Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

After 150 years we still have gaps? Come on man, stop talking nonsense. Of course we have gaps. It's only been 150 years. Some gaps will never be filled, because the organisms do not fossilize. Some fossils will forever remain hidden in mountains and deep below ground. What matters is whether we are making steady progress, which we are. Please don't be one of those creationists who doesn't pay attention.

Anyway, fossils are old hat. :D The new thing is the biochemical evidence captured in our chromosomes.

How abrupt does a major change have to be to "refute gradualism"? Does it refute all of gradualism, or only the part that talks about the evolution of the particular mechanism in question? This false dichotomy is used by creationists to attempt to refute the dreaded "Darwinism." If some crusty old scientist is found on a street corner chanting "gradualism, gradualism," then you have my permission to accuse him of too much faith. :rolleyes:
Nonsense? Creationist? Why is it when someone points out this weakness of the fossil record to a skeptic he delivers this emotional response. (thou protesteth too much;) )

Yes, fossils are old hat because they haven't delivered. You say because some remain forever hidden or never fossilized in the first place. OK, maybe.

I agree biochem evidence is the best place to go. I conjectured that biochem evidence may show that the REAL reason for the lack of fossil evidence, might be that 'saltation-like' jumps DO happen. In the realm of YOUR evolution paradigm - I am speaking. If that were to happen, the center of evolutionary theory would have to jump from gradualism to this new synthesis, I posit here. Are you saying that such a biochemical discovery is totally inconceivable?
 
Von said:
Nonsense? Creationist? Why is it when someone points out this weakness of the fossil record to a skeptic he delivers this emotional response. (thou protesteth too much )
It is nonsensical that you should suggest that 150 years is even vaguely enough time to uncover a reasonably smooth fossil record. It is also nonsensical to ignore the impossibility of doing so, even if evolution is correct.

Yes, fossils are old hat because they haven't delivered. You say because some remain forever hidden or never fossilized in the first place. OK, maybe.
You're not paying attention.

http://hometown.aol.com/darwinpage/landtosea.htm

http://hometown.aol.com/darwinpage/tetrapods.htm

http://hometown.aol.com/darwinpage/jaws.htm

I agree biochem evidence is the best place to go. I conjectured that biochem evidence may show that the REAL reason for the lack of fossil evidence, might be that 'saltation-like' jumps DO happen. In the realm of YOUR evolution paradigm - I am speaking. If that were to happen, the center of evolutionary theory would have to jump from gradualism to this new synthesis, I posit here. Are you saying that such a biochemical discovery is totally inconceivable?
What biochemical discovery? The one where the worm suddenly has working feet in one generation? I'm sure we will find cases where a 1- or 2-segment critter gives birth to a 6-segment critter or something like that. Is there some way to analyze that event to see if a designer had a hand in it?

~~ Paul
 
And they are quite right. Your argument is exactly the same as saying, "then why are there still apes?"
Exactly the same? How so?

Let me ask you how plausible it is to you that apes evolved from humans instead of vice versa? Is it not more likely than the other way around?
 
Von said:
Let me ask you how plausible it is to you that apes evolved from humans instead of vice versa? Is it not more likely than the other way around?
Chimps, bonobos, and humans evolved from a common ancestor.

~~ Paul
 
Finally, I'll bring up the point of infinite recursion introduced through the idea of your Designer: ultimately it would require some Designer being created by purely naturalistic processes, since you don't have the Deist's excuse of "he's always existed".
The infinite recursion is not my idea of a plausible conjecture. You missed it. I was trying to use a skeptic's paradigm, assuming he believed in strong-transhumanism, into showing him the dichotomy of his model. That dichotomy being, if strong-transhumanism is plausible, future intelligent design of a universe is plausible, therefore...etc.

Please get this right: I do not believe that scenario. I just was trying to find a transhumanist to try it out on. The person I tried it out on back peddled off transhumanism when he saw where I was going. Repeat: I do not subscribe to the infinite recursion. OK?
 
The infinite recursion is not my idea of a plausible conjecture. You missed it. I was trying to use a skeptic's paradigm, assuming he believed in strong-transhumanism, into showing him the dichotomy of his model. That dichotomy being, if strong-transhumanism is plausible, future intelligent design of a universe is plausible, therefore...etc.

Please get this right: I do not believe that scenario. I just was trying to find a transhumanist to try it out on. The person I tried it out on back peddled off transhumanism when he saw where I was going. Repeat: I do not subscribe to the infinite recursion. OK?
So your designer is created by purely naturalistic processes, then?
 
Exactly the same? How so?

Let me ask you how plausible it is to you that apes evolved from humans instead of vice versa? Is it not more likely than the other way around?

See, that's the thing. Nowhere does evolution say that man evolved from apes. What it says is that both man and apes evolved from a common prehistoric apelike primate. Your statement above is the same as your math. So far off base as to be laughably easy to debunk, which DrFrank and Paul have done admirably. You are the only person posting to this thread that cannot see how foolishly out to lunch you are. The fact that you continue to argue your untenable position displays how blinded you are by your faith.
 
How about you send us some links to the peer-reviewed scientific articles your book is based on, instead, VonNeumann?
 
You won't answer?:jaw-dropp
It's all tied together for me. First evolution, then origins, then physical laws. For me it seems easier to start now and work backwards. If we can't agree a designer wasn't needed for evolution, all the other topics seem redundant.

Do any on you skeptics here have the gonads to admit that Design is no more supernatural than a conjecture such as 'anthropic principle'? There were a couple of you who gave me a silent nod I think. Come on out of the closet and admit it.
I guess it depends on how you define the Anthopic Principle. I've seen it presented in different forms. I honestly don't know which is the 'accepted' version.

Losely, here are the general versions I know:
  1. We exist in the universe, so the universe must have characteristics that allow life like us to exist
  2. We exist in the universe, so the universe must be set up to specifically create life like us

The first option, seems like a reasonable, but somewhat useless statement. We are here, so the rules must allow us to be here. This doesn't imply design or a supernatural anything. But it also doesn't tell us very much.

The second option, implies some intent or set up. So sure, this does seem just as supernatural as a designer to me. But it also seems like faulty logic. If the universe was set up to create human life, then sure, that'd be similar to the designer argument. But just because we are here doesn't mean the universe was set up to create us.

I honestly don't know if you are talking about either of these versions, or if I have the definition 100% correct. But if you are saying that some skeptics think the idea of a designer is equally as unsupported as the idea that the universe was set up to create human life, I agree. If you're coming from the other side, I don't think the fact that life like us happens to exist implies any of the supernatural influence that a designer does.

That said, I *would* like to get back to evolution. I think it's a good place to start. I still don't see where you feel evolution needs a designer. I'm not trying to be repetitive, I would really like to understand your argument.
 
I think I first just thought could be categorized as teleo/non-teleo. Reading it again, I just don't think that #3 makes sense to me because of my definition of 'intelligence'. I suppose that is why you admit it is 'just for fun'. But, OK, it is valid that could make mistakes so I could accept #3 as an intelligent designer who got something other than what he had intended - an intelligent accident.

Not necessarily, he could simply have rolled the dice on it, and had nothing to do with the actual results, creating a universe that is indistinguishable from one born of the currently proposed theory.

It would still be teleo and along the lines of what I've heard many times here: a product of incompetence. You are offering #3 just to cover that base, I see.

I'm just saying that random and intelligent might not be as incompatible as you think.

And #4, I need your help to understand. When you say previous universe, do you presume lots and lots of universe collapses before one turns out like this one? ...and what is deterministic: the previous universe, the subsequent, or both?

Both. This universe could be the result of a series of big bangs followed by big crunches. That's non-random, and there's no designer involved. Again, I'm saying that non-random and intelligent do not necessarily go together.
 
Let me point out that Belz is not quoting ME with "all our opinions are faith-based" - it is an incorrect paraphrase. I only said you take SOME things on faith (and it appears you do not realize it).

That doesn't change the fact that you hold that anyone who "believes" in the theory or evolution does so mostly on faith.

This is a common theist/believer tactic : if you make it appear so that ALL parties are operating on faith, then it makes your unprovable position much more credible.
 
I am glad you brought up "gaps" in the fossil record. If those fossil gaps are never filled, it gives some preponderance to what Darwin himself forewarned about. ..that his gradualistic theory is false. Especially after 150 years if we still have gaps, then could it be said that is evidence more toward a theory that does not entertain gradualism?

Again, now you show your ignorance of both physics and evolution.

Do you know HOW fossilisation occurs ? Do you think members of every species that ever lived were fossilised ? Unfortunately, no. It's my understanding, in fact, that many, if not most, species will provide NO fossil, ever. And that's expected, you know, decomposition and all.
 
You won't answer?:jaw-dropp

If you were not one of the more polite skeptics on this forum, I'd say something quite unflattering to you. Instead, I'll address it generally.

Do any on you skeptics here have the gonads to admit that Design is no more supernatural than a conjecture such as 'anthropic principle'? There were a couple of you who gave me a silent nod I think. Come on out of the closet and admit it.

My gonads are ovaries--yes there is a design but not preplanned--a bottom up design like the internet--the designer is random mutation, identifiable forces, and natural selection--descent with modification.
 
Nonsense? Creationist? Why is it when someone points out this weakness of the fossil record to a skeptic he delivers this emotional response. (thou protesteth too much;) )

Yes, fossils are old hat because they haven't delivered. You say because some remain forever hidden or never fossilized in the first place. OK, maybe.

I agree biochem evidence is the best place to go. I conjectured that biochem evidence may show that the REAL reason for the lack of fossil evidence, might be that 'saltation-like' jumps DO happen. In the realm of YOUR evolution paradigm - I am speaking. If that were to happen, the center of evolutionary theory would have to jump from gradualism to this new synthesis, I posit here. Are you saying that such a biochemical discovery is totally inconceivable?

Yes, this is similar to Goulds periodic equilibrium explanation--but it's not an argument for a designer. And it involves how one define the term "jumps"...are we talking about phenotypic or genotypic changes and over what period of time? Some mutations are like fads and confer such an advantage that they spread rapidly--other times environmental causes (a meteor striking the earth, for example) greatly changes or speeds up the evolutionary path of survivors--sort of like bacteria vs. antibiotics.

Although we share 99 percent of our genes with chimps; the genes are expressed differently. Sciam has the study (they also have mp3s and podcasts for download). The clues to what happened as we diverged from our shared ancestor is being pieced together thanks to DNA. No designer has yet made an appearance.
 
Exactly the same? How so?

Let me ask you how plausible it is to you that apes evolved from humans instead of vice versa? Is it not more likely than the other way around?


No...apes are our cousins on the evolutionary tree...we share a common ancestor (a primate)--our closest species kin are chimps. Other bipedal type hominids also shared the earth at one time with humans, but we are the only ones left (unless you believe in Bigfoot)--we have common ancestors with all lifeforms on earth which will necessarily be furtherback than the creation of the
original appearance of that which we are comparing ourselves to.
 
Articulett said:
No designer has yet made an appearance.
He's a stealthy devil, don't you know?

What if god steers evolution not by tweaking genomes but by playing with the environment? After all, he knows about selection, so he need not interfere directly. That would mean that we'll never find evidence for ID in life, so it will look all naturalistic and stuff.

~~ Paul
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom