Peer-reviewed paper shows Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies

So you take heavy reliance on social media as evidence that it's not a grassroots movement?
That's not what she said and twisting her comments doesn't help your case.

Again, what would you consider to be evidence that the Tea Party is a grassroots movement?
It can't be grass roots because it's origin was not. OTOH, I don't think the OP study says there are no people in the TEA Party who are sincere.

The problem with confirmation bias is in not looking for evidence that would go against your hypothesis. That is, it's not enough only to consider evidence that confirms your hypothesis.
Until you recognize you've dismissed legitimate peer reviewed science as 'not science' you really have no room to accuse anyone of confirmation bias.
 
It can't be grass roots because it's origin was not. OTOH, I don't think the OP study says there are no people in the TEA Party who are sincere.

The paper specifically notes that the deliberately murky nature of the funding behind third-party advocacy groups like the ones that organized and funded the tea party movement, the people involved in the tea party may not even be aware of who's been helping them out and why (it's right before the paper talks about how most self-identified tea partiers actually support the smoke-free laws that their tea party organizations oppose).

Until you recognize you've dismissed legitimate peer reviewed science as 'not science' you really have no room to accuse anyone of confirmation bias.

They haven't even read the paper!
 
Last edited:
This paper is fine historical scholarship about anti-science, but is not itself science, that's a strawman argument. Not all {peer-reviewed, meticulously-documented} research publications need to be called science to be considered as strong evidence. Neither Brandt's nor Proctor's books are science, nor was Bernstein&Woodward's investigations.

Digging out, for example, the Burson-Marsteller proposal from 1992 (where Tea Party idea was already in play), is historical research, non-trivial to find.
 
The Justice League is sitting in their orbiting satellite.

Superman: I'm telling you guys, Luthor is obviously behind this Tea Party Movement.

Batman: You've got it all wrong; it's obviously the Joker.

Green Lantern: I can see Sinestro's fingerprints all over this movement.

Atom: You're all wrong; it's clearly Chronos.

Flash: Connect the dots! Captain Cold is to blame!
 
Peer-reviewed paper shows Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies
You start the discussion with the words "Peer-reviewed". This paper relates social history in a medical journal. Kinda undermines the "peer-reviewed" credential, doncha think? I mean, did the reviewers have degrees in the History of Lung Transplant Surgery or something? Now, they are entitled to their opinion, and they may be correct that tobacco companies supported anti-regulation activists. MDs, as a class, and college professors, as a class, are brighter than the average bear (see Murray, Losing Ground), so peer-reviewed or not, the assessment of a scholar or MD on a topic outside his/her area of expertise (say, fluid dynamics) carries more weight than would the opinion of, say, the average brick-layer, but the "peer-reviewed" qualification is beside the point. Would the fact that a journal of, say, gender studies, is peer reviewed validate a paper published in that journal on bacterial taxonomy?

And let's consider the argument: Advocates for constitutionally-limited government get money from tobacco companies, and tobacco kills people, therefore...

The authors get their income from the government, and the government kills people, therefore...
 
Last edited:
This paper is fine historical scholarship about anti-science, but is not itself science, that's a strawman argument. Not all {peer-reviewed, meticulously-documented} research publications need to be called science to be considered as strong evidence. Neither Brandt's nor Proctor's books are science, nor was Bernstein&Woodward's investigations.

Digging out, for example, the Burson-Marsteller proposal from 1992 (where Tea Party idea was already in play), is historical research, non-trivial to find.
You express a tunnel vision view of what science is or is not, typical of people who don't understand much about any science outside of what they are familiar with.

So you agree it's research, and the conclusions appear to be supported, and peers have reviewed the work, but somehow it's not science, why?
 
Peer-reviewed paper shows Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies You start the discussion with the words "Peer-reviewed". This paper relates social history in a medical journal. Kinda undermines the "peer-reviewed" credential, doncha think? I mean, did the reviewers have degrees in the History of Lung Transplant Surgery or something? Now, they are entitled to their opinion, and they may be correct that tobacco companies supported anti-regulation activists. MDs, as a class, and college professors, as a class, are brighter than the average bear (see Murray, Losing Ground), so peer-reviewed or not, the assessment of a scholar or MD on a topic outside his/her area of expertise (say, fluid dynamics) carries more weight than would the opinion of, say, the average brick-layer, but the "peer-reviewed" qualification is beside the point. Would the fact that a journal of, say, gender studies, is peer reviewed validate a paper published in that journal on bacterial taxonomy?

And let's consider the argument: Advocates for constitutionally-limited government get money from tobacco companies, and tobacco kills people, therefore...

The authors get their income from the government, and the government kills people, therefore...
Let's see, if one can dismiss the paper as 'not science' then one can ignore everything else about the conclusions. No confirmation bias there, nope.

...
They haven't even read the paper!
:rolleyes:


Tell me Malcolm, and John and Joe, are you dismissing the findings? Or are you just trying to dismiss the nomenclature that the research was a scientific study?
 
Peer-reviewed paper shows Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies You start the discussion with the words "Peer-reviewed". This paper relates social history in a medical journal. Kinda undermines the "peer-reviewed" credential, doncha think?

Not really, since the journal regularly publishes papers of that kind: "Tobacco Control is an international peer review journal covering the nature and consequences of tobacco use worldwide; tobacco's effects on population health, the economy, the environment, and society; efforts to prevent and control the global tobacco epidemic through population level education and policy changes; the ethical dimensions of tobacco control policies; and the activities of the tobacco industry and its allies."

You express a tunnel vision view of what science is or is not, typical of people who don't understand much about any science outside of what they are familiar with.

So you agree it's research, and the conclusions appear to be supported, and peers have reviewed the work, but somehow it's not science, why?

He's not actually arguing against the paper, just that it's history/investigative journalism, and not science as JoeTheJuggler was describing.
 
...
He's not actually arguing against the paper, just that it's history/investigative journalism, and not science as JoeTheJuggler was describing.
I'm sensitive because I've heard medical research dismissed more than once by people who have no clue how you'd do science that didn't involve test tubes or instruments.

I don't see why you can't use a review of historical documents to prove a relationship. Yes, it is also how one might conduct investigative journalism. I'll look at the methodology link again and think about it.
 
The paper specifically notes that the deliberately murky nature of the funding behind third-party advocacy groups like the ones that organized and funded the tea party movement, the people involved in the tea party may not even be aware of who's been helping them out and why
And yet, somehow, the advocacy groups are implanting the opinions which the Tea Partiers will parrot, rather than raising the platform from which the Tea Partiers can express the opinions they've expressed privately for years.
 
Tell me Malcolm, and John and Joe, are you dismissing the findings?
I hane not read the paper. As I wrote earlier (we agreed), "naturally" an industry threatened by regulation would find common cause with people philosophically predisposedd to limiting regulation. I don't see that as either surprising or scandalous.
Or are you just trying to dismiss the nomenclature that the research was a scientific study?
I would, but that's not my point. I see this article as an attempt by government-funded actors to undermine the argument for limited government. If tobacco funding undermines the Tea Party thesis, so also does government funding of social science research undermine all government-funded justifiations for expansive government.
 
And yet, somehow, the advocacy groups are implanting the opinions which the Tea Partiers will parrot, rather than raising the platform from which the Tea Partiers can express the opinions they've expressed privately for years.

Sure, if by "somehow" you mean "providing organization, guidance, networking, training, funding, and all the setup and work for national rallies for the tea partiers".
 
He's not actually arguing against the paper, just that it's history/investigative journalism, and not science as JoeTheJuggler was describing.

If you look at the Friday video I mentioned in the DeSmogBlog post, in Q&A (starting around 01:32) you will see Stan call on me and I comment on the paper, using terms like "terrific" and "wonderful", which it was, but unlike 3 of the other papers in the Billion Lives symposium, it wasn't science, but historical investigation of anti-science tactics in a specific case.
 
Sure, if by "somehow" you mean "providing organization, guidance, networking, training, funding, and all the setup and work for national rallies for the tea partiers".
So financial and logistical support changes minds in your world. I'm surprised you haven't joined the Tea Party yourself, with all that money being spent.
 
That's not how things like this work.

Are excruciatingly stupid strawmen all you and Brainster have now?
No, I'm done.

It's obvious to me that the strongest case you can make is that non-tobacco-company organizations which have several positions on several issues have chosen to support people who share some of those positions on some of those issues. You haven't linked "tobacco" to anything, or demonstrated that the people who attend tea party events aren't sincere proponents of the ideas the espouse, ideas which almost never include smoker's rights. I gave you every opportunity, you failed and flailed. Enough time wasted.
 
So you take heavy reliance on social media as evidence that it's not a grassroots movement?

Again, what would you consider to be evidence that the Tea Party is a grassroots movement?

The problem with confirmation bias is in not looking for evidence that would go against your hypothesis. That is, it's not enough only to consider evidence that confirms your hypothesis.

Started by people with incomes in the 70-120,000 dollar range in one or two places, spread from a central area outward more-or less in lines of travel radiating outward at a slow rate (social and mainstream media may speed it a little, but....), basic members identifiable and trackable,most show up almost entirely in their own areas, not at distant events, do not get free bus trips from "anonymous" providers...............
 
It's obvious to me that the strongest case you can make is that non-tobacco-company organizations which have several positions on several issues have chosen to support people who share some of those positions on some of those issues.

Since you have no idea what that case actually is or what the evidence for it is, what's "obvious" to you is pretty irrelevant.

or demonstrated that the people who attend tea party events aren't sincere proponents of the ideas the espouse,

I'm sure they are. They, however, aren't the ones in control of the tea party movement. AFP and especially FreedomWorks are in the driver's seat, and they always have been.

ideas which almost never include smoker's rights.

Did you not see all those links I provided about what a number of disparate tea party groups are actually saying about smoke-free laws?

I gave you every opportunity, you failed and flailed. Enough time wasted.

I told you exactly where to find what you were asking for. Don't blame me because you never bothered to read it for yourself.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom