Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Someone called Ben Pierce, who works at the NHS as Head of Data Analytics and Partnerships has reviewed Chan and Ridley's book Viral.

He's not very impressed (This is from a Twitter thread):
Gee, not a virologist, oh my. :rolleyes:
I would never suggest that the relevant experience of Ben Pierce, Head of Data Analytics and Partnerships at Imperial College Health Partners and formerly "Operations Manager of the Future Vaccine Manufacturing Research Hub at Imperial College London, where he managed a clinical trial of an innovative RNA Covid-19 vaccine candidate in Uganda", is truly comparable to the relevant experience of the poet Amy Elise Winter or to that of former assistant professor and calf scours researcher Dr Andrew G Huff.

It seems to me, however, that this thread would be considerably less active if discussing the opinions of non-virologists were off limits.

Seems to me, not a virologist...


Regarding one of the non-virologists mentioned above:
Those are completely irrelevant examples. EcoHealth Alliance analyses patterns of disease spread and viral genomes. In your examples the entire product these companies sell is stock market analyses.


Well, no. You don't understand how the company I mentioned earns its profit.

I was responding to someone who asked, in bold face:
Know anyone in a top management position whose key function was to analyze computer data.


If you believe the person who asked that question should have asked instead about "anyone in a top management position" at EcoHealth Alliance "whose key function was to analyze computer data", then I suggest you take that up with the person who phrased the question.

It seems to me, however, that the question quoted above was posed as part of an argument from personal incredulity, from a person who could scarcely believe "computer data" could possibly be so important as to warrant attention from one of the two vice presidents at a 501(c)(3) organization whose "budget has has [sic] grown exponentially" within the limited range of 9 to 15 million dollars per year.

As a counter to that argument from personal incredulity, the activities of top management at a multi-billion dollar business seem relevant to me.
 
I would never suggest that the relevant experience of ... [snip]
That comment was specific sarcasm directed at angrysoba who dismisses all the expertise of sources I cite because they are not "virologists".

It seems to me, however, that this thread would be considerably less active if discussing the opinions of non-virologists were off limits.
D'uh. :rolleyes:

[snipped]
Get back to me after I actually post something more about Huff, unless you have something specific to the legitimacy of the EcoHealth Alliance's discrediting of Huff.

He was hired and within a couple years promoted to VP. ECA claims he was no more than a computer analyst.
 
That comment was specific sarcasm directed at angrysoba who dismisses all the expertise of sources I cite because they are not "virologists".

Did not!

Here's what I wrote...

No, the virologists in question are themselves lab leak proponents. I think it was actually Latham who attempted to confront Shi in the Q&A.

The thing about expertise is that when you have someone with the apparent qualifications in the field, you should give them credit proportional to how they think in other areas.

To give an analogy, when "Gravy" used to argue with Architects and Engineers, one of the things he argued was that the petition for A&E9/11Truth contained a lot of architects who had no experience with high-rises, and engineers whose area was stuff like software engineering or biomechanical engineering. When Richard Gage pointed out that there were also a handful of structural engineers among the 1,000 or so signatures, Gravy noted that one of them argued the Twin Towers were brought down by nuclear warheads. In other words, their expertise was, for the most part lacking, and where it was present it was undermined considerably by other areas of their world-view.

This is the same feeling I get with the vast majority of those making the lab leak claims.

Many of them are indeed on the right-wing of the spectrum, many of them believe wacky ideas such as that Covid-19 is a prion, or they are straight up anti-vaxx Infowars-types, such as Andrew Huff and Bret Weinstein. And in the few cases where they do seem to have some actual experise they seem believe attendant weirdness such as that Ebola and HIV were man-made. Latham is one of the few with genuine exertise and he argues for the lab leak case for Ebola.

I think it is important to recognize that these are not smears by their opponents, but self-described and therefore self-discrediting views.

You misunderstood the first time.

I did not dismiss people just because they are not virologists. However, I will give some weight to specific expertise. This is a normal part of skepticism. If someone is making unusual claims, you have to ask why they are more believable than others. Expertise is one factor when weighing up how believable someone is.
 
The virus originated due to the research funded at the
WIV in Wuhan. /thread

Getting into the weeds is just so dumb at this point.
It was obvious then,....it is 1000 times more obvious now.
 
Did not!

Here's what I wrote...
Goodness, did I hit a hot button with you? :eye-poppi Look at what you posted: the virologists said X.

I never said you dismissed virologists I might have cited. You dismiss experts I cite often beginning your reply with, "they're not virologists."

You misunderstood the first time.

I did not dismiss people just because they are not virologists. However, I will give some weight to specific expertise. This is a normal part of skepticism. If someone is making unusual claims, you have to ask why they are more believable than others. Expertise is one factor when weighing up how believable someone is.
You do know what sarcasm is, right?

I said, "Gee, not a virologist, oh my."

This is off-topic and not worth my time quoting examples of you dismissing sources I cite rather than addressing the evidence I post. But you should really take a look at some of your replies to evidence I've cited.

And rather than even considering the evidence a number of times you've explained you do that because you yourself don't have the expertise to evaluate the evidence.


Moving on, the evidence for a lab-leak continues to accumulate and any new evidence for a natural spillover continues to be weak and full of plot holes. I'm still reading Huff's book so I'm not ready to comment on it yet.
 
Goodness, did I hit a hot button with you? :eye-poppi Look at what you posted: the virologists said X.

I never said you dismissed virologists I might have cited. You dismiss experts I cite often beginning your reply with, "they're not virologists."

You do know what sarcasm is, right?

I said, "Gee, not a virologist, oh my."

This is off-topic and not worth my time quoting examples of you dismissing sources I cite rather than addressing the evidence I post. But you should really take a look at some of your replies to evidence I've cited.

And rather than even considering the evidence a number of times you've explained you do that because you yourself don't have the expertise to evaluate the evidence.


Moving on, the evidence for a lab-leak continues to accumulate and any new evidence for a natural spillover continues to be weak and full of plot holes. I'm still reading Huff's book so I'm not ready to comment on it yet.

Interesting tactics there. Make an accusation, call my response off-topic and then say you can't be bothered to substantiate your accusation because that's off-topic and then tell me to reflect on what a bad boy I have been.

Maybe don't make the accusations that you are not prepared to back up, then? ;)

Anyway, please get back to reading Huff as I am looking forward to hearing some ground-shaking revelations.
 
Interesting tactics there. Make an accusation, call my response off-topic and then say you can't be bothered to substantiate your accusation because that's off-topic and then tell me to reflect on what a bad boy I have been.

Maybe don't make the accusations that you are not prepared to back up, then? ;)

Anyway, please get back to reading Huff as I am looking forward to hearing some ground-shaking revelations.
Tactics? :rolleyes: Seriously, as., my goal is to debate the side of the origin hypothesis so many people have dismissed out of hand.

Also I don't think sarcasm qualifies as an accusation. I thought you were well aware how often you've done that. You want me to back up my sarcasm when you've even admitted as much in your reply to my post.

Why should I have to hunt through the thread for your posts when you can just as easily do so? I don't care if you want to continue the discussion. Go for it. If you look you will see how often you've used "not a virologist" to dismiss my citations.
 
Last edited:
Because it is your claim, not mine. Why would I hunt through posts to back up your claim? :confused:;)

You seem to argue with feelings about who believes the lab leak vs who believed the governments stance at the start of the pandemic.

Ask yourself why you believed the government and certain "experts" but not others? Because they had good evidence? or because the side you didn't agree with politically was tending towards the other side? Perhaps you didnt even see it because it was wiped from your view by social media? Was your scientific skepticism directed by politics? I dont see another reason because what was obvious then is still obvious now.

Why would you side with the Chinese government and those who dismissed the most obvious source out-of-hand before anything was known? And then we learned those persons were paid and instrumental in the work done there. Are you not skeptical of this? It's baffling to me that anyone cannot see what is in front of them at this point. (to be honest, it baffled me 3 years ago as well)

I havent been in here in a while so perhaps you are now 50/50 with each theory instead of where I am at at 99.5% lab related. What would you say are your actual percentages after all that we know now?
 
Last edited:
... I havent been in here in a while so perhaps you are now 50/50 with each theory instead of where I am at at 99.5% lab related. What would you say are your actual percentages after all that we know now?
I'd like to know angrysoba's answer but here's mine: we are not at 50:50. There is considerably more evidence the source was the lab.

Here are some of the latest developments supporting the spillover hypothesis. They don't stand up to critical analysis:

Worobey, et al, mapped out some (but not all) of the earliest cases and found they radiated out from the seafood market. A lot of the spillover proponents latched onto this as if it were conclusive. Frankly I was surprised at how many experts commented on this study without critical analysis.
The market was identified early on as a super-spreader event location so one would expect cases to radiate out from said super-spreader event.

China continues to block access to critical information on the earliest cases so we don't know where they might have been infected.

The WIV is relatively close despite it being characterized as 'miles away'.

There are different demographics surrounding the WIV vs the market, in particular, the area around the WIV is not as densely residential as the area around the market. Worobey did not address this variable.

Where Worobey lacked data he simply concluded certain things must be true. Again, in particular, he proclaimed some documented cases he didn't have exposure data for must have been infected at a different wet market and there must have been a second spillover site. A number of people refer to this declaration claiming one or more other markets were identified by the Chinese government.

It's supposed to be in the WHO report. The only reference to any other market was the data that one of the earliest cases who had no connection to the seafood market had a relative in her house that had been to another market. And there might be a reference in the WHO report to evidence of COVID in the waste water from one other market. My memory is vague and I don't want to hunt through the report one more time for this not so relevant information.

I noted repeatedly the WHO report was being cited as a source when no such evidence was in the report. And because I could have missed it I asked the spillover proponents in this thread to please look at that WHO report and find for me any reference that CoV2 was found in any other market besides the seafood market. So far ...crickets.​

Then there was the most recent discovery that the Chinese had been sitting on genomic data from their first sampling of locations in the market. In a single sample they found COVID RNA in the same stall raccoon dog DNA was found. More people immediately and uncritically professed this proved COVID had a connection to a suspected intermediate source animal. Worobey announced it backed his findings up.

But with a more critical analysis:
We already knew they had live raccoon dogs at the market. There were pictures of them in cages from before the pandemic began.

Finding evidence of raccoon dogs in the same stall as positive COVID samples were found did not mean the dogs were infected.

It turned out there was a minimal amount of COVID RNA in that sample and other experts pointed out it suggested the source had been infected people in the market, not live animals sold from that stall.​

I posted citations for all of this.
 
I'd like to know angrysoba's answer but here's mine: we are not at 50:50. There is considerably more evidence the source was the lab.

Here are some of the latest developments supporting the spillover hypothesis. They don't stand up to critical analysis:

Worobey, et al, mapped out some (but not all) of the earliest cases and found they radiated out from the seafood market. A lot of the spillover proponents latched onto this as if it were conclusive. Frankly I was surprised at how many experts commented on this study without critical analysis.
The market was identified early on as a super-spreader event location so one would expect cases to radiate out from said super-spreader event.

China continues to block access to critical information on the earliest cases so we don't know where they might have been infected.

The WIV is relatively close despite it being characterized as 'miles away'.

There are different demographics surrounding the WIV vs the market, in particular, the area around the WIV is not as densely residential as the area around the market. Worobey did not address this variable.

Where Worobey lacked data he simply concluded certain things must be true. Again, in particular, he proclaimed some documented cases he didn't have exposure data for must have been infected at a different wet market and there must have been a second spillover site. A number of people refer to this declaration claiming one or more other markets were identified by the Chinese government.

It's supposed to be in the WHO report. The only reference to any other market was the data that one of the earliest cases who had no connection to the seafood market had a relative in her house that had been to another market. And there might be a reference in the WHO report to evidence of COVID in the waste water from one other market. My memory is vague and I don't want to hunt through the report one more time for this not so relevant information.

I noted repeatedly the WHO report was being cited as a source when no such evidence was in the report. And because I could have missed it I asked the spillover proponents in this thread to please look at that WHO report and find for me any reference that CoV2 was found in any other market besides the seafood market. So far ...crickets.​

Then there was the most recent discovery that the Chinese had been sitting on genomic data from their first sampling of locations in the market. In a single sample they found COVID RNA in the same stall raccoon dog DNA was found. More people immediately and uncritically professed this proved COVID had a connection to a suspected intermediate source animal. Worobey announced it backed his findings up.

But with a more critical analysis:
We already knew they had live raccoon dogs at the market. There were pictures of them in cages from before the pandemic began.

Finding evidence of raccoon dogs in the same stall as positive COVID samples were found did not mean the dogs were infected.

It turned out there was a minimal amount of COVID RNA in that sample and other experts pointed out it suggested the source had been infected people in the market, not live animals sold from that stall.​

I posted citations for all of this.

Agree. The argument seems to be maybe maybe maybe maybe.
Ignore the obvious obvious obvious obvious. The source has always been so so obvious. So what allows the opposition view to last for so long without any clear evidence in favor of it??

Take the 10,000 ft view and it is clear what happened. Get into the weeds of promoted information and you are victim to propaganda. Weeds and weeds for days and days. It has happened to really smart people. Is there anyone who has written about how this happened...psychologcally? Ina a non-biased way? ie just with actual facts from persons not paid with government grants??
 
Last edited:
Awful lot of opinions posted here by non-virologists who criticize/dismiss the opinions of others because they are non-virologists. I propose that posts in this thread be restricted to virologists only.
 
Because it is your claim, not mine. Why would I hunt through posts to back up your claim? :confused:;)
:bike:

:rolleyes: Do you or do you not immediately note when any experts I cite are not virologists?

Do you or do you not recognize that epidemiologists have equivalent relative expertise as virologists do in this origin debate?

Did you or did you not dismiss the work of Quay because his specialty was breast cancer and he had a private company and sold pamphlets on breast cancer?

You claimed you couldn't evaluate Quay's work because you didn't understand his Bayesian analysis of the locations of the hospitals that saw the earliest COVID cases ran along subway line 2 that came directly out of the WIV and into the city.

Did you apply the same caveat to anyone else who presented statistical data, or, if it supported the spillover hypothesis did you accept what they presented?​

Did you dismiss the work of Alina Chan because she was not a virologist? She's a molecular biologist specializing in gene therapy and cell engineering.

How about Nicholas Wade? Did you or did you not dismiss his reporting because he wasn't a virologist? He's a former editorial writer, science reporter, and science editor for The New York Times.

And so on....
 
Awful lot of opinions posted here by non-virologists who criticize/dismiss the opinions of others because they are non-virologists. I propose that posts in this thread be restricted to virologists only.

IOW [/thread] :)


Sorry, I'm too annoyed by the repeated references in the media that the lab leak hypothesis is a CT and that the spillover hypothesis is well supported by the evidence.
 
.... It has happened to really smart people. Is there anyone who has written about how this happened...psychologcally? Ina a non-biased way? ie just with actual facts from persons not paid with government grants??
I don't know about "a non-biased way" but I have addressed this.

The first problem was that for close to a year Daszak from the EcoHealth Alliance who was deeply involved in the gain of function research at the WIV purposefully steered anyone away from the lab-leak hypothesis. He asserted it was a CT. Tedros from the WHO finally called the claim out noting Daszak made this assertion before a single shred of evidence had even been collected on the lab leak hypothesis.

Many scientists are reluctant to call out the researchers like Shi as liars. These guys are colleagues and have done research together. I think this is one of the biggest reasons.

Some researchers don't want gain of function found as a cause because it might put a damper on their own research.

The US despite the GOP wanting to find China responsible when Trump was POTUS are reluctant to blame China for political reasons.

People like Fauci who were involved in funding decisions for work done at the WIV don't want to take any of the blame either. (Ignore the Rand Paul-Fauci debate, it's a red herring.)

Unfortunately a lot of the news media fell into the trap that a lab leak hypothesis was a CT.
 
Last edited:
You seem to argue with feelings about who believes the lab leak vs who believed the governments stance at the start of the pandemic.

Ask yourself why you believed the government and certain "experts" but not others? Because they had good evidence? or because the side you didn't agree with politically was tending towards the other side? Perhaps you didnt even see it because it was wiped from your view by social media? Was your scientific skepticism directed by politics? I dont see another reason because what was obvious then is still obvious now.

Why would you side with the Chinese government and those who dismissed the most obvious source out-of-hand before anything was known? And then we learned those persons were paid and instrumental in the work done there. Are you not skeptical of this? It's baffling to me that anyone cannot see what is in front of them at this point. (to be honest, it baffled me 3 years ago as well)

I havent been in here in a while so perhaps you are now 50/50 with each theory instead of where I am at at 99.5% lab related. What would you say are your actual percentages after all that we know now?

I argue “with feelings”? Not sure what that is supposed to mean.

Why do I “believe the government”? What government are we talking about?

Why do I “side with the Chinese government”? Ummm….I don’t. The Chinese government claims it came from an American lab. Remember?

It’s “baffling” to you and “obvious” to you? Well, sorry I don’t go by my gut or my “feelings”. I go by evidence.

The evidence we have is that it came from a wet market because that is where most of the early cases were connected to. In addition, the arguments presented from lab leak tend to be various contradictory claims about more than one lab or from bats caught in the wild or from the Mojiang mine. I have not seen a specific coherent argument for it coming from a lab. In addition, the evidence has gathered to refute some of the earlier concerns such as unique structural areas of the virus.

You seem overconfident on the other hand. That’s fine but you are also overconfident in other areas and have claimed that SARS-CoV2 no longer exists and the Covid-19 no longer exists etc…. So I am not sure how much faith I should put in your overconfident claims.
 
:bike:

:rolleyes: Do you or do you not immediately note when any experts I cite are not virologists?

Do you or do you not recognize that epidemiologists have equivalent relative expertise as virologists do in this origin debate?

Did you or did you not dismiss the work of Quay because his specialty was breast cancer and he had a private company and sold pamphlets on breast cancer?

You claimed you couldn't evaluate Quay's work because you didn't understand his Bayesian analysis of the locations of the hospitals that saw the earliest COVID cases ran along subway line 2 that came directly out of the WIV and into the city.

Did you apply the same caveat to anyone else who presented statistical data, or, if it supported the spillover hypothesis did you accept what they presented?​

Did you dismiss the work of Alina Chan because she was not a virologist? She's a molecular biologist specializing in gene therapy and cell engineering.

How about Nicholas Wade? Did you or did you not dismiss his reporting because he wasn't a virologist? He's a former editorial writer, science reporter, and science editor for The New York Times.

And so on....

You accuse me of only valuing virologists and not of epidemiologists and saying they have “equivalent” expertise? Okay but that only points out that you too value expertise. Glad you are on board! I don’t think I have said that epidemiologists have no value. You can quote me where I do.

I have rejected reading a 140 page “Bayesian analysis” preprint by Quay, and one of my reasons is that I don’t think he is an expert in the field. I note that this paper still has not found a home to be published in. I think it never will either.

I have not dismissed Alina Chan. I have posted links to her interviews and debates here on this thread.

How about Wade? I don’t remember. But I think he made claims about the unique structure of the virus. I have no expertise in that and I noted that he doesn’t either so I had to rely on experts who disagreed with him. Sure enough viruses with some of the features he mentions have been found in the wild.
 
The virus originated due to the research funded at the
WIV in Wuhan. /thread

Getting into the weeds is just so dumb at this point.
It was obvious then,....it is 1000 times more obvious now.
Funny how it was never that obvious to the people who are in a much better position to know than you.

...where I am at at 99.5% lab related.
Your confidence is impressive. Unfortunately the evidence it is based on is not. Until that anomaly is resolved this thread still has a purpose.
 
How about Wade? I don’t remember. But I think he made claims about the unique structure of the virus. I have no expertise in that and I noted that he doesn’t either so I had to rely on experts who disagreed with him. Sure enough viruses with some of the features he mentions have been found in the wild.
Let's start here ^ because it's better if I take these one at a time.

So you don't think any experts agreed with Wade or you chose which experts to accept?

Here's an example where you cited a video debunking Wade by someone named Potholer54. Did it sound good to you what Potholer54 had to say?

As near as I can tell, this is his profile:
Potholer54 is run by British journalist and trained geologist Peter Hadfield. Potholer54 videos address unscientific claims by tracing them back to their source and deferring to what is published in the scientific literature.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Hadfield_(journalist)

Should I waste 22 minutes of my time watching the video you linked to where he supposedly debunks Wade?

How about instead you quote from Wade's extensive report and tell us how Geologist Hadfield discredits the piece.

Origin of Covid — Following the Clues

This is what you said in your post:
as said:
For those of you who were pushing the article by Nicholas Wade, it might be worth checking out this video by Potholer54 in which he shows how much of Wade's article was a misrepresentation of Andersen et.al and coronavirus science in general, and in fact his insinuations about virology in general.
I consider myself very well informed about this topic and I don't see any major issues in Wade's paper.

Wade was exactly right about Andersen:
“Our analyses clearly show that SARS-CoV-2 is not a laboratory construct or a purposefully manipulated virus,” the five virologists declared in the second paragraph of their letter.
Yes, no issue there. What comes next is what's important:
... True, some older methods of cutting and pasting viral genomes retain tell-tale signs of manipulation. But newer methods, called “no-see-um” or “seamless” approaches, leave no defining marks. Nor do other methods for manipulating viruses such as serial passage, the repeated transfer of viruses from one culture of cells to another. If a virus has been manipulated, whether with a seamless method or by serial passage, there is no way of knowing that this is the case. Dr. Andersen and his colleagues were assuring their readers of something they could not know.
Wade goes on with much detail. So how did Hadfield debunk this?

Wade quotes from Daszak's interview at the Nipah Virus conference.
On 9 December 2019, before the outbreak of the pandemic became generally known, Dr. Daszak gave an interview in which he talked in glowing terms of how researchers at the Wuhan Institute of Virology had been reprogramming the spike protein and generating chimeric coronaviruses capable of infecting humanized mice.

“And we have now found, you know, after 6 or 7 years of doing this, over 100 new sars-related coronaviruses, very close to SARS,” Dr. Daszak says around minute 28 of the interview. “Some of them get into human cells in the lab, some of them can cause SARS disease in humanized mice models and are untreatable with therapeutic monoclonals and you can’t vaccinate against them with a vaccine. So, these are a clear and present danger….

“Interviewer: You say these are diverse coronaviruses and you can’t vaccinate against them, and no anti-virals — so what do we do?

“Daszak: Well I think…coronaviruses — you can manipulate them in the lab pretty easily. Spike protein drives a lot of what happen with coronavirus, in zoonotic risk. So you can get the sequence, you can build the protein, and we work a lot with Ralph Baric at UNC to do this. Insert into the backbone of another virus and do some work in the lab. So you can get more predictive when you find a sequence. You’ve got this diversity. Now the logical progression for vaccines is, if you are going to develop a vaccine for SARS, people are going to use pandemic SARS, but let’s insert some of these other things and get a better vaccine.” The insertions he referred to perhaps included an element called the furin cleavage site, discussed below, which greatly increases viral infectivity for human cells.
Did Wade misquote Daszak? Misrepresent Daszak? The video is posted in this thread if anyone wants to check.

Wade's paper here is very good. You should read it. You can do so in much less than 22 minutes.

It looks to me that you very clearly chose to discount Wade and you found a geologist :sarcasm: who confirmed your bias.


This is why I have said a number of times, you dismiss the arguer and avoid addressing the argument. Falling back on having to go with the 'experts' would be fine if you didn't seek out anyone/anything that confirms your bias.

Yes on some occasions you don't do that. It's why I've said I still believe debating this with you is worthwhile.

If I had to guess I'd say how reasonable you are depends on the time of day when you are posting, but then I'd have to look up the time differences between here and Japan.



I'll reply to your other comments in a bit.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom