Peer-reviewed paper shows Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies

It's not an ad hom as the spin doctors for the Tea Party are claiming it's a grass roots movement, ignoring the fact that their demonstrations, slogans, signs, transportation, et al have been provided by the long arms of several somebodies behind the scenes.

First, I'm not making any claim except that the article cited in the OP is insufficient to prove the claim that the Tea Party is not a grass roots movement. (Does that make me one of the straw "spin doctors for the Tea Party" you're arguing against?)

Second, are you claiming that all Tea Party "demonstrations, slogans, signs, transportation, et al" have been provided by tobacco companies?

And are you claiming that there is no such connection between other corporations and other grass roots movement?

When I was involved in a lot of anti-Bush demonstrations, we did in fact get support from any number of corporations. For example, a printing company sometimes donated signs. The SEIU (service workers' union) often bused groups of people to demonstrations. Does it follow that the movement opposed to Bush's invasion of Iraq was therefore not a grass roots movement? Were we merely all shills for the union? If I conducted a study that looked for nothing but connections between the SEIU and the anti-Iraq war movement, the only thing I could possibly find would be such connections. I would find no evidence that the movement was itself a grass roots movement (because I'm not looking for that evidence). It would be wrong of me to conclude that the anti-Iraq war movement wasn't a grass roots movement because of the existence of connections with other entities.

And yet again, this topic really is a CT topic and not a political one. Politically, I'm strongly opposed to everything in the Tea Party ideology. But that opposition doesn't mean I believe the people who are involved in the Tea Party are all tobacco company shills.
 
No amount of tobacco use is harmless.


I'm a former smoker. Occasionally I'll mooch a smoke off someone. Jack Daniels is present in a statistically significant number of these incidents. The next morning I wake up determined never to smoke a cigarette again.
barf2.gif


So I'd say that occasional cigarette is beneficial to me, in a preventative sorta way.
 
You don't seem to understand what confirmation bias is, Ginger, and several others have agreed with my observation that the article cited in the OP is not science (including you, I believe).
First, I never said, "not science", I may have been commenting on other's views.

And second, that's not the problem. The problem is you completely dismissed the evidence based on discounting the validity of it. Yet the evidence was valid.

That is how confirmation bias works.


..Confirmation bias consists of looking only for evidence that confirms one's hypothesis and failing to consider evidence to the contrary. The claim that the article cited in the OP proves that the Tea Party is not a grass roots movement is a typical case of confirmation bias.
I do believe "proof" is not part of scientific inquiry in this case. "Overwhelming evidence of", is a more appropriate statement.


.Again, if all you do is look for evidence of connections between the Tea Party and various corporations) including some tobacco companies, you cannot possibly have proof that the Tea Party is not a grass roots movement because we know even before starting that the only thing that can possibly be found by that method are connections between the Tea Party and the companies in question.
This would have more validity if you didn't start by dismissing the OP citation.

I've not done what you claim here. In fact, I've found evidence that on a continuum from all astroturf to pure grassroots, the TEA Party falls between the middle and astroturf.


And if that methodology is somehow sufficient to prove that something is not a grass roots movement, then it could be used to show that there are no grass roots movements since I doubt such movements exist that have no relationships whatsoever to corporations.
How would you go about this scientifically?:rolleyes:



Before we stray too far again, my claim is that the following (from the article cited in the OP) is not a scientific methodology:
This has been addressed, you're wrong, and you're beating a dead horse.
 
First, I'm not making any claim except that the article cited in the OP is insufficient to prove the claim that the Tea Party is not a grass roots movement. (Does that make me one of the straw "spin doctors for the Tea Party" you're arguing against?)
You seem to be having trouble providing counter evidence. So far all I've seen is assertion.

Second, are you claiming that all Tea Party "demonstrations, slogans, signs, transportation, et al" have been provided by tobacco companies?
I can't speak for Foolme, but this straw man may be the root of your problem.


And are you claiming that there is no such connection between other corporations and other grass roots movement?
It's more complicated than a "connection" however, yes, real grass roots organizations are not so deeply financed by corporate interests.


When I was involved in a lot of anti-Bush demonstrations, we did in fact get support from any number of corporations. For example, a printing company sometimes donated signs. The SEIU (service workers' union) often bused groups of people to demonstrations. Does it follow that the movement opposed to Bush's invasion of Iraq was therefore not a grass roots movement? Were we merely all shills for the union? If I conducted a study that looked for nothing but connections between the SEIU and the anti-Iraq war movement, the only thing I could possibly find would be such connections. I would find no evidence that the movement was itself a grass roots movement (because I'm not looking for that evidence). It would be wrong of me to conclude that the anti-Iraq war movement wasn't a grass roots movement because of the existence of connections with other entities.

And yet again, this topic really is a CT topic and not a political one. Politically, I'm strongly opposed to everything in the Tea Party ideology. But that opposition doesn't mean I believe the people who are involved in the Tea Party are all tobacco company shills.
First, support after the fact is not the same as initiating a movement.

In addition, the SEIU is an organization of members, workers, just as the teacher's union is. That's not equivalent to a corporation where stockholders are the members.

Maybe on paper a union looks like a corporation, and maybe the extreme right wing opinion on the SCOTUS thinks they are the same, but to most of us: unions are people, corporations are not.
 
Last edited:
In addition, the SEIU is an organization of members, workers, just as the teacher's union is. That's not equivalent to a corporation where stockholders are the members.

Maybe on paper a union looks like a corporation, and maybe the extreme right wing opinion on the SCOTUS thinks they are the same, but to most of us: unions are people, corporations are not.
Corporations are legal persons (i.e., they can own property, sue and be sued). Unions are 501(c)-5 corporations.
 
Corporations are legal persons (i.e., they can own property, sue and be sued). Unions are 501(c)-5 corporations.
So?

That does not make a corporation the equivalent of an organization formed by a group of people for some specific interest of those people like a labor union.
 
First, I never said, "not science".

And second, that's not the problem. The problem is you completely dismissed the evidence based on discounting the validity of it. Yet the evidence was valid.

What sort of 'science' is this supposed to be? Certainly not medical, despite it being in a medical journal, and if it's supposed to be political science, how come the piece displays a woeful lack of political history? Quite frankly the idea that independently people couldn't get the idea to call a movement protesting taxes and an arrogant out-of-touch government a 'tea party' is ludicrous. That's an obvious thing to call that sort of thing in the United States. This is like pretending that if in the eighties a special interest group was pondering capitalizing on a scandal involving corruption in an opposing ideological party and using the -gate suffix and twenty years later there being a scandal involving corruption in that party that became referred to with that -gate suffix and thinking that one caused the other.

No, there will always be corruption, and there will always be people pissed off about government and their economic policies/concerns and those will tend to be referred to by terms people will recognize. Hell, the tobacco companies probably chose that term for that reason, they thought people would recognize it and rally behind it.

Them using a scientific template is kinda cute, perhaps this is simply related to the fact it was going into a medical journal and they wanted to fit in? This isn't science, it isn't history, it looks more like a poorly developed prosecution case dependent on very circumstantial evidence which should be laughed out of court.

Let's take a look at this 'evidence' and put it into context:

Background The Tea Party, which gained prominence in the USA in 2009, advocates limited government and low taxes. Tea Party organisations, particularly Americans for Prosperity and FreedomWorks, oppose smoke-free laws and tobacco taxes.

No surprises there, and no connection either. There have always been advocates of lower taxes and more limited government in the US going back before the Revolution in this country, in fact at one point some got all pissed off and threw some tea in Boston Harbor under the pretense of being something they weren't while they were really a shadowy group with ulterior motives.

...oh wait!

:p

Methods We used the Legacy Tobacco Documents Library, the Wayback Machine, Google, LexisNexis, the Center for Media and Democracy and the Center for Responsive Politics (opensecrets.org) to examine the tobacco companies’ connections to the Tea Party.

Okay...kook alert! Tobacco companies (these days especially) are quite likely to be funding anything to do with conservatives/libertarians as many Democrats would like them taxed and regulated to death, even more so than most businesses. Were they even to find a direct connection i.e. tobacco companies directly funding GOP candidates, that would hardly be surprising.

Results Starting in the 1980s, tobacco companies worked to create the appearance of broad opposition to tobacco control policies by attempting to create a grassroots smokers’ rights movement.

Guess that one failed.

Simultaneously, they funded and worked through third-party groups, such as Citizens for a Sound Economy, the predecessor of AFP and FreedomWorks, to accomplish their economic and political agenda. There has been continuity of some key players, strategies and messages from these groups to Tea Party organisations.

Them and every other business, religious and military group which opposes the democratic agenda. On the other side you'll find numerous groups who oppose the GOP agenda and fund them.

As of 2012, the Tea Party was beginning to spread internationally.

What?!?! I'm just curious what they might mean by that.

Conclusions Rather than being a purely grassroots movement that spontaneously developed in 2009, the Tea Party has developed over time, in part through decades of work by the tobacco industry and other corporate interests. It is important for tobacco control advocates in the USA and internationally, to anticipate and counter Tea Party opposition to tobacco control policies and ensure that policymakers, the media and the public understand the longstanding connection between the tobacco industry, the Tea Party and its associated organisations.

I had to look some things up as I didn't pay much attention to any of this, so anyone is welcome to correct me if I am wrong, but here's the stage as I think it was set: the country was sliding into a deep recession, the Dems had just won a historic victory, taking the Presidency by a wide margin. They had won both bodies of Congress, having close to a supermajority in the Senate, which is something they could achieve with just a vote or two from blue state Republicans, and as I recall Arlen Spector would soon switch parties. At roughly the same time the rest of the 2009 appropriations bills are finally being signed with some extra goodies in there for programs popular with Dems, the banks etc are getting bailed out, and Dems are talking about a stimulus package, which for many people means 'roll out the barrel.' (of pork!)

This situation is virtually guaranteed to produce pissed off people, all they have to do is read the papers. There's plenty of groups out there who see all those pissed off people and want to help them become more pissed off and show the world just how pissed off they are! Now they have a pack of hyenas on their hands, sinking their teeth into RINOs and looking for donkeys for dessert! They get to DC wild-eyed and rabid, they're going to feast on the bloated sow that is our federal government and finally end the misery and corruption! 'No compromise, not even in the face of Armageddon!' Let it burn! Those ones that make it to DC know the rest of the howling pack of hyenas is right on their heels, cannibals all, they're still picking the RINO guts out of their teeth themselves. Death before dishonor!

Something similar happened in '78 (tax revolt illustrated best by proposition 13 in California) which was just a continuation of the '76 primary challenge by Reagan, who'd been part of the same damn thing in '66 which was a realization of the issues of big government and deficits raised in the '64 campaign. Those obviously had nothing to do with any 'smokers rights' groups, nor did the final culmination of it in 1980 when Reagan was elected. It's a constituency which has a long and storied place in American history, what it gets called is irrelevant and thinking the tobacco companies produced any of this, or created the conditions which got everyone all fired up is ridiculous. All that's needed is an obnoxious government looking more corrupt than usual, and Democrats in charge. It happened in '94 as well, I don't recall anything about tobacco being in the Contract with America though.

This is the part of the GOP that is often dominated by small business owners, their families, and those dependent on them. They're especially sensitive to tax increases and regulations as they don't have the resources to deal with them like big corporations do. They're also displeased when they see government running as much debt as it wants, bailing out big business and sticking it to them. Some of them think the government has no business telling them they can't allow smoking in their establishment if it's one where it has been traditionally popular, and fear/have endured losses of business as a result. Some people still smoke and tobacco taxes are about as regressive a tax as there is, and that's a larger constituency than people raising childen or even the Hispanic vote.Therefore one should expect some of them to be more partial to proposals to stymie the tobacco control movement, and tobacco companies to be partial to those sorts of candidates and movements. However its just one small part of a far larger picture.

There is a synergistic effect with the pissed off people and the groups wanting them pissed off and helping them show how pissed off they are, but that's true of basically every national grassroots movement in politics these days. What has to exist though are real conditions that anger those people, and the 2009 situation was destined to produce a reaction from that group of people, no force on earth could stop it, and no tobacco company produce it by itself, and no group control it completely, including the GOP establishment as you may have noticed.

Ever tried to herd a pack of hyenas? :p
 
Last edited:
... the SEIU is an organization of members, workers, just as the teacher's union is. That's not equivalent to a corporation where stockholders are the members.
Maybe on paper a union looks like a corporation, and maybe the extreme right wing opinion on the SCOTUS thinks they are the same, but to most of us: unions are people, corporations are not.
Corporations are legal persons (i.e., they can own property, sue and be sued). Unions are 501(c)-5 corporations.
So? That does not make a corporation the equivalent of an organization formed by a group of people for some specific interest of those people like a labor union.
"So?" So unions are corporations, and it's not just the opinion of "the extreme right of the SCOTUS" that "thinks they are". As to "the same": to the extent there's a difference between a corporation owned by contributors of financial assets (stock holders) and a corporation owned by contributors of labor assets (unions), please explain how the difference makes a difference, from the average citizen's POV. Unions sometimes perform a useful function. They operate like a combination of talent agency and law firm on retainer. That is, they negotiate contracts and impose costs on employers who violate contracts. That's useful. They can make life easier for employers by saving on negotiating costs (a standard employment contract).

So also are investors who pool resources to make a profit satisfying consumer wants "useful". Why exalt one over the other?

Sometimes unions, like other organizations, get captured by insiders who bend the organization to their interests.
 
Meanwhile Climategate told us that British scientists whose work is used in scaring people and governments into enacting global warming alarmist policies, were trying to keep facts which harmed their agenda away from the media at a time when they were courting large financial grants from corporations like Siemens. Siemens is one global energy company who hopes to capitalize in a carbon futures market.
On the same issue, NASA scientist James Hansen has allegedly accepted some $1.2 million from private environmental organizations to use his gov't position to advance these groups' agenda on global warming.
Al Gore has made a lot of money on climate change, some say as much as $100 million.

Let's not pretend the right has a lock on special interests quietly forwarding agendas. And last time I checked tobacco was not against the law. As for moral posturing, will we hold McDonald's responsible when morbidly obese leftist Michael Moore keels over from a heart attack?

This is all just partisanship. People will see through this thinly veiled attempt to discredit the opposition and in the end may have the result of driving people to join the Tea Party just to spite you.

Let their record on the issues and their actions speak for themselves.

Some credit is due for not using Media Matters as a legitimate reference, you see that a lot.
 
Meanwhile Climategate told us that British scientists whose work is used in scaring people and governments into enacting global warming alarmist policies, were trying to keep facts which harmed their agenda away from the media at a time when they were courting large financial grants from corporations like Siemens. Siemens is one global energy company who hopes to capitalize in a carbon futures market.
On the same issue, NASA scientist James Hansen has allegedly accepted some $1.2 million from private environmental organizations to use his gov't position to advance these groups' agenda on global warming.
Al Gore has made a lot of money on climate change, some say as much as $100 million.

So your response to this paper is a giant tu quoque, including things that one scientist has "allegedly" done (based on a lawsuit filed by this not exactly unbiased group)?

This is all just partisanship. People will see through this thinly veiled attempt to discredit the opposition and in the end may have the result of driving people to join the Tea Party just to spite you.

So write your own paper about the puppetmasters behind the pro-AGW movement, with full citations, and submit it to the journal of your choice.
 
You nearly had a credible reply, but didn't have the sense to omit this bit of silliness:

(based on a lawsuit filed by this not exactly unbiased group)?

If you're a Democrat or in any significant way opposed to Tea Party agenda, you and your thread here should be roundly dismissed for the same reason.

Or are we, not surprising, only dismissing bias when the other side is engaged in it?

Reading through this thread I see little evidence this isn't merely an attempt to discredit a political group you oppose with guilt by tenuous association with an easily identifiable evil- an evil which really has little to do with their agenda, which is in many ways right as rain.

If it wasn't smear tactics like this wouldn't be necessary, would they?
 
If you're a Democrat or in any significant way opposed to Tea Party agenda, you and your thread here should be roundly dismissed for the same reason.

Or are we, not surprising, only dismissing bias when the other side is engaged in it?

So you actually consider allegations made in lawsuits filed by the "American Tradition Institute" to be equivalent evidence to a paper written by academics whose research was funded by a National Cancer Institute grant and published in a peer-reviewed BMJ journal? And that both are equally "biased"?
 
Slightly OT but I found this quite interesting from George Monbiot:

Billionaires are hiding behind a network of “independent” groups, who manipulate politics on their behalf.


By George Monbiot, published in the Guardian 19th February 2013.

Conspiracies against the public don’t get much uglier than this. As the Guardian revealed last week, two secretive organisations working for US billionaires have spent $118m to ensure that no action is taken to prevent manmade climate change(1). While inflicting untold suffering on the world’s people, their funders have used these opaque structures to ensure that their identities are never exposed.

One name in particular jumped out at me: American Friends of the IEA. The Institute of Economic Affairs is a British group which, like all the others, calls itself a free market thinktank. Scarcely a day goes by on which its staff are not interviewed in the broadcast media, promoting the dreary old billionaires’ agenda: less tax for the rich, less help for the poor, less spending by the state, less regulation for business. In the first 13 days of February, its people were on the BBC ten times(8).

Never have I heard its claim to be an independent thinktank challenged by the BBC. When, in 2007, I called the institute a business lobby group, its then director-general responded, in a letter to the Guardian, that “we are independent of all business interests”(9). Oh yes?

The database, published by the Canadian site desmogblog.com, shows that American Friends of the IEA has received (up to 2010) $215,000 from the two secretive funds(10). When I spoke to the IEA’s fundraising manager, she confirmed that the sole purpose of American Friends is to raise money for the organisation in London(11). She agreed that the IEA has never disclosed the Donors’ Trust money it has received. She denied that the institute is a sockpuppet organisation: purporting to be independent while working for some very powerful US interests.
 
Two worthwhile news pieces from today:

Donors Trust: Little-Known Group Helps Wealthy Backers Fund Right-Wing Agenda in Secret
Since 1999, the nonprofit charity Donors Trust has handed out nearly $400 million in private donations to more than 1,000 right-wing and libertarian groups. The fact it has been able to quietly do so appears to explain why it exists: Wealthy donors can back the right-wing causes they want without attracting public scrutiny. The most detailed accounting to date shows Donors Trust funds a wish list of right-wing causes, prompting Mother Jones magazine to label it "the dark-money ATM of the right." We’re joined by John Dunbar, politics editor at the Center for Public Integrity and co-author of the group’s months-long investigation into Donors Trust. "They’re essentially a pass through," Dunbar says of Donors Trust. "They act as a kind of a middleman between what are very large, well-known private foundations created mostly by corporate executives, like the Kochs, for example, and they direct the money of those contributions to a very large network of right-leaning, free-market think tanks across the country."

The ATM for Climate Denial: Secretive Donors Trust Funds Vast Network of Global Warming Skeptics
While the secretive Donors Trust has given millions to a variety of right-wing causes, denying climate change appears to be its top priority. An analysis by the environmentalist group Greenpeace reveals Donors Trust has funneled more than one-third of its donations — at least $146 million — to more than 100 climate change denial groups over the past decade. In 2010, 12 of these groups received between 30 to 70 percent of their funding from Donors Trust. We’re joined by Suzanne Goldenberg, U.S. environment correspondent for The Guardian, who has written a series of articles detailing the ties between Donors Trust and opponents of climate change science. "The goal here is to create this illusion, this idea that there is a really strong movement against the science of climate change and against action on climate change," Goldenberg says. "In fact, that’s actually, to an extent, become a reality now: You see that opposition to action on climate change is central to Republican thinking."

You can watch the segments and/or read the transcripts at the links.
 
Skeptic Ginger:
In fact, DONORS has long funded thinktanks side-by-side with tobacco companies. I think the first detailed analysis of DONORS was my report a year ago, but the updated version from October can be found by Googling: Fakery 2 desmogblog
See Appendix I for DONORS (TRUST and CAPITAL FUNDs), including the interesting history of Whitney Ball's father (disallowed from law practice). Part of Appendix H covers Barre Seid's use of DONORS to launder money to Heartland. PBS/Frontline's "Climate of Doubt" had an early copy of "Fakery 2" to use. The spreadsheet attached there shows all grants from DONORS, 2002-2010, sorted by descending totals. Unless you have 2 side-by-side screens, HIDE the middle columns.

You may also want to read Appendices A.5 and A.6, which note tobacco and Koch roles in funding George Mason University, of which Nancy Mitchell Pfotenhauer is Vice-Rector. Get the August 20 report: Google desmogblog see no evil blame
You may also learn more about David Schnare (of ATI), an adjunct professor at GMU who teaches his tactics to law students. Finally, at the LTDL, try searching for "George Mason University" ... it gets 5000+ hits.
 
Hi new blood John.
:welcome4

I like your blog title: desmogblog. Hopefully the mods won't object to a link to it, it does seem thread related and not spamming.

I'll take a look at it.
 
What's it pay to be a shill nowadays? I'd like to get my mitts on some of that beautiful money -- from either side, I'm not particular.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom