Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Evidence needs to be credible. Claims by a documented liar cannot be considered credible with no corroboration.

Get back to us when Shi and the Chinese government allow an examination of the evidence that would support or refute Shi's claims.

Can we have the documentation of the lie?
 
So...much of the leaking of the emails and Slack channel has focused on areas where some scientists have expressed alarm at the structure of the virus and wondered aloud whether or not it demonstrates tinkering within the lab.

Still more, and to some extent I would include myself, have thought that maybe the public declarations play down the possibility of the lab leak too much given how much they themselves gave the very theory some credence.

However, here are some Slack messages between Andersen and Holmes (although presumably the others were priv) in which they seem to have had their fears assuaged that such structures as the particular receptor-binding domain and furin cleavage site could not exist in nature.

We can see that they were working with the assumption that the lab should be considered most likely origin if such a structure could not exist in nature, but that zoonosis should be considered first if such a structure COULD be found in nature.

Link

Also remember this is right at the beginning of covid-19. All the suggestions of bio-engineered virus were very early before the biology of SARs-CoV-2 had been properly analysed. Subsequently no scientists have suggested it is anything but a natural virus.
 
Give me a break. :rolleyes:

Since when is the claim, "I didn't do it", evidence said persons didn't do it?

Both Daszak and Shi have been caught lying, the evidence has been posted here more than once. The number of specimens and genome analysis they would have collected over two decades of research on coronaviruses is grossly inconsistent with the number of specimens and genome databases they admitted having.

Draw your own conclusions.

Do you understand 'presumption of innocence'? Until proven guilty people are innocent. Lying is not evidence of guilt. Provide evidence of lying (anonymous internet posts and newspaper opinions are not evidence).
 
Do you understand 'presumption of innocence'? Until proven guilty people are innocent. Lying is not evidence of guilt. Provide evidence of lying (anonymous internet posts and newspaper opinions are not evidence).

When it comes to the Proximal Origins paper, we don’t need a presumption of innocence anyway, because the authors were writing this without input from the WIV as far as I can see.

As usual with these types of data dumps of messages and emails, the assumption is that we will now find out the real secret where they say something like “okay, how do we cover-up the lab leak?” But what we actually find is scientists scratching their heads and wondering what is going on. It’s pretty clear that the deliberation process that they said had changed their mind had actually happened after all, as they said. In other words it is “corroboration” that they genuinely think it is from nature.

Now, are they quite as certain of it as their public statements suggest? Maybe not and like I said, I don’t really like that, but I do understand it.
 
Contact via the wildlife trade is many orders of magnitude more common than contact with infected animals in a lab, of scientific fieldwork.
Lab leak doesn't explain the presence of 2 separate lineages requiring 2 separate crossover events, both in exactly the same place

Lab leak does not explain why are the early cases either had direct connection to the market, or lived near the market. If it were a lab leak you would expect the cases to be connected to the lab or live near the lab, this wasn't the case.

Lab leak doesn't explain why Covid samples from the market were VASTLY more common in places where animals were kept




No. All the earliest know cases were either directly connected to the market or lived near the market. There was one "early" case that was falsely reported as being the first diagnosed and had no direct link to the market, but this proved incorrect. This patient actually contracted Covid in late Dec well after community spread was well underway.
This is the important issue. Studies suggest that there are about 60,000 infections of humans by novel bat viruses each year in China (it may be south east asia I'd need to check). So between SARS crossing over from bats (to animals) to humans in 2002 and SARS-CoV-2 in 2019, there had been around a million times that a novel bat virus had infected a human. All outside a laboratory. So on basic priors is a common event, natural infection of a person by a novel bat virus that had happened a million times since the last major outbreak caused by a natural cross over event by a bat virus (SARS)*, more or less likely that an extremely rare event (if it happened) of someone being infected by a previously unknown bar virus secretly stored in a laboratory?

*This excludes Ebola outbreaks that have occurred in Africa since caused by a bat derived virus. although some claim these were also laboratory leaked. Also small outbreaks without sustained transmission of novel coronavirus zoonoses.
 
From what others I find credible have said it is the FCS that is the stickler of non-natural evolution- not absolutely for sure, but very very likely.

The Furin Cleavage site supports natural evolution. Not only can it's evolution be tracked in related viruses the fact that it's out of frame in both Covid and it's wild relatives pretty much proves it's not an engineered feature. No competent virologist would ever make the mistake of inserting the FCS out of frame, but nature does things like this on occasion, and like I said you can see the same out of frame FCS in Covids closest wild relatives.
 
Post #490
Planigale said:
There is no evidence that 'gain of function' research was done at WIV on bat viruses. This is alleged but no evidence for this has been presented.
Grac said:
Fauci says Wuhan were investigating GoF on bat viruses. You've just seen that email, right?
Do you disagree with Fauci, and if so why are you in a better position to know more than him?
That was addressed by claiming Fauci didn't know what he was talking about, didn't know what kind of research was being done at the WIV despite the fact Fauci currently admits that is what they were doing at the WIV.

Any attempt to verify this explanation for Fauci's fantasized mistake or even verify it was a mistake? Nope, unless you count repeated claims Shi hasn't lied. That's it, that's the entire argument COVID doesn't have a lab origin.

Apparently that was in the same category as multiple sources of Shi lying about work they were doing at the WIV which immediately preceded the Nov 2019 cases of COVID.

According to Planigale all of the evidence supporting a lab origin has been: "anonymous internet posts and newspaper opinions [that] are not evidence". This despite no attempts whatsoever to address exactly how any piece of evidence is not credible.

One cannot debate or even discuss evidence with persons who don't address any evidence posted. There is a name for a person repeating requests for evidence that has been posted but it's impolite so suffice it to say, insincere is an adequate description.
 
Last edited:
That was addressed by claiming Fauci didn't know what he was talking about, didn't know what kind of research was being done at the WIV despite the fact Fauci currently admits that is what they were doing at the WIV.

Why would Fauci know what was happening at WIV? The genomic manipulation of coronavirus (which Baric says was not gain of function, and would have not been funded if it was gain of function by NIH), was carried out in the US not China. The NIH did not fund gain of function research at WIV. The suggestion previously made was that the research in the non-funded research proposal was funded from another source. If it was funded from another source why would Fauci know about it?

Fauci is not a virologist, his area of research is human immunology. He would not know about genetic manipulation of viruses, it is not what he did. That is why he asked experts for an opinion on the evidence for a laboratory origin of SARS-CoV-2

This article gives a fair summary of the issue.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/poli...ied-congress-about-gain-of-function-research/
 
Last edited:
Any attempt to verify this explanation for Fauci's fantasized mistake or even verify it was a mistake? Nope, unless you count repeated claims Shi hasn't lied. That's it, that's the entire argument COVID doesn't have a lab origin.

Apparently that was in the same category as multiple sources of Shi lying about work they were doing at the WIV which immediately preceded the Nov 2019 cases of COVID.

Your claims that Shi lied is no evidence of anything but your opinion. It is certainly not evidence that Shi lied.

Do you have a specific quote that you can disprove (an anonymous post about Bats does not count).

For ease I append the main interview Shi gave to Science.

https://www.science.org/pb-assets/PDF/News PDFs/Shi Zhengli Q&A-1630433861.pdf

https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.369.6503.487

MIT review
https://www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-covid-lab-leak-wuhan/

As the recent report from the ODNI says

Almost all IC agencies assess that SARS-CoV-2 was not genetically engineered. Most agencies assess that SARS-CoV-2 was not laboratory-adapted; some are unable to make a determination. All IC agencies assess that SARS-CoV-2 was not developed as a biological weapon.

The problem is as Shi says how can she provide evidence for something that never happened?

It is incumbent on you to provide evidence she lied. That means a quote, and evidence that the quote was a lie.

From the end of the MIT review

After talking to dozens of scientists involved over the past year, it has become clear to me that people’s opinions about the lab leak theory, to a large extent, depend on whether or not they believe Shi. Some support her, partly because they know her as a person or understand her work, or because they are willing to put up with the messy reality of science and China’s lack of transparency. Others, possibly driven by a deep mistrust of China, grave biosafety concerns, or an intense desire for greater transparency, simply reject every piece of evidence that she offers to define her work, and regard any inconsistencies as deliberate attempts to cover up a crime.

Not surprisingly, the allegations have taken a personal toll. “I’m a human being as well, you know,” Shi told me. “Have they considered what it feels like to be wrongly accused of unleashing a pandemic that has killed millions?”

Since the outbreaks, Shi has received numerous abusive emails and phone calls, even death threats. She has been called a liar, a mass murderer, and an accomplice of the Chinese Communist Party (even though she’s not a member). In May 2020, it was falsely rumored that she had defected to France with nearly 1,000 classified documents.

At Shi’s bat-themed office, I asked her how the past two years have marked her. Her girlish face suddenly dimmed.

“I can’t bear looking back,” she said, and turned her head away.
 
According to Planigale all of the evidence supporting a lab origin has been: "anonymous internet posts and newspaper opinions [that] are not evidence". This despite no attempts whatsoever to address exactly how any piece of evidence is not credible.

One cannot debate or even discuss evidence with persons who don't address any evidence posted. There is a name for a person repeating requests for evidence that has been posted but it's impolite so suffice it to say, insincere is an adequate description.

You misquote me. i have never said,
all of the evidence supporting a lab origin has been: "anonymous internet posts and newspaper opinions [that] are not evidence
The problem is that is the evidence you present.
 
Why would Fauci know what was happening at WIV?
:jaw-dropp I dunno, because it's his job? :rolleyes:


The genomic manipulation of coronavirus (which Baric says was not gain of function, and would have not been funded if it was gain of function bu NIH), was carried out in the US not China.
You continue to spout falsehoods that what? Make sense to you for ...reasons? A Google search is beneath you?

There's a whole recent history of US funding for GoF research, when it was halted, how Baric's research was excepted because it was ongoing, when the US reinstated GoF funding and just in the last week how all funding to any WIV research was halted.

The NIH admitted funding GoF research at the WIV back in 2021.
In Major Shift, NIH Admits Funding Risky Virus Research in Wuhan

Oh there I go again, wasting my time actually supporting my assertions.
On Wednesday, the NIH sent a letter to members of the House Committee on Energy and Commerce that acknowledged two facts. One was that EcoHealth Alliance, a New York City–based nonprofit that partners with far-flung laboratories to research and prevent the outbreak of emerging diseases, did indeed enhance a bat coronavirus to become potentially more infectious to humans, which the NIH letter described as an “unexpected result” of the research it funded that was carried out in partnership with the Wuhan Institute of Virology. The second was that EcoHealth Alliance violated the terms of its grant conditions stipulating that it had to report if its research increased the viral growth of a pathogen by tenfold.

The NIH based these disclosures on a research progress report that EcoHealth Alliance sent to the agency in August, roughly two years after it was supposed to. An NIH spokesperson told Vanity Fair that Dr. Fauci was “entirely truthful in his statements to Congress,” and that he did not have the progress report that detailed the controversial research at the time he testified in July. But EcoHealth Alliance appeared to contradict that claim, and said in a statement: “These data were reported as soon as we were made aware, in our year four report in April 2018.”
NIH admits US funded gain-of-function in Wuhan — despite Fauci’s denials
The National Institutes of Health has stunningly admitted to funding gain-of-function research on bat coronaviruses at China’s Wuhan lab — despite Dr. Anthony Fauci repeatedly insisting to Congress that no such thing happened.

Oooo, this just proves Fauci didn't know what was going on at the WIV. Back in 2021, his coworkers made excuses for the doddering old 80+yr old.. :sarcasm:


The NIH did not fund gain of function research at WIV. The suggestion previously made was that the research in the non-funded research proposal was funded from another source. If it was funded from another source why would Fauci know about it?
I dunno, common sense? Maybe because it was a critical component in investigating the origin of a pandemic? It's not hard to conclude the US funding would not be the only source of funding at the CHINESE WIV.

Did Fauci say maybe the Chinese funded the research? Was he asked? I don't know but anyone interested could probably find out. Not too relevant.


Fauci is not a virologist, his area of research is human immunology. He would not know about genetic manipulation of viruses, it is not what he did. That is why he asked experts for an opinion on the evidence for a laboratory origin of SARS-CoV-2
OMG! :sdl: You can't be that naive!
Fauci has been at the forefront of U.S. efforts to contend with viral diseases like HIV/AIDS, SARS, the Swine flu, MERS, Ebola, and COVID-19.
Immunology but not virology? Maybe because you aren't in the US you didn't know that but it's no excuse for not looking at anything about Fauci like his Wiki page. If you didn't look anything up about Fauci, how did you conclude he didn't know anything about viral research?

Moving on:
Covid Investigation Focus Shifts to Chinese Scientists at Wuhan Institute of Virology
Hu was seen on Chinese video handling samples with no personal protective equipment and no regard for any other biosafety measures.
Whoops!


The Intercept’s D.C. Bureau Chief Ryan Grim now reports that Hu received U.S. financial support for gain-of-function research on bat coronaviruses. Grim’s assertions are based on documents obtained through a Freedom of Information Act request by the transparency advocacy organization White Coat Waste Project.

The funding came in three grants totaling $41 million, doled out by USAID and the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, or NIAID, the agency then headed by Dr. Anthony Fauci. Hu is listed as an investigator on the grants.
There's a screenshot of the document showing Hu as the lead investigator.

Here's the most interesting part:
Grim’s report stresses an important link between Hu and the Furin Cleavage Site (FCS). ...
It is difficult to explain how this strand of viral DNA is substantially altered in one, small area with four amino acids and 12 nucleotides with the remainder of the sequence remaining intact.

Hu is directly tied to the FCS research.

“The investigators spoke to two researchers working at a US laboratory who were collaborating with the Wuhan institute at the time of the outbreak,” the Times reported. “They said the Wuhan scientists had inserted furin cleavage sites into viruses in 2019 in exactly the way proposed in Daszak’s failed funding application to Darpa.” A key hallmark of SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes Covid-19, is its furin cleavage site (FCS).
“The significance of the fact that ‘patient zero*:’ Ben Hu received US funding from NIH and USAID in 2018-2019 is that NIH and USAID support to Hu potentially directly funded the insertion of FCS sequences into SARS-ike coronaviruses that had been proposed in EcoHealth’s/WIV’s unsuccessful 2018 DARPA grant application,” said Dr. Richard Ebright, a molecular biologist and laboratory director at the Waksman Institute of Microbiology. “
*Hu denies he was patient zero and denies he was ill back in Nov 2019.

Those coincidences are adding up again. ...Shoot, I think I already posted that, probably posted the link.:cool:


Yeah no, that is not a "fair summary" given it is almost 2 years old.
 
Last edited:
You misquote me. i have never said,

The problem is that is the evidence you present.
Care to clarify then who it applies to?

Just me? To every single source I cited? How about sources I cited but which included citations for assertions they made? Have I only cited opinions?

But wait, isn't the WAPo you cited above a news source?

It gets so confusing. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
From the Vanity Fair article:

The letter did not mention the phrase “gain-of-function research” that has become so central to the bitter clashes over COVID-19’s origins. That type of controversial research—the manipulation of pathogens with the aim of making them more infectious in order to gauge their risk to humans—has divided the virology community. A review system established in 2017 requires federal agencies to particularly scrutinize any research proposals that involve enhancing a pathogen’s infectiousness to humans.

Dr. Fauci’s spokesperson told Vanity Fair that EcoHealth Alliance’s research did not fall under that framework, since the experiments being funded “were not reasonably expected to increase transmissibility or virulence in humans.”
 
From the Vanity Fair article:

I addressed that. Did you miss it?

Oooo, this just proves Fauci didn't know what was going on at the WIV. Back in 2021, his coworkers made excuses for the doddering old 80+yr old..
:sarcasm:

You do know Fauci walked his denial back right? Need I review everything that was posted in the last 3 pages even when I posted about it referring to post #490?


How can anyone have a discussion in this thread when people have such short attention spans?
 
Last edited:
So let's review the latest, look it up if anyone wants to discuss it, I will not be providing citations I have already provided.

We don't know if the State Dept report was true before the politics got thick. It said 3 WIV workers got sick in Nov 2019.

The FBI still supports the claim. A more recent intelligence report, unrelated to the FBI report, said the information about the 3 ill workers was not confirmable.

Dr Hu was identified as one of the three ill workers.


And now we find out there's a video of Dr Hu using unsafe lab practices available. In addition he just coincidentally was working on GoF with coronaviruses and wait for it ... by inserting the FCS.


How close is this getting to that smoking gun?

Anyone care to address this?
 
Last edited:
I addressed that. Did you miss it?



You do know Fauci walked his denial back right? Need I review everything that was posted in the last 3 pages even when I posted about it referring to post #490?


How can anyone have a discussion in this thread when people have such short attention spans?

Huh? There is no acknowledgement, as far as I know, that Fauci “admits” to funding gain-of-function.

You may infer it or you may use New York Post articles to argue it, but unless I see how words or representatives words, I don’t agree that he “admits” it.
 
:jaw-dropp I dunno, because it's his job? :rolleyes:



You continue to spout falsehoods that what? Make sense to you for ...reasons? A Google search is beneath you?

There's a whole recent history of US funding for GoF research, when it was halted, how Baric's research was excepted because it was ongoing, when the US reinstated GoF funding and just in the last week how all funding to any WIV research was halted.

The NIH admitted funding GoF research at the WIV back in 2021.
In Major Shift, NIH Admits Funding Risky Virus Research in Wuhan

Oh there I go again, wasting my time actually supporting my assertions.

NIH admits US funded gain-of-function in Wuhan — despite Fauci’s denials

Oooo, this just proves Fauci didn't know what was going on at the WIV. Back in 2021, his coworkers made excuses for the doddering old 80+yr old.. :sarcasm:



I dunno, common sense? Maybe because it was a critical component in investigating the origin of a pandemic? It's not hard to conclude the US funding would not be the only source of funding at the CHINESE WIV.

Did Fauci say maybe the Chinese funded the research? Was he asked? I don't know but anyone interested could probably find out. Not too relevant.


OMG! :sdl: You can't be that naive!
Immunology but not virology? Maybe because you aren't in the US you didn't know that but it's no excuse for not looking at anything about Fauci like his Wiki page. If you didn't look anything up about Fauci, how did you conclude he didn't know anything about viral research?

Moving on:
Covid Investigation Focus Shifts to Chinese Scientists at Wuhan Institute of Virology
Whoops!


There's a screenshot of the document showing Hu as the lead investigator.

Here's the most interesting part:

*Hu denies he was patient zero and denies he was ill back in Nov 2019.

Those coincidences are adding up again. ...Shoot, I think I already posted that, probably posted the link.:cool:


Yeah no, that is not a "fair summary" given it is almost 2 years old.

You think the job of the director of NIAID is to know what happens in foreign laboratories? Prior to December 2019 why should he be interested in WIV?

As director Fauci was not personally involved in grant awarding.

Fauci research was in human immunology. Not virology. Yes, HIV causes disease by impacting the immune system. He was not a virologist, and certainly not a coronavirus researcher.
Dr. Fauci was the longtime chief of the Laboratory of Immunoregulation. He made many contributions to basic and clinical research on the pathogenesis and treatment of immune-mediated and infectious diseases. He helped pioneer the field of human immunoregulation by making important basic scientific observations that underpin the current understanding of the regulation of the human immune response. In addition, Dr. Fauci is widely recognized for delineating the precise ways that immunosuppressive agents modulate the human immune response. He developed effective therapies for formerly fatal inflammatory and immune-mediated diseases such as polyarteritis nodosa, granulomatosis with polyangiitis (formerly Wegener's granulomatosis), and lymphomatoid granulomatosis.

Dr. Fauci made seminal contributions to the understanding of how HIV destroys the body's defenses leading to its susceptibility to deadly infections. Further, he was instrumental in developing treatments that enable people with HIV to live long and active lives.

I don't think Vanity Fair is a good source for objective analysis on science. Also this article is from 2021 yet you criticise me for using an article from 2021! This is at least from Science 2023 on the issue. Perhaps the use of vanity Fair might be a clue to you subsequent post?

https://www.science.org/content/art...nese-lab-at-center-of-pandemic-origin-dispute

I am sorry if I do not take the New York Post as anything else than another newspaper that you are referencing on science.
Then you reference a website called legal insurrection.

Actual interview with Hu. Note he says he never worked live viruses.
https://www.science.org/content/art...ientist-accused-being-pandemic-s-patient-zero
 
Care to clarify then who it applies to?

Just me? To every single source I cited? How about sources I cited but which included citations for assertions they made? Have I only cited opinions?

But wait, isn't the WAPo you cited above a news source?

It gets so confusing. :rolleyes:
You last post referenced
Vanity Fair
New York Post
Legal Insurrection.
 
Huh? There is no acknowledgement, as far as I know, that Fauci “admits” to funding gain-of-function.

You may infer it or you may use New York Post articles to argue it, but unless I see how words or representatives words, I don’t agree that he “admits” it.
Come on soba, keep up. Go to post #490, follow it back to the latest citation where Fauci admitted in 2020 there was said funding.

Or, just look it up.

Fauci appears to acknowledge gain-of-function research in Wuhan: Document
Fox News senior congressional correspondent Chad Pergram reports on an un-redacted email containing Dr. Fauci acknowledging genetic altering research in China from Feb. 2020.


Oh shoot! I forgot people had to put 2+2 together. :rolleyes:

Ex-CDC director says unredacted Fauci gain-of-function email reveals 'aggressive attempt' to change narrative
A newly-unredacted email from Dr. Anthony Fauci suggesting the COVID-19 pandemic may have been grounded in gain-of-function research essentially reveals his public statements from then on were an "aggressive attempt" to hide the truth, former CDC Director Robert Redfield said Monday.

Redfield, who served at the same time as Fauci during the Trump administration, said the news further backs up his longstanding belief the coronavirus originated from a laboratory and not a wet-market or zoonotic specimen.

"I think, it's very disheartening and very disappointing. And I've said before that I'm very disappointed in the leadership that both [then-NIH Director Francis] Collins and Fauci provided in not fostering a rigorous, aggressive, transparent scientific debate about what is really very reasonable scientific evidence that did point at this virus," Redfield told "The Story."

"Now you have, in his own words, that one -- he recognizes the abnormality of the furin-cleavage site being problematic – and he recognizes that, in fact, contrary to some of his statements, that there was actual gain of function research going on in that laboratory."

It is nice to see that most of what I've posted in this thread is being corroborated. I knew it would be given I was not simply citing news opinion pieces.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom