-workers. Even tourists are protected by these laws and covered by ACC.

What the Australian case demonstrates is that the sex trade is associated with exploitation. I know people say it was just one case, but one case proves exploitation occurs.

Just like one murder proves murder happens, one burglary proves burglary happens, and one speeding ticket proves drivers speed. If there were any more than this one case, we would hear about it because its almost impossible to keep the presence of a brothel secret due to the very fact that it needs to advertise for clients to operate.

We do not know how widespread the issue is.

It is very unlikely that the issue is widespread, for the reasons I have already outlined above.

I also suspect it is at high risk of involvement in criminal systems such as money laundering, a cash based anonymous business.

Money laundering is almost impossible in New Zealand due to the "Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism Act 2009"

https://www.nzba.org.nz/banking-inf...ncial-crime/you-and-the-money-laundering-law/

To launder cash, you need to bank it. To bank cash you have to get a bank account, and that is not as easy as it once was. I just recently opened a bank account - I had to jump a sequence of hoops and hurdles just to get a bank account, for example

- Three separate forms of identification, two of which had to be photographic such as a passport and a driver's licence

- Proof of a residential address, and three documentary items of evidence to prove I actually live there (such as power bills, telephone bills, rates demands etc

- My IRD number (Tax Dept Number)

The law really does require the banks to pin down exactly who you are. Also, if your banking patterns change, and you start doing things like depositing and/or withdrawing large amounts, that will trigger an investigation.

I do think bringing the sex trade into a legal structure is better than criminalizing it. Clearly the NZ model was an improvement, but that does not mean it cannot be improved.

This is the first any only thing you have said in this post that is correct.
 
What this entire diversion has never addressed is how criminalizing prostitution somehow stops child exploitation in sex work.

If course, the answer is, it doesn't.

In fact, it encourages child exploitation because in places where sex-work is criminalized, it is more often than not run by criminal gangs who WILL threaten sex-workers not to talk to the Police (who are already discouraged from having anything to to with the Police anyway through fear of arrest)
 
Mate, I'll play on that, and I think it's a case of the answer being simpler than you think.

Legalisation is all it takes. Pretty well everything else is covered by existing laws. Child exploitation is still a crime; employment conditions are guaranteed by employment laws; tax laws apply; legalisation brings prostitution under the umbrellas of those laws. There really isn't anything else.

The only extra change I can think of is immigration not allowing people on visas to work as hookers and I don't even think there was a law change required, it just got added in to Immigration Dep't rules.

I hear what you're saying, and I get it. It's conceptually a pretty straight-up thing. What I'm thinking about for the States is based on my experience with my fellow Americans: they're just not nice people.

In the construction trades in my State, as I said before, we used to be largely unregulated, but legal, kind of like you are proposing (and by unregulated I mean regs were technically in place but with no significant enforcement). It was a train wreck of abuses, with contractors taking the money and running and you couldn't even find the sons of bitches to prosecute them. Contractor registration pretty much stopped that cold, although many figured out how to conjure up dummy LLCs and continue the game.

So the prostitutes in my neck of the woods are almost entirely streetwalkers, or streetwalkers funneling through an escort agency. Physical brothels aren't really a thing around here. So how do we keep criminals, underage hookers, and STI riddled workers out of the game? Registration. Anonymity is where our criminal element thrives, and they rely on it. Take it out of the equation, and they are playing above board just like any other respectable and law-abiding self-employed contractor. They can contract through a house for convenience, or go solo and keep all the loot. But what they can't practically do is defy the regulations. It would be hard-wired into getting registered.

Banquetbear posted that it didn't work in Germany, but that seems to be related to some weird requirement to register with the local town. I don't see a need for that. A brothel would have to, as it is a semi-permanent business, but not a freelance sex contractor.

I get the impression from our Oceanic posters that you guys find any kind of identification as really invasive. Smartcooky just posted about the "hoops" he had to jump through to get a bank account, and what he described is pretty much the same procedure we have gone through for years in the States. Maybe your general population is more socially cooperative than ours. Ours is a bunch of ******* mad dogs waiting for their next legal loophole to exploit. See Trump, life of for more information on that..
 
If there's one thing I've learned from observation of homelessness and drug use in Portland, OR, it's that legalization (or decriminalization, in this case) without regulation is a recipe for disaster.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom