At this rate I'll never get back to the Huff book.
Factcheck, June 25, 2021: The Facts – and Gaps – on the Origin of the Coronavirus; By Jessica McDonald
Andersen doesn't agree:
Seems like what is and isn't GoF depends on people not wanting to say that is what they are doing. It is a pretty straightforward concept. Adding caveats doesn't belong in such a basic concept.
We know this:
Re the missing database:
Too much focus has been on RaTG13 which isn't that close to COVID 19. It's a convenient sidetrack for Shi. At this point the article goes on to describe all the evidence against a lab leak. Trouble is said evidence is all Shi saying so. The WHO team was denied access to things like the raw data supposedly showing none of the WIV staff had any COVID antibodies. And Shi claims no one at the lab had any illnesses, but this was during peak flu season.
Even more suspicious in my mind isn't the claim the RaTG13 is the closest Shi found or that some of the data was removed from her 2019 paper and returned, it's the bolded part below:
But Bloom did not find anything particularly close to COVID 19 in the data he retrieved from the cloud. But Bloom would have made note of that so it is again no smoking gun at this point.
Getting back to the article:
There are other possibilities explaining the facts here.
Distraction, I agree. But Shi having no reason to not report a virus closer to COVID than RaTG13, there are a couple reasons. When the paper was written in 2019 it's possible Shi and others were holding information back, either because they were selective about what they were disclosing on grant application progress reports, or there was a competitive reason to keep some research findings under wrap, or they knew they were now working with a very dangerous PPP and wanted that kept secret, or they actually had had a lab accident at that time and weren't sure if it had been contained or they knew it hadn't been but were covering up the earliest cases.
Bottom line, there are more explanations than claiming Shi had nothing to hide.
This is the reason, refined a bit from earlier explanations, about why the large genome database was taken offline:
An online database for internal use only? Yet that database had been accessible to researchers internationally. And a spreadsheet? No one who saw it before it disappeared in Sept 2019 described it as a spreadsheet. And this doesn't fit the separate incident of a number of genomes being removed from a published paper. That is what Bloom found in the cloud and which Shi gave him a satisfactory explanation for and updated the paper with the genome data returned.
Yes it is possible:
The article runs down the usual points, mainly a pandemic hasn't happened from a lab leak before, but it's certainly been an accident waiting to happen.
Then we get to this claim:
Here's the pdf
120 page WHO Report from early 2021
This is what it says about other wet markets:
I looked at this before and these "other markets" plural were never identified in this report. One relative of one of the cases not associated with the seafood market bought things at a different wet market.
Maybe one of you spillover enthusiasts would go through this WHO report again and find some evidence of "other markets" besides the one I mentioned.
The WHO report concludes:
Getting back to the factcheck article:
This is quite the exaggeration.
Of course a leading virologist is capable of hiding the role the WIV, herself and Daszak played in the pandemic. Since when have top scientists been immune to fraud and coverups?

That kind of willful blindness is just nuts.
And as for "hundreds of people", no, not necessarily. China is an authoritarian state. Two doctors who posted things to Weibo and to Promed were punished. One doctor is still under house arrest, the other one died of COVID. Just emailing a colleague could get one arrested.
And going by past experience with SARS, community leaders hid cases because they made their city look bad. They were caught and chastised because at that time China was trying to stop the spread.
Anyone who thinks China is just like any other modern country has no idea just how much of an authoritarian country it is.
Factcheck confirms the virus was not "engineered". That's been a given from early on. But serial passage in the lab can result in a virus that is indistinguishable from one that evolved in the wild.
This is bizarre:
No one would know how to do it?
Daszak said so in his own words on video, coronaviruses are easy to manipulate in the lab.
The Factcheck article spends the next number of paragraphs conflating "engineered" with manipulated with serial passages.
Not if the point was to find coronaviruses that might naturally evolve.
That is what Shi and Daszak were looking for. The whole point was to study versions that might turn up naturally so they could be prepared with vaccines ahead of a spillover. They weren't making bioweapons.
More shortsightedness even if these guys are virology experts. They don't know everything:
Just look at Baric's papers. He was using
human respiratory cells in the cultures, not just any old cell.
Again conflating "engineered":
No one is suggesting COVID was engineered.
And as for the 2009 H1N1v, it developed in a pig farm for heaven's sake, with humans in close contact with those pigs. Human flu virus and swine flu virus infect either a human or a pig at the same time and viola you get a recombinant flu virus. Yes it was well adapted to humans when it took off. Not to mention we have no idea how long it circulated in the human population of pig farmers before it spread beyond the town in Mexico it came from. The analogy fails.
The rest of the Factcheck article goes on with reasons the spillover source has not been found, all stuff already discussed here.