Peer-reviewed paper shows Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies You start the discussion with the words "Peer-reviewed". This paper relates social history in a medical journal. Kinda undermines the "peer-reviewed" credential, doncha think? I mean, did the reviewers have degrees in the History of Lung Transplant Surgery or something? Now, they are entitled to their opinion, and they may be correct that tobacco companies supported anti-regulation activists. MDs, as a class, and college professors, as a class, are brighter than the average bear (see Murray, Losing Ground), so peer-reviewed or not, the assessment of a scholar or MD on a topic outside his/her area of expertise (say, fluid dynamics) carries more weight than would the opinion of, say, the average brick-layer, but the "peer-reviewed" qualification is beside the point. Would the fact that a journal of, say, gender studies, is peer reviewed validate a paper published in that journal on bacterial taxonomy?
And let's consider the argument: Advocates for constitutionally-limited government get money from tobacco companies, and tobacco kills people, therefore...
The authors get their income from the government, and the government kills people, therefore...