OK. That is a weird sort of simultaneously moral relativist, and morally universalist position.http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=13813518#post13813518
Now, as you have gone to very lengthy pains to point out in this thread, you also reject the idea of individual morality- that people should be free to make their own moral choices, something you dismiss as 'liberal' or 'libertarian' (terms you seem to consider to be derogatory).
I'm disagreeing with a particular construction of morality, not disagreeing with morality, and particularly not individual morality. What you are describing is believed by a minority of people globally, and a vanishingly small minority of people historically. I think this do-what-thy-wilt morality is profoundly corrosive to people and society. That is completely different to not believing in morality, or not even believing in individual morality.
Look, you don't even believe in completely individual morality. If I thought murdering 5 year olds was morally good, it would stop being part of this individual morality and become part of your universal morality that had to be enforced to prevent bad things happening. I'm the same, we just draw the line in a different place.
I reject the idea that there is a self evident universal morality that everybody can agree on or should agree on if they were rational. I don't think there is a unique "correct" morality. I don't reject the idea that we need a universal morality. I certainly have moral beliefs. Regretfully I wasn't handed them by God and I look around the world and at history at the different moral assumptions people have had, and I come to the conclusion that if parts of morality are self evident in some way, it is a very small part. None the less, society has to be held together and you need a shared morality that everybody believes in to do that.So, if you reject both universal morality and individual morality, that doesn't leave much else, does it?
Well, I think once one gives up the idea that morality has been handed down by God, or is self evident, one has to be a little bit humble about such things. There was a lot of concern about this kind of thing towards the end of the 19th century. One holds ones morality provisionally, and it becomes something one thinks about, develops, tests, questions and compares. That is absolutely not the same as having no morality.Furthermore, in that same thread, you defined your own morality as 'seeing if it works or if it doesn't work'. Well, for a start, that's not morality, that's pragmatism.
No. That is not the case for reasons discussed at length. If it was done, and clearly it is being done in some places, I would try and learn from the example and rethink my assumptions. That isn't the same as supporting a course of action that I think will be an unfixable disaster just to confirm my suspicions.Then there's the problem (for you) that you are not prepared to apply this 'moral' pragmatism to the question of legalising prostitution. If you were, you would agree to let it happen, and then see if it works or not.
Did I actually say I don't support that? If somehow I did, I was certainly misspeaking. Society can not function without one doing this.Your opposition to this legalisation is surely a case of you trying to apply your own morality to others, something you say you don't support.
Proving scientifically if it worked or not. One can certainly have an opinion about it, a considered opinion, a rational opinion.... but one would be unlikely to be able to prove it I think. It would have to be a spectacular and immediate disaster for that to happen.Finally, of course, you keep ruling out any possibility of even determining if it has worked or not.
You misunderstood the previous thread.In summary, then, your so-called moral position is a self-contradictory mess. You don't have morals yourself, you don't agree with societies trying to agree to a common moral framework, you don't want individuals to use their own moral judgements, and you don't want others to use the same 'moral' criteria that you do.
Last edited: