Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
In the end Shuttit's argument is Pascal's Wager. There are a few substitutions, like indirect unpredictable irreversible social disruption instead of eternal damnation. But the argument is still equivalent to, "We can't be completely certain God won't get angry about all the sinful prostitutes and smite us all, so we'd be crazy to take the chance!"
It's related, but different. I am not saying "therefore do not legalise prostitution". I am saying, the data doesn't tell you whether to do it or not. The idea that this is some kind of objective, data driven, ideology free, politics free, managerial decision is an illusion. I of course think legalising prostitution is bad, but that isn't the argument I'm making at the moment.
 
Last edited:
Where are the stone tablets on which that is written? We are on the Titanic, it is night and we left the binoculars at home. There is no way to tell if there are icebergs ahead, we have no meaningful data to quantify the risk, equally, we have super reliably and accurate data that every hour of delay in arriving will cost us $20 dollars. Do we make the decision to steam full ahead into the night in the hope of saving $100 because that's what an analysis limited to where we can get good data tells us is optimal or do we factor in concerns about things we can't have definite knowledge of?

The issue is that there is something like a hidden premise in this argument. There is a worldview being assumed that has beliefs about the way human societies, and human progress works. Swap in a different world view and you get different conclusions.

What?
 
It's related, but different. I am not saying "therefore do not legalise prostitution". I am saying, the data doesn't tell you whether to do it or not. The idea that this is some kind of objective, data driven, ideology free, politics free, managerial decision is an illusion. I of course think legalising prostitution is bad, but that isn't the argument I'm making at the moment.


The managerial decision process might fail to take into account that some people have an intense irrational hatred of prostitutes, and instead of expressing it in a Jack the Ripper kind of way, they instead try to make sure the legal and social system is set up to cause prostitutes to suffer from exploitation, abuse, and disease as much as possible. They believe that having a violent pimp take away their profits leaving them in poverty and subjugation is appropriate poetic justice for their sinful conduct in leading good men astray. Their world will become a much darker place if prostitution becomes legal, safer, and heaven forbid, more rewarding.

Is that the sort of subjective, non data driven, ideological, political decision-making you're talking about?
 
Last edited:
The managerial decision process might fail to take into account that some people have an intense irrational hatred of prostitutes, and instead of expressing it in a Jack the Ripper kind of way, they instead try to make sure the legal and social system is set up to cause prostitutes to suffer from exploitation, abuse, and disease as much as possible. They believe that having a violent pimp take away their profits leaving them in poverty and subjugation is appropriate poetic justice for their sinful conduct in leading good men astray. Their world will become a much darker place if prostitution becomes legal, safer, and heaven forbid, more rewarding.
Maybe, or there may be people with a naïve utopian view of the world, who have a comically shallow idea of the worldview of the people who disagree with them. None the less, we do the best we can with the understanding of the world we have, and unfortunately data and certain knowledge is radically insufficient to answer these kinds of questions. One strategy under those circumstances is to pretend that the data is sufficient, when it produces conclusions we like of course.

Unfortunately, the sort of thought process you describe, deliberately provocative though it was, is much closer to the truth once you strip away the veneer. It can be better intentioned than that, it can be more considered than that, but it isn't fundamentally different from that.
 
Last edited:
Where are the stone tablets on which that is written?

Nothing is written on stone tablets, but the contention that sex workers are safer working in a legal and regulated industry than in a criminal one is more soundly based than most of those made both for and against the legalisation of prostitution.
 
Nothing is written on stone tablets, but the contention that sex workers are safer working in a legal and regulated industry than in a criminal one is more soundly based than most of those made both for and against the legalisation of prostitution.
In the same way that the Titanic charging at full speed into the darkness to save $100 would be better evidenced than slowing down because they couldn't see what was in front of them. Certain, confident, data driven conclusions are almost always insufficient, on their own, to guide action. The more insufficient the data, the more the decision has to depend on things other than data.

It's like we have a pathological need for certainty. We'll take a certain answer to a related question to the one we asked, over an uncertain answer to the question we actually asked every time.... and then act like we have the answer to our initial question.
 
Last edited:
We have data, you just don't like it because it proves you wrong, so you have to depend on some vague philosophical "Right to be wrong" nonense.
 
Certain, confident, data driven conclusions are almost always insufficient, on their own, to guide action. The more insufficient the data, the more the decision has to depend on things other than data.

...what would be sufficient to guide action?
 
You can always find a philosophical justification to disagree with something.

Do so isn't intellectual honest or useful however.
 
Last edited:
Because someone has stumbled across a philosophical argument that they interpret as "I don't have to have facts or evidence."
 
OK, but loads of other stuff has also changed. How do you tell what impact pornography had?

If you can't tell that it's had a bad effect, then there's no reason to criticise it.

You think you can detect the effect of the absence of pornography from all the other differences between these cultures? How? Would pornography even have the same impact in such a radically different country? How would you determine that?

Well, you could use the scientific method: form a hypothesis, and then test that hypothesis.
Oh, but that's right: you think you can't, so it's best just to reject any and all actions, just in case. We'd still be living in caves if everyone thought like you.

Right. I'm not saying you couldn't learn something by reading about 18th century french aristocrats pornography use, but we seem to be drifting quite a long way from controlled trials and proof and particularly measurement. I'm doubtful that this would give you some kind of quantified impact you could put into a spreadsheet. You can't prove these kinds of conclusions. They are just opinions. There are plenty of periods in history from which I've come away with conclusions about these matters, it is not certain knowledge though and it relies on all sorts of other beliefs one has about the nature of man and society. This is a pre-scientific type of knowledge we are talking about.
Who said anything about spreadsheets? If you can't identify any kind of negative effect of legalising prostitution, or of allowing free access to pornography, even after decades of that decision, then you have no reason to oppose it. You ramble vaguely on about effects on relations between the sexes, or the effect on marriage, but shy away when challenged to prove it.

No, you are mistaken. You have hit on the way we can approach these questions that I have been imperfectly trying to articulate. The problem is that it isn't certain knowledge, it can't really be quantified, and it is heavily dependent on our world view, our other beliefs about society and man. These aren't scientifically answerable questions. They aren't questions that data simply gives us an answer to. A feminist reading of history is going to give you a completely different conclusion about these things than a reactionary reading will. You are also talking about something very different now than "measuring an effect". Let's suppose in our cost benefit analysis of New Zealand, we suppose that legalised prostitution was supposed to save 10 prostitutes per year from being murdered, but our reading of the diary of a prostitute in Weimar Germany left us concerned about some kind of debauching effect on society. How do you compare those two things in the cost benefit? You could make up some numbers, but they are going to be unspeakably subjective and have error bars you could march an army through.

Again, if you can't indentify any negative effects, and several people here have identified a number of positive effects, you have no reason to oppose the suggested course of action.
 
Why? You reject any means of measuring why it would be bad, and also reject any concept of morality.
No I don't reject any concept of morality. All I'm saying, and have been saying, is that the scientific method is no good for answering these kinds of questions. You yourself pointed to non-scientific ways of thinking about the problem and I agreed with you.
 
Take an example, the Titanic speeding across the ocean. They knew that the visibility they had was inadequate to reliably detect icebergs. Is it sensible, knowing that, to say "well, based on the evidence we do have, there are no icebergs ahead, so full speed ahead". If the data is not adequate, then a decision has to be made that is not based on the data.

No, that analogy fails. If the Titanic is legalising prostitution, then what is the iceberg? You see, we know icebergs exist. We can detect them, measure them, quantify them, and prepare for them. You keep banging on about how the supposed possible disbenefits of legalised prostitution cannot be detected, measured or quantified- so not like icebergs at all.

You are approaching this like a modern developer, "fail fast and learn fast". The problem is, our failures take a long while, we can't even really tell reliably and agree when we have failed, we can't roll back and try again if we do think we might have failed, and ultimately the price of failure is destroying your society.

And yet you are still unable to say how legalised prostitution could harm society, never mind destroy it so utterly that nothing could be done to reverse that process before that destruction is complete- like, for example, re-criminalising that profession.
 
If you can't tell that it's had a bad effect, then there's no reason to criticise it.
You can't tell with certainty. The scientific method can't tell you. You gave an example of a way one could rationally form an opinion about this kind of thing. Rationality didn't start with the scientific method.

Well, you could use the scientific method: form a hypothesis, and then test that hypothesis.
Oh, but that's right: you think you can't, so it's best just to reject any and all actions, just in case. We'd still be living in caves if everyone thought like you.
No. I've explained this already. The fact that one can't be certain about such things isn't in and of itself any kind of bar to action. I certainly haven't made this argument in the current discussion. We just make our decision about what to do based on less certain things than scientific knowledge, like our experience and beliefs about how the world works, or world view, our ideology. Again, you gave examples in your own recent post of this kind of thinking.

Who said anything about spreadsheets?
I think banquetbear said something about matrices a while back. It doesn't matter.

If you can't identify any kind of negative effect of legalising prostitution, or of allowing free access to pornography, even after decades of that decision, then you have no reason to oppose it. You ramble vaguely on about effects on relations between the sexes, or the effect on marriage, but shy away when challenged to prove it.
Again, the question isn't not being able to identify things. That is easy. The issue is whether one can demonstrate them scientifically, that is effectively impossible if we are talking at the level of society that I am concerned with.

At an individual level it isn't that difficult, there are plenty of papers on porn addiction and other individualised harms. The thing is that actually, what motivates all this is some kind of libertarian belief that people should be allowed to do whatever they want so long as it isn't harming other people. If a generation of teenagers masturbate their lives away, then that is fine, so long as they freely choose to do so. These are actually ideology motivated policies rather than data motivated ones. Even where harm can be shown, we kind of decide that the harm is OK because of some non-quantifiable social good that we believe in.

Again though, the harm I am interested in is the long term harm to society, and that can not be demonstrated one way or the other scientifically.

Again, if you can't indentify any negative effects, and several people here have identified a number of positive effects, you have no reason to oppose the suggested course of action.
There are no ends of people identifying social harms of normalising prostitution, it has been covered in this thread. There was a discussion earlier about people increasingly viewing sex and relationships transactionally, where buying somebody dinner is not meaningfully different to paying a prostitute. The issue is that these kinds of harms can't be proven one way or the other by the scientific method. We could pretend that scientific knowledge, backed up by controlled experiments is the only kind of knowledge that there is. What we do then is smuggle in our own ideology upon which we are actually making these decisions, and then fight off people with other world views because we can't have ideology and unscientific thinking impacting our decisions.
 
Last edited:
Prostitution is normal, and always has been. The oldest profession. We're discussing legalising it, not normalising it. The very existence of it means sex has always been viewed transactionally by some, legal or not.
 
This just cracks me up.

Statement: What will happen if allow people to pay for sex....

Response: Outrage, the downfall of marriage and relationships, what would you tell your daughters, McNamara fallacy!

Statement: But what if you take video and sell it on the internet?

Response: Oh that's different. Carry on.

I have mentioned it a couple of times (and someone said it was on Family Guy, but I didn't see that episode), why is prostitution such a major problem but pornography is not? Every goddamn argument that people have made against prostitution could just as easily be made against pornography, but that never happens, except by the ones everyone agrees are moralists.

I think I've figured it out. It started with TragicMonkey's question about how many people here have actually used a prostitute, and it was silence. But then we got into the discussion of the "net benefit for society." And it all clicked.

See, prositution is bad because it's solely between those individuals, and the costs and benefits are for just them.

Porn, on the other hand, benefits us all!!!!! Men like porn, women like porn! So what if there are some shady aspects of the business and you can make all the same arguments against porn that you can against prostitution, but we all like porn, and we all benefit from porn, so there is a net benefit to society, see?

I get it now. I really do.
 
No, that analogy fails. If the Titanic is legalising prostitution, then what is the iceberg? You see, we know icebergs exist. We can detect them, measure them, quantify them, and prepare for them. You keep banging on about how the supposed possible disbenefits of legalised prostitution cannot be detected, measured or quantified- so not like icebergs at all.
You are correct that the situation of the titanic is very much better. Ultimately if they get the decision wrong, there will probably be pretty unanimous agreement that the call was a bad one. That isn't the case here. People with one world view may well think that this general liberalising trend towards normalising pornography, and prostitution and so on is effectively civilisation ending decline. Just as you said looking to historical examples might be a form of evidence, they will certainly be able to do that. People from another world view will see it as glorious liberation with no bad effects. The effects though can certainly be seen, the question is what their cause is. We know there are icebergs out there, the difficult is we have no good way of determining if we've hit one. There are no shortage of accounts of how those effects have come about, you just aren't going to demonstrate any of those accounts scientifically. All we have is explanations that strike us as plausible and convincing, or not.

And yet you are still unable to say how legalised prostitution could harm society, never mind destroy it so utterly that nothing could be done to reverse that process before that destruction is complete- like, for example, re-criminalising that profession.
This case has been being articulated for at least 60 years. Are you pretending not to have ever heard arguments against the sexual revolution and so on and why they might be bad? I don't mean to suggest bad faith, but I can't conceive you don't know the case. I have very little new to say on this that hasn't been said since before the Enlightenment.

One way of looking at the age old case is that the old version of liberty was more like mastery of the self. You were free when you mastered the desire to not shower and masturbate to hentai all day and became an ordered person. That was largely replaced by a notion of liberty that said, if you wanted to not wash and masturbate to hentai all day, then that was fine and valid and society should change so it didn't morally judge you or impede your lifestyle. The claim is that the second form of liberty relies on the social order, wealth and security built up by the first type of liberty. It is burning through the social capital that had been built up over centuries. Now we could talk about particular forms that moral decadence can take, in the individual or society.... but that is tired, worn out old ground.
 
Last edited:
Prostitution is normal, and always has been. The oldest profession. We're discussing legalising it, not normalising it. The very existence of it means sex has always been viewed transactionally by some, legal or not.
Yes, it is being normalised. Prostitution may always have been around, but it has pretty much always been treated as morally tainted. What is unusual is arguing that it is a job no different from being a nurse, and something that one would barely have an opinion on if ones daughter decided to become a prostitute. That is normalisation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom