Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=13813518#post13813518

Now, as you have gone to very lengthy pains to point out in this thread, you also reject the idea of individual morality- that people should be free to make their own moral choices, something you dismiss as 'liberal' or 'libertarian' (terms you seem to consider to be derogatory).
OK. That is a weird sort of simultaneously moral relativist, and morally universalist position.

I'm disagreeing with a particular construction of morality, not disagreeing with morality, and particularly not individual morality. What you are describing is believed by a minority of people globally, and a vanishingly small minority of people historically. I think this do-what-thy-wilt morality is profoundly corrosive to people and society. That is completely different to not believing in morality, or not even believing in individual morality.

Look, you don't even believe in completely individual morality. If I thought murdering 5 year olds was morally good, it would stop being part of this individual morality and become part of your universal morality that had to be enforced to prevent bad things happening. I'm the same, we just draw the line in a different place.

So, if you reject both universal morality and individual morality, that doesn't leave much else, does it?
I reject the idea that there is a self evident universal morality that everybody can agree on or should agree on if they were rational. I don't think there is a unique "correct" morality. I don't reject the idea that we need a universal morality. I certainly have moral beliefs. Regretfully I wasn't handed them by God and I look around the world and at history at the different moral assumptions people have had, and I come to the conclusion that if parts of morality are self evident in some way, it is a very small part. None the less, society has to be held together and you need a shared morality that everybody believes in to do that.

Furthermore, in that same thread, you defined your own morality as 'seeing if it works or if it doesn't work'. Well, for a start, that's not morality, that's pragmatism.
Well, I think once one gives up the idea that morality has been handed down by God, or is self evident, one has to be a little bit humble about such things. There was a lot of concern about this kind of thing towards the end of the 19th century. One holds ones morality provisionally, and it becomes something one thinks about, develops, tests, questions and compares. That is absolutely not the same as having no morality.

Then there's the problem (for you) that you are not prepared to apply this 'moral' pragmatism to the question of legalising prostitution. If you were, you would agree to let it happen, and then see if it works or not.
No. That is not the case for reasons discussed at length. If it was done, and clearly it is being done in some places, I would try and learn from the example and rethink my assumptions. That isn't the same as supporting a course of action that I think will be an unfixable disaster just to confirm my suspicions.

Your opposition to this legalisation is surely a case of you trying to apply your own morality to others, something you say you don't support.
Did I actually say I don't support that? If somehow I did, I was certainly misspeaking. Society can not function without one doing this.

Finally, of course, you keep ruling out any possibility of even determining if it has worked or not.
Proving scientifically if it worked or not. One can certainly have an opinion about it, a considered opinion, a rational opinion.... but one would be unlikely to be able to prove it I think. It would have to be a spectacular and immediate disaster for that to happen.

In summary, then, your so-called moral position is a self-contradictory mess. You don't have morals yourself, you don't agree with societies trying to agree to a common moral framework, you don't want individuals to use their own moral judgements, and you don't want others to use the same 'moral' criteria that you do.
You misunderstood the previous thread.
 
Last edited:
Also, I'm not sure why you'd single out only sex if you're talking about breaking up marriages. Even as reasons for divorce go, for example in Texas the legal reasons for a divorce include:

- Insupportability (yeah, just can't suffer him or her for any reason, is grounds for a no-fault divorce)
- Cruelty
- Adultery
- Conviction of a Felony (after you've been in jail for at least 1 year)
- Abandonment (left and lived apart for at least 1 year)
- Living Apart (for at least 3 years, regardless of why, even if you were deployed in a war or otherwise has nothing to do with your wanting it)
- Confinement in a Psychiatric Hospital

I hope you don't think it's any kind of intimate relationship if someone rented an apartment in another city to me for three years. Yet, yeah, my doing that is grounds for divorce.
Adultery is also grounds for divorce in New Jersey. So is habitual alcoholism or drug use, or "deviant sexual conduct" on the part of your spouse.
 
Most of the objections in New Zealand to the 2003 legislation was from bible bashing, self-righteous fundamentalist Christians.
Rather like here then.

The loudest dissenting voice was the leader of the Christian Heritage Party, Graham Capill. He was later jailed in 2005 for nine years on charges of rape and indecent assault against girls aged under 12 (committed during the 1990s). What a fine upstanding Christian man he is.
Was anyone surprised?

The second loudest voice was another sleazy and general all-around scum-bucket, Brian Tamaki, the leader of the "Destiny Church", a misogynistic cult-like Christian fundamentalist organization.
:rolleyes:
 
No.

The original quote was:

Cosmic Yak said:
Your opposition to this legalisation is surely a case of you trying to apply your own morality to others, something you say you don't support.
Did I actually say I don't support that? If somehow I did, I was certainly misspeaking. Society can not function without one doing this.
Here I understood you to be suggesting I didn't support applying my own morality to others. That is incorrect. There is really no way around some kind of enforced morality even if one wanted it. Why wouldn't one think ones own would be the best one for that purpose? I thought the focus of that part of the discussion was morality. I certainly oppose legalising prostitution and never intended to say otherwise.
 
Last edited:
Ridiculous. You say that the effects cannot be measured or quantified, and in literally the next sentence claim that they can.
It's as if the poster was throwing together nonsense, sprinkling it with poorly understood but impressive phrases, and hoping someone is impressed.
:rolleyes:
 
Lovely, then could you show me the evidence for the impact legalised prostitution has had on relations between the sexes.
:rolleyes:
You are the one making the claims, why don't you go and Do The Research.
 
At this point he's using Bayesians Statistics to prove Prostitutes are Immortal.
 
There are confounding factors for every metric, but I still think the incidence of things like rape and domestic violence are a better indicator of whether "cooperation and trust between the sexes" is increasing or decreasing than the ones shuttit wants to use.
To an extent, but changes in reporting rates are probably having more impact on the raw numbers.
 
Prostitution is normal, and always has been. The oldest profession. We're discussing legalising it, not normalising it. The very existence of it means sex has always been viewed transactionally by some, legal or not.
This is indeed true. Where does my SO offering to "make it worth my while" in exchange for Sunday morning breakfast in bed fit?
 
Yes, it is being normalised. Prostitution may always have been around, but it has pretty much always been treated as morally tainted. What is unusual is arguing that it is a job no different from being a nurse, and something that one would barely have an opinion on if ones daughter decided to become a prostitute. That is normalisation.
Bollocks. Go and study some actual history before you continue to spout off nonsense.
 
This is indeed true. Where does my SO offering to "make it worth my while" in exchange for Sunday morning breakfast in bed fit?

Is it a playful kidding around between partners in a committed relationship, or does she actually have to do the math on how many stranger's cocks she has to suck this week to make rent?
 
shuttlt;13885458I said:
certainly oppose legalising prostitution and never intended to say otherwise.

...the ACLU argues that:

ACLU said:
The criminalization of sex work makes sex workers more vulnerable to violence on the job and less likely to report violence. It prevents sex workers from accessing health care and other critical services, feeds an out of control mass incarceration system, and further marginalizes some of society’s most vulnerable groups, such as trans women of color and immigrants.

Sex workers deserve the same legal protections as anybody else. They should be able to maintain their livelihood without fear of violence or arrest, access health care and other services without discrimination, and seek justice when they are harmed. Decriminalization would help bring sex workers out of the dangerous margins and into the light where people are protected — not targeted — by the law.

https://www.aclu.org/news/topic/its-time-to-decriminalize-sex-work

They provide a comprehensive report where they dive deeper into the issue.

https://www.aclu.org/report/sex-work-decriminalization-answer-what-research-tells-us

Once you've had the chance to review the report, I have a few questions.

Do you support or oppose decriminalization?

If you oppose it, what are your alternative solutions to the issues that the ACLU outline: "maintain their livelihood without fear of violence or arrest, access health care and other services without discrimination, and seek justice when they are harmed?"
 
No.

The original quote was:


Here I understood you to be suggesting I didn't support applying my own morality to others. That is incorrect. There is really no way around some kind of enforced morality even if one wanted it. Why wouldn't one think ones own would be the best one for that purpose? I thought the focus of that part of the discussion was morality. I certainly oppose legalising prostitution and never intended to say otherwise.

Yes, sorry, my mistake, which I realised on re-reading the posts this morning.

However......
You think there really is no way around enforced morality? No, you don't:
shuttlt said:
I don't believe that it is healthy for one particular morality to be imposed over everything. I think that route is intrinsically totalitarian.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=13812769#post13812769

And again:
shuttlt said:
I think enforcing a single morality on everybody is a bad idea. I think generally it makes the world worse rather than better.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=13812820#post13812820

I am now wondering if you are genuinely so confused by your own arguments that you simply can't remember what you said a few months ago, or if it is- as some have suggested- disingenuity.
 
It's related, but different. I am not saying "therefore do not legalise prostitution". I am saying, the data doesn't tell you whether to do it or not. The idea that this is some kind of objective, data driven, ideology free, politics free, managerial decision is an illusion. I of course think legalising prostitution is bad, but that isn't the argument I'm making at the moment.

To come back to this: you think legalising prostitution is "bad", but you don't think racism is bad. Here is your "reasoning" for this position:

shuttlt said:
What you said just struck me as being very Platonic. It's like for you there is a world of abstract forms where things like racism have properties - like being wicked. They can be good or bad as a property of the idea. I don't believe in this ideal "form" of racism. There are only instances in the mud and contradiction of the real world.

Strange that your Platonic dodge only applies to thing other people think are bad, and not to the things you think are bad....
 
shuttlt said:
If I thought murdering 5 year olds was morally good, it would stop being part of this individual morality and become part of your universal morality that had to be enforced to prevent bad things happening.

Here I understood you to be suggesting I didn't support applying my own morality to others. That is incorrect. There is really no way around some kind of enforced morality even if one wanted it. Why wouldn't one think ones own would be the best one for that purpose? I thought the focus of that part of the discussion was morality. I certainly oppose legalising prostitution and never intended to say otherwise.

I think it relevant to quote my response to your earlier rejection of enforced morality:
Cosmic Yak said:
Commonly accepted codes of morality are not just one of the cornerstones of culture: they are also the foundation of justice, of any workable justice system. Societies decide what is mutually acceptable, and what is not, and devise their laws, legal systems and punishments on those decisions.
By rejecting all of this, shuttlt is rejecting any and all systems of justice.

Once again, shuttlt seems incapable or unwilling to "remember" his earlier stances and posts, or to maintain even a semblance of consistency.
 
Yes, sorry, my mistake, which I realised on re-reading the posts this morning.

However......
You think there really is no way around enforced morality? No, you don't:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=13812769#post13812769

And again:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=13812820#post13812820

I am now wondering if you are genuinely so confused by your own arguments that you simply can't remember what you said a few months ago, or if it is- as some have suggested- disingenuity.

And in any case, who is enforcing any morality, universal or individual, on anyone by legalizing prostitution?

Any women who are not prostitutes are not having any morality forced upon them because the law has no impact on them, and similarly, any men who do not use prostitutes are not having any morality forced upon them because the law has no impact on them either.

The only people who are impacted are prostitutes themselves who will be far better off both financially and from a personal safety perspective. The Police also benefit as they will no longer have to waste their time arresting prostitutes, and the courts who no longer have to waste time trying them.

The only people negatively affected will be all the insufferable, overbearing moralizing religious types who are only too willing to impose THEIR universal moral views on the individuals of our society in general. **** them I say!
 
Yes, sorry, my mistake, which I realised on re-reading the posts this morning.

However......
You think there really is no way around enforced morality? No, you don't:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=13812769#post13812769
I thought for a moment there you had got me. That line doesn't look like something I think. Read the full post. I am not saying that the world can work with everybody going about in some libertarian do-what-thou-wilt way. Regrettably, I don't think that that works. To some minimal degree, I assume you agree too, that we have to enforce some basic aspects of collective morality. This is just a practical issue of what you need to have a stable society.

Equally, the morality you are enforcing kind of needs to be compatible with the culture of the people, otherwise things turn ugly fast. You can't have a shared morality at anything but the most trivial level in a culturally and morally heterogeneous community. The larger things get, the harder it is to have enough cultural homogeneity to hold things together in this way.

That was what I was talking about in that post. There is no global universal morality you can just blanket over people and not expect to create chaos. You can't just build a liberal nation out of Afghanistan that embraces LGBT in anything other than a very long timescale with a lot of brutality and coercion. Similarly, it would be very difficult to impose the Taliban's morality on Portland and, though perhaps less severely, you can't just impose the morality of San Francisco on Wyoming unless you are prepared to be very coercive. I'm talking practicalities. People need public morality, otherwise society is amoral, equally no public morality is going to suit all people in all places.

The same is true of that second quote. That was a conversation about nations and populations.

Look, I wonder whether part of the problem isn't that you are looking at this from a self evidence moral truth perspective. You think it is a moral truth that everybody should have a right to pursue whatever their own view of morality is. You are reading my posts on this subject as if I am arguing from some moral truth. I'm not, I'm saying I think practically people need public morality, and I think once things get too heterogeneous, once people cease to be united by some common project, once you can't stuff peoples mouths with gold, or the promise of gold..... there are some serious limits on the scale public morality can go. Attempts to deny this reality lead to dark places.

It's not even as if I completely disagree with you on the moral side. I kind of see it like the quote from Grant:
The right of revolution is an inherent one. When people are oppressed by their government, it is a natural right they enjoy to relieve themselves of oppression, if they are strong enough, whether by withdrawal from it, or by overthrowing it and substituting a government more acceptable.
I believe in individual morality, and respect anybody who feels strongly enough about an issue that they are prepared to suffer for it. However, society can no more allow individuals to go around practicing whatever morality they want, any more than it can allow individuals to go around succeeding when ever they feel like it. Allowing either one at any scale is to allow anarchy.

One has to temper ones moral intuitions with practicality. Different moral intuitions conflict with one another and can't be fully realised.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom