Peer-reviewed paper shows Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies

Interesting that the South Carolina Tea Party convention held last month was in a non-smoking venue, even though the state has no restrictions on smoking at the workplace, restaurants or bars.

Woo hoo! You got 'em there, eh?

Oh, but wait... did you check out the Springmaid Beach Resort where it was held, where ALL ROOMS ARE NON-SMOKING?

It wasn't the SC TP policy. It was the property owners'.


ETA: Dang! How'd this thread get so long? That post was several pages ago. Oops.
 
So what was big tobacco's plan? Have a pentagonal pattern in the US of large concentrations of deaths via smoking to use as philosopher's stones for their ultimate transmutation circle?
 
So what was big tobacco's plan? Have a pentagonal pattern in the US of large concentrations of deaths via smoking to use as philosopher's stones for their ultimate transmutation circle?

I think their ultimate plan would be like that of any business... to further their profits and assure their survival if not longevity.

Does anyone actually think it a reach that Tobacco would get behind (or lead from the rear) a movement which has its stated goals as "less government intervention and lower taxes". With the known history of the tobacco industry, I think this is less a slam against them than it's a great frontal assault of the pretensions of the Tea Party.

And therein, you find the explanation for the robust defense (or robust attack of the report) in this thread. Like Betsy Ross and Johnny Appleseed, some people just want us to believe in the myths rather than look at the politics and money behind the actual story.
 
I think their ultimate plan would be like that of any business... to further their profits and assure their survival if not longevity.

Does anyone actually think it a reach that Tobacco would get behind (or lead from the rear) a movement which has its stated goals as "less government intervention and lower taxes". With the known history of the tobacco industry, I think this is less a slam against them than it's a great frontal assault of the pretensions of the Tea Party.

And therein, you find the explanation for the robust defense (or robust attack of the report) in this thread. Like Betsy Ross and Johnny Appleseed, some people just want us to believe in the myths rather than look at the politics and money behind the actual story.

I was clearly joking. :sarcasm:
 
I was clearly joking. :sarcasm:

I wasn't.... but I was clearly just using your post as a launching pad. I could've really just tacked my comments onto the thread. (Where'd you get the little "sarcasm" smiley? Is that now in the advance smileys,... which I seem to have turned off and forgotten how to locate?)
 
I learned a new term: cursorial hunters. I thought it must mean hyenas were curious, but I was wrong.

Complete derail, but you might find "persistence hunting" a profitable google.
 
1) It is well worth the time to read Bob Proctor's "Golden Holocaust: Origins of the Cigarette Catastrophe and the Case for Abolition." Check out the reviews on Amazon, such as one where I quote from the book:
'
I repeat just one of many horribly-fascinating quotes (p.114), from Bob Herbert's interview with David Goerlitz, the "Winston Man."
'Goerlitz then asked whether any of the company's executives smoke and got this answer: "Are you kidding? We reserve that right for the poor, the young, the black and the stupid."'

2) That is not exactly a Tea Party demographic, and since very few adults start smoking and keep doing it, when they said "stupid," I think they really meant "stupid enough as a teenager to make really bad decisions," an attribute that sadly applies to many otherwise-smart people.

3) From a tobacco perspective, either a Tea Party member already smokes or they don't, but this whole strategy works much better if most do not smoke.
For example, (physicist) Fred Singer (best known for climate anti-science, and one of the 4 key people in Oreskes/Conway "Merchants of Doubt") wrote this piece attacking EPA studies about secondhand smoke, funded indirectly by the tobacco industry. From the Wikipedia entry on him:
'Singer told CBC it made no difference where the money came from. "They don't carry a note on a dollar bill saying 'This comes from the tobacco industry,'" he said. "In any case I was not aware of it, and I didn't ask APCO where they get their money. That's not my business."[11] In December 2010 he wrote in American Thinker that he is nonsmoker who finds second-hand smoke an unpleasant irritant that cannot be healthy; he also wrote that his father, a heavy smoker, died of emphysema when relatively young. According to Singer, he serves on the advisory board of an anti-smoking organization, and has never been paid by Philip Morris or the tobacco lobby'
Right, he did not get a check from a tobacco company, but the money started there, just went through one of these3 or 4 deep funding chains.

4) Some people are surprised that this study had gotten support from the National Cancer Institute. While it may seem odd to some, NCI's mission is not limited to finding cures for cancer after people have it, but even better, finding ways to prevent it happening in the first place. While smoking causes lots of diseases, and the heart problems are likely worse, (From the CDC lung Cancer page):
'Lung Cancer, the Number One Cancer Killer
Each year, about 200,000 people in the United States are told they have lung cancer and more than 150,000 people die from this disease. Deaths from lung cancer represent about one out of every six deaths from cancer in the U.S.'
and
'Smoking causes 80 to 90 percent of cases of lung cancer. Don't smoke, and avoid secondhand smoke.'

All it would take to eliminate most lung cancer would be to end teenage smoking, for which raising taxes is especially effective, given the target demographic. While Big Tobacco is fighting a rearguard action in the US, Australia, etc, it is winning big in Asia.
Foolmewunz probably knows about this, but if not Google: indexmundi smoking prevalence
and select China, Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia, Vietnam, for example. Depending on the country, 45-63% of adult males smoke. % women is a lot lower, (just as it as in the US for years before they got their marketing in gear). Of course, this might ahve somethign to do with the recent efforts to expand the Tea Party to other countires, albeit with changes of flags.
 
Right because when one is trying to understand a U.S. political movement the best source of information is clearly a British M.A publication. Shouldn't this be in the CT forum?

The BMJ group is one of the oldest and most highly respected medical journals in the world.

http://tobaccocontrol.bmj.com/content/early/2013/02/07/tobaccocontrol-2012-050815.abstract

They are also the paper that broke the whole Wakefield-MMR fraud.

It isn't uncommon for them to look at issue that impact health, for example, when pharmaceutical companies are not releasing all of their results.

I have read the BMJ for a decade now, if it is in the BMJ, I seriously doubt it is going to be a conspiracy theory.

http://www.bmj.com/about-bmj

This is the thing about using evidence based medicine, sometimes the results are not what you expect and can really rock your world view.
 
Woo hoo! You got 'em there, eh?

Oh, but wait... did you check out the Springmaid Beach Resort where it was held, where ALL ROOMS ARE NON-SMOKING?

It wasn't the SC TP policy. It was the property owners'.


ETA: Dang! How'd this thread get so long? That post was several pages ago. Oops.

It's growing like a fungus.

But that was my point. The TP picked the venue -- I assume they knew it was non-smoking. My guess is that smoking issues simply aren't on the front burner, unless they are framed as restricting personal freedom by way of legislation.
 
... this is less a slam against them than it's a great frontal assault of the pretensions of the Tea Party.

And therein, you find the explanation for the robust defense (or robust attack of the report) in this thread. ...
Right. It was a non sequitur and an ad hominem attack on advocates for markets and constitutionally limited government. Looks like we agree. The difference between us is that you, Ant, and the authors approve this rhetorical tactic.
 
Tatyana:
Yes on comments about BMJ: some conspiracies are real:
Google: rico tobacco supreme court
Supreme Court upheld verdict of racketeering/conspiracy by tobacco companies.


For an inside story of how that happened, read Bad Acts by Sharon Eubanks and Stan Glantz. Sharon was the DOJ lawyer who drove the RICO litigation.
 
I thought I'd read somewhere a couple of years ago about Tea party republicans wanting to lower tobacco taxes, a quick search showed it actually happened

What happens when you give the Tea Party the keys to the House and leave them home alone for two years?

New Hampshire launched this experiment on itself with the 2010 elections when it gave the Republican Party and its Tea Party faction a generally veto-proof majority in both houses of a 424-seat legislature
(snip)
cuts the legislature made entirely on its own volition to state revenues, chiefly a 10-cent reduction in the state tobacco tax, already one of the lowest in the nation. The theory was that more people (mainly from Massachusetts) would buy more cigarettes at lower prices, thereby boosting total revenues, but it didn’t work out that way. The state government lost $20 million and big tobacco gained it by upping the cigarette price by the same 10 cents.

Why did our legislature do this? Because Americans for Prosperity, the billionaire Koch brothers’ lobbying group that’s been a driving force behind the Tea Party, was pushing hard for tobacco tax reductions here and in other states. (Americans for Prosperity has long been aligned with the tobacco industry. In June, it helped defeat Proposition 29 in California to raise the tax on cigarettes by a $1 a pack to generate $735 million for cancer research and anti-smoking campaigns.)

http://www.conwaydailysun.com/index...0-robert-gillette-home-alone-in-new-hampshire
 
The BMJ group is one of the oldest and most highly respected medical journals in the world.

http://tobaccocontrol.bmj.com/content/early/2013/02/07/tobaccocontrol-2012-050815.abstract

They are also the paper that broke the whole Wakefield-MMR fraud.

It isn't uncommon for them to look at issue that impact health, for example, when pharmaceutical companies are not releasing all of their results.

I have read the BMJ for a decade now, if it is in the BMJ, I seriously doubt it is going to be a conspiracy theory.

http://www.bmj.com/about-bmj

This is the thing about using evidence based medicine, sometimes the results are not what you expect and can really rock your world view.
This reminded me, re the complaints it was historical research and not scientific, public health science as well as social science research is still scientific research, regardless if historical documents are the data base they use in a study.
 
I thought I'd read somewhere a couple of years ago about Tea party republicans wanting to lower tobacco taxes, a quick search showed it actually happened



http://www.conwaydailysun.com/index...0-robert-gillette-home-alone-in-new-hampshire

Fiscal affairs, however, were not the legislature’s only focus. High priority went to a radical conservative social agenda which House leaders shared with the special interest groups that helped get them elected, like Americans for Prosperity, the anti-abortion Alliance Defense Fund and the ever-present National Rifle Association. An early action, for instance, allowed handguns in the State House, apparently as a convenience to the 40 or so legislators who say they carry, not to mention the political gesture.

No one’s been shot yet, but Rep. Kyle Tasker (R-Nottingham) last March became the first to drop his loaded .45 on the floor, amid nervous gasps. (It did not discharge.)
:eek:
 
Right. It was a non sequitur and an ad hominem attack on advocates for markets and constitutionally limited government. Looks like we agree. The difference between us is that you, Ant, and the authors approve this rhetorical tactic.

No, we don't agree at all, Malcolm. Gasp! (I know that'll shock some of you because Malcolm and I concur on so much.)

It's not an ad hom as the spin doctors for the Tea Party are claiming it's a grass roots movement, ignoring the fact that their demonstrations, slogans, signs, transportation, et al have been provided by the long arms of several somebodies behind the scenes. This isn't Mrs. Murphy standing up in the audience on the Joe Pyne show and rallying the country behind her simple words of wisdom and common sense. This is an orchestrated effort to create the impression of a homespun folksky movement which is really just a wing of a wing of the GOP.

Do I approve of exposing the actual backers of candidates/parties/movements? Yes.
 
You remember Joe Pyne? :eek:

The advantage of living in NYC in "broadcast" days was that we had three independent stations (5, 9, and 11 on the dial) plus the three majors and the PBS outlet. Channel 5 ran Alan Burke's show and got good ratings so one of the other two went looking for something similar and brought in The Joe Pyne Show. Burke was a tad more reprehensible (if less acerbic), as Pyne didn't really crossover to racism, although he was delightfully anti-feminist and anti-gay, so always got my liberal hackles up. We watched that crap (both of them) as a tonic to remind ourselves that the bigots and maroons weren't limited to wearing sunglasses and carrying cattle prods in Selma.
 
That is pure confirmation bias, Joe, yours.
You don't seem to understand what confirmation bias is, Ginger, and several others have agreed with my observation that the article cited in the OP is not science (including you, I believe). You could attempt to refute my claim about that paper by arguing that it is science and attempting to support that position. I suspect that since that isn't something you're comfortable doing, you instead try to attack me by claiming that my conclusion is based on confirmation bias while giving no support or evidence (or even an explanation) of that bizarre claim.

Confirmation bias consists of looking only for evidence that confirms one's hypothesis and failing to consider evidence to the contrary. The claim that the article cited in the OP proves that the Tea Party is not a grass roots movement is a typical case of confirmation bias.

Again, if all you do is look for evidence of connections between the Tea Party and various corporations) including some tobacco companies, you cannot possibly have proof that the Tea Party is not a grass roots movement because we know even before starting that the only thing that can possibly be found by that method are connections between the Tea Party and the companies in question.

And if that methodology is somehow sufficient to prove that something is not a grass roots movement, then it could be used to show that there are no grass roots movements since I doubt such movements exist that have no relationships whatsoever to corporations.

Before we stray too far again, my claim is that the following (from the article cited in the OP) is not a scientific methodology:

Methods We used the Legacy Tobacco Documents Library, the Wayback Machine, Google, LexisNexis, the Center for Media and Democracy and the Center for Responsive Politics (opensecrets.org) to examine the tobacco companies’ connections to the Tea Party.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom