Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

VonNeumann said:
If I say chipmunk is a darwin-faither then I labelled you, yes. But if I make reference to darwin-faithers, and you think I'm talking about you, then you have labeled yourself.

No, no, Von. You call all of us Darwin-faithers because it makes your position much more tenable if you think that "all our opinions are faith-based." That way you can claim anything you like.

VonNeumann said:
Good point. Skeptics fault IDers for NOT having enough imagination. Why? Because IDers cannot 'imagine' the evidence that the evolutionists cannot produce.

No, they fault them because IDers use arguments from incredulity to support their position. That's a fallacy, by the way.
 
Oh please, drfrank, don't expire on my account - breath. You say "I hope at least by now you'll have at least upgraded..." - I ask why? I already knew that a few amino acids may form spontaneously with a 'just so' set of conditions. I could give that a nod but we do NOT know how we could get a sufficiently rich supply by purely natural means. There is no evidence, yet, that a rich supply of amino acids appeared spontaneously on early Earth. So you have to say 'it could happen - it is not impossible' in order to move to the next step. That's faith. The next step is to have some events of amino acids self-assembling. I don't know how likely that is. Is there a lab experiment you can point me to , similar to the Miller-Urey, where some short chains spontaneously assembled? To say that a self-replicating peptide of 31 amino acids COULD self-assemble is something I can accept tentatively, on very small knowledge of how likely it really is. So I agree there are bits and pieces. But it takes faith to extrapolate that to the whole product of all the small probabilities, and come out with something that has probability sufficiently high. Don't forget that I used to have that faith. I understand where you are coming from. You think I've got no imagination because I can't make the jump over the gap. No, I can make the jump over the gap, but my imagination is just imagination - just because I can imagine something does not mean it happened or could happen.

Isn't this real simple? We still don't have any new revelations on how, from little random changes, complexity emerges. Maybe we will someday. Right now I think you take 99% of it on faith and you just do not admit that. That is what we have contention. You have spoken of 'dishonesty' here. You think I am dishonest because you cannot fathom my mindset. I can fathom your mindset, because mine was much the same, at least in so far as I did not let myself be bothered by all the missing pieces. You know the theory is incomplete, you just think there is enough to the parts that have some definition that you can ignore the parts that are lacking.

We can look at the same thing and see two different things. Like the frame-shift: I go "elegant design"; you go "proof of evolution."
This is always the fun part - "I think the evidence for the theory of evolution is incomplete and therefore I'll go off and believe something completely different on the basis of no evidence at all" :rolleyes: Your entire idea is a missing piece, VonNeumann lol.

On a similar note, I recently came across a IQ test filled in by a proponent of Intelligent Design

Please complete the following sequences:

Q1. 1 GOD! 3 4 GOD! 6
Q2. 1 4 GOD! GOD! 25
Q3. 1 1 2 3 5 GOD!
...
And, well, you get the idea.
Abiogenesis in particular and evolution are still young disciplines - hell, we've only known the structure of DNA for the last 50 years, but they've both come incredibly far. I fear that the gaps in current knowledge that you rely on are quickly being filled...
Isn't this real simple? We still don't have any new revelations on how, from little random changes, complexity emerges.
Apart from all the observations we have from nature and computer simulations :rolleyes: Also, please define how you're measuring complexity, or I'll just assume that's from the same stable as your measures of information.

Finally, I'll bring up the point of infinite recursion introduced through the idea of your Designer: ultimately it would require some Designer being created by purely naturalistic processes, since you don't have the Deist's excuse of "he's always existed".
 
Last edited:
Gr8wight said:
Strategy: when they disprove your mathematics, make your mathematics appear more complicated and hope...

Disprove? More complicated? You missed the drift. I made some mistakes but my point is still made even before I clarified. It is not complicated at all. The only beef PaulA' and Drfrank have, I believe, is that they think I proposed too long a sequence to have to spontaneously appear by chance.

And they are quite right. Your argument is exactly the same as saying, "then why are there still apes?"
 
Von said:
You have mentioned several n-residue proteins to illustrate the abundance of and functions of such things. Let me try casting this in terms of programs. We have this m-instruction program here that has the function X, and we have this k-instruction program there that has the function Y. You can merge function X and Y, juxtaposed such that you get the novel function Z.
A computer program is not a very good analogy, since it consists of sequential instructions, whereas a gene is a template for producing a unitary three-dimensional object. But anyway ...

Since functions of m+k instructions can be produced by juxtaposition, it follows that this process has no limit and that clearly a orders of magnitude of complexity-increase can emerge from extrapolation of this process of: random change to the small functions and re-combining them.
Juxtaposing two programs would only produce a single program that computed two functions, not really a novel program. However, take a look at Avida and DarwinBots.

So, with the computer program metaphor, what are your thoughts? Is there any way that such illustration helps describe how self-organization works among chains of amino acids? The first problem I see with the illustration is how to synthesize a selection landscape for the programs. How would simple programs evolve into complex programs? It is all in the 'sythesized environment" is it not?
Yes, the synthetic environment is paramount, because it produces the pressures that act to select the (more or less) randomly generated program fragments. This is how evolution works, too.

The argument made against modeling evolution is that the selection pressures are predetermined; that the simulation does not find novel functions as it progresses. First of all, there are evolution simulations that do find novel functions. But it doesn't matter, because the selection pressures in nature are predetermined relative to the organism, too. For example, there is a relatively stable external temperature that the organism must withstand. Organisms that are maladapted to the temperature are selected against.

I would have instead addressed evj if I knew anything about it. Thanks for the link on ev. Now I'll probably have to spend an inordinate amount of time just to try to begin to understand it.
Just run Evj and watch what it does. It evolves a single chromosome that contains a weighting matrix (the gene) and a bunch of binding sites. The question is whether the chromosome can evolve so the gene binds to the selected sites and no other loci. Not only does it, but we can predict the number of bits of information required to do so. You can watch the information climb from zero to the predicted value.

~~ Paul
 
Last edited:
Von said:
Good point. Skeptics fault IDers for NOT having enough imagination. Why? Because IDers cannot 'imagine' the evidence that the evolutionists cannot produce.

Scientists are not supposed to 'imagine' evidence, they are to produce it. Hey, if we only need more imagination instead of evidence, lets go back to trying to invent perpetual motion machines.
But they are producing it, if you'll pay attention. In the meantime, it's just a dumb old god of the gaps argument to claim that the lack of certain details means some magic must have been involved.

Now, IDers could make it more than a god of the gaps argument if they would also produce a steady stream of evidence in favor of ID. The problem is, again, that there is no evidence, only possible mathematical/logical arguments. So far, the math sucks. The probability of the flagellum falling together as a DCO is irrelevant. Dembski needs to calculate the probability of it coming about through evolution. How can he do that? Well, the first step would be to come up with a reasonable model of how it might have evolved. But he can't do that. Why? Because he is presupposing that evolution is impossible.

~~ Paul
 
Last edited:
You've done this so often I have to call foul:
"I was once like you" fallacy.
Fallacy? Look at it: I am not trying to prove anything, I am just saying I think our respective understandings of each other are non-symmetrical. ie: I can relate to your mindset because of having once had, from what I can tell, a very similar one. Just because you may have been Catholic once, for instance, does not give you the same perspective (understatement) into how I think.

Drfrank made a little fun of my declaration of being an early amateur paleontologist. He suggested something like I played with plastic dinosaurs (which I thought was pretty funny). But my point was this: while you (et al) may have been indoctrinated in a religious upbringing, and later 'saw the light', I was brought up with science-faith. It took a long time for me to realize that science=truth is not the correct assignment. Instead, a statement like science=highly constrained methods of qualifying truth is more accurate.
 
Von said:
It took a long time for me to realize that science=truth is not the correct assignment. Instead, a statement like science=highly constrained methods of qualifying truth is more accurate.
Yes, agreed, science cannot discover "the truth." I'm not even sure what "the truth" is. But I do not understand what you mean by "highly contrained methods of qualifying truth."

~~ Paul
 
Really ?
#3 does not equal #2, because there is no plan, purpose or design, but it did not happen by chance, which is why it also does not equal #1.

#4 Did not happen by chance, and has no plan, purpose or design. You don't seem to understand your own examples.
OK, I see what you mean. I must have interpretted your response too hastily.
Your response:
3: happened because of an intelligent agent, but completely without purpose. Just for fun.
4: Happened after previous universe collapsed: deterministic but not intelligent.
I think I first just thought could be categorized as teleo/non-teleo. Reading it again, I just don't think that #3 makes sense to me because of my definition of 'intelligence'. I suppose that is why you admit it is 'just for fun'. But, OK, it is valid that could make mistakes so I could accept #3 as an intelligent designer who got something other than what he had intended - an intelligent accident. It would still be teleo and along the lines of what I've heard many times here: a product of incompetence. You are offering #3 just to cover that base, I see.

And #4, I need your help to understand. When you say previous universe, do you presume lots and lots of universe collapses before one turns out like this one? ...and what is deterministic: the previous universe, the subsequent, or both?
 
No, no, Von. You call all of us Darwin-faithers because it makes your position much more tenable if you think that "all our opinions are faith-based." That way you can claim anything you like.
No, they fault them because IDers use arguments from incredulity to support their position. That's a fallacy, by the way.
Let me point out that Belz is not quoting ME with "all our opinions are faith-based" - it is an incorrect paraphrase. I only said you take SOME things on faith (and it appears you do not realize it).

If we really want to be a 'skeptic', we must have this very straight in our minds. We must be curious and inquisitive. "Skeptics" can never be so sure of themselves when they must span gaps with ideas. If we ARE so sure of ourselves when we conjecture our way through the gaps, we are not skeptics, we are "faith-ers". We all take some things on faith - we need to realize what they are.

BTW, I never consider my term Darwin-faither a personal attack any more than I would take offense to you calling be a God-faither or an ID-faither. I try to always realize what it is I take on faith - I try not to lie to myself. What I observe, in my opinion, is that you could benefit by trying to know yourself a little better, little bros. Ask Mom, she'll tell you :) .
 
Von said:
If we really want to be a 'skeptic', we must have this very straight in our minds. We must be curious and inquisitive. "Skeptics" can never be so sure of themselves when they must span gaps with ideas. If we ARE so sure of ourselves when we conjecture our way through the gaps, we are not skeptics, we are "faith-ers". We all take some things on faith - we need to realize what they are.
You're being fast and loose with the word faith. First of all, science attempts to fill the gaps, while true faith does not. It is the very presence of gaps that injects religion with faith. Second, the gaps will never all be filled. There will always be "gaps" in the fossil record, for example. Will you use this fact to call evolution faith forever?

~~ Paul
 
Yes, agreed, science cannot discover "the truth." I'm not even sure what "the truth" is. But I do not understand what you mean by "highly contrained methods of qualifying truth."

~~ Paul
I just mean the Rules of Science constrain us to qualifying only those things that the Rules will allow.

I'd like to add something. I made this point early on here in my post #243. Twenty three years ago I read a wonderful book "Goedel Escher & Bach" by Douglas Hoffstadler (sp?) where he had this neat illustration about:
1. Provable truths.
2. Unprovable truths.
3. Provable falsehoods.
4. Unprovable falsehoods.

He was speaking from the standpoint of Goedel's theorem, and therefore of formal systems. I cannot help but believe that this translates directly to "truth" (granted- whatever that really means) in the physical realm. That is, I think it applies not only to mathematics, but also to Science.

If it does, then, as 'skeptics', we have a choice with #2 and with #4, don't we?
We can have our ideas and conjectures for some of them and ignore the others, or we can keep all in a holding pattern. It is our nature to fill those gaps with something. If we hold strongly to that something, then those somethings are 'taken on faith'.

So, to close the loop, #2 and #4 are things for which the Rules of Science must keep Science mute.

What do you think about that, Paul?
 
Last edited:
I just mean the Rules of Science constrain us to qualifying only those things that the Rules will allow.

I'd like to add something. Twenty three years ago I read a wonderful book "Goedel Escher & Bach" by Douglas Hoffstadler (sp?) where he had this neat illustration about:
1. Provable truths.
2. Unprovable truths.
3. Provable falsehoods.
4. Unprovable falsehoods.

He was speaking from the standpoint of Goedel's theorem, and therefore of formal systems. I cannot help but believe that this translates directly to "truth" (granted- whatever that really means) in the physical realm. That is, I think it applies not only to mathematics, but also to Science.

If it does, then, as 'skeptics', we have a choice with #2 and with #4, don't we?
We can have our ideas and conjectures for some of them and ignore the others, or we can keep all in a holding pattern. It is our nature to fill those gaps with something. If we hold strongly to that something, then those somethings are 'taken on faith'.

So, to close the loop, #2 and #4 are things for which the Rules of Science must keep Science mute.

What do you think about that, Paul?
VonNeumann, the only real person taking things on faith here is you: you are so emotionally invested in your strange little hypothesis that you must dismiss any evidence for evolution, no matter how strong, using any means available to you.

Conversely, I'd find any evidence genuinely showing serious flaws with the theory of evolution amazingly exhilarating, as it would stimulate so many new lines of research and help us learn more accurately about the world. As would any positive evidence you have for your `simulation' argument. Unfortunately, you have yet to provide either of these.

The corresponding problem in science for "an unprovable truth" would be "something for which there is no evidence, but happens to be true". This is all fine and good, but how would you sift this arbitrary correct hypothesis from the infinite other hypotheses that also have no evidence supporting them.

If you are claiming your simulation comes under this heading, then that makes your simulation as valid as Flying Spaghetti Monsterism and Last Thursdayism, which is what I always suspected ;)

What is the missing number in the following pattern?

1, 5, 13, 20 ... 53, 72, 111, 1524, 1697
 
Von said:
I just mean the Rules of Science constrain us to qualifying only those things that the Rules will allow.
... that the rules will allow us to study. The rules will allow us to study anything that we can observe having an affect on anything else, and that follows a consistent set of logical rules. One could argue that there simply isn't anything else, but that's another topic.

If it does, then, as 'skeptics', we have a choice with #2 and with #4, don't we?
We can have our ideas and conjectures for some of them and ignore the others, or we can keep all in a holding pattern. It is our nature to fill those gaps with something. If we hold strongly to that something, then those somethings are 'taken on faith'.

So, to close the loop, #2 and #4 are things for which the Rules of Science must keep Science mute.
If we can prove that something is unprovable, then I would tend to ignore it. Often, however, we don't get that far, because no one can even give a coherent definition of the thing in question. God is such a thing.

~~ Paul
 
You're being fast and loose with the word faith. First of all, science attempts to fill the gaps, while true faith does not. It is the very presence of gaps that injects religion with faith. Second, the gaps will never all be filled. There will always be "gaps" in the fossil record, for example. Will you use this fact to call evolution faith forever?

~~ Paul
I am glad you brought up "gaps" in the fossil record. If those fossil gaps are never filled, it gives some preponderance to what Darwin himself forewarned about. ..that his gradualistic theory is false. Especially after 150 years if we still have gaps, then could it be said that is evidence more toward a theory that does not entertain gradualism? Many scientists have considered it counter evidence to gradualism already. If there were sufficient biochemistry evidence that evolution can progress considerably, say, in the gonad (!), then it would be safe for the crowds to follow like lemmings to the new paradigm. The new paradigm being that we do not expect to see gradualism in the fossil record. [By 'in the gonad' I postulate for fun that syntactical corrections coupled with accumulated mutation could somehow suddenly bring about a new species - coupled with the horizontal gene transfer via virus, to insure the existence of a genomically compatible mate.]

Personally, I think those who adhere to gradualism, and anticipate finally getting some really revolutionary fossil evidence someday, are old-school. To me, the evidence contradicts that and so they take gradualism "on faith". Why you call that use of the term "faith", as being "fast and loose", I do not know. What IS a better word, Paul?
 
Von said:
I am glad you brought up "gaps" in the fossil record. If those fossil gaps are never filled, it gives some preponderance to what Darwin himself forewarned about. ..that his gradualistic theory is false. Especially after 150 years if we still have gaps, then could it be said that is evidence more toward a theory that does not entertain gradualism? Many scientists have considered it counter evidence to gradualism already. If there were sufficient biochemistry evidence that evolution can progress considerably, say, in the gonad (!), then it would be safe for the crowds to follow like lemmings to the new paradigm. The new paradigm being that we do not expect to see gradualism in the fossil record. [By 'in the gonad' I postulate for fun that syntactical corrections coupled with accumulated mutation could somehow suddenly bring about a new species - coupled with the horizontal gene transfer via virus, to insure the existence of a genomically compatible mate.]
After 150 years we still have gaps? Come on man, stop talking nonsense. Of course we have gaps. It's only been 150 years. Some gaps will never be filled, because the organisms do not fossilize. Some fossils will forever remain hidden in mountains and deep below ground. What matters is whether we are making steady progress, which we are. Please don't be one of those creationists who doesn't pay attention.

Anyway, fossils are old hat. :D The new thing is the biochemical evidence captured in our chromosomes.

Personally, I think those who adhere to gradualism, and anticipate finally getting some really revolutionary fossil evidence someday, are old-school. To me, the evidence contradicts that and so they take gradualism "on faith". Why you call that use of the term "faith", as being "fast and loose", I do not know. What IS a better word, Paul?
How abrupt does a major change have to be to "refute gradualism"? Does it refute all of gradualism, or only the part that talks about the evolution of the particular mechanism in question? This false dichotomy is used by creationists to attempt to refute the dreaded "Darwinism." If some crusty old scientist is found on a street corner chanting "gradualism, gradualism," then you have my permission to accuse him of too much faith. :rolleyes:

~~ Paul
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom