It's all tied together for me. First evolution, then origins, then physical laws. For me it seems easier to start now and work backwards. If we can't agree a designer wasn't needed for evolution, all the other topics seem redundant.
I guess it depends on how you define the Anthopic Principle. I've seen it presented in different forms. I honestly don't know which is the 'accepted' version.
Losely, here are the general versions I know:
- We exist in the universe, so the universe must have characteristics that allow life like us to exist
- We exist in the universe, so the universe must be set up to specifically create life like us
The first option, seems like a reasonable, but somewhat useless statement. We are here, so the rules must allow us to be here. This doesn't imply design or a supernatural anything. But it also doesn't tell us very much.
The second option, implies some intent or set up. So sure, this does seem just as supernatural as a designer to me. But it also seems like faulty logic. If the universe was set up to create human life, then sure, that'd be similar to the designer argument. But just because we are here doesn't mean the universe was set up to create us.
I honestly don't know if you are talking about either of these versions, or if I have the definition 100% correct. But if you are saying that some skeptics think the idea of a designer is equally as unsupported as the idea that the universe was set up to create human life, I agree. If you're coming from the other side, I don't think the fact that life like us happens to exist implies any of the supernatural influence that a designer does.
That said, I *would* like to get back to evolution. I think it's a good place to start. I still don't see where you feel evolution needs a designer. I'm not trying to be repetitive, I would really like to understand your argument.