Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

The Atheist

Psychopath
Joined
Jul 3, 2006
Messages
38,197
TA, lomiller posts frequently inaccurate and unsupported scientific conclusions. Maybe you should read more of his posts.

I think you missed the exchange I was referring to, because science had nothing to do with it.



Continued from

here.

Posted By: jimbob
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I think you missed the exchange I was referring to, because science had nothing to do with it.

But it was nonsense. The argument started with an attempt to discredit the fact the pandemic started very close to several labs that were studying coronaviruses. That is significant.

That there are other labs in China doesn't negate the improbable coincidence near the WIV is where the pandemic started.

And it doesn't negate that argument (of all the gin joints) to say there are wet markets all over China.

Lomiller did descend into nonsense when he said, "if there were no Earth."

I admit I don't know what "that annoying tiger thing" is. Was that important to your sarcasm?
 
You should step back and re-read your posts some time. You are so far from making a valid argument it's downright hilarious.

What is hilarious is how consistent certain people are in this forum for declaring an argument that they can't counter "hilarious" (and then posting that annoying gif).
 
TA, lomiller posts frequently inaccurate and unsupported scientific conclusions.

I reference actual scientific papers and actual scientists who work in relevant fields instead of referencing rumors posted in magazines and the popular press the way you do.

That there are other labs in China doesn't negate the improbable coincidence near the WIV is where the pandemic started.
You've referenced at least 3 different labs at various points in the thread, including the Chinese CDC lab that the WiV doesn't have anything to do with. If there are multiple labs being accused of the same "leak" than it can't be all that improbable there is a "suspicious" lab nearby. In fact the history of new disease outbreaks is that some local lab almost always gets accused of releasing it.
 
Not sharing the database that was online and accessible until mid-Sept, 2019 would be something Shi would do under duress.

It's clear at this point China does not want SARS-CoV-2 to be the result of zoonotic crossover resulting from live animal markets. Not only did they sterilize the market and burn all the animals as soon as the outbreak was recognized. The fact that all the animals were destroyed without taking samples to look for viruses is a huge impediment to tracking down the original animal host. More recently China pulled down data from environment al samples that linked covid and animals in the market. They did similar things with SARS-CoV, trying to claim it came from outside China rather than the live animal trade.

If Dr Shi really was so compliant that she placed the wishes of the Chinese government over accurate scientific reporting of the evidence, why is is she was the one who linked SARS to live animal markets? IMO if Dr Shi was truly the pawn you claim she would never have presented evidence that points a finger at live animal markets as the source of the SARS-CoV and SARS-CoV-2 outbreaks.
 
That's a straw man. The reference was to that paper and that paper alone. Do you think no one isolated the SARS1-related viruses from civet cats? Think no one isolated the virus that infected the 3 miners who died in Yunnan?
What about all the coronaviruses we know about that cause mild infection in people? No one could culture those? And the coronavirus that infects pigs, do we only know about these because someone identified the genomes but never replicated the viruses first?

What is your problem with common sense?


Well, yeah! I also posted evidence they lied.


How is that two ways? It's an 'AND' not an 'OR'. Shi cannot speak freely. Her government minders are indeed almost certainly blocking her from sharing that genome database.

Not sharing the database that was online and accessible until mid-Sept, 2019 would be something Shi would do under duress.

What we don't know (a lab leak hypothesis plot hole) is what moved the government to take the database offline that early. What did they know about that hiding the genome database became important? Maybe the virus leaked from the CCDC lab that was under Dr Gao. While we are all looking at the WIV maybe something else happened earlier.

And by earlier I don't mean there was a wet market exposure in Sept 2019. No super spreader event occurred until Dec.

I think it is definitive that no virus was isolated from the miners. Indeed the clinicians thought about a fungal infection.
 
That's a straw man. The reference was to that paper and that paper alone. Do you think no one isolated the SARS1-related viruses from civet cats? Think no one isolated the virus that infected the 3 miners who died in Yunnan?

What about all the coronaviruses we know about that cause mild infection in people? No one could culture those? And the coronavirus that infects pigs, do we only know about these because someone identified the genomes but never replicated the viruses first?

What is your problem with common sense?


Well, yeah! I also posted evidence they lied.


How is that two ways? It's an 'AND' not an 'OR'. Shi cannot speak freely. Her government minders are indeed almost certainly blocking her from sharing that genome database.

Not sharing the database that was online and accessible until mid-Sept, 2019 would be something Shi would do under duress.

What we don't know (a lab leak hypothesis plot hole) is what moved the government to take the database offline that early. What did they know about that hiding the genome database became important? Maybe the virus leaked from the CCDC lab that was under Dr Gao. While we are all looking at the WIV maybe something else happened earlier.

And by earlier I don't mean there was a wet market exposure in Sept 2019. No super spreader event occurred until Dec.

Changing the goal posts?

No one is talking about isolating viruses from humans or civet cats or pigs or non-coronaviruses (in particular non-Sarbecoviruses). What we are talking about is isolating coronaviruses from bats. I have posted the three papers where the three isolates of viable coronavirus were reported as being cultured. I have posted comments from other scientists commenting on the fact that isolation is difficult, and that only WIV has done this. Yet you persist in your claim that it is easy. If it is that easy you should be able to find papers reporting the isolation and growth of coronaviruses from bats, or bat fecal matter and disprove this.

It is surprising how common this problem is. No one has cultured pneumocystis (I believe there are two claims of doing so but the work could not be replicated).

The explanation for the database going off line in September is that it was being rebuilt to enable geospatial searching. Then from early 2020 WIV was subject to cyber attacks and multiple hacking attempts and the decision was made to air gap the database.

The superspreader event is a strawman. It is unnecessary to the natural cross over theory. perfectly normal transmission events would have been sufficient.
 
The superspreader event is a strawman. It is unnecessary to the natural cross over theory. perfectly normal transmission events would have been sufficient.

Another issue is that there are a large number of early cases where the patient lived near the market but had not been to the market. This is consistent with normal community spread and completely inconsistent with a superspreader event.
 
The Chinese have submitted the outcome of the analysis of the market swabs here.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-023-06043-2
So taking positive co-locations of animal DNA with viral RNA Hominids are strongly associated with an OR 2.25 and p=0.015, but another primate is more strongly associated - Gibbon OR 5.5 p=0.04. Pigs OR 4 p=0, Cattle OR 4.6 p=0, Buffalo OR 11 p=0.015, sheep OR 5.1 p=0, goats OR 4.4 p=0.003, Deer (axis spp. asian deer) OR 10.7 p=0.001 and Deer (Odocoileus spp. white tailed deer etc.) OR 11 p=0.015. I assume these will all be associated with butchery. Interesting Deer are so strongly associated given the spread into wild deer population. Weasel family (mustids) OR 13.5 p=0.005 has the highest association. Racoon dogs are negatively associated with an OR 0.073 p=0.

Three samples had live virus (culturable) including one lineage A (early virus). Most of the rest appeared to be lineage B. One criticism of the cross over theory is that no early viral strains were isolated from the market, this now shown to be false with early SRAS-CoV-2 strains being isolated, showing transmission occurred early in the outbreak and both lineages being cultured.
 
Just an update because like last year other priorities prevail, taxes are due in 1 week and I'm behind due to my health.

Hooray for you, @Planigale, you finally looked at the earlier pages in the thread. Too bad you didn't look at the fact there were pages of discussion following the illness of the miners in Yunnan. There was evidence supporting the conclusion it was a lie when Shi claimed they died from a fungal infection. Few if any other experts support that conclusion. So why would Shi lie about that unless she was covering up what they did die from? As for the collected specimens that the WIV has, there was a long discussion about that too.

Now for the Chinese finally officially releasing the data they collected 3 years ago: the official release doesn't add more than the leak of that data revealed:

BBC: Covid origins: Chinese scientists publish long-awaited data
Some scientists say this is further evidence that the disease was initially transmitted from an infected animal to a human.

But others have urged caution in interpreting the findings and it remains unclear why it took three years for the genetic content of the samples to be made public. ...

But the Chinese researchers have pointed out that their discoveries fall short of definitive proof of how the outbreak started.
"These environmental samples cannot prove that the animals were infected," the paper explains.

The possibility remains, it adds, that the virus was brought into the market by an infected person, rather than an animal.
 
Just an update because like last year other priorities prevail, taxes are due in 1 week and I'm behind due to my health.

Hooray for you, @Planigale, you finally looked at the earlier pages in the thread. Too bad you didn't look at the fact there were pages of discussion following the illness of the miners in Yunnan. There was evidence supporting the conclusion it was a lie when Shi claimed they died from a fungal infection. Few if any other experts support that conclusion. So why would Shi lie about that unless she was covering up what they did die from? As for the collected specimens that the WIV has, there was a long discussion about that too.

Now for the Chinese finally officially releasing the data they collected 3 years ago: the official release doesn't add more than the leak of that data revealed:

BBC: Covid origins: Chinese scientists publish long-awaited data

1) You have no idea what I have or have not done do not claim that you know things you cannot know about me or my activities.

2) Neither you nor Shi are medically qualified. I am and spend most of my time working in respiratory medicine and infectious disease, I would probably qualify as an expert. The most likely cause for a pneumonia in this instance; miners being exposed to bat guano is a fungal pneumonia. I have seen no reports of positive or negative tests for fungal infections. No virus was ever isolated from the miners so the occurrence or otherwise of an unknown pneumonia is irrelevant to whether Covid-19 resulted from a leak from WIV or a natural cross over event most likely at the Wuhan wet market. The clinical presentation would not fit with Covid-19. The ages (36 - 63) and co-morbidities of the miners would not fit for them to get severe covid-19 requiring hospital admission. All six miners became unwell and three died; this is completely different from Covid-19 when you would expect most to have a mild or asymptomatic illness and perhaps only the oldest to have a significant pneumonia. The x-rays reported do not show appearances typical for covid-19. Why should Shi have tried to conceal a SARS-r CoV outbreak eight years before the pandemic? This would have been great for her, it would have brought lots more funding. The blood results from the three patients tested were negative on serology for both SARS-CoV-1 and SARS-CoV-2. So we can be fairly sure that the unknown pneumonia was not due to SARS or Covid-19. The miners are a red herring.

The problem remains that the more data comes out the more it favours a natural cross over event, and none favours an origin from WIV. All that favours WIV as a source is innuendo and co-incidence. BSL-4 laboratory - irrelevant. Research on mice with humanised lungs is irrelevant as WIV had no access to any virus that could be changed to / evolve into SARS-CoV-2. Shi lying is a circular argument; WIV must be the source otherwise why would Shi lie. Shi lied because WIV was the source. The alternative is WIV was not the source and there is not a conspiracy of scientists round the world lying and covering it up.

You are literally promoting a conspiracy theory.
 
Last edited:
1) You have no idea what I have or have not done do not claim that you know things you cannot know about me or my activities.

2) Neither you nor Shi are medically qualified. I am and spend most of my time working in respiratory medicine and infectious disease, I would probably qualify as an expert. The most likely cause for a pneumonia in this instance; miners being exposed to bat guano is a fungal pneumonia. I have seen no reports of positive or negative tests for fungal infections. No virus was ever isolated from the miners so the occurrence or otherwise of an unknown pneumonia is irrelevant to whether Covid-19 resulted from a leak from WIV or a natural cross over event most likely at the Wuhan wet market. The clinical presentation would not fit with Covid-19. The ages (36 - 63) and co-morbidities of the miners would not fit for them to get severe covid-19 requiring hospital admission. All six miners became unwell and three died; this is completely different from Covid-19 when you would expect most to have a mild or asymptomatic illness and perhaps only the oldest to have a significant pneumonia. The x-rays reported do not show appearances typical for covid-19. Why should Shi have tried to conceal a SARS-r CoV outbreak eight years before the pandemic? This would have been great for her, it would have brought lots more funding. The blood results from the three patients tested were negative on serology for both SARS-CoV-1 and SARS-CoV-2. So we can be fairly sure that the unknown pneumonia was not due to SARS or Covid-19. The miners are a red herring.

The problem remains that the more data comes out the more it favours a natural cross over event, and none favours an origin from WIV. All that favours WIV as a source is innuendo and co-incidence. BSL-4 laboratory - irrelevant. Research on mice with humanised lungs is irrelevant as WIV had no access to any virus that could be changed to / evolve into SARS-CoV-2. Shi lying is a circular argument; WIV must be the source otherwise why would Shi lie. Shi lied because WIV was the source. The alternative is WIV was not the source and there is not a conspiracy of scientists round the world lying and covering it up.

You are literally promoting a conspiracy theory.

Exactly. I have no idea why we keep having to discuss this incident when there is no reason to think it means anything at all. AFAICT it's nothing more that one factoid thrown out as part of a Gish Gallop of meaningless details in the absence of actual evidence for a lab leak.
 
Well, looks like the Senate Report o nthe Origins of Covid has been released.

Lurid cover, but some of the contents seem more sober and interesting.

Source
 
Well, looks like the Senate Report o nthe Origins of Covid has been released.

Lurid cover, but some of the contents seem more sober and interesting.

Source

Thanks.

Clearly a lot of work went into this. It is not intended to be a neutral report comparing the likelihood of a natural cross over event versus a laboratory source almost no consideration was given to evidence supporting a natural cause. It was intended to be a hatchet job; they were looking for evidence of guilt. To give them their due the conclusion was

This investigation focused on the question of the origins of the pandemic. It could not determine whether the SARS-CoV-2 virus was a product of nature alone or possible genetic manipulation. The preponderance of information affirms the plausibility of a research-related incident that was likely unintentional resulting from failures of biosafety containment during vaccine-related research. The nature of the identified biosafety vulnerabilities increased the likelihood that such containment failures were not immediately recognized. The possibility of unrecognized biocontainment breaches combined with SARS- CoV-2 clinical characteristics of asymptomatic infection and mild clinical illness in the majority of infections likely confounded early recognition and containment of the initial outbreak. Such initial unrecognized infections could serve as the nidus of the outbreak of COVID-19 in Wuhan and is a plausible proximate cause of the pandemic.

The strongest term they could use was that a research related incident was 'plausible'.

I think no one has ever said that such an occurrence was not possible, it is plausible, but this is far from saying that it is the most likely explanation. Certainly they found no smoking gun.

Some of their ideas really need a time machine to be convincing. An example is the suggestion that the Chinese were developing a covid vaccine in November 2019 (which they deny), and that the virus could have escaped from the laboratory carrying out animal testing of the vaccine. But this then begs the question about why the Chinese would be developing a vaccine for a virus two months before it was identified.
 
The strongest term they could use was that a research related incident was 'plausible'.


They go further. They say both hypotheses are plausible, but the preponderance of the evidence favors a lab leak:

The information contained in this Source Reference Document reflects 18 months of extensive research and accompanying analyses of these two plausible hypotheses. This document was the product of a multi-disciplinary effort by medical, scientific, legal, political and general policy analysts to catalog open source (unclassified) information relevant to the respective theories. Both hypotheses are plausible. The natural zoonotic spillover hypothesis is weakened by the absence of key epidemiological and genetic data from the Huanan Seafood Market. However, data required to support a natural zoonotic source is dependent on information provided by China, and that is incomplete or contradictory. The preponderance of circumstantial evidence supports an unintentional research-related incident.
 
They go further. They say both hypotheses are plausible, but the preponderance of the evidence favors a lab leak:

Thanks I missed that particular line.

I think that as they say all that favours a labarotory source is circumstantial evidence, there is no actual evidence. Whilst they say lack of some key bits of physical evidence to prove the natural spill over theory weakens it, they do not say the complete lack of actual physical evidence, and lack of key circumstantial evidence weakens the laboratory source theory.

The actual scientific analysis in general seems fair. The interpretation of the scientific evidence is generally fair, I would quibble with some bits. The use of circumstantial evidence is hugely biased as it is all looking in one direction and is far more subjectively interpreted. It also tells no coherent story, they cannot produce a timeline, that cannot agree on a laboratory involved, and they cannot get over the huge barrier that none of the laboratories had access to a virus that was a precursor to SARS-CoV-2.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom