Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

Again, you try to engage me in an argument where you presume too much about what I believe.

How about this: A designer or collection of designers create this simulation that we think is reality. Why? I don't know - possibly for amusement or to learn something? Where did they come from? I don't know. Is evolution possible within this simulation? In the strict sense of the definition, non-teleological/purposeless evolution, I would say no.. I would have to because the designers would have put the mechanism in the simulation as part of their plan, so it is not the flavor of evolution skeptics take to heart.

I believe design is something that takes place as a process of mind.

So whatever and whereever the designers are, they possess the process of mind.

So, that is about all I can give you? Yeh, that's about all it is. Is it science? No, not yet.

I think my rejection of evolution comes more from my awe of mind than anything else. How does something come spontaneously from nothing. How does mind come from something.
That's it? It's not going to make much of a book. An amateur philosophy of recycled ideas, and no science. I'll pass.
 
You're missing the designer who has always existed, never created. Handy thing to avoid infinite regress.
~~ Paul
Your seminal source of creativity is a mechanism of random mutation and natural selection, correct? Has that mechanism always existed? Was it never created? Is it a product of infinite regress?

How is it that you think you have your origin problem tucked away any better than anyone else?
 
VonNeumann - What makes you think that you have any ideas worth propagating?

I've seen no evidence in your postings that you have an original, interesting, or worthwhile thought in your head.

Put up or shut up.
 
Your seminal source of creativity is a mechanism of random mutation and natural selection, correct? Has that mechanism always existed? Was it never created? Is it a product of infinite regress?

How is it that you think you have your origin problem tucked away any better than anyone else?
It came about as a natural consequence of whatever determined the laws of the universe.

We don't know everything about our origins, but since our theory is based on all the evidence to date, I'd say it's farther along than competing ideas. ID is untestable, thus far, and therefore doesn't have evidence to support it.
 
It came about as a natural consequence of whatever determined the laws of the universe.

We don't know everything about our origins, but since our theory is based on all the evidence to date, I'd say it's farther along than competing ideas. ID is untestable, thus far, and therefore doesn't have evidence to support it.
There is not one iota of scientific evidence of "whatever determined the laws of the universe".

Its a problem for all of us. We can only conjecture. Do you really not know this?
 
It's all tied together for me. First evolution, then origins, then physical laws. For me it seems easier to start now and work backwards. If we can't agree a designer wasn't needed for evolution, all the other topics seem redundant.


I guess it depends on how you define the Anthopic Principle. I've seen it presented in different forms. I honestly don't know which is the 'accepted' version.

Losely, here are the general versions I know:
  1. We exist in the universe, so the universe must have characteristics that allow life like us to exist
  2. We exist in the universe, so the universe must be set up to specifically create life like us

The first option, seems like a reasonable, but somewhat useless statement. We are here, so the rules must allow us to be here. This doesn't imply design or a supernatural anything. But it also doesn't tell us very much.

The second option, implies some intent or set up. So sure, this does seem just as supernatural as a designer to me. But it also seems like faulty logic. If the universe was set up to create human life, then sure, that'd be similar to the designer argument. But just because we are here doesn't mean the universe was set up to create us.

I honestly don't know if you are talking about either of these versions, or if I have the definition 100% correct. But if you are saying that some skeptics think the idea of a designer is equally as unsupported as the idea that the universe was set up to create human life, I agree. If you're coming from the other side, I don't think the fact that life like us happens to exist implies any of the supernatural influence that a designer does.

That said, I *would* like to get back to evolution. I think it's a good place to start. I still don't see where you feel evolution needs a designer. I'm not trying to be repetitive, I would really like to understand your argument.
I think chasing forward to evolution makes a discussion that goes round and round and picks at this and that. Thousands of words and so little progress. You may agree that evolution is incomplete but it is good enough for you. I agree evolution is incomplete except I conclude it is not good enough, I doubt it is the seminal source of creativity.

So back to universe origins: that was helpful that you gave two anthropic principle (AP) facets. I agree that there seem to be two APs. You say the non-teleological AP (#1) "seems like a reasonable, but somewhat useless statement." I agree. The second one is basically a design-bent person's view of AP. ...Two extremely different views toward answering the same question.

Unless you can give me another theory, conjecture, idea, I ask what is there besides these two you gave? Oh, of course there is that it has always been here which is to say - I give up.

The conclusion has to be that there is nothing any of us can claim is scientific theory when it comes to origins, it is at best, weak conjecture.
 
There is not one iota of scientific evidence of "whatever determined the laws of the universe".

Its a problem for all of us. We can only conjecture. Do you really not know this?
It's not a problem for evolution, since something determined the laws of the universe, and those laws allowed evolution.

Analogy: How a rock got to the top of a hill doesn't really affect how gravity will work on it.

It's not a problem for abiogenesis, for the same reason.

That ignorance is just an unanswered question which probably vexes a lot of cosmologists, but at least they admit ignorance and try to find solutions, and probably have a lot more than an iota of evidence. ID justs says goddidit, with no justification, nor any attempt at justification.
 
its such a never ending philosophical debate because ID cannot be shown - evolution can - in a science room. Science leaves little room for doubt. At the end of the day, a proponent of ID has something pushing them that way - a belief in god or higher being. Beliefs are not science, facts and truths are. This is why ID is not science.

God is not real. I cant prove or disprove this. No one can. So how on earth did we get to this designer rubbish?

ID also has the great distinction of being second to scientific discovery. Did I miss something? when did something 'designed' get discovered before it was known as the result of some evolutionary process? ID always steps in after and says 'i told you so'

crap - religious rubbish designed to further abuse the minds of people.

my thoughts.
 
No. It agrees with our theories, doesn't it ? Animals that are, obviously, related to one another are found, one after another, in different stratas. There is no case of humans, say, found alongside dinosaurs. I'd say that this is pretty good evidence FOR gradual evolution.
Then, I'd say, you are easily satisfied.

If you were an alien and found a human designed computer program, and all the software revision history, you would come to the wrong conclusion then. You may determine from a bunch of data on a hard drive that some functions appeared in earlier times than others. All is written in the same code. Some of the same sequences appear in many different functions. Some functions seem to have been parented by other functions. You find that there are functions that replicate other functions (copy them on the hard drive for instance). You would note that you never found some functions that apeared late, with any date codes in the time vicinity of others.

It would be an illusion to you that the program wrote itself instead of that it was written by an outside entity, with a purpose. It is an illusion that the functions descended from a common ancestral set of functions with random changes and some sort of self-contained selection process.

No, Belz, you are so biased you can only draw ONE conclusion, aren't you?
 
Ohh, are you going to agree with her now because she's a woman ? I hope not. Because this would go a long way towards showing that your opinions are emotion-based. No offense to articulett.
What did I agree with her on? I think she is honest in that she thinks "design" is a good word for RM/NS as long as the adjective such as 'non planned' modifies it.

Why do you INSIST on this stupid point ? You're basically trying to use it to justify equating evolutionism with religion, which is ridiculous :

design
To conceive or fashion in the mind; invent
To formulate a plan for; devise: designed a marketing strategy for the new product.
To plan out in systematic, usually graphic form: design a building; design a computer program.
To create or contrive for a particular purpose or effect: a game designed to appeal to all ages.
To have as a goal or purpose; intend.
To create or execute in an artistic or highly skilled manner.

"Conceive", "Plan out", "Purpose", "Goal", "Create", "Artistic". None of these definitions apply to evolution by natural selection. Why do you continue to dwell on this use of words ? As pointed out earlier "my car doesn't want to start" is a perfectly good use of words in an allegorical sense. Please, oh PLEASE drop this and MOVE THE HELL ON!

Even if I conceded this, what would this do to advance your position ? Nothing. The god of the bible still isn't the designer, nor is Zeus.
For the Nth time, I am here to see what skeptics say they believe. You 'sound' angry at me Belz. I am not advancing a position. I push buttons. I get responses. ...I'm getting some good material here.

"god of the bible"? From what I can tell, this subject has been totally out of scope from anything I've ever ever ever said here. Ever. Save it for church lady (how many times do I have to remind you?).

You know, there is a level on which to discuss something like "design". What is it? I mean like when you or I design. How do we do it? Are you absolutely sure it reduces down to mechanism? What do you think about that?
 
It's not a problem for evolution, since something determined the laws of the universe, and those laws allowed evolution.

Analogy: How a rock got to the top of a hill doesn't really affect how gravity will work on it.

It's not a problem for abiogenesis, for the same reason.

That ignorance is just an unanswered question which probably vexes a lot of cosmologists, but at least they admit ignorance and try to find solutions, and probably have a lot more than an iota of evidence. ID justs says goddidit, with no justification, nor any attempt at justification.
Let me try to make sense of this for myself:
Something determined the physical laws, says the evolutionist.
Something determined the physical laws, says the IDer.
And you say IDers call Something god.
But evolutionists don't have a label except for the word Something.
The Something is just an unaswered question. You say cosmologists at least admit ignorance and probably know something.

OK, then you agree. Evolution does not answer what is Something and ID does not answer what is Something, at least not in the realm of scientific explanation - not for either one.

Whatever you believe or I believe, we just believe without evidence.

You know, if you are going to be a skeptic, you are going to have to get used to having to ignore things for which there is no evidence, or you are going to have to conjecture something and admit you believe it 'just cuz'.
 
I think chasing forward to evolution makes a discussion that goes round and round and picks at this and that. Thousands of words and so little progress. You may agree that evolution is incomplete but it is good enough for you. I agree evolution is incomplete except I conclude it is not good enough, I doubt it is the seminal source of creativity.
Well, to be clear, while I think there are some minor aspects of evolution that need to be looked at in more detail, on the whole I think it is an extremely well documented, backed up, and solid theory. I have heard no argument critical of evolution that provides evidence that a designer was involved.

Occasionally I hear arguments along the line "we don't know X, therefore only a designer could have done it", but you have to admit that is poor logic. And, often times it turns out that we do know "X" anyway.

I picked evolution as a starting point because I want to understand your views, and to do that I want to focus on 1 claim at a time. If the question is, "is there a designer?", then it seems easiest to focus on evolution, and if a designer is not needed there, to move to origins, and if a designer isn't needed there, to move to physical laws. It seemed like an efficient way to focus the discussion. If you agree, I'd like to go back to why you think a designer was involved with evolution. Is it because of observations related to evolution, or related to things outside evolution (e.g., physical laws)?
 
So back to universe origins: that was helpful that you gave two anthropic principle (AP) facets. I agree that there seem to be two APs. You say the non-teleological AP (#1) "seems like a reasonable, but somewhat useless statement." I agree. The second one is basically a design-bent person's view of AP. ...Two extremely different views toward answering the same question.

Unless you can give me another theory, conjecture, idea, I ask what is there besides these two you gave? Oh, of course there is that it has always been here which is to say - I give up.
So, just to clear things up. I offered these definitions because you asked:
Do any on you skeptics here have the gonads to admit that Design is no more supernatural than a conjecture such as 'anthropic principle'? There were a couple of you who gave me a silent nod I think. Come on out of the closet and admit it.
My point was, if you go with the definition of the anthropic principle that just says, "we exist, therefore this universe must have some aspects that allow things like us to exist". Then, gonads or no, it would be incorrect to say a designer is no more supernatural than the anthopic principle. If you go with the teleological definition, I agree isn't no more supernatural than a designer, but I also think it's poor logic and doesn't apply.

I'm just saying it is not correct to imply that skeptical arguments on the origin of the universe are equally as supernatural as those put out by people who believe in a designer.


The conclusion has to be that there is nothing any of us can claim is scientific theory when it comes to origins, it is at best, weak conjecture.
I disagree. And I'm not sure how you got to this conclusion. Just because the wasn't purpose to the origins of the universe, why does that mean we can't explain them?

But again, I think the discussion is easier if we stick with 1 claim at a time. If not evolution, where would you like to start?
 
Von,

Question:
Assuming for a moment that there was no designer, no god, nothing supernatural, and the world was the way it was. Do you agree that people, being as they are, would still believe in god or gods?

I'd be very interested in hearing your take on this.
 
Von said:
So, you are saying the common ancestor is extinct with no fossil record therefrom?
It is almost certainly extinct. Who knows about a fossil? Remember, there has been much separate evolution of human and ape since they split off from the common ancestor. I recommend Dawkins' The Ancestor's Tale.

Is this recurring idea about chimps evolving from Homo considered fringe?
Yes. I think the genetic trail will rule it out.

Your seminal source of creativity is a mechanism of random mutation and natural selection, correct? Has that mechanism always existed? Was it never created? Is it a product of infinite regress?
It's a product of natural laws. I have no idea whether they were "created" and, if so, how.

I'm hanging on. Since these are just abstracts, do you want to say how they apply?
No, do your own homework. Don't be like every other IDer I've talked to, who painstakingly avoid paying attention so as not to stumble across anything shocking.

~~ Paul
 
For VonNeumann (like it'll make any difference) :bwall

A small article on the pre-hominid fossil record may be found here. In particular, see Aegyptopithecus.

Also, doing a quick Google Image search on Aegyptopithecus will bring up some fossils that have been located.

I thought I'd point that out since there's absolutely no chance of you actually going looking for any evidence that contradicts your wild assertions :rolleyes:

So yes, our common ancestor undoubtedly looked a lot like that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom