Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Oh look! This is a blurb from Michigan State University about his credentials.



Link

That fits with what EHA say they employed him for...



Link

And that fits his publication record as well.

In other words, the corroborating evidence suggests he was doing analysis on how pathogens affect food security, not working in the WIV on gain of function research and peering into Zhengli Shi's secret bat enclosures where they extracted SARS-like viruses and did serial passaging on them and/or where miners from the Mojiang mine were subject to ever-more potent viruses until they died and Zhengli Shi said, "Errmmm just a fungus!" etc...

Your comments make no sense. I haven't even posted what he had to say as a whistleblower and yet you are already certain there was nothing to it.
 
According to this Reddit thread...



Link

Apparently this comes from an Alex Jones episode (I wonder if Knowledge Fight have covered it?)...

The Twitter screenshot is of Huff saying he has one of the "biggest stories of 2023" but is sitting on it because it is unrelated to Covid.

Commenters be skeptical:


But hey... looks like you can watch Alex Jones interview Huff to get the full story...

https://banned.video/watch?id=638fb57c5aa67c07101b7456
Nothing I read yet said anything about a shootout with the CIA. If you don't mind I'll skip all the CT stuff. Take that crap to the other subforum.

I don't care to watch an Alex Jones interview. I'm perfectly capable of pulling corroborated facts out of the book. I have already noted the flaws in Huff's book.

Are you aware how defensive you sound. The evidence for a lab leak grows. The evidence for a spillover is stalled. Worobey's study is flawed, the finding of some genetic evidence from swabs at the market isn't holding up as significant after all.


As for a big story I imagine that's about the US involvement in the gain of function research. The grant applications support that role.
 
Last edited:
Nothing I read yet said anything about a shootout with the CIA. If you don't mind I'll skip all the CT stuff. Take that crap to the other subforum.


Andrew G Huff's credibility is a relevant topic of discussion within this particular thread of this particular subforum because one particular contributor to this thread has been citing Huff's allegations as though they were evidence for a lab leak origin of Covid-19.

At the end of October 2021, Dr Andrew G Huff appears to have written the following at substack.com:
Dr Andrew G Huff said:
My security situation continues to intensify. We identified high end or military surveillance drones over my property and tailing me. Validated by LEOs We are locked and loaded and ready to take on these *******. Stacking bodies is just another day at the office. @michstatepolice
Yeah, right.

While trying to understand Dr Huff's employment history, I found a zoominfo page, last updated 3/20/2023, that says
Andrew Huff has been working as a Assistant Professor Large Animal Clinical Sciences at Michigan State University for 7 years.​
An archived but undated MSU directory page identifies Andrew Huff as
Assistant Professor
Hospital Epidemiologist

Large Animal Clinical Services
Veterinary Medical Center​
I presume the March 2023 update to that zoominfo page is already outdated and that Dr Andrew Huff is no longer associated with MSU, because a search of MSU's current directory does not find Andrew Huff but does find a current directory web page for his co-author Emily Silver Huff, an Assistant Professor of Forestry.

In December 2016, Andrew G Huff was listed as "Primary Contact" and signed his name as "Applicant" when he, his co-author Jennifer Roberts, and four others applied for a 12-month, $24,600 research grant from the American Association of Bovine Practitioners Foundation.
Description of the Proposed Study: The purpose of this study is to determine the accuracy of veterinary diagnosis of calf scours to improve antimicrobial stewardship and to help prevent antimicrobial resistance in New England and the Great Lakes Area (Figure 1)....
That grant application included biographical sketches written by each of the six applicants. Andrew G Huff's biographical sketch stated his professional experience as follows:
2002 - 2010 U.S. Army
2011 - 2013 Research Fellow, University of Minnesota
2013 - 2014 Senior Member of Technical Staff, Sandia National Laboratories
2014 - 2016 Associate Vice President, EcoHealth Alliance
2014 - 2016 Adjunct Faculty, Columbia University, Ecology and Evolutionary Biology
2016 - Present Assistant Professor, Michigan State University, College of Veterinary Medicine
He listed 8 publications, largely the same as in the list cited earlier by angrysoba.

From that, I conclude that Huff was an an Associate Vice President at EcoHealth Alliance for two years, ending in 2016. His published research mostly concerns statistical assessment of risks to the US food industry from infections in livestock.

I see no reason to believe Dr Andrew G Huff has ever had access to inside information concerning the origins of Covid-19.

Jordan Schachtel's article of two weeks ago describes Dr Huff's career and rise to notoriety:
Jordan Schachtel said:
Prior to the covid hysteria era, Andrew Huff was an unknown media brand, living a quiet life in Michigan as a veterinary public health lecturer....

So how exactly did Andrew Huff transform from a complete unknown to one of the most influential voices for the lab leak theory in an incredibly short time period?

He did so by taking to social media and bringing attention to himself by advancing one series of deep state and international conspiracies after another, positioning himself as the heroic protagonist on a mission to uncover the truth against all odds....
 
This is the problem. What they have 'exposed' is nonsense. They have thrown lots of mud hoping some will stick.

[Spoiler tags just to shrink the size of the post, it's the whole post.]
Yes there are 'credentialed' scientists but none with relevant expertise. There publications are based on anonymous unsourced leaks or are just mud slinging and noise.

The death of miners from pneumonia in 2012 is irrelevant to SARS-CoV-2 years later. This is a classic description of a fungal pneumonia. Literally if you put this story in a medical exam the answer would fungal pneumonia. No virus was isolated, subsequent testing of blood samples showed no evidence of SARS or SARS-CoV-2 infection, the illness was not SARS-CoV-2 which would not cause a 30% mortality rate in young people. There would be no reason for Shi to conceal a pathogenic coronavirus years before the pandemic. To the contrary this would have made her career and brought in funding. The whole miners story was just irrelevant noise and mud slinging a responsible group would have realised it was irrelevant.

There were not 22,000 genomes in the WIV database. There were 22,000 entries, samples from bat anal swabs, bat blood samples, tics, guano; the vast majority of which would have had no virus, some of which would have had fragments of RNA, very few of which (about a dozen) were sufficient to obtain whole genome sequencing, and three of which had viable (cultural) virus. A database with 22,000 entries does not mean 22,000 full gene sequences. Claiming this is just untrue. It is mud slinging. The database was set up in June 2019, briefly shut down for maintenance in September 2019, and shut down in february 2020. There is no evidence it was meant to be anything other than an internal laboratory resource, nor that it was ever intended to be publicly accessible. Most laboratories will have internal databases of work they are doing, but these will not be intended for public access, when sequences are ready for publication they are uploaded to public databases. There is immense sensitivity to middle income country researchers collecting data then it being swept up by better resourced researchers from the west and published with minimal recognition of those who collected the and originated the data. WIV cannot give people access to a database of 22,000 gene sequences because it is a fantasy database, people cannot have access to what does not exist.

The allegation that there were bat colonies at WIV is unsubstantiated, other than by an anonymous leak and video of a different laboratory.

The alleged gain of function research at WIV was not gain of function research* and could not have led to SARS-CoV-2. What they mainly do is argue that gain of function research is a bad thing, WIV might have done gain of function research, a pandemic is a bad thing. The pandemic stared in Wuhan therefore gain of function research at WIV was the cause. Or in another document that the development of a LAV SARS virus in the US was tested in Wuhan and somehow changed into SARS-CoV-2. Again an impossible event.

None of what DRASTIc argues might have happened could have led to SARS-CoV-2, it is just scientifically impossible. They just produce lots of innuendo and irrelevancy.


* https://www.factcheck.org/2021/05/the-wuhan-lab-and-the-gain-of-function-disagreement/

No reason for Shi to hide the fact if true that a virus leaked from their lab and caused a worldwide pandemic killing millions? You can't be serious.

I've already addressed your "scientifically impossible" nonsense.

Shi and her researchers were collecting specimens from bats and other animals since the 2003 SARS epidemic. Why would you think they put no genome database online until 2019? Where do you think all that data is?

There's no way to address your denials of any and everything with no evidence supporting your denials.

I can address your link, it's not a bad summary, you should read it.
“Because we don’t know the details for either of these scenarios, it’s not possible to say whether a hypothetical lab accident would have involved a virus exactly identical to that isolated in nature, or one that had been grown or somehow modestly manipulated in a lab.

This is what has been posted in the thread, you should read it.
The European Union made a similar statement. Both came in response to the release of a report by an international team convened by the World Health Organization. That report said a laboratory leak of a virus, involving “an accidental infection of staff,” was “an extremely unlikely pathway,” but the WHO director-general said that he didn’t believe the evaluation “was extensive enough.”
It was thoroughly covered in this thread that Daszak misled scientists into signing a letter to the Lancet that it was a spillover. Some of those scientists have since withdrawn their names from the letter, also documented in the thread.
WHO Director-General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus said the day the report was publicly released on March 30. “Let me say clearly that as far as WHO is concerned all hypotheses remain on the table.”

You should look into Daszak's clear attempt to steer investigators away from a lab leak. He also stands to be blamed if the lab leak is confirmed.

Rand Paul, of course has made it his mission to show Fauci's involvement. Also from your link and also covered in the thread.
Fauci responded that “the NIH has not ever and does not now fund gain-of-function research in the Wuhan Institute of Virology.”
That was a hasty reply given NIH funding has a long history of funding GoF research. He's already tried to fudge a bit, claiming it would be a spillover if a researcher got infected collecting specimens.
The answer to the question of whether it did or didn’t depends on whom you ask and their definition of gain-of-function.
No it doesn't. That was Fauci trying to gaslight the country.

Paul is an idiot, of course, focusing on Fauci while missing the bigger picture. And Tucker Carlson also glommed onto the lab hypothesis because scandal is what he sells.

We covered this in the thread:
... former New York Times science writer Nicholas Wade... wrote about “two main theories” of SARS-Co-V-2’s origin: “One is that it jumped naturally from wildlife to people. The other is that the virus was under study in a lab, from which it escaped.” Wade asserted that the “clues point in a specific direction” — a lab-leak. But he said at the outset: “It’s important to note that so far there is no direct evidence for either theory. Each depends on a set of reasonable conjectures but so far lacks proof.”

Wade's reporting was reasonable but IIRC @angrysoba dismissed anything Wade had to say.

It's becoming a tiring schtick in this thread discrediting the sources while ignoring the evidence.
More from your factcheck link:
In 2014, the U.S. government put a pause on new funding of gain-of-function research, which it defined this way: “With an ultimate goal of better understanding disease pathways, gain-of-function studies aim to increase the ability of infectious agents to cause disease by enhancing its pathogenicity or by increasing its transmissibility.” A 2016 paper on the ethics of gain-of-function research said: “The ultimate objective of such research is to better inform public health and preparedness efforts and/or development of medical countermeasures.”
Interesting given Fauci denied the NIH ever funded GoF research.


“Specifically, the funding pause will apply to gain-of-function research projects that may be reasonably anticipated to confer attributes to influenza, MERS, or SARS viruses such that the virus would have enhanced pathogenicity and/or transmissibility in mammals via the respiratory route,” the White House said in an Oct. 17, 2014, announcement.
On Dec. 19, 2017, the U.S. government’s pause, or moratorium, was lifted. ...

This is weird:
“EcoHealth Alliance has not nor does it plan to engage in gain-of-function research,” EcoHealth spokesman Robert Kessler told us in an email. Nor did the grant get an exception from the pause, as some have speculated, he said. “No dispensation was needed as no gain-of-function research was being conducted.”
Because I'm pretty sure the grant proposals contradict this, and that certain projects which were already in progress that involved GoF research were excepted from the ban. I'll have to go dig up that information which was posted in this thread.

Oh wait, this explains the discrepancy:
We didn't do it:
The NIAID told the Wall Street Journal: “The research by EcoHealth Alliance, Inc. that NIH funded was for a project that aimed to characterize at the molecular level the function of newly discovered bat spike proteins and naturally occurring pathogens. Molecular characterization examines functions of an organism at the molecular level, in this case a virus and a spike protein, without affecting the environment or development or physiological state of the organism. At no time did NIAID fund gain-of-function research to be conducted at WIV.”

And in a May 19 statement, NIH Director Dr. Francis Collins said that “neither NIH nor NIAID have ever approved any grant that would have supported ‘gain-of-function’ research on coronaviruses that would have increased their transmissibility or lethality for humans.”

Yes they did:
Richard Ebright, a professor of chemistry and chemical biology at Rutgers University and a critic of gain-of-function research, told the Washington Post that the EcoHealth/Wuhan lab research “was — unequivocally — gain-of-function research.” He said it “met the definition for gain-of-function research of concern under the 2014 Pause.” That definition, as we said, pertained to “projects that may be reasonably anticipated to confer attributes to influenza, MERS, or SARS viruses such that the virus would have enhanced pathogenicity and/or transmissibility in mammals via the respiratory route.”

Then we get to the meat of the matter:
Alina Chan, a molecular biologist and postdoctoral researcher at the Broad Institute of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and Harvard, said in a lengthy Twitter thread that the Wuhan subgrant wouldn’t fall under the gain-of-function moratorium because the definition didn’t include testing on naturally occurring viruses “unless the tests are reasonably anticipated to increase transmissibility and/or pathogenicity.” She said the moratorium had “no teeth.” But the EcoHealth/Wuhan grant “was testing naturally occurring SARS viruses, without a reasonable expectation that the tests would increase transmissibility or pathogenicity. Therefore, it is reasonable that they would have been excluded from the moratorium.”

Chan, who has published research about the possibility of an accidental lab leak of the virus, also said: “But we need to separate this fight about whether a particular project is GOF vs whether it has risk of lab accident + causing an outbreak.”

The link goes on to discuss the issue further. Then we get to this:
A 2015 paper by Baric, Shi and others, published with NIH funding in the journal Nature Medicine, examined the potential of SARS-like bat coronaviruses to lead to human disease. Researchers created a “chimeric virus” with the spike protein of the bat coronavirus and a mouse-adapted SARS backbone and found viruses could replicate in human airway cells. The study said “the creation of chimeric viruses … was not expected to increase pathogenicity.”

Fauci told Paul at the hearing: “Dr. Baric does not do gain-of-function research, and if it is, it’s according to the guidelines and it is being conducted in North Carolina, not in China.”

But it was GoF, even Baric said so. He said however they were using low pathogenic coronaviruses when they created chimeric viruses in the lab capable of infecting human airway cells.


The link ends there but what happened next has been documented in this thread: Shi took the humanized mice and the knowledge of how to reverse-engineer certain genomes or genetic segments back to the WIV. From there her and Baric stopped communicating.


The link then refers readers to the June 2021 factcheck on the origin of COVID

https://www.factcheck.org/2021/06/scicheck-the-facts-and-gaps-on-the-origin-of-the-coronavirus/

So I'll look into that in the next post.

It's odd @Planigale that you would cite a factcheck link that contradicts your claims.
 
Last edited:
Why would any scientist make publicly available their preliminary research findings? You keep private your ideas and preliminary research so it does not get stolen by other groups. Scence is competitive. You do not make your data publicly available until it is ready for publication.

You need to understand WIV had no virus that could be modified to make SARS-CoV-2. If you cannot understand the science it is not worth further discussion. WIV could not have created SARS-CoV-2 from any existing virus isolates they are all too distantly related. Identified viruses were as distantly related to SARS-CoV-2 as Homo sapiens is from Pan spp.

There is no clear definition of gain of function research. The research carried out at WIV would not meet most definitions of gain of function research. But as they had access to no precursor virus to SARS-CoV-2 it is irrelevant whether they did gain of function research. There is no way that SARS-CoV-2 could have been created at WIV, even with gain of function research. DRASTIC aren't giving out facts they are giving out propaganda.

All their data is old, I think it is telling that they have essentially gone silent. No recent research supports the laboratory leak theory.

It is clearly not wrong to have asked the question, could COVID-19 have originated from a laboratory leak?. But current data suggests this was impossible. Only racist Reds under the Beds bloggers pursue this. Literally to argue the case you have to start with a massive conspiracy and argue that witnesses are lying because their was a laboratory leak. if you don't prejudge the question and assume there was a laboratory leak there is no need to assume they are lying.
 
Last edited:
Nothing I read yet said anything about a shootout with the CIA. If you don't mind I'll skip all the CT stuff. Take that crap to the other subforum.

I don't care to watch an Alex Jones interview. I'm perfectly capable of pulling corroborated facts out of the book. I have already noted the flaws in Huff's book.

Are you aware how defensive you sound. The evidence for a lab leak grows. The evidence for a spillover is stalled. Worobey's study is flawed, the finding of some genetic evidence from swabs at the market isn't holding up as significant after all.


As for a big story I imagine that's about the US involvement in the gain of function research. The grant applications support that role.

The issue is that yet again we have an argument by innuendo from a dubious source.

As WD Clinger says, the credibility of a source matters. Your idea of what counts as “corroboration” is also suspect because we all know that people have been claiming “lab leak!” for a couple of years now. If Huff turns up a couple of years into this and says “I worked for EHA and I also say lab leak!” that is not “corroboration”. It’s even less so when you consider that he was gone by 2016 and we still don’t know the circumstances under which he left (you say he says he was a pain in the ass, but that could just mean he was obnoxious or incompetent. Was he even fired? In the Alex Jones interview he says he “left”.)

And it’s not my fault that he is talking to Alex Jones. This is YOUR source remember. If he is chatting to Alex Jones then why should I put that in the CT sub-forum? This is like saying that Major General Stubblebein (sp?) was an impeccable source but any interviews he had with Alex Jones belong in the CT section.
 
At this rate I'll never get back to the Huff book.

Factcheck, June 25, 2021: The Facts – and Gaps – on the Origin of the Coronavirus; By Jessica McDonald
Jesse Bloom, a computational biologist who studies viruses at the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center and the lead author of the letter in Science calling for a more rigorous investigation, told us in an email that he found natural zoonosis and lab accident scenarios involving a researcher being infected with a “natural collected virus” or “experimenting on and possibly growing or modestly modifying a naturally collected virus” all plausible.

“I don’t think there is sufficient evidence to estimate relative probabilities for these scenarios,” he said.


Andersen doesn't agree:
“[W]hile both lab and natural scenarios are possible, they are not equally likely — precedence, data and other evidence strongly favor natural emergence as a highly likely scientific theory for the emergence of SARS-CoV-2, while the lab leak remains a speculative hypothesis based on conjecture,” Kristian G. Andersen, a professor of immunology and microbiology at Scripps Research, told the New York Times.


Seems like what is and isn't GoF depends on people not wanting to say that is what they are doing. It is a pretty straightforward concept. Adding caveats doesn't belong in such a basic concept.
The [WIV] lab has made chimeric viruses that mix and match different elements to better understand what’s required to infect human cells — which some people consider to be gain-of-function experiments, although Shi does not. As we’ve written, there is no single definition of gain-of-function, but in this context it typically refers to modifications that aim to make a virus more dangerous or infectious to study potential disease pathways.


We know this:
Shi told Science that some of her coronavirus research was conducted at biosafety level 2 (BSL-2) — a basic lab safety level that some say is inadequate; this information has also been publicly available in the methods sections of published papers.


Re the missing database:
Fueling suspicions about the WIV is the institute’s removal of its online database of samples and virus sequences in September 2019 and news of a U.S. intelligence report that three WIV researchers fell ill and sought care in a hospital in November 2019.

Too much focus has been on RaTG13 which isn't that close to COVID 19. It's a convenient sidetrack for Shi. At this point the article goes on to describe all the evidence against a lab leak. Trouble is said evidence is all Shi saying so. The WHO team was denied access to things like the raw data supposedly showing none of the WIV staff had any COVID antibodies. And Shi claims no one at the lab had any illnesses, but this was during peak flu season.


Even more suspicious in my mind isn't the claim the RaTG13 is the closest Shi found or that some of the data was removed from her 2019 paper and returned, it's the bolded part below:
A bat sample collected at the mine, which is located in southwestern China about 1,000 miles from Wuhan, in 2013 ended up producing RaTG13, a partial sequence of which made it into a publication in 2016 under a different name. In a November addendum to her 2020 paper describing RaTG13, Shi reported she had collected eight other SARS-related coronaviruses from the mine, which she described in a preprint posted on May 21. All of those viruses are nearly the same and are only a 77.6% match to SARS-CoV-2, falling on a separate branch of the viral family tree than both SARS-CoV-1, the virus that caused the first coronavirus epidemic, and SARS-CoV-2.

But Bloom did not find anything particularly close to COVID 19 in the data he retrieved from the cloud. But Bloom would have made note of that so it is again no smoking gun at this point.


Getting back to the article:
Nothing about the mine story seems abnormal, Garry said, calling it a “distraction.” He added that there would have been no reason for Shi not to report identification of a virus more similar to SARS-CoV-2 than RaTG13 if she had found one.

“We wouldn’t be having this conversation because she would have known which animal or species of bat it came from. And the natural origin would be solved,” he said.
There are other possibilities explaining the facts here.

Distraction, I agree. But Shi having no reason to not report a virus closer to COVID than RaTG13, there are a couple reasons. When the paper was written in 2019 it's possible Shi and others were holding information back, either because they were selective about what they were disclosing on grant application progress reports, or there was a competitive reason to keep some research findings under wrap, or they knew they were now working with a very dangerous PPP and wanted that kept secret, or they actually had had a lab accident at that time and weren't sure if it had been contained or they knew it hadn't been but were covering up the earliest cases.

Bottom line, there are more explanations than claiming Shi had nothing to hide.


This is the reason, refined a bit from earlier explanations, about why the large genome database was taken offline:
As for the missing database, WIV told the WHO team that there had been an online spreadsheet of samples for internal use and there had been plans to make an interactive system, but because of more than 3,000 cyberattacks the data was kept offline.
An online database for internal use only? Yet that database had been accessible to researchers internationally. And a spreadsheet? No one who saw it before it disappeared in Sept 2019 described it as a spreadsheet. And this doesn't fit the separate incident of a number of genomes being removed from a published paper. That is what Bloom found in the cloud and which Shi gave him a satisfactory explanation for and updated the paper with the genome data returned.


Yes it is possible:
It’s possible, of course, that the Chinese are lying about the database, negative coronavirus test results of WIV staff and that WIV or another facility had SARS-CoV-2 or its precursor in one of its labs.
The article runs down the usual points, mainly a pandemic hasn't happened from a lab leak before, but it's certainly been an accident waiting to happen.


Then we get to this claim:
Garry, the Tulane virologist, also noted the past examples of natural spillovers, including SARS; the fact that the first four known COVID-19 cases in Wuhan had links to different wet markets, as shown in the WHO report — and no sign that Shi’s lab had any virus close to SARS-CoV-2.

Here's the pdf 120 page WHO Report from early 2021

This is what it says about other wet markets:
Many of the early cases were associated with the Huanan market, but a similar number of cases were associated with other markets and some were not associated with any markets. ...
I looked at this before and these "other markets" plural were never identified in this report. One relative of one of the cases not associated with the seafood market bought things at a different wet market.

Maybe one of you spillover enthusiasts would go through this WHO report again and find some evidence of "other markets" besides the one I mentioned. The WHO report concludes:
No firm conclusion therefore about the role of the Huanan market in the origin of the outbreak, or how the infection was introduced into the market, can currently be drawn.


Getting back to the factcheck article:
Garry said. “You have to think one of the leading virologists on the planet is part of a major conspiracy that is involving hundreds of people.”
This is quite the exaggeration.

Of course a leading virologist is capable of hiding the role the WIV, herself and Daszak played in the pandemic. Since when have top scientists been immune to fraud and coverups? :rolleyes: That kind of willful blindness is just nuts.

And as for "hundreds of people", no, not necessarily. China is an authoritarian state. Two doctors who posted things to Weibo and to Promed were punished. One doctor is still under house arrest, the other one died of COVID. Just emailing a colleague could get one arrested.

And going by past experience with SARS, community leaders hid cases because they made their city look bad. They were caught and chastised because at that time China was trying to stop the spread.

Anyone who thinks China is just like any other modern country has no idea just how much of an authoritarian country it is.

Factcheck confirms the virus was not "engineered". That's been a given from early on. But serial passage in the lab can result in a virus that is indistinguishable from one that evolved in the wild.


This is bizarre:
Even if scientists used methods that would not leave a trace of manipulation, as some lab leak proponents have suggested, that would still leave the arguably insurmountable problem of not knowing enough to create the virus.

“No one would know how to do it,” Perlman said. “If one doesn’t have the virus in hand, how do you decide to make this?”
No one would know how to do it? :rolleyes: Daszak said so in his own words on video, coronaviruses are easy to manipulate in the lab.
The Factcheck article spends the next number of paragraphs conflating "engineered" with manipulated with serial passages.
Any scientist wanting to add a furin cleavage site “would just plop it in nice and clean,”
Not if the point was to find coronaviruses that might naturally evolve. That is what Shi and Daszak were looking for. The whole point was to study versions that might turn up naturally so they could be prepared with vaccines ahead of a spillover. They weren't making bioweapons. :rolleyes:


More shortsightedness even if these guys are virology experts. They don't know everything:
But Perlman, who has done experiments passaging coronaviruses in mice, said that would not work. “Most of the time when you take viruses and pass them in tissue culture cells, you get cells that grow very well in tissue culture cells and nowhere else,” he said. And humanized mice are still mostly mice, he said, so the virus would adapt to growing better in mice, not humans.
Just look at Baric's papers. He was using human respiratory cells in the cultures, not just any old cell.


Again conflating "engineered":
The H1N1 swine flu pandemic in 2009, for example, he said, was very well adapted to humans and took off very easily and very quickly. “It is not a sign that they were bioengineered,” Boni said.
No one is suggesting COVID was engineered.

And as for the 2009 H1N1v, it developed in a pig farm for heaven's sake, with humans in close contact with those pigs. Human flu virus and swine flu virus infect either a human or a pig at the same time and viola you get a recombinant flu virus. Yes it was well adapted to humans when it took off. Not to mention we have no idea how long it circulated in the human population of pig farmers before it spread beyond the town in Mexico it came from. The analogy fails.


The rest of the Factcheck article goes on with reasons the spillover source has not been found, all stuff already discussed here.
 
Why do people use the word “gaslight” when they mean to say “lie”. You are claiming that Fauci was straight-up lying about GoF.
I get tired of writing lie. Fauci claimed GoF meant something else and the NIH wasn't funding that research.

It's a lie because Fauci probably knew better. It's gaslighting if he wants us to believe the NIH was funding something else.
 
The issue is that yet again we have an argument by innuendo from a dubious source.

As WD Clinger says, the credibility of a source matters. Your idea of what counts as “corroboration” is also suspect because we all know that people have been claiming “lab leak!” for a couple of years now. If Huff turns up a couple of years into this and says “I worked for EHA and I also say lab leak!” that is not “corroboration”. It’s even less so when you consider that he was gone by 2016 and we still don’t know the circumstances under which he left (you say he says he was a pain in the ass, but that could just mean he was obnoxious or incompetent. Was he even fired? In the Alex Jones interview he says he “left”.)

And it’s not my fault that he is talking to Alex Jones. This is YOUR source remember. If he is chatting to Alex Jones then why should I put that in the CT sub-forum? This is like saying that Major General Stubblebein (sp?) was an impeccable source but any interviews he had with Alex Jones belong in the CT section.
I'm not replying to anymore of this until I actually post what is in Huff's book. You are imagining what I will post I guess, but you certainly aren't addressing anything I have posted.
 
Why would any scientist make publicly available their preliminary research findings?
WTF are you even talking about? No one said Shi published preliminary findings.

Either go read what actually happened or stop wasting everyone's time!


You need to understand WIV had no virus that could be modified to make SARS-CoV-2. If you cannot understand the science it is not worth further discussion. WIV could not have created SARS-CoV-2 from any existing virus isolates they are all too distantly related. Identified viruses were as distantly related to SARS-CoV-2 as Homo sapiens is from Pan spp.
:id:


There is no clear definition of gain of function research. The research carried out at WIV would not meet most definitions of gain of function research. But as they had access to no precursor virus to SARS-CoV-2 it is irrelevant whether they did gain of function research. There is no way that SARS-CoV-2 could have been created at WIV, even with gain of function research. DRASTIC aren't giving out facts they are giving out propaganda.
You don't know this either.

[snipped the rest, already addressed.]
 
Too much focus has been on RaTG13 which isn't that close to COVID 19.

The only people focusing on RaTG13 are the lab leakers. It was seen as exhibit A for why they must have caused the pandemic. The suggestions have varied from RaTG13 being close enough to change into SARS-CoV2 or that if it is that close they probably have some even closer. Probably the miners had it, etc...

It's a convenient sidetrack for Shi.


Jesus! Shi wasn't the one banging on about it. You guys were! The Lab Leakers, remember! This is what is frustrating to me. You constantly spin narratives which heavily imply guilt. It is "convenient" for Shi that DRASTIC focused on RaTG13 is it? The "smug" Daszak tried to hide his "role in the outbreak".
 
So as I'm investigating Huff for myself a question came to me.

How did this guy get his PhD, enlist in the military, publish papers and work for EHA for at least a couple years, getting to the position of VP if he was such a flakey CTer?

I don't disagree he has CT issues and has lost his way at some point and I have said so. But he's no Alex Jones or Glenn Beck. And crazy or not I see no reason to dismiss everything he has to say without looking at it.

That's all for now. :)
 
So as I'm investigating Huff for myself a question came to me.

How did this guy get his PhD, enlist in the military, publish papers and work for EHA for at least a couple years, getting to the position of VP if he was such a flakey CTer?


His progression toward flakey CTer is easier to understand if you get those events in the correct order:

2002 - 2010 U.S. Army
2011 - 2013 Research Fellow, University of Minnesota (ETA: BA 2010, MS 2011, PhD 2014)
2013 - 2014 Senior Member of Technical Staff, Sandia National Laboratories
2014 - 2016 Associate Vice President, EcoHealth Alliance
2014 - 2016 Adjunct Faculty, Columbia University, Ecology and Evolutionary Biology
2016 - Present Assistant Professor, Michigan State University, College of Veterinary Medicine


Note also that during the last six of his seven years as an assistant professor at MSU, he published a grand total of one paper.

Scientists reading this thread will be aware that, at most major universities in the US, a position as "assistant professor" is generally term limited. After a certain period of time, usually seven years, you get promoted or booted.

Some people have a hard time dealing with involuntary retirement.
 
Last edited:
At this rate I'll never get back to the Huff book.

Factcheck, June 25, 2021: The Facts – and Gaps – on the Origin of the Coronavirus; By Jessica McDonald



Andersen doesn't agree:



Seems like what is and isn't GoF depends on people not wanting to say that is what they are doing. It is a pretty straightforward concept. Adding caveats doesn't belong in such a basic concept.



We know this:



Re the missing database:


Too much focus has been on RaTG13 which isn't that close to COVID 19. It's a convenient sidetrack for Shi. At this point the article goes on to describe all the evidence against a lab leak. Trouble is said evidence is all Shi saying so. The WHO team was denied access to things like the raw data supposedly showing none of the WIV staff had any COVID antibodies. And Shi claims no one at the lab had any illnesses, but this was during peak flu season.


Even more suspicious in my mind isn't the claim the RaTG13 is the closest Shi found or that some of the data was removed from her 2019 paper and returned, it's the bolded part below:


But Bloom did not find anything particularly close to COVID 19 in the data he retrieved from the cloud. But Bloom would have made note of that so it is again no smoking gun at this point.


Getting back to the article:
There are other possibilities explaining the facts here.

Distraction, I agree. But Shi having no reason to not report a virus closer to COVID than RaTG13, there are a couple reasons. When the paper was written in 2019 it's possible Shi and others were holding information back, either because they were selective about what they were disclosing on grant application progress reports, or there was a competitive reason to keep some research findings under wrap, or they knew they were now working with a very dangerous PPP and wanted that kept secret, or they actually had had a lab accident at that time and weren't sure if it had been contained or they knew it hadn't been but were covering up the earliest cases.

Bottom line, there are more explanations than claiming Shi had nothing to hide.


This is the reason, refined a bit from earlier explanations, about why the large genome database was taken offline:
An online database for internal use only? Yet that database had been accessible to researchers internationally. And a spreadsheet? No one who saw it before it disappeared in Sept 2019 described it as a spreadsheet. And this doesn't fit the separate incident of a number of genomes being removed from a published paper. That is what Bloom found in the cloud and which Shi gave him a satisfactory explanation for and updated the paper with the genome data returned.


Yes it is possible:
The article runs down the usual points, mainly a pandemic hasn't happened from a lab leak before, but it's certainly been an accident waiting to happen.


Then we get to this claim:


Here's the pdf 120 page WHO Report from early 2021

This is what it says about other wet markets:

I looked at this before and these "other markets" plural were never identified in this report. One relative of one of the cases not associated with the seafood market bought things at a different wet market.

Maybe one of you spillover enthusiasts would go through this WHO report again and find some evidence of "other markets" besides the one I mentioned. The WHO report concludes:



Getting back to the factcheck article:
This is quite the exaggeration.

Of course a leading virologist is capable of hiding the role the WIV, herself and Daszak played in the pandemic. Since when have top scientists been immune to fraud and coverups? :rolleyes: That kind of willful blindness is just nuts.

And as for "hundreds of people", no, not necessarily. China is an authoritarian state. Two doctors who posted things to Weibo and to Promed were punished. One doctor is still under house arrest, the other one died of COVID. Just emailing a colleague could get one arrested.

And going by past experience with SARS, community leaders hid cases because they made their city look bad. They were caught and chastised because at that time China was trying to stop the spread.

Anyone who thinks China is just like any other modern country has no idea just how much of an authoritarian country it is.

Factcheck confirms the virus was not "engineered". That's been a given from early on. But serial passage in the lab can result in a virus that is indistinguishable from one that evolved in the wild.


This is bizarre:
No one would know how to do it? :rolleyes: Daszak said so in his own words on video, coronaviruses are easy to manipulate in the lab.
The Factcheck article spends the next number of paragraphs conflating "engineered" with manipulated with serial passages.
Not if the point was to find coronaviruses that might naturally evolve. That is what Shi and Daszak were looking for. The whole point was to study versions that might turn up naturally so they could be prepared with vaccines ahead of a spillover. They weren't making bioweapons. :rolleyes:


More shortsightedness even if these guys are virology experts. They don't know everything:
Just look at Baric's papers. He was using human respiratory cells in the cultures, not just any old cell.


Again conflating "engineered":
No one is suggesting COVID was engineered.

And as for the 2009 H1N1v, it developed in a pig farm for heaven's sake, with humans in close contact with those pigs. Human flu virus and swine flu virus infect either a human or a pig at the same time and viola you get a recombinant flu virus. Yes it was well adapted to humans when it took off. Not to mention we have no idea how long it circulated in the human population of pig farmers before it spread beyond the town in Mexico it came from. The analogy fails.


The rest of the Factcheck article goes on with reasons the spillover source has not been found, all stuff already discussed here.

The 'deleted' sequences are nothing to do with Shi or WIV. They are partial sequences.

https://academic.oup.com/mbe/article/38/12/5211/6353034

This is why people are reluctant to publish gene sequencing they have done; a US scientist sweeps in does analysis on the sequences publishes a paper but the workers who did the research and work to collect and sequence the data are not co-authors. this is why the WIV database would not be publicly available. I think publication is probably justified but the publication is problematic.

Consideration has been given to multiple entries at more than one market.

https://virological.org/t/early-app...-suggests-sars-cov-2-has-a-natural-origin/691

This of course favours a natural cross over event rather than a laboratory leak origin.
 
Oh look, you found a paper already posted in the thread about the data Bloom found in the cloud. That's a good start.

I wrongly attributed the paper to Shi when it was Wang. He's up there in management at the CCDC along with Gao.

From Bloom's paper:
However, about a month after I publicly posted this manuscript to bioRxiv as a preprint, the deleted sequence data were discussed in a July 21, 2021, press conference by the vice minister of China’s National Health Commission and subsequently in two blog posts by a China state-affiliated reporter (Wang 2021a, 2021b). The press conference and blog posts stated that the sequence data were removed from the SRA because the journal Small had mistakenly deleted the data availability statement in the paper of Wang et al. (2020), leading the authors to think that they should also delete the actual data. Confusingly, this explanation is inconsistent with the reason provided by the authors to the SRA (fig. 6), and I am unable to reconcile the discrepancy. The press conference and blog posts also stated that the sequences were all collected on or after January 30, 2020, rather than “early in the epidemic” as originally described in Wang et al. (2020). Finally, the press conference and blog noted that on July 8, 2021, the deleted data were made available on the Chinese NGDC database under accession PRJCA005725.
I've been trying to tell you this but you apparently aren't reading my posts either or you would know this is not new information in the thread.


Notice also that those earliest genomes are still missing the key demographic information needed to know where they were infected.

Detection of SARS-CoV-2 in Different Types of Clinical Specimens
The limitations of this study include that some patients did not have detailed clinical information available, so the data could not be correlated with symptoms or disease course and that the number of some types of samples was small. Further investigation of patients with detailed temporal and symptom data and consecutively collected specimens from different sites is warranted.


Also those are not likely to have been the earliest cases. Here's more from Bloom's paper:
Understanding the spread of SARS-CoV-2 in Wuhan is crucial to tracing the origins of the virus, including identifying events that led to infection of patient zero. The first reports outside of China at the end of December 2019 emphasized the role of the Huanan Seafood Market (ProMED 2019), which was initially suggested as a site of zoonosis. However, this theory became increasingly tenuous as it was learned that many early cases had no connection to the market (Cohen 2020; Huang et al. 2020; Chen et al. 2020). Eventually, Chinese CDC Director Gao Fu dismissed the theory, stating “At first, we assumed the seafood market might have the virus, but now the market is more like a victim. The novel coronavirus had existed long before” (Global Times 2020).

Indeed, there were reports of cases that far preceded the outbreak at the Huanan Seafood Market. The Lancet described a confirmed case having no association with the market whose symptoms began on December 1, 2019 (Huang et al. 2020). The South China Morning Post described nine cases from November 2019 including details on patient age and sex, noting that none were confirmed to be “patient zero” (Ma 2020). Professor Yu Chuanhua of Wuhan University told the Health Times that records he reviewed showed two cases in mid-November, and one suspected case on September 29 (Health Times 2020). At about the same time as Professor Chuanhua’s interview, the Chinese CDC issued an order forbidding sharing of information about the COVID-19 epidemic without approval (China CDC 2020), and shortly thereafter Professor Chuanhua recontacted the Health Times to say that the November cases could not be confirmed (Health Times 2020). Then, China’s State Council issued a much broader order requiring central approval of all publications related to COVID-19 to ensure they were coordinated “like moves in a game of chess” (Kang, Cheng, et al. 2020). In 2021, the joint WHO-China report dismissed all reported cases prior to December 8 as not COVID-19, reviving the theory that the virus might have originated at the Huanan Seafood Market (WHO 2021).
Retracted as not really proven cases when the Chinese government said to shut up.. :rolleyes:


But none of this gets you closer to understanding this was not the large database taken offline in Sept 2019. Maybe you should look into that.
 
From the DRASTIC publication.

version 2 released in June 2019, went in active for a week during the second half of August19, before becoming definitely inaccessible (out of the WIV at least) on the 12th Sep It was online intermittently after this date from mid-December 2019, and occasionally until February 2020, but was not accessed from outside ofthe WIV after 12 September2019.

So the database from being set up was not publicly accessible. This was an internal database.

There are estimated to be atl east 100 unpublished sequences of bat betacoronaviruses in Batvirus.whiov.ac.cn, which urgently need to be accessed byi nternational scientists in order to investigate the origins of SARS-CoV-2

So even DRASTIC only claim a hundred sequences (how they come to that number is unclear) and some of those are actually published sequences. Not thousands. It is unlikely that any of these would actually be helpful in defining the origin of SARS-CoV-2 as the closely related wild viruses are not found where WIV collected samples. The only way that it could elucidate the origin is if you start off with the assumption that the WIV had a viable precursor virus (unlikely) and that Shi was lying when she said there were no closely related viruses in the database.

https://zenodo.org/record/4512260#.ZGM1oi8w3VM
 
So apparently there is a Covid conference going on right now and Zhengli Shi spoke there.

Link

A lab leaker tried to do some Covid Truth by sharing lab origin ideas on Ebola and Covid-19.

This is the theory that Latham and Wilson (two actual virologists!) proposed:

We suggest, first, that inside the miners RaTG13 (or a very similar virus) evolved into SARS-CoV-2, an unusually pathogenic coronavirus highly adapted to humans. Second, that the Shi lab used medical samples taken from the miners and sent to them by Kunming University Hospital for their research. It was this human-adapted virus, now known as SARS-CoV-2*, that escaped from the WIV in 2019.

Link

This theory was taken seriously by Skeptic Ginger, and still sort of is, because of the lingering accusations that Zhengli-shi was lying about the fungal infection. And yet, Skeptic Ginger also claims that RaTG13 is a "convenient" distraction for Zhengli-Shi.

Chan and Ridley also put a lot of stock in RaTG13, even though all these theories have been rendered outdated by the discovery of BANAL-52.

But anyway, there does seem to be some drama here...

1/3 My experience of #Nido2023 (the coronavirus meeting in Montreux) so far
1) The organisers refused to let me share the materials I bought. That is, two articles, one on #Ebola2014 and our proposed origin of SARS-CoV-2

See: https://independentsciencenews.org/health/did-west-africas-ebola-outbreak-of-2014-have-a-lab-origin/
and

This is under the instruction of Swiss virologist Volker Thiel.
They have also been removing ones I have left around while I have been attending the talks. T

They also stopped me asking my question to ZLS.

See next tweet below:

At the conclusion of Shi Zhengli's talk the microphone person went over to hand me the microphone but the podium stopped them and sent them to another questioner.

Then I put my hand up again and a different microphone person came over to me....

The chair tried again to stop them and Flo Debarre (trying to whisper from 6 rows in front) says" dont give him the microphone" quite loudly. So they withdrew it and went over to flo instead who explained something or other to them...

By now the audience is wondering what's up! Several few people came up after and said it wasn't right to censor questioners. They don't even know the organisers have stopped me sharing articles.

Then began a favourite game, conference cat-and-mouse. So I set out more articles and left them for the audience to pick up. But I sat nearby so the organisers could see I was watching. After 20mins or so two organisers did take them all. I followed them, which they didnt expect.

I tracked them downstairs to the poster room, expecting they would throw them in the bin. They were for some reason coming my way. They saw me, turned and scurried into the poster room. They didnt know I was following them. Then they realised I was and the one holding....

the papers ran behind the posters while the other stopped. I said "I am glad your colleague likes science so much she took all the copies". Then I pointed out they were stealing and the copies cost 10 Francs each. They offered to give them back at the end of the conference...

This wont do though. A) its still censorship B) I will have to carry them home and they are heavy and it may not be practical. C) I expect they will be damaged.

Stuart Neil replies

so for those less well versed

1 doc on how either RaTG13 is the precursor to SARS-CoV-2 or that it was isolated from the Mojiang miners (noone else, even the the most ardent drastics believe this anymore)

2. The 'ebola theory' is not only ludicrous, it is libellous.

2014 ebola emerged in gueckedo, Guinea. approx 100 miles from the Lassa clinic in Kenema. It is clearly demonstrable that infections in Sierra Leone and Liberia were derived both genetically and temporally from infections in Guinea, which then reimported them back later.

Latham's whole theory is based on Kristian Andersen and Bob Garry having a long term collaborative NIH grant in the emrgence of arenaviruses in west Africa.

Note to the hard of understanding: Kenema is a diagnostic and surveillance lab for people presenting with suspected VHFs..

there is (and certainly wasnt then) any viral culture or experimentation.

By the way, it seems that a theory about Robert Garry's lab in Africa being responsible for the 2014 Ebola outbreak which was made back then, was resurrected with the appearance of Holmes, Andersen and Worobey on the Deconding the Gurus podcast. Some off-hand comment by Andersen set the conspiracy theorists off ("See! He knew Garry let loose the Ebola virus!")

By the way, Capsid, if you are still there, did you attend or hear about this conference? Did you witness this scene?

Is there any video of Shi's presentation and Q&A?
 
From the DRASTIC publication.



So the database from being set up was not publicly accessible. This was an internal database.



So even DRASTIC only claim a hundred sequences (how they come to that number is unclear) and some of those are actually published sequences. Not thousands. It is unlikely that any of these would actually be helpful in defining the origin of SARS-CoV-2 as the closely related wild viruses are not found where WIV collected samples. The only way that it could elucidate the origin is if you start off with the assumption that the WIV had a viable precursor virus (unlikely) and that Shi was lying when she said there were no closely related viruses in the database.

https://zenodo.org/record/4512260#.ZGM1oi8w3VM

Yeah, this database is one that Flo Debarre was talking about (and had nothing to do with the one Bloom was talking about or the GISAID one that Debarre looked at to find the swab data from the market). She says that it went inactive in September 2019 then was active again at some point early 2020 before becoming inactive again. I think she worked this out by looking at a monitoring site. Apparently it was never very active anyway.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom