This IS the second time a virus erupts near a lab he works with hundreds of miles from the supposed source.
1st time...Ebola--Sierra Leone. (Or actually across the border in Guinea but disputed as the first cases reported were not actually the first cases.
He is in Australia now so perhaps dont go there. haha
This IS the second time a virus erupts near a lab he works with hundreds of miles from the supposed source.
1st time...Ebola--Sierra Leone. (Or actually across the border in Guinea but disputed as the first cases reported were not actually the first cases.
He is in Australia now so perhaps dont go there. haha
I was kidding before but this is NSW when the virus was normally in QL where 4 humans previously died??? Oh man.. Dont give me ideas.
(but I cant help but look at patterns). If this actually crosses to humans...seriously. I mean really. Lets take a look...just for fun ok?
I was kidding before but this is NSW when the virus was normally in QL where 4 humans previously died??? Oh man.. Dont give me ideas.
(but I cant help but look at patterns). If this actually crosses to humans...seriously. I mean really. Lets take a look...just for fun ok?
Right, and don’t forget who first “discovered” Hendra in the wild? Hume Field. And who does he work for now? EcoHealth Alliance. And Hendra is the first part of Henipavirus related to Nipah virus, which was found in Malaysia and whose spillover was discovered by Jonathan Epstein of…. EcoHealth Alliance! Coincidence? Well, what did Science magazine say Zhengli-Shi found in the Mojiang mine? A new henipavirus!!!!
And of course Worobey “discovered” the origins of HIV…. Or did he?
And Garry and Holmes get blamed for that Ebola outbreak.
I think we are indeed seeing a pattern, but the pattern could be that we always attribute spillovers to scientists’ behaviour, rather than nature. And the worse the effects the bigger the attribution.
So I think my priors are that this is pretty much par for the course. I admit that I could be wrong.
Well... it looks like the Proximal Origins authors' emails and Slack discussions have all been released by Shellenberger et. al.
What is notable is how much **** they talk about each other behind their colleagues's backs with Holmes referring to Ego Health.
Someone is called Butt Lesion, but I am not sure who.
The ones I have seen so far are the early ones where they are extremely concerned about the FCS and "the restriction site" - hmmm... maybe that Washburne pre-print wasn't so far off then....
A Columbia University scientist claims her boss — and former lover — repeatedly dropped his drawers and demanded she diagnose a lesion on his butt.
Associate Professor Mady Hornig says her boss at the university’s Mailman School of Public Health also demanded co-credit for her work; kicked her under the table at meetings to keep her from speaking; presented her work as his own, and kept her from getting tenure, Hornig claims in a Manhattan federal court lawsuit.
In 2014, Professor Walter Ian Lipkin, head of the Center for Infection & Immunity, called Hornig into his office and “demanded that she look at lesions on his buttocks,” Hornig alleges. He did so again a year later, Hornig charges.
Hornig is suing the school, claiming Lipkin has ruined her reputation.
No this is not what Gao said. I previously quoted his exact words.
from a scientific perspective, we do not rule out any possibilities, but any possibility requires evidence. There is currently no evidence to support the theory of a laboratory leak. Science relies on empirical evidence and questioning, so it is possible to discuss any possibilities within the scientific context.
Tackling your denial one piece at a time: Live bats at the WIV.
Have you really forgotten all the evidence that was posted? You could look it up before making this embarrassing false assertion.
Unrelated to the lab origin hypothesis? A lawyers' trick? Really? Seriously?
BTW, you have a lot of nerve talking about the tactic of discrediting a witness. That's what you've done time and time again here avoiding addressing at the evidence. Maybe that's why you are oblivious to the evidence there were live bats kept at the WIV.
How is it not relevant that both Daszak and Shi denied having any live bats, claiming they only had the genome data.
Daszak claimed in a Tweet they had no live bats in the WIV lab then realized that would be easily discredited so he deleted the Tweet.
More from the above link:
Click on the link for 5 embedded citations in this paragraph.
What is the relevance of having or not having bats at WIV?
Is the suggestion that they had a live bat at WIV that carried SARS-CoV-2 precursor virus that then spread to a laboratory worker which then started the pandemic? If so then this is in essence a natural cross over event all be it happening in a laboratory. It would then mean that the virus was natural and not synthesised by some unspecified 'gain of function' genetic manipulation. It would also mean that they would probably have a good idea where to look for a precursor virus in the wild, which would exonerate them.
Is it just to 'prove' that Shi is a liar? Because Shi says she did not keep bats and an anonymous internet poster says she did and you prefer to believe an anonymous internet poster. You do appreciate that keeping bats is very different from keeping viruses, and that virologists would not know how to look after bats. Keeping bats is more challenging than keeping well adapted laboratory strains of mice or rats.
Lots of people have been through WIV and none say they saw bats. There is a video that someone claims to show bat cages at WIV, but this is taken from a old publicity video and was not claimed to represent WIV. The alleged patents are in Chinese so I cannot tell what they say. What I can tell you is when you patent something you cover a large number of functions many of which you may never have actually done. So even if it is a claim for a patent to improve keeping bats, by someone who has exclusively worked at WIV, that does not meant he ever actually kept bats at WIV.
I think it is worth remembering that there was a bat biologist and specialist in BSL4 laboratories and biosecurity working at WIV in November 2019. Andersen can recall no bats, no one becoming unwell and no laboratory leaks. Given that she has experience of keeping bats it is likely she would know.
Apart from these two explanations I cannot see why the presence of bats was significant.
SG why do you think the alleged presence of bats at WIV relevant to explaining the origin of SARS-CoV-2? You keep mentioning it, but the why you think it is significant is unclear.
Right, and don’t forget who first “discovered” Hendra in the wild? Hume Field. And who does he work for now? EcoHealth Alliance. And Hendra is the first part of Henipavirus related to Nipah virus, which was found in Malaysia and whose spillover was discovered by Jonathan Epstein of…. EcoHealth Alliance! Coincidence? Well, what did Science magazine say Zhengli-Shi found in the Mojiang mine? A new henipavirus!!!!
And of course Worobey “discovered” the origins of HIV…. Or did he?
And Garry and Holmes get blamed for that Ebola outbreak.
I think we are indeed seeing a pattern, but the pattern could be that we always attribute spillovers to scientists’ behaviour, rather than nature. And the worse the effects the bigger the attribution.
So I think my priors are that this is pretty much par for the course. I admit that I could be wrong.
It depends on the stats. I have no idea how many virologists were out there collecting samples or working in various labs near these outbreaks. Especially ones studying bats. The same names come up again and again.
How many people and programs in every country are out there doing this work? If I took other virologists that are less known would the same thing happen occasionally where their labs have deadly outbreaks next to them that were not there beforehand and on things they were studying?
I just dont know how odd it is that these scientists end up next to an outbreak that was not there before they set up shop- and was not expected to be there. Any idea?
The Sierra Leone lab was supposed to be studying Lassa Fever but later admitted they did "a few" experiments with Ebola since it is also a hemorrhagic disease- centered in area around the DRC (Congo)- very far.
I just find it curious. And it doesnt take any conspiracy to do it.
Ho do you get from "Fauci prompted him write a paper on the subject" which is what you quoted to "Fauci promoted him to lie about the subject". Why would Fauci want him to lie about anything and why would Anderson do so?
You realize there is a whole right wing industry dedicated to quote mining scientists e-mails for thins that "prove" science is bad and scientists are evil? They then feed these twisted, out of context quotes to gullible people like yourself in order to promote their anti-science agenda.
Ho do you get from "Fauci prompted him write a paper on the subject" which is what you quoted to "Fauci promoted him to lie about the subject". Why would Fauci want him to lie about anything and why would Anderson do so?
You realize there is a whole right wing industry dedicated to quote mining scientists e-mails for thins that "prove" science is bad and scientists are evil? They then feed these twisted, out of context quotes to gullible people like yourself in order to promote their anti-science agenda.
Who cares about slicing and dicing the emails or what any right winger says.
Or trying to look at any miniscule thing in SG's post for some error.
Do you think it was scientifically responsible rule out any lab leak (or even say highly unlikely), with the lab right near the epicenter, just weeks into the pandemic? And why did they want that paper out so fast? What was the rush to judgement? Why did the public need to be reassured it was 'natural' when no one knew?
For something this big and impactful, there should have been a long time of careful analysis.
Fauci is a liar about lots of things. From the start of COVID I said so when he claimed masks didn't prevent the spread of COVID. Then later he claimed he never said that and knew about the airborne studies all along. You don't want to get me started on that because I was responsible for protecting health care workers at the time when there was a shortage of PPE.
Stop getting you info from anti-science sources. What Fauci said was that N95 masks wouldn't protect you without additional protection and training so they should be left for the medical professionals who needed them and could benefit from them. He later recommended standard surgical masks as being potentially effective in preventing infected people from passing along the virus in casual contact.
How many people and programs in every country are out there doing this work? If I took other virologists that are less known would the same thing happen occasionally where their labs have deadly outbreaks next to them that were not there beforehand and on things they were studying?
As I said above there are labs studying viruses in every major city on the planet. There is ALWAYS going to be a lab near where an outbreak occurs, and that lab is almost always going to be studying things that are high risk for that area, so labs everywhere in China study Coronaviruses, labs in parts of Africa at high risk for Ebola study Ebola, and so on. There will always be a lab nearby that the anti-science crowd can blame for any outbreak, and they do.
It's like clockwork, every single epidemic or pandemic gets blamed on lab leak. It's never actually the lab it's always zoonotic crossover that has been going on for billions of years, but there will always be some out there to blame it on the scientists because "science bad, scientists evil"
Do you think it was scientifically responsible rule out any lab leak (or even say highly unlikely), with the lab right near the epicenter, just weeks into the pandemic?
Again, what lab? There are going to be dozens of BSL-2 and BSL-3 labs in a major city like Wuhan, why do you think it was coincidence some of these were nearby?
The possibility WAS considered but there was simply no evidence for it. When you have no evidence for a lab leak, good evidence for something that has strong precedent for causing epidemics of novel virus.
And why did they want that paper out so fast? What was the rush to judgement? Why did the public need to be reassured it was 'natural' when no one knew?
When misinformation is being spread why would anyone sit on data that debunks it? Public misinformation aside, scientific communication needs to start immediately, some of that will stand other parts will fall by the wayside. The zoonotic crossover theory stands because the data supports it, lab leak was considers and dismissed because there is no data to support it.
Who cares about slicing and dicing the emails or what any right winger says.
Or trying to look at any miniscule thing in SG's post for some error.
Do you think it was scientifically responsible rule out any lab leak (or even say highly unlikely), with the lab right near the epicenter, just weeks into the pandemic? And why did they want that paper out so fast? What was the rush to judgement? Why did the public need to be reassured it was 'natural' when no one knew?
For something this big and impactful, there should have been a long time of careful analysis.
The rush was that there was a novel virus causing a pandemic that no one knew anything about and there was a lot of uninformed speculation about.
If you remember this had started because some of the authors had expressed concern that there features that suggested this was an artificially created virus that had either escaped from of been deliberately released from a laboratory. Fauci said that this was an important issue and that they should get a group of experts on viral / genetic evolution to review the genome and put together a paper summarising the evidence. All that seems something that should be done with some urgency.
When the group looked more carefully at the genome, e.g. out of frame furin cleavage sequence, comparison with other coronaviruses and new information being published, they felt that the genome showed no evidence of laboratory manipulation and fitted with a natural virus. Since that was the conclusion they came to when they wrote up the paper for publication that is what they said. There is no evidence they were pressurised by anyone to come to cetain conclusions, indeed the opposite as they were originally asked to write the paper to summarise the evidence for an artificial origin.
Some people are capable of changing their minds when review of evidence does not support their initial assumptions.
Sadly the evidence is that for most people once they have come to a conclusion it is very difficult for them to change their opinion. There are good studies showing people have much more confidence in poor quality evidence that supports their opinion and dismiss, nitpick and over critique good quality evidence that contradicts their opinion. Humans are not rational.
The rush was that there was a novel virus causing a pandemic that no one knew anything about and there was a lot of uninformed speculation about.
If you remember this had started because some of the authors had expressed concern that there features that suggested this was an artificially created virus that had either escaped from of been deliberately released from a laboratory. Fauci said that this was an important issue and that they should get a group of experts on viral / genetic evolution to review the genome and put together a paper summarising the evidence. All that seems something that should be done with some urgency.
When the group looked more carefully at the genome, e.g. out of frame furin cleavage sequence, comparison with other coronaviruses and new information being published, they felt that the genome showed no evidence of laboratory manipulation and fitted with a natural virus. Since that was the conclusion they came to when they wrote up the paper for publication that is what they said. There is no evidence they were pressurised by anyone to come to cetain conclusions, indeed the opposite as they were originally asked to write the paper to summarise the evidence for an artificial origin.
Some people are capable of changing their minds when review of evidence does not support their initial assumptions.
Sadly the evidence is that for most people once they have come to a conclusion it is very difficult for them to change their opinion. There are good studies showing people have much more confidence in poor quality evidence that supports their opinion and dismiss, nitpick and over critique good quality evidence that contradicts their opinion. Humans are not rational.
I agree....except for the part where the NEEDED tp say something about origin. Science doesnt need to move on public scariness timelines. It moves with good facts.
I, myself, believed what they said. Of course, why wouldnt I? What do I know?
Later, I just did some research, as a curious person does, noticed the weird coincidence on my own and wondered why the media had NEVER mentioned it (or at least I had not heard it). It was so obvious, so close to the outbreak, and such a bizarre thing to obfuscate that it got me looking further into it. I dont like being treated as a sheeple that needs corralling into the public pen and told what to think. They pushed it very hard without good evidence. How could they have good evidence? How could they know even if it looked natural? There was no reason other than they didnt want people blaming the lab.. Anyone that did was 'crazy.
Since then, the tides have turned. I am no longer a crazy person, thank goodness!
And here I am. Still unconvinced by what started as propaganda at the beginning.
I also agree, that for most in this thread, no evidence of any relation to the lab will suffice. Mind are not changing And that is ok. You can go along for eternity. Pandemic is over and this thread will likely be lost to history.
You realize this is what's happening every time you use google, Facebook or YouTube right? They feed you links to whatever is similar to what you've looked at before.
The way you control for this is to follow the links back to the published peer reviewed research and read that. If there is followup, responses or citations in the peer reviewed literature read that as well.
You don't think professional virologists who study the genetics of viruses regularly can't tell the difference between human edits and natural evolution?
No evidence of any relation to a lab has been presented. All that's been presented is a pile of innuendo accusing various scientists of lying, without much in the way of support.
You realize this is what's happening every time you use google, Facebook or YouTube right? They feed you links to whatever is similar to what you've looked at before.
I started with a map. I looked at knowledge when they said it may have come from bats.... then looked at the map. That's what started it. Absolutely ZERO prompts. I just wondered why the obvious proximity had not been known to me til I saw it myself. (I was not on social media/twitter/facebook etc.... so forgive if I was late to the debate. (I had believed for a few years by then that most of those sites to contribute to 'brain trash' and so deleted them and never used them again)
The way you control for this is to follow the links back to the published peer reviewed research and read that. If there is followup, responses or citations in the peer reviewed literature read that as well.
And? This did not support that it was natural...quite the opposite. The research stated there were animals there and humanized mice, and viral engineering. Talks, papers, conferences, etc.... It wasnt secret.
You don't think professional virologists who study the genetics of viruses regularly can't tell the difference between human edits and natural evolution?
Baric thinks it could be done because he did it. In fact, he invented it just for coronaviruses...years before the outbreak. And he taught it to Shi. Did you know that? What do you think of it?
Do you think there is some special batch of just a few virologists we should listen to, even those who had no previous experience with coronaviruses?
No evidence of any relation to a lab has been presented. All that's been presented is a pile of innuendo accusing various scientists of lying, without much in the way of support.
And no natural spillover evidence has been presented- even though it was literally on the doorstep of the premiere lab in the entire world to detect it.
None. No animal, no solid evidence of even the possible animal. Where is the animal?
That is my take on it. You can believe whatever you like and everyone is free to their own view of it. It won't change what the actual truth of it is. Perhaps one day we will get some solid truths out of it.
I started with a map. I looked at knowledge when they said it may have come from bats.... then looked at the map. That's what started it. Absolutely ZERO prompts. I just wondered why the obvious proximity had not been known to me til I saw it myself. (I was not on social media/twitter/facebook etc.... so forgive if I was late to the debate. (I had believed for a few years by then that most of those sites to contribute to 'brain trash' and so deleted them and never used them again)
And? This did not support that it was natural...quite the opposite. The research stated there were animals there and humanized mice, and viral engineering. Talks, papers, conferences, etc.... It wasnt secret.
Baric thinks it could be done because he did it. In fact, he invented it just for coronaviruses...years before the outbreak. And he taught it to Shi. Did you know that? What do you think of it?
Do you think there is some special batch of just a few virologists we should listen to, even those who had no previous experience with coronaviruses?
And no natural spillover evidence has been presented- even though it was literally on the doorstep of the premiere lab in the entire world to detect it.
None. No animal, no solid evidence of even the possible animal. Where is the animal?
That is my take on it. You can believe whatever you like and everyone is free to their own view of it. It won't change what the actual truth of it is. Perhaps one day we will get some solid truths out of it.
This is an example of how pejorative terms are used to imply guilt. What is meant by humanised mice? These are standard laboratory mice who have had a single gene altered. They are entirely normal mice except that instead of expressing mouse ACE2 on cells they express human ACE2. ACE2 is the receptor that the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein binds to. This then causes the virus to enter the cell, hijack the cell biochemistry, and reproduce itself. So what was the 'gain of function'? A mouse SARS virus, (a virus that causes illness in mice but not humans), has its spike protein altered for a spike protein on a newly discovered bat coronavirus. So the mouse virus can only cause disease in the mice if the new spike protein can bind to human ACE2 and allow the virus to enter the mouse cells. This is not gain of function, it is unknown whether the spike protein can bind to human ACE2 before the experiment, but what is known is the mouse virus does not cause disease in humans.
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.