However, even if SARS-CoV-2 was made in a Wuhan lab, US funding is not a prerequisite: scientists outside of the US are capable of doing science without US funds. The NIH grant subcontracted to WIV was about viruses too distant from SARS-CoV-2 to be their progenitors. If Chinese researchers led a secret project, they did not require US funding to carry it out.
Furthermore, the US debate on gain-of-function experiments will not resolve issues abroad. US-Americans often overlook the fact that the US do not govern the world. Banning gain-of-function experiments in the US would not prevent scientists in other countries from conducting them.
I believe that using the origin of COVID-19 as a pretext does a disservice to the critical issue of regulating dangerous experiments in biology (not just those involving viruses). I also now disagree with the
claim that we need to know how COVID-19 originated to prepare for the next pandemic: there no reason that the next one should follow the same pattern, and we should
prepare for all possible threats.
Florence Débarre