Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Old news to some extent. Under normal circumstances I don't think this would have been prosecuted. He wrote an e-mail suggesting people should avoid discussing origin of covid on government email but use private email to avoid FOI requests. There is no evidence any data was in fact concealed. Hence the conspiracy to do so.
 
I thought the material from Wuhan was released in 2023. Nothing mentioned about Wuhan viral lab.
2025 this came out but nothing says what this chimeric term means.
This as they say depends on your definition of gain of function. At least some of the research would be best termed loss of function research. For example you take the spike protein from a wild type infectious (at least in bats) virus and you put it in a pseudo virus that cannot replicate. That is certainly not gain of function. They also used a virus that is not infectious in humans (WIV1) and modified the spike protein by putting spike protein from wild bat virus to see if the wild bat virus might be able to infect humans. At a stretch that might be called gains of function for the WIV1 virus. All this research has been published, discussed, years ago.

The important fact is that none of these experiments could have produced SARS-CoV-2.

I think the object might be to try and claim that Fauci lied and can thus be prosecuted for perjury by saying that NIH didn't (even indirectly) fund gain of function at Wuhan. I don't think that the majority of virologists would regard the research as gain of function which is why they had to get a quote from a chemist who has an obsession about lab leaks.

The first article is about how people realised there were DNA sequences from swabs from the wet market in Wuhan on line that proved that despite claims from China (and Chinese law) live animals that could have carried and been the source of SARS-CoV-2 were sold. Not a smoking gun but certainly another piece of evidence to support the hypothesis of zoonotic transmission occurring (more than once) at the Wuhan wet market.

The best source of discussion for all this is Flo Debarre, her discussion is detailed sometimes a bit technical but clearly refutes most of the nonsense supporters of the lab leak hypothesis spout.

ETA
However, even if SARS-CoV-2 was made in a Wuhan lab, US funding is not a prerequisite: scientists outside of the US are capable of doing science without US funds. The NIH grant subcontracted to WIV was about viruses too distant from SARS-CoV-2 to be their progenitors. If Chinese researchers led a secret project, they did not require US funding to carry it out.

Furthermore, the US debate on gain-of-function experiments will not resolve issues abroad. US-Americans often overlook the fact that the US do not govern the world. Banning gain-of-function experiments in the US would not prevent scientists in other countries from conducting them.

I believe that using the origin of COVID-19 as a pretext does a disservice to the critical issue of regulating dangerous experiments in biology (not just those involving viruses). I also now disagree with the claim that we need to know how COVID-19 originated to prepare for the next pandemic: there no reason that the next one should follow the same pattern, and we should prepare for all possible threats.

Florence Débarre
 
Last edited:
I think it is more of a technicality, to be honest.

Much of it amounts to the belief among certain people that somewhere there will be some emails saying, "We made Covid in the lab". He doesn't actually have had to have said anything of the sort, but the appearance of him being hauled before courts just gives the appearance of them covering up the origins of Covid.

Meanwhile, no additional evidence for that claim has appeared. Just the usual bad methodology of poring over emails and Slack messages and saying, "Look at this!"
 
I think it is more of a technicality, to be honest.

Much of it amounts to the belief among certain people that somewhere there will be some emails saying, "We made Covid in the lab". He doesn't actually have had to have said anything of the sort, but the appearance of him being hauled before courts just gives the appearance of them covering up the origins of Covid.

Meanwhile, no additional evidence for that claim has appeared. Just the usual bad methodology of poring over emails and Slack messages and saying, "Look at this!"
I think for people like Rand, this is the equivalent of convicting Capone of tax evasion. They will use any method to punish those they believe caused the Covid pandemic.

I think normally since no significant information was concealed and no financial irregularity occurred this would have been treated as a disciplinary matter, perhaps resulting in dismissal. With a poisoned DoJ, trivial things will be prosecuted to the uttermost.
 
The Lab-Leak Obsession and the Cost of Toxic Apathy
Jonathan Howard on bsky, Sep 1, 2026
New episode on how the lab leakers helped ensure we are all more vulnerable to dangerous viruses, not that they care about that.
https://bsky.app/#

The Lab-Leak Obsession and the Cost of Toxic Apathy
Podcast Episode · We Want Them Infected Podcast · September 1 · 1h 24m
podcasts.apple.com

In This Episode
(...)
The heart of the episode is a wide-ranging critique of the lab-leak movement.
(...)
• Why infection itself—not vaccination—was associated with the highest myocarditis, pericarditis, and mortality risk
• The molecular, evolutionary, geographic, and epidemiological case the hosts present for zoonotic emergence
• Why secrecy by Chinese authorities does not, by itself, establish that SARS-CoV-2 originated in a laboratory
• How lab-leak advocacy became intertwined with attacks on Anthony Fauci, Francis Collins, and other scientists
(...)
 
Last edited:
I don't have time to listen to those podcasts but I will say this:-

The motivations for blaming a lab leak and achieving herd immunity by infection were the same - Covid was just an inconvenience that people wanted to get past with as little effort as possible, not a deadly disease with unknown long-term effects that we had no immunity to. Not doing the most we possibly could to stop it was highly irresponsible. The result of that irresponsibility was that everyone suffered, including those who did the right thing. Any person in a position of power who was involved in that minimization deliberately failed in their duty and should be removed and ignored.

Instead, we see the people who did the right thing having their feet held to the fire for having the temerity to put our lives before corporate profits and 'freedom'. That's not just disgusting, it's perverse. In a just world the perpetrators of these witch hunts would be sanctioned in the strongest possible terms. They are literally enemies of society who want to see people die.

let me reiterate - the lab leak theory was never about labs, it was about finding an excuse to not do what needed to be done. If the government was to blame (and covering it up) then the government couldn't be trusted and therefore we didn't need to - or even shouldn't - do as we were told. This is the reaction of selfish individuals with no sense of civic duty or empathy.

Covid wasn't the only disease ravaging the world at the start of this decade, there was another one already in the wild that worked in symbiosis with it to get more people infected - the libertarian mind virus.
 
I think it is worth remembering the HIV pandemic persists, it still kills 1,000,000 people a year, mostly preventable. TB a now curable pandemic from the 18th century kills rather more every year. The 'Spanish Flu' virus of 1917 still circulates and still kills many persons.
 
I don't have time to listen to those podcasts but I will say this:-
It's possible to listen to podcasts while doing manual chores like the laundry, gardening etc. or while commuting.
In some cases, it's possible to change the speed. I do it all the time with YouTube videos. In spite of my impaired hearing, I can double the speed and still understand what is being said in some cases.

The motivations for blaming a lab leak and achieving herd immunity by infection were the same - Covid was just an inconvenience that people wanted to get past with as little effort as possible, not a deadly disease with unknown long-term effects that we had no immunity to. Not doing the most we possibly could to stop it was highly irresponsible. The result of that irresponsibility was that everyone suffered, including those who did the right thing.
Not quite true. Sometimes they claim that it was leaked intentionally as a bio-weapon. Sometimes they even claim that it was both harmless and a bio-weapon.

Any person in a position of power who was involved in that minimization deliberately failed in their duty and should be removed and ignored.
Any minimizer, whether powerful or not, should be ignored.

Instead, we see the people who did the right thing having their feet held to the fire for having the temerity to put our lives before corporate profits and 'freedom'. That's not just disgusting, it's perverse. In a just world the perpetrators of these witch hunts would be sanctioned in the strongest possible terms. They are literally enemies of society who want to see people die.
They are not enemies of society, at least not of society as we know it. They actually value the economy of capitalism higher than people's lives and made it clear from the very beginning.

let me reiterate - the lab leak theory was never about labs, it was about finding an excuse to not do what needed to be done. If the government was to blame (and covering it up) then the government couldn't be trusted and therefore we didn't need to - or even shouldn't - do as we were told. This is the reaction of selfish individuals with no sense of civic duty or empathy.
It was primarily an element of the blame game: 'China was responsible for stopping it. They should have stopped it. And since they didn't stop it, we can't be blamed for letting it rip in our own countries.' On top of that came the claims that it would only serve to strengthen people's immunity and wasn't worse than the common cold, so if people weren't willing to go out and get infected, they were to blame for preventing herd immunity by infection.
(The irony is that this implies that China would then have been doing the whole world a favor by not preventing the spread, but nobody is bothered by this piece of cognitive dissonance

Covid wasn't the only disease ravaging the world at the start of this decade, there was another one already in the wild that worked in symbiosis with it to get more people infected - the libertarian mind virus.
Indeed!
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom