Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Looking at the grants posted

Hu listed as Investigator not PI so not fund holder.

1) Understanding the risks of Bat coronavirus emergence, pending ie not awarded money togo to Ecohealth.

2) pathogenicity studies on two novel Bat SARSr-CoV in transgenic mice expressing human ACE22019 - 2021 $44,000. Chinese funded

3) Understanding the risks of Bat coronavirus emergence, awarded money to Ecohealth.

4) bat virology 2019 - 21 funded by china $230,000

5) Predict 2 money to Ecohealth and this is then subcontracted to Hu by UCDavis.

So gross exaggeration implying that Hu got $millions to carry out research. He was not a PI or fundholders, and most of the US money would have gone elsewhere. Certainly nothing to say he was doing research on the Furin cleavage site.

innuendo.
 
... Actual interview with Hu. Note he says he never worked live viruses.
https://www.science.org/content/art...ientist-accused-being-pandemic-s-patient-zero
And yet his name is listed as a researcher on a project to add fcs to coronaviruses.

Those pesky details like citations within links. We know Hu denies ever being sick. Should anyone be surprised he denies working with live viruses?

White Coat Waste Project.

The funding came in three grants totaling $41 million, doled out by USAID and the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, or NIAID, the agency then headed by Dr. Anthony Fauci. Hu is listed as an investigator on the grants.

…The NIAID and USAID grants list Hu as an investigator in the projects being funded. Hu is a top deputy to Shi Zhengli, known in the virology world as “batwoman” for her work extracting samples of viruses from bats in Chinese caves. The FOIA documents were first obtained by White Coat Waste in 2021 but given new relevance with the reporting of Hu’s involvement.


“The significance of the fact that ‘patient zero:’ Ben Hu received US funding from NIH and USAID in 2018-2019 is that NIH and USAID support to Hu potentially directly funded the insertion of FCS sequences into SARS-ike coronaviruses that had been proposed in EcoHealth’s/WIV’s unsuccessful 2018 DARPA grant application,” said Dr. Richard Ebright, a molecular biologist and laboratory director at the Waksman Institute of Microbiology. “


Gosh, I wonder why Hu would deny this?
 
What is wrong with giving the primary source then?
Oh for pity's sake. Why should I go further down any rabbit holes than is necessary to address your unsupported assertions? You don't even bother to check anything before denying whatever.

Round and round the mulberry bush you keep saying Shi hasn't been caught lying. Now you say Fauci hasn't lied, Hu hasn't lied, I forget, did you claim Daszak hasn't lied either?

Well there you go, case proved, the WIV is in the clear.
 
Come on soba, keep up. Go to post #490, follow it back to the latest citation where Fauci admitted in 2020 there was said funding.

Or, just look it up.

Fauci appears to acknowledge gain-of-function research in Wuhan: Document



Oh shoot! I forgot people had to put 2+2 together. :rolleyes:

Ex-CDC director says unredacted Fauci gain-of-function email reveals 'aggressive attempt' to change narrative

It is nice to see that most of what I've posted in this thread is being corroborated. I knew it would be given I was not simply citing news opinion pieces.

Not the claim.

I have said that Fauci needs to clarify what he meant but the question is regarding whether or not the NIH funded gain-of-function. This is what he can be held accountable for and not what the WIV were doing on their own.

It may be, and I will concede if it turns out to be true, that Fauci has merely denied that what they were funding was gain-of-function when privately he believed that it was.
 
Not the claim.

I have said that Fauci needs to clarify what he meant but the question is regarding whether or not the NIH funded gain-of-function. This is what he can be held accountable for and not what the WIV were doing on their own.

It may be, and I will concede if it turns out to be true, that Fauci has merely denied that what they were funding was gain-of-function when privately he believed that it was.
So Redfield's word isn't good enough? Think he's lying?


The GOP released the unredacted email. There's a screen-grab image of it here plus quotes from it.
In an email to U.S. government public health officials in February 2020, Fauci wrote that “scientists in the Wuhan University are known to have been working on gain-of-function experiments … associated with bat viruses adapting to human infection,” according to an image of the document tweeted by the House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus. The email reveals that Fauci knew of the Wuhan Institute of Virology’s research into coronaviruses that mirrored COVID-19 prior to his claim that there was no evidence that the virus was produced in a laboratory.

Fauci also wrote that “there were mutations in the virus that would be most unusual to have evolved naturally in the bats and that there was a suspicion that this mutation was intentionally inserted.” He claimed this was the conclusion of international physicians following a conference call on Feb. 1, 2020 — after which they wrote a now-controversial “proximal origins” paper that claimed the virus emerged naturally.

How is that not admitting he knew about the GoF research at the WIV?

As for funding, yes there was funding including for the fcs study by Dr Hu and the EHA distributing funding to Dr Shi. That's all posted in this thread with citations.


We need a spoon feeding emoji.
 
Last edited:
And yet his name is listed as a researcher on a project to add fcs to coronaviruses.

Those pesky details like citations within links. We know Hu denies ever being sick. Should anyone be surprised he denies working with live viruses?







Gosh, I wonder why Hu would deny this?

Sorry, I just went through this. He received no funding. He was an investigator on funded projects. The only ones from the US government were the known ecohealth projects, where ecohealth held the money. Shi was named as co-PI. Hu is not named on the grant applications. These grants are a bit like saying because you once worked at the Ritz you owned the Rirz.

None of these grants say anything about Furin cleavage sites, that is a different grant, Defuse 2 submitted to DARPA bur refused. Again Hu is not mentioned in this grant.

This article is just nonsense.
 
So Redfield's word isn't good enough? Think he's lying?


The GOP released the unredacted email. There's a screen-grab image of it here plus quotes from it.


How is that not admitting he knew about the GoF research at the WIV?

As for funding, yes there was funding including for the fcs study by Dr Hu and the EHA distributing funding to Dr Shi. That's all posted in this thread with citations.


We need a spoon feeding emoji.

Fauci was wrong. People sometimes say things in emails that subsequently turn out to be incorrect. People sometimes change their opinion as information emerges. His email represented his non-expert opinion based on information he had at the time in a rapidly changing situation. As was said Fauci is a human immunologist not a bat coronavirologist. He was not responsible for WIV. He would have had the same flurry of erroneous information as everyone else had making claims that the virus was engineered, and that WIV did gain of function research to create the virus. These allegations turned out not to be true. That is why the report from ODNI says that none of the intelligence agencies believe the virus was engineered. That is why the experts Fauci asked to review the virus came to the conclusion that the features fitted with a naturally evolved virus.
 
From defuse 2 grant application.

We will sequence their spike proteins, reverse engineer them to conduct binding assays, and inset them int bat SARS CoV (WIV, SHCO14) backbones (these use bat-SARSr-CoV backbones, not SARS-CoV, and are exempt from dual-use and gain of function concerns)
 
Sorry, I just went through this. He received no funding. He was an investigator on funded projects. ...
Is this because you have a language or a cultural barrier? Of course we are talking about funded research.

This article [post] is just nonsense.
ftfy

How bizarre that you claim to know Fauci was wrong.

Fortunately interested persons can look at the unredacted emails and read what Dr Redfield had to say about the whole sordid affair.
 
Wrong grant application.

Defuse 2 is the grant application that mentioned studying / inserting Furin cleavage sites.

The other grants listed did not. If you cannot be bothered to check the primary sources then you won't know when the web sites are making misleading statements.

Hu is a bio-informatics guy - really a computer geek. Not a hnds on virologist. Of course you can jst add him to the long list of experts who disagree with you therefore must be lying.

This is a summary of the research actually done (not proposed) at WIV funded by NIH. Nor a furincleavage site in sight.

https://www.niaid.nih.gov/diseases-conditions/coronavirus-bat-research
 
Wrong grant application.

https://www.documentcloud.org/docum...g-risk-bat-coronavirus-emergence-grant-notice

Wu not listed as a researcher, no Furin cleavage site.

Predict was a project run from UC Davis. They then subcontracted with ecohealth who the subcontracted with WIV to do virus hunting.

https://www.ucdavis.edu/news/uc-dav...-program-predict-and-prevent-pandemic-threats

I cannot find an exct description of what WIV was funded to do, it was virus hunting and revovery. No mention of Hu, he would have been fairly junior at the time. Still no furin cleavage sites.

if you can find an actual document saying that hu was funded to do work on Furin Cleavage sites or planned to do it, please post it.

Defuse was the only grant proposal mentioning Furin cleavage sites, it went to DARPA (not NIAID) and was refused. The planned place of the work was in Baric's lab in NC.
 
I don't need to hunt **** down for you. The grant where Hu is listed as a researcher and the fcs specifically noted was GRANTED! And it was a direct grant to the WIV, not one to the EHA.
The one you are citing was not granted, and the comment was made, if you'd read the damn quotes or do a better job of looking into this **** before spouting your wishful thinking gotchas, that a later grant request noting the same goal was NOT granted. That specifically referred to the application for the DARPA grant.

Of course you can't find anything when you dismiss a source without looking at it. The source I cited backed up the assertions it made with a citation and quotes from the White Coat Waste Project. They are a legit group but like PETA they rub people the wrong way.
 
Last edited:
I don't need to hunt **** down for you. The grant where Hu is listed as a researcher and the fcs specifically noted was GRANTED! And it was a direct grant to the WIV, not one to the EHA.
The one you are citing was not granted, and the comment was made, if you'd read the damn quotes or do a better job of looking into this **** before spouting your wishful thinking gotchas, that a later grant request noting the same goal was NOT granted. That specifically referred to the application for the DARPA grant.

Of course you can't find anything when you dismiss a source without looking at it. The source I cited backed up the assertions it made with a citation and quotes from the White Coat Waste Project. They are a legit group but like PETA they rub people the wrong way.
Sorry I checked their primary sources, which is how you do things, no grant mentions Hu and no grant mentions Furin cleavage sites except Defuse. You can believe what you want, but if you can't be bothered to check primary sources your opinion is not based on the facts. Just other peoples misdirection. Are you happy to be misled, or do you want to know the truth? Why not go to the primary sources? You always quote tertiary+ sources.
 
Sorry I checked their primary sources, which is how you do things, no grant mentions Hu and no grant mentions Furin cleavage sites except Defuse. You can believe what you want, but if you can't be bothered to check primary sources your opinion is not based on the facts. Just other peoples misdirection. Are you happy to be misled, or do you want to know the truth? Why not go to the primary sources? You always quote tertiary+ sources.

There was a document that was obtained (through FOIA request by a group called whitecoat waste that had Ben Hu listed as a researcher IIRC.

I think it is probably a real document.

That said I want to know were the idea that Ben Hu got sick from Covid. It just seems to have been anonymous sources whispering to Shellenberger. It may be true but it might be someone trying to get China to reveal more.

Meanwhile it seems the NIH has requested data and notebooks etc…. from the WIV and as none has been forthcoming they have said they will provide no further funding.

I think they clearly want more transparency.

https://abcnews.go.com/Health/us-halts-funding-access-wuhan-lab-heart-covid/story?id=101499843
 
There was a document that was obtained (through FOIA request by a group called whitecoat waste that had Ben Hu listed as a researcher IIRC.

I think it is probably a real document.

That said I want to know were the idea that Ben Hu got sick from Covid. It just seems to have been anonymous sources whispering to Shellenberger. It may be true but it might be someone trying to get China to reveal more.

Meanwhile it seems the NIH has requested data and notebooks etc…. from the WIV and as none has been forthcoming they have said they will provide no further funding.

I think they clearly want more transparency.

https://abcnews.go.com/Health/us-halts-funding-access-wuhan-lab-heart-covid/story?id=101499843

Yes, I looked at their documents. This was NIH type grant applications. They ask what previous NIH grants have you been involved with. So if you were a MSc or PhD or post grad funded by an NIH grant you put it down. That doesn't mean you were a grant holder or a PI, it just means you were a grunt. The laboratory director got a grant, you were told to do science you did science. Now you apply for a grant yourself, you have to put down what previous funding you were involved with. If a grant paid for you to make Hamster burgers you put it down. Someone else was the grant holder, the laboratory director, and funded your PhD in Hamster burgers. Now you move on you apply for your first grant in the science of Guinea Pig burgers your CV has to include your previous research and funders.

This is a typical example of people obtain documents misinterpreting them and making news. Idon't know if anyone else is familiar with applying for research grants but this is definitely low level stuff they were quoting.

Nowhere in any of the primary documents does it mention Hu or him working with Furin cleavages sites.

ETA by primary documents I mean the actual grant applications Hu quoted.
 
Last edited:
There was a document that was obtained (through FOIA request by a group called whitecoat waste that had Ben Hu listed as a researcher IIRC.

I think it is probably a real document.

That said I want to know were the idea that Ben Hu got sick from Covid. It just seems to have been anonymous sources whispering to Shellenberger. It may be true but it might be someone trying to get China to reveal more.
Bold is mine noting your hyperbole. I'm not sure why you diss Shellenberger's credibility while you post "it is probably a real document" re his report on the work of Dr Hu.

All this dissing of anonymous sources like they are also anonymous to the reporter is unfounded. One usually relies on the reporter to vet the source and the information.

History of the evidence:
First it was reported in a cable from the US Embassy that 3 people from the WIV got sick and were hospitalized in Nov 2019

Then it was noted in some article that under the Chinese system going to the hospital was like going to a clinic, it didn't mean the 3 were hospitalized

Then the FBI found the report of the 3 ill workers credible

Then the names were released (sorry you don't like anonymous sources) Dr Hu was one of the 3

Another source noted one of their symptoms was they lost their sense of smell

Dr Hu as well as the other 2 named all deny they were ill in Nov 2019

Shi has stated all the people at the WIV tested negative for coronavirus antibodies, but she denied access to the raw data when the WHO inspection took place

Daszak claims the WHO team never asked for said raw data (keep in mind their time at the WIV was only a couple of hours, short relative to the task they were there to complete)

Dr Shi still has not released the raw data re the antibody testing

Then the FOIA request resulted in a data dump of thousands of emails (you can find the data dump online)

Fortunately the White Coat Waste Project pulled some relevant emails where Fauci said there probably was GoF research going on at the WIV

The Waste Project also noted the grant from the US directly to the WIV and they posted a screenshot of Dr Hu's name listed as a researcher on the project

The plan was to insert an fcs into the coronavirus to determine if there was a threat of a natural spillover, the goal was to develop a vaccine before a spillover

There's a video of Dr Hu working in the lab without gloves (I have not yet seen that video)

The US Intelligence Agency released a report recently that found the evidence of the 3 ill workers was sketchy at best​
Now, you can take Hu's word for it he was not ill in Nov 2019. There's Dr Shi's word none of the staff were ill, and the recent intelligence report that failed to confirm there were 3 ill staff members in Nov 2019 and you can continue defending your hill.

I choose to keep looking for more evidence and at the moment it looks like the 3 persons from the WIV may have indeed been patient zeros.



Meanwhile it seems the NIH has requested data and notebooks etc…. from the WIV and as none has been forthcoming they have said they will provide no further funding.

I think they clearly want more transparency.

https://abcnews.go.com/Health/us-halts-funding-access-wuhan-lab-heart-covid/story?id=101499843
Daszak didn't provide follow up reports he was supposed to file following one of the grants that went through the EHA. He says he did. Earlier in the thread I posted a cite for that grant including the fact he had not delivered the required progress reports. That was the grant where the WIV/Shi got the $600K from the EHA. It was a later grant proposal that was denied.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom