Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

I believe there was this one in which Daszak's discussion with Racaniello is taken as evidence that the viruses must have leaked from a lab.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=13430705&postcount=377
OK, I take that back. It was a year ago and I'm positive that since that time I made clear my position was neither hypothesis was off the table.

You do have to admit that was pretty darn close to an outright admission they were manipulating SARS-like CoVs in the lab at the same time the outbreak started right in the WIV's backyard. And it was just before he found out that comment had some pretty bad implications. I don't believe he ever revisited it to say he meant something else.


Moving forward Bloom had something new to add today. He's been honest about tracking the origin of COVID except he went out of his way to support Shi when she explained the removed genome fragments he found in the cloud. I understand that.


There's a lot quoted here but it is only a small portion of the news article which is long and thorough. People should read the whole article.
Raccoon dogs did not start COVID-19, new study says
“The COVID lab leak theory is dead,” declared Edward Holmes, one of the researchers involved in the raccoon dog study.
The spillover hypothesis side does get carried away with "smoking gun" framing.


This is where DeBarre came in.
An evolutionary biologist in France named Florence Débarre spotted the new data and, according to the Atlantic, notified colleagues around the world. With their enormous collection of genetic material from different species, the GISAID samples were a chronicle of the Huanan market in the earliest days of the pandemic. Here, possibly, in the endless string of genetic sequences, lay hidden the origin story of SARS-CoV-2.

Despite what China had to say about the finding:
Chinese scientists had already analyzed all the Huanan swabs, surmising that “the market may [have] acted as an amplifier of transmission due to the high number of visitors every day.” Their study explicitly discounted the possibility that the virus had jumped from an animal to humans.


Worobey, Andersen, and Holmes got excited.
Now, working with the raw data, Kristian Andersen, Michael Worobey and Holmes came to an entirely different conclusion. They believed that the pandemic had begun in stall 29, on the southwestern edge of the market.

In that stall sat caged raccoon dogs.

“The Strongest Evidence Yet That an Animal Started the Pandemic,” said the headline of the Atlantic article that broke the news.
From there the news article summarizes a bit of the supporters' POVs about the 2 hypotheses over the last 3 years.


This explains a lot about DeBarre and others confusing the larger database revealed by DRASTIC and this database of the swabs taken from the market. So apparently there were 3 databases, one from Sept 2019, one from Shi's paper that Bloom found in the cloud and this one recently released where the Chinese revealed the genetic data they found in market swabs that they had kept secret for a couple years.
Unlike some other researchers looking for the pandemic’s origins, Bloom was not a self-promoter. He did not attack critics on Twitter or make wild, unsupportable claims. “He is the most ethical scientist I know. He wants to dig deep and discover the truth,” a fellow scientist told Vanity Fair.

The raccoon dog revelation gave Bloom a new project. The data used by the Worobey group had been removed from GISAID, only to materialize there again in more fulsome form in late March. Whereas the raccoon dog group had worked with 227 FASTQ files — the format used to store long strings of genetic code — there were 696 FASTQ files in the Huanan sequences that reappeared on GISAID several weeks later.

Working with the bigger database, Bloom processed an astonishing three terabytes of data from the Huanan Market — genetic sequences from the same swabs taken in early 2020 that Worobey and his collaborators thought pointed to raccoon dogs.

Bloom’s analysis did not merely look at where coronavirus and animal genetic material commingled but also at how thorough that commingling had been. And while the Worobey group had only examined mammalian DNA, Bloom sifted through every strand of genetic material, regardless of whether it came from a chicken, a human or a cut of beef.
I found that interesting that Worobey appeared to take a fairly bias confirming look at the market data.


In a paper published in late April, Bloom wrote that “the samples that contain abundant material from raccoon dogs and other non-human susceptible species generally contain little or no SARS-CoV-2 reads.” ...

In other words, the Chinese researchers who had been the first to study the swabs, and had concluded that humans carried the virus to the market, appeared to have been correct all along.

As for the raccoon dog, it was unquestionably innocent. “There is a negative correlation between the abundance of SARS-CoV-2 and mitochondrial material from raccoon dogs,” Bloom wrote.

The most viral material came from swabs with DNA from stalls where seafood such as catfish and largemouth bass were sold.


This was weird:
Worobey, Andersen and Holmes did not respond to a request for comment. Nor did several other researchers listed as co-authors on the raccoon dog paper. Alexander Crits-Christoph of Johns Hopkins was the sole respondent. He sent Yahoo News an insulting email in response to questions raised by the new study.


Chan weighed in:
“The raccoon dog team made a big fuss out of what is most likely a contaminated sample,” molecular biologist Alina Chan of the Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard told Yahoo News.

“Not only is there no correlation between raccoon dog and virus genetic material, but even the only sample with both raccoon dog and virus was likely cross-contaminated during the sample processing,” she said.


And Bloom was his usual neutral self:
In his paper, Bloom argues that his study does not contradict the raccoon dog hypothesis but, rather, merely points out the near impossibility of using the market swabs to reach any meaningful conclusion about viral origins.

“A careful analysis of these samples does not prove or disprove any particular scenario for how the virus entered the market,” Bloom told Yahoo News, “but does suggest that genetic analysis of the samples is not directly informative for answering that question.”


The news article goes on to address the media's role distorting the facts. I have noted this problem between Trump, Biden, and all the rest of the politics it has made a jolly mess of the actual evidence. Maybe this is where Planigale got confused about HIV being in the mix but I don't know:
FactCheck.org labeled the notion that the coronavirus originated in a laboratory a “baseless conspiracy theory,” putting credible questions about a lab leak into the same category as obviously untrue claims that the SARS-CoV-2 virus contained strains of HIV.


And can people in this thread please stop claiming no reputable scientists support the lab origin hypothesis? I do get tired of hearing that BS.
“The origin of COVID-19 debate has gotten so fierce that there are solid scientists on both sides who will take any chance to say there is new evidence bolstering their preferred hypothesis,” she said.

It is especially prevalent in the media:
She and others faulted the media for continuing to favor the market origin — and for not applying sufficient scrutiny to the raccoon dog claim.
IMO they were bamboozled by Daszak's efforts to make the lab hypothesis look like a CT.

Dissenting opinions to Blooms conclusions are noted in the news article.


Here'a a link to Bloom's paper:
Association between SARS-CoV-2 and metagenomic content of samples from the Huanan Seafood Market - Jesse D. Bloom
 
Hi SG. Thanks for that. I will check out the Bloom paper. He’s also someone who is lab-leak friendly who I think has done some interesting, good faith work.

Two things:

A) I agree with you that the raccoon dog swabs are being over-egged. What is important is that there were more animals there that did not get tested. The claims that it reveals where the virus came from is too strong a claim.

B) Debarre did NOT confuse the database. What she found was that the same database that DRASTIC said was taken down in 2019, did actually go back online in early 2020. This is important because Shi said it was removed during the pandemic due to hacking attempts. Of course this comment by Shi would make no sense if it was taken down before the pandemic, so why did Shi say this? Why would she lie? Debarre found that a monitoring site showed it was accessible at various parts of early 2020, so that could have been the time there were hacking attempts. Furthermore, my understanding was that it was accessible via a public-facing website as many universities have, where you have to enter an email and password. It seems that this is what was being talked about when the “hacking” claims were made.

Debarre much later discovered the swab data on the gene bank before those two were taken back offline. The two things are not related.

Anyway, thanks again for the Bloom, I will have a look at it.
 
Hi SG. Thanks for that. I will check out the Bloom paper. He’s also someone who is lab-leak friendly who I think has done some interesting, good faith work.

Two things:

A) I agree with you that the raccoon dog swabs are being over-egged. What is important is that there were more animals there that did not get tested. The claims that it reveals where the virus came from is too strong a claim.

B) Debarre did NOT confuse the database. What she found was that the same database that DRASTIC said was taken down in 2019, did actually go back online in early 2020. This is important because Shi said it was removed during the pandemic due to hacking attempts. Of course this comment by Shi would make no sense if it was taken down before the pandemic, so why did Shi say this? Why would she lie? Debarre found that a monitoring site showed it was accessible at various parts of early 2020, so that could have been the time there were hacking attempts. Furthermore, my understanding was that it was accessible via a public-facing website as many universities have, where you have to enter an email and password. It seems that this is what was being talked about when the “hacking” claims were made.

Debarre much later discovered the swab data on the gene bank before those two were taken back offline. The two things are not related.

Anyway, thanks again for the Bloom, I will have a look at it.

You are welcome. I appreciate you being one of the few people making an effort to discuss the 2 origin hypotheses though you have your moments as have I.


They are not the same data bases. I will take a closer look since I found there were 2 databases Bloom looked at when I thought there was 1. That leaves 3 databases. Regardless I found DeBarre's belittling DRASTIC to be uncalled for.

DB #1) Bloom found genome data missing from a 2019 paper written by Shi (et al I believe). That's the one Bloom found the data in the cloud and Shi explained why the data that had been online on a NIH server was removed. I don't remember the reason but Bloom accepted the explanation and Shi put the data back online, editing the paper yet again.

DB # 2) This was all the genetic material that was generated from the market sampling. That is the one DeBarre is apparently talking about that she saw back in 2020. I am not surprised. We discussed in the thread the findings of those market samples. COVID 19 was found in the drain from the market. I think the discussion here was about cultures when it apparently was just genome analysis sans cultures that we were looking at.

#2 is the DB I need to take a closer look at.

DB #3) This database had 22,000 genomes of all the specimens Shi and her teams had been collecting from caves and the mine in Yunnan. Shi was looking for the reservoir of SARS1 and reported they found it in ~2007, (I don't remember the exact year).

That is the database removed mid-Sept 2019. You must recall this database since you haven't been convinced removing that data had anything to do with COVID. First cases would have had to have been as early as Sept. But now it looks possible there were cases that early but that China believed they had snuffed the lab escape out.

Lots of speculation, lots of things that fit different hypothesized reasons for the early removal of the database. But one thing is very clear, that database was not online anytime since Sept 2019. In 2020 DeBarre had to have been looking at the results of the swabs of the market.

China reported at that time the market was not the spillover site, only a super-spreader event site. This was repeatedly noted in the thread.
 
I think it is unlikely Flo Debarre whose profession is dealing with databases of gene sequences would get the confused.

1) The WIV database recording samples colected by WIV and associated gene sequences if any. This was set up in June 2019, and was accesible via the laboratory intranet. It was briefly off line in September for updating. This was on line until February 2020 when it was taken off line because of multiple hacking attempts. There is no evidence this was a publically available database.

This is the database that Drastic claims was taken off line. This is the database that DRASTIC claim was previously publically accessible. The evidence (cite below) shows that it was online from end 2019 to february 2020. This fits with Shi's comments on this. There is no evidence this was a publically accessible database, no one claims to have used it. Drastic's claims are wrong. Of note the only people to have made this claim are Drastic and the story originates with them.

2) The GISAID database, this is hosted in the US and was set up to host influenza sequences, but came to be widely used for SARS-CoV-2 sequences. This is where the Wuhan market sample sequences were posted by CDC, seen by Flo Debarre, then taken down by CDC, then reposted with data on associated animals. I posted above the main positive associations, and what struck me was the high association with deer.

DRASTIC as a group are ideologically committed to the laboratory leak theory, their interpretation and publications are biased to support this explanation. You may not like that they also support a laboratory leak source for HIV, but they do.
The monitoring website (http://msis.csdb.cn) was still accessible in early 2022 (h/t @coroldo1
). I accessed it, and it showed that the database was still available until February 2020. That is, after the pandemic started, like Shi Zhengli said. [reposted]▫️5/n

The monitoring website also shows that the database was never much active, and only started existing in June 2019... Which is quite far from the picture of a major public website suddenly removed that is painted by some.

Another point of Shi Zhengli’s reply (image in tweet 3) can be checked with publicly available data, namely when WIV started working on this database project (h/t @zhihuachen
), again confirming what she wrote. ▫️7/n

The database was not taken down in Sep 2019 but after the start of the pandemic, as Shi Zhengli said.

https://twitter.com/flodebarre/status/1577401140345507859
 
Last edited:
You can think whatever you want @Planigale. Or you could make an effort to understand just what is in that 22,000 genome database for yourself.

The link in your quote is dead, and I cannot access DeBarre's Twitter, BTW.

This assertion of yours in particular is not backed up by any source and frankly without some evidence it's bull ****.
You may not like that they also support a laboratory leak source for HIV, but they do.
You can't back this up because it's false.

There are enough identified credentialed scientists in DRASTIC to know your attempt to dismiss them by claiming crap like that reflects on you, not on them.
Given the nature of the group it's not hard to find actual criticisms without making crap up. You should try it.

Not everyone in the scientific community takes DRASTIC to be a bunch of flakes. This citation from the Wiki page discusses the group in a way that appears even handed, even if the sentence leading to the citation isn't:
CNET: How the coronavirus origin story is being rewritten by a guerrilla Twitter group - The group, known as Drastic, has investigated, corrected, uncovered and agitated in a quest to uncover the pandemic's starting point.
Segreto, for instance, was falsely accused of attacking Angela Rasmussen, a virologist at the Georgetown Center for Global Health Science and Security, though this was denied by her former head of department. Rasmussen has stated Segreto has participated in attacks against her online, calling the conduct hurtful and upsetting.

And this:
On March 5, a group of scientists and researchers, in collaboration with some Drastic members including Demaneuf and Segreto, published an open letter in The Wall Street Journal and French publication Le Monde calling for a "full and unrestricted investigation" into the origins of the coronavirus. They reason that such an investigation can only be carried out by a team independent of the WHO, which did not have the capability to adequately scrutinize a leak when it visited Wuhan in early 2021.

Some signatories of the open letter have pointed out how important Drastic has been in finding clues and gathering data, including the link between RaTG13, the master's thesis and the miners. Yet even as Drastic has rattled the cages and unearthed a trail of obfuscation, their heavy-handed approach hasn't always been received positively by virologists, other researchers or the WHO.


Getting back to the Wiki page (and before you try to avoid a discussion by trashing the source, look at the citations).
DRASTIC
Many of DRASTIC's members use pseudonyms, while identified members have backgrounds including mycology,[11][12] neuroscience, and data science.[7][13]


In May 2020, a DRASTIC member discovered a master's thesis and a PhD thesis, according to which three bat guano miners from Mojiang county in Yunnan Province who fell ill with a pneumonia-like illness in 2012 had actually died from a SARS-like coronavirus.[8][14] After the miners fell ill, and before the causative agent was determined, Wuhan Institute of Virology scientists visited to collect virus samples to investigate whether the cause was a novel coronavirus.
While Wiki goes on to say the WIV determined the causative agent was fungal, those claims were not made until summer 2021. Where is a paper discussing this conclusion before the pandemic began? Was it not an important enough finding for scientists at the WIV to write this conclusion up? :rolleyes: Did they not look into those miners' illness despite traveling to the mine to investigate what killed these men and despite this was their whole field of study for more than a decade?


In September 2021, DRASTIC leaked a rejected grant proposal by EcoHealth Alliance and co-investigators, submitted to DARPA in 2018. The proposed project cost $14.2 million and was aimed at "defusing the threat of bat-borne coronaviruses". The leaked documents included a plan to insert "human-specific" furin cleavage sites into SARS-like bat coronaviruses. ...

While the mere presence of the furin cleavage site is not suspicious, some scientists argue the fact that these experiments were proposed raises concerns.[30][31][32]
And they have exposed a lot more.
 
So I got Huff's book yesterday. I read the last half first.

First from his webpage:
1) The guy has
a doctorate in environmental health science in an emerging infectious disease specialty track (PhD)
... who was the Vice President at the EchoHealth Alliance, (EHA).

He wasn't as EHA claims in their dissing of this whistleblower,

EcoHealth Alliance Statement Regarding Book by Andrew Huff
1) Mr. Huff was employed by the EcoHealth Alliance from 2014 to 2016. However, reports that he worked at or with the Wuhan Institute of Virology during that time are untrue. He was assigned to a completely different project working on computer-based algorithms to assess emerging disease threats.
So that's the role a VP would be assigned to? :rolleyes:

And if the project(s) he oversaw were to "assess emerging disease threats" it is exactly what Daszak and Shi were doing. Obviously Huff had to interact with Shi and the WIV even if you believe the analogy, "he was just a coffee boy" crap. :p

It's obvious why Huff was 'forced out'. He continually pointed out lapses in biosafety. It's typical for people like Daszak to dismiss risks and to not like them pointed out. What Huff describes happened over the couple of years he was there is realistic.

Huff presented his case that he was a legit whistleblower and that included some stuff one could easily interpret was that employee who complained over and over. It's no wonder he rubbed so many people the wrong way, especially smug Dr Daszak.

Huff appears to be exaggerating to some extent, but that's pretty standard in these tell-all books.

It's also clear as day an effort has been made to discredit him. And that case is obviously based on Huff being a threat because of what he's exposed. If Huff were no threat it wouldn't be hard to discredit him. But a PhD who advanced to the level of VP? Not so easy to discredit.

The saying, 'just because he's paranoid doesn't mean the FBI isn't after him' comes to mind.


I'll follow with what he exposed after I read more of the book. So far a lot matches what has already been suggested, the outbreak started as early as Aug, 2019. That's why Dec cases exploded the way they did.

And Huff believes military games attendees were infected. According to Huff the US military has to know this. Otherwise how do you explain no comment on testing attendees one way or the other?

Not sure how that fits with military attendees from multiple countries, not just the US. That needs more looking into. People were asking for an investigation yet none was forthcoming from any country. Seems at least odd.
 
Last edited:
Andrew Huff is self-discrediting.

I just went to his Twitter feed and the first thing I get is his promotion of RFK

https://twitter.com/dc_draino/status/1657093603926106131?s=46&t=BHmkcsLn6CV4ZBrdyNlAYQ

Second thing, denying masks work, while haranguing a healthcare professional:

https://twitter.com/aghuff/status/1657180848649633795?s=46&t=BHmkcsLn6CV4ZBrdyNlAYQ

A retweet of Glenn Beck saying he is going to make the Biden’s pay, and he needs YOUR help (aka money) to do it:

https://twitter.com/glennbeck/status/1657016154555052034?s=46&t=BHmkcsLn6CV4ZBrdyNlAYQ

I find it hard to trust what he says, especially second hand with all that spin.
 
EHA did not call him a coffee boy.

It was a rhetorical analogy. :rolleyes:

EHA did claim Huff had a job analyzing computer statistics and supposedly had no access to other things going on at the EHA, when he had been promoted to VP and had a relevant PhD. Also the years Huff worked there are significant as to what he's reported on in his book. Evidence gathered after he left the EHA need explaining as to where he got the information.

Huff is a mixed bag and I said so. But you can't dismiss him without actually looking at what he has to say. I don't give a rip if he supports RFK or if Glenn Beck has been fundraising for Huff and claims some Biden connection. I do care what Huff had to say that is supportable like the example I gave asking why the Army would not have tested soldiers returning from the military games in Wuhan. And what Huff has to say about Daszak matches exactly what we've seen of Daszak in public appearance like that interview at the Nipah conference.

It's clear Huff was a pain in the ass at EHA, he himself describes time and time again researchers were not following biosafety protocols. But there is corroborating evidence of those lapses in biosafety.

Baric's work at the UNC lab is always described as being the epitomy of safety. And yet:
Near Misses at UNC Chapel Hill’s High-Security Lab Illustrate Risk of Accidents With Coronaviruses
Reports indicate UNC researchers were potentially exposed to lab-created coronaviruses in several incidents since 2015. These incidents highlight the risks even in the most secure and respected research facilities


There is no perfect lab or perfectly followed protocols.


There's more and what I post from the book I will post corroborating evidence. I've bookmarked a bunch of stuff but I don't want to post things piecemeal.
 
I've already said very clearly, without any doubt whatsoever, multiple times, why. Are you not reading my posts again? :mad:

There's no discussion here if you can't/don't read my posts, short posts no less.

It is not really clear. You say....

It's obvious why Huff was 'forced out'. He continually pointed out lapses in biosafety. It's typical for people like Daszak to dismiss risks and to not like them pointed out. What Huff describes happened over the couple of years he was there is realistic.

Huff presented his case that he was a legit whistleblower and that included some stuff one could easily interpret was that employee who complained over and over. It's no wonder he rubbed so many people the wrong way, especially smug Dr Daszak.

Huff appears to be exaggerating to some extent, but that's pretty standard in these tell-all books.

It's clear Huff was a pain in the ass at EHA, he himself describes time and time again researchers were not following biosafety protocols. But there is corroborating evidence of those lapses in biosafety.

This looks like a self-serving narrative to me.

"I was fired because I was so concerned about biosafety whereas the poopyheads at EHA including the "smug" Daszak were extremely reckless.

So, are there documents that support this? EHA writing something like "You are hereby fired for being too noble for our despicable organization"?



I'll follow with what he exposed after I read more of the book. So far a lot matches what has already been suggested, the outbreak started as early as Aug, 2019. That's why Dec cases exploded the way they did.

And Huff believes military games attendees were infected. According to Huff the US military has to know this. Otherwise how do you explain no comment on testing attendees one way or the other?
Not sure how that fits with military attendees from multiple countries, not just the US. That needs more looking into. People were asking for an investigation yet none was forthcoming from any country. Seems at least odd.

How can this be attributed to inside knowledge given that Huff had already left the organization by 2016? How do we know that Huff had any inside knowledge at all that is relevant to the supposed lab leak?

It was a rhetorical analogy. :rolleyes:

Or maybe EHA accurately described his role as an analyst mostly involved with computer modelling on outbreaks. After all, his publication record is public record.

His area of expertise seems to be to do with food security and biosurveillance. I think he is trading here on an ambiguity about what "biosecurity" means. In other words, I don't think it is about the biosecurity of labs, but rather the threats posed to agriculture by pathogens.

EHA did claim Huff had a job analyzing computer statistics and supposedly had no access to other things going on at the EHA, when he had been promoted to VP and had a relevant PhD. Also the years Huff worked there are significant as to what he's reported on in his book. Evidence gathered after he left the EHA need explaining as to where he got the information.

Hmmm... promoted to VP? Of the entire organization? Is there some corroboration for that? I wonder why he would be that high up in the organization and only there for a couple of years. Does there really need to be any "explanation" about where he got his information? I think any of us, if we were just coffee boys could make claims about how the virus was spreading during the Wuhan Military Games. But none of us worked at EHA duing the Games. Not me, not you, not Huff. In other words, there is no clear way of working out if he is privy to genuine good information that isn't already publicly avaiable or how much he is simply making up. He seems like a crank and conspiracy theorist to me.

Huff is a mixed bag and I said so. But you can't dismiss him without actually looking at what he has to say. I don't give a rip if he supports RFK or if Glenn Beck has been fundraising for Huff and claims some Biden connection. I do care what Huff had to say that is supportable like the example I gave asking why the Army would not have tested soldiers returning from the military games in Wuhan. And what Huff has to say about Daszak matches exactly what we've seen of Daszak in public appearance like that interview at the Nipah conference.

"Mixed bag" is kind. A person supporting RFK Jr goes down as a crank in my book. And you can't start using publicly available information such as Daszak's interview as evidence that Huff has inside knowledge. Again, this is not "independent" corroboration. This is essentially one guy who once worked for EHA long before the pandemic who suddenly sees an opportunity to be relevant and is going on Infowars, a variety of right-wing conspiracy kook channels and saying stuff he has no business knowing about such as the US army, and various European armies covering up the Covid outbreak from the Wuhan Military Games. Seriously, think about it, Skeptic Ginger. Why the ever-living **** would all these militaries decide to cover this up? This is really on the insane side of things, and you are using someone who was fired in 2016 as a whistleblower on an organization that he says was responsible for a pandemic in 2019 that all the world's militaries are covering up, that the US government is covering up, that the world's media is covering up, etc... it is bat ****.

There's more and what I post from the book I will post corroborating evidence. I've bookmarked a bunch of stuff but I don't want to post things piecemeal.

Repeating lab leak claims is not what "corroborating" means. Huff is not a corroborative source.

I need to see some specifics.

Why was he fired?
What is the actual evidence, not just wild claims about stuff he cannot know?
 
Let's start here:
It is not really clear. You say....
Why was he fired?
What is the actual evidence, not just wild claims about stuff he cannot know?
Oh for pity's sake. :rolleyes:

Caught not reading my posts so you pretend I wasn't clear when you go back and see, whoops! I was very specific.

I think we can dismiss this continuation of you dissing sources regardless of their evidence.


This looks like a self-serving narrative to me.

"I was fired because I was so concerned about biosafety whereas the poopyheads at EHA including the "smug" Daszak were extremely reckless.
Of course it was self serving, I even said that. You quoted me saying that but didn't highlight that part.

SG said:
Huff presented his case that he was a legit whistleblower and that included some stuff one could easily interpret was that employee who complained over and over. It's no wonder he rubbed so many people the wrong way, especially smug Dr Daszak.

Huff appears to be exaggerating to some extent, but that's pretty standard in these tell-all books.
There I highlighted it for you. You don't think what Daszak has put out against Huff wasn't self serving?

Let's compare from my posts and yours:
Me: "Huff was that employee who complained over and over."
EHA: "Huff had a job analyzing computer statistics."
You: "Or maybe EHA accurately described his role as an analyst mostly involved with computer modelling on outbreaks."

You and the EHA are describing a member of a team. Huff was promoted to VP! Have you ever worked for a large company where the VP's role was described as an analyst? Seriously?


How can this be attributed to inside knowledge given that Huff had already left the organization by 2016? How do we know that Huff had any inside knowledge at all that is relevant to the supposed lab leak?
I haven't gotten to that part yet, have some patience.


His area of expertise seems to be to do with food security and biosurveillance. I think he is trading here on an ambiguity about what "biosecurity" means. In other words, I don't think it is about the biosecurity of labs, but rather the threats posed to agriculture by pathogens.
Great, saved me some rabbit hole time. There are 9 published papers there with Huff's name on them from 2013 to 2020. Not sure how you boiled the list down to food safety. The titles almost all have to do with pandemics and infection control issues.


Hmmm... promoted to VP? Of the entire organization?
There might be 1 or 2 VPs with the rest titled Associate VPs. It was hard to tell from a brief glance at their organizational chart.

From those evil people over at Fox News book reviews:
Dr. Andrew G. Huff, a former executive at the now-controversial scientific research group EcoHealth Alliance which has been swept up in the firestorm surrounding the origins of COVID-19, authored a new book he says outlines the Wuhan lab-leak theory as a fact.

Huff, an Iraq War veteran and a former research fellow at the Department of Homeland Security's Centers of Excellence, offers a unique perspective with insight from the intel community in his book, "The Truth About Wuhan: How I Uncovered the Biggest Lie in History."
Did you make any effort at all to look at Huff's bio before you dismissed him as a minor player at the EHA?


Is there some corroboration for that?
Did you see the EHA denying that fact?


I wonder why he would be that high up in the organization and only there for a couple of years.
Not everyone who becomes VP of a large corporation starts out in the mailroom. He was first promoted to Assistant VP then VP. I'll have to look again at what position he was initially hired as. Huff didn't get hired at the EHA right out of college. People at the top of large corporations are most often hired away from management positions at other corporations.


Does there really need to be any "explanation" about where he got his information? I think any of us, if we were just coffee boys could make claims about how the virus was spreading during the Wuhan Military Games. But none of us worked at EHA duing the Games. Not me, not you, not Huff. In other words, there is no clear way of working out if he is privy to genuine good information that isn't already publicly avaiable or how much he is simply making up. He seems like a crank and conspiracy theorist to me.

"Mixed bag" is kind. A person supporting RFK Jr goes down as a crank in my book. And you can't start using publicly available information such as Daszak's interview as evidence that Huff has inside knowledge. Again, this is not "independent" corroboration. This is essentially one guy who once worked for EHA long before the pandemic who suddenly sees an opportunity to be relevant and is going on Infowars, a variety of right-wing conspiracy kook channels and saying stuff he has no business knowing about such as the US army, and various European armies covering up the Covid outbreak from the Wuhan Military Games. Seriously, think about it, Skeptic Ginger. Why the ever-living **** would all these militaries decide to cover this up? This is really on the insane side of things, and you are using someone who was fired in 2016 as a whistleblower on an organization that he says was responsible for a pandemic in 2019 that all the world's militaries are covering up, that the US government is covering up, that the world's media is covering up, etc... it is bat ****.

Repeating lab leak claims is not what "corroborating" means. Huff is not a corroborative source.

I need to see some specifics.
Guess you missed this part of my post even though you quoted it:
SG said:
There's more and what I post from the book I will post corroborating evidence. I've bookmarked a bunch of stuff but I don't want to post things piecemeal.


Now I've wasted more time because you didn't read what I posted and because you were so anxious to diss Huff and discount what he had to say, you attacked my comments prematurely.
 
Last edited:
His area of expertise seems to be to do with food security and biosurveillance. I think he is trading here on an ambiguity about what "biosecurity" means. In other words, I don't think it is about the biosecurity of labs, but rather the threats posed to agriculture by pathogens.

Great, saved me some rabbit hole time. There are 9 published papers there with Huff's name on them from 2013 to 2020. Not sure how you boiled the list down to food safety. The titles almost all have to do with pandemics and infection control issues.


When I looked at that list, there were only 8 published papers in the list. There were 3 citations. The third of those citations appears to be a self-citation:
[CITATION] Romanticism to Nazism: The German Youth Movement
AG Huff - 1972 - Harvard University​

Of the 8 published papers, only 1 was published after 2016:
Jessica D. Garcia, Andrew G. Huff and Emily S. Huff. Understanding farmers’ biosecurity beliefs and behaviours related to antimicrobial resistant bacteria in Michigan, USA. Animal Production Science 60(5) 674-682 https://doi.org/10.1071/AN18765
Submitted: 29 June 2018 Accepted: 9 July 2019 Published: 7 February 2020​
That paper was submitted in June 2018, accepted in July 2019, and is concerned with "what preventative measures farmers may or may not be using to decrease human and animal exposure to" bacteria rather than viruses.

Andrew Huff describes qualifications and experience that would be consistent with "a job analyzing computer statistics", as Skeptic Ginger put it:
Andrew Huff said:
I earned degrees in psychology (BA), security technologies and geographic information systems (MS), and a doctorate in environmental health science in an emerging infectious disease specialty track (PhD) at the University of Minnesota. After graduation, I continued my education at MIT in complex systems modeling and analysis. This is how I learned to use qualitative and quantitative methods to analyze complex problems.


On her ResearchGate page, Emily Huff shortens the title of the paper cited above to "Understanding Farmers". She describes herself thusly:
Emily Huff said:
I am an Assistant Professor in Human Dimensions of Natural Resources in the Department of Forestry at Michigan State University. I study coupled human and natural systems using qualitative, quantitative, and predictive modeling approaches.


The first author, Jessica D Garcia, earned a BS in Biology at Texas State University in San Marcos, what appears to be a doctorate in veterinary medicine from Ohio State University, and is currently working on her master's degree in education at the University of Tennessee while holding a position at that university as "Large Animal Internal Medicine Resident".

Considering the backgrounds and publications of the three co-authors of A G Huff's most recent publication (in 2018), I too find myself wondering why A G Huff or his co-authors would have any inside information about the origins of Covid-19.
 
Let's start here:Oh for pity's sake. :rolleyes:

Caught not reading my posts so you pretend I wasn't clear when you go back and see, whoops! I was very specific.

I'm not pretending anything. It is unclear why he was fired.

I want the specifics about his firing. What is the story?

Are you claiming that EHA fired him for warning them about biosecurity?

I don't believe it at all.
 
Of course it was self serving, I even said that. You quoted me saying that but didn't highlight that part.

This merely seems to be you acknowledging that your BS detector was going off while reading his book, but you decided to rationalize it as just a normal thing for tell-all books.
 
Oh look! This is a blurb from Michigan State University about his credentials.

Dr. Andrew Huff is a multidisciplinary scientist and conducts research in high performance computing, risk analysis, bioterrorism, spatial analysis, modeling and simulation, epidemiology, emerging infectious disease ecology, and environmental health as it relates to agricultural and biological food production systems, biosurveillance systems, and public health.

Link

That fits with what EHA say they employed him for...

1) Mr. Huff was employed by the EcoHealth Alliance from 2014 to 2016. However, reports that he worked at or with the Wuhan Institute of Virology during that time are untrue. He was assigned to a completely different project working on computer-based algorithms to assess emerging disease threats.

Link

And that fits his publication record as well.

In other words, the corroborating evidence suggests he was doing analysis on how pathogens affect food security, not working in the WIV on gain of function research and peering into Zhengli Shi's secret bat enclosures where they extracted SARS-like viruses and did serial passaging on them and/or where miners from the Mojiang mine were subject to ever-more potent viruses until they died and Zhengli Shi said, "Errmmm just a fungus!" etc...
 
According to this Reddit thread...

Andrew Huff finally got his story of COVID being lab-made out via NY Post this past weekend. Biggest story ever. Hannity had him on 2 minutes. Alex Jones had him on for hours. Game over. Gates/Fauci/Daszak/DARPA exposed. The CIA sent a gunman to kill him at his house, but he outgunned him. Legendary

Link

Apparently this comes from an Alex Jones episode (I wonder if Knowledge Fight have covered it?)...

The Twitter screenshot is of Huff saying he has one of the "biggest stories of 2023" but is sitting on it because it is unrelated to Covid.

Commenters be skeptical:

If you hanger the biggest story and the CIA is after you......... Why the **** would you wait to reveal it. I call nonsense on this one

And advertise it on twitter, info wars and now he wants to hopefully be on Rogan. Just sounds like he wants to sell his book lmao.

Does someone have a link to him smoking a CIA agent?

Seems like ********, Jones cuts him off right at the end to go to commercial, then doesn’t revisit it.

But hey... looks like you can watch Alex Jones interview Huff to get the full story...

https://banned.video/watch?id=638fb57c5aa67c07101b7456
 
You can think whatever you want @Planigale. Or you could make an effort to understand just what is in that 22,000 genome database for yourself.

The link in your quote is dead, and I cannot access DeBarre's Twitter, BTW.

This assertion of yours in particular is not backed up by any source and frankly without some evidence it's bull ****.You can't back this up because it's false.

There are enough identified credentialed scientists in DRASTIC to know your attempt to dismiss them by claiming crap like that reflects on you, not on them.
Given the nature of the group it's not hard to find actual criticisms without making crap up. You should try it.

Not everyone in the scientific community takes DRASTIC to be a bunch of flakes. This citation from the Wiki page discusses the group in a way that appears even handed, even if the sentence leading to the citation isn't:
CNET: How the coronavirus origin story is being rewritten by a guerrilla Twitter group - The group, known as Drastic, has investigated, corrected, uncovered and agitated in a quest to uncover the pandemic's starting point.


And this:



Getting back to the Wiki page (and before you try to avoid a discussion by trashing the source, look at the citations).
DRASTIC



While Wiki goes on to say the WIV determined the causative agent was fungal, those claims were not made until summer 2021. Where is a paper discussing this conclusion before the pandemic began? Was it not an important enough finding for scientists at the WIV to write this conclusion up? :rolleyes: Did they not look into those miners' illness despite traveling to the mine to investigate what killed these men and despite this was their whole field of study for more than a decade?


And they have exposed a lot more.

This is the problem. What they have 'exposed' is nonsense. They have thrown lots of mud hoping some will stick.

Yes there are 'credentialed' scientists but none with relevant expertise. There publications are based on anonymous unsourced leaks or are just mud slinging and noise.

The death of miners from pneumonia in 2012 is irrelevant to SARS-CoV-2 years later. This is a classic description of a fungal pneumonia. Literally if you put this story in a medical exam the answer would fungal pneumonia. No virus was isolated, subsequent testing of blood samples showed no evidence of SARS or SARS-CoV-2 infection, the illness was not SARS-CoV-2 which would not cause a 30% mortality rate in young people. There would be no reason for Shi to conceal a pathogenic coronavirus years before the pandemic. To the contrary this would have made her career and brought in funding. The whole miners story was just irrelevant noise and mud slinging a responsible group would have realised it was irrelevant.

There were not 22,000 genomes in the WIV database. There were 22,000 entries, samples from bat anal swabs, bat blood samples, tics, guano; the vast majority of which would have had no virus, some of which would have had fragments of RNA, very few of which (about a dozen) were sufficient to obtain whole genome sequencing, and three of which had viable (cultural) virus. A database with 22,000 entries does not mean 22,000 full gene sequences. Claiming this is just untrue. It is mud slinging. The database was set up in June 2019, briefly shut down for maintenance in September 2019, and shut down in february 2020. There is no evidence it was meant to be anything other than an internal laboratory resource, nor that it was ever intended to be publicly accessible. Most laboratories will have internal databases of work they are doing, but these will not be intended for public access, when sequences are ready for publication they are uploaded to public databases. There is immense sensitivity to middle income country researchers collecting data then it being swept up by better resourced researchers from the west and published with minimal recognition of those who collected the and originated the data. WIV cannot give people access to a database of 22,000 gene sequences because it is a fantasy database, people cannot have access to what does not exist.

The allegation that there were bat colonies at WIV is unsubstantiated, other than by an anonymous leak and video of a different laboratory.

The alleged gain of function research at WIV was not gain of function research* and could not have led to SARS-CoV-2. What they mainly do is argue that gain of function research is a bad thing, WIV might have done gain of function research, a pandemic is a bad thing. The pandemic stared in Wuhan therefore gain of function research at WIV was the cause. Or in another document that the development of a LAV SARS virus in the US was tested in Wuhan and somehow changed into SARS-CoV-2. Again an impossible event.

None of what DRASTIc argues might have happened could have led to SARS-CoV-2, it is just scientifically impossible. They just produce lots of innuendo and irrelevancy.

* https://www.factcheck.org/2021/05/the-wuhan-lab-and-the-gain-of-function-disagreement/
 
Last edited:
I'm not pretending anything. It is unclear why he was fired.

I want the specifics about his firing. What is the story?

Are you claiming that EHA fired him for warning them about biosecurity?

I don't believe it at all.
I'm not sure why you don't believe it.

He describes himself (my words, not his) as a royal pain in the ass, complaining all the time in meetings and about all the people they worked with. And it's biosafety not biosecurity, a subtle difference. Huff noted no one took his reports seriously.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom