Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

Disprove? More complicated? You missed the drift. I made some mistakes but my point is still made even before I clarified. It is not complicated at all. The only beef PaulA' and Drfrank have, I believe, is that they think I proposed too long a sequence to have to spontaneously appear by chance.

Come on kids, let's take a look at Talk Origins!

Gee whiz, there's a known self-replicating peptide (chain of amino acids not long enough to be called a protein, but otherwise identical) of only 32 amino acids long. Wow, that's actually 1 amino acid less than I used in my calculation earlier :eek:

Of course, and this is important to remember, this is simply one that has been found - it is incredibly unlikely to be either the simplest or unique.

Furthermore, of course, using identical methods to earlier, it comes out that such a peptide is in fact quite probable to come into existence.

So well done, VonNeumann, you managed to pick approximately the correct number by pure chance :)

TalkOrigins said:
Okay, you are looking at that number again, 1 chance in 4.29 x 1040, that's a big number, and although a billion starting molecules is a lot of molecules, could we ever get enough molecules to randomly assemble our first replicator in under half a billion years?

Yes, one kilogram of the amino acid arginine has 2.85 x 1024 molecules in it (that's well over a billion billion); a tonne of arginine has 2.85 x 1027 molecules. If you took a semi-trailer load of each amino acid and dumped it into a medium size lake, you would have enough molecules to generate our particular replicator in a few tens of years, given that you can make 55 amino acid long proteins in 1 to 2 weeks [14,16].

So how does this shape up with the prebiotic Earth? On the early Earth it is likely that the ocean had a volume of 1 x 1024 litres. Given an amino acid concentration of 1 x 10-6 M (a moderately dilute soup, see Chyba and Sagan 1992 [23]), then there are roughly 1 x 1050 potential starting chains, so that a fair number of efficent peptide ligases (about 1 x 1031) could be produced in a under a year, let alone a million years. The synthesis of primitive self-replicators could happen relatively rapidly, even given a probability of 1 chance in 4.29 x 1040 (and remember, our replicator could be synthesized on the very first trial).

Assume that it takes a week to generate a sequence [14,16]. Then the Ghadiri ligase could be generated in one week, and any cytochrome C sequence could be generated in a bit over a million years (along with about half of all possible 101 peptide sequences, a large proportion of which will be functional proteins of some sort).

Although I have used the Ghadiri ligase as an example, as I mentioned above the same calculations can be performed for the SunY self replicator, or the Ekland RNA polymerase. I leave this as an exercise for the reader, but the general conclusion (you can make scads of the things in a short time) is the same for these oligonucleotides.

Another mystery solved! :shaggy: *jazz hands*

Edit: apologies - the superscripts are screwed up in the quote, but it's all fine in the actual link
 
Last edited:
Quick question. What's the difference between "10% of a brain" and "10% of the frontal lobe"?

I disbelieve that this story ever occurred. But if something like it did occur, then I chalk it up to miscommunication between you and the surgeon.
He may have said "all of his left frontal lobe and most of his right.." something like that. ...and, yes, he was talking about having only removed tissue from the frontal lobe and then HE extrapolated that to be evidence affirming my question about the brain. Perhaps you are as astonished as I was that he would draw such a simple conclusion.
 
an aside:
I paired with a brain surgeon in a ski lift line once, long ago. He was stuck with me next to him for 20 minutes:eek: I asked him about the 'we only use 10% of our brains..' thing, and he said 'I'm sure of it.' I asked how he could be so sure. He said he had removed 90% of the frontal lobe of a cattle rancher. The fellow recovered. Went back to cattle ranching. I asked if his wife ever said he changed, ..if he quit playing piano, writing poetry or whatever the fellow had been fond of doing. Surgeon said, "i dunno, never asked..."
I heard the same story, except the guy had a hook for a hand...
 
1. DSE and I are discussing ultimate origins, viz a viz this thread (Origin of Physical Laws).
Actually I thought we were discussing evolution. But then it seemed like we got to a point where you stopped questioning evolution, but shifted to questioning origins. So I tried to shift to talk about origins of life. I suggested that there seemed to be a reasonable amount of evidence to explain how life might have started without a designer, and then (again, from my point of view), it seemed like you shifted to physical laws.

Don't get me wrong. You're answering way more than your share of posts, and it's easy to see how some of the conversations by get mixed up.

But, to clarify, is it correct that you accept that:
  1. Evolution (without any help from a designer) can adequately explain how life would develop from simple life forms into all of the forms we see today.
  2. Accepted scientific theories can explain how life could develop from non-life without the need for a designer.

If that's true. Great. Then we can move to physical laws. I just want to make sure we're all on the same page.
 
Wrong. Catch up. You use old quotes from people who were only describing missing pieces of the puzzle--many of those pieces have been filled in...and none match your "life came from aliens" theory--Though you may have been well read in the past, you are not well read in the current further evidence in support of evolution. Of course, science isn't about popularity--otherwise there would be "scientific proof" for god--since that's a popular paradigm. But it is about replication and adding to the evolving sphere of knowledge--and this is true in all scientific fields. And that is why the many scientists who do know the latest information on evolution and so forth are so compelling. The pieces of the puzzle fit. And to acknowledge that means having to bear the brunt of the ignoramuses on this planet who have a vested interest in believing that there must be an intelligent disigner. Truly, to me, the arguments against evolution are as primative as those who couldn't believe the earth was spherical and not even the center of the universe. By the way, Gould and Crick are dead--but neither believed in an intelligent designer...and I'm not sure Darwin did either (though he may have given lip service to one to avoid the anger atheism inspires.).

Gradualism is more than apparent in our genes...we can now "see" what sort of mutations ended up being fortuitous--

You have some sort of pet theory about a designer and we've learned that it has something to do with aliens, but your main arguments tend to be those of creationists--the old Haldane's dilemma--long resolved. You seem unaware of the latest understandings of both DNA and evolution and you also seem unwilling to offer any support for your pet theory. Your main evidence seems to be the gaps you perceive in our understanding of evolution--which is pretty much what ID proponents do. That being said, are you the VonNeumann cited in Sam Harris' book, End of Faith?--He is described as "mathematician, game theorist, savant of national defense, and agnostic--converting to Catholicism while in the throes of cancer..."

I think you have a good audience here if you were to present evidence, but it's the continual lack of evidence and your seeming failure to keep up on the latest info. in regards to evolution that makes your speculation so difficult to take seriously. You seem to have a desire to think you're smarter and have figured out some truth beyond what science has revealed...but you give no details as to what that truth really is or what the evidence is in support of these claims. You put scientists who have added to the growing embodiment of evidence in support of evolution down without offering a single piece of evidence in return for your "better" theory. You continually point to "flaws" in evolution...many of which have been addressed, but you don't ever acknowledge it.

And in a group of skeptics, of course evidence is important--it is the tool we use to separate truth from fiction...the tool we use to understand our world. It's the best there is, frankly--especially given the capacity human's have for fooling themselves. Science tends to weed out the fakery pretty quickly (hence the disgaced Korean cloners and Raelians...are you a Raelian?). You feel miffed when someone questions your beliefs (not backed by evidence) and yet you continually deride scientific understanding without seeming to grasp it fully. You point your skeptic lens at evolution which is fine--but you become disgruntled when people point to flaws in panspermia and the "aliens did it" theory you seem to espouse.
Art', let me tell you friend, even though there is a lot of stereotyping going on around here, I don't believe we can be labeled, any of us, so easily. I don't know what a Raelian is nor what is Haldane's dilemma. I am me, a free thinker, a person who changes his mind sometimes, a person who feels gut sure about certain things. I am a person who has been so very wrong about things and very right and wished I had published some ideas decades ago, even if only as a letter to the editor. We are all just humans seeking truth.

You came in late so let me clarify something:
1. Panspermia. I don't buy it. I think it is more plausible than some other ideas but I believe we are alone in this universe so - no aliens.
2. Lateral gene transfer. I thought of this idea when I was a teen. I thought it was a great idea for accelerating evolution (I was a deep darwin-faither). Turns out, decades later, I was right about lateral gene transfer. Who cares. ...but that's why I trust my gut because my contrarian ideas are sometimes right.
3. Viral delivery system. A designer (but not an alien) could deliver genetic material by seeding the planet with viruses. This is a subset to what the panspermia guys say.
4. If you want to ridicule me about my ID slant, here it is : the designers are 'programmers' who created this 'simulation' we live in. They are outside the simulation. Over a few decades I have accumulated almost 20 observations that make the case (for me) that we live in a simulation.

BTW, while I want to stay anonymous, I can atleast verify that I am not the von Neumann you make reference to :)
 
Over a few decades I have accumulated almost 20 observations that make the case (for me) that we live in a simulation.
Von, I'd be very interested to know more about these observations. I know you mentioned earlier that you didn't want to give out more details right now. Is there any way to convince you to let us know more about them?
 
But, to clarify, is it correct that you accept that:
  1. Evolution (without any help from a designer) can adequately explain how life would develop from simple life forms into all of the forms we see today.
  2. Accepted scientific theories can explain how life could develop from non-life without the need for a designer.
If that's true. Great. Then we can move to physical laws. I just want to make sure we're all on the same page.
I do not know why you condition moving on to the original thread with my having to answer these two questions. But.. I have not problem with that.
1. My opinion: it could adequately explain it, with the following caveat. There is no way for us to have evidence what the world genomic store contained 500MYA. That is, if we could go back and catalog all the genetic information that resided in every microbe, every organism, every virus, from that time. If there already existed a basic prototype of all the genetic information we have today - then I think it is plausible that all diversity could have unfolded from that. Most here would think that is totally ludicrous - but I am trying to stretch.
2. No. It is evident that the conjectures of life from non-life are few and sketchy. It is evident to me that a few of the skeptics here think there is a lot more than what there really is.

So I can see how diversity of life may have evolved from simple beginnings, but with a big concession - that being that it had to have been planned. Not planned such that exactly what would unfold was predestined, but planned to the extent that something like this would happen. Now, I have said the word 'planned' which would require a 'planner'. I didn't avoid a designer, did I - Drat!

I'm even more convinced for the origin of the simple life, that there had to be a plan. And even MORE convinced that the origin of the physical laws had to be a plan.

Is there any possible way to have all this stuff that appears planned, without any plan? Yes.

The only other possible way is the strong anthropic principle. But of course, that is just as metaphysical/supernatural as invoking a designer. Why (I'm sure some of you ask)? Because, all those google-plex-plex-plex universes are unobservable, it is untestable, unfalsfiable, etc.

Your turn. Your favored conjecture on origin of physical laws?
 
Von, I'd be very interested to know more about these observations. I know you mentioned earlier that you didn't want to give out more details right now. Is there any way to convince you to let us know more about them?
wait for my book, if I ever get off my arse.
 
Gee whiz, there's a known self-replicating peptide (chain of amino acids not long enough to be called a protein, but otherwise identical) of only 32 amino acids long. Wow, that's actually 1 amino acid less than I used in my calculation earlier :eek:

Of course, and this is important to remember, this is simply one that has been found - it is incredibly unlikely to be either the simplest or unique.

Furthermore, of course, using identical methods to earlier, it comes out that such a peptide is in fact quite probable to come into existence.

So well done, VonNeumann, you managed to pick approximately the correct number by pure chance :)

Another mystery solved! :shaggy: *jazz hands*
[/i]
That's good. I think there were some self-replicators 'evolved' in Conway's LIFE also. That's cool stuff. Someone said IDers have no imagination. I have a wild imagination. With nothing but mere imagination, I used to believe that the existence of a few things like tiny self-replicators were sufficient to indicate that the intermediate steps must be there. I still have the imagination, but my threshold for credulity has risen.

I know drfrank you do not like my computer metaphors (but) ... Let us say someone shows me a simple program that replicates itself.
I go "so what - big deal."
They say "but this program came out of a random program generator."
I say "big deal, its only six instructions long. "
They say "yes, but now with this self replicator, what else is possible?"
They say "Maybe the self replicator will help catalyze other small programs and those will help other progams emerge."
Finally he proposes, "eventually you could have anything, like Microsoft's Windows XP."

I say, "I doubt it."

They say, "you are an ignoramus and probably think XP was designed. How could it be with all its inefficiencies? You have no imagination."

Nevertheless, drfrank, I do think it is interesting about the peptide. BTW, what do you honestly think about the Miller-Urey amino acid synthesis? I don't think I've seen anyone bring that up on this thread.
 
I disbelieve that this story ever occurred. But if something like it did occur, then I chalk it up to miscommunication between you and the surgeon.
:) It just occurred to me, being "drkitten", perhaps you are an MD? The story doesn't reflect well on the profession? OK, I've told the story so many times, maybe I make the surgeon sound a little callous. But of course, he did save the cattle rancher's life - I gotta give him that.
 
"Maybe the self replicator will help catalyze other small programs and those will help other progams emerge."
Finally he proposes, "eventually you could have anything, like Microsoft's Windows XP."

I say, "I doubt it."

They say, "you are an ignoramus and probably think XP was designed. How could it be with all its inefficiencies? You have no imagination."

Your analogy is off based...because certainly you would agree that XP was predicated on Windows 98 which was evolved from Windows95, 3.1, the "user friendly" mode of Mac in a more affordable vehicle, dos...programming code..the binary system...etc. XP evolved...and it is, of course, not any sort of end point...just a stepping stone... Of course, human's are the "selectors" of developing technology...saving and building upon that which works, that which is easier, that which is cheapest, the next cool idea, etc.--the old stuff fades out or evolves to something that better fits in the world of humans that spawned it. But of course, the first programmers did not design or envision XP. They were a critical step, but the latest incarnation was not a planned or forseeable application of the first computer programs...XP, evolved from that which came before...yes it was designed, but not from scratch and not until it became the "next step"--humans can readily select and build upon that which works...nature has to wait for a fortuitous "accident", mutation, meteor impact, etc. for the next step to occur--but nature has an infinite number of "tickets" in the lottery-to-speak and with eons of step by step natural selection (that which "works" and has a survival advantage and/or reproductive advantage), eventually one would expect a complex world...just as one can expect a complex oak tree to result at least once in while given all the vectors (acorns) created and randomly being eaten, falling to earth, etc.--So what sort of hand


Certainly education has evolved...we haven't needed a designer to stop sacrificing virgins and doing rain dances. We didn't need a designer to discover atoms...dna...to invent the technology we have today...it evolved...the current embodiment of knowledge in all areas of science could not have been predicted or planned out eons ago...much less 800 years ago--before the discovery of dinosaurs, carbon dating, and even the printing press--not even 20 years ago. So at what point is a designer needed?--when each step builds the next? A computer program is selected for by the environment of humans and the functions they find valuable...but life forms prior to humans could only be selected via the environment --predators, prey, elements, etc. that they were in.

And of all the life forms, do you think humans are part of the "overall plan"? And I'd be curious about some of the evidence too. I already know the problems you have with evolution...and I'm just curious about the evidence you find more compelling for an Intelligent Designer. This thread is supposed to be about the best case for ID...and It sounds like you have something more to offer than creationists and the like. So what is it? And at what point do you think there was a plan...and where do you think this plan or design is going...what are the implications of this designer? Can this designer be known? Does he/she/it interfer with current evolution (macroevolution...evolution of knowledge...technological evolution...viral evolution...?) Do you think humanity might be a sort of simulation in the way we might observe grow bacteria on an algar plate...or grow colonies of drosophilia to study their genes? Do you think your personal consciousness (memory of self, predilections, etc.) survive death?
 
Art', let me tell you friend, even though there is a lot of stereotyping going on around here, I don't believe we can be labeled, any of us, so easily.
I totally agree.
VonNeumann said:
...Darwin-faithers...
VonNeumann said:
...Darwin-faithers...
VonNeumann said:
...Darwin-faithers...
VonNeumann said:
...Darwin-faithers...
VonNeumann said:
...Darwin-faithers...
VonNeumann said:
...Darwin-faithers...
VonNeumann said:
...Darwin-faithers...
VonNeumann said:
...Darwin-faithers...
VonNeumann said:
...Darwin-faithers...
VonNeumann said:
...Darwin-faithers...
 
The best I could come up with as an answer is, if the universe WASN'T perfectly suited for us in it's basic laws, we wouldn't be here to ask 'why not?'.

It's an interesting theory, and the usual rationalist counter-argument would be as you've outlined here.

Still and all, I can't help but feel there's something to it. After all, it's not just any old capacity that this universe seems to accommodate - it's the capacity to notice itself.

That seems somehow "bigger" than, say, the simpler forms of life that might exist if conditions were slightly different, or the kinds of matter-interactions that might exist if the universe were very different.

Let's say, somebody has to win the lottery, so in one sense the lottery winner was "meant to be" the lottery winner; in another sense not (and the lottery winner who thinks he was predestined is being foolish).

But why should there be such a thing as a "winner" at all? In the analogy, winning, this "special" thing, is the capacity of the universe to notice itself, its own doings. We can say that we have won the lottery, and we would be foolish to think we were predestined to do so; but why is the universe such that it has a "winner" in this sense?
 
That's good. I think there were some self-replicators 'evolved' in Conway's LIFE also. That's cool stuff. Someone said IDers have no imagination. I have a wild imagination. With nothing but mere imagination, I used to believe that the existence of a few things like tiny self-replicators were sufficient to indicate that the intermediate steps must be there. I still have the imagination, but my threshold for credulity has risen.

I know drfrank you do not like my computer metaphors (but) ... Let us say someone shows me a simple program that replicates itself.
I go "so what - big deal."
They say "but this program came out of a random program generator."
I say "big deal, its only six instructions long. "
They say "yes, but now with this self replicator, what else is possible?"
They say "Maybe the self replicator will help catalyze other small programs and those will help other progams emerge."
Finally he proposes, "eventually you could have anything, like Microsoft's Windows XP."

I say, "I doubt it."

They say, "you are an ignoramus and probably think XP was designed. How could it be with all its inefficiencies? You have no imagination."

Nevertheless, drfrank, I do think it is interesting about the peptide. BTW, what do you honestly think about the Miller-Urey amino acid synthesis? I don't think I've seen anyone bring that up on this thread.
OK, so you're willing to admit that small self-replicating peptides could have come about and, all in all, probably aren't that unlikely?

The main arguments against Miller-Urey, as levelled by Creationists/IDers, are that the atmospheric oxygen content of early Earth was much higher than they used in their experiment, and hence amino acids would be unable to form. Therefore, they reason, the experimental results are invalid.

Unfortunately, the current scientific consensus is that the early earth atmosphere only had about 0.1% oxygen, and was rich in hydrogen. Also, if life developed deep underwater (around thermal vents, for example), the atmospheric content would be more or less irrelevant anyway.

Check out CB035 and CB035.1 for a more detailed description and proper references.

So, with this in mind, it is plausible that amino acids could easily have been floating around all over the place, and that first self-replicator would be far from improbable, especially given half a billion years.

I hope at least by now you'll have at least upgraded from "Evolution and abiogenesis are purely faith based and has no real evidence" to "Evolution and abiogenesis are both supported by significant evidence, even if both are far from complete at the moment". I won't be holding my breath, though ;)
 
I find it kind of funny, since IDers always seem to base their hypothesis on their complete and utter lack of imagination.

Are you saying this is in contrast to Darwinists, who use plenty of imagination in their stories?? I'm not sure I agree.
 
...
But why should there be such a thing as a "winner" at all? In the analogy, winning, this "special" thing, is the capacity of the universe to notice itself, its own doings. We can say that we have won the lottery, and we would be foolish to think we were predestined to do so; but why is the universe such that it has a "winner" in this sense?
For all we know, the Universe might have been an attempt to create the perfect chocolate cake, in which case it all failed miserably ;)
 
Von said:
Well good, then. So you can map out a path from simple 3-amino acid proteins, of that sort of magnitude, on up to something like a 100-amino acid protein then? Seriously, I am glad I finally found one of you fine specialists to be able to map out one example. Is there a white paper on this? Please direct us.
No, I can't, but that is no reason to jump to conclusions about the impossibility of an evolutionary solution. The point is that these calculations of proteins and structures falling together as DCOs are irrelevant: No one is claiming that the flagellum fell together as a DCO.

If you search about, you can find families of 60-residue proteins, hormones as short as 7--10 residues, glucagon at 29 residues, and the BPV E5 protein at 44 residues. Remember that protein are composed of common domains, which allows for the possibility of novel proteins being formed by juxtaposition of existing genetic sequences. For example, insulin has a 21-residue chain and a 30-residue chain.

Is there an abstract on the evj program. I'd like to see some pieces that fill in the missing foundation on the mansion.
Here is the Ev (father of Evj) page, with links to the papers:

http://www.lecb.ncifcrf.gov/~toms/paper/ev/


~~ Paul
 
For those who care, (and perhaps no one does but me), I figured I would paste in a relevant paragraph I just conjured up for another thread:

Some try to argue that our Universe was uniquely and precisely "designed" for life. This is clearly bonkers. In principal, complex adaptive systems could arise out of any type of Universe - any type at all that you could possibly make up. For example, you can develop a completely fantastical Universe where heat and water don't exist; gravity is much weaker; and a substance I just made up, called glugoglop is prominent, which has no equivalent in this Universe. It is still possible for complex adaptive systems to arise, and therefore life forms to evolve, although they will look quite substantially different from what we know of life. This is especially true given an infinite amount of time (or whatever dimensional equivalent the Universe has) to work with.
Guess what: Those life forms will probably think their Universe was uniquely and precisely designed for life, and that our Universe is completely fictitious.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom