Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
Maybe. All these things are question of ideology, our experience of the world and guesswork. There isn't an answer that can be proven. For every anecdote of yours I can produce a bunch of mine. The idea that we are making data driven, rational decisions about these things is an illusion that gives people false confidence that we know what we are doing. We are implementing ideology. That goes back to my core point.

The Hammer fallacy.
 
Reported rapes.

In the 1960s, very few women reported rapes, and no married woman could report that her husband had raped her, because it wasn't made illegal until the 1980s.

Edited by sarge: 
edited to remove moderated content
.
I know it was reported rapes. I said "reported" in the post that you are correcting me on. I wasn't the one who claimed the graph showed an increase in line with population The data presented showed nothing of the kind. It's smartcooky in their conclusion that I replied to who slides from talking about reported rapes, to talking about rapes. Complain to smartcooky.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The only way to get this information would be, at the very start of internet porn and dating apps, to have a properly controlled experiment. This was impossible even back then, and even if some idiot thought they could run such an experiment now, the ship has long sailed.
Quite. No experiment would in fact have been possible. No experiment of this type is ever done in these cases. We do not in fact know or measure what the effects of our policies are. They are not in fact data driven. That is a fig leaf. What they in fact are, and have always been, is ideology.
 
Quite. No experiment would in fact have been possible. No experiment of this type is ever done in these cases. We do not in fact know or measure what the effects of our policies are. They are not in fact data driven. That is a fig leaf. What they in fact are, and have always been, is ideology.

Unbelievable. You are talking rubbish.
 
What on earth kind of evidence are you asking for? A peer-reviewed study? I'm pretty sure that it's pretty hard to formulate a scientific examination of such a vague and nebulous concept like "relations between the sexes". Statistics? How would you propose such a study be designed?
Well, indeed. Most questions that are important, that we want to answer, can't be answered by science. You end up having to turn that question into something trivial like "did the rape rate increase", and we can't even track that back to it's cause. We end up playing the politicians game of saying "here's the answer to a completely different question that I can answer". As I said earlier, Critical Theory was invented precisely because of this issue. People here tend to have some non-provable idea that some kind of society where everybody's individual freedom was maximised in some way is the way to organise things. It's ideas like that that the legalisation of prostitution is based on, not data or science.
 
Last edited:
Maybe. All these things are question of ideology, our experience of the world and guesswork. There isn't an answer that can be proven. For every anecdote of yours I can produce a bunch of mine. The idea that we are making data driven, rational decisions about these things is an illusion that gives people false confidence that we know what we are doing. We are implementing ideology. That goes back to my core point.

So if we have no way of knowing if legalising prostitution will affect cooperation and trust between the sexes, but we do know that it has definite benefits for those who will be involved in it whether we legalise it or not, then we surely opt for legalisation.
 
Unbelievable. You are talking rubbish.
OK. Explain how your controlled experiment on, say, the normalisation of pornography in society would run? There are a lot of variables to consider, this would need to be huge. I mean, we are talking about the effects on children of growing up in a society where pornography is normalised, and normalised amongst their peers, bleeds into their movies, TV and music. You can't just randomly assign pornography to half the kids in the class. Their parents would have to first grow used to having access, their classmates would have to have access as we tracked their development over decades. Are you imagining two Truman Show style fake communities where we track things over 40 years? One could easily do some trivial experiment like exposing half of the test subjects to porn for 10 minutes per day and getting them to answer a questionnaire, but that hardly answers our question about the impact of porn on society. Given that I am talking rubbish, how would your experiment go to show the effect of normalised, ubiquitous pornography on society? Go.....
 
Last edited:
So if we have no way of knowing if legalising prostitution will affect cooperation and trust between the sexes, but we do know that it has definite benefits for those who will be involved in it whether we legalise it or not, then we surely opt for legalisation.
No. This would be a systematic error. If you have an individualist philosophy, that maybe believes in some Rousseauian idea of man without society being naturally good, and that liberating man from social taboos and constraints is naturally good for man and society, then it fits right in with ones ideology anyway. As I said, before any of the inadequate data can become the basis for our decision, we already make an ideological decision. Take an example, the Titanic speeding across the ocean. They knew that the visibility they had was inadequate to reliably detect icebergs. Is it sensible, knowing that, to say "well, based on the evidence we do have, there are no icebergs ahead, so full speed ahead". If the data is not adequate, then a decision has to be made that is not based on the data.

You are approaching this like a modern developer, "fail fast and learn fast". The problem is, our failures take a long while, we can't even really tell reliably and agree when we have failed, we can't roll back and try again if we do think we might have failed, and ultimately the price of failure is destroying your society.
 
Last edited:
shuttlt said:
Does it? You've got numbers very close to zero pre-1960, presumably the population wasn't that small in the 50s...

Do you read, or did you just see the graph and go "aha!" and then post the first thing that popped into your head?

Firstly, you didn't read Item 1. As TheAtheist pointed out.. this graph denotes reported rapes. Prior to the 1970's very few women reported that they had been raped. For starters, they were made to feel ashamed, they were often blamed for having been raped. Also, they would very likely have to report the harrowing details to a male officer they didn't know, because policewomen in the 1950s and 1960 were as rare as rocking-horse ****. They were only allowed to be administrative roles until 1960, and by 1970, they made up a whopping 2.4% of the Police establishment (most of those in Auckland)

Secondly, you didn't read Item 2. There was a huge spike in reported rapes from 1980 to 2010... The bulk of these were historical, dating back 20 to 40 years earlier. Guess where that dates them when the rapes actually took place?
 
OK. Explain how your controlled experiment on, say, the normalisation of pornography in society would run? There are a lot of variables to consider, this would need to be huge. I mean, we are talking about the effects on children of growing up in a society where pornography is normalised, and normalised amongst their peers, bleeds into their movies, TV and music. You can't just randomly assign pornography to half the kids in the class. Their parents would have to first grow used to having access, their classmates would have to have access as we tracked their development over decades. Are you imagining two Truman Show style fake communities where we track things over 40 years? One could easily do some trivial experiment like exposing half of the test subjects to porn for 10 minutes per day and getting them to answer a questionnaire, but that hardly answers our question about the impact of porn on society. Given that I am talking rubbish, how would your experiment go to show the effect of normalised, ubiquitous pornography on society? Go.....

You have never conducted controlled experiments this is clear. I have. You are talking rubbish.
 
Quite. No experiment would in fact have been possible. No experiment of this type is ever done in these cases. We do not in fact know or measure what the effects of our policies are. They are not in fact data driven. That is a fig leaf. What they in fact are, and have always been, is ideology.

Hammer fallacy - again.
 
Do you read, or did you just see the graph and go "aha!" and then post the first thing that popped into your head?

Firstly, you didn't read Item 1. As TheAtheist pointed out.. this graph denotes reported rapes.
Yes, indeed. If you read my post, I said reported as well. It was only in your conclusion to your post where you stopped saying reported and started talking about rapes.

Prior to the 1970's very few women reported that they had been raped.
This may well be, and I did consider this. However, I was told that the graph suggested there was an increase in line with population growth, so I was looking for it.

For starters, they were made to feel ashamed, they were often blamed for having been raped. Also, they would very likely have to report the harrowing details to a male officer they didn't know, because policewomen in the 1950s and 1960 were as rare as rocking-horse ****. They were only allowed to be administrative roles until 1960, and by 1970, they made up a whopping 2.4% of the Police establishment (most of those in Auckland)
Doubtless, doubtless. I didn't choose the graph and claim it showed something. If you want to know say that too much changed over the period to really say anything, then I'm onboard with that.

Secondly, you didn't read Item 2. There was a huge spike in reported rapes from 1980 to 2010... The bulk of these were historical, dating back 20 to 40 years earlier. Guess where that dates them when the rapes actually took place?
Sure, but again, somebody claimed the graph showed an increase in rapes in line with population growth. Does that come down to just going, "one graph kind of slopes up, the other graph kind of slopes up.... the growth is probably the same"? What about that graph, given all the problems that are perfectly obvious with it, suggests the increase in rapes is increasing with population growth?

Given that the population increased by 13% between 1999 and 2010 and the reported rape rate increased by 50%, just how much faster would the reported rape rate have to increase than the population for you to not hand wave it off as population growth? Would 13% vs 100% be too much? 200%?
 
No. This would be a systematic error. If you have an individualist philosophy, that maybe believes in some Rousseauian idea of man without society being naturally good, and that liberating man from social taboos and constraints is naturally good for man and society, then it fits right in with ones ideology anyway. As I said, before any of the inadequate data can become the basis for our decision, we already make an ideological decision. Take an example, the Titanic speeding across the ocean. They knew that the visibility they had was inadequate to reliably detect icebergs. Is it sensible, knowing that, to say "well, based on the evidence we do have, there are no icebergs ahead, so full speed ahead". If the data is not adequate, then a decision has to be made that is not based on the data.

You are approaching this like a modern developer, "fail fast and learn fast". The problem is, our failures take a long while, we can't even really tell reliably and agree when we have failed, we can't roll back and try again if we do think we might have failed, and ultimately the price of failure is destroying your society.

If we don't know whether legalising prostitution would benefit or harm society as a whole, if there are arguments to be made for both benefit and harm and we don't have the data to decide which is right, we cannot make the decision on that basis, true. But we still have to make a decision about legalisation; choosing not to do it could result in unnecessary continuing harm if those who argue it would be an overall societal benefit are right. If we do know that legalisation will definitely benefit at least some people, that surely tips the scales in favour.
 
OK. Explain how your controlled experiment on, say, the normalisation of pornography in society would run? There are a lot of variables to consider, this would need to be huge. I mean, we are talking about the effects on children of growing up in a society where pornography is normalised, and normalised amongst their peers, bleeds into their movies, TV and music. You can't just randomly assign pornography to half the kids in the class. Their parents would have to first grow used to having access, their classmates would have to have access as we tracked their development over decades. Are you imagining two Truman Show style fake communities where we track things over 40 years? One could easily do some trivial experiment like exposing half of the test subjects to porn for 10 minutes per day and getting them to answer a questionnaire, but that hardly answers our question about the impact of porn on society. Given that I am talking rubbish, how would your experiment go to show the effect of normalised, ubiquitous pornography on society? Go.....

If we go by your criteria, then it would be impossible to measure any effects of doing anything. You've spent several pages arguing just that.
In the real world, though, there are a number of ways we could measure those effects. The first would be to compare a single society from its state in the past to the present, given that access to pornography is widespread now when it wasn't before.
Another would be to compare two (or more) present-day societies, one western, with free access to porn, and another, say, Middle Eastern, where it's not only more difficult but also culturally frowned upon.
A third would be to look at it from a class-based perspective. Historically, the upper classes in Europe had ready access to erotic literature and art, whilst the lower classes did not.
All of those would give points for comparison and conclusions.
I have no doubt, though, that you will return to your constant refrain that, because of your misapplication of what some obscure dead man said centuries ago, then the effects of progressive policies are unmeasurable, and so we shouldn't do them, because the effects would be terrible. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
You have never conducted controlled experiments this is clear. I have. You are talking rubbish.
Terrific. Enlighten me. How would you conduct a controlled experiment to determine the impact of ubiquitous pornography on society? I don't see how it would be possible without radically simplifying and reducing the question, but you know more than I do, how would it be possible?
 
If we go by your criteria, then it would be impossible to measure any effects of doing anything. You've spent several pages arguing just that.
In the real world, though, there are a number of ways we could measure those effects. The first would be to compare a single society from its state in the past to the present, given that access to pornography is widespread now when it wasn't before.
Another would be to compare two (or more) present-day societies, one western, with free access to porn, and another, say, Middle Eastern, where it's not only more difficult but also culturally frowned upon.
A third would be to look at it from a class-based perspective. Historically, the upper classes in Europe had ready access to erotic literature and art, whilst the lower classes did not.
All of those would give points for comparison and conclusions.
I have no doubt, though, that you will return to your constant refrain that, because of your misapplication of what some obscure dead man said centuries ago, then the effects of progressive policies are unmeasurable, and so we shouldn't do them, because the effects would be terrible. :rolleyes:

Oh shuttlt won't commit to that - all they will commit to is a "could be terrible".

shuttlt's assertions seem to be a result of two well know cognitive biases - zero-sum and the good old hammer bias. All of the assertions they have made in this thread are according to their "arguments" meaningless anyway.
 
If we go by your criteria, then it would be impossible to measure any effects of doing anything. You've spent several pages arguing just that.
Kind of.

In the real world, though, there are a number of ways we could measure those effects. The first would be to compare a single society from its state in the past to the present, given that access to pornography is widespread now when it wasn't before.
OK, but loads of other stuff has also changed. How do you tell what impact pornography had?

Another would be to compare two (or more) present-day societies, one western, with free access to porn, and another, say, Middle Eastern, where it's not only more difficult but also culturally frowned upon.
You think you can detect the effect of the absence of pornography from all the other differences between these cultures? How? Would pornography even have the same impact in such a radically different country? How would you determine that?

A third would be to look at it from a class-based perspective. Historically, the upper classes in Europe had ready access to erotic literature and art, whilst the lower classes did not.
Right. I'm not saying you couldn't learn something by reading about 18th century french aristocrats pornography use, but we seem to be drifting quite a long way from controlled trials and proof and particularly measurement. I'm doubtful that this would give you some kind of quantified impact you could put into a spreadsheet. You can't prove these kinds of conclusions. They are just opinions. There are plenty of periods in history from which I've come away with conclusions about these matters, it is not certain knowledge though and it relies on all sorts of other beliefs one has about the nature of man and society. This is a pre-scientific type of knowledge we are talking about.

All of those would give points for comparison and conclusions.
I have no doubt, though, that you will return to your constant refrain that, because of your misapplication of what some obscure dead man said centuries ago, then the effects of progressive policies are unmeasurable, and so we shouldn't do them, because the effects would be terrible. :rolleyes:
No, you are mistaken. You have hit on the way we can approach these questions that I have been imperfectly trying to articulate. The problem is that it isn't certain knowledge, it can't really be quantified, and it is heavily dependent on our world view, our other beliefs about society and man. These aren't scientifically answerable questions. They aren't questions that data simply gives us an answer to. A feminist reading of history is going to give you a completely different conclusion about these things than a reactionary reading will. You are also talking about something very different now than "measuring an effect". Let's suppose in our cost benefit analysis of New Zealand, we suppose that legalised prostitution was supposed to save 10 prostitutes per year from being murdered, but our reading of the diary of a prostitute in Weimar Germany left us concerned about some kind of debauching effect on society. How do you compare those two things in the cost benefit? You could make up some numbers, but they are going to be unspeakably subjective and have error bars you could march an army through.
 
Last edited:
In the end Shuttit's argument is Pascal's Wager. There are a few substitutions, like indirect unpredictable irreversible social disruption instead of eternal damnation. But the argument is still equivalent to, "We can't be completely certain God won't get angry about all the sinful prostitutes and smite us all, so we'd be crazy to take the chance!"
 
If we don't know whether legalising prostitution would benefit or harm society as a whole, if there are arguments to be made for both benefit and harm and we don't have the data to decide which is right, we cannot make the decision on that basis, true. But we still have to make a decision about legalisation; choosing not to do it could result in unnecessary continuing harm if those who argue it would be an overall societal benefit are right. If we do know that legalisation will definitely benefit at least some people, that surely tips the scales in favour.
Where are the stone tablets on which that is written? We are on the Titanic, it is night and we left the binoculars at home. There is no way to tell if there are icebergs ahead, we have no meaningful data to quantify the risk, equally, we have super reliably and accurate data that every hour of delay in arriving will cost us $20 dollars. Do we make the decision to steam full ahead into the night in the hope of saving $100 because that's what an analysis limited to where we can get good data tells us is optimal or do we factor in concerns about things we can't have definite knowledge of?

The issue is that there is something like a hidden premise in this argument. There is a worldview being assumed that has beliefs about the way human societies, and human progress works. Swap in a different world view and you get different conclusions.
 
Last edited:
Terrific. Enlighten me. How would you conduct a controlled experiment to determine the impact of ubiquitous pornography on society? I don't see how it would be possible without radically simplifying and reducing the question, but you know more than I do, how would it be possible?

So you have nothing, thank you.8
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom