Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Just to respond to this.

If you read the literature you will see that isolation means being able to obtain a full gene sequence, almost never are 'isolated' bat coronaviruses grown. For instance the paper on the three novel coronaviruses I referenced above they were isolated by gene sequencing not by growing an actual virus.
If I read the literature? :rolleyes:

The post you quoted referred to a large database. Of course those weren't all full genomes. But regarding what you quoted, I'll have to go sort out what was me and what was from the paper, usually I use brackets if I put something in a quote that isn't in the original.


Edited to add, nope you are arguing against what is in the original paper, not something I added. Take your quibble up with them.
 
Last edited:
An important twitter thread is here linking to the embargoed release of all the WIV isolated coronaviruses. The full sequences or nearly full were uploaded prior to the pandemic when there was no reason to keep them secret but embargoed (a normal process to allow the original researchers priority in publishing), and only released post pandemic. It is clear that WIV had no precursor virus to SARS-CoV-2.

https://twitter.com/edwardcholmes/status/1632652493263093765

You are not paying attention. Just like DeBarre's mistake, you are referring to Bloom's investigation.

The database removed from online access in Sept 2019 contained 22,000 genomes. If you read my post more carefully you will see what DRASTIC was referring to was not Bloom's work.
 
Last edited:
This is a link to Flo Denarre on the database.

https://twitter.com/flodebarre/status/1652729420174573568

In summary the claim the database was taken down in September 2019 is false, it was taken down in February 2020. It was first put on line in June 2019. The evidence is it was never a publicly available database but on a laboratory intranet.
:rolleyes:

Been there, done that.

The database removed from online access in Sept 2019 contained 22,000 genomes. If you read my post more carefully you will see what DRASTIC was referring to was not Bloom's work.

Try again.
 
A new bat coronanvirus has ben isolated. This is from the Islands off the South of China well away from Wuhan which is in the centre of China. The interesting thing about this virus is it would be a potential (distant) ancestor of SARS-CoV-1 and SARS-CoV-2 carrying a similar spike protein and most interesting the spike protein carries a Furin cleavage site similar to SARS-CoV-2 showing that this occurs naturally and is not a signal that SARs-CoV-2 had been created by secret gain of function research on a previously unknown virus.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1995820X23000470

Just to respond to this.

At least 19 of these coronaviruses were isolated (meaning grown in cell culture)

If you read the literature you will see that isolation means being able to obtain a full gene sequence, almost never are 'isolated' bat coronaviruses grown. For instance the paper on the three novel coronaviruses I referenced above they were isolated by gene sequencing not by growing an actual virus.


Having read that paper myself, I can confirm that the three novel coronaviruses were identified by gene sequencing, not by growing an actual virus. The methods used for sequencing and identification are described by the paper's sections 2.2, 2.3, 3.1, 3.2, and 3.3.

If I read the literature? :rolleyes:

The post you quoted referred to a large database. Of course those weren't all full genomes. But regarding what you quoted, I'll have to go sort out what was me and what was from the paper, usually I use brackets if I put something in a quote that isn't in the original.


Edited to add, nope you are arguing against what is in the original paper, not something I added. Take your quibble up with them.


Having read that paper myself, I see nothing that could support Skeptic Ginger's contention that the three novel coronaviruses described in that paper were identified by growing an actual virus.

ETA: Judging from the sentence I highlighted in pink, I suspect Skeptic Ginger failed to read the sentence I highlighted in blue, and mistakenly assumed Planigale was referring to the partially anonymous preprint of a subsequent slideshow that Skeptic Ginger had cited in her own post.
 
Last edited:
Once again, examining the background of authors cited by Skeptic Ginger has proved to be entertaining.

According to Billy Bostickson's ResearchGate page, he not only styles himself a "Professor" (also a "Coordinator") at DRASTIC, but has been affiliated since 2012 with Rage University (whose "mission is to advance the tactics, tools and techniques of radical activists, empowering them to use information, direct action, media and communication to help communities and individuals to achieve social, environmental and political change, as well as to protect them from State Repression and Violence") where he is "Head of Department", presumably the Communication department. He describes that job as "Public Relations". His self-described "Skills and Expertise" include subversion, advertising, and propaganda. He lists 20 "publications", all written toward the end of 2021, all promoting the idea of a lab leak, which have been cited a total of 3 times.

Gilles Demaneuf is a data scientist with the Bank of New Zealand in Auckland.

I cannot tell you anything about the background of that paper's first author, whom the paper identifies only as "Anonymous OSINT Contributor".
 
Having read that paper myself, I can confirm that the three novel coronaviruses were identified by gene sequencing, not by growing an actual virus. The methods used for sequencing and identification are described by the paper's sections 2.2, 2.3, 3.1, 3.2, and 3.3.

Having read that paper myself, I see nothing that could support Skeptic Ginger's contention that the three novel coronaviruses described in that paper were identified by growing an actual virus.

ETA: Judging from the sentence I highlighted in pink, I suspect Skeptic Ginger failed to read the sentence I highlighted in blue, and mistakenly assumed Planigale was referring to the partially anonymous preprint of a subsequent slideshow that Skeptic Ginger had cited in her own post.
This is laughable. What paper did you read that talked about 3 new coronaviruses when I quoted DRASTIC's pdf that outlined 22,000 genomes?

These are 2 separate databases. How can I make that any more clear. :rolleyes:
 
Having read that paper myself, I can confirm that the three novel coronaviruses were identified by gene sequencing, not by growing an actual virus. The methods used for sequencing and identification are described by the paper's sections 2.2, 2.3, 3.1, 3.2, and 3.3.

Having read that paper myself, I see nothing that could support Skeptic Ginger's contention that the three novel coronaviruses described in that paper were identified by growing an actual virus.

This is laughable. What paper did you read that talked about 3 new coronaviruses when I quoted DRASTIC's pdf that outlined 22,000 genomes?


If I possessed some minimal degree of reading comprehension, I'd guess I was talking about that paper. You know:
  • the same paper Planigale was talking about,
  • the same paper I linked to twice in the post you quoted (hint: look for the phrase "that paper"), and
  • the same paper I linked to in the previous sentence.

These are 2 separate databases. How can I make that any more clear. :rolleyes:
You could try using more emoticons and larger type.

That's all you have, discredit the authors because you can't discredit the evidence.

There are at least 3 of you in this thread doing that.:rolleyes:
Kinda hard to discredit the anonymous first author of the bullet points you cited, but that anonymous author's two co-authors sort of discredit themselves. Do you not understand why referring to yourself as a "Professor" at DRASTIC is risible? Do you not understand why a ResearchGate web page that boasts of your propaganda skills is self-discrediting? Do you not understand why a publication record that consists of 20 "publications" devoted to promoting the idea of a lab leak, none of which will ever be submitted to peer review, is not a sign of someone doing genuine science?
ETA: I don't doubt that the second author is a "Professor" at Rage University—which appears to offer no degree programs—but DRASTIC (Decentralized Radical Autonomous Search Team Investigating COVID-19) is not the sort of institution that can plausibly award that title.


Do you not understand why your habitual reliance on such sources suggests you are citing them not because you have examined what they say with a healthy degree of skepticism, but simply because they agree with you?
 
Last edited:
If I possessed some minimal degree of reading comprehension, I'd guess I was talking about that paper. You know:
  • the same paper Planigale was talking about,
  • the same paper I linked to twice in the post you quoted (hint: look for the phrase "that paper"), and
  • the same paper I linked to in the previous sentence.


You could try using more emoticons and larger type.


Kinda hard to discredit the anonymous first author of the bullet points you cited, but that anonymous author's two co-authors sort of discredit themselves. Do you not understand why referring to yourself as a "Professor" at DRASTIC is risible? Do you not understand why a ResearchGate web page that boasts of your propaganda skills is self-discrediting? Do you not understand why a publication record that consists of 20 "publications" devoted to promoting the idea of a lab leak, none of which will ever be submitted to peer review, is not a sign of someone doing genuine science?
ETA: I don't doubt that the second author is a "Professor" at Rage University—which appears to offer no degree programs—but DRASTIC (Decentralized Radical Autonomous Search Team Investigating COVID-19) is not the sort of institution that can plausibly award that title.


Do you not understand why your habitual reliance on such sources suggests you are citing them not because you have examined what they say with a healthy degree of skepticism, but simply because they agree with you?

Thanks. I hadn't really looked at DRASTIC before. Much of the unsubstantiated claims to 'justify' a laboartory leak theory seems to originate from this anonymous group. The unsubstantiated claim of bats at WIV, the unsubstantiated and probably false claim about the 'publically available' database being taken offline. They also claim that HIV originated from oral polio vaccine and SARS-CoV-2 originated from an oral SARS vaccine.
 
Thanks. I hadn't really looked at DRASTIC before.
It shows. :rolleyes:

Much of the unsubstantiated claims to 'justify' a laboartory leak theory seems to originate from this anonymous group.
They are not all anonymous.
The DRASTIC Team

I don't see many discussions in research and science community circles discarding the work of this whistleblower group. Angrysoba has throughout this thread discounted Chan, Segreto, Deigin, Quay and others sidestepping any debate about their research or evidence they uncovered.

MIT researcher attacked for work on COVID-19 origin feels 'validated' after DOE report
The Department of Energy believes with low confidence that the COVID-19 outbreak started from a lab leak in Wuhan. A local researcher has been pushing the United States to investigate the lab for more than a year. Her remarks have led to threats and harassment.

"Backlash was swift and furious.
I think a lot of scientists were really offended by it. People called me a race traitor. I was attacked by a Chinese media article," said Dr. Alina Chan, a scientific advisor at the Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard. "All of that time fighting for the lab origin to be investigated, I do feel validated."



When you finally got it (I think) that there were 2 different databases being conflated here, you ignored that HUGE mistake you made and went on to call everything unsubstantiated. You claim the whole story of the large genome database being taken offline by the Chinese in Sept 2019 is probably a false claim. Funny that given multiple researchers have publicly asked China to restore access to the database. It's discussed with citations earlier on in the thread.

The unsubstantiated claim of bats at WIV, the unsubstantiated and probably false claim about the 'publically available' database being taken offline.
Typical, hand wave away evidence one never actually looked at. That makes it easier for one to pretend to actually be debating. Just labeling something unsubstantiated doesn't make it so. Just claiming that a citation is found in a news report doesn't make the research paper referred to and linked to in that paper invalid.


They also claim that HIV originated from oral polio vaccine and SARS-CoV-2 originated from an oral SARS vaccine.
Where'd you get this **** from? Did you make it up? Hear it in the hallway or break room?

The CTers who had all those claims about HIV coming from live vaccines were decades before DRASTIC was even formed. Now you make a bizarre attempt to discredit this group claiming they are CTers. Good grief, get over it. :rolleyes:

DRASIC is a legit whistleblower group that have leaked or posted papers, articles, resources, and evidence for all their claims. They were the first to dig up both the master's and the PhD theses about the Mojiang miners including getting them translated into English. They have documented their evidence about that database. It's not a group of flakes or CTers.

Why are most of them anonymous? From the link to their webpage above:
Many D.R.A.S.T.I.C. Members, especially “China Experts” and Scientists prefer to operate anonymously due to privacy, security and professional concerns, and are thus not listed on this page
 
I don't see many discussions in research and science community circles discarding the work of this whistleblower group. Angrysoba has throughout this thread discounted Chan, Segreto, Deigin, Quay and others sidestepping any debate about their research or evidence they uncovered.

This is not true. I have criticized each of them on substantive points. But I have also noted that some of the claims they have made are claims I am not competent to address. If I am not competent to address them, then it would make no sense to debate, say, whether a furin cleavage site can evolve in the wild.

No one is an expert on everything, so it is a normal skeptical heuristic to rely on experts rather than attempt to investigate all arguments that involve complex and very narrow areas of expertise. This is not something unique to me. It is Skepticism 101. Almost nobody will be qualified to “debate” these issues and I am skeptical of those outside the field of virology who make big claims about it. This is why I did not feel the need to read a 150 page pre-print by Stephen Quay in which he gave a “Bayesian analysis”. If the paper is good he should submit it to a peer-reviewed journal and let experts look at the maths and the evolutionary microbiology.

The only things I am really able to do is look at the coherence of the arguments made and whether or not experts agree with the claims being made by one side or another. So far, for me, some of the claims made by Cham, for example, lack coherence such as the initial emphasis on the Mojiang Mine which has been rendered obsolete by the findings of viruses closer to SARS-CoV2 than wee discovered in the Mojiang Mine.

And yes, in some cases, the other beliefs a person may have might influence how much stock you will put in their judgment. I generally am fairly well-disposed to Deigin because I think he is more cautious than some of his fellow lab leakers. Segreto, on the other hand seems to be full-on anti-vax and seems to also favour the theory, which I don’t think you would agree with, that the lab Covid came from was a US one.

There are also some other people in DRASTIC who are truly weird, such as those who think Covid is a prion etc…

Like I said, some of this is just Skepticism 101.
 
This is not true. I have criticized each of them on substantive points. But I have also noted that some of the claims they have made are claims I am not competent to address. If I am not competent to address them, then it would make no sense to debate, say, whether a furin cleavage site can evolve in the wild.

No one is an expert on everything, so it is a normal skeptical heuristic to rely on experts rather than attempt to investigate all arguments that involve complex and very narrow areas of expertise. This is not something unique to me. It is Skepticism 101. Almost nobody will be qualified to “debate” these issues and I am skeptical of those outside the field of virology who make big claims about it. This is why I did not feel the need to read a 150 page pre-print by Stephen Quay in which he gave a “Bayesian analysis”. If the paper is good he should submit it to a peer-reviewed journal and let experts look at the maths and the evolutionary microbiology.

The only things I am really able to do is look at the coherence of the arguments made and whether or not experts agree with the claims being made by one side or another. So far, for me, some of the claims made by Cham, for example, lack coherence such as the initial emphasis on the Mojiang Mine which has been rendered obsolete by the findings of viruses closer to SARS-CoV2 than wee discovered in the Mojiang Mine.

And yes, in some cases, the other beliefs a person may have might influence how much stock you will put in their judgment. I generally am fairly well-disposed to Deigin because I think he is more cautious than some of his fellow lab leakers. Segreto, on the other hand seems to be full-on anti-vax and seems to also favour the theory, which I don’t think you would agree with, that the lab Covid came from was a US one.

There are also some other people in DRASTIC who are truly weird, such as those who think Covid is a prion etc…

Like I said, some of this is just Skepticism 101.
But once you've made some statement about whatever re these particular educated persons you over and over say things like not so and so again; not the furin cleavage site again, not the blah blah blah again as if you've discredited everything out of their mouths.

At the beginning of this thread a lot of evidence was being put out there, some of which was discredited and a lot of which was subsequently corroborated.

I've summarized the strongest points in a number of posts. When I've said Worobey's work was weak sauce I've cited why, he still doesn't have the data on those earliest cases.

As for the work of Pekar, he produced the 3rd or 4th genomic analysis tracing COVID back, the analyses contradict each other. I've not heard one supersedes the rest and why.

When I've said the latest claim raccoon dogs were the source of COVID was hardly a smoking gun, I've said why, the only evidence found was something we already knew, they sold raccoon dogs at the market. We already knew that, there are pictures of them there.

When I've said they still haven't found the trail of COVID to Wuhan you've said they didn't test that many animals, they only tested animals in certain places, and so on. But then another year goes by and another and still no source where something close to COVID is found circulating. So no one is still looking?

Want to try again?



ETA some additional follow up.
....

There are also some other people in DRASTIC who are truly weird, such as those who think Covid is a prion etc…
I have not seen this, do you have a source?

And as for Segreto being anti-vax, I'll have to look at that again, I don't recall that, especially how it might have some bearing on the origin hypotheses, just like Quay's specialty means he can't look at the origin of COVID.
 
Last edited:
But once you've made some statement about whatever re these particular educated persons you over and over say things like not so and so again; not the furin cleavage site again, not the blah blah blah again as if you've discredited everything out of their mouths.

At the beginning of this thread a lot of evidence was being put out there, some of which was discredited and a lot of which was subsequently corroborated.

I've summarized the strongest points in a number of posts. When I've said Worobey's work was weak sauce I've cited why, he still doesn't have the data on those earliest cases.

As for the work of Pekar, he produced the 3rd or 4th genomic analysis tracing COVID back, the analyses contradict each other. I've not heard one supersedes the rest and why.

When I've said the latest claim raccoon dogs were the source of COVID was hardly a smoking gun, I've said why, the only evidence found was something we already knew, they sold raccoon dogs at the market. We already knew that, there are pictures of them there.

When I've said they still haven't found the trail of COVID to Wuhan you've said they didn't test that many animals, they only tested animals in certain places, and so on. But then another year goes by and another and still no source where something close to COVID is found circulating. So no one is still looking?

Want to try again?

Try what again? I am not sure what point you are making. You claimed that I dismissed without evidence or debate. I think this is false. I never said that you did that. As far as I can see, I have never displayed any over-confidence in any of the evidence for the spillover. On the contrary, you have expressed surprise that I wasn't "running to the bank" with it.



ETA some additional follow up.
I have not seen this, do you have a source?

Early in the (previous) thread. I can't be bothered going back to look for it now. Maybe another time.

And as for Segreto being anti-vax, I'll have to look at that again, I don't recall that, especially how it might have some bearing on the origin hypotheses, just like Quay's specialty means he can't look at the origin of COVID.

Her theory seems to be that Fort Detrick is the source of the pandemic through mRNA vaccine research, and she seems to single out Baric. Also her theory seems to be that the recent monkeypox outbreaks etc... are somehow involved...

https://twitter.com/search?q=vaccines (from:Rossana38510044)&src=typed_query
 
Ah, Kevin McCairn is the one who argues that Covid is caused by a prion not a virus.

He was a co-author with Segreto and Deigin on a paper about the origins.

While you say "I did not see this", you did because you replied to me and even bolded the word "prion". I get that didn't remember, but it is not true that you didn't see it.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=13416515&postcount=251
 
Try what again? I am not sure what point you are making. You claimed that I dismissed without evidence or debate. I think this is false. I never said that you did that. As far as I can see, I have never displayed any over-confidence in any of the evidence for the spillover. On the contrary, you have expressed surprise that I wasn't "running to the bank" with it.
Your posts come across to me as being over-confident in the spillover hypothesis like mine must sound to you like I'm over-confident the evidence favors the lab leak.

I do think the lab hypothesis evidence is piling up.

The spillover side got all giddy about Worobey's study as if it were proof. The missing data problem was in plain sight but not many people seemed to challenge his study. More in plain sight was his failure to point out how close the CCDC lab was to the market and Worobey's framing of the distance to the WIV as if it was on the other side of Wuhan.

And did Worobey go beyond his epidemiology map and note the market was smack in the middle of a crowded area with lots of people in and out while the WIV was not and did not have crowds of people in and out? Nope.

The genetic testing that showed raccoon dogs were at one market stall COVID remnants were found really got people going. Oooh, China released data they were sitting on, why did they wait 2 years? It was especially annoying to read Worobey claiming his research had been corroborated as fact when no such thing happened. And the news media glommed on of course.

Now we have DeBarre making a serious mistake about which databases she was talking about and condescendingly attacking DRASTIC. I sincerely doubt she'll make much ado about that mistake when she figures it out. I wonder if the NYT reporter will notice, let alone address DeBarre's letter to her.


Early in the (previous) thread. I can't be bothered going back to look for it now. Maybe another time.
Fair enough but no one with any knowledge of prions and viruses would make that mistake. The people in DRASTIC are not flakes.

Going back over Deigin and Soretto, seems to me they got conflated somewhere in the thread either by me or because some source one of us cited included them both. I don't want to hunt that up either.

Deigin is no flake and is a co-founder of DRASTIC
His extensive paper reminds me how often I posted in-depth evidence that you called a data dump and didn't read. How can any of us discuss this topic seriously when people are not serious about looking at the evidence?

From that Twitter link to Segretto I agree her evidence is pretty useless.
Her theory seems to be that Fort Detrick is the source of the pandemic through mRNA vaccine research, and she seems to single out Baric. Also her theory seems to be that the recent monkeypox outbreaks etc... are somehow involved...

https://twitter.com/search?q=vaccines (from:Rossana38510044)&src=typed_query
Instead of wasting time on that one going back to see that I likely dismissed her then, I'll try to remember to quit bringing her up now.


But speaking of bringing up people, DeBarre really attacked Chan in DeBarre's Twitter feed. Chan is also no flake. I had her book, Viral: The Search for the Origin of COVID-19, cowritten with Matt Ridley, and it was comprehensive and impressive. Just to rub it in a bit, your book recommendation, Spillover, was out of date and not so impressive. Though it is important to look at all the spillover events that have led to outbreaks and pandemics over the centuries.

I get the Huff whistleblower book Thursday. I'm not going to put much credence in it until I see it given he's been trashed by people who fired him.
 
Ah, Kevin McCairn is the one who argues that Covid is caused by a prion not a virus.

He was a co-author with Segreto and Deigin on a paper about the origins.

While you say "I did not see this", you did because you replied to me and even bolded the word "prion". I get that didn't remember, but it is not true that you didn't see it.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=13416515&postcount=251
Oh and look at what I replied:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=13415438#post13415438
Which is why besides maybe a mention, this belongs in the CT thread.

We are trying at least, to discuss the evidence of the COVID origin. That some CTer thinks it originated in the lab is not relevant in this thread.

It's ignorant to proclaim it is a prion. This is what I think of that: So anything else the guy has to say belongs in the other forum.

Why do you argue it's a CT instead of addressing the actual evidence pro or con? Are you having trouble understanding the difference?

Oh it goes on from there in my next post:
And McCairn is not one of the signatories.

So is it guilt by association now, Segreto and Canard wrote a paper or something with McCairn?? That's what you are basing discrediting the the whole letter with 26 signatories (if I counted right) on it? Did you look at the credentials of the signatories? There are a large number of virologists, the folks you said did not support the lab hypothesis on that letter.
Those would be the scientists who called Daszak out on his attempt to get a bunch of scientists to claim the lab hypothesis was a CT.

Yeah there's quite a bit there we need not go over unless you want to.

Deigin is not a flake, Segreto appears to be if that Twitter feed is a valid example, and I don't recall McCairn but it would appear I called that prion stuff nonsense at the time. I doubt I would have cited anything he wrote. And I don't see he's part of DRASTIC from their website.
 
Last edited:
McCairn was one of the signatories of one of the papers by Deigin and Segreto:

An open debate on SARS-CoV-2's proximal origin is long overdue
Rossana Segreto (1), Yuri Deigin (2), Kevin McCairn (3), Alejandro Sousa (4 and 5), Dan Sirotkin (6), Karl Sirotkin (6), Jonathan J. Couey (7), Adrian Jones (8), Daoyu Zhang (9)

I don't understand what you are objecting to if you at one and same time say that someone confusing a virus with a prion does not know what they are talking about and can be dismissed easily, but also don't want me to dismiss people such as Segreto, even though you just said that on the basis of that feed Segreto can be dismissed. :confused:

Also, if I "appear" to be overconfident, I think that's what's called a "you thing" not a "me thing". My criticism of you is that you have seized on multiple "smoking guns" that turned out to be "steaming piles" ;) .
 
Regarding "Deigin is no flake and is a co-founder of DRASTIC". Yeah, I already said I have some room for his points. He tends to be cautious whereas some others much less so. So I am not blanket dismissing.

One of the other founders of DRASTIC is Billy Bostickson who had a big falling out with Deigin and he is one of the primary pushers of Huff.

Now, you say "he's been trashed by people who fired him". Do you know why he was fired?

The letter that EHA wrote in response to his book that essentially accused EHA and various other bodies of creating the virus states:

1) Mr. Huff was employed by the EcoHealth Alliance from 2014 to 2016. However, reports that he worked at or with the Wuhan Institute of Virology during that time are untrue. He was assigned to a completely different project working on computer-based algorithms to assess emerging disease threats.

2) Mr. Huff alleges that EcoHealth Alliance was engaged in gain of function research to create SARS-CoV-2. This is not true.

3) Mr. Huff makes a number of other speculations and allegations about the nature of the collaboration between EcoHealth Alliance and the Wuhan Institute of Virology. Given that he never worked at or with the Wuhan Institute of Virology, his assertions along these lines cannot be trusted.

4) Mr. Huff claims that SARS-CoV-2 emerged as a lab leak from the Wuhan Institute of Virology based on research conducted there on bat coronaviruses and, further, that this research was related to U.S. intelligence gathering efforts. This is not true.

Link

He worked there for only two years (2014-2016).

Do you really think that letter constitutes "trashing" the poor innocent Huff who had merely accused them of mass murder?

Seriously, Huff has been tweeting out how he thinks Daszak and Fauci should be hanged. I have posted the pictures of the tweets here. He goes on Infowars and various weird right-wing stations. Why would you treat this guy as any more of an authority than say Alex Jones?

Your whole framing of this as EHA "trashing" him when he accused them of mass murder and called for them to be executed is bizarre! It's seriously up is down nonsense!
 
McCairn was one of the signatories of one of the papers by Deigin and Segreto:

I don't understand what you are objecting to if you at one and same time say that someone confusing a virus with a prion does not know what they are talking about and can be dismissed easily, but also don't want me to dismiss people such as Segreto, even though you just said that on the basis of that feed Segreto can be dismissed. :confused:
That depends on what you are referring to as "papers".

If a number of scientists sign a paper that says Daszak misled everyone who signed a letter to the Lancet and they take it back, that is not the same as a number of researchers whose names appear on a research paper.

Also, if I "appear" to be overconfident, I think that's what's called a "you thing" not a "me thing". My criticism of you is that you have seized on multiple "smoking guns" that turned out to be "steaming piles" ;) .
So name the evidence I cited you don't agree with. I can deal with that.

Find me a single post where I said any of the evidence supporting the lab leak hypothesis was a smoking gun. Now that I cannot agree with because I never said it.
 
So name the evidence I cited you don't agree with. I can deal with that.

Find me a single post where I said any of the evidence supporting the lab leak hypothesis was a smoking gun. Now that I cannot agree with because I never said it.

I believe there was this one in which Daszak's discussion with Racaniello is taken as evidence that the viruses must have leaked from a lab.

The smoking gun just became the flash from a bullet.

The GatewayPundit ...[ hear me out I tracked it to the original source ]... Posted this 3 weeks ago: Top WHO Official [Peter Daszak] Caught on Video in December 2019 Revealing Coronavirus Manipulation at Wuhan Lab Before Pandemic (VIDEO)

The video is an interview with Daszak during the Nipah Virus International Conference in Singapore Dec 9-10, 2019 where Daszak was one of the participants.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=13430705&postcount=377
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom