Hi @zeynep,
Last week in Geneva, I told you that your 2021 @nytimes Opinion on Covid origin had not aged well.
You challenged me to find errors. Here are some.

1/
Link: nytimes.com/2021/06/25/opi…
Disclaimer: in June 2021, I believed the stories I am about to debunk. I had been introduced to them by someone I trusted; I had not yet worked on them and taken the time to check them.

2/
Opinion | Where Did the Coronavirus Come From? What We Already Know Is Troubling. (Published 2021)
Even if the coronavirus did not emerge from a lab, the groundwork for a potential disaster had been laid for years, and learning its lessons is essential to preventing others.
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/25/opinion/coronavirus-lab.html
1) The Database.
The database was still online in February 2020.
In your piece, you put a link to the DRASTIC report, but you could have checked instead the original source, the monitoring website, which was still online at the time you wrote your text.

3/
For example, the same group...
You will find more details on the database in this thread.

4/
2) The miners' disease.
Like almost all people who reported on it in 2021, you presented events as if an infection by SARS-like viruses was the only diagnosis. This made Shi's mention of a fungus in @janeqiuchina's interview sound like a lie.

5/
The master’s thesis hypothe...
But the first consulted expert did suspect a fungal infection. Curiously, this is almost never mentioned in stories on the miners.

6/
Remote Meeting Minute Time:...
More details on the miners' diseases in this thread.

7/
3) The link between RaTG13 and Ra4991.
This was also a classic in 2021, a nice narrative polished by DRASTIC: online sleuths finding the hidden link between RaTG13 and Ra4991, and therefore the Mojiang mine… But a fable.

8/
Suspicious internet sleuths...
A fable, because the connection between RaTG13 and the Mojiang mine had been communicated as early as Jan 2020, and finding the link between RaTG13 and Ra4991 required as elaborate sleuthing skills as… using Google Scholar. More details in this thread

9/
Likewise, the PhD thesis did not "reveal" that WIV had been sampling the mine: this was described in Ge et al. 2016…

10/
doi.org/10.1007%2Fs122…
The Ph.D. thesis was more c...
These Mojiang stories were very 2020-early 2021. The fascination for the Mojiang mine became obsolete as soon as we learned later in 2021 that closer relatives to SARS-CoV-2 had been found in Laos by Temmam et al.

11/
doi.org/10.1038/s41586…
These stories were however influential in making people believe in a lab leak. And as written above, I was also initially fooled by these narratives as well. But I started finding inconsistencies:

12/
In June 2021, I found that RaTG13's provenance had been communicated to a journalist as early as Jan 2020. It took me weeks, though, to digest the consequences of a finding that challenged the narratives in which I believed.

13/
In the Fall 2021, I questioned the inconsistency that you note in your piece between the alleged date of disappearance of the database and the explanation given (hacking attempts).

14/
I started investigating myself. The monitoring website was still up, I received the help of native Chinese speakers, and I found out that DRASTIC had given a completely biased narrative: the databased had not disappeared for good in Sep 2019.

15/
(The scenario has other inconsistencies: Why would WIV have published a paper in December on a database they would have put offline months before because if contained the proof of a lab accident??)

16/
(Likewise, why would WIV have shared the full sequence of RaTG13 in 2020 if there was something nefarious about its provenance?? It would have been so much easier not to share the full sequence at all.)

17/
Rare are the journalists who checked the actual source documents instead of DRASTIC's digests, so you are not anything but alone in these errors.

18/
I hope you will read the threads I included. I wrote them for people who I think were misled at some point and went on a wrong path, like I did at some point. I know it takes time to accept it; I went through this myself.

19/
But I also hope that you realize that if US-Americans largely believe in a lab leak, it's actually also (and mainly) because they could read these (false) scary stories about WIV in reputable newspapers.

20/