First, I never said, "not science".
And second, that's not the problem. The problem is you completely dismissed the evidence based on discounting the validity of it. Yet the evidence was valid.
What sort of 'science' is this supposed to be? Certainly not medical, despite it being in a medical journal, and if it's supposed to be political science, how come the piece displays a woeful lack of political history? Quite frankly the idea that independently people couldn't get the idea to call a movement protesting taxes and an arrogant out-of-touch government a 'tea party' is
ludicrous. That's an
obvious thing to call that sort of thing in the United States. This is like pretending that if in the eighties a special interest group was pondering capitalizing on a scandal involving corruption in an opposing ideological party and using the -gate suffix and twenty years later there being a scandal involving corruption in that party that became referred to with that -gate suffix and thinking that one caused the other.
No, there will always be corruption, and there will always be people pissed off about government and their economic policies/concerns and those will tend to be referred to by terms people will recognize. Hell, the tobacco companies probably chose that term for that reason, they thought people would recognize it and rally behind it.
Them using a scientific template is kinda cute, perhaps this is simply related to the fact it was going into a medical journal and they wanted to fit in? This isn't science, it isn't history, it looks more like a poorly developed prosecution case dependent on
very circumstantial evidence which should be laughed out of court.
Let's take a look at this 'evidence' and put it into context:
Background The Tea Party, which gained prominence in the USA in 2009, advocates limited government and low taxes. Tea Party organisations, particularly Americans for Prosperity and FreedomWorks, oppose smoke-free laws and tobacco taxes.
No surprises there, and no connection either. There have always been advocates of lower taxes and more limited government in the US going back before the Revolution in this country, in fact at one point some got all pissed off and threw some tea in Boston Harbor under the pretense of being something they weren't while they were really a shadowy group with ulterior motives.
...oh wait!
Methods We used the Legacy Tobacco Documents Library, the Wayback Machine, Google, LexisNexis, the Center for Media and Democracy and the Center for Responsive Politics (opensecrets.org) to examine the tobacco companies’ connections to the Tea Party.
Okay...kook alert! Tobacco companies (these days especially) are quite likely to be funding anything to do with conservatives/libertarians as many Democrats would like them taxed and regulated to death, even more so than most businesses. Were they even to find a
direct connection i.e. tobacco companies directly funding GOP candidates, that would
hardly be surprising.
Results Starting in the 1980s, tobacco companies worked to create the appearance of broad opposition to tobacco control policies by attempting to create a grassroots smokers’ rights movement.
Guess that one failed.
Simultaneously, they funded and worked through third-party groups, such as Citizens for a Sound Economy, the predecessor of AFP and FreedomWorks, to accomplish their economic and political agenda. There has been continuity of some key players, strategies and messages from these groups to Tea Party organisations.
Them and every other business, religious and military group which opposes the democratic agenda. On the other side you'll find numerous groups who oppose the GOP agenda and fund them.
As of 2012, the Tea Party was beginning to spread internationally.
What?!?! I'm just curious what they might mean by that.
Conclusions Rather than being a purely grassroots movement that spontaneously developed in 2009, the Tea Party has developed over time, in part through decades of work by the tobacco industry and other corporate interests. It is important for tobacco control advocates in the USA and internationally, to anticipate and counter Tea Party opposition to tobacco control policies and ensure that policymakers, the media and the public understand the longstanding connection between the tobacco industry, the Tea Party and its associated organisations.
I had to look some things up as I didn't pay much attention to any of this, so anyone is welcome to correct me if I am wrong, but here's the stage as I think it was set: the country was sliding into a deep recession, the Dems had just won a historic victory, taking the Presidency by a wide margin. They had won both bodies of Congress, having close to a supermajority in the Senate, which is something they could achieve with just a vote or two from blue state Republicans, and as I recall Arlen Spector would soon switch parties. At roughly the same time the rest of the 2009 appropriations bills are
finally being signed with some extra goodies in there for programs popular with Dems, the banks etc are getting bailed out, and Dems are talking about a stimulus package, which for many people means 'roll out the barrel.' (of pork!)
This situation is virtually
guaranteed to produce pissed off people, all they have to do is read the papers. There's plenty of groups out there who see all those pissed off people and want to help them become more pissed off and show the world just how pissed off they are! Now they have a pack of hyenas on their hands, sinking their teeth into RINOs and looking for donkeys for dessert! They get to DC wild-eyed and rabid, they're going to
feast on the bloated sow that is our federal government and
finally end the misery and corruption! 'No compromise, not even in the face of Armageddon!' Let it
burn! Those ones that make it to DC know the rest of the howling pack of hyenas is right on their heels, cannibals all, they're still picking the RINO guts out of their teeth themselves. Death before dishonor!
Something similar happened in '78 (tax revolt illustrated best by proposition 13 in California) which was just a continuation of the '76 primary challenge by Reagan, who'd been part of the same damn thing in '66 which was a realization of the issues of big government and deficits raised in the '64 campaign. Those
obviously had nothing to do with any 'smokers rights' groups, nor did the final culmination of it in 1980 when Reagan was elected. It's a constituency which has a long and storied place in American history, what it gets called is
irrelevant and thinking the tobacco companies produced any of this, or created the conditions which got everyone all fired up is
ridiculous. All that's needed is an obnoxious government looking more corrupt than usual, and Democrats in charge. It happened in '94 as well, I don't recall anything about tobacco being in the Contract with America though.
This is the part of the GOP that is often dominated by small business owners, their families, and those dependent on them. They're especially sensitive to tax increases and regulations as they don't have the resources to deal with them like big corporations do. They're also displeased when they see government running as much debt as it wants, bailing out big business and sticking it to them. Some of them think the government has no business telling them they can't allow smoking in their establishment if it's one where it has been traditionally popular, and fear/have endured losses of business as a result. Some people still smoke and tobacco taxes are about as regressive a tax as there is, and that's a larger constituency than people raising childen or even the Hispanic vote.Therefore one should expect some of them to be more partial to proposals to stymie the tobacco control movement, and tobacco companies to be partial to those sorts of candidates and movements. However its just one small part of a far larger picture.
There is a synergistic effect with the pissed off people and the groups wanting them pissed off and helping them show how pissed off they are, but that's true of basically every national grassroots movement in politics these days. What has to exist though are
real conditions that anger those people, and the 2009 situation was
destined to produce a reaction from that group of people, no force on earth could stop it, and no tobacco company produce it by itself, and no group control it completely, including the GOP establishment as you may have noticed.
Ever tried to herd a pack of hyenas?
