Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

What is so imaginary about the "stories" of Darwinists?
I read T'ai Chi's statement like that at first glance (as critical of evolution), but on closer inspection I think he was actually stating that evolution specifically doesn't require imagination.

Of course, only he can correct us as to the true meaning :)
 
So I can see how diversity of life may have evolved from simple beginnings, but with a big concession - that being that it had to have been planned. Not planned such that exactly what would unfold was predestined, but planned to the extent that something like this would happen. Now, I have said the word 'planned' which would require a 'planner'. I didn't avoid a designer, did I - Drat!
Drat is right! I really thought we were making progress more progress than we were.

Okay, I'm sorry if this is a little bit of a repeat, but it wasn't clear to me exactly what you were arguing before. So maybe the best way is to take everything one step at a time. From the beginning.

Okay, why the concession? Why does it have to have been planned?


Also:
Your turn. Your favored conjecture on origin of physical laws?
I think it'd be easier discussion-wise if we start with evolution, move back to origins, then to physical laws.
 
wait for my book, if I ever get off my arse.
You said you had 20 observations or so. Can you maybe tell us 5? Or are the interdependent?

Think of it this way, if you can convince this group, you've got it made.
 
I hope at least by now you'll have at least upgraded from "Evolution and abiogenesis are purely faith based and has no real evidence" to "Evolution and abiogenesis are both supported by significant evidence, even if both are far from complete at the moment". I won't be holding my breath, though ;)
Oh please, drfrank, don't expire on my account - breath. You say "I hope at least by now you'll have at least upgraded..." - I ask why? I already knew that a few amino acids may form spontaneously with a 'just so' set of conditions. I could give that a nod but we do NOT know how we could get a sufficiently rich supply by purely natural means. There is no evidence, yet, that a rich supply of amino acids appeared spontaneously on early Earth. So you have to say 'it could happen - it is not impossible' in order to move to the next step. That's faith. The next step is to have some events of amino acids self-assembling. I don't know how likely that is. Is there a lab experiment you can point me to , similar to the Miller-Urey, where some short chains spontaneously assembled? To say that a self-replicating peptide of 31 amino acids COULD self-assemble is something I can accept tentatively, on very small knowledge of how likely it really is. So I agree there are bits and pieces. But it takes faith to extrapolate that to the whole product of all the small probabilities, and come out with something that has probability sufficiently high. Don't forget that I used to have that faith. I understand where you are coming from. You think I've got no imagination because I can't make the jump over the gap. No, I can make the jump over the gap, but my imagination is just imagination - just because I can imagine something does not mean it happened or could happen.

Isn't this real simple? We still don't have any new revelations on how, from little random changes, complexity emerges. Maybe we will someday. Right now I think you take 99% of it on faith and you just do not admit that. That is what we have contention. You have spoken of 'dishonesty' here. You think I am dishonest because you cannot fathom my mindset. I can fathom your mindset, because mine was much the same, at least in so far as I did not let myself be bothered by all the missing pieces. You know the theory is incomplete, you just think there is enough to the parts that have some definition that you can ignore the parts that are lacking.

We can look at the same thing and see two different things. Like the frame-shift: I go "elegant design"; you go "proof of evolution."
 
You said you had 20 observations or so. Can you maybe tell us 5? Or are the interdependent?

Think of it this way, if you can convince this group, you've got it made.
More than 10, anyway. Thanks for the interest DSE but I think I'll just tell you to go read Wolfram's "A New Kind of Science". Go visit the 'Digital Physics' web sites. You can pick up on most of the concepts there, I think. I'll keep a few of what I think are still my own ideas up my sleeve and hope I don't embarrass myself when I eventually try them out on an audience.
 
Drat is right! I really thought we were making progress more progress than we were.

Okay, I'm sorry if this is a little bit of a repeat, but it wasn't clear to me exactly what you were arguing before. So maybe the best way is to take everything one step at a time. From the beginning.

Okay, why the concession? Why does it have to have been planned?


Also:

I think it'd be easier discussion-wise if we start with evolution, move back to origins, then to physical laws.
You won't answer?:jaw-dropp

If you were not one of the more polite skeptics on this forum, I'd say something quite unflattering to you. Instead, I'll address it generally.

Do any on you skeptics here have the gonads to admit that Design is no more supernatural than a conjecture such as 'anthropic principle'? There were a couple of you who gave me a silent nod I think. Come on out of the closet and admit it.
 
No, I can't, but that is no reason to jump to conclusions about the impossibility of an evolutionary solution. The point is that these calculations of proteins and structures falling together as DCOs are irrelevant: No one is claiming that the flagellum fell together as a DCO.

If you search about, you can find families of 60-residue proteins, hormones as short as 7--10 residues, glucagon at 29 residues, and the BPV E5 protein at 44 residues. Remember that protein are composed of common domains, which allows for the possibility of novel proteins being formed by juxtaposition of existing genetic sequences. For example, insulin has a 21-residue chain and a 30-residue chain.
You have mentioned several n-residue proteins to illustrate the abundance of and functions of such things. Let me try casting this in terms of programs. We have this m-instruction program here that has the function X, and we have this k-instruction program there that has the function Y. You can merge function X and Y, juxtaposed such that you get the novel function Z.

Since functions of m+k instructions can be produced by juxtaposition, it follows that this process has no limit and that clearly a orders of magnitude of complexity-increase can emerge from extrapolation of this process of: random change to the small functions and re-combining them.

So, with the computer program metaphor, what are your thoughts? Is there any way that such illustration helps describe how self-organization works among chains of amino acids? The first problem I see with the illustration is how to synthesize a selection landscape for the programs. How would simple programs evolve into complex programs? It is all in the 'sythesized environment" is it not?

I would have instead addressed evj if I knew anything about it. Thanks for the link on ev. Now I'll probably have to spend an inordinate amount of time just to try to begin to understand it.
 
In principal, complex adaptive systems could arise out of any type of Universe - any type at all that you could possibly make up. For example, you can develop a completely fantastical Universe where heat and water don't exist; gravity is much weaker; and a substance I just made up, called glugoglop is prominent, which has no equivalent in this Universe. It is still possible for complex adaptive systems to arise, and therefore life forms to evolve, although they will look quite substantially different from what we know of life. This is especially true given an infinite amount of time (or whatever dimensional equivalent the Universe has) to work with.
Wow, wowbagger. You stated several things here that indicate you think the physical laws of our universe are arbitrary. If I understand your drift, you think you can turn a knob and get another channel.

Do you think that you could change the electrostatic charge of an electron by one part in a trillion and this universe would still, say with better than .00001% certainty, evolve beings that are self-aware? I do not know, but I think many physicists would doubt it.

Yet you appear to be saying that a universe could form, with everything the same as ours except NO electrons, and surely sentient beings would evolve who would wonder if there were any universes other than there own?

Where do you get this ultra-positivism from? What do you base it on?
 
Are you saying this is in contrast to Darwinists, who use plenty of imagination in their stories?? I'm not sure I agree.
Good point. Skeptics fault IDers for NOT having enough imagination. Why? Because IDers cannot 'imagine' the evidence that the evolutionists cannot produce.

Scientists are not supposed to 'imagine' evidence, they are to produce it. Hey, if we only need more imagination instead of evidence, lets go back to trying to invent perpetual motion machines.
 
Referring to the OP:

If we existed in a universe where all the physical laws etc... suggested that life should be impossible then that would be a good argument for the existence of God.
 
VonNeumann said:
DSE, you've totally lost me here. You say there is information to suggest #1 (origin of Physical laws from chance) is LIKELY?

In short: yes.

Perhaps you'd care to read a few articles before you flaunt your incredulity.
 
I thought #1, #2 were broad enough to encompass the two you added.

ie:
#3=#2
and
#4=#1

...that OK?

With that spirit in mind, please add some not already covered.

Really ?

Von said:
1. Happened by chance and with absolutely no plan/purpose/design.
2. Happened due to plan/purpose/design.
3. ..do you know of some others?

Belz... said:
Oh, absolutely.

3: happened because of an intelligent agent, but completely without purpose. Just for fun.
4: Happened after previous universe collapsed: deterministic but not intelligent.

#3 does not equal #2, because there is no plan, purpose or design, but it did not happen by chance, which is why it also does not equal #1.

#4 Did not happen by chance, and has no plan, purpose or design. You don't seem to understand your own examples.
 
VonNeumann said:
an aside:
I paired with a brain surgeon in a ski lift line once, long ago. He was stuck with me next to him for 20 minutes:eek: I asked him about the 'we only use 10% of our brains..' thing, and he said 'I'm sure of it.' I asked how he could be so sure. He said he had removed 90% of the frontal lobe of a cattle rancher. The fellow recovered. Went back to cattle ranching. I asked if his wife ever said he changed, ..if he quit playing piano, writing poetry or whatever the fellow had been fond of doing. Surgeon said, "i dunno, never asked..."

It's a good thing he ONLY TOOK OUT the unused parts! :rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom