I'm not sure you realize what you've just said yes to. You're now saying that credibility is based on a group's claims about its own credibility.
No, I'm saying that if some important aspect of the group is something that they are not being truthful about, that naturally has a detrimental effect their credibility. It's not based on a group's claims about its own credibility, but its
truthfulness about those claims.
Because if you're lying about something that's a purported core aspect of yourself (saying "you can trust me, because I'm an X", when you're not an X at all), you're probably not credible.
They're not making the claim you've made.
"Rather than being a purely grassroots movement that spontaneously developed in 2009, the Tea Party has developed over time, in part through decades of work by the tobacco industry and other corporate interests."
That's the claim they made in the abstract to their paper, which I reproduced in the OP (and would have put in the thread title, except it was far too long).
So if the same methodology as used in the paper cited in the OP were used to look for connections between other grassroots organizations and existing corporations, would it follow that those organizations were created by the existing corporations and that they are, therefore, not grassroots movements?
Or does this methodology only work on the Tea Party?
So do it.
I mean it. All but one of the resources the paper's authors used, especially the voluminous Legacy Tobacco Documents Library, are completely free and open to anyone. I gave you a link to an also-free paper describing the search methodology they used.
Pick a movement, and find the same kind of evidence that the paper's authors found (there are 184 citations in the paper itself, and 166 additional citations in the supplemental file to the paper).
The evidence is the same in both cases: funding.
No, it's not, because the issue is
who is doing the funding and openness
about that funding.