If you can't tell that it's had a bad effect, then there's no reason to criticise it.
You can't tell with certainty. The scientific method can't tell you. You gave an example of a way one could rationally form an opinion about this kind of thing. Rationality didn't start with the scientific method.
Well, you could use the scientific method: form a hypothesis, and then test that hypothesis.
Oh, but that's right: you think you can't, so it's best just to reject any and all actions, just in case. We'd still be living in caves if everyone thought like you.
No. I've explained this already. The fact that one can't be certain about such things isn't in and of itself any kind of bar to action. I certainly haven't made this argument in the current discussion. We just make our decision about what to do based on less certain things than scientific knowledge, like our experience and beliefs about how the world works, or world view, our ideology. Again, you gave examples in your own recent post of this kind of thinking.
Who said anything about spreadsheets?
I think banquetbear said something about matrices a while back. It doesn't matter.
If you can't identify any kind of negative effect of legalising prostitution, or of allowing free access to pornography, even after decades of that decision, then you have no reason to oppose it. You ramble vaguely on about effects on relations between the sexes, or the effect on marriage, but shy away when challenged to prove it.
Again, the question isn't not being able to identify things. That is easy. The issue is whether one can demonstrate them scientifically, that is effectively impossible if we are talking at the level of society that I am concerned with.
At an individual level it isn't that difficult, there are plenty of papers on porn addiction and other individualised harms. The thing is that actually, what motivates all this is some kind of libertarian belief that people should be allowed to do whatever they want so long as it isn't harming other people. If a generation of teenagers masturbate their lives away, then that is fine, so long as they freely choose to do so. These are actually ideology motivated policies rather than data motivated ones. Even where harm can be shown, we kind of decide that the harm is OK because of some non-quantifiable social good that we believe in.
Again though, the harm I am interested in is the long term harm to society, and that can not be demonstrated one way or the other scientifically.
Again, if you can't indentify any negative effects, and several people here have identified a number of positive effects, you have no reason to oppose the suggested course of action.
There are no ends of people identifying social harms of normalising prostitution, it has been covered in this thread. There was a discussion earlier about people increasingly viewing sex and relationships transactionally, where buying somebody dinner is not meaningfully different to paying a prostitute. The issue is that these kinds of harms can't be proven one way or the other by the scientific method. We could pretend that scientific knowledge, backed up by controlled experiments is the only kind of knowledge that there is. What we do then is smuggle in our own ideology upon which we are actually making these decisions, and then fight off people with other world views because we can't have ideology and unscientific thinking impacting our decisions.