Peer-reviewed paper shows Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies

The Tea Party, a loosely organised network of grassroots coalitions at local and state levels, is a complex social and political movement to the right of the traditional Republican Party that promotes less government regulation and lower taxes.1–4 It is often characterised as a grassroots movement that spontaneously arose in 2009.4–5 However, it has also been cited as an example of corporate ‘astroturfing,’ 5 defined as a movement that ‘appears to be grassroots, but is either funded, created or conceived by a corporation or industry trade association, political interest group or public relations firm.’6–8 National organisations funded by corporations, particularly Americans for Prosperity (AFP) and FreedomWorks, played an important role in structuring and supporting the Tea Party in the initial stages.5 They provided training, communication and materials for the earliest Tea Party activities, including the first ‘Tea Party’ on 27 February 2009.1 9 FreedomWorks organised the nationwide Tea Party tax protests in April 2009,10 the town hall protests about the proposed healthcare reform in August 20091 and the Taxpayers’ March on Washington the following September 2009.11 They continued to facilitate and support many of the local chapters and leaders that arose from the early events in 2009.5 AFP and FreedomWorks continued to facilitate local Tea Party activities by co-sponsoring rallies,1 12 13 creating talking points and organisational tips for supporters,14 15 supplying literature for local Tea Party groups16 and providing training sessions.1 3 17 FreedomWorks was a founding partner of the 2010 Contract from
America (recalling the Republican Party’s 1994 Contract with America).18

As of 2012, AFP and FreedomWorks were supporting the tobacco companies’ political agenda by mobilising local Tea Party opposition to tobacco taxes and smoke-free laws.19 20 This support for the tobacco companies’ agenda continues the tobacco industry use of AFP and FreedomWorks’ predecessor organisation, Citizens for a Sound Economy (CSE), as a third-party ally since at least 1991 (figure 1). Moreover, starting in the 1980s, major US tobacco companies attempted to manufacture an astroturf citizen ‘smokers’ rights movement’ to oppose local tobacco control policies. These smokers rights’ groups had grassroots membership in several localities, but were created, coordinated and funded by the cigarette companies.21

Although the Tea Party is widely considered to have started in 2009,9 this paper presents a historical study of some of the tobacco companies’ early activities and key players in the evolution of the Tea Party. Many people in the smokers’ rights effort or the tobacco companies went on to Tea Party organisations. Moreover, while the Tea Party started in the USA, it is beginning to spread internationally. 22–26 In 2012 FreedomWorks expanded the movement internationally, training activists in 30 countries, including Israel, Georgia, Japan, Nigeria and Serbia.22 This international expansion makes it likely that Tea Party organisations will be mounting opposition to tobacco control (and other health) policies as they have done in the USA.

[/thread]
 
So you actually consider allegations made in lawsuits filed by the "American Tradition Institute" to be equivalent evidence to a paper written by academics whose research was funded by a National Cancer Institute grant and published in a peer-reviewed BMJ journal? And that both are equally "biased"?

I don't care. Were the allegations true or not?

I didn't think we were discussing the veracity of claims anyway, just whether it showed objectivity to immediately dismiss them because they came from an ideology you oppose. Which is what it seemed you were doing, and really only bolstered my point about partisanship. You didn't care if the allegations were true or not, you didn't even want to know about them because they came from the other side and attacked yours- and thought just waving your hand and scoffing look at the source, that would dismiss the matter.
Conversely people on the left will look at the claims of this thread and readily accept them whether true or not (they probably are to some extent) simply because taking the Tea Party down delights them.

I just wonder, if this group or you have ever taken an even precursory glance at connections between tobacco companies and Democrat politicians or political groups? I bet you'd never look, wouldn't care if you did, and connections probably do exist. But that wouldn't give you an opportunity for political capital, would it?

Not that this is unusual, both sides do all these silly things. It's just the left seems a little more hypocritical when expressing feigned moral outrage about it.
 
I don't care. Were the allegations true or not?

You're the one who brought up the allegations, you provide evidence that they're true.

I didn't think we were discussing the veracity of claims anyway, just whether it showed objectivity to immediately dismiss them because they came from an ideology you oppose.

No, I dismiss them because they come from a blatantly-partisan organization that is deliberately filing fishing-expedition lawsuits as part of their AGW-denialist campaign.

You didn't care if the allegations were true or not, you didn't even want to know about them because they came from the other side and attacked yours- and thought just waving your hand and scoffing look at the source, that would dismiss the matter.

Funny, that seems like a perfect description of the people rejecting the paper in the OP (the second reply to my initial post was someone dismissing it because it was published by a paper run by the British medical society!). Especially without ever having bothered to actually read it.

Conversely people on the left will look at the claims of this thread and readily accept them whether true or not (they probably are to some extent) simply because taking the Tea Party down delights them.

Or maybe because they come from respected academics and are heavily sourced and cited in a peer-reviewed paper, as opposed to being allegations in a lawsuit filed for the purpose of fishing for evidence to prove those allegations.

I just wonder, if this group or you have ever taken an even precursory glance at connections between tobacco companies and Democrat politicians or political groups? I bet you'd never look, wouldn't care if you did, and connections probably do exist. But that wouldn't give you an opportunity for political capital, would it?

I myself cited a source upthread that contained and exposed some of those very connections. But that's also little more than a tu quoque, and a particularly irrelevant one as well, since the tobacco companies either funding or not funding Democratic politicians and groups has no bearing whatsoever on their documented role in the creation and support of the Tea Party as described in this paper.

Not that this is unusual, both sides do all these silly things. It's just the left seems a little more hypocritical when expressing feigned moral outrage about it.

Yes, both sides are bad, so vote Republican. I've heard that refrain many times before, thanks.
 
Last edited:
While not a major research focus, I have occasionally looked at the tobacco vs political party issue and of course have rummaged the LTDL for many hours. The simple summary is that Big Tobacco is totally "non-partisan," having most given up on anti-science in favor of expanding political activities. There is no evidence of caring about someone's politics, only that they espouse policy helpful to them, preferably with as little obvious connection. Their ideal helpers are people who say: "I've never smoked, but freedom..." or "I don't like smoking, but this law is fair and provides revenue for *good things*.>"

On p.38 of Fakery 2 @ DeSMog blog I wrote:
"These are generally conservative / Libertarian think tanks, but political
viewpoint does not guarantee participation. The Hoover Institution is certainly
conservative, but I did not find it much in the tobacco records. It seemed less
involved in climate anti-science. Hoover Fellow George Shultz was active in the
fight against a ballot proposition funded by fossil companies Valero, Tesoro and
Koch Industries. He encourages electric and plug-in-hybrid vehicles and at 90 is
involved in energy efficiency efforts. All this would seem anathema to many of
the think tanks whose names appear here often. Some think tanks seem legitimate
centers of conservative thought, others more like PR agencies/lobbyists.
Of course, tobacco companies still lobby directly. In California, although
legislatures are majority Democratic, most tobacco money is given to Republicans.
(link)."

If you follow the link, and then another link to the report @ American Lung Association of CA you can get to "Campaign Contributions and Lobbying Expenditures of Tobacco Interests in California: January 2011-June 2012" which lists contributions to each State Senator or Representative, either directly from PM USA or Reynolds American, or indirectly through "California Distributors Association PAC", but of course, some of the murkier funding chains are hard to find, so this cannot be complete. It just gives the easiest-to-find tobacco money.

The simplest chart is on p.9, State Senators:
$150,325 Total, 40 State Senators:
25 Dems, 62.5%, of whom 22 took zero known $, and 3 took $28,200, 19% of the money.
15 Reps, 37.5%, of whom 1 took zero $, and 14 took $122,125, 81% of the $.

Of course, this is just a hint, given the complexity of funding chains and it takes a great deal of work to dig this out. CA has the 2nd lowest adult smoking rate, Utah is #1, has a strongly Republican legislature, but I'd guess tobacco contributions are relatively low. I'd speculate that more legislators of both parties in states with strong tobacco industries take tobacco money.

So, I think the tobacco companies are totally non-partisan, will give to anyone who can help, but at least in some times and places, Democrats take less money than the Republicans. I suspect this has changed over time, since after all, the US South used to be Democratic.
 
I myself cited a source upthread that contained and exposed some of those very connections. But that's also little more than a tu quoque, and a particularly irrelevant one as well, since the tobacco companies either funding or not funding Democratic politicians and groups has no bearing whatsoever on their documented role in the creation and support of the Tea Party as described in this paper.

Way to sidestep the point which was that the only reason you or the left would care about the sins of tobacco companies is that you can use it against the right.

Yes, both sides are bad, so vote Republican. I've heard that refrain many times before, thanks.

Don't be silly, only a tool votes on party lines. If you've heard it many times maybe it's true- the hypocrisy of the left is often insultingly patronizing.
 
Way to sidestep the point which was that the only reason you or the left would care about the sins of tobacco companies is that you can use it against the right.

That's your strawman, and has nothing to do with me. Nor does it have anything to do with the paper, since no matter how much money the tobacco companies gave Democrats (and, as John Mashey's numbers show, tobacco companies still give four times as much money to Republicans), it has absolutely zero bearing on what the authors of the paper concluded.

Don't be silly, only a tool votes on party lines. If you've heard it many times maybe it's true- the hypocrisy of the left is often insultingly patronizing.

So do you actually have anything to say about the paper in question, or is your only reason for posting in this thread to try and deflect as much attention as possible from its conclusions by repeatedly banging the tu quoque drum as loudly as you can?

EDIT: Your sig is highly amusing, in light of your posts in this thread.
 
Last edited:
To be more precise, although it may well be true (and would be consistent with other data, such as Heartland advisor lists, and generally, tobacco ties with many conservative thinktanks (with the notable seeming exception of Hoover), I only specified the California numbers. That is a good sample (~10% of US), but CA is not necessarily representative.

In any case, one of the truly amusing things about the wrath raised by all this, including blaming it on Obama, Al Gore, etc, etc ... is that this work was funded by 2 NCI contracts to do exactly this sort of work, i.e., historical analysis to discover tobacco tactics:
one for study of the tobacco documents, which only really started becoming available in last decade, and the other for post-docs to help.

The first started in 2001, and the second in 2006, each renewed yearly, unsurprising, as UCSF is very good at this and the funding is modest (~1% of UCSF's).
PRAISE GEORGE BUSH! :-) He had the foresight to have NCI fund good work, Obama merely continued it. (Actually, I doubt Presidents get anywhere near such budgets.)
 
Just in case people wondered, the last post (PRAISE BUSH) was irony.

Go to the LTDL search engine and put in "GW Bush".
The tobacco guys were happy, especially as they knew him well from TX days.
 
That's your strawman, and has nothing to do with me. Nor does it have anything to do with the paper, since no matter how much money the tobacco companies gave Democrats (and, as John Mashey's numbers show, tobacco companies still give four times as much money to Republicans), it has absolutely zero bearing on what the authors of the paper concluded.

Oh I think it does have everything to do with you since this IS your thread, and you are promoting the paper. Is it because you care about people getting lung cancer? Or is it because you found something that makes the Tea Party look bad?

So do you actually have anything to say about the paper in question, or is your only reason for posting in this thread to try and deflect as much attention as possible from its conclusions by repeatedly banging the tu quoque drum as loudly as you can?

EDIT: Your sig is highly amusing, in light of your posts in this thread.


I don't recall that you ever posted anything but the abstract, if you did then forgive me. Very amusing, you post a link to a pay to read academic report and then expect people would pay to discuss it with you. Scratch amusing, let's try arrogant.

I don't need to read the paper because I never disputed its findings in the least, and only commented on the inherent partisanship of people interested in promoting it, merely to attempt to wholly discredit a political group they disagree with. It's cheap, and speaks of lowbrow tactics in the political arena.

As for your comment about my sig, it does say I invite the opportunity to be proven wrong, not just receive rude replies for pointing out the painfully obvious.
 
Oh I think it does have everything to do with you since this IS your thread, and you are promoting the paper. Is it because you care about people getting lung cancer? Or is it because you found something that makes the Tea Party look bad?

Both, actually.

I don't recall that you ever posted anything but the abstract, if you did then forgive me.

I did so in this thread here and here.

Very amusing, you post a link to a pay to read academic report and then expect people would pay to discuss it with you. Scratch amusing, let's try arrogant.

I paid for the paper so I could talk about it, others can too.

As for your comment about my sig, it does say I invite the opportunity to be proven wrong, not just receive rude replies for pointing out the painfully obvious.

Will the above example of me proving you wrong suffice?
 

Since the "action on climate change" has only been global socialism in disguise that has served to increase the speed of China and India's industrialization at the cost of increasing global greenhouse gas emissions and lowering living standards in previously industrialized nations, you're darned right that is Republican agenda and on that they've got it right.

Look at the facts. Since the inception of Kyoto, total GGE has risen and so has its rate of increase. Kyoto and the UN's climate change committee has been a thinly disguised money grab by corrupt third world politicians and an attempt to force global socialist ideology.

It seems you alarmists won't be happy until the whole planet is one big brown polluted and impoverished wasteland that you can blame the GOP for.
 
Since the "action on climate change" has only been global socialism in disguise that has served to increase the speed of China and India's industrialization at the cost of increasing global greenhouse gas emissions and lowering living standards in previously industrialized nations, you're darned right that is Republican agenda and on that they've got it right.

Look at the facts. Since the inception of Kyoto, total GGE has risen and so has its rate of increase. Kyoto and the UN's climate change committee has been a thinly disguised money grab by corrupt third world politicians and an attempt to force global socialist ideology.

It seems you alarmists won't be happy until the whole planet is one big brown polluted and impoverished wasteland that you can blame the GOP for.

Boy, it sure is a good thing that you're only in this thread to comment on the inherent partisanship of people interested in promoting something, merely to attempt to wholly discredit a political group they disagree with, because it's cheap, and speaks of lowbrow tactics in the political arena.
 
Both, actually.



I did so in this thread here and here.



I paid for the paper so I could talk about it, others can too.

I'm sorry, did one of those links take me to the whole paper you created a thread about, expecting people to debate you on?

Will the above example of me proving you wrong suffice?

If you're here to split hairs about whether you posted MORE than the abstract and not the point that nobody pays for **** like that in internet forums, no I don't need an education on that- especially when I did say "forgive me if you did".

It seems you have missed the very core of political discussion. You're supposed to win over people to your side of the aisle by presenting your position in an appealing way and then you become the majority together.

Patronizing them with piles of BS you hope they fall for is not that. You as good as admit people would have to pay for this paper to discuss it, why pretend you just proved me wrong- especially when I made a point of including a disclaimer when I said that?
 
Boy, it sure is a good thing that you're only in this thread to comment on the inherent partisanship of people interested in promoting something, merely to attempt to wholly discredit a political group they disagree with, because it's cheap, and speaks of lowbrow tactics in the political arena.

It does the mockingbird thingy. What's next, "yo mama" jokes?
 
Since the "action on climate change" has only been global socialism in disguise that has served to increase the speed of China and India's industrialization at the cost of increasing global greenhouse gas emissions and lowering living standards in previously industrialized nations, you're darned right that is Republican agenda and on that they've got it right.

Look at the facts. Since the inception of Kyoto, total GGE has risen and so has its rate of increase. Kyoto and the UN's climate change committee has been a thinly disguised money grab by corrupt third world politicians and an attempt to force global socialist ideology.

It seems you alarmists won't be happy until the whole planet is one big brown polluted and impoverished wasteland that you can blame the GOP for.

Could I interest you in taking this discussion to the Conspiracy Theories sub-fora, where it would be better suited, as it is a bat crap denialist conspiracy theory?

Better yet, pop into the climate change thread in the science sub-fora and get a much needed education in the subject matter. You really should bring up "Climategate" there. It'll be hilarious.
 
Last edited:
I'm sorry, did one of those links take me to the whole paper you created a thread about, expecting people to debate you on?

I told people where to find the paper and where I purchased it from.

Do you expect posters who open threads to discuss books they've read to post the entire contents of the books they want to discuss?

If you're here to split hairs about whether you posted MORE than the abstract and not the point that nobody pays for **** like that in internet forums, no I don't need an education on that-

You said "I don't recall that you ever posted anything but the abstract". I did post more than the abstract, showing that your recollection was incorrect.

Your sig claims that you invite the opportunity to be proven wrong. Your reaction to my doing just that regarding the above would seem to indicate that you are being less than truthful in that sig.

especially when I did say "forgive me if you did".

Why should I forgive you when you're treating me with this kind of hostility for doing something that you yourself claim to invite?

It seems you have missed the very core of political discussion. You're supposed to win over people to your side of the aisle by presenting your position in an appealing way and then you become the majority together.

Maybe if you talked about how "action on climate change" has only been global socialism in disguise and how the UN's climate change committee has been a thinly disguised money grab by corrupt third world politicians and an attempt to force global socialist ideology some more it would help.

You as good as admit people would have to pay for this paper to discuss it,

Which I've done since the beginning.

why pretend you just proved me wrong-

Because you were wrong.
 
Last edited:
Could I interest you in taking this discussion to the Conspiracy Theories sub-fora, where it would be better suited, as it is a bat crap denialist conspiracy theory?

Better yet, pop into the climate change thread in the science sub-fora and get a much needed education in the subject matter. You really should bring up "Climategate" there. It'll be hilarious.

Did you call me a "bat crap denialist"? I think you as good as did.

I guess the ad hominem is the last resort of those with no argument.

Which is you trying to refute the dismal failure of Kyoto. Worldwide greenhouse gas emissions have soared, as has the rate of their increase. You can provide a substantiated rebuttal or just leave.

To clarify my position, the world may well be warming. The role of the sun HAS been actively suppressed, and the policies promoted to "cure" warming have all been thinly disguised attempts at global socialism-whether by intent or accident is not my knowledge. They have only lead to a worsening of the situation.
 
Because you were wrong.


When the point I was here to make was this:

Is it because you care about people getting lung cancer? Or is it because you found something that makes the Tea Party look bad?

Found you replying:
Both, actually.

Oh I don't think so. At all. Because I'm not interested in splitting hairs about paraphrasing or semantics when you know what I meant and I include a disclaimer to establish that was something that wasn't important anyway.

Absolute childish behavior. "forgive me if I am wrong".

"Oh but you are wrong, look, everyone, he's wrong about what he already just said he might be wrong about! I win! I win! I'm the lowest denominator!"
 
Could I interest you in taking this discussion to the Conspiracy Theories sub-fora, where it would be better suited, as it is a bat crap denialist conspiracy theory?

Better yet, pop into the climate change thread in the science sub-fora and get a much needed education in the subject matter. You really should bring up "Climategate" there. It'll be hilarious.

If you'd like some hilarity served to you here's a link to my posts in the most relevant thread:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=9116261#post9116261

Just for you, Peaches.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom