Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Yes, the most likely explanation for a lab origin is that SARs-CoV-2 was in the laboratory. The talk of gain of function and humanised mice then becomes irrelevant. We also only need one virus, the theory of synthesising virus requires more than one virus isolate, a prolonged period of work, and still requires an accidental leak at the end. It requires a conspiracy. The only reason for going on about this is to blame someone. By making it a deliberate action rather than an accident. Someone being infected from a sample collected, and either coming back to the laboratory having been infected in the wild, or being infected in WIV does not require any conspiracy. Patient zero may have been mildly ill and not even aware that they had been infected, they then passed it on, it would have taken a few weeks before anyone noticed there was an outbreak by which time patient zero would be better and the cases turning up may have been socially distant.

I agree. No conspiracy is required to have it happen. It is the cover up, so quickly, that was so bothersome because they ignored all of the things you are mentioning here which seem to be rational and very real scenarios. Still "lab related"...which is the phrase I have come to use instead of 'leak' (if you look at my past posts).

Even Shi thought it was suspect at the start. I'd bet she got in BIG trouble for saying that off-the-cuff. She could not be shipped off/disappeared as she is so high profile.

But she thought the same of the Hanta infections in Yunnan. How could it have happened? Eventually she found a novel Hanta virus had occurred naturally with animals (2 species of mammal) kept too close together in the lab infecting the researchers. A simple mistake no one foresaw.
No such thing was possible with SarsCov-2 once it was spreading so rapidly. It was too big, too deadly, too infectious and going global. Had it been contained, we might have known a lot more from her and other researchers.

I was in China in Aug 2019 and was amazed an all the propaganda they gave to us- as Americans. Like, dont they know that we know? I got use to it after a while, except for being monitored all the time. Anyway, I was polite, I was their guest. so it goes.
 
Last edited:
I started with a map. I looked at knowledge when they said it may have come from bats.... then looked at the map. That's what started it. Absolutely ZERO prompts.

Not sure what you are trying to say but SARS-CoV-2 IS original a bat virus, it probably passed though some other species via the national scale trade in wildlife that goes on in China but it is most definitely a bat virus originally.

And? This did not support that it was natural...quite the opposite. The research stated there were animals there and humanized mice, and viral engineering.
Humanized mice have nothing to do with viral engineering. The mice are the ones that have had their genetic code altered to so that one of their proteins is human like. They are used to look for viruses with the potential to attach to the human version of that receptor and therefor could potentially infect humans.


And no natural spillover evidence has been presented-

This has to be an outright lie on your part at this point. The epidemic started in a wildlife market. Virus samples were collected form that market in the places animals were kept. Every early cases either had a direct connection to that market or lived near it. There were 2 different lineages of the virus in the market, something that is only plausible if it was zoonotic crossover. Similar wildlife markets gave rise to SARS, Ebola outbreaks and probably AIDS.



That is my take on it. You can believe whatever you like and everyone is free to their own view of it. It won't change what the actual truth of it is. Perhaps one day we will get some solid truths out of it.

We already have solid truths out of it, some people are choosing to attack the scientists who reveal that truth instead of accepting the truth.
 
Same thing imagining that GoF is somehow a made up term to induce fear. :rolleyes:

Gain of function is an accepted term, the problem is that you repeatedly ignore what the term means and call everything gain of function even when it clearly isn't.
 
So the fact that there were labs right in the vicinity and multiple researchers specifically shown that specific market means that...?

It means absolutely nothing that there are labs in a downtown area of a major city. Every city the size of Wuhan has many labs, most of which are likely to be centrally located. There is always going to be multiple labs near where the outbreak starts.

So far we have no knowledge of viruses anywhere except for inside the lab.


Just the opposite. We have no viruses in any lab that are particularly close to Covid. RATG-13 is was the closest known relative sampled pre-pandemic but it was never isolated as a live virus, only from genetic markers in bat feces.

RATG-13, however, separated from Covid 5 decades ago and even if it existed as a live virus it could not have given rise to the virus that caused the pandemic. It is to far distant to even be genetically engineered into something like Covid.
 
This has to be an outright lie on your part at this point. The epidemic started in a wildlife market. Virus samples were collected form that market in the places animals were kept. Every early cases either had a direct connection to that market or lived near it. There were 2 different lineages of the virus in the market, something that is only plausible if it was zoonotic crossover. Similar wildlife markets gave rise to SARS, Ebola outbreaks and probably AIDS.

We already have solid truths out of it, some people are choosing to attack the scientists who reveal that truth instead of accepting the truth.

This is quite the accusation but I think you misunderstand what I require as proof, similar to other scientists. Even if it is natural, doesnt mean it was not from the lab. Earlier cases predate the market so you'd need to explain it or just say that the Chinese lie about their data. I have a tendency to agree with that. They sure lied about many other things,and the story changed over time, and multiple origins were proposed. Social unrest there is to be avoided so you need to know their statements arent mostly for the western audience but for the cohesion of their own population. Can you imagine the pressure their gov't was under knowing they were the epicenter of it all?

If you CAN prove the origin, you'd be the first to do it but perhaps you can!
I'd fund a parade in your honor if you could- or maybe just send you some nice flowers.
The world is in such turmoil for so long without good data and good answers.
Thanks. :)
 
Last edited:
This is quite the accusation but I think you misunderstand what I require as proof, similar to other scientists. Even if it is natural, doesnt mean it was not from the lab.

Contact via the wildlife trade is many orders of magnitude more common than contact with infected animals in a lab, of scientific fieldwork.

Lab leak doesn't explain the presence of 2 separate lineages requiring 2 separate crossover events, both in exactly the same place

Lab leak does not explain why are the early cases either had direct connection to the market, or lived near the market. If it were a lab leak you would expect the cases to be connected to the lab or live near the lab, this wasn't the case.

Lab leak doesn't explain why Covid samples from the market were VASTLY more common in places where animals were kept


Earlier cases predate the market

No. All the earliest know cases were either directly connected to the market or lived near the market. There was one "early" case that was falsely reported as being the first diagnosed and had no direct link to the market, but this proved incorrect. This patient actually contracted Covid in late Dec well after community spread was well underway.
 
No. All the earliest know cases were either directly connected to the market or lived near the market. There was one "early" case that was falsely reported as being the first diagnosed and had no direct link to the market, but this proved incorrect. This patient actually contracted Covid in late Dec well after community spread was well underway.

Who says?
Not the WHO team or the Chinese that gave them the data at that time. Where do you get this info? There is actually more reason by what intelligence says going back even further past what the Chinese acknowledged.
Interested to know if there is some new solid information that I didnt know. Is there?
Thanks.
 
Who says?
Not the WHO team or the Chinese that gave them the data at that time. Where do you get this info? There is actually more reason by what intelligence says going back even further past what the Chinese acknowledged.
Interested to know if there is some new solid information that I didnt know. Is there?
Thanks.

The WHO team gave us the dates for the earliest known diagnosis, these show exactly what I indicated above. Given what we know about Covid these are unlikely to the very first cases, but they are almost certainly the first cases that reported to a hospital and therefor the first cases for which it's even possible to have data.
 
Since when is personal credulity a valid arguing point with you?:rolleyes:

Give me a break. :rolleyes:

Since when is the claim, "I didn't do it", evidence said persons didn't do it?

Both Daszak and Shi have been caught lying, the evidence has been posted here more than once. The number of specimens and genome analysis they would have collected over two decades of research on coronaviruses is grossly inconsistent with the number of specimens and genome databases they admitted having.

Draw your own conclusions.
 
Now we are in agreement. Yay!!

I think this is a very possible scenario.
It is a crossover, but not really a natural spillover since the cause of it was direct collection and a lapse in safety measures, which do happen, even if all protocols are given a good try to follow.
And yet no virus genome close to COVID has been found, or at least disclosed to have been found.

There is evidence on video, for example, of WIV staff collecting specimens in the field without gloves. So clearly such a scenario is possible.

But it leaves the problem of COVID being genetically matched to spread rapidly as soon as it was introduced to humans in Wuhan. From Baric's 2016 paper cited above there was one virus they found, WIV1, that Baric discovered was ready to spread in people. He concluded such spread would not be efficient at first.

Then there is that pesky little furin cleavage site that made COVID explosively contagious. While there has been such a gene segment found in the wild, there is no trail as to how it got into COVID. For example, it wasn't circulating in the bat populations where Shi and her staff collected SARS-like CoV specimens in the wild.

Capsid noted it that serial passages of SARS-like CoVs in VERO cells led to the furin site evolving out of SARS-like CoVs if it had been inserted. But that also meant it wasn't likely to have arisen in the wild. I posted a citation noting that.

Yet had it been artificially inserted and the virus grown in cell cultures and mice in the lab it would easily explain how the furin got there.
With SARS1 after it jumped from civet cats or raccoon dogs to humans the virus circulated in the human population for several months before becoming as easily transmissible as it became. For example when it reached Canada where infection control was usually effectively practiced, they learned one could not hang reuseable gowns on a rack in the anteroom like they did with other isolation cases. That little difference resulted in the virus spreading among staff. And in Hong Kong it spread in drainage pipes in a large apartment building, and it spread from an elevator ride to people who then took it to 9 different countries.

But it took a month for that kind of transmissibility to be established. The evidence supports that wasn't needed with COVID. It was explosively transmissible from the start.

In addition to noting that differed from other zoonotic spillovers, had that happened naturally in the wild one would expect outbreaks all over the place before the pandemic started in Wuhan. First, the crossover animals would need to be circulating the infection among themselves. The virus typically through a recombination event could conceivably have acquired the furin site. How likely is that?

It would have had to have been somewhere the viruses were circulating in the wild. The seafood market wasn't such a place, no virus with the furin site was circulating in animals at the market. They didn't even sell live bats according to reports and it isn't likely the recombinant event occurred among raccoon dogs with no evidence COVID was circulating in that species let alone two coronaviruses circulating leading to a recombinant event.

So now what are the odds COVID emerged in the wild and infected raccoon dogs, then people at the market, or, infected a staff member collecting specimens for the WIV who then spread it to who? Someone at the market? Staff or students at the WIV? Family or friends in Wuhan near the market?

In either of those scenarios, given how adding that furin site made COVID so easily transmissible it didn't need to circulate among humans to get there, one would expect to have seen little COVID outbreaks someplace other than the wet market. Were it in raccoon dogs then one should have seen other cases among the hunters, farmers, transporters or other animal handlers in addition to the Wuhan outbreak. Were it in a person collecting specimens in the cave one would have expected to see similar viruses circulating among the bats in the caves.
Finding a furin cleavage site in another bat species in the wild would make a recombinant event possible. But that is only a very remote possibility it then just happened to have jumped to a person heading back to the WIV but who wasn't bringing that specimen back. Where were the two species of CoVs circulating that allowed the recombinant event? They were found in different caves IIRC.

That's a whole lot of ducks that would have needed to have been lined up for any of those naturally evolved SARS-like CoV2 to have led to the pandemic.

OTOH, one only needs a purposeful insertion of the furin site into a CoV that was already adapted to humans with the ACE2 binding sites, and from there this virus could easily have been cultured in the mice or human respiratory cells because by now WIV researchers would have known culturing in VERO cells would not work.

One researcher or other staff member at the WIV mucking around with the resulting PPP in a BSL2 lab gets infected and spreads it to the community in Wuhan near the WIV where it soon becomes a PP, pandemic pathogen, no longer just potential.


Which scenario makes more sense and is supported by more evidence: that COVID evolved in the wild or it evolved in the lab?
 
And yet no virus genome close to COVID has been found, or at least disclosed to have been found.

There is evidence on video, for example, of WIV staff collecting specimens in the field without gloves. So clearly such a scenario is possible.

But it leaves the problem of COVID being genetically matched to spread rapidly as soon as it was introduced to humans in Wuhan. From Baric's 2016 paper cited above there was one virus they found, WIV1, that Baric discovered was ready to spread in people. He concluded such spread would not be efficient at first.

Then there is that pesky little furin cleavage site that made COVID explosively contagious. While there has been such a gene segment found in the wild, there is no trail as to how it got into COVID. For example, it wasn't circulating in the bat populations where Shi and her staff collected SARS-like CoV specimens in the wild.

Capsid noted it that serial passages of SARS-like CoVs in VERO cells led to the furin site evolving out of SARS-like CoVs if it had been inserted. But that also meant it wasn't likely to have arisen in the wild. I posted a citation noting that.

Yet had it been artificially inserted and the virus grown in cell cultures and mice in the lab it would easily explain how the furin got there.
With SARS1 after it jumped from civet cats or raccoon dogs to humans the virus circulated in the human population for several months before becoming as easily transmissible as it became. For example when it reached Canada where infection control was usually effectively practiced, they learned one could not hang reuseable gowns on a rack in the anteroom like they did with other isolation cases. That little difference resulted in the virus spreading among staff. And in Hong Kong it spread in drainage pipes in a large apartment building, and it spread from an elevator ride to people who then took it to 9 different countries.

But it took a month for that kind of transmissibility to be established. The evidence supports that wasn't needed with COVID. It was explosively transmissible from the start.

In addition to noting that differed from other zoonotic spillovers, had that happened naturally in the wild one would expect outbreaks all over the place before the pandemic started in Wuhan. First, the crossover animals would need to be circulating the infection among themselves. The virus typically through a recombination event could conceivably have acquired the furin site. How likely is that?

It would have had to have been somewhere the viruses were circulating in the wild. The seafood market wasn't such a place, no virus with the furin site was circulating in animals at the market. They didn't even sell live bats according to reports and it isn't likely the recombinant event occurred among raccoon dogs with no evidence COVID was circulating in that species let alone two coronaviruses circulating leading to a recombinant event.

So now what are the odds COVID emerged in the wild and infected raccoon dogs, then people at the market, or, infected a staff member collecting specimens for the WIV who then spread it to who? Someone at the market? Staff or students at the WIV? Family or friends in Wuhan near the market?

In either of those scenarios, given how adding that furin site made COVID so easily transmissible it didn't need to circulate among humans to get there, one would expect to have seen little COVID outbreaks someplace other than the wet market. Were it in raccoon dogs then one should have seen other cases among the hunters, farmers, transporters or other animal handlers in addition to the Wuhan outbreak. Were it in a person collecting specimens in the cave one would have expected to see similar viruses circulating among the bats in the caves.
Finding a furin cleavage site in another bat species in the wild would make a recombinant event possible. But that is only a very remote possibility it then just happened to have jumped to a person heading back to the WIV but who wasn't bringing that specimen back. Where were the two species of CoVs circulating that allowed the recombinant event? They were found in different caves IIRC.

That's a whole lot of ducks that would have needed to have been lined up for any of those naturally evolved SARS-like CoV2 to have led to the pandemic.

OTOH, one only needs a purposeful insertion of the furin site into a CoV that was already adapted to humans with the ACE2 binding sites, and from there this virus could easily have been cultured in the mice or human respiratory cells because by now WIV researchers would have known culturing in VERO cells would not work.

One researcher or other staff member at the WIV mucking around with the resulting PPP in a BSL2 lab gets infected and spreads it to the community in Wuhan near the WIV where it soon becomes a PP, pandemic pathogen, no longer just potential.


Which scenario makes more sense and is supported by more evidence: that COVID evolved in the wild or it evolved in the lab?

LAB LAB LAB!!
In the lab, but also could be natural infection inside the lab from something created in the lab that then generates with other things in the lab or other animals or humans or goes human to another animal and then back again.....gosh pick one!!

Know what I mean?
In fact there are so many scenarios where these little invisible critters move around and sort themselves out using the best survival strategy (if they can and especially if they had previous help to do it) as to be impossible to say....but just to say- it came out of the lab as a near certainty- or because of the 'used' lab animals from the lab going to market- so still the lab.

The farm animal no one can pinpoint arriving separate in the same town and infecting 2x down the road from the virus detectors is hard to parse with what we know now.
 
Last edited:
LAB LAB LAB!!
In the lab, but also could be natural infection inside the lab from something created in the lab that then generates with other things in the lab or other animals or humans or goes human to another animal and then back again.....gosh pick one!!

Know what I mean?
No, I'm confused. :)

The way recombinant events occur is a person or other animal gets infected with 2 different strains of a virus. The viruses break into segments inside the cell they infect and recombine in a different configuration before copies are made and exit the cell to reinfect another cell.

So for this scenario to occur in a lab someone has to consciously infect one cell or one cell culture with two different viral strains. I suppose lab animals might accidentally become infected with 2 or more strains of a virus, if the viruses are airborne or a lab worker caring for lab animals was incredibly careless. I'm sure it has happened.

It still leaves the problem the lab had to be working in this case with a coronavirus strain that had a furin cleavage site. They certainly haven't said they were doing any such thing.


In fact there are so many scenarios where these little invisible critters move around and sort themselves out using the best survival strategy (if they can and especially if they had previous help to do it) as to be impossible to say....but just to say- it came out of the lab as a near certainty- or because of the 'used' lab animals from the lab going to market- so still the lab.
There is no likely scenario as you describe here unless the workers/researchers at the WIV were working with 2 strains of coronaviruses that allowed a recombinant event.

You sterilize a lot of things in a lab to prevent unwanted organisms confounding your results. Even when new lab animals are brought into a lab they are quarantined until it's clear they aren't carrying any pathogens that again might confound the results.


The farm animal no one can pinpoint arriving separate in the same town and infecting 2x down the road from the virus detectors is hard to parse with what we know now.
One would expect to find coronavirus strains circulating somewhere, either in the animals or the animal handlers.
 
No, I'm confused. :)

The way recombinant events occur is a person or other animal gets infected with 2 different strains of a virus. The viruses break into segments inside the cell they infect and recombine in a different configuration before copies are made and exit the cell to reinfect another cell.

So for this scenario to occur in a lab someone has to consciously infect one cell or one cell culture with two different viral strains. I suppose lab animals might accidentally become infected with 2 or more strains of a virus, if the viruses are airborne or a lab worker caring for lab animals was incredibly careless. I'm sure it has happened.

It still leaves the problem the lab had to be working in this case with a coronavirus strain that had a furin cleavage site. They certainly haven't said they were doing any such thing.


There is no likely scenario as you describe here unless the workers/researchers at the WIV were working with 2 strains of coronaviruses that allowed a recombinant event.

You sterilize a lot of things in a lab to prevent unwanted organisms confounding your results. Even when new lab animals are brought into a lab they are quarantined until it's clear they aren't carrying any pathogens that again might confound the results.


One would expect to find coronavirus strains circulating somewhere, either in the animals or the animal handlers.

From what others I find credible have said it is the FCS that is the stickler of non-natural evolution- not absolutely for sure, but very very likely.

The lab itself knew viruses were left in the steel receptacles and instruments and they needed better ways to disinfect. (there was a patent filed for it in 2020). They knew sometimes they got bit! and there was a patent for that too. I think you were the one that found that one. Feels like ages ago.

Once the virus has merged adapted been engineered or who knows....the thing no one thinks can happen, always happens.

So I think simple answers about where a tiny little virus, and/or the millions of replicants of it, went or traveled are near impossible to detect now that so much time has passed. China wont let anyone into their blood samples from Wuhan/2019 to check. They also wont let anyone into Mojiang, or the lab for that matter. We really should be so furious at China for all the blockade of transparent invetigation. :mad:

All we know is where the successful virus in humans ended up...Wuhan.
and we know it was very infectious to humans at the start and we know the lab nearby was doing tests to make that happen- and said so.
 
But it took a month for that kind of transmissibility to be established. The evidence supports that wasn't needed with COVID. It was explosively transmissible from the start.

We can always go round and round on these topics, but who is to say it was explosively transmissable from the start if we haven't agreed on the starting time.

For example, it is often claimed by LLers that September 2019 could have been the start of the emergence if it was a leak, because that is when the databse was taken down/public-facing website was removed etc...

But then we are talking a few months before "explosive transmission". Similarly, you have posited the Wuhan Military Games as a superspreader event, although I see almost nobody making that claim any more.

Besides, you also brought this up in the past and said that SARS-1 took a month, but pointed out that H5N1 has taken many years and still not got there. MERS presumably somewhere between the two but never as infectious as SARS-1. Nipah, way more infectious than Hendra, despite their relationship. Ebola, not as infectious.

What can we learn from this except that different viruses have become transmissable at different rates, and it is pretty much a tautology that pandemics are the ones that have some kind of transmissible advantage.
 
And yet no virus genome close to COVID has been found, or at least disclosed to have been found.

This is of course an argument for zoonosis.

If the lab had viruses close to Covid, it would suggest a lab leak.

Few people think the virus was made out of wholecloth.

Nature is BIG, so finding viruses similar to any other in nature is obviously going to be difficult.

However, one thing we do know is that since Covid, viruses closer to SARS-CoV2 than RaTG-13 have been found in the wild, in Laos.

Of course, it was subsequently insinuated that maybe that virus had been in the WIV the whole time.
 
From what others I find credible have said it is the FCS that is the stickler of non-natural evolution- not absolutely for sure, but very very likely.

The lab itself knew viruses were left in the steel receptacles and instruments and they needed better ways to disinfect. (there was a patent filed for it in 2020). They knew sometimes they got bit! and there was a patent for that too. I think you were the one that found that one. Feels like ages ago.

Once the virus has merged adapted been engineered or who knows....the thing no one thinks can happen, always happens.

So I think simple answers about where a tiny little virus, and/or the millions of replicants of it, went or traveled are near impossible to detect now that so much time has passed. China wont let anyone into their blood samples from Wuhan/2019 to check. They also wont let anyone into Mojiang, or the lab for that matter. We really should be so furious at China for all the blockade of transparent invetigation. :mad:

All we know is where the successful virus in humans ended up...Wuhan.
and we know it was very infectious to humans at the start and we know the lab nearby was doing tests to make that happen- and said so.

I completely agree with the highlighted.

One way or the other they have shrouded the origins of Covid in mystery.

I think over time we will learn more, but it could be decades from now.
 
So...much of the leaking of the emails and Slack channel has focused on areas where some scientists have expressed alarm at the structure of the virus and wondered aloud whether or not it demonstrates tinkering within the lab.

Still more, and to some extent I would include myself, have thought that maybe the public declarations play down the possibility of the lab leak too much given how much they themselves gave the very theory some credence.

However, here are some Slack messages between Andersen and Holmes (although presumably the others were priv) in which they seem to have had their fears assuaged that such structures as the particular receptor-binding domain and furin cleavage site could not exist in nature.

We can see that they were working with the assumption that the lab should be considered most likely origin if such a structure could not exist in nature, but that zoonosis should be considered first if such a structure COULD be found in nature.

Link
 
Give me a break. :rolleyes:

Since when is the claim, "I didn't do it", evidence said persons didn't do it?

Both Daszak and Shi have been caught lying, the evidence has been posted here more than once. The number of specimens and genome analysis they would have collected over two decades of research on coronaviruses is grossly inconsistent with the number of specimens and genome databases they admitted having.

Draw your own conclusions.

What does that have to do with your comments?

(bold is mine) Is it incomprehensible to you that there were SARS-like CoVs at the WIV that have not been disclosed?
....

The idea with decades of collecting and studying SARS-like CoVs Shi didn't have something closer genetically to SARS CoV 2 than RaTG13 is simply not credible.

Just because someone has been caught lying doesn't allow for you to pick and choose what else they say is a lie.

Credibility by itself is not evidence . But you know that.:rolleyes:
 
...

Credibility by itself is not evidence.
Evidence needs to be credible. Claims by a documented liar cannot be considered credible with no corroboration.

Get back to us when Shi and the Chinese government allow an examination of the evidence that would support or refute Shi's claims.
 
From what others I find credible have said it is the FCS that is the stickler of non-natural evolution- not absolutely for sure, but very very likely.

The lab itself knew viruses were left in the steel receptacles and instruments and they needed better ways to disinfect. (there was a patent filed for it in 2020). They knew sometimes they got bit! and there was a patent for that too. I think you were the one that found that one. Feels like ages ago.

Once the virus has merged adapted been engineered or who knows....the thing no one thinks can happen, always happens.

So I think simple answers about where a tiny little virus, and/or the millions of replicants of it, went or traveled are near impossible to detect now that so much time has passed. China wont let anyone into their blood samples from Wuhan/2019 to check. They also wont let anyone into Mojiang, or the lab for that matter. We really should be so furious at China for all the blockade of transparent invetigation. :mad:

All we know is where the successful virus in humans ended up...Wuhan.
and we know it was very infectious to humans at the start and we know the lab nearby was doing tests to make that happen- and said so.
Except I'm a little more optimistic about the chances of finding patient zero and/or the actual origin of the jump to people I agree with all of this.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom