It seems to be one of those “big if true” stories, in which we have literally no idea how much is true.
Jamie Metzl, a former member of the World Health Organization expert advisory committee on human genome editing who raised questions starting in early 2020 about a possible research-related pandemic origin, said, “It’s a game changer if it can be proven that Hu got sick with COVID-19 before anyone else. That would be the ‘smoking gun.’ Hu was the lead hands-on researcher in Shi’s lab.”
Sources tell Public and Racket that other news organizations are chasing aspects of this story. On Saturday, The Times of London quoted an anonymous U.S. State Department investigator saying, “It has become increasingly clear that the Wuhan Institute of Virology was involved in the creation, promulgation, and cover-up of the Covid-19 pandemic.”
They seem to have talked to a lot of lab leakers to give commentary, and I’ll say up front that I am leery of the involvement of Shellenberger and Taibbi. For all we know their “sources” could be people like Rand Paul, or Marjorie Taylor Greene or Mike Pompeo.
But perhaps the whereabouts of the named scientists could be checked somehow. For example, were all of them at the WIV at the time or were any of them attending conferences? Did any of them have any contact with other scientists by email or conference call etc…
It could be interesting to see how it plays out.
The other part here is that they were talking about the closest relatives of SARS-CoV2. Where does the evidence come from that the viruses were the closest relatives? Do we know what these viruses are? Or are we just hearing someone extrapolating from theories of the origin and making an assumption about what they were doing?
Some of the evidence given seems to be the paper that Hu and Yu co-authored with Zhengli-Shi, BUT were the closest relatives to SARS-CoV2 included in this? If not, then why not?
This has a certain flavour to it similar to the “intelligence experts” who recently told us about alien space ships and bodies that he heard about from other sources that seem to match already known theories of alien cover-ups.
Shellenberger in particular seems fishy to me. Not only was he one of the Twitter files authors (along with Taibbi), but he’s a big Hunter Biden laptop character who also wrote a piece that IIRC wondered aloud if Nancy Pelosi’s attacker was his gay lover. In other words he seems less the type of person to get good intel and much more so the type of person a right-wing politician might think is a good conduit for propagating conspiracy theories.