Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

So your designer is created by purely naturalistic processes, then?
I don't know why you asked that just now. I never said what I think is the origin of "the designer(s)". I have heard the question given to me asking where did (a) designer(s) come from. I took those questions to be rhetorical, as if saying 'if you posit a designer you have a big problem because then where did she/it/he come from'. None of us have anything but wild conjecture on ultimate origins of something vs nothingness, do we not?

Also, YOUR designer, I presume, is created by and creates by "purely natural processes", right? We are, as you know, diametrically cross positioned on that one.

I'll take the blame on the confusion. Even with all the words I've spewed here, the context of weaving in and out of thought-experiment vs my own beliefs can be easily lost.
 
He's a stealthy devil, don't you know?

What if god steers evolution not by tweaking genomes but by playing with the environment? After all, he knows about selection, so he need not interfere directly. That would mean that we'll never find evidence for ID in life, so it will look all naturalistic and stuff.

~~ Paul
That's not ridiculously far-fetched, in a way. If I were able to design a universe that unfolds from a handful of well planned out starting seeds, I think I might be careful to let it grow, to see what happens, without ever touching it. I might even be doing it as an experiment to see if the self awareness that I hope will emerge will be able to detect me, the creator. ...or will they be too dumb and be easily blinded by the sparkle of 'reality'.
 
My gonads are ovaries--yes there is a design but not preplanned--a bottom up design like the internet--the designer is random mutation, identifiable forces, and natural selection--descent with modification.
:eek: A lady. I apologize for previously having referred to you as a guy. You have more gonadular-fortitude than some on this thread who would never assign the word "design" to random mutation and natural selection.

This is interesting to me how you have made a definition of design here:
1. There is a design, but not preplanned
2. a bottom up design like the internet
3. the designer is random mutation, identifiable forces, and natural selection

When I design, I usually design top down but sometimes I design bottom up (speaking in terms of computer program design). Bottom up allows me to defer some of the far reaching systematic aspects of design till later. But I still must have a plan in my design. Is there something more you can add to your definition? What did you have in mind specifically when you said 'identifiable forces'?
 
Von said:
You mean: "Chimps, bonobos, and humans evolved [each directly] from a common ancestor."?
What do you mean by directly? Careful now.

I don't know why you asked that just now. I never said what I think is the origin of "the designer(s)". I have heard the question given to me asking where did (a) designer(s) come from. I took those questions to be rhetorical, as if saying 'if you posit a designer you have a big problem because then where did she/it/he come from'. None of us have anything but wild conjecture on ultimate origins of something vs nothingness, do we not?
So you postulate a "designer," but then refuse to go any further? Well, that's not doing science, in the most excellent tradition of Intelligent Design.

That's not ridiculously far-fetched, in a way. If I were able to design a universe that unfolds from a handful of well planned out starting seeds, I think I might be careful to let it grow, to see what happens, without ever touching it. I might even be doing it as an experiment to see if the self awareness that I hope will emerge will be able to detect me, the creator. ...or will they be too dumb and be easily blinded by the sparkle of 'reality'.
This is certainly a safe sort of god to believe in. How does he expect us to detect him, when there is no evidence whatsoever?

~~ Paul
 
Again, now you show your ignorance of both physics and evolution.

Do you know HOW fossilisation occurs ? Do you think members of every species that ever lived were fossilised ? Unfortunately, no. It's my understanding, in fact, that many, if not most, species will provide NO fossil, ever. And that's expected, you know, decomposition and all.
Fossilization is rare. It seems that most fossils we find are due to some calamity and many forms of life are preserved all at once. We get a snapshot here or there. If gradualism is valid, I do not expect to find much evidence of it in the fossil record either. My point is that what we DO find in the fossil record is way too sketchy to form pro-gradualism conclusions, don't you agree?
 
Wow, wowbagger. You stated several things here that indicate you think the physical laws of our universe are arbitrary. If I understand your drift, you think you can turn a knob and get another channel.

Do you think that you could change the electrostatic charge of an electron by one part in a trillion and this universe would still, say with better than .00001% certainty, evolve beings that are self-aware? I do not know, but I think many physicists would doubt it.

Yet you appear to be saying that a universe could form, with everything the same as ours except NO electrons, and surely sentient beings would evolve who would wonder if there were any universes other than there own?

Where do you get this ultra-positivism from? What do you base it on?

The first thing I want to make clear is that I do NOT think anyone has the power to turn a "knob" to change the Universe. Anyone who claims such powers is clearly bonkers, and I think you'll agree with at least that much.

When I said "any type of Universe you could make up", I meant: "... make up in your head", utilizing your imagination.

I did not mean to imply that our laws of physics were literally arbitrary. This was merely a thought exercise. And, it was meant to demonstrate that the Universe was not precisely designed for life.

But, if you still want to know: Here is the basis for my ultra-positivism:
All good books about complexity theory will talk about Algorithmic Information Content (AIC), and perhaps Complex Adaptive Software Agents.
Humans can program software Agents to follow simple rules, and the Agents could even adapt those very rules over time, according to whatever laws the programmer throws in. But, the behavior that ultimately emerges from these agents often startles the very programmers who initially designed them.

Perhaps the novel "Prey", by Michael Crichton, is not the best example, but it is the best attempt at demonstrating the possibilities, for the average Joe, as far as I have read so far. In this novel, a swarm of non-living nano-particles is able to evolve some very disturbing behavior, and for all practical purposes: It's basically alive! Could they be sentient? Probably not. But, they work in very organized, very complex ways, much like lifeforms on this planet.

In the real world, we can only show this on the computer screen, right now. I severely doubt anybody is really going to develop nano-swarms any time soon. But the concept of emergent behavior is the same.

What computer models can do, is recognize patterns, develop a behavior based on them, test the behavior, and where the behavior fails: to adapt the rules (or schema) of their behavior accordingly, and test again, and so on...

But: Complex systems CAN NOT emerge under two conditions: If the AIC is too high or too low. In principal (and this means using our imaginations a bit), if the Universe was made up of one infinitely sized crystal, with no impurities, just perfect order everywhere, then complex behavior CAN NOT emerge, because everything is too ordered.
Similarly, if the entire Universe was made up of particles that are completely different from each other as could possibly be, then complex behavior also can NOT emerge: There will be no "similarities" to find, no patterns to recognize and test behavior against.

So, barring those two extreme cases, just about any "Universe" in between could at least develop complex adaptive systems.

For my next post, I shall try to explain how it could only be a short step from such systems to sentient life forms. And, therefore, lifeforms could emerge from any "Universe" you could devise, in your head.

But, I have to take a break from ranting, right now.

Footnote: I do NOT claim to be an expert on complexity theory. This information is merely based on a bunch of books I've read. All errors contined in here are my own.
 
I don't know why you asked that just now. I never said what I think is the origin of "the designer(s)". I have heard the question given to me asking where did (a) designer(s) come from. I took those questions to be rhetorical, as if saying 'if you posit a designer you have a big problem because then where did she/it/he come from'. None of us have anything but wild conjecture on ultimate origins of something vs nothingness, do we not?
You said in a previous post that you reject the idea of an infinite recursion of designers. The only thing left is an original designer created by purely naturalistic processes. Unless I'm missing something.

Also, YOUR designer, I presume, is created by and creates by "purely natural processes", right? We are, as you know, diametrically cross positioned on that one.
So your designer creates by what? Supernatural processes? Metanatural? Pseudonatural? Unnatural? Artificial? What?

I'll take the blame on the confusion. Even with all the words I've spewed here, the context of weaving in and out of thought-experiment vs my own beliefs can be easily lost.
Not to mention attacking your "darwin-faither" strawman, rather than addressing people's arguments directly.
 
Stew said:
You said in a previous post that you reject the idea of an infinite recursion of designers. The only thing left is an original designer created by purely naturalistic processes. Unless I'm missing something.
You're missing the designer who has always existed, never created. Handy thing to avoid infinite regress.

~~ Paul
 
See, that's the thing. Nowhere does evolution say that man evolved from apes. What it says is that both man and apes evolved from a common prehistoric apelike primate. Your statement above is the same as your math. So far off base as to be laughably easy to debunk, which DrFrank and Paul have done admirably. You are the only person posting to this thread that cannot see how foolishly out to lunch you are. The fact that you continue to argue your untenable position displays how blinded you are by your faith.
You are incorrect that the math was debunked. PaulA' did not disagree with the vanishingly small probability of a particular 100 amino acid chain appearing, he asked why I insist that it could have only happened all at once without some intermediate steps. We are ALL still waiting for even ONE scenario that takes us from the small chains that might spontaneously form, and how they may self-organize into something larger. You may believe that is possible but you do not have evidence that it is.

What is the difference between 'evolved from apes' and 'evolved from an apelike [ancestor]' when you cannot specify ANY specifics about that posited "ape-like" ancestor. Is your imagined apelike ancestor certainly non-simian? Do you KNOW that no simians evolved from Homo X (X = sapiens et al)?

Of course, you do not know any of these things. You comfort yourself with pretending that you do, as you point at me and saying my points are laughable.

"Blinded by faith" is a good description of what basis there is for your self-congratulated self-certainty.

Further, I am not arguing '[my] untenable position'. I have merely pointed out what I think is more plausible to me than what most of you here consider plausible. I don't care whether you buy it or not. I do not care what you think of me. I am here ONLY because I want to learn about how this culture here, the self-labeled-'skeptics', defend what they believe. I have my reasons for being interested in that. What I have learned from you is that you appear only to throw a shot at me, and it appears to me emotional. Emotional response is what one gets from a religious person when one calls into the slightest question about anything they believe.

Yes, I observe that you exhibit characteristics of a religious person. That is interesting to me.
 
:eek: A lady. I apologize for previously having referred to you as a guy. You have more gonadular-fortitude than some on this thread

Ohh, are you going to agree with her now because she's a woman ? I hope not. Because this would go a long way towards showing that your opinions are emotion-based. No offense to articulett.

who would never assign the word "design" to random mutation and natural selection.

Why do you INSIST on this stupid point ? You're basically trying to use it to justify equating evolutionism with religion, which is ridiculous :

design
To conceive or fashion in the mind; invent
To formulate a plan for; devise: designed a marketing strategy for the new product.
To plan out in systematic, usually graphic form: design a building; design a computer program.
To create or contrive for a particular purpose or effect: a game designed to appeal to all ages.
To have as a goal or purpose; intend.
To create or execute in an artistic or highly skilled manner.

"Conceive", "Plan out", "Purpose", "Goal", "Create", "Artistic". None of these definitions apply to evolution by natural selection. Why do you continue to dwell on this use of words ? As pointed out earlier "my car doesn't want to start" is a perfectly good use of words in an allegorical sense. Please, oh PLEASE drop this and MOVE THE HELL ON!

This is interesting to me how you have made a definition of design here:
1. There is a design, but not preplanned

Which is an oxymoron.

2. a bottom up design like the internet

Only in no way, shape or form like it at all.

3. the designer is random mutation, identifiable forces, and natural selection

Even if I conceded this, what would this do to advance your position ? Nothing. The god of the bible still isn't the designer, nor is Zeus.
 
Fossilization is rare. It seems that most fossils we find are due to some calamity and many forms of life are preserved all at once. We get a snapshot here or there. If gradualism is valid, I do not expect to find much evidence of it in the fossil record either. My point is that what we DO find in the fossil record is way too sketchy to form pro-gradualism conclusions, don't you agree?

No. It agrees with our theories, doesn't it ? Animals that are, obviously, related to one another are found, one after another, in different stratas. There is no case of humans, say, found alongside dinosaurs. I'd say that this is pretty good evidence FOR gradual evolution.
 
You said in a previous post that you reject the idea of an infinite recursion of designers. The only thing left is an original designer created by purely naturalistic processes. Unless I'm missing something.

And of course, this would completely defeat the point of positing a designer despite the evidence!
 
What is the difference between 'evolved from apes' and 'evolved from an apelike [ancestor]' when you cannot specify ANY specifics about that posited "ape-like" ancestor. Is your imagined apelike ancestor certainly non-simian? Do you KNOW that no simians evolved from Homo X (X = sapiens et al)?

We don't. We simply have no evidence of them. Are you starting to understand how science works, now ?

Of course, you do not know any of these things. You comfort yourself with pretending that you do, as you point at me and saying my points are laughable.

The bleak universe posited by modern science, purposeless, deadly and without hope, is comforting ??? You're taking your TU QUOQUEs too far.

"Blinded by faith" is a good description of what basis there is for your self-congratulated self-certainty.

:i:
 
Von said:
You are incorrect that the math was debunked. PaulA' did not disagree with the vanishingly small probability of a particular 100 amino acid chain appearing, he asked why I insist that it could have only happened all at once without some intermediate steps. We are ALL still waiting for even ONE scenario that takes us from the small chains that might spontaneously form, and how they may self-organize into something larger. You may believe that is possible but you do not have evidence that it is.
Hang on! Who said we are still waiting for examples of larger protein evolving from smaller ones?

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=9887347&dopt=Abstract

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/...ve&db=PubMed&list_uids=12127461&dopt=Abstract

What is the difference between 'evolved from apes' and 'evolved from an apelike [ancestor]' when you cannot specify ANY specifics about that posited "ape-like" ancestor. Is your imagined apelike ancestor certainly non-simian? Do you KNOW that no simians evolved from Homo X (X = sapiens et al)?
The difference is that the genetic sequence data shows that humans did not evolve from present-day apes, nor vice versa.

Of course, you do not know any of these things. You comfort yourself with pretending that you do, as you point at me and saying my points are laughable.
I'm not laughing at you, but I do keep admonishing you to pay attention.

~~ Paul
 
You said in a previous post that you reject the idea of an infinite recursion of designers. The only thing left is an original designer created by purely naturalistic processes. Unless I'm missing something.

So your designer creates by what? Supernatural processes? Metanatural? Pseudonatural? Unnatural? Artificial? What?

Not to mention attacking your "darwin-faither" strawman, rather than addressing people's arguments directly.
Again, you try to engage me in an argument where you presume too much about what I believe.

How about this: A designer or collection of designers create this simulation that we think is reality. Why? I don't know - possibly for amusement or to learn something? Where did they come from? I don't know. Is evolution possible within this simulation? In the strict sense of the definition, non-teleological/purposeless evolution, I would say no.. I would have to because the designers would have put the mechanism in the simulation as part of their plan, so it is not the flavor of evolution skeptics take to heart.

I believe design is something that takes place as a process of mind.

So whatever and whereever the designers are, they possess the process of mind.

So, that is about all I can give you? Yeh, that's about all it is. Is it science? No, not yet.

I think my rejection of evolution comes more from my awe of mind than anything else. How does something come spontaneously from nothing. How does mind come from something.
 
Last edited:
The difference is that the genetic sequence data shows that humans did not evolve from present-day apes, nor vice versa.
So, you are saying the common ancestor is extinct with no fossil record therefrom?

I have a book here that I think I read but I cannot remember anything it said.. Its by John Gribbin & Jermy Cherfas, 2003, The First Chimpanzee.


Is this recurring idea about chimps evolving from Homo considered fringe?
 
And of course, this would completely defeat the point of positing a designer despite the evidence!
Agreed. Unless that is an anthropomorphic reference to "designer". Art' uses the term "designer" to refer to natural selection. She calls it non-planned design.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom