VonNeumann
Muse
- Joined
- Jan 25, 2006
- Messages
- 914
Nonsense? Creationist? Why is it when someone points out this weakness of the fossil record to a skeptic he delivers this emotional response. (thou protesteth too muchAfter 150 years we still have gaps? Come on man, stop talking nonsense. Of course we have gaps. It's only been 150 years. Some gaps will never be filled, because the organisms do not fossilize. Some fossils will forever remain hidden in mountains and deep below ground. What matters is whether we are making steady progress, which we are. Please don't be one of those creationists who doesn't pay attention.
Anyway, fossils are old hat.The new thing is the biochemical evidence captured in our chromosomes.
How abrupt does a major change have to be to "refute gradualism"? Does it refute all of gradualism, or only the part that talks about the evolution of the particular mechanism in question? This false dichotomy is used by creationists to attempt to refute the dreaded "Darwinism." If some crusty old scientist is found on a street corner chanting "gradualism, gradualism," then you have my permission to accuse him of too much faith.![]()
Yes, fossils are old hat because they haven't delivered. You say because some remain forever hidden or never fossilized in the first place. OK, maybe.
I agree biochem evidence is the best place to go. I conjectured that biochem evidence may show that the REAL reason for the lack of fossil evidence, might be that 'saltation-like' jumps DO happen. In the realm of YOUR evolution paradigm - I am speaking. If that were to happen, the center of evolutionary theory would have to jump from gradualism to this new synthesis, I posit here. Are you saying that such a biochemical discovery is totally inconceivable?