Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
This just cracks me up.

Statement: What will happen if allow people to pay for sex....

Response: Outrage, the downfall of marriage and relationships, what would you tell your daughters, McNamara fallacy!

Statement: But what if you take video and sell it on the internet?

Response: Oh that's different. Carry on.
Who is arguing this? Certainly not me.
 
Who is arguing this? Certainly not me.

We know. You are against prostitution but have literally zero argument outside of referencing a philosophical get out of logic free card over and over.

If you can't explain what your problem is, you don't get a seat at the adult table where the discussion is actually happening.
 
Prostitution is normal, and always has been. The oldest profession. We're discussing legalising it, not normalising it. The very existence of it means sex has always been viewed transactionally by some, legal or not.

A lot of socially negative behaviors have been around a long time. Guys fighting to resolve personal disputes, for another example. Been accepted by the participants probably before the first trick was turned. That is in no way a justification for legalization.
 
Yes, it is being normalised. Prostitution may always have been around, but it has pretty much always been treated as morally tainted. What is unusual is arguing that it is a job no different from being a nurse, and something that one would barely have an opinion on if ones daughter decided to become a prostitute. That is normalisation.

Looking through the articles on NZ prostitution, I noted that the workers names are changed or omitted. Looking at the linked brothel sites, no face pics shown and fake names there too. Pretty sure my plumber doesn't go to such lengths to conceal his identity.
 
Looking through the articles on NZ prostitution, I noted that the workers names are changed or omitted. Looking at the linked brothel sites, no face pics shown and fake names there too. Pretty sure my plumber doesn't go to such lengths to conceal his identity.
Well, no. I would say that is because there is a natural, or at least deeply engrained, tendency to in fact morally judge such work. You would have to radically change society to in fact make prostitution no different from plumbing. None the less, that doesn't mean you can't go some of the way there, or won't do damage in trying to go there.
 
Well, no. I would say that is because there is a natural, or at least deeply engrained, tendency to in fact morally judge such work. You would have to radically change society to in fact make prostitution no different from plumbing. None the less, that doesn't mean you can't go some of the way there, or won't do damage in trying to go there.

One of the articles had the brothel worker involved in a relationship with a man, and she chose not to tell him what she did for a living. When she came clean, he split. So I'm guessing that normalization isn't even happening there. It's still a down low occupation, but not criminal anymore. Maybe that is a good thing, all in.

I mean, some people can drink responsibly, and appreciate a fine wine. Some are alchys who drive drunk. But we don't really question the moral justification of distillery workers. Maybe a controlled vice is better than criminality, without trying to normalize it.
 
Well, no. I would say that is because there is a natural, or at least deeply engrained, tendency to in fact morally judge such work. You would have to radically change society to in fact make prostitution no different from plumbing. None the less, that doesn't mean you can't go some of the way there, or won't do damage in trying to go there.

Or, sex work has been stigmatized by a certain subset of religions that have done their best to make sex a bad thing and which we are now slowly shedding.

Society now is better than it was. Clearly keeping up the change will be for the better.
 
No I don't reject any concept of morality. All I'm saying, and have been saying, is that the scientific method is no good for answering these kinds of questions. You yourself pointed to non-scientific ways of thinking about the problem and I agreed with you.

Yes, you do. You have explicitly said so on many occasions.
What you actually mean, then, is that you reject other people's morality- which is not the same thing at all.
 
You can't tell with certainty. The scientific method can't tell you. You gave an example of a way one could rationally form an opinion about this kind of thing. Rationality didn't start with the scientific method.

And yet you seem certain that deletirious effects will happen. Curious.

No. I've explained this already. The fact that one can't be certain about such things isn't in and of itself any kind of bar to action. I certainly haven't made this argument in the current discussion. We just make our decision about what to do based on less certain things than scientific knowledge, like our experience and beliefs about how the world works, or world view, our ideology. Again, you gave examples in your own recent post of this kind of thinking.

Then, once again, you have no reason to argue against legalising prostitution.

Again, the question isn't not being able to identify things. That is easy. The issue is whether one can demonstrate them scientifically, that is effectively impossible if we are talking at the level of society that I am concerned with.

No, it is about being to identify things. You can't criticise an action because of the danger of possible disbenefits you can't identify. How can you not see this?

At an individual level it isn't that difficult, there are plenty of papers on porn addiction and other individualised harms.

Which is an argument against addiction, not against porn. People get addicted to all sorts of things- exercise and cleaning the house, for example. That's no reason to ban them. It is a reason to provide support, though.

The thing is that actually, what motivates all this is some kind of libertarian belief that people should be allowed to do whatever they want so long as it isn't harming other people.

Harming other people- or themselves. Important distinction.

If a generation of teenagers masturbate their lives away, then that is fine, so long as they freely choose to do so. These are actually ideology motivated policies rather than data motivated ones. Even where harm can be shown, we kind of decide that the harm is OK because of some non-quantifiable social good that we believe in.

Which is not only untrue, it is also arguing against your previous point. You said it wasn't harming people. Now you're saying it does.

Again though, the harm I am interested in is the long term harm to society, and that can not be demonstrated one way or the other scientifically.

Nor identified in any other way, it seems. If a harm cannot be identified in any way, how can you define it as a harm?

There are no ends of people identifying social harms of normalising prostitution, it has been covered in this thread.

So you can identify the harms? For goodness sake, man, make your mind up.

There was a discussion earlier about people increasingly viewing sex and relationships transactionally, where buying somebody dinner is not meaningfully different to paying a prostitute. The issue is that these kinds of harms can't be proven one way or the other by the scientific method. We could pretend that scientific knowledge, backed up by controlled experiments is the only kind of knowledge that there is. What we do then is smuggle in our own ideology upon which we are actually making these decisions, and then fight off people with other world views because we can't have ideology and unscientific thinking impacting our decisions.

No, you're trying to make that the issue. The actual point is, as I stated above, that if the harm cannot be identified by any means, then it cannot legitimately be termed a harm.
 
Yes, you do. You have explicitly said so on many occasions.
What you actually mean, then, is that you reject other people's morality- which is not the same thing at all.
Did I? I don't distrust you, but I think there must be a misunderstanding here. Could you point to somewhere I've said this. It doesn't sound like something I think.
 
Last edited:
No I don't reject any concept of morality. All I'm saying, and have been saying, is that the scientific method is no good for answering these kinds of questions. You yourself pointed to non-scientific ways of thinking about the problem and I agreed with you.

Asserting, never supporting.
 
...snip...


I think banquetbear said something about matrices a while back. It doesn't matter.


...snip...

Sums up your entire stream of consciousness - doesn't matter what or even if someone said something.

Thankfully reality exists.
 
Well, no. I would say that is because there is a natural, or at least deeply engrained, tendency to in fact morally judge such work. You would have to radically change society to in fact make prostitution no different from plumbing. None the less, that doesn't mean you can't go some of the way there, or won't do damage in trying to go there.

We know you would say it - but can you provide evidence for your assertion....

Oh sorry forgot "It doesn't matter." whether what you say is true or not.
 
And yet you seem certain that deletirious effects will happen. Curious.
I believe that there will be. I am certainly not mathematically certain. I gladly admit I could be wrong.

Then, once again, you have no reason to argue against legalising prostitution.
Yes I do, I'm just not really focused on doing that. My argument here is that effectively the decision is not determined by the data, it is not a scientific decision, it is a decision that is much more influenced by our world view, our ideology, the kinds of far less certain knowledge that you mentioned, like looking at the experience of other cultures and other times. There is no point in arguing about that though, if people take the view that their perspective on the question is scientific and ideology free. So, I tackle the first problem first.

No, it is about being to identify things. You can't criticise an action because of the danger of possible disbenefits you can't identify. How can you not see this?
I think I do see disbenefits being actualised as policies like this are implemented. The problem has never been not being able to see disbenefits. The problem is that the nature of many of the disbenefits is such that they can't be scientifically demonstrated.

In any case, people get concerned about disbenefits that they can't prove all the time. Rolfe is concerned in the trans thread about what will happen if bathrooms and changing rooms are opened up to transwomen based on self ID. She is concerned that as that becomes normalised more and more men with unwholesome intentions will enter women's spaces. Now, that is a very difficult thing to prove one way or the other. It is a concrete concern though, even if it can't really be quantified. In principle, perhaps this risk count be quantified, but it doesn't seem to have been. Does Rolfe's concern count for zero in the cost benefit analysis?

Which is an argument against addiction, not against porn. People get addicted to all sorts of things- exercise and cleaning the house, for example. That's no reason to ban them. It is a reason to provide support, though.
Sure, but are all things one might get addicted to equally addictive and equally harmful if addicted? You seem to be dismissing this harm out of hand. Why? Is there some unquantifiable social benefit that comes from giving people the freedom to become addicted to hentai and masturbate their lives away? This is starting to feel a lot like an ideological good trumping the data and the science.

Harming other people- or themselves. Important distinction.
Is it? That sounds like an ideological distinction. Does the data tell you that that is an important distinction? Does science tell you one is worse than the other. All I'm saying is that these kinds of things (normalising prostitution/pornography) inevitably depend on ones ideology. I'm not saying that that means you can't take a position. I'm saying that means it is primarily an ideological conversation, not really one about data and science and studies.

Which is not only untrue, it is also arguing against your previous point. You said it wasn't harming people. Now you're saying it does.
I do not think I said it wasn't harming people.

Nor identified in any other way, it seems. If a harm cannot be identified in any way, how can you define it as a harm?
Interesting question. We can't really do any kind of cost benefit analysis if we can't quantify harm. How about "tending to reduce the capacity of society to maintain order". Or "the reduction in social trust". Really what we think is a harm comes a lot from our world view/ideology, so we are back there again.

So you can identify the harms? For goodness sake, man, make your mind up.
I never said I couldn't, or at least I never meant to. What I have been telling you is that it is very easy to say "I think X is a harm based on this social theory I find convincing, or based on a similarity I see to this historical example". What you often can't do is demonstrate scientifically that there is in fact a link between the claimed cause and the harm.

No, you're trying to make that the issue. The actual point is, as I stated above, that if the harm cannot be identified by any means, then it cannot legitimately be termed a harm.
I've told you already..... you identified an example of a way of identifying a harm I agreed with. One can look at historical examples and draw conclusions. That's pretty much where my world view comes from, along with reading the thoughts of other people who have done the same. There are great thick books comparing the collapse of different civilisations and trying to learn lessons from them. What you absolutely can't do is scientifically prove any of these theories. You can't get a value for risk, and another value for impact out of those theories. Again, this is based on an example that you provided.
 
Unfortunately, the sort of thought process you describe, deliberately provocative though it was, is much closer to the truth once you strip away the veneer. It can be better intentioned than that, it can be more considered than that, but it isn't fundamentally different from that.


Oh, I know it's true that some people feel that way about prostitutes. That's because many of those who do are very vocal about it. They sometimes even seem to think it shows their own moral superiority to deliver spittle-flecked rants about HAR-lots and Jezz-EE-bels and how only the righteous ranter is going to be spared when Gawd rains down the fire like Sodom and Gomorrah.

Now, we can try to understand that attitude better, for example by looking at evolution. Has there been, over the eons, some competitive advantage for societies to keep some of those people around, keep their genes in the deck so to speak, and even sometimes listen to them, instead of just throwing them in tar pits and then getting on with their sexy fun? Probably, yes, and we can make a very good guess at that underlying reason: infectious disease, during the ages and ages when humanity had no way of treating it and no clue what caused it, but were smart enough to notice that people who had intimate contact with fewer other people got less of it.

Infectious disease is the largest factor in natural selection, historically killing more of our ancestors than predators, natural disasters, hunger, or war. We've been one of the few generations to live with a mere shadow of that threat, expecting all of our siblings to grow up with us instead of about half of them. But old instincts associated with it still manage to prioritize themselves in surprising ways, such as with Covid-19 when all of a sudden all the bodily-autonomy do-your-own-thing people were calling for concentration camps for the unvaccinated, while all the same political blocs who were telling me when I was a kid how it would be my proper duty to go to Vietnam when I turned eighteen were suddenly violently opposed to being compelled to take individual risks for the benefit of society. Weird, huh? Hypocrisy all around, for sure, but it's also not surprising that consistent rational thinking breaks down a bit when confronting the force that dominated our fates since before we had opposable thumbs.

So there you go: you don't have to fear prostitutes any more, because we have medicine.
 
What I have been telling you is that it is very easy to say "I think X is a harm based on this social theory I find convincing, or based on a similarity I see to this historical example". What you often can't do is demonstrate scientifically that there is in fact a link between the claimed cause and the harm.

Likewise others can say "I think X is a benefit based on this social theory I find convincing, or based on a similarity I see to this historical example", even if they also can't demonstrate scientifically that there is in fact a link between the claimed cause and the benefit. So neither is any help when it comes to making a decision about whether to do X.

If there is, however, data which indicates that there are people - those who would be most effected by the decision - who will most likely benefit from X, then the case for X is stronger than the case against X.
 
Likewise others can say "I think X is a benefit based on this social theory I find convincing, or based on a similarity I see to this historical example", even if they also can't demonstrate scientifically that there is in fact a link between the claimed cause and the benefit. So neither is any help when it comes to making a decision about whether to do X.
Yes to the first part, no to the second. That just isn't how decisions are made. Look, suppose there is some jungle ahead of us that we are thinking of walking through. I'm convinced, but can't prove, it is full of ravenous tigers, and diamonds as big as your fist are there for the taking. You are convinced, but can't prove, it is full of head hunters, and diamonds as big as your fist are there for the taking. We can even prove to high likelihood that there diamonds as big as your fist are there for the taking, but while we can give an account of why we think the jungle is in fact deadly, neither of us can prove it. We don't therefore decide to meet in the middle and walk into the jungle on the assumption that the only thing in there are diamonds as big as your fist are there for the taking. You can't scientifically demonstrate any of this individualistic liberty, relations as a contract stuff is actually good for society either, but it's so culturally dominating that it gets implemented as if you could. Decisions are simply not taken in the way you describe.

If there is, however, data which indicates that there are people - those who would be most effected by the decision - who will most likely benefit from X, then the case for X is stronger than the case against X.
This is not how decisions are made. It's already come up that ubiquitous free porn may create a bunch of porn addicts and harm people, but that's dismissed because of the unquantifiable assumed good of "individual liberty" etc. Nobody has proved that that is a good. It's not based on data. It's just assumed because the ideology that believes it is sufficiently dominant.

Honestly, this feels like the way Jeremy Bentham viewed the world.
 
Last edited:
I do not think I said in that thread that I reject any concept of morality. Where did I say that I did? Political realism isn't a rejection of morality.

shuttlt said:
I reject self evident universalist morality.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=13813518#post13813518

Now, as you have gone to very lengthy pains to point out in this thread, you also reject the idea of individual morality- that people should be free to make their own moral choices, something you dismiss as 'liberal' or 'libertarian' (terms you seem to consider to be derogatory).
So, if you reject both universal morality and individual morality, that doesn't leave much else, does it?
Furthermore, in that same thread, you defined your own morality as 'seeing if it works or if it doesn't work'. Well, for a start, that's not morality, that's pragmatism. Then there's the problem (for you) that you are not prepared to apply this 'moral' pragmatism to the question of legalising prostitution. If you were, you would agree to let it happen, and then see if it works or not. Your opposition to this legalisation is surely a case of you trying to apply your own morality to others, something you say you don't support.
Finally, of course, you keep ruling out any possibility of even determining if it has worked or not.
In summary, then, your so-called moral position is a self-contradictory mess. You don't have morals yourself, you don't agree with societies trying to agree to a common moral framework, you don't want individuals to use their own moral judgements, and you don't want others to use the same 'moral' criteria that you do.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom