1) The Database.
The database was still online in February 2020.
In your piece, you put a link to the DRASTIC report, but you could have checked instead the original source, the monitoring website, which was still online at the time you wrote your text.
Briefly, DRASTIC & collaborators discovered that a database of bat and rodent viruses used to be shared publicly by WIV, and is not available anymore. Using a website monitoring access to the database, they estimated the database was put offline in Sep 2019.
When asked about it, Shi Zhengli explained in emails, in interviews, and to the WHO joint mission, that the database had been put offline after the pandemic started, because of hacking attempts… which is incompatible with the alleged Sep 2019 date.

3/n
Now there are different possible attitudes towards this contradiction:
a) Continue to use the Sep 2019 date (thereby implying that Shi Zhengli and others were wrong, or even lied); or
b) Check whether the Sep 2019 date is correct.

4/n
The monitoring website (
http://msis.csdb.cn) was still accessible in early 2022 (h/t
@coroldo1
). I accessed it, and it showed that the database was still available until February 2020. That is, after the pandemic started, like Shi Zhengli said.
[reposted]

5/n
The monitoring website also shows that the database was never much active, and only started existing in June 2019... Which is quite far from the picture of a major public website suddenly removed that is painted by some.

6/n
Another point of Shi Zhengli’s reply (image in tweet 3) can be checked with publicly available data, namely when WIV started working on this database project (h/t
@zhihuachen
), again confirming what she wrote.
Another point of Shi Zhengli’s reply (image in tweet 3) can be checked with publicly available data, namely when WIV started working on this database project (h/t
@zhihuachen), again confirming what she wrote.
https://t.co/BYtaCvodT8

7/n
The database was not taken down in Sep 2019 but after the start of the pandemic, as Shi Zhengli said.
But this piece of misinformation keeps spreading.

8/n
I hope that journalists who repeated the incorrect Sep 2019 date will be able to update their papers
(Feb 2020 confirmed by
https://technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-covid-lab-leak-wuhan/…)

9/n
Finally, there are also some people who have been informed that the Sep 2019 date is incorrect (or even who suspected from the start it was), but continue to propagate it to raise suspicion around WIV's activities.
This is downright unethical coming from scientists.

10/end
The people who keep spreading the incorrect Sep 2019 date want us to believe that the database would have been taken down because it contained info showing that WIV is at the origin of SARS-CoV-2's emergence, such as a progenitor virus, or its building blocks;

11/+
And somehow, all the world would have missed these publicly available incriminating sequences -- or, some people would have known about them and kept quiet to protect WIV.

12/+
he (erroneous) Sep 2019 date points at something nefarious having been done at WIV, because there would have been no reason otherwise to take down the database before the pandemic began.
It is dishonest to keep spreading this misinformation.

12/+
I focused the thread on the date the database was taken down, but it is not even clear whether the database was ever really accessed by people outside of WIV.
(More details in the quoted thread and the tweets it cites)

14/n
Coroldo1
@coroldo1
1. If we agree on referring to the 61.5MB database, it's not public accessible from the traffic monitoring system.
Though WIV geographical located in Wuhan, central China.
WIV was using CSTNET, WIV's IP address was/is/and always will be in Beijing.....
Too long full quote here:
6.4GB was downloaded from the 61.5MB SQL database from within the China science and technology network, (CSTN), nearly all from Beijing, equivalent to 100 DB downloads'
I don't mind also sharing following��
https://twitter.com/coroldo1/status/1464432876234043392…
twitter.com/zhihuachen/status/1464022337796382730…
So, public/external/intetnal access interpretation were all based on false assumption, not knowing the fact that WIV's own configuration in June 2019 showed up in monitoring system as from 'Beijing'. Sorry we are not in Chinese social media platform, otherwise these interpretation would be flooded with rebuttal immediately. The CAS Network is too famous for internet history, and first email from China was sent from there. CSTNET is an INTRANET, not an Internet.
So to wrap up:
1. 61.5 MB, the file types, file sizes, etc from traffic monitoring system(the exact same one used to accuse WIV took it offline), did not, with a single thread of evidence of its status as public accessible to external users.
If the accuser knew WIV was in CSTNET.
2. 61.5MB, nor did evidence it's offline in September 2019. I know ppl might start shifting goalpost about the 'definition of offline', or we 'moved on', we 'just suggested maybe'.
Most of the volume was due to IPs in Beijing, and it turns out that this is where WIV is registered (cf. quoted tweet)

15/n
Additionally, most of the volume was concentrated on June 18-19, 2019, which we can interpret as tests of the database in the context of the CSData paper describing it.

16/+