Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
It is when you treat unquantifiable things as unimportant or non-existent and exclude them from the decision making process, which is what I claimed.

...McNamara talks about things "that what can't be measured easily". Not "unquantifiable".

Do you not understand the difference?

You tell me. Is it improved feelings of cooperation and trust between the sexes? That would be one of the things I would be worried about screwing up if I normalised prostitution. Are we just pretending that the only effects of doing this are the effects we want to see?

This isn't how any of this works.

How are you imagining that this is how it should work?

I'm not the one who is claiming that the McNamara applies here. This question relates to McNamara. If you want ME to answer this question, then you are all but conceding that McNamara doesn't apply.

I've already cited the reasons for the reforms. To safeguards the human rights of sex workers and protects them from exploitation. To promote the welfare and occupational health and safety of sex workers. To be conducive to public health.

So its over to you now. For us: our guide to whether or not the reforms are a success will be measured in terms of the safeguards for the human rights of sex workers, whether or not we can protect them from exploitation, to what degree we are promoting the welfare and occupational health and safety of sex workers, and for everything to be conducive to public health.

All of these things have been studied. For example:

https://www.otago.ac.nz/christchurch/otago018607.pdf

And there has been ongoing studies into the impact of the reforms.

So it goes back to you. You obviously don't believe me. So you tell me: what do you think New Zealanders (in general) have decided is the metric for success of the reforms?

Yes, sure.... I would assume the metric would be something that could be measured. I don't think I've said it wouldn't be. That really isn't what's at issue.

So what is that metric then?

I don't see why. My issue isn't that they can't have come up with some metrics. I'm sure they have. The issue is that the important effects that concern me can't be quantified.

If they can't be quantified, then they are irrelevant to McNamara.

And we are back to the McNamara fallacy, that things that can't be quantified are considered irrelevant or unimportant and are excluded from our analysis.

We aren't back to the McNamara fallacy. Because the McNamara fallacy isn't some innate, all-powerful law. And in reality, sometimes there are things that ARE irrelevant or unimportant and should be excluded from our analysis.

It isn't a fallacy to exclude the opinions of somebody that lives on the other side of the world from our analysis.

I'm sure they did. We have a Conservative party in the UK. They aren't philosophically conservative either, they are Blairite neo-liberals.

So now we are at the point of the "no-true-conservative."

Gotcha.

Is it a secret? Do I have to guess the name? Is it Rumpelstiltskin?

Yes.

Wow, these noble sages intuited through their worn out vaginas what the effect on society of the law would be, did they?

Yeah, they did, and they got it right.

How did they assess what the impact on society would be of this law, or were they just advocating for themselves?

The job of assessing "what the impact on society would be of this law" didn't fall to the sex workers. That fell to our legislative process. It went through the robust process of three readings in the house. The impact on society was debated. What more do you expect to happen in a society?

If it wasn't driven by liberals, the it's a remarkable coincidence given that the liberal ideology that has been responsible for all of the other such changes. Did all the liberal charities, lawyers, journalists, and politicians go home? Were the prostitutes in an empty room and left to enact the legislation themselves?

It was driven by sex workers, it was championed by both the left and the right here.

So you don't know the history of your ideas, the justification for your ideas, what the arguments against your ideas have been, you really haven't read anything about the ideas behind the things you believe? What is the point in us talking then if you don't even understand your own beliefs? We are here arguing about the roof, and there aren't any foundations.

You accused me of being "coy" in my worldview because I stated that we do not need to have a "theory to guide our actions." And we don't. I'm not being coy here at all.

You probably need to understand your own ideology before we complicate things before throwing conservativism in there.

I...haven't thrown "conservativism in there." I haven't bought up conservativism at all.

How even is this conversation a real thing that is happening?

I'll ask my question again: what does this have to do with conservatives? You bought them into the conversation, not me.

It is impossible to go further if you either really don't understand your own ideas and how they fit together, or pretend to. Your ideas have to have some structure to them. If they are just an assorted collection of things that look plausible to you, then discussion about them really can only be very limited.

I understand my ideas perfectly well thanks. I also understand how they fit together, and my ideas have some structure to them.

I'm ready to discuss my ideas with you whenever you are ready.

Right, you assume your moral frame as some kind of neutral common sense that everybody should see. The same as an Ayatollah might think it is common sense that women should cover their faces. Their is no divinely inspired, universally obvious truth in your moral assumptions. They weren't handed to you on stone tablets at the top of a mountain. They are just a particular set of beliefs that happen to be kind of generic in the West at the moment. Not so long ago, they were quite a bit different and people thought that version of them was just as obvious as you think these ones are.

What is your moral frame?

How do you think sex workers should be treated in society?

How should they be treated by the police?

How should they be treated by the welfare system? By the tax system?

Should sex workers be subject to arrest? Should they get thrown in jail?

Should we view the work that they do as acceptable? Or should they be shunned and disgraced at every opportunity?

This does sound a lot like a moral crusade.

It sounds like you are on a moral crusade.

I think doing what you propose would perhaps improve the conditions of some prostitutes in some ways, but I think it would also turn ordinary women into something more like prostitutes and I think it would make society worse, to the ultimate detriment of the prostitutes.

The reforms have been in place for nearly twenty years. So lets examine some of the things you imagine would have happened.

Have the reforms "turned ordinary women into something more like prostitutes?" How are you imagining that would look like? What evidence would suggest that was happening? Does the evidence suggest that it has already happened?

How would you determine whether or not "society was worse?" What is your benchline? How do we measure this? And how would this be to the ultimate detriment of sex workers?

You solve these problems by only focusing on the thing you want to fix, and as with the McNamara fallacy excluding any downsides that aren't right in front of you from consideration.


That's kinda how you fix problems. You focus on fixing the things you want to fix. That's literally how it works.

If there are downsides that aren't immediately apparent, you fix them as they come up. This isn't a fallacy. Its just how things actually get done.

The weird thing is that after all that time, there is still no concern for unintended consequences. No amount of time is sufficient because these things are never taken into consideration, things are never done in a way where one could know.

What makes you think that?

GEORGINA BEYER via Hansard said:
But if one does have fears, this legislation will be reviewed in 5 years to see how it is operating and whether it is effective. If this bill passes tonight, in 5 years we will be able to reassess its worth. That is something that those who are wavering should be comforted by.

https://www.parliament.nz/en/pb/han...r-georgina-prostitution-reform-bill-procedure

You are advocating for INACTION. For never doing anything, because "no amount of time is sufficient because these things are never taken into consideration, things are never done in a way where one could know" can be applied to absolutely everything.

Sure, well.... since nobody has learned anything from that experience... maybe we can carry on on the same course and all become forth rate powers. I guess Australasia will be part of the Chinese empire. I should think Britain will stay joined at the hip to the US in it's decline.

As a person that has had to deal with the colonialist legacy of the British empire all of my life, I don't give a damn about the fate of Britain. I don't want to be part of the British empire or a Chinese Empire. We are doing just fine as we are thank-you-very-much.

Well, if you can't quantify it, and on that basis you exclude it from your decision making, then that is the McNamara fallacy.

I didn't say that "we couldn't quantify it" (even though we can't.) I asked you why it was relevant.

And merely excluding something IS NOT ENOUGH TO MAKE IT A FALLACY. Things are excluded from the decision making process all of the time. NOT EVERYTHING IN THE WORLD IS THE MCNAMARA FALLACY.

Terrific, but the goals of the reforms aren't the total effects of the reforms. Again, McNamara has a bunch of metrics he used to track the success of the war. He had a dinky list of goals at least as nice as yours.

It was more than a "dinky list of goals."

The flaw in McNamara's thinking was that "war was reduced to a mathematical model". The fallacy here was the thinking that "by increasing estimated enemy deaths and minimizing one's own, victory was assured."

That isn't what my "dinky list of goals" is all about. We aren't working to "victory conditions." We have declared a framework, and if we work within that framework we can ensure that sex workers are kept safe and free from exploitation.

That's it. There is no fallacy at play here.

The problem was that they ended up leaving out things that were ultimately important. Who says your list of goals is everything that is important in measuring whether this law was good or bad for New Zealand?

Nobody is claiming that "list of goals is everything that is important in measuring whether this law was good or bad for New Zealand."

Are you telling me that if the project achieved all those goals, but had unintended side effects that outweighed the benefits of achieving those goals, then the project would be a success, and job well done?

We haven't had any unintended side effects that outweighed the benefits of achieving those goals.

But if we do: then by all mean, please, point them out.

From your way of looking at it, McNamara's management of Vietnam was a great success and job well done so long as he hit his goals, like a good VC killed to Americans killed ratio.

You are appying McNamara incorrectly.

No, exactly... McNamara fallacy, worse than McNamara fallacy... they are acting as if only the goals they have identified exist. Their policy could cause all sorts of problems, but so long is that doesn't impact their goals.... big success.

The word "could" is doing an awful lot of work here.

The reforms simply haven't caused all sorts of problems. And if they do, we will deal with them. What is wrong with that approach?

If you are doing a cost/benefit analysis, you don't decide what you're goals are and restrict your analysis to that.... you start with trying to understand what the totality of the effects of a particular project are. Any dumb project can be a success if you just exclude any of the potential negative consequences of the project from the success criteria.

Why are you imagining that this wasn't what happend here? Do you think that those goals were just plucked out of mid air? Do you really not understand what happened in those sixteen years and three readings during the debates?

I think though that if you really don't have any structured understanding of your ideas, and are just shooting from the hip, we should really stop arguing. There is even less point than normal.

LOL.

Now we have WAP on Radio 1.

Would you mind sharing what WAP means please? And why it is wrong to be on Radio 1?
 
You tell me. Is it improved feelings of cooperation and trust between the sexes? That would be one of the things I would be worried about screwing up if I normalised prostitution.

Whereas I think women might be more inclined to trust the men they went on dates with if they knew that the sort of men who can't be trusted were able to get their sexual needs met safely and legally.

That's a metric we could look at: has the incidence of rape in New Zealand increased or decreased since prostitution was legalised?
 
Whereas I think women might be more inclined to trust the men they went on dates with if they knew that the sort of men who can't be trusted were able to get their sexual needs met safely and legally.

...the kind of men that are problematic are also the kind of men who don't worry about getting "their sexual needs met safely and legally." That wasn't the point of the reforms. So consequently:

That's a metric we could look at: has the incidence of rape in New Zealand increased or decreased since prostitution was legalised?

This metric wouldn't tell us anything anything at all about the reforms.
 
Whereas I think women might be more inclined to trust the men they went on dates with if they knew that the sort of men who can't be trusted were able to get their sexual needs met safely and legally.

That's a metric we could look at: has the incidence of rape in New Zealand increased or decreased since prostitution was legalised?

A good idea, but correlation v causation would rear it's head. In the same time span, we saw the Rise of the Internet, with dating apps and free porn (as I think shuttIt noted earlier). How would we isolate sexual assault as a variable related to legalization?
 
Last edited:
A good idea, but correlation v causation would rear it's head. In the same time span, we saw the Rise of the Internet, with dating apps and free porn (as I think shuttIt noted earlier). How would we isolate sexual assault as a variable related to legalization?

The only way to get this information would be, at the very start of internet porn and dating apps, to have a properly controlled experiment. This was impossible even back then, and even if some idiot thought they could run such an experiment now, the ship has long sailed.
 
The more I think about it, we actually have kind of a legalized prostitution in the States, and I don't mean the flipping train wreck in rural Nevada. Our 'Escort Services' are flourishing, and they have perfected the art of technically not being prostitutes, mostly via euphemisms. Legit gig work and all that. The only substantial difference is that the tax man doesn't get a taste of the 'extras' (offered by the escorts of their own volition, of course).
 
The more I think about it, we actually have kind of a legalized prostitution in the States, and I don't mean the flipping train wreck in rural Nevada. Our 'Escort Services' are flourishing, and they have perfected the art of technically not being prostitutes, mostly via euphemisms. Legit gig work and all that. The only substantial difference is that the tax man doesn't get a taste of the 'extras' (offered by the escorts of their own volition, of course).

This aspect of prostitution was always difficult to control, although that doesn't mean it wasn't attempted. In the 1980s I worked for Victoria Police, a very large force. There were police tasked with calling escort services, taking "show money" (real money, just provided by the department which they had to account for) and when the escort took off sufficient amounts of clothing (a bra by memory) promptly arrested them.

Is this the type of policing anyone wants to see?

I also feel sorry for the police involved. Getting (to some extent) aroused should not be part of any job description.
 
This aspect of prostitution was always difficult to control, although that doesn't mean it wasn't attempted. In the 1980s I worked for Victoria Police, a very large force. There were police tasked with calling escort services, taking "show money" (real money, just provided by the department which they had to account for) and when the escort took off sufficient amounts of clothing (a bra by memory) promptly arrested them.

Is this the type of policing anyone wants to see?

I also feel sorry for the police involved. Getting (to some extent) aroused should not be part of any job description.
Isn't that entrapment?
 
Isn't that entrapment?

It may be now, but not then. There were also police masquerading as streetwalkers in St Kilda. I actually had to sack a Department employee who when approaching a police streetwalker and being told he was under arrest actually showed his police ID. The civilian and police ID were essentially identical, but sworn police had a badge. This guy was threatened with a charge of Impersonating Police, which had grave consequence, if he didn't agree to go. It was actually one of the saddest days of my working life. The man said he needed to work and asked if he could apply for another job in the Department. I said no. Not great days.
 
This aspect of prostitution was always difficult to control, although that doesn't mean it wasn't attempted. In the 1980s I worked for Victoria Police, a very large force. There were police tasked with calling escort services, taking "show money" (real money, just provided by the department which they had to account for) and when the escort took off sufficient amounts of clothing (a bra by memory) promptly arrested them.

Is this the type of policing anyone wants to see?

I also feel sorry for the police involved. Getting (to some extent) aroused should not be part of any job description.

In my super square little beach town, we had an obnoxiously obvious Massage Parlor operation, with paper over the windows and the works. The local police ran a 9 month investigation before busting them, which most of us believe involved every male member of the force sampling the wares. They did flat out bust them and publicly shut them down.

Going back a while, the Atlantic City Escort Services, whose name were Legion for they were many, had code words for what you wanted that an existing customer had to tip you off to in advance. Then if you and the young lady happened to hit it off after the Escorting, well that had nothing to do with the Agency.
 
...the kind of men that are problematic are also the kind of men who don't worry about getting "their sexual needs met safely and legally." That wasn't the point of the reforms. So consequently:



This metric wouldn't tell us anything anything at all about the reforms.

Agreed. Rape is not so much about sex, as it is about power and control, so rapes pre and post 2003 will tell us nothing useful... however, for the curious

NZRapes1950-2014.png


A few thing to keep in mind about this graph

1. These are raw reported rape numbers (not per capita numbers) the only metric we have. If victims don't report them, they cannot appear in the stats.

2. The green line marks the point at which the 1985 amendment to the Crimes Act 1961 introduced the category of 'sexual violation' and made rape within marriage a crime. Together with a large spike in reported historical rapes in the late 1980s, early 1990s and early 2010, these are the reasons for the big spike

3. The red line marks the point at which prostitution was made legal

4. Between 1950 and 2014, the NZ population rose from 1.9 million to 4.5 million

This shows that rapes in NZ have approximately followed the population trend, and there has been no per capita increase since 2003.
.
.
 
There are confounding factors for every metric, but I still think the incidence of things like rape and domestic violence are a better indicator of whether "cooperation and trust between the sexes" is increasing or decreasing than the ones shuttit wants to use.
 
There are confounding factors for every metric, but I still think the incidence of things like rape and domestic violence are a better indicator of whether "cooperation and trust between the sexes" is increasing or decreasing than the ones shuttit wants to use.
You are kind of talking about only looking at the very extreme end of the distribution if you are taking those as metrics. If you wanted to check on a friends marriage, and determined that that week there had been no rapes or violence in the marriage.... is it a good marriage?
 
This shows that rapes in NZ have approximately followed the population trend, and there has been no per capita increase since 2003.
.
.
Does it? You've got numbers very close to zero pre-1960, presumably the population wasn't that small in the 50s. Then, ignoring the spike, there is something like a linear increase. Presumably the population didn't increase by 40x between 1960 and 1980? Then looking 1999-2010, you have it going from 400 to 600 reported cases, an increase of 50%. In the same period, the population increased from 3,835,100 to 4,350,700, an increase of 13%.

Where are you getting that the increase in reported rapes follows the population growth? It's increasing at many times the population growth and has been for pretty much the entire graph since 1960.
 
You are kind of talking about only looking at the very extreme end of the distribution if you are taking those as metrics. If you wanted to check on a friends marriage, and determined that that week there had been no rapes or violence in the marriage.... is it a good marriage?

If a marriage lasts 40 years is it a good marriage? My parents were married for over 40 years, my mother was the unhappiest woman I ever knew. We would all have been better off if she'd divorced my abusive father and brought us up alone. So measures like the ones you prefer - how long a marriage lasts, the number of single mothers - don't tell us much about whether "cooperation and trust between the sexes" is deteriorating or not either. Maybe making it easier for a woman to exit a failed marriage just finally allows us to know how many failed marriages there always were.
 
A good idea, but correlation v causation would rear it's head. In the same time span, we saw the Rise of the Internet, with dating apps and free porn (as I think shuttIt noted earlier). How would we isolate sexual assault as a variable related to legalization?
Again, this is the issue.... you really can't tell "from the data" what the effects of these policies or ideas are. Even if you could, there are always multiple interacting factors involved. It's not as if there is going to be a relationship like, legalising prostitution increases marital breakup by 2% or decreases the rape rate by 3%. Legalising prostitution in an Amish community in Pennsylvania is not going to produce the same results as legalising it in Detroit. There is no data driven way of saying what the impact on society of legalising prostitution was in New Zealand, and there is certainly no data driven way of making a general statement about what the impact is. All answers to the question are ideological.
 
Sex workers and their clients are much safer now.

Those are the only two metrics that matter, and we can show that it's true.

I expect BanquetBear, and TheAtheist will have about the same opinion of these scumbags that I do, especially Capill the kiddie fiddler.

In spades.

The irony of Capill being anti-gay and anti-prostitution while being a child molester was stark.

Does it? You've got numbers very close to zero pre-1960, presumably the population wasn't that small in the 50s...

Reported rapes.

In the 1960s, very few women reported rapes, and no married woman could report that her husband had raped her, because it wasn't made illegal until the 1980s.

Edited by sarge: 
edited to remove rule 12 violation
 
Last edited by a moderator:
If a marriage lasts 40 years is it a good marriage? My parents were married for over 40 years, my mother was the unhappiest woman I ever knew. We would all have been better off if she'd divorced my abusive father and brought us up alone. So measures like the ones you prefer - how long a marriage lasts, the number of single mothers - don't tell us much about whether "cooperation and trust between the sexes" is deteriorating or not either. Maybe making it easier for a woman to exit a failed marriage just finally allows us to know how many failed marriages there always were.
Maybe. All these things are question of ideology, our experience of the world and guesswork. There isn't an answer that can be proven. For every anecdote of yours I can produce a bunch of mine. The idea that we are making data driven, rational decisions about these things is an illusion that gives people false confidence that we know what we are doing. We are implementing ideology. That goes back to my core point.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom