Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
OK, I take that back. It was a year ago and I'm positive that since that time I made clear my position was neither hypothesis was off the table.I believe there was this one in which Daszak's discussion with Racaniello is taken as evidence that the viruses must have leaked from a lab.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=13430705&postcount=377
You do have to admit that was pretty darn close to an outright admission they were manipulating SARS-like CoVs in the lab at the same time the outbreak started right in the WIV's backyard. And it was just before he found out that comment had some pretty bad implications. I don't believe he ever revisited it to say he meant something else.
Moving forward Bloom had something new to add today. He's been honest about tracking the origin of COVID except he went out of his way to support Shi when she explained the removed genome fragments he found in the cloud. I understand that.
There's a lot quoted here but it is only a small portion of the news article which is long and thorough. People should read the whole article.
Raccoon dogs did not start COVID-19, new study says
The spillover hypothesis side does get carried away with "smoking gun" framing.“The COVID lab leak theory is dead,” declared Edward Holmes, one of the researchers involved in the raccoon dog study.
This is where DeBarre came in.
An evolutionary biologist in France named Florence Débarre spotted the new data and, according to the Atlantic, notified colleagues around the world. With their enormous collection of genetic material from different species, the GISAID samples were a chronicle of the Huanan market in the earliest days of the pandemic. Here, possibly, in the endless string of genetic sequences, lay hidden the origin story of SARS-CoV-2.
Despite what China had to say about the finding:
Chinese scientists had already analyzed all the Huanan swabs, surmising that “the market may [have] acted as an amplifier of transmission due to the high number of visitors every day.” Their study explicitly discounted the possibility that the virus had jumped from an animal to humans.
Worobey, Andersen, and Holmes got excited.
From there the news article summarizes a bit of the supporters' POVs about the 2 hypotheses over the last 3 years.Now, working with the raw data, Kristian Andersen, Michael Worobey and Holmes came to an entirely different conclusion. They believed that the pandemic had begun in stall 29, on the southwestern edge of the market.
In that stall sat caged raccoon dogs.
“The Strongest Evidence Yet That an Animal Started the Pandemic,” said the headline of the Atlantic article that broke the news.
This explains a lot about DeBarre and others confusing the larger database revealed by DRASTIC and this database of the swabs taken from the market. So apparently there were 3 databases, one from Sept 2019, one from Shi's paper that Bloom found in the cloud and this one recently released where the Chinese revealed the genetic data they found in market swabs that they had kept secret for a couple years.
I found that interesting that Worobey appeared to take a fairly bias confirming look at the market data.Unlike some other researchers looking for the pandemic’s origins, Bloom was not a self-promoter. He did not attack critics on Twitter or make wild, unsupportable claims. “He is the most ethical scientist I know. He wants to dig deep and discover the truth,” a fellow scientist told Vanity Fair.
The raccoon dog revelation gave Bloom a new project. The data used by the Worobey group had been removed from GISAID, only to materialize there again in more fulsome form in late March. Whereas the raccoon dog group had worked with 227 FASTQ files — the format used to store long strings of genetic code — there were 696 FASTQ files in the Huanan sequences that reappeared on GISAID several weeks later.
Working with the bigger database, Bloom processed an astonishing three terabytes of data from the Huanan Market — genetic sequences from the same swabs taken in early 2020 that Worobey and his collaborators thought pointed to raccoon dogs.
Bloom’s analysis did not merely look at where coronavirus and animal genetic material commingled but also at how thorough that commingling had been. And while the Worobey group had only examined mammalian DNA, Bloom sifted through every strand of genetic material, regardless of whether it came from a chicken, a human or a cut of beef.
In a paper published in late April, Bloom wrote that “the samples that contain abundant material from raccoon dogs and other non-human susceptible species generally contain little or no SARS-CoV-2 reads.” ...
In other words, the Chinese researchers who had been the first to study the swabs, and had concluded that humans carried the virus to the market, appeared to have been correct all along.
As for the raccoon dog, it was unquestionably innocent. “There is a negative correlation between the abundance of SARS-CoV-2 and mitochondrial material from raccoon dogs,” Bloom wrote.
The most viral material came from swabs with DNA from stalls where seafood such as catfish and largemouth bass were sold.
This was weird:
Worobey, Andersen and Holmes did not respond to a request for comment. Nor did several other researchers listed as co-authors on the raccoon dog paper. Alexander Crits-Christoph of Johns Hopkins was the sole respondent. He sent Yahoo News an insulting email in response to questions raised by the new study.
Chan weighed in:
“The raccoon dog team made a big fuss out of what is most likely a contaminated sample,” molecular biologist Alina Chan of the Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard told Yahoo News.
“Not only is there no correlation between raccoon dog and virus genetic material, but even the only sample with both raccoon dog and virus was likely cross-contaminated during the sample processing,” she said.
And Bloom was his usual neutral self:
In his paper, Bloom argues that his study does not contradict the raccoon dog hypothesis but, rather, merely points out the near impossibility of using the market swabs to reach any meaningful conclusion about viral origins.
“A careful analysis of these samples does not prove or disprove any particular scenario for how the virus entered the market,” Bloom told Yahoo News, “but does suggest that genetic analysis of the samples is not directly informative for answering that question.”
The news article goes on to address the media's role distorting the facts. I have noted this problem between Trump, Biden, and all the rest of the politics it has made a jolly mess of the actual evidence. Maybe this is where Planigale got confused about HIV being in the mix but I don't know:
FactCheck.org labeled the notion that the coronavirus originated in a laboratory a “baseless conspiracy theory,” putting credible questions about a lab leak into the same category as obviously untrue claims that the SARS-CoV-2 virus contained strains of HIV.
And can people in this thread please stop claiming no reputable scientists support the lab origin hypothesis? I do get tired of hearing that BS.
“The origin of COVID-19 debate has gotten so fierce that there are solid scientists on both sides who will take any chance to say there is new evidence bolstering their preferred hypothesis,” she said.
It is especially prevalent in the media:
IMO they were bamboozled by Daszak's efforts to make the lab hypothesis look like a CT.She and others faulted the media for continuing to favor the market origin — and for not applying sufficient scrutiny to the raccoon dog claim.
Dissenting opinions to Blooms conclusions are noted in the news article.
Here'a a link to Bloom's paper:
Association between SARS-CoV-2 and metagenomic content of samples from the Huanan Seafood Market - Jesse D. Bloom