Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

This is an example of how pejorative terms are used to imply guilt. What is meant by humanised mice? These are standard laboratory mice who have had a single gene altered. They are entirely normal mice except that instead of expressing mouse ACE2 on cells they express human ACE2. ACE2 is the receptor that the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein binds to. This then causes the virus to enter the cell, hijack the cell biochemistry, and reproduce itself. So what was the 'gain of function'? A mouse SARS virus, (a virus that causes illness in mice but not humans), has its spike protein altered for a spike protein on a newly discovered bat coronavirus. So the mouse virus can only cause disease in the mice if the new spike protein can bind to human ACE2 and allow the virus to enter the mouse cells. This is not gain of function, it is unknown whether the spike protein can bind to human ACE2 before the experiment, but what is known is the mouse virus does not cause disease in humans.

In the papers and articles they are called 'humanized mice" meaning they are given, as you say, some functionality normally for humans not already in the mouse. That's it. Take it up with them. I have no delusions of what it means. I had no idea it was somehow pejorative. To whom? The mice?
 
Last edited:
Hmmm…. I will say that having read the emails (but not the Slack channel yet), it doesn’t look that good.

There are a couple of things that seem to stand out. One is that they definitely do seem to change their minds somewhat from thinking it looks like a tampered virus to one that COULD be natural, but they have serious concerns that it could still be engineered in a way that is indistinguishable from natural. There is clearly debate about how strongly they should lean natural. Some are more convinced than others of it being natural.

That said it wouldn’t surprise me if these emails result in some resignations.
 
In the papers and articles they are called 'humanized mice" meaning they are given, as you say, some functionality normally for humans not already in the mouse. That's it. Take it up with them. I have no delusions of what it means. I had no idea it was somehow pejorative. To whom? The mice?

Same thing imagining that GoF is somehow a made up term to induce fear. :rolleyes:
 
The humanized mice are sometimes also called transgenic mice, and yes they have human receptors to test the binding of various viruses in order to see if they are likely to infect humans.

There is actually quite a lot of discussion between the virologists about murine coronaviruses. I am not exactly sure whether they are talking about the viruses that specifically affect lab mice and presumably humanized mice or those that might affect wild mice.

There are some quotes where Garry is specifically referring to gain of function being done in WIV but I am not sure what the context of it is. I haven’t found the Slack message or email when browsing through the documents.

Obviously these emails and Slack messages should be treated with some caution because they don’t necessarily reflect actual inside knowledge but sometimes assumptions.

What is interesting is that at the beginning of the correspondence they seem to have fairly idiosyncratic spelling of some of the things like “furine cleavage site” and each others names which suggests to me that they were not all known to each other before they started on the report.

It also seems that they didn’t necessarily set out to write a published paper but to investigate what is likely to have happened. It seems pretty clear to me that they were pretty open-minded about a number of scenarios including passaging or lab escape of a complete virus (without tampering). They clearly thought that there were two categories of lab leak theories. One type that was relatively respectable and one type that was in the crackpot region (HIV and bioweapon theories).

From a positive side, it does seem as though they made genuine efforts to figure out what was going on and they show no sign that they are inventing a nature origins scenario. Andersen clearly says that he thinks it is likely natural and the presence of the WIV is probably a coincidence but that there are nagging doubts because of the possibility of producing something that looks natural but isn’t.

The negative side is that these doubts are not really reflected in the paper and indeed do seem to have been deliberately downplayed partly because of how they worried an objective-sounding conclusion would be interpreted by the public.

I think that is not good and unfortunately the type of thing that loses trust.
 
The humanized mice are sometimes also called transgenic mice, and yes they have human receptors to test the binding of various viruses in order to see if they are likely to infect humans.

There is actually quite a lot of discussion between the virologists about murine coronaviruses. I am not exactly sure whether they are talking about the viruses that specifically affect lab mice and presumably humanized mice or those that might affect wild mice.

There are some quotes where Garry is specifically referring to gain of function being done in WIV but I am not sure what the context of it is. I haven’t found the Slack message or email when browsing through the documents.

Obviously these emails and Slack messages should be treated with some caution because they don’t necessarily reflect actual inside knowledge but sometimes assumptions.

What is interesting is that at the beginning of the correspondence they seem to have fairly idiosyncratic spelling of some of the things like “furine cleavage site” and each others names which suggests to me that they were not all known to each other before they started on the report.

It also seems that they didn’t necessarily set out to write a published paper but to investigate what is likely to have happened. It seems pretty clear to me that they were pretty open-minded about a number of scenarios including passaging or lab escape of a complete virus (without tampering). They clearly thought that there were two categories of lab leak theories. One type that was relatively respectable and one type that was in the crackpot region (HIV and bioweapon theories).

From a positive side, it does seem as though they made genuine efforts to figure out what was going on and they show no sign that they are inventing a nature origins scenario. Andersen clearly says that he thinks it is likely natural and the presence of the WIV is probably a coincidence but that there are nagging doubts because of the possibility of producing something that looks natural but isn’t.

The negative side is that these doubts are not really reflected in the paper and indeed do seem to have been deliberately downplayed partly because of how they worried an objective-sounding conclusion would be interpreted by the public.

I think that is not good and unfortunately the type of thing that loses trust.


Fair analysis. I think you are right. People engaging in group science, in good faith, don't always see where the end result should be. They simply contribute to the consensus. There is usually a leader directing the conversation. Who was that in this case?
ie, Who was the one who edited the language and tone of the paper?
eta: oh and who actually did the submission and hit the send button? (might be different people)

We both know that even given the same set of facts to go by (or suppositions, inferences, etc...), you and I could create 2 articles that give off vastly different opinions to the public.

*apologies that I havent done a deep dive into these emails.
 
Last edited:
Fair analysis. I think you are right. People engaging in group science, in good faith, don't always see where the end result should be. They simply contribute to the consensus. There is usually a leader directing the conversation. Who was that in this case?
ie, Who was the one who edited the language and tone of the paper?
eta: oh and who actually did the submission and hit the send button? (might be different people)

We both know that even given the same set of facts to go by (or suppositions, inferences, etc...), you and I could create 2 articles that give off vastly different opinions to the public.

*apologies that I havent done a deep dive into these emails.

There is quite a lot of deliberation about the language used. Andersen for example prefers to use language like “consistent with evolution” but thinks that is not an effective way to communicate to the public.

Public messaging is, of course, important and we see a lot of that with climate change where saying “extreme weather X could be related to climate change” or is “likely” but then they worry that climate change deniers will drive a bus through the wording.

I sympathize but ultimately I would prefer they erred on the side of leaving that possibility more open. The long-term result would be that they maintain their credibility but these emails will massively damage that in my opinion.
 
There also seems to be some controversy over Jeremy Fararr “micro-editing” a word to make LL seem less likely.

I think ultimately Andersen is the CA (contact author?) but Holmes is the one who submitted , I think because he sends an email saying he wants everyone to finish editing the Google doc by time X and then he would tidy up the Word document before sending it. I think.

Anyway, some of the things they say will raise eyebrows but for the most part it certainly shows they took lab leak more than seriously (they complain about running out of underpants, etc….), but I think the picture emerges for me that ultimately they thought zoonosis was likelier.
 
In the papers and articles they are called 'humanized mice" meaning they are given, as you say, some functionality normally for humans not already in the mouse. That's it. Take it up with them. I have no delusions of what it means. I had no idea it was somehow pejorative. To whom? The mice?

Are they?

Care to reference the paper and give the quote?

My evidence;
Liu MQ, Lin HF, Li J, Chen Y, Luo Y, Zhang W, Hu B, Tian FJ, Hu YJ, Liu YJ, Jiang RD, Gong QC, Li A, Guo ZS, Li B, Yang XL, Tong YG, Shi ZL. A SARS-CoV-2-Related Virus from Malayan Pangolin Causes Lung Infection without Severe Disease in Human ACE2-Transgenic Mice. J Virol. 2023 Feb 28;97(2):e0171922. doi: 10.1128/jvi.01719-22. Epub 2023 Jan 23. PMID: 36688655; PMCID: PMC9972989.
This is the term used in actual scientific papers. No one would say humanised or even humanized it is too non-specific. The introduction of humanised (or humanized) is done by those trying to make it seem as if this was somehow infecting pseudo-humans. Yes it is used in articles but mostly those with an agenda to imply that this type of research could lead to the creation of SARS-CoV-2 in a laboratory.
 
Are they?

Care to reference the paper and give the quote?

My evidence;

This is the term used in actual scientific papers. No one would say humanised or even humanized it is too non-specific. The introduction of humanised (or humanized) is done by those trying to make it seem as if this was somehow infecting pseudo-humans. Yes it is used in articles but mostly those with an agenda to imply that this type of research could lead to the creation of SARS-CoV-2 in a laboratory.

Go to google.
Type in "humanized mice"
See results.
Tell me what you see.

Anything come up on that page that is propaganda about sars cov 2?

Also: lets have better debates than quibbles over normal scientific language.
 
Last edited:
Same thing imagining that GoF is somehow a made up term to induce fear. :rolleyes:

But calling genetic manipulation of viruses that is not 'gain of function' research is done to imply that the research was wrong, or criminal, or negligent and that it led to the laboratory creation of SARS-CoV-2. Putting the spike protein coding RNA sequence from a novel wild bat coronavirus into a murine virus is not gain of function. Creating pseudo viruses or chimeric viruses is not gain of function.

What is wrong with being specific and accurate about the actual research done? Just saying Shi did 'gain of function' research therefore she is a bad person who created SARS-CoV-2 is intellectual laziness. It saves actual having to think about the facts, about what was actually done, and what the actual consequences of that experiment could have been.
 
I started with a map. I looked at knowledge when they said it may have come from bats.... then looked at the map. That's what started it. Absolutely ZERO prompts. I just wondered why the obvious proximity had not been known to me til I saw it myself. (I was not on social media/twitter/facebook etc.... so forgive if I was late to the debate. (I had believed for a few years by then that most of those sites to contribute to 'brain trash' and so deleted them and never used them again)



And? This did not support that it was natural...quite the opposite. The research stated there were animals there and humanized mice, and viral engineering. Talks, papers, conferences, etc.... It wasnt secret.



Baric thinks it could be done because he did it. In fact, he invented it just for coronaviruses...years before the outbreak. And he taught it to Shi. Did you know that? What do you think of it?
Do you think there is some special batch of just a few virologists we should listen to, even those who had no previous experience with coronaviruses?



And no natural spillover evidence has been presented- even though it was literally on the doorstep of the premiere lab in the entire world to detect it.
None. No animal, no solid evidence of even the possible animal. Where is the animal?
That is my take on it. You can believe whatever you like and everyone is free to their own view of it. It won't change what the actual truth of it is. Perhaps one day we will get some solid truths out of it.

The animal is almost certainly dead. The outbreak of coronavirus infection in a group of animals that subsequently led to infection in humans has probably died out. RNA viruses mutate quite rapidly, the best that one can hope for is to find related viruses with a common ancestor, in a bat population. We are not going to find the progenitor of SARS-CoV-2 in an animal population. We might find an animal population with intermittently circulating viruses related to SARS-CoV-2 derived from a bat population with a common ancestor. What you are asking for is like a creationist demanding to see the missing link before he will believe that humans and apes evolved from a common ancestor.

The direct ancestor of SARS has not been found. The animal source of SARS has not been found. The animal source of Ebola in West Africa has not been found. The animal source of the recent mPox outbreak has not been found. It is not the normal course of events to find these things. That is why people have claimed that all these were viruses escaped from a laboratory. One would believe there were no outbreaks of viral illness before virologists!
 
The animal is almost certainly dead. The outbreak of coronavirus infection in a group of animals that subsequently led to infection in humans has probably died out. RNA viruses mutate quite rapidly, the best that one can hope for is to find related viruses with a common ancestor, in a bat population. We are not going to find the progenitor of SARS-CoV-2 in an animal population. We might find an animal population with intermittently circulating viruses related to SARS-CoV-2 derived from a bat population with a common ancestor. What you are asking for is like a creationist demanding to see the missing link before he will believe that humans and apes evolved from a common ancestor.

The direct ancestor of SARS has not been found. The animal source of SARS has not been found. The animal source of Ebola in West Africa has not been found. The animal source of the recent mPox outbreak has not been found. It is not the normal course of events to find these things. That is why people have claimed that all these were viruses escaped from a laboratory. One would believe there were no outbreaks of viral illness before virologists!


So the fact that there were labs right in the vicinity and multiple researchers specifically shown that specific market means that...?

They were total idiots not to know what was right in front of them?

So far we have no knowledge of viruses anywhere except for inside the lab. With animals. We know the coronaviruses were there. Those ones were documented. The undocumented ones or ones under investigation and as yet unpublished we do not know. And please do not say there were not animals there, including bats.

But yeah...the market. Not the first cases but still the market. And 2x spillover in the same spot but no animal or origin anywhere else, and no direst evidence there. Literally minutes walk from those that were charged to find these things!!
Ok. We shall see how it pans out over time.
I think I'd sooner believe a faith healer.
 
So the fact that there were labs right in the vicinity and multiple researchers specifically shown that specific market means that...?

They were total idiots not to know what was right in front of them?

So far we have no knowledge of viruses anywhere except for inside the lab. With animals. We know the coronaviruses were there. Those ones were documented. The undocumented ones or ones under investigation and as yet unpublished we do not know. And please do not say there were not animals there, including bats.

But yeah...the market. Not the first cases but still the market. And 2x spillover in the same spot but no animal or origin anywhere else, and no direst evidence there. Literally minutes walk from those that were charged to find these things!!
Ok. We shall see how it pans out over time.
I think I'd sooner believe a faith healer.

None of the known coronaviruses at WIV could have been turned into SARS-CoV-2. So you have to postulate an unknown coronavirus at WIV. The most economical explanation then becomes that the unknown coronavirus at WIV was SARS-CoV-2. That perhaps a worker at WIV became infected and that is how the virus leaked from the laboratory, it does not require any 'gain of function' research. This in essence remains a cross over event occurring in a laboratory.

Isolating viable bat coronaviruses is not that easy, WIV managed about one every three years despite the large numbers of samples they collected. So it is unlikely that they could have more than a couple of secret live viruses at most. They would have had no reason to keep this secret prior to December 2019. If they had isolated much before then they would have published it.

I am not sure what most of your post means, you are quite vague.

So the fact that there were labs right in the vicinity and multiple researchers specifically shown that specific market means that...?
WIV was not in the vicinity of the Wuhan wet market, it is not minutes walk from the market. WIV is on the other side of the city.

If you want to talk about another laboratory then we can ignore what Shi did or did not do or collect at WIV.

The Chinese tried to steer researchers away from the Wet Market, they were very keen to deny any possible of involvement of the wet market. Illegal animal sales happened at the market and the government obviously turned a blind eye to the illegal trading that had been banned because of the risk it might trigger a SARS like outbreak.

So far we have no knowledge of viruses anywhere except for inside the lab.
We know of closely related viruses from bats and pangolins (from bats) in the wild. More closely related than the viruses known to be in WIV.

Not the first cases but still the market. And 2x spillover in the same spot but no animal or origin anywhere else, and no direst evidence there.
I agree we do not know and are unlikely to know the first cases, given Covid-19 is relatively mild or asymptomatic in most young people. What we do know is that the earliest cases for which we have infornmation cluster around the wet market. We do know that SARS-CoV-2 early viruses both lineage A and B have been isolated from multiple sites in the wet market. So good direct evidence that the virus was widespread in the wet market early on. Evidence of two different lineages one of which died out. A laboratory source should only have resulted in a single lineage.

It is difficult to take your views seriously when you do not seem to know basic facts and base your opinion on erroneous information like WIV was only a few minutes walk from the wet market. That you think that the only related coronaviruses are in WIV, and are not aware the most closely related viruses have been found in the wild. (Of course the WIV viruses were collected in the wild and related viruses presumably still circulate in bats.)

Yes, it is a coincidence that a major coronavirus research centres is in Wuhan. Sometimes coincidences are just coincidences. Every city will have a virus laboratory, given that the two major health threats (animal and human) are flu and coronaviruses it is likely that research will be done on those in most virology laboratories. So it is not unlikely that the outbreak happened in a city with a laboratory doing research on coronaviruses.
 
Last edited:
None of the known coronaviruses at WIV could have been turned into SARS-CoV-2. .....
(bold is mine) Is it incomprehensible to you that there were SARS-like CoVs at the WIV that have not been disclosed? Clearly there were, given there's evidence of staff and students collecting the specimens in the Yunnan caves to take back to the WIV for research.

They've been collecting coronavirus specimens from Yunnan caves since 2013 and earlier. Where are all those specimens? Where is the record of their genomes if the specimens have been destroyed? Heck, there is even a record that lung biopsies were taken from the 3 miners who died of an unknown or undisclosed viral illness they contracted in a Yunnan mine. It is unknown where those specimens went. Why would China keep those specimens secret?


Mar 2016; SARS-like WIV1-CoV poised for human emergence; Baric et al.
... This manuscript describes efforts to extend surveillance beyond sequence analysis, constructing chimeric and full-length zoonotic coronaviruses to evaluate emergence potential. Focusing on SARS-like virus sequences isolated from Chinese horseshoe bats, the results indicate a significant threat posed by WIV1-CoV. Both full-length and chimeric WIV1-CoV readily replicated efficiently in human airway cultures and in vivo, suggesting capability of direct transmission to humans. ...

This research article has been posted in this thread multiple times. Anyone interested, (assuming the member I'm replying to isn't), Shi worked with Baric in his lab at the UNC for a while. She gave him the genome for a coronavirus she had isolated from her work with coronaviruses.

When Shi returned to her labs at the WIV she had learned the reverse engineering technique Baric used and she asked him for some of the humanized mice which he sent her.


The idea with decades of collecting and studying SARS-like CoVs Shi didn't have something closer genetically to SARS CoV 2 than RaTG13 is simply not credible.
 
(bold is mine) Is it incomprehensible to you that there were SARS-like CoVs at the WIV that have not been disclosed?

.....

The idea with decades of collecting and studying SARS-like CoVs Shi didn't have something closer genetically to SARS CoV 2 than RaTG13 is simply not credible.

Since when is personal credulity a valid arguing point with you?:rolleyes:
 
None of the known coronaviruses at WIV could have been turned into SARS-CoV-2. So you have to postulate an unknown coronavirus at WIV. The most economical explanation then becomes that the unknown coronavirus at WIV was SARS-CoV-2. That perhaps a worker at WIV became infected and that is how the virus leaked from the laboratory, it does not require any 'gain of function' research. This in essence remains a cross over event occurring in a laboratory.

Now we are in agreement. Yay!!

I think this is a very possible scenario.
It is a crossover, but not really a natural spillover since the cause of it was direct collection and a lapse in safety measures, which do happen, even if all protocols are given a good try to follow.
 
Now we are in agreement. Yay!!

I think this is a very possible scenario.
It is a crossover, but not really a natural spillover since the cause of it was direct collection and a lapse in safety measures, which do happen, even if all protocols are given a good try to follow.

Yes, the most likely explanation for a lab origin is that SARs-CoV-2 was in the laboratory. The talk of gain of function and humanised mice then becomes irrelevant. We also only need one virus, the theory of synthesising virus requires more than one virus isolate, a prolonged period of work, and still requires an accidental leak at the end. It requires a conspiracy. The only reason for going on about this is to blame someone. By making it a deliberate action rather than an accident. Someone being infected from a sample collected, and either coming back to the laboratory having been infected in the wild, or being infected in WIV does not require any conspiracy. Patient zero may have been mildly ill and not even aware that they had been infected, they then passed it on, it would have taken a few weeks before anyone noticed there was an outbreak by which time patient zero would be better and the cases turning up may have been socially distant.
 
(bold is mine) Is it incomprehensible to you that there were SARS-like CoVs at the WIV that have not been disclosed? Clearly there were, given there's evidence of staff and students collecting the specimens in the Yunnan caves to take back to the WIV for research.

They've been collecting coronavirus specimens from Yunnan caves since 2013 and earlier. Where are all those specimens? Where is the record of their genomes if the specimens have been destroyed? Heck, there is even a record that lung biopsies were taken from the 3 miners who died of an unknown or undisclosed viral illness they contracted in a Yunnan mine. It is unknown where those specimens went. Why would China keep those specimens secret?


Mar 2016; SARS-like WIV1-CoV poised for human emergence; Baric et al.


This research article has been posted in this thread multiple times. Anyone interested, (assuming the member I'm replying to isn't), Shi worked with Baric in his lab at the UNC for a while. She gave him the genome for a coronavirus she had isolated from her work with coronaviruses.

When Shi returned to her labs at the WIV she had learned the reverse engineering technique Baric used and she asked him for some of the humanized mice which he sent her.


The idea with decades of collecting and studying SARS-like CoVs Shi didn't have something closer genetically to SARS CoV 2 than RaTG13 is simply not credible.

The miners are irrelevant. It all happened years before Covid. The miners did not die of covid-19. The mortality rate in young people is much to high to be covid-19. The x-rays were wrong. No SARS like virus was detected, no antibodies were detected. The clinical scenario speaking as a specialist in lung infections that fits best is a fungal pneumonia. This is a classic story for fungal pneumonia. If this history was given in an exam the answer would be fungal pneumonia.

The transgenic mice expressing human ACE2 are irrelevant they cannot create a human pathogen Mice remain mice, you adapt the virus to replicate in mice and evade the mouse immune system.

SG, we have been over this before. isolating viable coronavirus from bats is extremely difficult. Many people have been sampling, but Shi's lab was the only one in the world to isolate viable virus, and even then rarely on average about one virus every three years. I think to a total of about six? All with published gun sequences. Mostly what they obtain is fragmentary RNA. Occasionally they get sufficient to construct a whole genome. Yes they have thousands of samples most of which will contain no virus. Not even drastic claim that there were hundreds of secret viruses. Also why would they keep viruses secret? Discovering viruses brings in funding. if they could have shown that the miners died of an unknown virus infection that would have been a major grant winner.

Also as I said before Andersen a bat biologist and biosecurity expert was working in the BSL4 laboratory at WIV in November 2019 and saw nothing unusual. No illness no secret gain of function research, no bats.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom