Peer-reviewed paper shows Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies

Actually, the paper has been free for nearly 2 months. Go the the original URL, and see:
All Versions of this Article:

tobaccocontrol-2012-050815v1
tobaccocontrol-2012-050815v2 most recent

UCSF bought open access for it about a week after the original.

California Tea party organizations worked shoulder-to-shoulder with the tobacco companies to defeat California Prop 29 to raise cigarette taxes. Cigarette companies only survive by addicting children to something that will kill many and damage most, but they had lots of willing helpers. UCSF is one of the US's leading institutions for medical research and education, and people there get to see people dying miserably a teenage mistake induced by some of the cleverest marketeers in the world. They certainly knew what they were doing in trying for a decade or two to create something like the Tea Party.
I would suggest that when the next try to raise cigarette taxes come up, if tea Party folks don't want to be associated with people who kill children slowly, they can vote to raise those taxes and save a lot of children.
 
Well I doubt I have an argument with you, since for instance earlier you mentioned:

The simplest chart is on p.9, State Senators:
$150,325 Total, 40 State Senators:
25 Dems, 62.5%, of whom 22 took zero known $, and 3 took $28,200, 19% of the money.
15 Reps, 37.5%, of whom 1 took zero $, and 14 took $122,125, 81% of the $.

And it doesn't appear that the sole reason you care about this study is it might give you ammunition to use to discredit a segment of the political landscape you disagree with on other issues where they have a legitimate and possibly superior stance.

For the record I'm neither a Republican nor Tea Party member, I espouse (edit: eschew) affiliation with any party and vote issues and candidates, not party lines. I do respect one of the cores of the Tea Party platform being the absolute failure of representation we have today in the US Congress and the desire to overhaul that mess- and when I see the attacks on them as racist, or trying to associate them with any morally contemptible issue possible I do think that should be pointed out.

It could thus be said my quarrel was less with UCSF than the way this was presented in this thread.

On another note about taxes, tax revenues aren't always directed where they are supposed to, that may be a legitimate issue in this, and Tea Party members (not affiliated with tobacco companies) probably object overall to the underlying "the solution is more taxes" concept.
I don't think adding a buck or two to the cost of a pack of cigarettes will keep teenagers from trying cigarettes and instead will just be funneled into nanny state programs.
I'd rather see the damn things just plain outlawed. They don't do anything good for anyone anyway.
 
Last edited:
<OT>Batvette, I think you meant eschew, not espouse</OT>
 
Right you are. Thanks for that.
Maybe the confusion arises from a happy divorce? As in hate the ex?

I can see that reasoning...

On the global warming question this monster thread is probably the best place to discuss it - I started looking at global warming about 10-years ago to see how convincing the evidence was on either side and became convinced of its veracity, when I found I could get a pretty good first-order approximation using publicly available data and the simplistic analytical techniques I use every day as an engineer.

The one unequivocal greenhouse-gas piece of evidence I found was that the upper atmosphere is cooling at the same time that the lower atmosphere is warming.

Solar forcing would alter both in the same direction, whilst increasing the insulation between between the two layers would provide that signal - Our atmosphere tends to be warmed by the surface of the Earth as opposed to directly by the Sun.
 
Okay I've seen that as a rebuttal to the solar factor but try this one on for size- it still leaves us blaming greenhouse gases and not the sun, okay. Yet those promoting your theory acknowledge the unprecedented peaks of sunspot activity (and thus output) from the '40's through 70's, which continue albeit somewhat decreased.
Would not such warming cause large scale melting of polar ice regions, and the release of large amounts of methane gas? Doesn't such warming also produce CO2? Don't these gases produce a residual warming effect which would mimic the release of man made sources for years after the solar variance subsided?
So the melting ice from the early, acknowledged increased solar period releases methane gas, causing more warming forcing rising C02 levels, more ice melting, more methane release, a runaway effect indistinguishable from AGW. Just a theory. Yes we should assume fossil fuel burning would cause warming not expected by the variation- but that variation was huge, would the C02 levels from our fossil fuels approach the effect of the natural methane release, its heating, and C02 release?

Note I don't strongly argue the science. It's not "my yob" as they say. I could accept the science and it sure seems like the globe has warmed- yet I have a grasp of the people factor here and I cannot get away from the fact that climate change research is rather unique in its ability to be perverted and populated by ideologues who wouldn't even realize they were.

Nothing stranger than all men who enter the priesthood already believe in God and it's beyond reasonable you'd find many atheists in the field.

That makes me question the science, the policy debate is so absurd I can't believe it's gotten this far. (my arguments in that thread)

Reiterating the science may be right. Not trusting the scientists though.
 
Last edited:
Okay I've seen that as a rebuttal to the solar factor but try this one on for size- it still leaves us blaming greenhouse gases and not the sun, okay. Yet those promoting your theory acknowledge the unprecedented peaks of sunspot activity (and thus output) from the '40's through 70's, which continue albeit somewhat decreased.
Would not such warming cause large scale melting of polar ice regions, and the release of large amounts of methane gas? Doesn't such warming also produce CO2? Don't these gases produce a residual warming effect which would mimic the release of man made sources for years after the solar variance subsided?
So the melting ice from the early, acknowledged increased solar period releases methane gas, causing more warming forcing rising C02 levels, more ice melting, more methane release, a runaway effect indistinguishable from AGW. Just a theory. Yes we should assume fossil fuel burning would cause warming not expected by the variation- but that variation was huge, would the C02 levels from our fossil fuels approach the effect of the natural methane release, its heating, and C02 release?

Note I don't strongly argue the science. It's not "my yob" as they say. I could accept the science and it sure seems like the globe has warmed- yet I have a grasp of the people factor here and I cannot get away from the fact that climate change research is rather unique in its ability to be perverted and populated by ideologues who wouldn't even realize they were.

Nothing stranger than all men who enter the priesthood already believe in God and it's beyond reasonable you'd find many atheists in the field.

That makes me question the science, the policy debate is so absurd I can't believe it's gotten this far. (my arguments in that thread)

Reiterating the science may be right. Not trusting the scientists though.
Not that any of this climate change is relevant to the thread, but there's something seriously wrong with a lot of your statements in this post:
If you understand the scientific method, please realize the fact that nobody studied ecology with the some sort of faith that we were significantly impacting our climate before climate change was brought into public discussion. That is not how science works; and if it seems that way to you, study the science, and I mean from the basics to the top. If you have to, talk to a researcher about it in person.
Your comparison of scientists to priests is unnecessary and couldn't be more inaccurate. There's a clear difference between people who believe in a deity without any evidence, or people who build knowledge on top of the preexisting knowledge base. Understand this. Whenever I do an antibody stain, I don't do it out of faith that enzymes can bind specific regions on proteins. Climate change is the same way in the academic arena, and there is a scientific consensus on the topic.

Just helping you out.
 
Actually, the paper has been free for nearly 2 months. Go the the original URL, and see:
All Versions of this Article:

tobaccocontrol-2012-050815v1
tobaccocontrol-2012-050815v2 most recent

UCSF bought open access for it about a week after the original.

California Tea party organizations worked shoulder-to-shoulder with the tobacco companies to defeat California Prop 29 to raise cigarette taxes. Cigarette companies only survive by addicting children to something that will kill many and damage most, but they had lots of willing helpers. UCSF is one of the US's leading institutions for medical research and education, and people there get to see people dying miserably a teenage mistake induced by some of the cleverest marketeers in the world. They certainly knew what they were doing in trying for a decade or two to create something like the Tea Party.
I would suggest that when the next try to raise cigarette taxes come up, if tea Party folks don't want to be associated with people who kill children slowly, they can vote to raise those taxes and save a lot of children.

The link for you, thanks.
 
And they'll show it to us if we just give them a credit card number!

Now you can read it for free - what is your opinion?

Hardly an unsupported conspiracy theory.
 
People may find some background facts useful.
1) The Center for Tobacco Control Research and Education (CTCRE) was an offshoot of UCSF's Cardiovascular research, relevant since smoking was the largest single cause of death in the 20th century (usual estimate = 100M deaths). UCSF of course is one of the top US schools in medical research and education.

2) As a result of lawsuits that were finally won against the tobacco companies (led by lawyers I've spent some time with), the companies were required to provide large numbers of documents. They have their own websites ... which oddly, are a bit hard to use. UCSF got the money to set up the Legacy Tobacco Documents Library, which is rather easier to use and has 80M+ pages of material.

3) Starting ~2001, Stan Glantz (who runs CTCRE) started getting grants for studying all this data, including supporting postdocs, basically, to better understand tobacco company strategies and tactics, which can be summarized as: get kids to smoke, at all costs, and use terrific marketeering and lobbying, as well as tax-exempt 501(c)(3) public charities as front groups.

4) I've used the LTDL quite often, and when I first start looking for something, I get numerous hits, then I have to look at them to see which are relevant. As a side-effect, I often see things not directly relevant in the current search, but that might be interesting for other studies. I have hundreds of documents bookmarked this way, and so do the researchers at CTCRE.

5) So, the researchers weren't looking for the Tea party, they were looking at the evolution of tobacco company tactics, but then ran into the high tobacco funding of Citizens for a Sound Economy, the organization that split into the Tea party sparkplugs Americans For Prosperity and FreedomWorks. They then started following the threads around, and they know the other tobacco players way better than I do, and voila, there was the long history of tobacco company involvement, I am slightly chagrined not to have noticed it, as I've researched the funding flows, but I ignored CSE as it had been dissolved years ago, but Amanda and Rachel did a terrific research job. From personal experience, it is nontrivial to follow the track of people who were trying hard to cover their tracks. The tobacco companies have a long history of trying to use front groups where the people involved have no clue of the connection.

6) Two things are important to tobacco companies.
a) At the beginning, ability to addict children, to stay in business, and it is well-known that raising taxes differentially inhibits teenage smoking.
Google: cigarette taxes teenage smoking
USA Today had a recent editorial, but this has been known for decades

b) At the end, avoidance of a spotlight on the health costs. For tobacco companies, it is far better if people don't have insurance and just die quietly, somewhere out of sight, so they can be ignored. Insurance companies that penalize smokers would not be favored. Likewise, health maintenance organizations that expose the costs would not be favored. But most of all, any kind of government-related healthcare in which the total costs of smoking become more visible, and become more visible to the population as a whole, would need to be avoided, because a lot of people would get much more interested in stopping people from starting smoking. (This is not an argument pro-Obamacare or anything else, just the observation that making the costs more visible is not in the tobacco companies' interests.

People at a place like UCSF, who get to see people dying miserably from mistakes they were encouraged to make as kids, to support cigarette profits, care about preventing that, as cheaply as possible, i.e., prevention beats expensive attempts to repair the damage.
CTCRE people care about health and countering the tobacco companies, and if they'd been interested in attacking the Tea Party, I'd guess this paper would have come out ~2010.
Tea Partiers can believe whatever they want, and they can make a choice: when they next proposition comes to raise cigarette taxes, they can again work side-by-side with the tobacco companies to stop it. Or, they can say "we didn't know we were being used, and we keep our low-tax values elsewhere, but we refuse to help the tobacco companies kill children slowly."
Adults who were addicted as children find it very hard to stop, and ought not to be demonized (unlike tobacco companies executives), but if one could magically stop anyone under 20 from smoking (if they are dumb enough to start later, feel free), in 50 years the problem would be gone, in the cheapest-possible way.

Anyone interested in tobacco company tactics might read the long, superb history by Stanford's Robert Proctor: Golden Holocaust: Origins of the Cigarette Catastrophe...
 
Now you can read it for free - what is your opinion?

Hardly an unsupported conspiracy theory.
Doesn't substantiate the claim made in the thread topic at all.

"Over here's the tobacco companies supporting some organizations."

"Over there's the Tea Party."

They don't even make a compelling case that the tobacco companies provided substantial support to the Tea Party, much less that they created it.
 
"Over here's the tobacco companies supporting some organizations."

"Over there's the Tea Party."

That's not even close to what the paper says.

They don't even make a compelling case that the tobacco companies provided substantial support to the Tea Party, much less that they created it.

They do, actually. They document organizations and individuals, by name, that at the behest of the tobacco industry (as revealed by the tobacco companies' own internal documentation) organized and led the tobacco industry's astroturf "smoker's rights" and pro-tobacco lobbying and advocacy groups, then traced those exact same organizations and individuals to the organization and leadership of the Tea Party astroturf "movement". Then it connects them all by, again, citing internal tobacco industry documentation that shows that many of the strategies and messages of the "Tea Party" that were orchestrated by these same industry-controlled and -funded organizations originated from within the tobacco companies themselves, including the "tea party" branding and the emphasis on taxes.
 
Did you call me a "bat crap denialist"? I think you as good as did.

No, I called your arguments bat crap denialist arguments.

Which is you trying to refute the dismal failure of Kyoto. Worldwide greenhouse gas emissions have soared, as has the rate of their increase. You can provide a substantiated rebuttal or just leave.

You keep repeating this over multiple threads as if it was a good argument. It's not. It doesn't mean anything to the fact that the Earth is warming, that we're primarily responsible, and that we can still do something about it.

To clarify my position, the world may well be warming.

It is. Demonstrably so.

The role of the sun HAS been actively suppressed,

Conspiracy theory. The sun has been scientifically proven to not be responsible for recent warming.

and the policies promoted to "cure" warming have all been thinly disguised attempts at global socialism-whether by intent or accident is not my knowledge. They have only lead to a worsening of the situation.

Conspiracy theory. You never did explain how cutting emissions was the same as global socialism.
 
Okay I've seen that as a rebuttal to the solar factor but try this one on for size- it still leaves us blaming greenhouse gases and not the sun, okay. Yet those promoting your theory acknowledge the unprecedented peaks of sunspot activity (and thus output) from the '40's through 70's, which continue albeit somewhat decreased.

Lie. The sun has been very calm.

Would not such warming cause large scale melting of polar ice regions, and the release of large amounts of methane gas? Doesn't such warming also produce CO2?

Warming does. The sun isn't what is causing the warming, though.

Don't these gases produce a residual warming effect which would mimic the release of man made sources for years after the solar variance subsided?

Nope.

So the melting ice from the early, acknowledged increased solar period releases methane gas, causing more warming forcing rising C02 levels, more ice melting, more methane release, a runaway effect indistinguishable from AGW.

Nope.

Just a theory.

No, it's not. It's a bat crap denialist lie.

Yes we should assume fossil fuel burning would cause warming not expected by the variation- but that variation was huge, would the C02 levels from our fossil fuels approach the effect of the natural methane release, its heating, and C02 release?

You have much to learn about climate change, specifically feedback mechanisms. It would probably be best if you kept out of any discussion until such a time as you know anything about it.

Note I don't strongly argue the science. It's not "my yob" as they say.

You don't argue the science because you don't know or understand the science.

I could accept the science and it sure seems like the globe has warmed- yet I have a grasp of the people factor here and I cannot get away from the fact that climate change research is rather unique in its ability to be perverted and populated by ideologues who wouldn't even realize they were.

The only ones bringing in ideology and politics is climate deniers like you.

Nothing stranger than all men who enter the priesthood already believe in God and it's beyond reasonable you'd find many atheists in the field.

Climate science isn't a religion.

That makes me question the science, the policy debate is so absurd I can't believe it's gotten this far. (my arguments in that thread)

The debate is absurd because people like you make it absurd. You don't understand the science but you still question it, that is highly arrogant.

Reiterating the science may be right. Not trusting the scientists though.

That makes your opinions irrelevant.
 
Doesn't substantiate the claim made in the thread topic at all.

"Over here's the tobacco companies supporting some organizations."

"Over there's the Tea Party."

They don't even make a compelling case that the tobacco companies provided substantial support to the Tea Party, much less that they created it.

You missed out the links between the two that are shown in the paper (which I won't quote as it would be difficult without violating rule 4
 
You missed out the links between the two that are shown in the paper (which I won't quote as it would be difficult without violating rule 4
The reason you can't provide a clear link between "FreedomWorks" and "AFP" (which most of the article discussed) and "The Tea Party" is because the article didn't provide one either. You would have to quote pretty much the whole paper to hide the fact that it doesn't document any strong link between them. The "link" consists of this:

"There has been continuity of some key players, strategies and messages from these groups to Tea Party organisations."

On that basis, you might as well argue that JREF was created by the fundamentalists, since fundamentalists join and post their messages and strategeries here.

Oh, wait, there was also this:

"As of 2012, key personnel from the smokers’ rights groups had founded or worked at firms that consulted for Tea Party groups".

Not "founded Tea Party groups" much less the Tea Party itself. No, they founded firms that consulted for Tea Party groups. Well, if that's not a smoking pipe ...

And yet, even though the Tea Party is ostensibly owned and operated by Big Tobacco, the paper concedes,

"Although AFP and FreedomWorks oppose smoke-free laws, a 2011 survey on support for smoke-free laws found that the proportion of people who favour smoke-free laws was similar among those who identify with, and those who oppose, the Tea Party (72% and 75%, respectively, in states without smoke-free laws, p=0.145 by χ2 and 77% and 87% in states with smoke-free laws, p=0.139). Tea Party supporters also favour preserving Medicare, which does not align with AFP and FreedomWorks’ opposition to government-run healthcare."

So the smokers' rights groups advocate smokers' rights, and the Tea Party has its own agenda which mostly involves issues other than smoking. And when they do think about smoking, they think pretty much like the population at large.

It's still not too late to move this thread to CT.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom