Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

The paper you quote seems to be from people in Florida with no back ground in virology. They just speculate, they provide no evidence of anything.
Although I have seen reports that Karl Sirotkin might have a background in genetics, all 7 of the publications listed on his ResearchGate page are related to the lab leak hypothesis. Under "Disciplines", he listed only one: "Linguistics", with "Composition Studies" as the specific topic.

Dan Sirotkin is Karl Sirotkin's son. Dan has said he attended Harvard and completed a bachelor's degree in political science. His employment history describes valuable experience as a janitor, waiter, and inmate.
 
Last edited:
You're offering up the Wahington Examiner and you want us to take you seriously? Get back to us when you have something other than conspiracy theory nonsense.

Good grief! I said it was a summary, the information including corroborating or the initial sources are in the thread.

Trying to dismiss the established facts by dismissing a summary that doesn't claim to provide primary evidence when the primary evidence has already been posted does no favors to support spillover hypothesis arguments. And remember, this is only about one piece of the lab origin evidence: there were live bats kept at the WIV while Shi and Daszak denied there were, and, Daszak later admitted the WHO investigation team never asked about live bats.

Why should I have to repeat back pages of the thread to go round and round the mulberry bush with lab leak hypothesis deniers?
I shouldn't have to, it's already posted.


Can you support the spillover hypothesis with any convincing evidence? Here's a summary of that evidence:
Spillovers are the most common way pathogens enter the human population.
The cases appear to cluster around the seafood wet market.
They sold raccoon dogs in the same stall COVID genetic material was found.
One or more genetic analyses could support the spillover hypothesis.​
Feel free to add to the list.

Here are the problems with the spillover hypothesis evidence:
Lab accidents have led to pathogens entering the human and animal populations including at least one outbreak of foot and mouth disease in the UK.
Worobey's analysis lacks data on the earliest cases that China is withholding key information about.
The CCDC labs are not located in his analysis and they were very near the market and also studying pathogenic coronaviruses.
The WIV was not that far away as is implied when discussing the origin hypotheses.
The market being a super-spreader site fits the data.
There is no evidence of any COVID or COVID-like viruses in any other markets or in any populations of raccoon dogs.
Another intermediate animal source has not been found.
No other outbreaks of COVID or COVID-like pneumonias occurred across China, something you would expect as opposed to the first cases turning up suddenly in Wuhan and Wuhan only.
One or more genetic analyses easily support a lab leak origin hypothesis.​
 
Last edited:
We know the sequences of all three live viruses they had isolated. None of which were close to SARS-CoV-2. RaTG13 was never isolated as a live virus it is a reconstructed sequence, so only exists in a database. We know the closest indentified (by WGS not culture) viruses in the wild were from Laos, not anywhere that WIV had looked for bat viruses. No viruses simialr to SARS-CoV-2 were identified in the sequences from the areas where WIV were looking for viruses.
No we don't know that. You might believe it. Shi and Daszak have been demonstrated liars about the pandemic. And you would expect that given they would bear the ultimate blame. In addition China refuses to release all the coronavirus genomes they have a database on.

The research done at WIV was not gain of function research. [snip]
Another disproved claim.

There is no evidence that WIV did any serial passage, nor is there any reason for them to have done so.
Listen to the interview with Daszak at the Nipah virus conference. He states plainly that the were looking to create a vaccine before a spillover occurred. Coronaviruses were easily manipulated in the lab—all his words directly out of his own mouth.

Serial passgae is a classical way of attenuating a virus not making it more virulent. Serial passage in mice would make it more specific for mice not humans. That they could have done serial passage is not evidence that they did so. [snipped unnecessary snark]
There was evidence they were doing so, there was evidence they were making the coronavirus more infectious and an unexpected side effect was mice got a lot sicker.

As for only making attenuated viruses, what do you think gain of function research is? It's well documented and one reason a lot of researchers would prefer the lab leak hypothesis go away as it could put the damper on their own research.

Then there are the mice, for pity's sake, bring your knowledge up to date. Humanized mice means they have cells identical to human cells in their respiratory track. There are also live cells in cultures that are used to reproduce viruses and those cells are similar to human respiratory track cells.

Didn't I just correct you on all this? I'm not going to do it again. If you want to debate the origin of this virus you are going to have to get up to speed on the science.

[snipped more stuff already discussed ad nauseum.]


One of the early mutations was necessary because the location of the Furin cleavage site splitting the spike protein made SARs-CoV-2 relatively poorly adapted to humans.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7127415/

The paper you quote seems to be from people in Florida with no back ground in virology. They just speculate, they provide no evidence of anything.
All of this has been covered in the thread. That link has nothing about the furin site, NOTHING. I'm not sure what your goal was posting the link.


This is so typical of folks debating topics they don't like the facts of. Wait a while and repeat all the debate points that have been refuted with supporting and corroborating evidence. Keep the debate going round and round the same failed debate points, over and over, again and again. :rolleyes:
 
No we don't know that. You might believe it. Shi and Daszak have been demonstrated liars about the pandemic. And you would expect that given they would bear the ultimate blame. In addition China refuses to release all the coronavirus genomes they have a database on.

Another disproved claim.

Listen to the interview with Daszak at the Nipah virus conference. He states plainly that the were looking to create a vaccine before a spillover occurred. Coronaviruses were easily manipulated in the lab—all his words directly out of his own mouth.

There was evidence they were doing so, there was evidence they were making the coronavirus more infectious and an unexpected side effect was mice got a lot sicker.

As for only making attenuated viruses, what do you think gain of function research is? It's well documented and one reason a lot of researchers would prefer the lab leak hypothesis go away as it could put the damper on their own research.

Then there are the mice, for pity's sake, bring your knowledge up to date. Humanized mice means they have cells identical to human cells in their respiratory track. There are also live cells in cultures that are used to reproduce viruses and those cells are similar to human respiratory track cells.

Didn't I just correct you on all this? I'm not going to do it again. If you want to debate the origin of this virus you are going to have to get up to speed on the science.

[snipped more stuff already discussed ad nauseum.]


All of this has been covered in the thread. That link has nothing about the furin site, NOTHING. I'm not sure what your goal was posting the link.


This is so typical of folks debating topics they don't like the facts of. Wait a while and repeat all the debate points that have been refuted with supporting and corroborating evidence. Keep the debate going round and round the same failed debate points, over and over, again and again. :rolleyes:

The 'gain of function' research used pseudo type viruses, I gave a reference to this to clarify what these are. They are replication deficient viruses, they cannot reproduce, it is not gain of function research because the viruses are not gaining function, they have been made functionless.

The paper referenced above explicitly says that pseudo type viruses are used so that research can be done safely in BSL2 laboratories.

The other model they used was A mouse SARS-coV-1 related virus. SARS-coV-1 is distantly related to SARS-CoV-2 and no serial passage, Furin cleavage sites etc. can turn it into SARS-CoV-2. This is a mouse virus, not a virus pathogenic in humans.

We know empirically this was not gain of function research because whilst the control virus caused mortality in mice the virus with the spike protein from a novel coronavirus identified (the so called gain of function) showed no mortality in mice - it had lost function. Indeed they tried it as a protective vaccine in mice giving the adapted virus prior to the control virus produced a protective effect.

Just to correct your assertion, the mice dod not have cells identical to human cells in their airways. All that was done was that the mice had the gene for the human ACE2 receptor in place of the mouse ACE2 receptor. Only one gene / protein is 'humanised' the mice are otherwise mice. That is why they used a mouse virus.

https://www.nature.com/articles/nm.3985

The problem is that you have a broad idea of what you think might have happened but do not know the details of what actually happened.

They might have hidden a novel virus from the world, but why would they? They might have done serial passage of viruses, but they didn't and why would they, and it would only make a virus more adapted to mice (with a human ACE2 receptor). They might have started making a SARS-CoV-2 vaccine in November 2019, but they didn't and why would they? They might have had bat colonies but the people who worked there say they didn't but an anonymous poster say they did.

A claim previously made is that SARS-Cov-2 was highly adapted for human ACE-2 receptor, but wild type related viruses have a higher affinity for human ACE2 receptor than early SARS-CoV-2 isolates. So this shows that claims that SARS-coV-2 must have been pre-adapted to humans is untrue.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-022-04532-4
 
First you said there were only attenuated viruses resulting from serial passages, now you admit GoF research on viruses exists but you insist that's different from what we have here with COVID.

But it isn't. There is an abundance of evidence posted in this thread that Shi at the WIV and maybe others were working directly with SARS-like CoVs using serial passages to increase the infectivity of the virus. Daszak is on video admitting why they were doing it. China is withholding some key evidence about the beginning of the pandemic and Shi lied about not having live bats at the WIV.

We know many of the details. They are exposed in published research papers from before the pandemic started.

You think it was impossible to create COVID in the lab. That is an unsupportable position. Whereas how it could have happened is supported by many pieces of the jigsaw puzzle. Are all the pieces there? Nope, not yet. But the circumstantial evidence is piling up.

Fauci is beginning to backpedal, redefining what constitutes a lab leak:

Anthony Fauci attempts to narrow what would count as a Covid lab leak

He says if a researcher were infected in a cave in Yunnan and brought it back to Wuhan, that would be a natural spillover. Guess he's not impressed the market is where an intermediate animal infected a human.

US funded research to create 'mutant viruses' at Wuhan lab ahead of COVID-19, records show
Fox News yes but supported with evidence:
The EcoHealth Alliance used U.S. tax dollars to research "mutant viruses" during its work with the Wuhan lab in China, according to federal grant applications.

Judicial Watch, a conservative watchdog group, obtained 552 pages from the National Institutes of Health through the Freedom of Information Act about grants to the EcoHealth Alliance that included information for research the group did at the Wuhan Institute of Virology.

A June 5, 2013, grant application from EcoHealth to the NIH explains its plans to use bat coronavirus to create a mutant virus, according to one document in the release.
That was posted in this thread pages back.


From Axios: China 'began developing two Covid vaccines' before official outbreak
Chinese researchers may have begun developing two Covid vaccines in November 2019, before the official start of the outbreak, a US senate report has claimed.

The claims come in a 300-page document, which concluded that the pandemic most likely came from a lab leak and was the result of a "research-related incident" in Wuhan.

It said the theory that Covid-19 jumped from animals to humans in a market no longer deserved the "presumption of accuracy".

The report argued that Chinese researchers appeared to begin development of at least two Covid vaccines at the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) in November 2019, meaning "SARS-CoV-2 would have been present at the WIV before the known outbreak of the pandemic".

The claims give further credence to the lab leak theory and support accusations that China covered up early cases of the outbreak.

The 300-page report, released to Axios, was the full version of a 35-page summary published in October by the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee.
 
Last edited:
Using scary terms like 'mutants' and 'gain of function' research does not make it so. We have empiric proof the research was not gain of function research (in the usual sense) the virus with the modified spike protein was less virulent than the 'wild type' virus. The virus being a mouse SARS like virus, very distant from SARS-CoV-2. Other work was done with pseudo type viruses which are replication deficient developed to allow work on viruses in BSL2 laboratories. I argue the research done was NOT gain of function research. I do not debate that work was done to see if the viruses isolated from bats were potentially able to infect humans; but that this is not gain of function research.

There is no evidence they were doing serial passage. Either in cell lines or animals. The whole idea that the virus needed to have its infectivity increased comes from the false proposition that it was highly adapted to human ACE2 receptor. In fact as I referenced above with an actual scientific paper and not a newspaper wild type related bat viruses are found with a higher affinity for ACE2 than early strains of SARS-CoV-2. This means adaption was unnecessary and also that it hadn't been done as the virus was not particularly well adapted to humans. (Which is why one cross over strain died out). the classic way of making an attenuated virus for use in a vaccine is by serial passage. Serial passage results in viruses well adapted to e.g. mice or cell culture and not adapted for human to human transmission.

A researcher in the field coming down with an infection is not a laboratory leak. I think even the senate paper you quote says this.

I am afraid that parts of the senate report are so awful that it has become literally a joke in scientific circles. From thinking coronaviruses have double stranded DNA to the ludicrous and non-evidenced based claim that China was developing a SARS-CoV-2 vaccine in November and that the pandemic was probably the result of a laboratory leak of SARS-CoV-2 being used to challenge test animals in the vaccine development process that work being done at another laboratory entirely from WIV that the document accepts could not have carried out that type ovf vaccine development work, and did not involve Shi. It does not answer the question of why they would develop vaccine for a virus no one knew about, had caused no serious illness (remember very few people mostly old and co-morbid become seriously ill with SARs-CoV-2), in November 2019. Nor is there any evidence that they were doing so, other than the racist opinion that the only way Chinese scientists could have developed a putative vaccine (that was never put into production) so quickly was to have started in November rather than January because American scientists could not have done so as quickly! (The Oxford team developed a vaccine in less than 4 weeks, manufacturing and clinical trials took longer.)

ETA
I suspect we will see that the Chinese must have begun building the additional isolation hospitals back in 2018 because it would have taken American construction teams longer that 2 weeks to build a hospital.
 
Last edited:
Some interesting pieces of info that bust a lot of the lab leak narratives here:

https://twitter.com/flodebarre/status/1652729420174573568?s=46&t=BHmkcsLn6CV4ZBrdyNlAYQ

Twitter blocks me so I hunted for Flo Debarre. The first page of hits were all to Twitter links. But I did find this one that mentions her:

Science: Do three new studies add up to proof of COVID-19’s origin in a Wuhan animal market?
Three new studies offer one indisputable conclusion about the origin of SARS-CoV-2: Despite the passage of 2 years and the Chinese government’s lack of transparency, data that can shed light on the pandemic’s greatest mystery still exist. And although these new analyses don’t all reach the same conclusion for how COVID-19 was sparked, each undercuts the theory that the virus somehow escaped from the Wuhan Institute of Virology, long a focus of suspicions. ...

The studies were posted as preprints and are not peer reviewed, but scientists, biosecurity experts, journalists, and others are already intensely examining their details. “I have been brought closer to the zoonosis side with these preprints,” says Flo Débarre, an evolutionary biologist at the French national research agency, CNRS, who has followed the origin debate closely and not thrown her lot with either the natural-origin or the lab-leak camp.

There's nothing new there except 2 of the Preprints are now published. It's the same problematic studies: Weak genetic correlation, Worobey's study missing early cases, and the genetic data interpretation which is anything but the only interpretation of the data.

Is there anything new in her Tweet? Can you copy/paste the Tweet?
 
Last edited:
I’ll see what I can do. Not sure how the formatting will work, but let’s try…

Hi @zeynep,
Last week in Geneva, I told you that your 2021 @nytimes Opinion on Covid origin had not aged well.
You challenged me to find errors. Here are some. ▫️1/
Link: nytimes.com/2021/06/25/opi…

Disclaimer: in June 2021, I believed the stories I am about to debunk. I had been introduced to them by someone I trusted; I had not yet worked on them and taken the time to check them. ▫️2/

Opinion | Where Did the Coronavirus Come From? What We Already Know Is Troubling. (Published 2021)
Even if the coronavirus did not emerge from a lab, the groundwork for a potential disaster had been laid for years, and learning its lessons is essential to preventing others.
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/25/opinion/coronavirus-lab.html

1) The Database.
The database was still online in February 2020.
In your piece, you put a link to the DRASTIC report, but you could have checked instead the original source, the monitoring website, which was still online at the time you wrote your text. ▫️3/
For example, the same group...
You will find more details on the database in this thread. ▫️4/


2) The miners' disease.
Like almost all people who reported on it in 2021, you presented events as if an infection by SARS-like viruses was the only diagnosis. This made Shi's mention of a fungus in @janeqiuchina's interview sound like a lie. ▫️5/
The master’s thesis hypothe...
But the first consulted expert did suspect a fungal infection. Curiously, this is almost never mentioned in stories on the miners. ▫️6/
Remote Meeting Minute Time:...
More details on the miners' diseases in this thread. ▫️7/


3) The link between RaTG13 and Ra4991.

This was also a classic in 2021, a nice narrative polished by DRASTIC: online sleuths finding the hidden link between RaTG13 and Ra4991, and therefore the Mojiang mine… But a fable. ▫️8/
Suspicious internet sleuths...
A fable, because the connection between RaTG13 and the Mojiang mine had been communicated as early as Jan 2020, and finding the link between RaTG13 and Ra4991 required as elaborate sleuthing skills as… using Google Scholar. More details in this thread▫️9/

Likewise, the PhD thesis did not "reveal" that WIV had been sampling the mine: this was described in Ge et al. 2016… ▫️10/

doi.org/10.1007%2Fs122…
The Ph.D. thesis was more c...
These Mojiang stories were very 2020-early 2021. The fascination for the Mojiang mine became obsolete as soon as we learned later in 2021 that closer relatives to SARS-CoV-2 had been found in Laos by Temmam et al. ▫️11/

doi.org/10.1038/s41586…

These stories were however influential in making people believe in a lab leak. And as written above, I was also initially fooled by these narratives as well. But I started finding inconsistencies: ▫️12/
In June 2021, I found that RaTG13's provenance had been communicated to a journalist as early as Jan 2020. It took me weeks, though, to digest the consequences of a finding that challenged the narratives in which I believed. ▫️13/
In the Fall 2021, I questioned the inconsistency that you note in your piece between the alleged date of disappearance of the database and the explanation given (hacking attempts). ▫️14/
I started investigating myself. The monitoring website was still up, I received the help of native Chinese speakers, and I found out that DRASTIC had given a completely biased narrative: the databased had not disappeared for good in Sep 2019. ▫️15/
(The scenario has other inconsistencies: Why would WIV have published a paper in December on a database they would have put offline months before because if contained the proof of a lab accident??)▫️16/
(Likewise, why would WIV have shared the full sequence of RaTG13 in 2020 if there was something nefarious about its provenance?? It would have been so much easier not to share the full sequence at all.)▫️17/
Rare are the journalists who checked the actual source documents instead of DRASTIC's digests, so you are not anything but alone in these errors. ▫️18/
I hope you will read the threads I included. I wrote them for people who I think were misled at some point and went on a wrong path, like I did at some point. I know it takes time to accept it; I went through this myself. ▫️19/
But I also hope that you realize that if US-Americans largely believe in a lab leak, it's actually also (and mainly) because they could read these (false) scary stories about WIV in reputable newspapers. ▫️20/
 
I also found this exchange between DeBarre and Alina Chan that show DeBarre's Tweets.

https://nitter.1d4.us/flodebarre/status/1632422156263931904

Nothing new there either.

I followed it here: https://nitter.1d4.us/flodebarre/status/1632811845458227206#m

Essentially DeBarre refutes that Worobey left out early data because there are cases on his epidemiology map that are not near the market.

The language in the Tweets is telling:
an authoritative-sounding member of a pro-lab leak activist group called DRASTIC
:rolleyes:


DeBarre goes on explaining the suggestion there were early cases not in Worobey's paper was based on cases that were not culture confirmed. Supposedly this is a discovery that there aren't missing cases after all.

But that's not the missing data. The cases were identified but China has refused to disclose anything about them like where they live and where were they potentially exposed.


DeBarre goes on to suggest the study ruling out pangolins as an intermediate host was flawed. But there isn't any more on the pangolins that I have seen.


Here is the Twitter thread not blocked. It's the same thing I was looking at but easier to read.

https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1632811845458227206.html

Is this what you were linking to?
 
Last edited:
I'll have to look further at your post before commenting more on it.

We discussed the miner's fungal diagnosis at length. I'll see if I can find it in the thread. There is no evidence they died of a fungal disease except as a secondary infection. They were treated initially with anti-fungals and did not get better.

Shi brought up the fungal sidetrack in a late comment, IIRC. It wasn't something that was in anything she discussed about the miners before that. And the lung samples they took from the miners has not been produced. There was an antibody test on blood from the miners. We had a discussion about just which test was done. I'll have to look that up.
 
I'll have to look further at your post before commenting more on it.

We discussed the miner's fungal diagnosis at length. I'll see if I can find it in the thread. There is no evidence they died of a fungal disease except as a secondary infection. They were treated initially with anti-fungals and did not get better.

Shi brought up the fungal sidetrack in a late comment, IIRC. It wasn't something that was in anything she discussed about the miners before that. And the lung samples they took from the miners has not been produced. There was an antibody test on blood from the miners. We had a discussion about just which test was done. I'll have to look that up.

Your contention was that Shi lied and somehow knew it was a spillover of a SARS-like virus, which her and Daszak covered upthen isolated and did gain of function and serial passaging on to create a more virulent or transmissible virus. This is the claim made by those two Counterpunch writers.

It was an elaborate conspiracy theory. Whereas the more prosaic claim is that she was passing on what she knew of the case (that fungal infection has been claimed as the likely cause of death). I don’t think any definitive conclusion has ever been reached.

The point has always been to attempt to paint Shi as an inveterate liar up to no good. Whether the lies have any specific relevance to the origins of SARS is always secondary. Lab leak theories work primarily through innuendo.

Do we believe it came from the Mojiang mine? Who cares, just hint at it.
Do we believe it came from captive bats? Who cares, just hint at it!
Do we believe it came from RaTG13? Who cares, just hint at it?
From WIV BSL-4? You know the drill!
From CCDC? Ditto.
Rinse and repeat.
 
DRASTIC
...is a loose collection of internet activists assembled to investigate the origins of COVID-19, in particular the lab leak theory. Composed of about 30 core members, and primarily organized through the social media website Twitter...

In 2021 CNET reported that members of DRASTIC have engaged in personal attacks against virologists and epidemiologists on Twitter, falsely accusing some of working for the Chinese Communist Party.
Seems legit...
 
Yep, IRC. This published paper discusses the miner's symptom cluster, the Master's and PhD theses revealed by DRASTIC and the Sci Am interview with Shi in 2020. And we've been through every bit of this **** in the thread already. But it seems people just can't help themselves repeating this information sans the parts inconsistent with the spillover narrative. :rolleyes:

Frontiers in Public Health published in Oct 2020: Lethal Pneumonia Cases in Mojiang Miners (2012) and the Mineshaft Could Provide Important Clues to the Origin of SARS-CoV-2
A Master's thesis (in the Chinese language) was found on the cnki.net website which described in detail the severe illness in miners. The thesis concluded that a SARS-like CoV originating from Chinese horseshoe bats (Rhinolophus) was the predicted causative agent. The cases were remotely monitored by a prominent pulmonologist in China. Retrospective analysis of the pneumonia cases shows striking similarities with COVID-19. Bilateral pneumonia, vascular complications like pulmonary thromboembolism, and secondary infections are the main similarities.
This study scientifically investigated any reports of atypical pneumonia cases covering the period 2004 to 2019, between the SARS (1) epidemic and COVID-19. We identified a case described in two scientific magazines. The first mention was in an interview with Dr. Zhengli Shi, a principal scientist of WIV, in the Scientific American journal (2). In the interview, Shi talked about a mineshaft in Mojiang where a lethal pneumonia-like disease occurred in six miners in 2012 (2). The discussion outlined that a diverse group of coronaviruses was discovered in the mine following the outbreak. These lethal pneumonia cases were also covered in news, including a more detailed article in Science magazine in 2014 (4). ...

In the Scientific American interview, Dr. Zhengli Shi outlines that fungus was responsible for pneumonia in the miners (2). However, no detailed information was elucidated in literature and the cause of the miners' illness remained a mystery.


Dr. Nanshan's diagnosis for patients 3 and 4 were interstitial pneumonia (primarily of viral origin), with a possibility of secondary infection (invasive pulmonary aspergillosis). He requested swab testing and SARS antibody testing (to be carried in WIV). He also asked the hospital staff to confirm with the Kunming Institute of Zoology for the type of bat. ...

The thesis concludes that severe pneumonia in miners was due to SARS-like CoV from horseshoe bats. Dr. Nanshan's conclusion that the Mojiang miners pneumonia appeared to be primarily viral and that it was most probably due to bat-related coronaviruses, is noteworthy.


The retrospective analysis of the illness in the miners greatly resembles COVID-19 in the following aspects (Table 1B).
See the link for the table.

1. The radiological picture seen in the CT scans of COVID-19 patients (13) and miners cases (7) is very similar, ...

2. Elevated D-dimer values and pulmonary thromboembolism, a complication seen in COVID-19 were also found in three of the six miners in 2012 (7)....

3. Lymphocytopenia, that is, low lymphocyte counts are another common feature characteristic of a viral disease, and common in both the miners' pneumonia cases and COVID-19.

4. The similarity in treatments: Treatment given to the miners were antivirals, steroids, mechanical ventilation, antibiotics (for treating the secondary bacterial infections), and antifungals (for treating the secondary fungal infections). Anti-thrombotic agents like warfarin, heparin were also given in the case of patient 4 who successfully recovered. ....

5. Elevated Serum Amyloid A protein: is an inflammatory marker that shows characteristic high values in cases of viral infection. A high SAA value or an increasing trend is an indicator of bad prognosis in the case of COVID-19 (15). ...

And here's that information left out when proclaiming the miners died of a fungal infection:
Based on the detailed evidence presented in the Master's thesis (7) and the Ph.D. thesis (9) and the discussion presented here, we do not think that fungus was the primary reason for the illness. Dr. Nanshan predicted the miners' illness to be a primary interstitial viral pneumonia (high probability) with invasive aspergillosis as a secondary infection (a condition commonly observed in COVID-19) (16). We think that if it was a fungal disease, only antifungals could have cured the illness.

Now why do you think Shi would then insist the miners died of a fungal infection and leave out all this other stuff?

Here are more (not all the questions mentioned in the paper) questions the WIV has still not answered:
... However, further questions remain as to which antigen was used for the Ab detection in the pneumonia patients and what was the exact protocol used. Why is this information not available in any of the seroprevalence studies by WIV? Why were the severe pneumonia cases in 2012 not mentioned in any of the WIV publications before 2020? Were any SARS-like CoV isolated from the bat fecal samples collected in 2012–13? Why were the Mojiang miners pneumonia cases in 2012 not reported to any public health agency like the WHO? ...

According to the literature, three research groups went to the Mojiang mine to collect samples between 2012 and October 2014 (5, 9, 10). The mine was promptly closed as per the (2). Why was the Mojiang mine being visited by researchers until October 2014? Questions also remain as to why Dr. Shi attributed the outbreak in Mojiang to a fungus in the interview with Scientific American. Was the mine open for researchers and were any samples brought after 2014? Did any of the researchers who visited the Mojiang mineshaft get infected by any coronavirus between 2012 and 2019? Are there any whole genome sequences available for SARS-like CoV originating from this mine? Why is the pathogen database (http://www.viruses.nsdc.cn/chinavpi/) associated with the project (2013FY113500) (10) not accessible anymore? ...

The Master's thesis by Li Xu concludes that the pneumonia-illness in the miners was due to a SARS-like CoV from horseshoe bats. The remote consultation and diagnosis by a prominent pulmonologist in China, Dr. Nanshan, adds credibility to the diagnosis of the pneumonia cases in 2012.
 
DRASTIC
Seems legit...
Well this is interesting from the link:
Ryan, Jackson (April 15, 2021). "How the coronavirus origin story is being rewritten by a guerrilla Twitter group". CNET. Archived from the original on June 16, 2021. Retrieved June 1, 2021.

There's the same **** going on from the 'lab-leak is a CT' pushers as well. The language from some of the spillover proponents is bloody obvious their framing is an attempt to denigrate the lab leak side. Daszak's attempts to direct researchers and the WHO initially into labeling anyone suggesting the lab leak hypothesis was pushing a CT is well documented in the thread and easy to find online.

Then there is the GOP and Trump who initially wanted to blame China. One cannot trust much that came from them either. And should we ignore any issues with Fauci because Rand Paul is an idiot?

Bottom line, you have to look at the sources, not at the messengers.
 
Last edited:
Your contention was that Shi lied and somehow knew it was a spillover of a SARS-like virus, which her and Daszak covered upthen isolated and did gain of function and serial passaging on to create a more virulent or transmissible virus. This is the claim made by those two Counterpunch writers.
WTF? :rolleyes: No, you have this quite jumbled up here.

Shi's group was collecting bat samples for years from the Yunnan area looking for the reservoir of SARS1 which they eventually found. They collected thousands of samples and brought those plus a few live bats back to the WIV.

After the pandemic began Shi denied they had any live bats at the WIV despite evidence this was false. She denied they had any live cultures of coronaviruses at the WIV despite evidence this was also false. She claimed the miners at the mine who died in 2012 died of a fungal infection despite evidence this was a secondary infection.

Daszak admitted on video at the Nipah conference that SARS-like CoVs were easily manipulated and they hoped to develop a universal vaccine before the next spillover event. That was in Dec 2019 just as the COVID pandemic was beginning.

In Oct of 2019 a large database of coronavirus genomes established by the WIV was taken offline. It has yet to be made available again.

As the initial cases of COVID began turning up in Wuhan in Dec 2019 the demographic details of a few of those initial cases were withheld by the Chinese government. They continue to refuse to share those details.

There are still some questions like why did the secrecy begin over certain aspects. Shi was less than forthcoming about the specimens they were collecting from the bat caves all along? Could be that before 2007 she had yet to publish the discovery of the reservoir for SARS1. That makes since as researchers are competitive about their work.

At some point in about 2017 US funding re Gain of Function research was restricted. Despite having applied and received a DARPA grant 2 or 3 years earlier they were more than a year behind providing a progress report on that work. (Check the dates, I'm going by memory.)

Despite Fauci denying the US funded any of the GoF research at the WIV, that has been recently debunked and not by Rand Paul.

Fauci Testimony on Gain-of-Function Research Was ‘Inconsistent’ with Existing Intel, Says Ex-Director of National Intelligence

Which is interesting given the cite I just linked to of Fauci backtracking on how a spillover can actually come from a lab if one of the researchers is exposed collecting samples.

No one is hinting at anything. I've been posting supportable facts. Conclude what you want.

There's no "elaborate" CT here. China refuses to release certain data. Is that an elaborate CT? Shi has made some inconsistent statements about not having live bats or live cultures. Yet it's documented she got humanized mice from Baric and they were using human respiratory cells in cultures. The live bats at the WIV have been documented with more than one piece of evidence.

Shi's claim the miners in 2012 died of a fungal infection goes unexplained despite multiple medical experts looking at the same data concluding with overwhelming cited evidence they had a SARS-like virus and the aspergillus was secondary.

Conclude what you like but that is not some elaborate CT.


It was an elaborate conspiracy theory. Whereas the more prosaic claim is that she was passing on what she knew of the case (that fungal infection has been claimed as the likely cause of death). I don’t think any definitive conclusion has ever been reached.
Are you selectively reading the data? Passed on what she knew? What, like this researcher studying SARS CoVs for the last nearly 20 years didn't really know that much about the fatal illness the miners in Yunnan had?

You can't be serious with that dismissal.


The point has always been to attempt to paint Shi as an inveterate liar up to no good. Whether the lies have any specific relevance to the origins of SARS is always secondary. Lab leak theories work primarily through innuendo.

Do we believe it came from the Mojiang mine? Who cares, just hint at it.
Do we believe it came from captive bats? Who cares, just hint at it!
Do we believe it came from RaTG13? Who cares, just hint at it?
From WIV BSL-4? You know the drill!
From CCDC? Ditto.
Rinse and repeat.
If this is supposed to be legitimate debate points, it borders on sad.

Face it, you are out of valid new arguments and the old ones are pretty weak. Let me try a couple that are hopefully more realistic:

There is still no intermediate source animal and no evidence the virus began anywhere except in Wuhan. There is no evidence it circulated in people before it acquired some serious infect-ability capabilities.

The genetic evidence that raccoon dogs were present in the market at the same time as COVID is not only merely a weak correlation, it's not new. We already knew there were live raccoon dogs being sold at the market. There's no evidence the raccoon dogs carried the virus into the market. There isn't even any evidence the raccoon dogs were infected.

Worobey's study not only is missing data on early cases, it would have only taken a single person with the virus to infect someone at the market. From there a super-spreader event explains the data.

There are a number of genetic mapping studies that have supported different conclusions. The TopHap being one of them that supports the lab leak hypothesis. Some researchers I've cited here concluded B lineages evolved from A lineages. And I just saw a more recent one that concluded A & B lineages did enter the human population separately but from the lab origin. If I didn't post it yet I will.

Two separate spillover events are pretty hard to see when one cannot find evidence of COVID or a related virus circulating in any population before Wuhan. If it was brought to Wuhan before the outbreak why can it not be found in any other population of raccoon dogs or people outside of Wuhan? Hunters, transporters or handlers, other markets the infected raccoon dogs were sold at?


You guys wear me out constantly rehashing old arguments.
 
Face it, you are out of valid new arguments and the old ones are pretty weak.

I'm not claiming any "new" arguments.

New arguments are not necessary. I'm going to wait and see how the evidence stacks up for one or the other.

To me, the lab leak still looks incoherent.
 
I'm not claiming any "new" arguments.
Didn't you just post this:
Some interesting pieces of info that bust a lot of the lab leak narratives here:

https://twitter.com/flodebarre/statu...6CV4ZBrdyNlAYQ
So nothing in the Twitter feed was new then? :boggled:


To me, the lab leak still looks incoherent.
Maybe if you'd actually skim the bullet points I post instead of skipping everything because long posts apparently overwhelm you, you'd see the lab leak hypothesis is incredibly coherent.
 
Using scary terms like 'mutants'
The media uses that term. I don't believe I have though I may have used the term mutations given they are what led to the variants.
and 'gain of function' research does not make it so.
GoF is the proper scientific term.


We have empiric proof the research was not gain of function research (in the usual sense) the virus with the modified spike protein was less virulent than the 'wild type' virus. The virus being a mouse SARS like virus, very distant from SARS-CoV-2. Other work was done with pseudo type viruses which are replication deficient developed to allow work on viruses in BSL2 laboratories. I argue the research done was NOT gain of function research. I do not debate that work was done to see if the viruses isolated from bats were potentially able to infect humans; but that this is not gain of function research.
You can make these claims all you want. There are multiple pieces of evidence they indeed were working on GoF with SARS-like CoVs at the WIV.


There is no evidence they were doing serial passage. Either in cell lines or animals. The whole idea that the virus needed to have its infectivity increased comes from the false proposition that it was highly adapted to human ACE2 receptor. In fact as I referenced above with an actual scientific paper and not a newspaper wild type related bat viruses are found with a higher affinity for ACE2 than early strains of SARS-CoV-2. This means adaption was unnecessary and also that it hadn't been done as the virus was not particularly well adapted to humans. (Which is why one cross over strain died out). the classic way of making an attenuated virus for use in a vaccine is by serial passage.
There are two things here. 1) Were they manipulating SARS-like CoVs? Daszak himself said in an interview how easily this is done. Have you listened to him that video? You only need to hear a few minutes, not the whole interview.

2) You claim that some wild-type bat viruses "found with a higher affinity for ACE2 than early strains of SARS-CoV-2."

Are you referring to this 2015 article in Nature? A SARS-like cluster of circulating bat coronaviruses shows potential for human emergence This is when Shi was in North Carolina working with Baric in the UNC lab.

This might be a big part of your misunderstanding. Baric did use a pseudo-type virus with a different backbone. His biosafety control was impeccable compared to that used at the WIV.

None of that work directly preceded the development of COVID. After that research Shi took what she learned back to the WIV along with acquiring the humanized mice. Biosafety at the WIV was quite different than it was at the lab at the UNC.

This is all documented in this thread. It's no wonder you are asserting erroneous things if you are getting them from that 2015 paper.


Serial passage results in viruses well adapted to e.g. mice or cell culture and not adapted for human to human transmission.
I don't understand why you think this. I recommend you read what humanized mice are and how those plus also using human respiratory cells in cultures result in viruses adapted to human respiratory cells.

A humanized mouse is a mouse carrying functioning human genes, cells, tissues, and/or organs. Humanized mice are commonly used as small animal models in biological and medical research for human therapeutics.


A researcher in the field coming down with an infection is not a laboratory leak. I think even the senate paper you quote says this.
That was Fauci's weird backpedal. There is no evidence that's how it happened. The evidence supports the hypothesis COVID was the result of GoF work done on SARS-like CoVs in the WIV lab, most likely in 2018-2019.


I am afraid that parts of the senate report are so awful that it has become literally a joke in scientific circles. From thinking coronaviruses have double stranded DNA to the ludicrous and non-evidenced based claim that China was developing a SARS-CoV-2 vaccine in November and that the pandemic was probably the result of a laboratory leak of SARS-CoV-2 being used to challenge test animals in the vaccine development process that work being done at another laboratory entirely from WIV that the document accepts could not have carried out that type ovf vaccine development work, and did not involve Shi. It does not answer the question of why they would develop vaccine for a virus no one knew about, had caused no serious illness (remember very few people mostly old and co-morbid become seriously ill with SARs-CoV-2), in November 2019. Nor is there any evidence that they were doing so, other than the racist opinion that the only way Chinese scientists could have developed a putative vaccine (that was never put into production) so quickly was to have started in November rather than January because American scientists could not have done so as quickly! (The Oxford team developed a vaccine in less than 4 weeks, manufacturing and clinical trials took longer.)
I haven't read the Senate report so I can't comment on everything here. What I can comment on is there is existing evidence posted in the thread which contradicts many of your conclusions.

For example you ask why would they develop a vaccine for a virus that did not exist. That was what EcoHealth Alliance, working with Dr Shi at the WIV stated was their goal. It's in writing. It's in Daszak's interview. That was the whole point of their research, develop the vaccine before another spillover of a SARS-like CoV occurs. Daszak's goal was reasonable. How they were going about it was not.


ETA
I suspect we will see that the Chinese must have begun building the additional isolation hospitals back in 2018 because it would have taken American construction teams longer that 2 weeks to build a hospital.
There are satellite images showing the hospital being built in response to the pandemic. It went up in a couple weeks.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom