Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

I don’t trust Shellenberger’s report. He literally reported that anonymous sources have told him the US is in possession of UFOs suggesting that these were alien spacecraft. You can listen to his podcast episode with Michael Shermer if you like.
 
I don’t trust Shellenberger’s report. He literally reported that anonymous sources have told him the US is in possession of UFOs suggesting that these were alien spacecraft. You can listen to his podcast episode with Michael Shermer if you like.
Not interested. I don't trust Hu, Shi, Daszak, Fauci, and Collins. Why it's a standoff. ;)

It's not like Shellenberger is the only source of information here.

You've been slicing and dicing the 3 sick worker cherries since the beginning of the thread. You focused on these 3 workers as if they existed in a vacuum. What, don't have their names and full confessions? Well that settles it, it's all a CT. :covereyes


Oh wait, whether Hu got sick or not he is on the document describing WIV researchers inserting the fcs into SARS-like CoVs. Which of those 2 things might be more important here, the research or who got sick first?

The infection control practices at the WIV were appalling. That much is blatantly obvious.


Do you want to add anything more to my list re the 3 ill workers?

History of the evidence of the 3 ill workers:
First it was reported in a cable from the US Embassy that 3 people from the WIV got sick and were hospitalized in Nov 2019

Then it was noted in some article that under the Chinese system going to the hospital was like going to a clinic, it didn't mean the 3 were hospitalized

Then the FBI found the report of the 3 ill workers credible

Then the names were released (sorry you don't like anonymous sources) Dr Hu was one of the 3

Another source noted one of their symptoms was they lost their sense of smell

Dr Hu as well as the other 2 named all deny they were ill in Nov 2019

Shi has stated all the people at the WIV tested negative for coronavirus antibodies, but she denied access to the raw data when the WHO inspection took place

Daszak claims the WHO team never asked for said raw data (keep in mind their time at the WIV was only a couple of hours, short relative to the task they were there to complete)

Dr Shi still has not released the raw data re the antibody testing

Then the FOIA request resulted in a data dump of thousands of emails (you can find the data dump online)

Fortunately the White Coat Waste Project pulled some relevant emails where Fauci said there probably was GoF research going on at the WIV

The Waste Project also noted the grant from the US directly to the WIV and they posted a screenshot of Dr Hu's name listed as a researcher on the project

The plan was to insert an fcs into the coronavirus to determine if there was a threat of a natural spillover, the goal was to develop a vaccine before a spillover

There's a video of Dr Hu working in the lab without gloves (I have not yet seen that video)

The US Intelligence Agency released a report recently that found the evidence of the 3 ill workers was sketchy at best​
Did I misrepresent anything, leave anything out?

I found the images of Dr Hu working without gloves, BTW, but not the video. According to The Sun, (OMG they must be deep fakes, we can't rely on any pics in a tabloid), the video of workers collecting specimens from the bat caves don't include Hu.

The tabloid headline: LAB RATS Shocking pictures show scientists at ‘Patient Zero’ lab ‘BITTEN by bats’ & handling dangerous viruses with no protection

Pay that clickbait headline no mind it's the images that matter. BTW, some of those same images are in citations earlier in the thread. They didn't appear in The Sun first.
 
Last edited:
Bold is mine noting your hyperbole. I'm not sure why you diss Shellenberger's credibility while you post "it is probably a real document" re his report on the work of Dr Hu.

All this dissing of anonymous sources like they are also anonymous to the reporter is unfounded. One usually relies on the reporter to vet the source and the information.

History of the evidence:
First it was reported in a cable from the US Embassy that 3 people from the WIV got sick and were hospitalized in Nov 2019

Then it was noted in some article that under the Chinese system going to the hospital was like going to a clinic, it didn't mean the 3 were hospitalized

Then the FBI found the report of the 3 ill workers credible

Then the names were released (sorry you don't like anonymous sources) Dr Hu was one of the 3

Another source noted one of their symptoms was they lost their sense of smell

Dr Hu as well as the other 2 named all deny they were ill in Nov 2019

Shi has stated all the people at the WIV tested negative for coronavirus antibodies, but she denied access to the raw data when the WHO inspection took place

Daszak claims the WHO team never asked for said raw data (keep in mind their time at the WIV was only a couple of hours, short relative to the task they were there to complete)

Dr Shi still has not released the raw data re the antibody testing

Then the FOIA request resulted in a data dump of thousands of emails (you can find the data dump online)

Fortunately the White Coat Waste Project pulled some relevant emails where Fauci said there probably was GoF research going on at the WIV

The Waste Project also noted the grant from the US directly to the WIV and they posted a screenshot of Dr Hu's name listed as a researcher on the project

The plan was to insert an fcs into the coronavirus to determine if there was a threat of a natural spillover, the goal was to develop a vaccine before a spillover

There's a video of Dr Hu working in the lab without gloves (I have not yet seen that video)

The US Intelligence Agency released a report recently that found the evidence of the 3 ill workers was sketchy at best​
Now, you can take Hu's word for it he was not ill in Nov 2019. There's Dr Shi's word none of the staff were ill, and the recent intelligence report that failed to confirm there were 3 ill staff members in Nov 2019 and you can continue defending your hill.

I choose to keep looking for more evidence and at the moment it looks like the 3 persons from the WIV may have indeed been patient zeros.

Also Andersen who was working in WIV in November and socialised with Shi's team verifies that there wasn't an outbreak of illness. So we have three primary sources who were actually at WIV at the time who said it did not happen. Who are on record.

You have analysis by hostile intelligence agencies and the ODNI report concludes

We have no indications that any of these researchers were hospitalized because of the symptoms consistent with COVID-19. One researcher may have been hospitalized in this timeframe for treatment of a non-respiratory medical condition.

China’s National Security Commission investigated the WIV in early 2020 and took blood samples from WIV researchers. According to the World Health Organization's March 2021 public report, WIV officials including Shi Zhengli—who leads the WIV laboratory group that conducts coronavirus research—stated lab employee samples all tested negative for SARS-CoV-2 antibodies.

While several WIV researchers fell mildly ill in Fall 2019, they experienced a range of symptoms consistent with colds or allergies with accompanying symptoms typically not associated with COVID-19, and some of them were confirmed to have been sick with other illnesses unrelated to COVID-19. While some of these researchers had historically conducted research into animal respiratory viruses, we are unable to confirm if any of them handled live viruses in the work they performed prior to falling ill.

However you are happy to go with gossip by anonymous people as a better source of evidence.
 
Not interested. I don't trust Hu, Shi, Daszak, Fauci, and Collins. Why it's a standoff. ;)

It's not like Shellenberger is the only source of information here.

You've been slicing and dicing the 3 sick worker cherries since the beginning of the thread. You focused on these 3 workers as if they existed in a vacuum. What, don't have their names and full confessions? Well that settles it, it's all a CT. :covereyes


Oh wait, whether Hu got sick or not he is on the document describing WIV researchers inserting the fcs into SARS-like CoVs. Which of those 2 things might be more important here, the research or who got sick first?

The infection control practices at the WIV were appalling. That much is blatantly obvious.


Do you want to add anything more to my list re the 3 ill workers?

History of the evidence of the 3 ill workers:
First it was reported in a cable from the US Embassy that 3 people from the WIV got sick and were hospitalized in Nov 2019

Then it was noted in some article that under the Chinese system going to the hospital was like going to a clinic, it didn't mean the 3 were hospitalized

Then the FBI found the report of the 3 ill workers credible

Then the names were released (sorry you don't like anonymous sources) Dr Hu was one of the 3

Another source noted one of their symptoms was they lost their sense of smell

Dr Hu as well as the other 2 named all deny they were ill in Nov 2019

Shi has stated all the people at the WIV tested negative for coronavirus antibodies, but she denied access to the raw data when the WHO inspection took place

Daszak claims the WHO team never asked for said raw data (keep in mind their time at the WIV was only a couple of hours, short relative to the task they were there to complete)

Dr Shi still has not released the raw data re the antibody testing

Then the FOIA request resulted in a data dump of thousands of emails (you can find the data dump online)

Fortunately the White Coat Waste Project pulled some relevant emails where Fauci said there probably was GoF research going on at the WIV

The Waste Project also noted the grant from the US directly to the WIV and they posted a screenshot of Dr Hu's name listed as a researcher on the project
The plan was to insert an fcs into the coronavirus to determine if there was a threat of a natural spillover, the goal was to develop a vaccine before a spillover

There's a video of Dr Hu working in the lab without gloves (I have not yet seen that video)

The US Intelligence Agency released a report recently that found the evidence of the 3 ill workers was sketchy at best​
Did I misrepresent anything, leave anything out?

I found the images of Dr Hu working without gloves, BTW, but not the video. According to The Sun, (OMG they must be deep fakes, we can't rely on any pics in a tabloid), the video of workers collecting specimens from the bat caves don't include Hu.

The tabloid headline: LAB RATS Shocking pictures show scientists at ‘Patient Zero’ lab ‘BITTEN by bats’ & handling dangerous viruses with no protection

Pay that clickbait headline no mind it's the images that matter. BTW, some of those same images are in citations earlier in the thread. They didn't appear in The Sun first.

Hu got sick or not he is on the document describing WIV researchers inserting the fcs into SARS-like CoVs

This is simply not true. There is no such document. i have linked to the actual documents, I have read them. They say no such thing. If you can find such a document please link to it. From the ODNI report.

We assess that some scientists at the WIV have genetically engineered coronaviruses using common laboratory practices. The IC has no information, however, indicating that any WIV genetic engineering work has involved SARS-CoV-2, a close progenitor, or a backbone virus that is closely-related enough to have been the source of the pandemic.

You claim to have better intelligence than ODNI? When you find that document you had better send it to the CIA and FBI because they obviously didn't find it!

The Waste Project also noted the grant from the US directly to the WIV and they posted a screenshot of Dr Hu's name listed as a researcher on the project

Yes. The projects Hu listed himself as being involved with did not involve inserting a furin cleavage site into the S protein of a SARSr CoV. I have linked to the actual project grants listed by Hu and shown in the screenshot. The actual grants do not mention Hu by name. They certainly do not identify what he actually did. Hu himself in his interview says he does not work with live viruses and does bio-informatics.

I found the images of Dr Hu working without gloves, BTW, but not the video.

So what? Most of the time you work in a laboratory without gloves. Most of the work would not involve live viruses or any reason to wear gloves.
 
This is simply not true. There is no such document. i have linked to the actual documents, I have read them. They say no such thing. If you can find such a document please link to it. From the ODNI report.
:sdl: You still haven't figured out you linked to the wrong document. There is a link to the right one in this thread. I told you I have no obligation to spoon feed anything to you.

Here's a hint, one grant provided millions to the WIV from ~2014-2018. That is the one Hu's name is on. Another grant proposal was awarded to the EHA. That is the one where Daszak didn't file the regular reports he was supposed to file. And finally there was the latest grant proposal that was denied.

Perhaps with those hints you might recognize you aren't looking at the right documents. You could always do a Google search.


You claim to have better intelligence than ODNI? When you find that document you had better send it to the CIA and FBI because they obviously didn't find it!
:sdl: They could ask the FBI for their copy. But I don't think that is what the latest intelligence report said. They addressed the evidence for the 3 ill workers separate from any assessment of grants and grant proposals.


I suppose no one should hold it against you that you don't understand why multiple intelligence reports from different agencies in the US are inconsistent and the last one in no way supersedes the earlier reports from the other departments.


Yes. The projects Hu listed himself as being involved with did not involve inserting a furin cleavage site into the S protein of a SARSr CoV. I have linked to the actual project grants listed by Hu and shown in the screenshot. The actual grants do not mention Hu by name. They certainly do not identify what he actually did. Hu himself in his interview says he does not work with live viruses and does bio-informatics.

See answer above.


So what? Most of the time you work in a laboratory without gloves. Most of the work would not involve live viruses or any reason to wear gloves.
It's the Wuhan Institute of Virology, not a facility that assesses environmental toxins in the workplace. :rolleyes:

Sure, maybe someone specifically misrepresented pictures of Dr Hu—deep fakes! And all those field workers collecting specimens in the wild with inconsistent PPE use doesn't suggest at all that people in the BSL2 lab at the WIV were let's say, less than meticulous about infection control. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
... However you are happy to go with gossip by anonymous people as a better source of evidence.
So much straw in here, makes it hard to see where one is going.


Re three primary sources, that is laughable.
 
Last edited:
:sdl: You still haven't figured out you linked to the wrong document. There is a link to the right one in this thread. I told you I have no obligation to spoon feed anything to you.

Here's a hint, one grant provided millions to the WIV from ~2014-2018. That is the one Hu's name is on. Another grant proposal was awarded to the EHA. That is the one where Daszak didn't file the regular reports he was supposed to file. And finally there was the latest grant proposal that was denied.

Perhaps with those hints you might recognize you aren't looking at the right documents. You could always do a Google search.


:sdl: They could ask the FBI for their copy. But I don't think that is what the latest intelligence report said. They addressed the evidence for the 3 ill workers separate from any assessment of grants and grant proposals.


I suppose no one should hold it against you that you don't understand why multiple intelligence reports from different agencies in the US are inconsistent and the last one in no way supersedes the earlier reports from the other departments.




See answer above.


It's the Wuhan Institute of Virology, not a facility that assesses environmental toxins in the workplace. :rolleyes:

Sure, maybe someone specifically misrepresented pictures of Dr Hu—deep fakes! And all those field workers collecting specimens in the wild with inconsistent PPE use doesn't suggest at all that people in the BSL2 lab at the WIV were let's say, less than meticulous about infection control. :rolleyes:

From
https://blog.whitecoatwaste.org/202...tigation-proves-u-s-govt-funded-patient-zero/

NIAID $3,586,760 'Understanding the risk of bat coronavirus emergence' Ecohealth Alliance and International field and lab locations - pending
This grant includes plans for FCS work by Baric at NC.

NIAID $3,066,375 'Understanding the risk of bat coronavirus emergence'
Ecohealth Alliance and International field and lab locations -awarded

https://cdn.factcheck.org/UploadedFiles/NIAID_EcoHealth_20142019.pdf
https://www.documentcloud.org/docum...request-55058-first-look-institute-2_redacted
Nothing about Furin Cleavage site nor Hu.

Predict 2 $38,000,000 Awarded to UC Davis sub contract to eco health. (Presumably further sub contracted to WIV). This involved no genetic engineering this was survey and ecology work.
https://www.ecohealthalliance.org/program/predict
 
Not interested. I don't trust Hu, Shi, Daszak, Fauci, and Collins. Why it's a standoff. ;)

It's not like Shellenberger is the only source of information here.

In terms of names he is.

You've been slicing and dicing the 3 sick worker cherries since the beginning of the thread. You focused on these 3 workers as if they existed in a vacuum. What, don't have their names and full confessions? Well that settles it, it's all a CT. :covereyes

We don't have much to go on at all. What we have, according to the recent intelligence report, echoing the previous intelligence report is...

Several WIV researchers were ill in Fall 2019 with symptoms;
some of their symptoms were consistent with but not diagnostic of COVID-19. The IC continues to assess that this information neither supports nor refutes either hypothesis of the pandemic’s origins because the researchers’ symptoms could have been caused by a number of diseases and some of the symptoms were not consistent with COVID-19.

We have no indications that any of these researchers were
hospitalized because of the symptoms consistent with COVID-19. One researcher may have been hospitalized in this timeframe for treatment of a non-respiratory medical condition.

While several WIV researchers fell mildly ill in Fall 2019, they experienced a range of symptoms consistent with colds or allergies with accompanying symptoms typically not associated with COVID-19, and some of them were confirmed to have been sick with other illnesses unrelated to COVID-19. While some of these researchers had
historically conducted research into animal respiratory viruses, we are unable to confirm if any
of them handled live viruses in the work they performed prior to falling ill.


Oh wait, whether Hu got sick or not he is on the document describing WIV researchers inserting the fcs into SARS-like CoVs. Which of those 2 things might be more important here, the research or who got sick first?

The infection control practices at the WIV were appalling. That much is blatantly obvious.


Do you want to add anything more to my list re the 3 ill workers?

History of the evidence of the 3 ill workers:
First it was reported in a cable from the US Embassy that 3 people from the WIV got sick and were hospitalized in Nov 2019​


I don't see any evidence of these "cables". I asked you about this before, and you did some weird side-step which amounted to admitting the cables were about a different matter, and acted as though I was the one who hadn't read your posts properly when I asked you again for the cables about the sick WIV workers. So maybe you need to edit your list so that you don't keep repeating the incorrect information.

The origin of the sick co-workers seems to be the fact sheet. Where they got this information from, who knows.

Then it was noted in some article that under the Chinese system going to the hospital was like going to a clinic, it didn't mean the 3 were hospitalized

Then the FBI found the report of the 3 ill workers credible

Did they? Or did they base their decision on something else? I see nobody saying that they based it on the sick worker story.

Then the names were released (sorry you don't like anonymous sources) Dr Hu was one of the 3

Another source noted one of their symptoms was they lost their sense of smell

Indeed, but we also know that a certain group of people within the US government were making all kinds of claims to anyone who would listen. Remember that the wife of one of the named people were said to have died of Covid.

You will then ask for a source, and I will dig up David Asher talking to the Mail and/or Sharri Markson and you can say, "Ha ha! You're using the Mail" But THAT is where you are getting information about the sick workers.

The wife of a Wuhan lab researcher working on deadly viruses apparently died of Covid in December 2019, according to a bombshell US report. The leader of a State Department investigation under the Trump administration made the shock claim amid renewed interest in the lab-leak origin theory of Covid. David Asher, who led an investigation on COVID-19’s origins, told the Daily Caller an employee at the Wuhan Institute of Virology provided US intelligence with the information on the lab researcher’s wife dying from a mysterious virus.

https://www.express.co.uk/news/worl...na-Wuhan-virus-Joe-Biden-Trump-latest-news-vn

Did the wife die of Covid?

If yes, then I would put the reports as far more credible.

If not, then, again I have to wonder if David Asher is one of the anonymous sources for the names of the workers.

This is what these things hinge on. The reliability of the sources of the information.

You accept as reliable, Shellenberger's claims about the sick WIV workers.

Here he is on UFOs...

And now, multiple sources close to the matter have come forward to tell Public that Grusch’s core claims are accurate. The individuals are all either high-ranking intelligence officials, former intelligence officials, or individuals who we could verify were involved in U.S. government UAP efforts for three or more decades each. Two of them have testified, including as recently as last year, to both AARO and Congress.

The individuals said they had seen or been presented with “credible” and “verifiable” evidence that the U.S. government, and U.S. military contractors, possess at least 12 or more alien space crafts, some of which they shared with AARO, which AARO has refused to provide to Congress. The reason AARO “has not discovered any verifiable information,” they said, is because it does have the authority to verify it and may not want to verify it.

Link

I think we have a pretty good idea who some of these particular individuals are, and passing on the information that the US posesses at least 12 alien spacecraft has to at least make me a bit skeptical if Shellenberger's article naming Ben Hu is the only source we have to go on.

I could name plenty of sources who could easily have been talking to Shellenberger who are likely to be telling porkie pies. David Asher is one of those.

Like I have said in the past, if we see that Ben Hu was hospitalized with something like Covid (no, if he had appendicitis during that time, I will not count it), or if his wife died of Covid-like illness in December 2019, then I will definitely change my opinion on this.

Until then, we have sketchy information and innuendo from extremely untrustworthy sources.​
 
We also have Andersen, a bat immunologist working at WIV in November 2019 and who socialised with the Shi team. She says there was no outbreak of respiratory illness and no one's wife died. She was tested for exposure when she returned to Australia in early 2020 and had not been exposed to SARS-CoV-2.

Ping Yu one of the named scientists had stopped working at WIV and had relocated to Beijing at the relevant time. So naming her as one of the infected scientists was clearly wrong.

Hu denies any ill health in November, or any outbreak of illness.
 
In terms of names he is.

We don't have much to go on at all. What we have, according to the recent intelligence report, echoing the previous intelligence report is...

I don't see any evidence of these "cables". I asked you about this before, and you did some weird side-step which amounted to admitting the cables were about a different matter, and acted as though I was the one who hadn't read your posts properly when I asked you again for the cables about the sick WIV workers. So maybe you need to edit your list so that you don't keep repeating the incorrect information.

The origin of the sick co-workers seems to be the fact sheet. Where they got this information from, who knows.

Did they? Or did they base their decision on something else? I see nobody saying that they based it on the sick worker story.

Indeed, but we also know that a certain group of people within the US government were making all kinds of claims to anyone who would listen. Remember that the wife of one of the named people were said to have died of Covid.

You will then ask for a source, and I will dig up David Asher talking to the Mail and/or Sharri Markson and you can say, "Ha ha! You're using the Mail" But THAT is where you are getting information about the sick workers.

https://www.express.co.uk/news/worl...na-Wuhan-virus-Joe-Biden-Trump-latest-news-vn

Did the wife die of Covid?

If yes, then I would put the reports as far more credible.

If not, then, again I have to wonder if David Asher is one of the anonymous sources for the names of the workers.

This is what these things hinge on. The reliability of the sources of the information.

You accept as reliable, Shellenberger's claims about the sick WIV workers.

Here he is on UFOs...

Link

I think we have a pretty good idea who some of these particular individuals are, and passing on the information that the US posesses at least 12 alien spacecraft has to at least make me a bit skeptical if Shellenberger's article naming Ben Hu is the only source we have to go on.

I could name plenty of sources who could easily have been talking to Shellenberger who are likely to be telling porkie pies. David Asher is one of those.

Like I have said in the past, if we see that Ben Hu was hospitalized with something like Covid (no, if he had appendicitis during that time, I will not count it), or if his wife died of Covid-like illness in December 2019, then I will definitely change my opinion on this.

Until then, we have sketchy information and innuendo from extremely untrustworthy sources.
Your post is in the queue. I'm currently working on the pages in Planigale's link where she left so much low hanging fruit by not reading the progress report on the grant that I'm behind.
 
Your post is in the queue. I'm currently working on the pages in Planigale's link where she left so much low hanging fruit by not reading the progress report on the grant that I'm behind.

Take your time. There’s no rush and we both know what we are going to write for the next five times.

On the other hand we could just leave it until something else comes back to save us the bother.
 
From
https://blog.whitecoatwaste.org/202...tigation-proves-u-s-govt-funded-patient-zero/

NIAID $3,586,760 'Understanding the risk of bat coronavirus emergence' Ecohealth Alliance and International field and lab locations - pending
This grant includes plans for FCS work by Baric at NC.

NIAID $3,066,375 'Understanding the risk of bat coronavirus emergence'
Ecohealth Alliance and International field and lab locations -awarded

https://cdn.factcheck.org/UploadedFiles/NIAID_EcoHealth_20142019.pdf
https://www.documentcloud.org/docum...request-55058-first-look-institute-2_redacted
Nothing about Furin Cleavage site nor Hu.
[bold is mine]
It's nice you posted the details of the EHA grant progress report but it's still not the earliest stuff from 2014.

The report you posted covers June 2018 to May 2019 (described as years 4-5) while the grant was initially awarded in 2014. I'm pretty sure the earlier progress reports weren't done. That was noted in a cite up thread.

Note also this report was filed in 2021, well after the pandemic was underway. That explains why the report refers in a number of places that they were manipulating the RBDs (receptor binding sites on the genome) but the specifics like adding an fcs are noticeably absent. That was also true in the 2014 grant description I found, but the specifics were more detailed.

If you find the progress reports from years 1-3 you'll get a gold star! I don't think they exist. That's when Daszak didn't file the required annual progress reports.


I did find the description of the initial request and noted funds were granted:

First I found this:
Understanding the Risk of Bat Coronavirus Emergence, 2014; NIH Awards by Location & Organization

And that led to this:
Understanding the Risk of Bat Coronavirus Emergence; Project Number 1R01AI110964-01; Contact PI/Project Leader DASZAK, PETER; Awardee Organization ECOHEALTH ALLIANCE, INC.; Date; 27-May-2014


I'll get back to comparing the two descriptions of manipulating the RBS in the next post, one from 2014 and the one you posted from 2018-2019, but I want to address a couple of things you posted that weren't accurate.

Have you taken the next step and actually read what you posted?
I know 72 pages is a lot to read but more than half of it is about Daszak's project surveying the prevalence of spillovers in the populations near where the bats were endemic and a quarter of the report is filling in the required boxes, easy to skim and scroll past. It's the paragraphs in between that have the most relevant stuff.

Daszak and his team did a pretty comprehensive survey of the prevalence of coronaviruses in various bat populations in an extensive area of caves. They used the WIV labs, it is mentioned multiple times under participants. Not sure why you noted Baric or his lab were involved as that doesn't rule out work done at the WIV. If you think I conflated the two you'd be wrong.
To find the WIV lab mentioned look for the boxes like this one on page 23:
G9 Foreign component
Organization name: Wuhan Institute of Virology
There is also a reference to using the CCDC lab in the report, sorry, I lost my place so don't know the page it was on.

I was especially interested the EHA found that horseshoe bats in a Yunnan cave system near the mine had important SARS-related CoVs. Daszak felt it was important enough to note it specifically.
On page 31)
We also identified one cave system in Yunnan Province with horseshoe bats that had diverse SARSr CoVs including some with S proteins capable of using human ACE2 entry receptors
One reason Daszak might have had for pointing this out specifically was by that time COVID was pandemic. Seemed convenient in retrospect but who knows.


Re Dr Hu not being mentioned as a participant, that's because all of the team members are not mentioned. Shi is noted but Hu being under her isn't. However you can find he was there, he's listed as an author on a couple of publications identified as resulting from the work the grant has accomplished. Here's one of them:

Page 65 of the report: publications Discovery of a rich gene pool of bat SARS-related coronaviruses provides new insights into the origin of SARS coronavirus
Authors
Ben Hu, Data curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Validation, Visualization, Writing – original draft,#1
There are a number of other members responsible for this paper. Hu looks like the primary investigator. Shi and Daszak are listed at the bottom showing the administrative roles they played.


To review: The work was done at the WIV. While Shi did work with Baric at the UNC including learning how to reverse engineer genomes and taking back some of the humanized mice. But this work under the 2014 grant was done by Shi and Daszak with Hu contributing at the WIV.

Not sure if some of the sampled bats in Daszak's survey were tested in other labs but most if not all of the coronavirus identification was done at the WIV.
 
Last edited:
[bold is mine]
It's nice you posted the details of the EHA grant progress report but it's still not the earliest stuff from 2014.

The report you posted covers June 2018 to May 2019 (described as years 4-5) while the grant was initially awarded in 2014. I'm pretty sure the earlier progress reports weren't done. That was noted in a cite up thread.

Note also this report was filed in 2021, well after the pandemic was underway. That explains why the report refers in a number of places that they were manipulating the RBDs (receptor binding sites on the genome) but the specifics like adding an fcs are noticeably absent. That was also true in the 2014 grant description I found, but the specifics were more detailed.

If you find the progress reports from years 1-3 you'll get a gold star! I don't think they exist. That's when Daszak didn't file the required annual progress reports.


I did find the description of the initial request and noted funds were granted:

First I found this:
Understanding the Risk of Bat Coronavirus Emergence, 2014; NIH Awards by Location & Organization

And that led to this:
Understanding the Risk of Bat Coronavirus Emergence; Project Number 1R01AI110964-01; Contact PI/Project Leader DASZAK, PETER; Awardee Organization ECOHEALTH ALLIANCE, INC.; Date; 27-May-2014


I'll get back to comparing the two descriptions of manipulating the RBS in the next post, one from 2014 and the one you posted from 2018-2019, but I want to address a couple of things you posted that weren't accurate.

Have you taken the next step and actually read what you posted?
I know 72 pages is a lot to read but more than half of it is about Daszak's project surveying the prevalence of spillovers in the populations near where the bats were endemic and a quarter of the report is filling in the required boxes, easy to skim and scroll past. It's the paragraphs in between that have the most relevant stuff.

Daszak and his team did a pretty comprehensive survey of the prevalence of coronaviruses in various bat populations in an extensive area of caves. They used the WIV labs, it is mentioned multiple times under participants. Not sure why you noted Baric or his lab were involved as that doesn't rule out work done at the WIV. If you think I conflated the two you'd be wrong.
To find the WIV lab mentioned look for the boxes like this one on page 23:

There is also a reference to using the CCDC lab in the report, sorry, I lost my place so don't know the page it was on.

I was especially interested the EHA found that horseshoe bats in a Yunnan cave system near the mine had important SARS-related CoVs. Daszak felt it was important enough to note it specifically.
On page 31)
One reason Daszak might have had for pointing this out specifically was by that time COVID was pandemic. Seemed convenient in retrospect but who knows.


Re Dr Hu not being mentioned as a participant, that's because all of the team members are not mentioned. Shi is noted but Hu being under her isn't. However you can find he was there, he's listed as an author on a couple of publications identified as resulting from the work the grant has accomplished. Here's one of them:

Page 65 of the report: publications Discovery of a rich gene pool of bat SARS-related coronaviruses provides new insights into the origin of SARS coronavirus
Authors

There are a number of other members responsible for this paper. Hu looks like the primary investigator. Shi and Daszak are listed at the bottom showing the administrative roles they played.


To review: The work was done at the WIV. While Shi did work with Baric at the UNC including learning how to reverse engineer genomes and taking back some of the humanized mice. But this work under the 2014 grant was done by Shi and Daszak with Hu contributing at the WIV.

Hu (as you say) does bioinformatics / data. He isn't doing the bio-engineering. I have never said he doesn't work at WIV, nor that he does not work with Shi, I have merely said that he is not a 'genetic engineer'. Hu would not be the one inserting a furin cleavage site. In his first author paper of 2017, it is notable that at the time the research was done, WIV clearly did not have transgenic mice, and did not manipulated the S protein.

i am pleased you recognise there is no mention of inserting a furin cleavage site prior to the non-funded 2019 project submission. If the research had already been done then why would they need to submit a request to fund the research, and why didn't they publish it?

The initial work on producing chimeric viruses was done in Baris's lab in NC. Yes, WIV obtain hACE2 transgenic mice. Yes subsequently WIV appear to have done research with chimeric viruses at the WIV laboratory. This is not gain of function research and could not have synthesised SARS-CoV-2. As the ODNI report says all the intelligence agencies agree SARS-CoV-2 was not engineered / synthesised I am not sure why you are heading down this rabbit hole.

Also I don't think Daszak does any laboratory work. He is mostly administrative. He helps write the papers. His background appears to be in field work.
 
Last edited:
Hu (as you say) does bioinformatics / data. He isn't doing the bio-engineering. I have never said he doesn't work at WIV, nor that he does not work with Shi, I have merely said that he is not a 'genetic engineer'. Hu would not be the one inserting a furin cleavage site.
Right, you weren't trying to dismiss the evidence. :rolleyes:

If he was the principal investigator then he was involved in some or all aspects of the GoF research in bat SARS-r CoVs. He was in the lab whether he worked with the viruses directly.

‘Ridiculous,’ says Chinese scientist accused of being pandemic’s patient zero
Hu says he never worked with live viruses in that experiment or any others done in Shi’s lab. “My work in the lab was mainly genome characterization and evolutionary analysis of viruses,” Hu wrote.
I've already pointed out whether or not these are the three WIV workers reported as being ill in Nov 2019, it's one piece of a large body of evidence. The fact Hu's name was on the grant, it's still the grant that matters. So stop with the crap that this nitpick or that sidetrack is relevant to the question: the origin of COVID-19. Hu was involved in the work.


i am pleased you recognise there is no mention of inserting a furin cleavage site prior to the non-funded 2019 project submission. If the research had already been done then why would they need to submit a request to fund the research, and why didn't they publish it?
I haven't posted about this yet, so maybe you should stop replying as if I had.

The initial work on producing chimeric viruses was done in Baris's lab in NC. Yes, WIV obtain hACE2 transgenic mice. Yes subsequently WIV appear to have done research with chimeric viruses at the WIV laboratory. This is not gain of function research...
Nonsense. Fauci's BS excuse was a fail.They changed the infectivity of the CoVs they were working with, aka the pathogen gained a function. You need to read more current stuff, no one is claiming this wouldn't have been GoF.

and could not have synthesised SARS-CoV-2. As the ODNI report says all the intelligence agencies agree SARS-CoV-2 was not engineered / synthesised I am not sure why you are heading down this rabbit hole.
And I'm not sure why you keep repeating this unsupported falsehood.

Also I don't think Daszak does any laboratory work. He is mostly administrative. He helps write the papers. His background appears to be in field work.

You have no idea how involved Daszak was/is in the field and in lab work. From your posts you just assume every administrator has a desk job or whatever it is you think they all do. And you've decided all Hu does is data analysis which is not what his contribution to that published paper says.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Daszak
Daszak earned a B.Sc. in zoology in 1987, at Bangor University and a Ph.D. in parasitic infectious diseases in 1994 at University of East London.[2] ...

Starting in 2014, Daszak was Principal Investigator of a six-year NIH project which was awarded to the EcoHealth Alliance and which focused on the emergence of novel zoonotic coronaviruses with a bat origin.[12]
I don't think a principal investigator sits in an office and never shows up in the lab or in the field. Why would it matter if he ever touched a machine or a culture plate? It doesn't, he was directly involved.

Same as with Hu. He was deeply involved and aware of what work was being done in the lab, he wasn't a secretary crunching data someone fed him. Bioinformatics and medical research are more and more partners these days.


Yes a lot of work was done at Baric's lab with his HIV backboned chimera and all that. Beyond that, you just make stuff up. And BTW, that last cite I posted about Baric included him saying he was surprised to find one of his creations readily infected human airway cells. He believed the coronaviruses he had been working with were benign. They weren't.

The grant does not include anything about Baric and/or the UNC lab. This is you putting pieces together based on your confirmation bias.

I'll ask again, did you read the 72 page grant progress report you cited? Or did you just skim a bit here and a bit there?
 
Right, you weren't trying to dismiss the evidence. :rolleyes:

If he was the principal investigator then he was involved in some or all aspects of the GoF research in bat SARS-r CoVs. He was in the lab whether he worked with the viruses directly.

‘Ridiculous,’ says Chinese scientist accused of being pandemic’s patient zero

I've already pointed out whether or not these are the three WIV workers reported as being ill in Nov 2019, it's one piece of a large body of evidence. The fact Hu's name was on the grant, it's still the grant that matters. So stop with the crap that this nitpick or that sidetrack is relevant to the question: the origin of COVID-19. Hu was involved in the work.



I haven't posted about this yet, so maybe you should stop replying as if I had.

Nonsense. Fauci's BS excuse was a fail.They changed the infectivity of the CoVs they were working with, aka the pathogen gained a function. You need to read more current stuff, no one is claiming this wouldn't have been GoF.

And I'm not sure why you keep repeating this unsupported falsehood.



You have no idea how involved Daszak was/is in the field and in lab work. From your posts you just assume every administrator has a desk job or whatever it is you think they all do. And you've decided all Hu does is data analysis which is not what his contribution to that published paper says.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Daszak
I don't think a principal investigator sits in an office and never shows up in the lab or in the field. Why would it matter if he ever touched a machine or a culture plate? It doesn't, he was directly involved.

Same as with Hu. He was deeply involved and aware of what work was being done in the lab, he wasn't a secretary crunching data someone fed him. Bioinformatics and medical research are more and more partners these days.


Yes a lot of work was done at Baric's lab with his HIV backboned chimera and all that. Beyond that, you just make stuff up. And BTW, that last cite I posted about Baric included him saying he was surprised to find one of his creations readily infected human airway cells. He believed the coronaviruses he had been working with were benign. They weren't.

The grant does not include anything about Baric and/or the UNC lab. This is you putting pieces together based on your confirmation bias.

I'll ask again, did you read the 72 page grant progress report you cited? Or did you just skim a bit here and a bit there?

PI (principle investigator) has a technical meaning, it refers to the grant holder, and guarantor. For WIV this was Shi. Hu was first author, but never PI. For most papers you can read the contribution of authors, Daszak in the last few years does no lab work, he plans, he supervises, he writes papers; science admin. His main area is disease ecology.

'Gain of function' is deliberately increasing the pathogenicity of a human pathogen in the definition that is commonly used. The backbone was WIV-1 (not HIV as you wrote) this is a mouse virus so by definition what is done to it is not 'gain of function'. The majority of viral chimeras produced (6) failed to replicate, again showing that this was not gain of function but actually loss of function. The whole object was to see if the novel virus might be infectious in humans. But rather than using the novel virus they used a well characterised murine virus as the backbone and only transposed the gene for the S protein into the murine virus backbone then looked to see whether it could replicate in a cell culture expressing human ACE2. People are still doing exactly the same experiments now and they are still not classified as gain of function.
 
and could not have synthesised SARS-CoV-2. As the ODNI report says all the intelligence agencies agree SARS-CoV-2 was not engineered / synthesised I am not sure why you are heading down this rabbit hole.
And I'm not sure why you keep repeating this unsupported falsehood.
Planigale's one-sentence summary of what the (updated) ODNI report says is false, but that sentence becomes a correct summary of what the ODNI report says if you replace the word "all" by "most" and insert the word "probably". With my highlighting:
ODNI report said:
We judge the virus was not developed as a biological weapon. Most agencies also assess with low confidence that SARS-CoV-2 probably was not genetically engineered; however, two agencies believe there was not sufficient evidence to make an assessment either way.


ETA this similar quotation from the recently declassified ODNI report:
ODNI said:
Almost all IC agencies assess that SARS-CoV-2 was not genetically engineered. Most agencies assess that SARS-CoV-2 was not laboratory-adapted; some are unable to make a determination. All IC agencies assess that SARS-CoV-2 was not developed as a biological weapon.




I don't think a principal investigator sits in an office and never shows up in the lab or in the field. Why would it matter if he ever touched a machine or a culture plate? It doesn't, he was directly involved.
The day-to-day activities of a principal investigator vary a lot by field of research, size of grant, nature of institution, and the PI's own strengths and weaknesses and preferences.

The PI usually writes grant applications, progress reports, and research papers, coordinates and reviews grant applications, reports, and research papers written by others who are funded by the grant, travels to conferences and presents papers, and (usually anonymously) referees journal submissions and reviews grant applications.

With large grants, the PI mainly acts as a research manager. With small grants, the PI may do all or a large fraction of the hands-on research.
 
Last edited:
Planigale's one-sentence summary of what the (updated) ODNI report says is false, but that sentence becomes a correct summary of what the ODNI report says if you replace the word "all" by "most" and insert the word "probably". With my highlighting:





The day-to-day activities of a principal investigator vary a lot by field of research, size of grant, nature of institution, and the PI's own strengths and weaknesses and preferences.

The PI usually writes grant applications, progress reports, and research papers, coordinates and reviews grant applications, reports, and research papers written by others who are funded by the grant, travels to conferences and presents papers, and (usually anonymously) referees journal submissions and reviews grant applications.

With large grants, the PI mainly acts as a research manager. With small grants, the PI may do all or a large fraction of the hands-on research.

Thank you, I stand corrected.

Also thank you for an excellent summary of what a PI does.
 
I was watching a video by Mick West and Steven Greenstreet about the UFO sightings and they talked about how almost every single claim about seeing alien spaceships come from someone who said they heard it from someone who definitely saw X. They wanted to know why it was that the people who saw these crafts themselves were not speaking on oath about these.

It seems to me that the same things could be said about the supposed illnesses with Covid of Ben Hu and other researchers and the death, from Covid, of the wife of one of the researchers.

Why is no one willing to speak on oath about the information they have about Ben Hu getting Covid or of the other researchers or of the death of someone's wife? Instead, people just print anonymously sourced info and people are expected to take it at face value.

Except clearly the intelligence agencies are not that persuaded by it. Why is it that they say that any illness that they have heard of is not diagnostic?

Even if we say that the FBI and department of Energy have some kind of moderate or low confidence of a lab leak, you would have thought that information that the leading researcher was inserting FCS and was patient zero would be Exhibit A in their case, and they wouldn't be moderately or low confidence in their claims.

The alternative, and the one I think is most likely, is that just as David Grusch is repeating nonsense that someone told him about UFOs, so too are the reporters saying Ben Hu was patient zero. Given that Shellenberger literally believes both the UFO stories and was one of the main journalists making claims about Ben Hu, and given that he also released the emails and slack messages, suggests someone (*cough* David Asher *cough) is trying to push a narrative.
 
... It seems to me that the same things could be said about the supposed illnesses with Covid of Ben Hu and other researchers and the death, from Covid, of the wife of one of the researchers.
Everyone else meaning one person, Shellenberger?

Why is no one willing to speak on oath about the information they have about Ben Hu getting Covid or of the other researchers or of the death of someone's wife? Instead, people just print anonymously sourced info and people are expected to take it at face value.
Because it's China, not the US. Speaking out is rarely done.

Except clearly the intelligence agencies are not that persuaded by it. Why is it that they say that any illness that they have heard of is not diagnostic?
Meaning one agency?


Even if we say that the FBI and department of Energy have some kind of moderate or low confidence of a lab leak, you would have thought that information that the leading researcher was inserting FCS and was patient zero would be Exhibit A in their case, and they wouldn't be moderately or low confidence in their claims.
Because the FBI and other intelligence agencies in the US have free access to everything that goes on in China. :rolleyes:


The alternative, and the one I think is most likely, is that just as David Grusch is repeating nonsense that someone told him about UFOs, so too are the reporters saying Ben Hu was patient zero. Given that Shellenberger literally believes both the UFO stories and was one of the main journalists making claims about Ben Hu, and given that he also released the emails and slack messages, suggests someone (*cough* David Asher *cough) is trying to push a narrative.
See paragraph 1.
 
PI (principle investigator) [snip unsupported assertion]
Hu was the principle investigator ON THAT PAPER. You denied he was involved at all. I posted evidence he was very much involved.

'Gain of function' is deliberately increasing the pathogenicity of a human pathogen in the definition that is commonly used. The backbone was WIV-1 (not HIV as you wrote)
Yes HIV backbone as I wrote. Are you ever embarrassed by these confirmation biased mistakes? You would do yourself a favor to read the beginning of the thread. It was discussed there.

Evolutionary Arms Race between Virus and Host Drives Genetic Diversity in Bat Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome-Related Coronavirus Spike Genes
Shi is an author on this paper. She worked directly with Baric on these chimeras though this paper is from Sept 2020 and by that time Shi was no longer working with Baric.
... For SARS-CoV, we used the pseudotyped virus carrying the S protein of strain BJ01 with HIV backbone, which was isolated from a human patient in the middle phase of 2002 to 2003, due to the biosafety regulations in China...


... this is a mouse virus so by definition what is done to it is not 'gain of function'. [snipped more stuff based on your original false premise].
Arguing what is and isn't GoF is moot and a sidetrack, just like fussing over whether Hu was one of 3 patient zeros. SARS CoV2 has gained the function of being significantly more infectious. Changes in the RBS is one key difference. Where that came from can be addressed without the sidetrack of what is and isn't GoF research. [... Which has been addressed so I'm not ceding the argument, it's time to move on.]
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom