Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

A link would be nice. But discrediting this reporting by dissing the authors can only get you so far.

How about addressing the arguments they are making.

I did.

We should note that much of this intelligence is presumably known to other agencies. The intelligence report said any reports of illnesses "consistent" with Covid-19 were not diagnostic of the scientists being patient zero.

But if they are, then I would think we would have other questions too...

As such, not only do we know there were WIV scientists who had developed COVID-19-like illnesses in November 2019, but also that they were working with the closest relatives of SARS-CoV-2, and inserting gain-of-function features unique to it.

November 2019? Even if they got sick with something that is consistent with Covid-19 (such as the flu), the idea they were patient zero seems to contradict the claims that:
a) The database going offline in September 2019 was the time of the outbreak.
b) The Wuhan Military Games of October 2019 was a superspreader event.

And again, what was this "closest relative of SARS-CoV-2"? There is no reason to think that RaTG-13 could have been engineered into SARS-CoV-2.
 
What is new here are specific names. As far as I remember, the names had not been released before.

As for "corroboration", it doesn't count as corroboration if it is merely the same sources repackaging the same information. In the same way that the UFOs stories in recent days do not "corroborate" what has gone before, but rather just repeat what has been said before.

Of course, I get it that the names are new. I wasn't trying to say you hadn't posted nothing new. I was saying this continues to corroborate things I posted about much earlier.

I'd have to go back and see what was posted earlier. Off the top of my head I'd say I posted about Chan's book and the fact they testified before Parliament.
 
... November 2019? Even if they got sick with something that is consistent with Covid-19 (such as the flu), the idea they were patient zero seems to contradict the claims that:
a) The database going offline in September 2019 was the time of the outbreak.
b) The Wuhan Military Games of October 2019 was a superspreader event.

And again, what was this "closest relative of SARS-CoV-2"? There is no reason to think that RaTG-13 could have been engineered into SARS-CoV-2.
They don't have to be patients zero, 1 and 2. They happened to be 3 people from the lab who were among the first to get infected.
 
Of course, I get it that the names are new. I wasn't trying to say you hadn't posted nothing new. I was saying this continues to corroborate things I posted about much earlier.

I'd have to go back and see what was posted earlier. Off the top of my head I'd say I posted about Chan's book and the fact they testified before Parliament.

The sick workers thing had been talked about for a long time. It was included in that Intelligence Summary that was released long ago.

ETA: And I just want to say that "repeating X does not mean corroborating X".

Remember that the claims of sick workers have been made by US government sources. If the same US government sources were informing these reporters, then it would not be corroboration, it would just be the US government sources repeating themselves.
 
Last edited:
They don't have to be patients zero, 1 and 2. They happened to be 3 people from the lab who were among the first to get infected.

But it doesn't really make much sense if they got infected months after the outbreak, does it? They would hardly be "among the first" then.
 
They don't have to be patients zero, 1 and 2. They happened to be 3 people from the lab who were among the first to get infected.

But these are the claims being made:

According to multiple U.S. government officials interviewed as part of a lengthy investigation by Public and Racket, the first people infected by the virus, “patients zero,” included Ben Hu, a researcher who led the WIV’s “gain-of-function” research on SARS-like coronaviruses, which increases the infectiousness of viruses.
 
But it doesn't really make much sense if they got infected months after the outbreak, does it? They would hardly be "among the first" then.

There are fuzzy bits at the beginning. There is a lot we don't know because China is hiding some of the information on the first cases.

We don't know if reports from the military games mean anything. Attendees reported the streets of Wuhan were unusually quiet. We've not heard back that any of the different countries' servicepersons who went to the games have been tested one way or the other.

Full hospital parking lots have not been explained or refuted.

People should stop claiming Worobey's epidemiological study is some kind of smoking gun.

Recognize the biased news reporting.

Stop injecting CT accusations into the thread. Have we not moved past that yet?

We are still at both hypotheses remaining on the table.
 
But these are the claims being made:
One more report, not a new irrefutable report. It may very well be good information from sources that don't now about the earliest history pre Nov 2019.

There might also be other explanations for the database removal. Hopefully all will be revealed in the end.
 
Naming the workers does.

I don't think it does.

If, on the other hand, for example says that they were supposed to have had a meeting, phone call etc... from one or more of the scientists, or if they had been due to speak at a conference and had pulled out suddenly, THEN I think we could call that corroborating information.

But if it likely comes from the same source (US anonymous government sources) then it is no more corroborating, to my mind, than the recent UFO stuff.
 
There are fuzzy bits at the beginning. There is a lot we don't know because China is hiding some of the information on the first cases.

We don't know if reports from the military games mean anything. Attendees reported the streets of Wuhan were unusually quiet. We've not heard back that any of the different countries' servicepersons who went to the games have been tested one way or the other.

Full hospital parking lots have not been explained or refuted.

People should stop claiming Worobey's epidemiological study is some kind of smoking gun.

Recognize the biased news reporting.

Stop injecting CT accusations into the thread. Have we not moved past that yet?

We are still at both hypotheses remaining on the table.

The Wuhan Military Games thing never had any legs as far as I could see. It's completely beyond the limits of plausibility that the whole city was in near-lock-down without the news getting out. And then you have to explain how a virus spreading like wild-fire suddenly died down again only to explode into life again from a superspreading event in the Huanan Seafood Market a couple of months later.
 
WIV Illnesses in Fall 2019 Not Diagnostic

The IC assesses that information indicating that
several WIV researchers reported symptoms
consistent with COVID-19 in autumn 2019 is not
diagnostic of the pandemic’s origins. Even if
confirmed, hospital admission alone would not be
diagnostic of COVID-19 infection.

IC Declassified report back in 2021, I think, said they did not find the reports of illness (even if confirmed) to be diagnostic of Covid-19 infection.

So is there any evidence they had Covid-19 or were even sick?

It looks to me that claims are becoming ever more certain whilst not based on any better evidence.

https://www.dni.gov/files/ODNI/documents/assessments/Declassified-Assessment-on-COVID-19-Origins.pdf
 
Did they have a test for COVID in Nov 2019 or earlier? What is needed is to see if they had pneumonia with ground-glass appearance on their Xrays. China might have saved specimens, or they could have been tested in the labs outside of Wuhan. Those labs identified a new coronavirus before the Chinese gov told them all to destroy the specimens and the data.

Wuhan scientists ‘created mutant virus before pandemic’
Scientists in the Chinese city of Wuhan worked alongside the country’s military to combine the world’s most deadly viruses before the Covid pandemic began, it was claimed on Sunday.

According to investigators who examined intercepted communications and scientific research, Chinese scientists were running the secret project at the Wuhan Institute of Virology.

And another piece is revealed:
The newspaper said it had examined hundreds of documents, including confidential reports, internal memos, scientific papers and email correspondence and that the institute in Wuhan was engaged in increasingly risky experiments on coronaviruses it gathered from bat caves in southern China. ...

The Sunday Times said that the lab stopped making its findings public in 2016 after researchers discovered a new type of coronavirus in a mineshaft in Mojiang in Yunnan province where people had died from symptoms similar to Sars. The fatalities were not reported. ...

I made some fresh popcorn while we wait to see how this story develops. Want some?
:popcorn6
 
Did they have a test for COVID in Nov 2019 or earlier? What is needed is to see if they had pneumonia with ground-glass appearance on their Xrays. China might have saved specimens, or they could have been tested in the labs outside of Wuhan. Those labs identified a new coronavirus before the Chinese gov told them all to destroy the specimens and the data.

Wuhan scientists ‘created mutant virus before pandemic’


And another piece is revealed:


I made some fresh popcorn while we wait to see how this story develops. Want some?
:popcorn6

Being in the UK I read this. It contains nothing new. It shows the usual scientific incompetence of presumably humanities educated journalists e.g. they talk of extracting RNA from the spike protein. They make reference to no SARS like viruses having a furin cleavage site leading scientists to speculate this was introduced as part of gain of function research but fail to point out that furin cleavage sites have subsequently been identified in viruses from wild bats, and that more closely related viruses to SARS-CoV-2 have been identified from south China. That viruses with a higher affinity for human ACE2 have been subsequently identified so SARS-CoV-2 was not uniquely adapted to human ACE2. So a very one sided report with nothing new (at least to this thread). They also talk about mice with human lungs, when in fact the mice had a single gene modification so they expressed human rather than mouse ACE2 everything else remained mouse. No attempt to produce a balnced argument.
 
Did they have a test for COVID in Nov 2019 or earlier? What is needed is to see if they had pneumonia with ground-glass appearance on their Xrays. China might have saved specimens, or they could have been tested in the labs outside of Wuhan. Those labs identified a new coronavirus before the Chinese gov told them all to destroy the specimens and the data.

Wuhan scientists ‘created mutant virus before pandemic’


And another piece is revealed:


I made some fresh popcorn while we wait to see how this story develops. Want some?
:popcorn6

In that Torygraph article, it says....

The Sunday Times said that the lab stopped making its findings public in 2016 after researchers discovered a new type of coronavirus in a mineshaft in Mojiang in Yunnan province where people had died from symptoms similar to Sars. The fatalities were not reported.


In the Shellenberger article it says...

Hu and Yu researched the novel lineage of SARS-like viruses from which SARS-CoV-2 hails, and in 2019 coauthored a paper with Shi Zhengli that described SARS-like lineages they had studied over the years.

Obvious contradiction there. They stopped making their findings public in 2016, but published a paper of their findings in 2019? Huh???

Also, "fatalities i[n Mojiang mine] not reported"? This is flat-out false as we all know. Article from 2014...

Link

In June 2012, three men removing slag from a derelict copper mine in southwestern China fell ill with severe pneumonia and died. Six months later, researchers went spelunking in the mine—an artificial cave hewn from a hillside—in search of pathogens. After taking anal swabs from bats, rats, and musk shrews living in the cave, the team has discovered what it says is a new virus that may have felled the workers.


This is like Gelman Amnesia.

We read these articles that we can see are riddled with basic errors that are not even about specialist topics, but simply getting dates wrong or based on hearsay, and yet whenever the next article full of hearsay comes along, it's "Wow! ShOCKIng NeW RevELatIoNS!!1!"
 
Re the contradiction, it depends. China need not block all research going public. If you recall, Shi self-censored that 2019 research and had to disclose it after Bloom found the missing data in the cloud.

Not sure what you read @Planigale as you so infrequently post any citations!!! :rolleyes:

I've had a look at The Times UK on COVID but it's paywalled. It's clear however that they are conducting multiple ongoing investigative journalism pieces and it doesn't sound like they are finished.

Also, as far as contradictions, one would expect that if one were reporting on multiple papers from multiple sources. From the MSN news I cited in a post above:
... According to investigators who examined intercepted communications and scientific research, ...An investigation by The Sunday Times claimed that US investigators believe that one of the reasons why there is no published information on the work is because it was done in collaboration with researchers from the Chinese military.

The newspaper said it had examined hundreds of documents, including confidential reports, internal memos, scientific papers and email correspondence and that the institute in Wuhan was engaged in increasingly risky experiments on coronaviruses it gathered from bat caves in southern China.

A genetically engineered virus with researchers recombining whole viral segments from one virus into another was not evidenced by the initial COVYD 19. That is how involvement with the military was ruled out. I'd like to know if any of the uncovered emails discuss how to use serial passages instead.

I'd like to know the source of all this evidence The Times uncovered and if they received it all at once or piecemeal.

One of the biggest clues here that The Times has done legit investigating besides their excellent reputation (I checked) is that their reporting explains why, when we know the WIV had been collecting samples from the Yunnan miners, the mines and the surrounding caves for ~8 years, the data from those specimen collections has been missing with no explanation.

Paywalled or not I imagine more will be coming out in other non-paywalled sources in the days/weeks to come.

BTW, that would be the 20+K genomes taken offline that DRASTIC reported on.
 
Last edited:
Here are some lead-ins from The Times articles that I can't see the rest of. Most of the articles in my search of the paper were articles I didn't include below that were about the response in the UK to the pandemic.

These few popped up in my search going back to the end of April. I would like to see what is in these articles.

Live Q&A: What really went on at Wuhan lab weeks before Covid erupted?
Last weekend a major investigation by The Sunday Times Insight team into the origins of the Covid-19 pandemic revealed that scientists in Wuhan were working alongside the Chinese military …

Friday June 16 2023 | The Times

What really went on inside the Wuhan lab weeks before Covid erupted
Jonathan Calvert

… dangerous experiments, which caused a leak from the Wuhan Institute of Virology and started the Covid-19 outbreak.The US investigators say one of the reasons there is no published …

Saturday June 10 2023 | The Sunday Times

Don’t rule out theory Covid leaked from Wuhan lab, Chinese official says
Laurence Sleator

A former senior Chinese government scientist who helped lead the country’s pandemic response has said the possibility that Covid-19 leaked from a lab in Wuhan should not be …

Tuesday May 30 2023 | The Times

China releases Wuhan citizen journalist three years after Covid lockdown arrest
Didi Tang

A Chinese citizen journalist who was arrested for documenting the initial outbreak of the Covid pandemic three years ago has been released, but apparently on condition that he does not …

Wednesday May 3 2023 | The Times
That last one shows people that the scientists like Shi are not free to speak out and instead are motivated to deny any involvement the WIV had in the pandemic.
 
... Also, "fatalities i[n Mojiang mine] not reported"? This is flat-out false as we all know. Article from 2014...

Link

This is like Gelman Amnesia.

We read these articles that we can see are riddled with basic errors that are not even about specialist topics, but simply getting dates wrong or based on hearsay, and yet whenever the next article full of hearsay comes along, it's "Wow! ShOCKIng NeW RevELatIoNS!!1!"
So you are saying that in 2014 [20 MAR 2014] we knew what was false?

It was later reported those were not the viruses the miners had so I need a clarification.

It sounds like you are saying that the miners' deaths were not reported. Reported to whom, when? I'm confused what exactly you are saying is false. Obviously the local people knew the miners got sick and some died. Was there any analysis of the virus they had? All of that is in the two theses DRASTIC uncovered.

The Science article doesn't mention the theses. Maybe the authors were not aware of them.
 
Last edited:
So you are saying that in 2014 [20 MAR 2014] we knew what was false?

It was later reported those were not the viruses the miners had so I need a clarification.

It sounds like you are saying that the miners' deaths were not reported. Reported to whom, when? I'm confused what exactly you are saying is false. Obviously the local people knew the miners got sick and some died. Was there any analysis of the virus they had? All of that is in the two theses DRASTIC uncovered.

The Science article doesn't mention the theses. Maybe the authors were not aware of them.

Pretty sure the thesis hadn’t been written then. There is really no reason an MA thesis would be part of the reporting. It’s false that the fatalities had not been reported. Of course they had. But it is only now that they have gained more attention.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom