Now we are in agreement. Yay!!
I think this is a very possible scenario.
It is a crossover, but not really a natural spillover since the cause of it was direct collection and a lapse in safety measures, which do happen, even if all protocols are given a good try to follow.
And yet no virus genome close to COVID has been found, or at least disclosed to have been found.
There is evidence on video, for example, of WIV staff collecting specimens in the field without gloves. So clearly such a scenario is possible.
But it leaves the problem of COVID being genetically matched to spread rapidly as soon as it was introduced to humans in Wuhan. From Baric's 2016 paper cited above there was one virus they found, WIV1, that Baric discovered was ready to spread in people.
He concluded such spread would not be efficient at first.
Then there is that pesky little furin cleavage site that made COVID explosively contagious. While there has been such a gene segment found in the wild, there is no trail as to how it got into COVID. For example, it wasn't circulating in the bat populations where Shi and her staff collected SARS-like CoV specimens in the wild.
Capsid noted it that serial passages of SARS-like CoVs in VERO cells
led to the furin site evolving out of SARS-like CoVs if it had been inserted. But that also meant it wasn't likely to have arisen in the wild. I posted a citation noting that.
Yet had it been artificially inserted and the virus grown in cell cultures and mice in the lab it would easily explain how the furin got there.
With SARS1 after it jumped from civet cats or raccoon dogs to humans the virus circulated in the human population for several months before becoming as easily transmissible as it became. For example when it reached Canada where infection control was usually effectively practiced, they learned one could not hang reuseable gowns on a rack in the anteroom like they did with other isolation cases. That little difference resulted in the virus spreading among staff. And in Hong Kong it spread in drainage pipes in a large apartment building, and it spread from an elevator ride to people who then took it to 9 different countries.
But it took a month for that kind of transmissibility to be established. The evidence supports that wasn't needed with COVID. It was explosively transmissible from the start.
In addition to noting that differed from other zoonotic spillovers, had that happened naturally in the wild one would expect outbreaks all over the place before the pandemic started in Wuhan. First, the crossover animals would need to be circulating the infection among themselves. The virus typically through a recombination event could conceivably have acquired the furin site. How likely is that?
It would have had to have been somewhere the viruses were circulating in the wild. The seafood market wasn't such a place, no virus with the furin site was circulating in animals at the market. They didn't even sell live bats according to reports and it isn't likely the recombinant event occurred among raccoon dogs with no evidence COVID was circulating in that species let alone two coronaviruses circulating leading to a recombinant event.
So now what are the odds COVID emerged in the wild and infected raccoon dogs, then people at the market, or, infected a staff member collecting specimens for the WIV who then spread it to who? Someone at the market? Staff or students at the WIV? Family or friends in Wuhan near the market?
In either of those scenarios, given how adding that furin site made COVID so easily transmissible it didn't need to circulate among humans to get there, one would expect to have seen little COVID outbreaks someplace other than the wet market. Were it in raccoon dogs then one should have seen other cases among the hunters, farmers, transporters or other animal handlers in addition to the Wuhan outbreak. Were it in a person collecting specimens in the cave one would have expected to see similar viruses circulating among the bats in the caves.
Finding a furin cleavage site in another bat species in the wild would make a recombinant event possible. But that is only a very remote possibility it then just happened to have jumped to a person heading back to the WIV but who wasn't bringing
that specimen back. Where were the two species of CoVs circulating that allowed the recombinant event? They were found in different caves IIRC.
That's a whole lot of ducks that would have needed to have been lined up for any of those naturally evolved SARS-like CoV2 to have led to the pandemic.
OTOH, one only needs a purposeful insertion of the furin site into a CoV that was already adapted to humans with the ACE2 binding sites, and from there this virus could easily have been cultured in the mice or human respiratory cells because by now WIV researchers would have known culturing in VERO cells would not work.
One researcher or other staff member at the WIV mucking around with the resulting PPP in a BSL2 lab gets infected and spreads it to the community in Wuhan near the WIV where it soon becomes a PP, pandemic pathogen, no longer just potential.
Which scenario makes more sense and is supported by more evidence: that COVID evolved in the wild or it evolved in the lab?