So the fact that there were labs right in the vicinity and multiple researchers specifically shown that specific market means that...?
They were total idiots not to know what was right in front of them?
So far we have no knowledge of viruses anywhere except for inside the lab. With animals. We know the coronaviruses were there. Those ones were documented. The undocumented ones or ones under investigation and as yet unpublished we do not know. And please do not say there were not animals there, including bats.
But yeah...the market. Not the first cases but still the market. And 2x spillover in the same spot but no animal or origin anywhere else, and no direst evidence there. Literally minutes walk from those that were charged to find these things!!
Ok. We shall see how it pans out over time.
I think I'd sooner believe a faith healer.
None of the known coronaviruses at WIV could have been turned into SARS-CoV-2. So you have to postulate an unknown coronavirus at WIV. The most economical explanation then becomes that the unknown coronavirus at WIV was SARS-CoV-2. That perhaps a worker at WIV became infected and that is how the virus leaked from the laboratory, it does not require any 'gain of function' research. This in essence remains a cross over event occurring in a laboratory.
Isolating viable bat coronaviruses is not that easy, WIV managed about one every three years despite the large numbers of samples they collected. So it is unlikely that they could have more than a couple of secret live viruses at most. They would have had no reason to keep this secret prior to December 2019. If they had isolated much before then they would have published it.
I am not sure what most of your post means, you are quite vague.
So the fact that there were labs right in the vicinity and multiple researchers specifically shown that specific market means that...?
WIV was not in the vicinity of the Wuhan wet market, it is not minutes walk from the market. WIV is on the other side of the city.
If you want to talk about another laboratory then we can ignore what Shi did or did not do or collect at WIV.
The Chinese tried to steer researchers away from the Wet Market, they were very keen to deny any possible of involvement of the wet market. Illegal animal sales happened at the market and the government obviously turned a blind eye to the illegal trading that had been banned because of the risk it might trigger a SARS like outbreak.
So far we have no knowledge of viruses anywhere except for inside the lab.
We know of closely related viruses from bats and pangolins (from bats) in the wild. More closely related than the viruses known to be in WIV.
Not the first cases but still the market. And 2x spillover in the same spot but no animal or origin anywhere else, and no direst evidence there.
I agree we do not know and are unlikely to know the first cases, given Covid-19 is relatively mild or asymptomatic in most young people. What we do know is that the earliest cases for which we have infornmation cluster around the wet market. We do know that SARS-CoV-2 early viruses both lineage A and B have been isolated from multiple sites in the wet market. So good direct evidence that the virus was widespread in the wet market early on. Evidence of two different lineages one of which died out. A laboratory source should only have resulted in a single lineage.
It is difficult to take your views seriously when you do not seem to know basic facts and base your opinion on erroneous information like WIV was only a few minutes walk from the wet market. That you think that the only related coronaviruses are in WIV, and are not aware the most closely related viruses have been found in the wild. (Of course the WIV viruses were collected in the wild and related viruses presumably still circulate in bats.)
Yes, it is a coincidence that a major coronavirus research centres is in Wuhan. Sometimes coincidences are just coincidences. Every city will have a virus laboratory, given that the two major health threats (animal and human) are flu and coronaviruses it is likely that research will be done on those in most virology laboratories. So it is not unlikely that the outbreak happened in a city with a laboratory doing research on coronaviruses.