Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

I'll have to look further at your post before commenting more on it.

We discussed the miner's fungal diagnosis at length. I'll see if I can find it in the thread. There is no evidence they died of a fungal disease except as a secondary infection. They were treated initially with anti-fungals and did not get better.

Shi brought up the fungal sidetrack in a late comment, IIRC. It wasn't something that was in anything she discussed about the miners before that. And the lung samples they took from the miners has not been produced. There was an antibody test on blood from the miners. We had a discussion about just which test was done. I'll have to look that up.

!) From memory they did not get treated with anti-fungals.
2) sadly even with anti-fungal treatment people die of fungal pneumonia
3) The illness they had was clearly not covid 19. The mortality rate was too high.

FWIW I would be an expert on pneumonia and have certainly seen fungal pneumonias, viral pneumonias etc. The original description of the miners illness was not typical for covid-19. It might fit better with SARS which has a much higher mortality. Most of the features are non-specific raised risk of thrombosis, raised inflammatory markers occur with all pneumonias, there are no particular features other then the radiology which are unique to covid-19. The fungal infection associated with bats is histoplasmosis, there is no record of this being tested for.
 
Last edited:
The media uses that term. I don't believe I have though I may have used the term mutations given they are what led to the variants.
GoF is the proper scientific term.


You can make these claims all you want. There are multiple pieces of evidence they indeed were working on GoF with SARS-like CoVs at the WIV.


There are two things here. 1) Were they manipulating SARS-like CoVs? Daszak himself said in an interview how easily this is done. Have you listened to him that video? You only need to hear a few minutes, not the whole interview.

2) You claim that some wild-type bat viruses "found with a higher affinity for ACE2 than early strains of SARS-CoV-2."

Are you referring to this 2015 article in Nature? A SARS-like cluster of circulating bat coronaviruses shows potential for human emergence This is when Shi was in North Carolina working with Baric in the UNC lab.

This might be a big part of your misunderstanding. Baric did use a pseudo-type virus with a different backbone. His biosafety control was impeccable compared to that used at the WIV.

None of that work directly preceded the development of COVID. After that research Shi took what she learned back to the WIV along with acquiring the humanized mice. Biosafety at the WIV was quite different than it was at the lab at the UNC.

This is all documented in this thread. It's no wonder you are asserting erroneous things if you are getting them from that 2015 paper.


I don't understand why you think this. I recommend you read what humanized mice are and how those plus also using human respiratory cells in cultures result in viruses adapted to human respiratory cells.

A humanized mouse is a mouse carrying functioning human genes, cells, tissues, and/or organs. Humanized mice are commonly used as small animal models in biological and medical research for human therapeutics.


That was Fauci's weird backpedal. There is no evidence that's how it happened. The evidence supports the hypothesis COVID was the result of GoF work done on SARS-like CoVs in the WIV lab, most likely in 2018-2019.


I haven't read the Senate report so I can't comment on everything here. What I can comment on is there is existing evidence posted in the thread which contradicts many of your conclusions.

For example you ask why would they develop a vaccine for a virus that did not exist. That was what EcoHealth Alliance, working with Dr Shi at the WIV stated was their goal. It's in writing. It's in Daszak's interview. That was the whole point of their research, develop the vaccine before another spillover of a SARS-like CoV occurs. Daszak's goal was reasonable. How they were going about it was not.


There are satellite images showing the hospital being built in response to the pandemic. It went up in a couple weeks.

I don'y think you read peoples posts before replying to them.

Re affinity of wild bats for human ACE 2 being greater than SARS-CoV-2 is referenced above but I will repost.
A claim previously made is that SARS-Cov-2 was highly adapted for human ACE-2 receptor, but wild type related viruses have a higher affinity for human ACE2 receptor than early SARS-CoV-2 isolates. So this shows that claims that SARS-coV-2 must have been pre-adapted to humans is untrue.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-022-04532-4

You claim that Shi collected bats and took them back to WIV. There is no evidence for this and workers at WIV deny this.

You claim the Database was offline but as referenced above Flo Debarre was able to access it in February 2020. Showing this claim was false.

A number of virologists have said the work done was not gain of function because it was not designed to cause a gain in function. Empirically from the results it did nit do so.

I have never denied that work was done using a mouse SARS like virus, I have repeatedly said so, but you cannot get SARS-CoV-2 from a SARS-CoV-1 virus. They are too distantly related.

I explain to you that the humanised mice used had a single human gene for the ACE 2 receptor replacing the mouse receptor. That was the only way in which the were humanised.

The group the senate report said had developed a vaccine was not the Shi's WIV group, so the Ecohealth grant is irrelevant and there was no immediate funding to develop a vaccine in anywise. There is no evidence Shi's group were working on a vaccine and the senate report does not suggest they did so, nor have they since, they are not vaccinologists.
 
Didn't you just post this:
So nothing in the Twitter feed was new then? :boggled:

No, it was a round-up of responses to common lab leak talking points.


Maybe if you'd actually skim the bullet points I post instead of skipping everything because long posts apparently overwhelm you, you'd see the lab leak hypothesis is incredibly coherent.

Not yet it isn't.
 
!) From memory they did not get treated with anti-fungals.
Well they did. Four of the six got antifungals. The two that didn't were among the 3 survivors. Those 2 were discharged before they got secondary fungal infections.

2) sadly even with anti-fungal treatment people die of fungal pneumonia
3) The illness they had was clearly not covid 19. The mortality rate was too high.
The medical providers who cared for or consulted about care for these patients, and the writers and/or commenters on the master's and doctorate theses concluded the fungus was secondary.

It's not relevant that people can die from primary fungal infections. These 3 did not.

We are at one of many dead horse points in this exchange. :deadhorse

FWIW I would be an expert on pneumonia and have certainly seen fungal pneumonias, viral pneumonias etc. The original description of the miners illness was not typical for covid-19. It might fit better with SARS which has a much higher mortality. Most of the features are non-specific raised risk of thrombosis, raised inflammatory markers occur with all pneumonias, there are no particular features other then the radiology which are unique to covid-19. The fungal infection associated with bats is histoplasmosis, there is no record of this being tested for.
It was in 2012, of course it wasn't the exact SARS-like coronavirus as the pandemic strain. No one has said they brought COVID-19 itself back from the mine for heaven's sake! Only 6 miners got infected and no one who wasn't cleaning the mine got sick. That's a very different pattern from both SARS1 and COVID.

Read this so it will make more sense to you:
The lab leak origin hypothesizes the following: Shi and others were researching dangerous coronaviruses they collected from horseshoe bats in Yunnan. Both SARS1 and most likely the virus the 6 miners became infected with arose from the reservoir of coronaviruses in those bats.

They did not "engineer" COVID. They did not directly insert genes into the viruses they were working on.

But they were almost certainly "manipulating coronaviruses in the lab" because Daszak said as much.


Re affinity of wild bats for human ACE 2 being greater than SARS-CoV-2 is referenced above but I will repost.
That is old news already addressed in the thread. We discussed at length when the coronaviruses were found in Laos that were closer to COVID than the RaTG13 virus..

It doesn't mean there wasn't GoF research going on at the WIV. From the link:
None of these bat viruses contains a furin cleavage site in the spike protein. Our findings therefore indicate that bat-borne SARS-CoV-2-like viruses that are potentially infectious for humans circulate in Rhinolophus spp. in the Indochinese peninsula.
The furin site cleavage has not been found in the sarbecoviruses, only in more distantly related coronaviruses.


You claim that Shi collected bats and took them back to WIV. There is no evidence for this and workers at WIV deny this.
Stop ignoring the evidence posted. Re the live bats at the WIV, there is a lot of evidence from a variety of sources. I doubt Shi collected them herself BTW, her students and staff did. :deadhorse

You claim the Database was offline but as referenced above Flo Debarre was able to access it in February 2020. Showing this claim was false.
No, not the full database. I'll address this stuff in my reply to AS coming up. The woman has made a number of unsupportable claims including this one.

A number of virologists have said the work done was not gain of function because it was not designed to cause a gain in function. Empirically from the results it did nit do so.
Evidence posted they were doing GoF research, lots of evidence. :deadhorse

I have never denied that work was done using a mouse SARS like virus, I have repeatedly said so, but you cannot get SARS-CoV-2 from a SARS-CoV-1 virus. They are too distantly related.
What is a "mouse SARS-like virus"? There is no such thing. There were rats that were sampled which harbored different viruses. Those viruses couldn't be directly connected to the miner's illnesses.


I explain to you that the humanised mice used had a single human gene for the ACE 2 receptor replacing the mouse receptor. That was the only way in which the were humanised.
Baric's humanized mice have been described with citations. Shi asked him to send her some. He did. All evidence cited in the thread. :deadhorse

The group the senate report said had developed a vaccine was not the Shi's WIV group, so the Ecohealth grant is irrelevant and there was no immediate funding to develop a vaccine in anywise. There is no evidence Shi's group were working on a vaccine and the senate report does not suggest they did so, nor have they since, they are not vaccinologists.
No one said Shi was working on the vaccine at the WIV. Daszak said that was the ultimate goal of manipulating the coronaviruses in the lab, to develop a vaccine before another natural SARS-like CoV spillover occurred.

The WIV was not the only lab with researchers EcoHealth Alliance was doling out US research grant money to. He was coordinating a lot of the research, looking in multiple places for potential spillover events. I'm not going to go over all that again. :deadhorse
 
No, it was a round-up of responses to common lab leak talking points.

Not yet it isn't.
And yet the number of virologists and other experts see a coherent lab leak hypothesis.

I'll address DeBarre next. The claims are full of **** at first glance.
 
Well they did. Four of the six got antifungals. The two that didn't were among the 3 survivors. Those 2 were discharged before they got secondary fungal infections.

Huh?

This is not supported by evidence. I don't think anywhere has established that the fungus was a secondary infection.

Also, two of the three who recovered had anti-fungals. I think the sixth one was not as seriously ill as the others.

Remember that they also were treated and admitted to smaller clinics at different times as well, from what I remember.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8490156/table/tbl1/

All of them seemed to have been given various steroids, anti-virals (in most cases), anti-biotics and anti-fungals (in most cases).

So I don't think we can make strong claims either way. The three who died tended to be older, have had complicating medical issues as well, etc... and from what I remember were exposed to the mine for longer. So to point out that one of the survivors didn't have anti-fungals, and one of the deceased didn't have an anti-viral proves that Shi lied and covered up the discovery of Covid-19 in a mineshaft seems far-fetched.
 
Also the symptoms of the miners' condition is described there. Maybe SG and Plainigale can chime in on whether those symptoms are the same or similar to that of Covid-19.

One of the miners actually seemed to have died a month after getting "Severe ascites".
 
I’ll see what I can do. Not sure how the formatting will work, but let’s try…
Hi @zeynep,
Last week in Geneva, I told you that your 2021 @nytimes Opinion on Covid origin had not aged well.
You challenged me to find errors. Here are some. ▫️1/
Link: nytimes.com/2021/06/25/opi…

Disclaimer: in June 2021, I believed the stories I am about to debunk. I had been introduced to them by someone I trusted; I had not yet worked on them and taken the time to check them. ▫️2/

Opinion | Where Did the Coronavirus Come From? What We Already Know Is Troubling. (Published 2021)
Even if the coronavirus did not emerge from a lab, the groundwork for a potential disaster had been laid for years, and learning its lessons is essential to preventing others.
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/25/o...virus-lab.html
This was Daszak's stated goal. There's nothing to debunk. It would be fine if they hadn't unleashed the thing they were trying to prevent.

Hubris comes to mind.


1) The Database.
The database was still online in February 2020.
In your piece, you put a link to the DRASTIC report, but you could have checked instead the original source, the monitoring website, which was still online at the time you wrote your text. ▫️3/
For example, the same group...
You will find more details on the database in this thread. ▫️4/
This takes a bit of sorting.

There is the large genome database the Chinese government removed access to in Sept 2019. This was revealed by DRASTIC.

And there was the database of 4 coronavirus genomes in Shi's paper that was removed from the paper (published in the US), found in the cloud by Jesse Bloom then explained by Dr Shi to Bloom's satisfaction and put back in the paper. IIRC Bloom was interested in the full genomes and he got those.

I don't think the dates of Bloom's cloud data match up at all to what DeBarre is talking about .

Re the large database China blocked which was not associated with any study, the NYTs reports access was reestablished July 30th 2021. I don't have access to the article but this is from the search blurb:
Chinese researchers have uploaded genetic sequences of coronaviruses to a scientific database more than a year after they took them offline.
That certainly confirms the database was not online in Feb 2020 as DeBarre claims. I don't know what to make of DeBarre's assertion except it would be very odd for multiple scientists to ask China to restore access if it wasn't really blocked. It wasn't just reporters saying so.


2) The miners' disease.
Like almost all people who reported on it in 2021, you presented events as if an infection by SARS-like viruses was the only diagnosis. This made Shi's mention of a fungus in @janeqiuchina's interview sound like a lie. ▫️5/
That wasn't the only reason Shi appeared to be lying. Shi never addressed all of the evidence that the miners had a respiratory virus.


But the first consulted expert did suspect a fungal infection. Curiously, this is almost never mentioned in stories on the miners. ▫️6/
Remote Meeting Minute Time:...
More details on the miners' diseases in this thread. ▫️7/
It was noted in all the places you would expect to see it, the fungal infection was SECONDARY.

DeBarre might very well be an expert in relevant fields, her credentials as noted online look impressive. But she has taken Shi's word for it that the miners died of fungal infection without looking at all the other facts. More than enough has been posted supporting the conclusion the fungus was secondary including the labs which most definitely supported the diagnosis of a viral infection. If these miners had shown up with a primary fungal infection the clinical course would have been very different.


3) The link between RaTG13 and Ra4991.

This was also a classic in 2021, a nice narrative polished by DRASTIC: online sleuths finding the hidden link between RaTG13 and Ra4991, and therefore the Mojiang mine… But a fable. ▫️8/
Suspicious internet sleuths...
Her disdain for DRASTIC is palpable.

A fable, because the connection between RaTG13 and the Mojiang mine had been communicated as early as Jan 2020, and finding the link between RaTG13 and Ra4991 required as elaborate sleuthing skills as… using Google Scholar. More details in this thread▫️9/
DeBarre is contradicting herself here. Did the miners have a virus or a fungus? RaTG13 was indeed discovered in specimens Shi's team found in the mine or in nearby caves. But Shi has not discussed what the miners had except to say they died of a fungal infection, and no one has accounted for any lung biopsy specimens that were collected from the miners. Oddly they are missing. :rolleyes:

One could not have Googled much at all about the Mojiang miners' viral infections until DRASTIC dug up the Master's and PhD theses and that was not as early as Jan 2020. Perhaps DeBarre was looking in hindsight? Shi did publish a number of papers before the pandemic began. Maybe that's what DeBarre is talking about.


Likewise, the PhD thesis did not "reveal" that WIV had been sampling the mine: this was described in Ge et al. 2016… ▫️10/
That PhD thesis was written about the miner's illness, not about anything to do with the WIV collecting specimens or taking them back to Wuhan. But Shi and her colleagues were studying SARS-like coronaviruses in the bats in Yunnan at the time because they were looking for the reservoir of SARS1. I just don't recall anything about the WIV in the PhD thesis. I don't think anyone from the WIV came to the mine or saw the miners when they were ill. Shi got notified after the fact and her team went later.

Shi's work pursuing the reservoir of SARS did result in a number of papers one would find searching Google Scholar. Maybe that's where some of the confusion arises here.

doi.org/10.1007%2Fs122…
The Ph.D. thesis was more c...
These Mojiang stories were very 2020-early 2021. The fascination for the Mojiang mine became obsolete as soon as we learned later in 2021 that closer relatives to SARS-CoV-2 had been found in Laos by Temmam et al. ▫️11/
No they did not become obsolete. The Laos coronaviruses were closely related to COVID, more so than RaTG13. We discussed that in this thread when those specimens were found.

doi.org/10.1038/s41586…


These stories were however influential in making people believe in a lab leak. And as written above, I was also initially fooled by these narratives as well. But I started finding inconsistencies: ▫️12/
In June 2021, I found that RaTG13's provenance had been communicated to a journalist as early as Jan 2020. It took me weeks, though, to digest the consequences of a finding that challenged the narratives in which I believed. ▫️13/
In the Fall 2021, I questioned the inconsistency that you note in your piece between the alleged date of disappearance of the database and the explanation given (hacking attempts). ▫️14/
Again I don't know what her evidence is that the database did not go offline in Sept 2019. DeBarre seems intent on schooling this reporter and again pushing the lab origin off as a CT. Again, there are many many legitimate researchers who contradict DeBarre's conclusions.

Given we have Daszak, Worobey and a slew off other experts pushing the natural spillover hypothesis one could easily find a piece written by them using the language they have promoted that this was practically a smoking gun. They had to be reminded that, no it was not.

I started investigating myself. The monitoring website was still up, I received the help of native Chinese speakers, and I found out that DRASTIC had given a completely biased narrative: the databased had not disappeared for good in Sep 2019. ▫️15/
And yet a NYTs reporter claims it reappeared in July 2021. (This was news to me. I imagine they had time to scrub the data, we'll likely never know.) As for DRASTIC's interpretation of the Chinese theses, they posted links to the original papers in Chinese and to the English translations for all to see.

Where she got the idea the database did not go offline in 2019 is curious. But DRASTIC was not the only source that the database wasn't online.


(The scenario has other inconsistencies: Why would WIV have published a paper in December on a database they would have put offline months before because if contained the proof of a lab accident??)▫️16/
(Likewise, why would WIV have shared the full sequence of RaTG13 in 2020 if there was something nefarious about its provenance?? It would have been so much easier not to share the full sequence at all.)▫️17/
The paper Shi wrote was in 2019, not 2020. The full sequence of RaTG13 was not published early on, only parts of it.

And why would so many researchers including the WHO inspection team keep calling for the Chinese to return access to the large genome database? See, I can ask revealing questions too.


Rare are the journalists who checked the actual source documents instead of DRASTIC's digests, so you are not anything but alone in these errors. ▫️18/
It's not like the journalists were the only ones involved here except DRASTIC. :rolleyes:


I hope you will read the threads I included. I wrote them for people who I think were misled at some point and went on a wrong path, like I did at some point. I know it takes time to accept it; I went through this myself. ▫️19/
But I also hope that you realize that if US-Americans largely believe in a lab leak, it's actually also (and mainly) because they could read these (false) scary stories about WIV in reputable newspapers. ▫️20/
Not everyone is going by scary stuff in the papers. I can see anyone who believed Trump and the GOP generated all the lab leak evidence to come away thinking there was no truth to the story.


Bottom line, there is too much politics and confirmation bias in many places. It's hard to know what is reliable and what is not. I think it's pretty well sorted out in this thread for anyone willing to look back through the earlier pages.
 
Last edited:
Huh?

This is not supported by evidence. I don't think anywhere has established that the fungus was a secondary infection.

Also, two of the three who recovered had anti-fungals. I think the sixth one was not as seriously ill as the others.

Remember that they also were treated and admitted to smaller clinics at different times as well, from what I remember.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8490156/table/tbl1/

All of them seemed to have been given various steroids, anti-virals (in most cases), anti-biotics and anti-fungals (in most cases).

So I don't think we can make strong claims either way. The three who died tended to be older, have had complicating medical issues as well, etc... and from what I remember were exposed to the mine for longer. So to point out that one of the survivors didn't have anti-fungals, and one of the deceased didn't have an anti-viral proves that Shi lied and covered up the discovery of Covid-19 in a mineshaft seems far-fetched.
I didn't say one of the deceased didn't have any antivirals. :confused:

From the abstract of that paper:
The origin of SARS-CoV-2 is still the subject of a controversial debate. ... The laboratory leak theory is essentially based on a publication by Rahalkar and Bahulikar in 2020 linking SARS-CoV-2 to the Mojiang mine incident in 2012 during which six miners fell sick and three died. We analyzed the clinical reports. The diagnosis is not that of COVID-19 or SARS. SARS-CoV-2 was not present in the Mojiang mine. We also bring arguments against the laboratory leak narrative.
This isn't true. The miners' illness was in no way the only basis for the lab leak theory.

The table you linked to showed not surprisingly the miners had various pre-existing conditions.

The paper is aimed at discounting the lab origin. This is the title: "Origin of COVID-19: Dismissing the Mojiang mine theory and the laboratory accident narrative"

So you've essentially searched out a biased paper. That's fine if your goal was to find one side of the evidence. But don't post this as some sort of significant evidence the miners didn't have a viral infection suspected to be from a SARS-like coronavirus.
 
The table you linked to showed not surprisingly the miners had various pre-existing conditions.

The paper is aimed at discounting the lab origin. This is the title: "Origin of COVID-19: Dismissing the Mojiang mine theory and the laboratory accident narrative"

So you've essentially searched out a biased paper. That's fine if your goal was to find one side of the evidence. But don't post this as some sort of significant evidence the miners didn't have a viral infection suspected to be from a SARS-like coronavirus.

Do you dispute anything in the table?

If not, then why complain about where it came from?
 
Curiouser and curiouser.

It looks like DeBarre and the NYT did conflate the genome database taken offline in Sept 2019 (I said Oct in a couple posts too late to edit the correction) and exposed by DRASTIC with the genome data that was in a Jan 2020 paper which Dr Bloom found lacked full genome data on the earliest cases. He found the full genome data in the Cloud and that is indeed the data which was put back online in June of 2021. And it wasn't mysterious if one had followed the email exchange between Bloom and Shi.

I wish I wasn't blocked from her Twitter because I'd like to ask her about it.

When I tried to search for the genome database taken offline by the Chinese I got pages and pages of hits about the database from the 2020 paper. I even tried different search engines.

Finally using the search string "oct 2019 Virus Sequences Deleted by china per DRASTIC" I got the one I was looking for. [Annoyingly if I use the correct month, Sept instead of Oct, a huge ad pops up at the top of the page for Gravitas. That's James O'Keefe's dishonest group that has been posting faked videos. So I went back to Oct because I didn't want to see that *******'s ad.]

But I digress.

The following was the only return I got among 3 pages of search returns that had what I was looking for. This database did not reappear in 2021 as the NYT and DeBarre mistakenly claim. And no wonder DeBarre thinks she need only search in Google Scholar to show everyone up. (Sorry, that was unnecessary snark but it's people like this who haven't looked very carefully at the evidence who then go off spreading false information.)

An investigation into the WIV databases that were taken offline

Unlike the database Bloom was looking for that had a couple dozen genomes that came from some of the earliest patient specimens, the database DRASTIC revealed had 22,000 genomes, not all bat coronaviruses.
The administrator of the database is Shi Zhengli herself.

○ In http://batvirus.whiov.ac.cn (the WIV address for the database), whiov stands for Wu Han Institute Of Virology. The ‘batvirus’ prefix can be confusing as this is not just a bat database despite the name.

○ The alternative address is http://www.scidb.cn/dadaSet/handle/768 which is its online location on a Chinese service for science datasets.

● It is the most important BatCoV database in China and holds the samples and sequences from the WIV. A description is available online here (English translation). [hyperlinks in the citation]

● It focuses primarily on bats and rodents, but also held bird and arthropods (insects & ticks) samples

The database held more than 22,000 samples and sequence records, including for all WIV sampling trips going back many years, plus some data from external DBs (namely DBatVir (bats) and DRodVir (rodents), managed by the Institute of Pathogen Biology in Beijing - both still available).

○ Tick pathogens were also very much a field of study, with more than 50,000 tick samples collected.

● The database contains data on seasonal epidemics of viruses crossing the species barrier, data not provided by DBatVir (for bats) or DRodVir (for rodents). This makes it potentially the best database for investigating whether the theory of natural spillover of SARS-CoV-2 is plausible.The database includes samples and sequences of bat beta-coronaviruses gathered by the WIV on trips to Yunnan including Mojiang (where RaTG13 was sampled), sequence that had not all been made public.
● Rodents were a common WIV sampling target too. One of the first sampling trips by the WIV at the Mojiang mine in 2012 (shortly after the death of 3 workers who removed bat guano there) would include sampling of rats, not just bats. On that occasion the Mojiang paramoxyvirus was discovered.

● More specifically:

○ The WIV had collected over 15,000 samples from bats (amongst the 22,000 records of samples in the DB)

○ The DB contained over 1,400 strains of viruses across all species (animal, insect), including around 1,000 coronaviruses, with at least 500 recently discovered bat coronaviruses, and at least 50 of these close to SARS. ○ At least 19 of these coronaviruses were isolated (meaning grown in cell culture)
This begs the question, where is this genome data and why is it offline? Has Shi or the WIV shown us those 50 genomes close to SARS? Why do we only see the RaTG13 with the imperfect match?


A quick note about the genomes Bloom uncovered, none went back further than Jan 2020.

And about the larger database, one would think it could reveal convincing evidence of a spillover. Why not release it?
 
Last edited:
Why did Debarre block you? Did you have any interaction with her?

Anyway, you could always set up a "burner account" on another device or browser to read her feed.
 
Why did Debarre block you? Did you have any interaction with her?

Anyway, you could always set up a "burner account" on another device or browser to read her feed.

No interaction. I don't know why I'm blocked unless getting blocked from Laurie Garrett shared her blocking list. And that was very disappointing as I had so much respect for her after reading her coming pandemic book. All I did was post a rebuttal to her claim the spillover was all but proven.

I think it is possible Twitter did it, maybe one has to be opted in rather than Garrett having to block people.

It's not convenient to set up another account. Usually one can search around and find an option on someone's feed who shared the stream. I don't have much trouble and I would have probably found the right one here if you had quoted some identifying part of it like the first Tweet.
 
Last edited:
A new bat coronanvirus has ben isolated. This is from the Islands off the South of China well away from Wuhan which is in the centre of China. The interesting thing about this virus is it would be a potential (distant) ancestor of SARS-CoV-1 and SARS-CoV-2 carrying a similar spike protein and most interesting the spike protein carries a Furin cleavage site similar to SARS-CoV-2 showing that this occurs naturally and is not a signal that SARs-CoV-2 had been created by secret gain of function research on a previously unknown virus.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1995820X23000470

As actual scientific evidence accumulates it points towards a natural origin of SARS-CoV-2 and initial ill informed and non-evidence based speculation that the Furin cleavage site was evidence of gain of function research or the spike protein was highly adapted to humans* has been shown to be untrue. Unfortunately ideas and innuendo that have got into peoples heads are hard to shift.

*Previously referenced article showing that naturally occurring coronaviruses have spike proteins with higher affinity for the human ACE2 receptor than early strains of SARS-CoV-2.
 
Curiouser and curiouser.

It looks like DeBarre and the NYT did conflate the genome database taken offline in Sept 2019 (I said Oct in a couple posts too late to edit the correction) and exposed by DRASTIC with the genome data that was in a Jan 2020 paper which Dr Bloom found lacked full genome data on the earliest cases. He found the full genome data in the Cloud and that is indeed the data which was put back online in June of 2021. And it wasn't mysterious if one had followed the email exchange between Bloom and Shi.

I wish I wasn't blocked from her Twitter because I'd like to ask her about it.

When I tried to search for the genome database taken offline by the Chinese I got pages and pages of hits about the database from the 2020 paper. I even tried different search engines.

Finally using the search string "oct 2019 Virus Sequences Deleted by china per DRASTIC" I got the one I was looking for. [Annoyingly if I use the correct month, Sept instead of Oct, a huge ad pops up at the top of the page for Gravitas. That's James O'Keefe's dishonest group that has been posting faked videos. So I went back to Oct because I didn't want to see that *******'s ad.]

But I digress.

The following was the only return I got among 3 pages of search returns that had what I was looking for. This database did not reappear in 2021 as the NYT and DeBarre mistakenly claim. And no wonder DeBarre thinks she need only search in Google Scholar to show everyone up. (Sorry, that was unnecessary snark but it's people like this who haven't looked very carefully at the evidence who then go off spreading false information.)

An investigation into the WIV databases that were taken offline

Unlike the database Bloom was looking for that had a couple dozen genomes that came from some of the earliest patient specimens, the database DRASTIC revealed had 22,000 genomes, not all bat coronaviruses.
This begs the question, where is this genome data and why is it offline? Has Shi or the WIV shown us those 50 genomes close to SARS? Why do we only see the RaTG13 with the imperfect match?


A quick note about the genomes Bloom uncovered, none went back further than Jan 2020.

And about the larger database, one would think it could reveal convincing evidence of a spillover. Why not release it?


Just to respond to this.

At least 19 of these coronaviruses were isolated (meaning grown in cell culture)

If you read the literature you will see that isolation means being able to obtain a full gene sequence, almost never are 'isolated' bat coronaviruses grown. For instance the paper on the three novel coronaviruses I referenced above they were isolated by gene sequencing not by growing an actual virus.
 
An important twitter thread is here linking to the embargoed release of all the WIV isolated coronaviruses. The full sequences or nearly full were uploaded prior to the pandemic when there was no reason to keep them secret but embargoed (a normal process to allow the original researchers priority in publishing), and only released post pandemic. It is clear that WIV had no precursor virus to SARS-CoV-2.

https://twitter.com/edwardcholmes/status/1632652493263093765
 
This is a link to Flo Denarre on the database.

https://twitter.com/flodebarre/status/1652729420174573568

1) The Database.
The database was still online in February 2020.
In your piece, you put a link to the DRASTIC report, but you could have checked instead the original source, the monitoring website, which was still online at the time you wrote your text.

Briefly, DRASTIC & collaborators discovered that a database of bat and rodent viruses used to be shared publicly by WIV, and is not available anymore. Using a website monitoring access to the database, they estimated the database was put offline in Sep 2019.

When asked about it, Shi Zhengli explained in emails, in interviews, and to the WHO joint mission, that the database had been put offline after the pandemic started, because of hacking attempts… which is incompatible with the alleged Sep 2019 date.▫️3/n

Now there are different possible attitudes towards this contradiction:

a) Continue to use the Sep 2019 date (thereby implying that Shi Zhengli and others were wrong, or even lied); or

b) Check whether the Sep 2019 date is correct. ▫️4/n

The monitoring website (http://msis.csdb.cn) was still accessible in early 2022 (h/t
@coroldo1
). I accessed it, and it showed that the database was still available until February 2020. That is, after the pandemic started, like Shi Zhengli said.
[reposted]▫️5/n

The monitoring website also shows that the database was never much active, and only started existing in June 2019... Which is quite far from the picture of a major public website suddenly removed that is painted by some. ▫️6/n

Another point of Shi Zhengli’s reply (image in tweet 3) can be checked with publicly available data, namely when WIV started working on this database project (h/t
@zhihuachen
), again confirming what she wrote.
Another point of Shi Zhengli’s reply (image in tweet 3) can be checked with publicly available data, namely when WIV started working on this database project (h/t
@zhihuachen), again confirming what she wrote.
https://t.co/BYtaCvodT8
▫️7/n

The database was not taken down in Sep 2019 but after the start of the pandemic, as Shi Zhengli said.

But this piece of misinformation keeps spreading. ▫️8/n

I hope that journalists who repeated the incorrect Sep 2019 date will be able to update their papers
(Feb 2020 confirmed by https://technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-covid-lab-leak-wuhan/…) ▫️9/n

Finally, there are also some people who have been informed that the Sep 2019 date is incorrect (or even who suspected from the start it was), but continue to propagate it to raise suspicion around WIV's activities.

This is downright unethical coming from scientists. ▫️10/end

The people who keep spreading the incorrect Sep 2019 date want us to believe that the database would have been taken down because it contained info showing that WIV is at the origin of SARS-CoV-2's emergence, such as a progenitor virus, or its building blocks;▫️11/+

And somehow, all the world would have missed these publicly available incriminating sequences -- or, some people would have known about them and kept quiet to protect WIV.▫️12/+

he (erroneous) Sep 2019 date points at something nefarious having been done at WIV, because there would have been no reason otherwise to take down the database before the pandemic began.
It is dishonest to keep spreading this misinformation.▫️12/+

I focused the thread on the date the database was taken down, but it is not even clear whether the database was ever really accessed by people outside of WIV.
(More details in the quoted thread and the tweets it cites)▫️14/n

Coroldo1
@coroldo1
1. If we agree on referring to the 61.5MB database, it's not public accessible from the traffic monitoring system.

Though WIV geographical located in Wuhan, central China.
WIV was using CSTNET, WIV's IP address was/is/and always will be in Beijing.....
Too long full quote here:
6.4GB was downloaded from the 61.5MB SQL database from within the China science and technology network, (CSTN), nearly all from Beijing, equivalent to 100 DB downloads'
I don't mind also sharing following��https://twitter.com/coroldo1/status/1464432876234043392…
twitter.com/zhihuachen/status/1464022337796382730…
So, public/external/intetnal access interpretation were all based on false assumption, not knowing the fact that WIV's own configuration in June 2019 showed up in monitoring system as from 'Beijing'. Sorry we are not in Chinese social media platform, otherwise these interpretation would be flooded with rebuttal immediately. The CAS Network is too famous for internet history, and first email from China was sent from there. CSTNET is an INTRANET, not an Internet.

So to wrap up:
1. 61.5 MB, the file types, file sizes, etc from traffic monitoring system(the exact same one used to accuse WIV took it offline), did not, with a single thread of evidence of its status as public accessible to external users.
If the accuser knew WIV was in CSTNET.
2. 61.5MB, nor did evidence it's offline in September 2019. I know ppl might start shifting goalpost about the 'definition of offline', or we 'moved on', we 'just suggested maybe'.

Most of the volume was due to IPs in Beijing, and it turns out that this is where WIV is registered (cf. quoted tweet)▫️15/n

Additionally, most of the volume was concentrated on June 18-19, 2019, which we can interpret as tests of the database in the context of the CSData paper describing it.▫️16/+

In summary the claim the database was taken down in September 2019 is false, it was taken down in February 2020. It was first put on line in June 2019. The evidence is it was never a publicly available database but on a laboratory intranet.
 
Last edited:
A new bat coronanvirus has ben isolated. This is from the Islands off the South of China well away from Wuhan which is in the centre of China. The interesting thing about this virus is it would be a potential (distant) ancestor of SARS-CoV-1 and SARS-CoV-2 carrying a similar spike protein and most interesting the spike protein carries a Furin cleavage site similar to SARS-CoV-2 showing that this occurs naturally and is not a signal that SARs-CoV-2 had been created by secret gain of function research on a previously unknown virus.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1995820X23000470

As actual scientific evidence accumulates it points towards a natural origin of SARS-CoV-2 and initial ill informed and non-evidence based speculation that the Furin cleavage site was evidence of gain of function research or the spike protein was highly adapted to humans* has been shown to be untrue. Unfortunately ideas and innuendo that have got into peoples heads are hard to shift.
Dishonest framing of the facts duly noted. Insulting people posting lab origin scientific evidence is also noted as insulting the arguer where you apparently cannot address the arguments.
This was just discovered and yet you are claiming it wasn't evidence based to say it hasn't been seen before it was discovered? :boggled:

Now on to your link:

In addition you've posted an unsupportable claim the spike protein and furin cleavage site origins found in COVID could not have been the result of gain of function manipulation in the lab because they've been found in other animals (eg the pangolin) and other bats.

That's not how it works and more importantly it's not what your citation says. We know coronaviruses like influenza viruses often change by recombining. Instead of genetic drift you get a genetic shift.

But you can't just show, 'look, this little gene sequence could be in COVID because it was found in the wild in a related virus'.

It's nice that a furin cleavage site was found in the wild in a related SARS coronavirus. That's an important finding. However, the paper doesn't say they found the direct precursor virus circulating in this new location.

From the paper:
Although the origin of SARS-CoV-2 remains unknown, accumulating evidence indicates that SARS-CoV-2 originates from bats naturally, including the fact that the closest relatives of SARS-CoV-2 are bat coronaviruses from Yunnan Province of China and Lao PDR (Letko et al., 2020b; Zhou P et al., 2020; Li et al., 2021).
Just like with SARS1 which had a reservoir in horseshoe bats in Yunnan, no one is doubting SARS2 (COVID) will also turn out to have a reservoir in bats and probably horseshoe bats. That reservoir is almost certainly going to be in southern China or Laos or in similar bats elsewhere.

None of that precludes COVID coming from a lab leak where researchers were doing gain of function research on closely related SARS-like coronaviruses. There is a citation posted in this thread noting one cannot tell the difference between a naturally evolved virus and one developed through serial passage in a lab.

This is an important discovery BUT one still needs to show the path a bat virus took from caves in Hainan Province, China to the city of Wuhan China.

That remains a gaping hole in the spillover origin hypothesis. And BTW, as long as that gaping hole remains all of the 'accumulating evidence' you seem to think is tilting the scales is barely moving the needle. Important evidence yes, smoking gun, no.

The new beta CoV identified in this study is a distant relative of SARS-CoV-2 and harbors a polybasic furin-like cleavage site similar to SARS-CoV-2, strongly indicating that the SARS-CoV-2 furin cleavage site was naturally originated. However, the potential of Bat CoV CD35 to spill over into humans and/or animals remains unknown and needs further investigation.


I'll address your other posts next.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom