Physical Laws - Best Case for ID?

Then, I'd say, you are easily satisfied.

Oh, the entire biological evidence points to something, and you think it's insufficient. It's you who can't BE satisfied.

If you were an alien and found a human designed computer program, and all the software revision history, you would come to the wrong conclusion then.

An easy analogy, though flawed. Technology is clearly the result of intelligence, and tools have no function, by themselves. Naturalistic processes are not so easy to attribute to a designer, as you've seen in this thread.

It would be an illusion to you that the program wrote itself instead of that it was written by an outside entity, with a purpose. It is an illusion that the functions descended from a common ancestral set of functions with random changes and some sort of self-contained selection process.

Except that no one could possibly be wrong about this.

No, Belz, you are so biased you can only draw ONE conclusion, aren't you?

Biased by what ? Evidence ? Yes. Very.
 
For the Nth time, I am here to see what skeptics say they believe. You 'sound' angry at me Belz. I am not advancing a position. I push buttons. I get responses. ...I'm getting some good material here.

Must I understand that your only purpose here is to gather responses from non-IDers so you can go back to your creationist friends and "debunk" those responses where your statements WON'T be challenged ?

"god of the bible"? From what I can tell, this subject has been totally out of scope from anything I've ever ever ever said here. Ever. Save it for church lady (how many times do I have to remind you?).

I see you haven't noticed I also mentionned Zeus. Either that or you don't think I was attributing that one to you, but somehow I was the other.

You know, there is a level on which to discuss something like "design". What is it? I mean like when you or I design. How do we do it? Are you absolutely sure it reduces down to mechanism? What do you think about that?

I'm not sure what you're getting at is what I think.
 
What is the real reason for your pain, Complexity? Perhaps your serotonin medication level needs be adjusted?
I get pissed off when I see someone fall so short of their potential.

A mind is a terrible thing to waste.

You misuse your own mind and try to pass your shortcomings on to the rest of us.
 
Okay, break's over. I'm now going to continue my story from Post#947 of this thread.

One thing I forgot to do in my previous post is define Algorithmic Information Content (AIC): AIC is a measure of how compressible a string of data is. If a string is all the character, such as "AAAAAAAA", then the instructions to recreate that data is simply "Repeat 'A' 8 times.”, and thus the AIC is very low. If every single character was different, for example: "AWZU?4HT", then AIC is very high: it can not be compressed, and there is no pattern to it (barring the possibility of coincidence). Such a high AIC is said to be "random".
Complex adaptive systems exist to find patterns in data, and are capable of adapting their pattern-finding rules, when tested against new data. Therefore, an imaginary "Universe" that is entirely uniform, or crystalline, could not develop complex adaptive systems. And, a "Universe" that is entirely random also can not: There would be no basis for formulating an adaptive schema to.
Luckily, virtually any Universe you can conjure up in your head, barring those two extreme ends of AIC, qualifies as a sufficient balance between order and chaos! This could include, but is not limited to, a Universe where there is no such thing as water nor heat, much weaker gravity, and lots of "glugoglop" (see post#880 on this thread).

The next concept I wish to get across is Infinite Time. Infinite Time is, by definition, a LOT longer than the longest thing could ever take. Therefore, using pure probability against life arising anywhere is useless. It doesn't matter if the chances are 1 in 16 Trillion Googolplex Billion. Given Infinite Time, such an occurrence is almost certainly going to happen at least once, if not many, many times.
(Of course, I shouldn't have to add that the concept of cumulative adaptations makes the probability of life forms existing much better than any Trillions anyone can calculate.)

Science, of course, does not have all the answers, yet, as to how consciousness can arise from previously non-conscious adaptive systems, but available evidence speculates the following:
All known life forms (or at the very least, the multi-cellular ones), do not posses just one single adaptive computing process, but several such processes, working in parallel to recognize patterns in various ways, from various sensory inputs. And, such processes can each adapt their calculations based on feedback and memory of past experiences. If you imagine life in an alternative Universe, like one of my fictional ones, you can substitute "multi-cellular life" with any collective of complex adaptive agents that manage to work together, and end up doing so for their common survival. My points will work just as well.

One day, this collective learns that it can run a LOT more efficiently if there was a serial process in place to manage all these multiple, parallel thoughts. This "realization" could easily come about by accident: as a mutant process parasitically taking over others. Perhaps most of such systems just die off as a result. But, it only takes one to find a balance between control and delegation of processing, that can be sustainable. (There could even be more than once such ratio - but explaining why would go beyond scope of my message, here. Read more about Evolutionarily Stable Systems, to know more.) It doesn't matter what the chances of such a balance being "found" are. Remember, we are given infinite time to find it.
This serial process could even be illusionary, or non-permanent. It doesn't have to exist in a single set of neurons or whatever "processing unit" equivalents you are using. It could take turns arising out of different units at different times.
The next step is for this serial process (or illusion of serial process) to take itself into consideration in its own calculations. To prevent the problems associated with infinite recursion, it might take on the task of separating itself from all outside influence, for short durations of time, thus able to "measure" its own existence independently. (Some speculate that the mind delves into quantum layers, where uncertainty principals rule, but I do not need to go that far to make my basic point. That is beyond scope of this post. But, it could help explain the existence of "free will".)

And thus, we have some ideas of how consciousness can arise, as a serial manager of parallel processes, that have arisen to find patterns in the Information that is the Universe around it, and react to them, in order to keep existing, simply because the "chemical" forms happen to be are relatively stable - and often self replicating.

In principal, such a concept can happen in any Universe. The argument that ours was uniquely tuned for life, with "just the right level of gravity, and a planet just the right distance from the sun, and just the right this, that, and the other thing" is null and void. It is not a good argument for Intelligent Design to hold.

So there!

Disclaimer: I, once again, wish to remind the reader that I am not really an expert on such matters. I merely attained these ideas from a bunch of science books. Any errors found in here are my own.
 
My God Can Beat Up Your God !

All this ID tripe begs the annoying question: If life required an intelligent designer to begin with, who created the intelligent living designer, and who created the living designer's designer, etc, etc, etc, ???

And WHO is this designer the creationists (who insist it has nothing to do with religion under oath in court) refer to?

The ID argument has no logical stopping point nor any general goal except to eradicate all mention of evolution and (by their own admission), replace it with theistic dogma.

It's not a circular argument. It's worse than that - it's a hyperbolic argument that just keeps on expanding, never closing, that keeps on going and going and going and ..., provoking endless questions while answering none factually.

One can believe in ID till the gods come marching home, but it never has and never will accomplish a single thing to benefit science or society in any measurable way.

Science requires tangible evidence on which to stand. Faith requires no evidence, which is why anything that is faith-based can never qualify as a science in the proper sense of the concept.
 
Last edited:
It's not a circular argument. It's worse than that - it's a hyperbolic argument that just keeps on expanding, never closing, that keeps on going and going and going and ..., provoking endless questions while answering none factually.

Like any good conspiracy theory.
 
no just probaley repackaging the same garbage in an attempt to fox you
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom