Peer-reviewed paper shows Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies

The reason you can't provide a clear link between "FreedomWorks" and "AFP" (which most of the article discussed) and "The Tea Party" is because the article didn't provide one either.

It did, actually. It even cited the sources.

So the smokers' rights groups advocate smokers' rights, and the Tea Party has its own agenda which mostly involves issues other than smoking. And when they do think about smoking, they think pretty much like the population at large.

We've already discussed in this thread the curious insistence of so many Tea Party groups of protesting anti-smoking laws and tobacco taxes just as the AFP and FW want despite the fact that the membership as a whole does not share those sentiments.
 
Last edited:
It did, actually. It even cited the sources.
I've consulted those sources. They don't support the notion that the Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies either. They say the Tea Party was created in the space of about month by utilizing social media and existing lists of people sympathetic to conservative causes. You know, the conventional wisdom.

If you can make the case that the Tea Party movement was created by the tobacco companies, make it. I've read your paper, and I say it's not in there. The strongest case that paper makes is that some people who belong to smokers' rights groups also have a connection to the Tea Party, which is a very different claim.

We've already discussed in this thread the curious insistence of so many Tea Party groups of protesting anti-smoking laws and tobacco taxes just as the AFP and FW want despite the fact that the membership as a whole does not share those sentiments.
So what that proves is that some people who are in the Tea Party movement also have a pro-smoking agenda. Since they are not authorized to speak for the Tea Party as a whole, and do not have widespread support among Tea Party membership, the amount of influence they exert on Tea Party politics would appear to be negligible.
 
I've consulted those sources. They don't support the notion that the Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies either. They say the Tea Party was created in the space of about month by utilizing social media and existing lists of people sympathetic to conservative causes. You know, the conventional wisdom.

They do. I even quoted several large excerpts from them and related sources about how FW and AFP organized, funded, and directed the agenda of the Tea Party.

So what that proves is that some people who are in the Tea Party movement also have a pro-smoking agenda.

No, what it proves is that Tea Party organizations follow the pro-smoking agenda of FW and AFP, and not the anti-smoking agenda of their membership, showing that the Tea Party is a top-down organization, not a grassroots one.
 
ANTpogo:
I don't think this is framed quite right.
The clear goal of the tobacco guys was to "hide among the crowd" (as they did when they funded TASSC), in this case, they were looking for people who would absolutely oppose cigarette taxes, but the last thing in the world they'd want would be an explicit "we're with tobacco." They'd long used thinktanks, where people understood the game, but it was far more valuable for them to be able to blend into a much larger crowd.
The very "best" astroturf operations are those whose agendas can stay hidden from other people they can attract. Certainly, key leaders knew, but tactically, the fewer people that knew, the better.

But this is easily fixed: TeaPartiers need not change worldviews at all, but the next time someone wants to raise tobacco taxes, ALL they have to do is vote YES, PLEASE ... and over time, the cigarette problem will die off, at the least cost to citizens. Of course, they can say "I don't care how many kids will get addicted,nothing matters but lower taxes, and ideally, cigarette taxes should be zeroed." A respectable action by Tea partiers would be serious soul-searching: is helping tobacco companies a Tea Party value? Then, either say so, or stop helping them, without changing anything else.
 
But this is easily fixed: TeaPartiers need not change worldviews at all, but the next time someone wants to raise tobacco taxes, ALL they have to do is vote YES, PLEASE ... and over time, the cigarette problem will die off, at the least cost to citizens. Of course, they can say "I don't care how many kids will get addicted,nothing matters but lower taxes, and ideally, cigarette taxes should be zeroed." A respectable action by Tea partiers would be serious soul-searching: is helping tobacco companies a Tea Party value? Then, either say so, or stop helping them, without changing anything else.

I' m no TPer, but I don't think special taxes for social engineering, targeting tobacco, alcohol, guns of medical devices are warranted - ever! You're claim that a selective tax on tobacco is not a violation of a TPers position is unevidenced.

Your claim that to oppose a tax on tobacco necessarily means, "I don't care how many kids will get addicted ..." is an amazingly vicious, cynical and silly statement. It's demagogic, it contains an 'if-by-whiskey' fallacy, it contains an implicit strawman fallacy, it includes an 'illicit negative' formal fallacy. Ridiculous at every level. It's just as ridiculous as to claim the the Dems 3.8% Obamacare device tax means that Dems prefer to euthanize the ill.

You argument has no place in a civil discussion, much less a rational debate.

Congratulations on proposing the most absurd and vile argument I've seen this year on this forum, and welcome to my ignore list.
 
Last edited:
They do. I even quoted several large excerpts from them and related sources about how FW and AFP organized, funded, and directed the agenda of the Tea Party.
"The sudden and sharp increase in the scale of protest meant that the five conservative leadership groups could no longer administer the Tea Party on a day-to-day basis. After two months, direct control of local Tea Party groups by FreedomWorks-#tcot-Smart Girl Politics-dontgo-American Majority had faded. Facilitation was now in the hands of a broad network of Republican Party and staunch conservative organizations."

FreedomWorks was only one of five groups spearheading the organization during the initial weeks, and by the second month it had outgrown them all and become a true grassroots organization.

"[A]s the Tea Party's numbers grew precipitously, conservative organizations aided the growth of a second wave of Tea Party protests through facilitated mobilization, where local activists utilized preexisting networks and resouces, like the Young Republicans, local campaign committees, donor lists, Internet blogs, and social networking sites, to build a grass-roots movement."

You can continue to claim that it's a top-down movement, but your own sources contradict that claim.
 
I' m no TPer, but I don't think special taxes for social engineering, targeting tobacco, alcohol, guns of medical devices are warranted - ever! You're claim that a selective tax on tobacco is not a violation of a TPers position is unevidenced.

So called "social engineering" taxes work pretty well for us here in Sweden. We pay about 50% tax on tobacco. Then again, we're a socialist hell hole.

ETA: It seems the US does as well. I guess legislators don't share your concern about "social engineering taxes".

Congratulations on proposing the most absurd and vile argument I've seen this year on this forum, and welcome to my ignore list.

Aren't you over reacting a bit?
 
Last edited:
FreedomWorks was only one of five groups spearheading the organization during the initial weeks,

Which "administer[ed] the Tea Party on a day-to-day basis"

and by the second month it had outgrown them all and become a true grassroots organization.

No, by the second month control "in the hands of a broad network of Republican Party and staunch conservative organizations", and still wasn't "grassroots".

You can continue to claim that it's a top-down movement, but your own sources contradict that claim.

"[C]onservative organizations aided the growth of a second wave of Tea Party protests through facilitated mobilization", i.e., after the main astroturf Tea Party groups were created, additional "tea party" groups were created by the controlling conservative organizations who used their organizational and networking resources to assist local activists.
 
No, by the second month control "in the hands of a broad network of Republican Party and staunch conservative organizations", and still wasn't "grassroots".
"[A]s the Tea Party's numbers grew precipitously, conservative organizations aided the growth of a second wave of Tea Party protests through facilitated mobilization, where local activists utilized preexisting networks and resouces, like the Young Republicans, local campaign committees, donor lists, Internet blogs, and social networking sites, to build a grass-roots movement."

I guess your definition of "grass-roots" differs from mine, and from the source your paper cites as support.
 
I guess your definition of "grass-roots" differs from mine, and from the source your paper cites as support.

As does your definition of "conservative organizations aided the growth of a second wave of Tea Party protests through facilitated mobilization", apparently.
 
Last edited:
As does your definition of "conservative organizations aided the growth of a second wave of Tea Party protests through facilitated mobilization", apparently.
"Facilitated mobilization" can mean lots of things, from offering the use of phone lines so that local leaders can coordinate strategy for a national rally to sending mass emails to a list of people who have expressed interest in political action in the past. In my mind, it doesn't transform a grassroots movement of hundreds of thousands (in the early weeks) into an astroturf movement, and it certainly doesn't make people who aren't motivated by the concerns of smokers into pawns of the tobacco companies.

I don't smoke, and I regard the Tea Party as a group of foaming ultraconservatives. I didn't think it was "created by the tobacco companies" back when you claimed there was proof in a paper I wouldn't pay to read, and having read the paper (and followed the footnotes) I find the claim even more ridiculous now.

I think you're suffering from some serious confirmation bias here. I don't know why it's important to you to paint the tobacco companies as a Tea Party Svengali, as though that would make their politics either more or less credible, but I'm not interested in belaboring the point.
 
In my mind, it doesn't transform a grassroots movement of hundreds of thousands (in the early weeks) into an astroturf movement

Except the quotes you posted say that during the initial weeks the Tea Party movement was directly day-to-day controlled by AFP and FW, and only later (ie, after the astroturf Tea Party movement was created) did a "second wave" spread that was more grassroots, albeit one still heavily aided and facilitated by top-down conservative organizations.
 
Except the quotes you posted say that during the initial weeks the Tea Party movement was directly day-to-day controlled by AFP and FW, and only later (ie, after the astroturf Tea Party movement was created) did a "second wave" spread that was more grassroots, albeit one still heavily aided and facilitated by top-down conservative organizations.
My last word in the thread, I swear:

The day-to-day administration by FreedomWorks consisted of supplying the phone lines which more than 50 local activists used to communicate with each other.

They were only one of five conservative organizations which spearheaded the initial recruitment, but that's more than can be said for Americans for Prosperity.

And it was "recruitment" (signing up like-minded individuals who sincerely supported conservative causes) not "astroturfing" (paying people to create the impression of popular support where it doesn't exist, by using fake personas which each generate multiple messages). The fact that they were able to grow to hundreds of thousands of people who were willing to travel to Washington to demonstrate in the space of a few weeks demonstrates that the support was there. Fortunately, it appears to have been as shallow as it was widespread, though I hope the Tea Party continues to prod conservatives into nominating candidates who are too extreme to win general elections.

The gentleman yields.
 
Societies can have legitimate arguments over social engineering taxes, but most societies try to protect children from making permanently-damaging stupid mistakes while their brains are developing. Some people prefer to let the "best" marketeers on Earth pit their skills and marketing budgets against the judgement of children, and they've been pretty successful. Most current adult smokers started as kids *after* the Surgeon General report in 1964. Joe Camel, starting in the late 1980s, was aimed squarely at kids, and was as recognizable as Mickey Mouse to 6-year-olds. Now, THAT is marketing.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom