Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Wait… you don’t want to watch the video because Hadfield is a geologist? Where’s that ironymeter?

You are so funny sometimes. That's not why I didn't watch it.

I read Wade's piece and knew from corroborating evidence that it was a valid account. Then you come along and say, 'watch this video where this guy debunks Wade's piece.'

I didn't even know at the time who the video source was or that he was a geologist. What I did know was that instead of seriously addressing the Wade article you posted a drive-by asking people to listen to a 22 minute video espousing your POV.

You could have presented a case backed up by said geologist specifically addressing anything in the Wade piece you felt was debunked.

But no, let other people do your homework for you, post a drive-by and remain in your safe confirmation-biased place.

You can still address the debunking video, it's not too late. What has Mr Hadfield asserted that Wade got wrong? What is Hadfield's evidence? I'm more than happy to debate what you think Wade got wrong.

What I am trying to point out is that you've dismissed evidence once again, not by addressing the evidence, but rather by hand-waving the evidence away using one excuse or another.
 
Last edited:
You are so funny sometimes. That's not why I didn't watch it.

I read Wade's piece and knew from corroborating evidence that it was a valid account. Then you come along and say, 'watch this video where this guy debunks Wade's piece.'

I didn't even know at the time who the video source was or that he was a geologist. What I did know was that instead of seriously addressing the Wade article you posted a drive-by asking people to listen to a 22 minute video espousing your POV.

You could have presented a case backed up by said geologist specifically addressing anything in the Wade piece you felt was debunked.

But no, let other people do your homework for you, post a drive-by and remain in your safe confirmation-biased place.

You can still address the debunking video, it's not too late. What has Mr Hadfield asserted that Wade got wrong? What is Hadfield's evidence? I'm more than happy to debate what you think Wade got wrong.

What I am trying to point out is that you've dismissed evidence once again, not by addressing the evidence, but rather by hand-waving the evidence away using one excuse or another.

If I have time, I'll have another look at them again.

:thumbsup::)
 
Because of course Dr Gao, the former top CCDC guy, would say this:

Top Chinese scientist concedes that coronavirus may have leaked from Wuhan lab

What's key here is him saying may have leaked from "Wuhan Lab" as opposed to lab outside of China.
Chinese authorities have officially maintained a vague stance, meant largely to deflect criticism. Meanwhile, scientists who may hold clues to how the pandemic began — likely sometime in late 2019 — appear to have been silenced.

That changed ever so slightly this week, when George Gao, the former head of the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention, offered his thoughts on the contentious question to a BBC podcast.


Told ya so*:
“Don’t rule out anything.”

It may not seem like much, but Gao was clearly acknowledging that the coronavirus could have emerged as a result of a laboratory accident at the Wuhan Institute of Virology.

The remarks came in a new BBC podcast, “Fever: The Hunt for Covid’s Origin.”

Initially, most scientists thought the virus originated at a wildlife market in Wuhan. But gradually, opinion has shifted toward the likelihood of human error.


*Not directed at anyone still holding to the facts that neither hypothesis has been confirmed or ruled out, but rather at all the people in this thread who have been attacking me from the beginning of this thread as a CTer.
 
Last edited:
Because of course Dr Gao, the former top CCDC guy, would say this:

Top Chinese scientist concedes that coronavirus may have leaked from Wuhan lab

What's key here is him saying may have leaked from "Wuhan Lab" as opposed to lab outside of China.



Told ya so*:

*Not directed at anyone still holding to the facts that neither hypothesis has been confirmed or ruled out, but rather at all the people in this thread who have been attacking me from the beginning of this thread as a CTer.

The BBC journalists are a bit deceptive here, they did not interview him themselves but took a quote from elsewhere.

To quote myself upthread
There is a slight slant here. What he actually says that in science one should never rule something out. He also says he is aware of no evidence to support a laboratory source. He says that he is aware that WIV staff were tested for antibodies to SARS and SARS-CoV-2 early on and were negative so making it unlikely that one of them was infected at the beginning of the outbreak. That Shi checked the lab and they (WIV) had no viruses that were closely related to SARS-CoV-2. The implication being the possibility of a laboratory source was considered, investigated and no evidence to support WIV as a source was found.

Actual quote from Gao
Scientifically, we do not rule out any possibilities. But every possibility requires evidence, and there is no evidence of a lab leak. Science requires evidence and questioning, so within the scientific context, any possibility can be discussed.
https://www.chinadaily.com.cn/a/202306/03/WS647b0056a31033ad3f7ba3d7.html
 
Last edited:
I think it should also be pointed out that while lab leak is not itself a CT, almost every variant of the lab leak scenario when it is properly fleshed out requires a pretty huge CT.
 
I think it should also be pointed out that while lab leak is not itself a CT, almost every variant of the lab leak scenario when it is properly fleshed out requires a pretty huge CT.
Nonsense! Are you afraid to discuss the evidence?

Stop trying to end a rational discussion of the actual evidence by covering it up with the CT blanket Daszak tried to use back in early 2020. No CT is needed and both origin hypotheses are on the table. Multiple scientists have said so, Tedros from the WHO said as much, and now we have Gao the retired head of China's CDC saying so.*

If you want to consider CTs here there's a well documented effort by Daszak to scam other scientists into signing onto a letter to the Lancet while Daszak hid the fact he wrote that letter. Once uncovered more than a few of the letter's signatories withdrew their names from the letter.


*If you have evidence Gao didn't say so @Planigale, post it. Otherwise don't expect a reply questioning an established fact.
 
Last edited:
Nonsense! Are you afraid to discuss the evidence?

Stop trying to end a rational discussion of the actual evidence by covering it up with the CT blanket Daszak tried to use back in early 2020. No CT is needed and both origin hypotheses are on the table. Multiple scientists have said so, Tedros from the WHO said as much, and now we have Gao the retired head of China's CDC saying so.*

If you want to consider CTs here there's a well documented effort by Daszak to scam other scientists into signing onto a letter to the Lancet while Daszak hid the fact he wrote that letter. Once uncovered more than a few of the letter's signatories withdrew their names from the letter.


*If you have evidence Gao didn't say so @Planigale, post it. Otherwise don't expect a reply questioning an established fact.

I gave you the exact verbatim quote,

Scientifically, we do not rule out any possibilities. But every possibility requires evidence, and there is no evidence of a lab leak. Science requires evidence and questioning, so within the scientific context, any possibility can be discussed.

Shi says she considered the possibility of a lab leak, she checked the WIV for any evidence of a possible precursor virus for SARS-CoV-2, and didn't find one, one virus was related, but too distantly to be a precursor. Gao considered it and found no evidence.
 
I gave you the exact verbatim quote,
And it said exactly what I posted:
“Don’t rule out anything.”
It may not seem like much, but Gao was clearly acknowledging that the coronavirus could have emerged as a result of a laboratory accident at the Wuhan Institute of Virology.
Not "did".

Gao is consistent with the position I have, neither origin hypothesis has been proved. From there I happen to lean toward the lab origin. Gao put it back on the table for a reason, not because he was being pedantic.



Shi says she considered the possibility of a lab leak, she checked the WIV for any evidence of a possible precursor virus for SARS-CoV-2, and didn't find one, one virus was related, but too distantly to be a precursor. Gao considered it and found no evidence.
Good grief! Shi had every reason to lie as did Daszak. Did you expect her to come clean? "Oh gee, my work resulted in millions of deaths and a worldwide pandemic, oops".

Not many scientists anywhere would admit to such a mistake. In China that kind of mistake and exposing it publicly would have resulted in a jail sentence.

People at the WIV who might know about the leak would see the same writing on the wall. And the people who knew exactly what Shi was working on (in the BSL2 lab, by the way, not the level 4 lab), might be very few.
 
Or perhaps Shi had no reason to lie, as she told the truth and there was no precursor to SARS-CoV-2 at WIV. The obvious and simple option is Shi told the truth. You have to invent a complex conspiracy of scientists from around the world hiding (for what reason) a coronavirus, carrying out secret (why?) research, then lying about it.
 
Why Shi would lie is blatantly obvious. Coming up with scenarios where she might not have is an exercise in futility.

Shi had every reason to lie. What reason (not scenario) would she have to not lie?
 
Why Shi would lie is blatantly obvious. Coming up with scenarios where she might not have is an exercise in futility.

Shi had every reason to lie. What reason (not scenario) would she have to not lie?

The most obvious one, she had no reason to lie. There was no precursor virus to SARS-CoV-2 at WIV. It was not a laboratory leak from her laboratory.

Occam's razor would favour this. Any alternative explanation requires coming up with multiple other 'facts', and multiple other scientists lying. It requires a conspiracy.

(I note the recent US congressional report although favouring a laboratory leak actually suggests it was from a different laboratory and nothing to do with Shi; in this scenario Shi is telling the truth yet there is a laboratory leak origin. I still do not think this is the most likely explanation, as it is based on the idea that a vaccine was being made pre-pandemic and SARS-CoV-2 was some form of vaccine precursor, however it is a better fit with known facts than the WIV laboratory leak scenario.)
 
Well, Shellenberger and Taibbi now have a story citing anonymous US government sources saying:

Sources within the US government say that three of the earliest people to become infected with SARS-CoV-2 were Ben Hu, Yu Ping, and Yan Zhu. All were members of the Wuhan lab suspected to have leaked the pandemic virus.

As such, not only do we know there were WIV scientists who had developed COVID-19-like illnesses in November 2019, but also that they were working with the closest relatives of SARS-CoV-2, and inserting gain-of-function features unique to it.

When a source was asked how certain they were that these were the identities of the three WIV scientists who developed symptoms consistent with COVID-19 in the fall of 2019, we were told, “100%”

They also cite Alina Chan to provide commentary on who these figures are.

I don’t know what to make of this so far.

https://open.substack.com/pub/publi...-by-covid-19?utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web
 
It seems to be one of those “big if true” stories, in which we have literally no idea how much is true.

Jamie Metzl, a former member of the World Health Organization expert advisory committee on human genome editing who raised questions starting in early 2020 about a possible research-related pandemic origin, said, “It’s a game changer if it can be proven that Hu got sick with COVID-19 before anyone else. That would be the ‘smoking gun.’ Hu was the lead hands-on researcher in Shi’s lab.”

Sources tell Public and Racket that other news organizations are chasing aspects of this story. On Saturday, The Times of London quoted an anonymous U.S. State Department investigator saying, “It has become increasingly clear that the Wuhan Institute of Virology was involved in the creation, promulgation, and cover-up of the Covid-19 pandemic.”

They seem to have talked to a lot of lab leakers to give commentary, and I’ll say up front that I am leery of the involvement of Shellenberger and Taibbi. For all we know their “sources” could be people like Rand Paul, or Marjorie Taylor Greene or Mike Pompeo.

But perhaps the whereabouts of the named scientists could be checked somehow. For example, were all of them at the WIV at the time or were any of them attending conferences? Did any of them have any contact with other scientists by email or conference call etc…

It could be interesting to see how it plays out.

The other part here is that they were talking about the closest relatives of SARS-CoV2. Where does the evidence come from that the viruses were the closest relatives? Do we know what these viruses are? Or are we just hearing someone extrapolating from theories of the origin and making an assumption about what they were doing?

Some of the evidence given seems to be the paper that Hu and Yu co-authored with Zhengli-Shi, BUT were the closest relatives to SARS-CoV2 included in this? If not, then why not?

This has a certain flavour to it similar to the “intelligence experts” who recently told us about alien space ships and bodies that he heard about from other sources that seem to match already known theories of alien cover-ups.

Shellenberger in particular seems fishy to me. Not only was he one of the Twitter files authors (along with Taibbi), but he’s a big Hunter Biden laptop character who also wrote a piece that IIRC wondered aloud if Nancy Pelosi’s attacker was his gay lover. In other words he seems less the type of person to get good intel and much more so the type of person a right-wing politician might think is a good conduit for propagating conspiracy theories.
 
So far (I'm not all the way through the link) if you go back through this thread you'll find I and a couple other people posted about all this earlier. IOW this corroborates what I've previously posted.

Taibbi may be quite brash and he's publicly gotten into people's faces more than a few times. I'm not aware other than him having a brazen POV that he's been discredited as an investigative reporter. What am I missing?

Chan is reliable. I don't recall why you've brushed off her investigative reporting and I'm a bit too tired at the moment to go back and look. I did find this paragraph in your link worth consideration:

“Ever since I put out my [May 2020] preprint [research paper] saying that an accidental lab origin was possible, I was criticized as a conspiracy theorist,” said Chan. “If this info had been made public in May of 2020, I doubt that many in the scientific community and the media would have spent the last three years raving about a raccoon dog or pangolin in a wet market.”
:th:
 
... Shellenberger in particular seems fishy to me. Not only was he one of the Twitter files authors (along with Taibbi), but he’s a big Hunter Biden laptop character who also wrote a piece that IIRC wondered aloud if Nancy Pelosi’s attacker was his gay lover. In other words he seems less the type of person to get good intel and much more so the type of person a right-wing politician might think is a good conduit for propagating conspiracy theories.
A link would be nice. But discrediting this reporting by dissing the authors can only get you so far.

How about addressing the arguments they are making.
 
Apparently we'll know in a few days whether the story about the researchers being the earliest patients is true:

Next week, the Directorate of National Intelligence is expected to release previously classified material, which may include the names of the three WIV scientists who were the likely among the first to be sickened by SARS-CoV-2.

A bill signed by President Biden earlier this year specifically called for the release of the names and roles of the sick researchers at the WIV, their symptoms and date of symptom onset, and whether these researchers had been involved with or exposed to coronavirus research.
 
The most obvious one, she had no reason to lie. There was no precursor virus to SARS-CoV-2 at WIV. It was not a laboratory leak from her laboratory.
You keep repeating this crap that has been discredited again and again.

Obviously she has significant reasons to lie.

As for not "her laboratory"? WTF? Of course it was her lab. She worked out of the BSL2 lab for years. Do you think she only came to the WIV to run the new BSL4 lab? :boggled:
 
Shellenberger in particular seems fishy to me. Not only was he one of the Twitter files authors (along with Taibbi), but he’s a big Hunter Biden laptop character who also wrote a piece that IIRC wondered aloud if Nancy Pelosi’s attacker was his gay lover. In other words he seems less the type of person to get good intel and much more so the type of person a right-wing politician might think is a good conduit for propagating conspiracy theories.

As far as I can see, Shellenberger never passed on the bogus story about DePape being romantically involved with Paul Pelosi. (I assume you meant to say "Nancy Pelosi's husband's attacker). He did report on what a complete lunatic DePape was, and compared the coverage of the Pelosi attack with the relative lack of coverage of the assassination attempt on SC Justice Kavanaugh.
 
So far (I'm not all the way through the link) if you go back through this thread you'll find I and a couple other people posted about all this earlier. IOW this corroborates what I've previously posted.

What is new here are specific names. As far as I remember, the names had not been released before.

As for "corroboration", it doesn't count as corroboration if it is merely the same sources repackaging the same information. In the same way that the UFOs stories in recent days do not "corroborate" what has gone before, but rather just repeat what has been said before.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom