drfrank
Critical Thinker
- Joined
- Nov 24, 2005
- Messages
- 445
Disprove? More complicated? You missed the drift. I made some mistakes but my point is still made even before I clarified. It is not complicated at all. The only beef PaulA' and Drfrank have, I believe, is that they think I proposed too long a sequence to have to spontaneously appear by chance.
Come on kids, let's take a look at Talk Origins!
Gee whiz, there's a known self-replicating peptide (chain of amino acids not long enough to be called a protein, but otherwise identical) of only 32 amino acids long. Wow, that's actually 1 amino acid less than I used in my calculation earlier
Of course, and this is important to remember, this is simply one that has been found - it is incredibly unlikely to be either the simplest or unique.
Furthermore, of course, using identical methods to earlier, it comes out that such a peptide is in fact quite probable to come into existence.
So well done, VonNeumann, you managed to pick approximately the correct number by pure chance
TalkOrigins said:Okay, you are looking at that number again, 1 chance in 4.29 x 1040, that's a big number, and although a billion starting molecules is a lot of molecules, could we ever get enough molecules to randomly assemble our first replicator in under half a billion years?
Yes, one kilogram of the amino acid arginine has 2.85 x 1024 molecules in it (that's well over a billion billion); a tonne of arginine has 2.85 x 1027 molecules. If you took a semi-trailer load of each amino acid and dumped it into a medium size lake, you would have enough molecules to generate our particular replicator in a few tens of years, given that you can make 55 amino acid long proteins in 1 to 2 weeks [14,16].
So how does this shape up with the prebiotic Earth? On the early Earth it is likely that the ocean had a volume of 1 x 1024 litres. Given an amino acid concentration of 1 x 10-6 M (a moderately dilute soup, see Chyba and Sagan 1992 [23]), then there are roughly 1 x 1050 potential starting chains, so that a fair number of efficent peptide ligases (about 1 x 1031) could be produced in a under a year, let alone a million years. The synthesis of primitive self-replicators could happen relatively rapidly, even given a probability of 1 chance in 4.29 x 1040 (and remember, our replicator could be synthesized on the very first trial).
Assume that it takes a week to generate a sequence [14,16]. Then the Ghadiri ligase could be generated in one week, and any cytochrome C sequence could be generated in a bit over a million years (along with about half of all possible 101 peptide sequences, a large proportion of which will be functional proteins of some sort).
Although I have used the Ghadiri ligase as an example, as I mentioned above the same calculations can be performed for the SunY self replicator, or the Ekland RNA polymerase. I leave this as an exercise for the reader, but the general conclusion (you can make scads of the things in a short time) is the same for these oligonucleotides.
Another mystery solved!
*jazz hands*Edit: apologies - the superscripts are screwed up in the quote, but it's all fine in the actual link
Last edited: