Peer-reviewed paper shows Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies

ANTPogo- You've done an outstanding job of laying out the case and pointing to the foundation of evidence.

It's threads like this that continue my disillusionment with this forum. People dig in their heals and refuse to budge, regardless of the evidence.

It's become a real life, only not intentionally funny, version of the Python Argument Clinic.
 
I don't see why you can't use a review of historical documents to prove a relationship.

But a claim substantially beyond the existence of a relationship has been made. In fact the claim has been made that it's not a grassroots movement. (And the claim in this thread title is that the Tea Party movement was created by the tobacco companies.)

If the only thing the paper did was to look for evidence of a relationship, it cannot possibly be sufficient to conclude that the Tea Party is not a grassroots movement.
 
Started by people with incomes in the 70-120,000 dollar range in one or two places, spread from a central area outward more-or less in lines of travel radiating outward at a slow rate (social and mainstream media may speed it a little, but....), basic members identifiable and trackable,most show up almost entirely in their own areas, not at distant events, do not get free bus trips from "anonymous" providers...............

And the paper cited in the OP did not consider any such things.

It examined certain documents for evidence of connections between certain companies and the Tea Party movement. Not surprisingly, it found connections.

So if the same methodology as used in the paper cited in the OP were used to look for connections between other grassroots organizations and existing corporations, would it follow that those organizations were created by the existing corporations and that they are, therefore, not grassroots movements?

Or does this methodology only work on the Tea Party?
 
If the group making those statements is saying they're more credible for coming from a grassroots organization of political independents instead of from "the Republican establishment", when in reality the group making those statements is and always has been organized and funded by that very same establishment, then yes.
I'm not sure you realize what you've just said yes to. You're now saying that credibility is based on a group's claims about its own credibility.


So write in to the journal's editors.
They're not making the claim you've made.

Remember, I'm an opponent of the Tea Party. I think it espouses an awful (and logically inconsistent) ideology that has been around our country nearly from the beginning.

I think the widespread popularity of the movement is genuine. The people who support it really believe what they say they do and they're not paid shills of tobacco companies. (Indeed someone I know personally who held positions very much like those of the Tea Party long before the Tea Party existed who has a Tea Party supporter is also morally opposed to tobacco use.)

But this paper is not science and it doesn't prove what you say it proves.
 
I also stand by my first post in this thread: this really belongs in the CT section because we're not discussing any political topic.
 
I hane not read the paper. As I wrote earlier (we agreed), "naturally" an industry threatened by regulation would find common cause with people philosophically predisposedd to limiting regulation. I don't see that as either surprising or scandalous. I would, but that's not my point. I see this article as an attempt by government-funded actors to undermine the argument for limited government. If tobacco funding undermines the Tea Party thesis, so also does government funding of social science research undermine all government-funded justifiations for expansive government.
Unless you have more specific evidence that UCSF, the NIH and the NCI have a history of being government shills, then your conspiracy theory position just goes too far over the line to be taken seriously.

There is evidence, OTOH, and it's been posted in this thread, that the tobacco companies had an active arm organizing astroturf and other front groups to influence beliefs that were not evidence based but rather self serving only.
 
Last edited:
But a claim substantially beyond the existence of a relationship has been made. In fact the claim has been made that it's not a grassroots movement. (And the claim in this thread title is that the Tea Party movement was created by the tobacco companies.)

If the only thing the paper did was to look for evidence of a relationship, it cannot possibly be sufficient to conclude that the Tea Party is not a grassroots movement.
This post doesn't present an argument that makes sense.

What do you think a relationship is?
 
I also stand by my first post in this thread: this really belongs in the CT section because we're not discussing any political topic.
Did you ever answer my question about your own confirmation bias? I don't believe you did.

SG said:
JoeTheJuggler said:
But again, the paper cited in the OP is not science.
How do you dismiss a university study funded by the NIH and the National Cancer Institute, published in a respected peer reviewed medical journal, using the also published peer reviewed Tobacco documents research methodology as "not science"?

That is pure confirmation bias, Joe, yours.
 
Unless you have more specific evidence that UCSF, the NIH and the NCI have a history of being government shills, then your conspiracy theory position just goes too far over the line to be taken seriously.

There is evidence, OTOH, and it's been posted in this thread, that the tobacco companies had an active arm organizing astroturf and other front groups to influence beliefs that were not evidence based but rather self serving only.
The evidence is the same in both cases: funding.
 
I'm not sure you realize what you've just said yes to. You're now saying that credibility is based on a group's claims about its own credibility.

No, I'm saying that if some important aspect of the group is something that they are not being truthful about, that naturally has a detrimental effect their credibility. It's not based on a group's claims about its own credibility, but its truthfulness about those claims.

Because if you're lying about something that's a purported core aspect of yourself (saying "you can trust me, because I'm an X", when you're not an X at all), you're probably not credible.

They're not making the claim you've made.

"Rather than being a purely grassroots movement that spontaneously developed in 2009, the Tea Party has developed over time, in part through decades of work by the tobacco industry and other corporate interests."

That's the claim they made in the abstract to their paper, which I reproduced in the OP (and would have put in the thread title, except it was far too long).

So if the same methodology as used in the paper cited in the OP were used to look for connections between other grassroots organizations and existing corporations, would it follow that those organizations were created by the existing corporations and that they are, therefore, not grassroots movements?

Or does this methodology only work on the Tea Party?

So do it.

I mean it. All but one of the resources the paper's authors used, especially the voluminous Legacy Tobacco Documents Library, are completely free and open to anyone. I gave you a link to an also-free paper describing the search methodology they used.

Pick a movement, and find the same kind of evidence that the paper's authors found (there are 184 citations in the paper itself, and 166 additional citations in the supplemental file to the paper).

The evidence is the same in both cases: funding.

No, it's not, because the issue is who is doing the funding and openness about that funding.
 
Last edited:
This post doesn't present an argument that makes sense.
Read it again? I think maybe you're skimming posts.

What do you think a relationship is?
:confused:

A relationship between a movement and selected companies is not the equivalent to one thing creating the other, nor is it evidence that the movement is not a grass roots movement.

For example, a government contractor is a company that has a relationship with the government. This relationship does not imply that the company was created by the government. Nor does it tell us what type of company that contractor is or is not.

My point is that looking for only evidence of connections between the Tea Party and certain corporations and finding that evidence is not evidence that the Tea Party was created by tobacco companies or that the Tea Party is not a grass roots movement.

Nothing in the paper addresses what evidence would be needed to determine whether a movement is a grassroots movement.

If you applied the same methodology to most "movements" I think you could find connections between those movements and selected corporations. It wouldn't mean that those movements were created by those corporations or that those movements are not grassroots movements.

Again, do you see the difference between this discussion and discussion of a political topic? This really belongs in the CT section.
 
Bizarro CT it is then.
Just as much as to assert that some funding from tobacco companies discredits the Tea Party agenda.
Taxes fund the police department, they could be in on it to.
Police departments have a direct financial interest in their funding, not in one side or another of the tobacco issue. No more or less than any other organization, they consist of self-interested individuals who respond to the schedule of incentives that the insitutional environment presents.
And what the heck does the National Cancer Institute have to do with this government conspiracy theory of yours?
a) It's Ant's conspiracy theory, not mine, that fundng buys assent to a policy. However true that may be, it's ad hominem argument and therefore it makes more sense to discuss the real issue (e.g., the contribution that regulation may make to health, the role of government in the education industry).
b) You'll have to ask Ant. I only implicated tax-funded universities.
 
Apply the skepticism that is supposed to be the hallmark of this forum and you will quickly see:

1. The evidence presented amounts to post hoc. The tobacco companies talked about doing X and X happened (much later). Therefore, the tobacco companies did it.

2. A fair amount of the evidence presented in support of the paper amounts to Argument by Authority. The paper was peer-reviewed (as we are told in the thread title). But who peer-reviews papers in Tobacco Control? Pretty obviously folks who hate tobacco, just as papers in the Journal of 9-11 Studies are reviewed by 9-11 Truthers. I'm not saying we should discount entirely anything published in either Journal, just that the words "peer-reviewed" are not tantamount to "amen".

3. The fact that others have used the words "Tea Party" ignores the historical (1773) meaning of those words. The 9-11 Truthers had their own Tea Party around 2007, and then tried to claim that they were the original Tea Party. There was a "tea-bag revolt" back in 1988 when Congress voted itself a 50% pay increase. I would be willing to wager that there has been some group claiming some version of "Tea Party" status every 20 years or so.

4. The "grassroots" argument is silly. Remember, Occupy Wall Street was not a grassroots movement; it was kicked off by an article in Adbusters magazine. Who cares? Both Occupy and the Tea Party (neither of which I found particularly compelling or sensible) found popular support, and that matters a heck of a lot more than whether they were "grassroots" or not.
 
Last edited:
Just as much as to assert that some funding from tobacco companies discredits the Tea Party agenda.
You missed a whole lot of how one gets from A to Z with this straw version.


Police departments have a direct financial interest in their funding, not in one side or another of the tobacco issue. No more or less than any other organization, they consist of self-interested individuals who respond to the schedule of incentives that the insitutional environment presents.a) It's Ant's conspiracy theory, not mine, that fundng buys assent to a policy. However true that may be, it's ad hominem argument and therefore it makes more sense to discuss the real issue (e.g., the contribution that regulation may make to health, the role of government in the education industry).
b) You'll have to ask Ant. I only implicated tax-funded universities.
So governments and universities, the NIH, and the NCI are all in on the conspiracy because of their funding sources but the police with the same public funding is not. Bizarre CT, check.

And no, I'm not referring to the OP or ANTPogo, I'm strictly referring to your claims in the post I replied to.
 
You missed a whole lot of how one gets from A to Z with this straw version.


So governments and universities, the NIH, and the NCI are all in on the conspiracy1 because of their funding sources but the police with the same public funding is not.2 Bizarre CT, check.

And no, I'm not referring to the OP or ANTPogo, I'm strictly referring to your claims in the post I replied to.
1. You're the one calling "conspiracy". This is indirect ad hominem, right? It amounts to "you're delusional". I have not done this to you. Please try to keep it civil,
2. I thought my point was obvious. Some demonstration of a financial interest in the outcome of an argument does not make the argument false (or true). The abstract "__A__ (person or party) got money from __B__ (source), therefore A's case for agenda __X__ is bought" works just as well for government funding as for tobacco industry funding. University professors are in no position to throw this stone.

Also, the article "the" doesn't work here: anti-tobacco warriors have a stake in public concern over tobacco, anti-poaching warriors have a stake in public concern for endangered species (Save the Desert Pupfish!), anti-crime warriors (aka "police") have a stake in public concern over crime, etc.
 
1. You're the one calling "conspiracy". This is indirect ad hominem, right? It amounts to "you're delusional". I have not done this to you. Please try to keep it civil,

So report it, if you think you're being attacked or insulted.

The abstract "__A__ (person or party) got money from __B__ (source), therefore A's case for agenda __X__ is bought" works just as well for government funding as for tobacco industry funding. University professors are in no position to throw this stone.

No, it doesn't, because of the vast differences in the origins, nature, usage, and openness of the funding. It's why there is no equivalent to the Legacy Tobacco Documents Library for "university professors", and why there will never be an equivalent.
 
So report it, if you think you're being attacked or insulted.
With these moderators? Useless.
No, it doesn't, because of the vast differences in the origins, nature, usage, and openness of the funding. It's why there is no equivalent to the Legacy Tobacco Documents Library for "university professors", and why there will never be an equivalent.
You mean, if the organization that provides the money extracts that money at gunpoint (taxation), with the threat of forcibile innoculation with HIV (prison), the advocacy it purchases is somehow more credible than if the organization derives its income from mutually agreed-upon transactions (sales of goods and services)? Please explain how the difference in sources of funding alters the implication that people may discount the funded advocacy.
 
Last edited:
With these moderators? Useless.

Uh huh.

You mean, if the organization that provides the money extracts that money at gunpoint (taxation), with the threat of forcibile innoculation with HIV (prison), the advocacy it purchases is somehow more credible than if the organization derives its income from mutually agreed-upon transactions (sales of goods and services)? Please explain how the difference in sources of funding alters the implication that people may discount the funded advocacy.

Your bizarre views of how government works and why you think secret tobacco industry funding to lie about and distort science about tobacco is somehow directly comparable to the system of research grants awarded to academic institutions are entirely your own responsibility, not mine.
 
Last edited:
1) In 1953, John Hill of Hill & Knowlton created a strategy for the tobacco companies to a void going out of business as the science (i.e., animal studies and human epidemiology) was clearly going against them. A few years earlier, Hill had quit smoking for health reasons.

2) In 1964, a task force (on whose members the tobacco industry had vetoes), determined that the scientific evidence was clear that smoking was bad for you. Nearly 50 years later, ~20% of adult Americans still smoke. Since most long-term smokers started before 20, almost anyone born after (1964-20) = 1944 started as a teenager AFTER the Surgeon Report.

3) Historians have long studied the tactics that enabled the tobacco companies to stay in business, an oddity given that their product, used as directed, requires addicting children to something that will kill half of them.

4) The tobacco settlements of the late 1990s require tobacco companies to provide masses of documentation. They crated websites that just happened to be really miserable to use. UCSF created the LTDL to do better. Unfortunately, although more documents do come, most of their collection stops around 2002 ... so that AFP and FW generally aren't well-covered, although their predecessor CSE is.

5) If one reads the tobacco histories (Brandt and Proctor) and spends hundreds of hours searching the LTDL, one can find all sorts of things. Here's a summary of the history:
a) At first, the tobacco companies got together to form industry associations like Council for Tobacco Research (CTR), later Tobacco Industry Council (TIRC). But these proved to be obvious.
b) Then, among other things, they recruited "independent thinktanks" (with a strong correlation with those funded by Kochs, Scaife, L&H Bradley, etc. It is especially lucky that PM's Roy Marden wrote a memo every year from 1991-2001 listing who got how much money. Likewise, the LTDL has lots of "begging letters" from thinktanks to tobacco companies explaining the good work they've done and asking for more money. Likewise, there are great memoes saying what thinktanks will do; I especially like "access to GW Bush."
Here, they had people who absolutely knew who they were working for, but could seem to be "independent."
c) But they far more strongly preferred to have a large movement of people who had no idea. It would be impossible to keep that secret.

6) This paper grew out of a well-established historical research flow trying to figure out the tobacco industry. Finding the Tea Party was an emergent result. I applaud their work, because some of the other folks (*like me) who've looked very hard at this for years didn't uite dig hard enough to find the details of the connection.
See "Fakery 2: More Funny Finances, Free Of Tax" @ DeSMogBLog and read the tobacco and funding sections, including the Heartland begging letter.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom