Try what again? I am not sure what point you are making. You claimed that I dismissed without evidence or debate. I think this is false. I never said that you did that. As far as I can see, I have never displayed any over-confidence in any of the evidence for the spillover. On the contrary, you have expressed surprise that I wasn't "running to the bank" with it.
Your posts come across to me as being over-confident in the spillover hypothesis like mine must sound to you like I'm over-confident the evidence favors the lab leak.
I do think the lab hypothesis evidence is piling up.
The spillover side got all giddy about Worobey's study as if it were proof. The missing data problem was in plain sight but not many people seemed to challenge his study. More in plain sight was his failure to point out how close the CCDC lab was to the market and Worobey's framing of the distance to the WIV as if it was on the other side of Wuhan.
And did Worobey go beyond his epidemiology map and note the market was smack in the middle of a crowded area with lots of people in and out while the WIV was not and did not have crowds of people in and out? Nope.
The genetic testing that showed raccoon dogs were at one market stall COVID remnants were found really got people going. Oooh, China released data they were sitting on, why did they wait 2 years? It was especially annoying to read Worobey claiming his research had been corroborated as fact when no such thing happened. And the news media glommed on of course.
Now we have DeBarre making a serious mistake about which databases she was talking about and condescendingly attacking DRASTIC. I sincerely doubt she'll make much ado about that mistake when she figures it out. I wonder if the NYT reporter will notice, let alone address DeBarre's letter to her.
Early in the (previous) thread. I can't be bothered going back to look for it now. Maybe another time.
Fair enough but no one with any knowledge of prions and viruses would make that mistake. The people in DRASTIC are not flakes.
Going back over Deigin and Soretto, seems to me they got conflated somewhere in the thread either by me or because some source one of us cited included them both. I don't want to hunt that up either.
Deigin is no flake and is a co-founder of DRASTIC
His extensive paper reminds me how often I posted in-depth evidence that you called a data dump and didn't read. How can any of us discuss this topic seriously when people are not serious about looking at the evidence?
From that Twitter link to Segretto I agree her evidence is pretty useless.
Her theory seems to be that Fort Detrick is the source of the pandemic through mRNA vaccine research, and she seems to single out Baric. Also her theory seems to be that the recent monkeypox outbreaks etc... are somehow involved...
https://twitter.com/search?q=vaccines (from:Rossana38510044)&src=typed_query
Instead of wasting time on that one going back to see that I likely dismissed her then, I'll try to remember to quit bringing her up now.
But speaking of bringing up people, DeBarre really attacked Chan in DeBarre's Twitter feed. Chan is also no flake. I had her book,
Viral: The Search for the Origin of COVID-19, cowritten with Matt Ridley, and it was comprehensive and impressive. Just to rub it in a bit, your book recommendation,
Spillover, was out of date and not so impressive. Though it is important to look at all the spillover events that have led to outbreaks and pandemics over the centuries.
I get the Huff whistleblower book Thursday. I'm not going to put much credence in it until I see it given he's been trashed by people who fired him.