Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

If you go back to the initial conference call and the emails instead of relying on their testimony 3 years later when they've worked on rationalizing you get more reliable evidence

How Fauci and NIH leaders worked to discredit the COVID-19 lab leak theory
You can read the rest yourself.


The problem you have here angrysoba is the evidence is stacked against you.

You said Fauci ADMITTED to prompting scientists to disprove the lab leak theory.

What you then link to is a cobbled together narrative by the Washingron Examiner where they ACCUSE him of that.

This is what is frustrating. You consistently frame these issues as though Fauci, Andersen, Worobey etc are these devious liars and to prove your case you link to weird MAGA outlets and GOP politicians stating it.

You seem to do this every time, and then when you recycle the stories, you say you have already proved your claims.

Honestly, if I saw quotes from you, from MTG and Trump side by side, I doubt I would be able to tell the difference.
 
Did I say any meaningless version of limitations? I did not. Why would that be what I meant?


I don't need to, you can look it up. But since I just came across it:
https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abm4454
2/3, that can be a big issue when you are talking about small numbers.

Is that what you are talking about? When you say ignoring the cases that had no link to the market?

You obfviously have not even read the paper.

You clearly do not understand anything about it.

In summary:

The cases where there was no link to the market were closer to the market than cases that DID have something to do with the market. This is part of their evidence for why the market clearly was influencing those cases too.

This is another example of you framing the issue dishonestly. Worobey and others have repeatedly explained that the cases not connected to the market were still consistent with a market origin given their proximity. This suggests onward human-to-human transmission.

Anyway, now you are asserting that if the Chinese CDC say it did not come from the wet market, that you will simply agree, and that Worobey "ignores" it.

:rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:
 
Is that what you are talking about? When you say ignoring the cases that had no link to the market?

You obfviously have not even read the paper.

You clearly do not understand anything about it.

In summary:

The cases where there was no link to the market were closer to the market than cases that DID have something to do with the market. This is part of their evidence for why the market clearly was influencing those cases too.

This is another example of you framing the issue dishonestly. Worobey and others have repeatedly explained that the cases not connected to the market were still consistent with a market origin given their proximity. This suggests onward human-to-human transmission.

Anyway, now you are asserting that if the Chinese CDC say it did not come from the wet market, that you will simply agree, and that Worobey "ignores" it.

:rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:

When Worobey went to China in 2014, as 'gain of functiion' in the US was halted from funding, the CCDC took him to that exact market and and showed him some cages and pointed out the risk there. No need to cite them, or call in anyone to stop it as illegal. Just show him. He took photos.

BTW, the CCDC office is walking distance to the Huanan market. Just across a bridge from what I recall. The lab was a few miles to the east.

What a coincidence, right? (of the thousands of such markets in China)

Shall we continue to roll eyes?
 
Last edited:
Give it up angrysoba. Insulting me and refusing to look at the actual evidence is not helping your case.

Worobey is full of himself, that doesn't make him a liar.

Fauci is a liar about lots of things. From the start of COVID I said so when he claimed masks didn't prevent the spread of COVID. Then later he claimed he never said that and knew about the airborne studies all along. You don't want to get me started on that because I was responsible for protecting health care workers at the time when there was a shortage of PPE. Fauci is no hero. And BTW, that goes back to him mishandling the HIV pandemic, another issue. People don't remember how many lives were lost due to his actions. Look it up. Anyone who thinks Fauci is some hero is a fool.

And here he is doing it again claiming all along he had an open mind about the lab origin.

No, the evidence is clear that man is a self-serving *******. You can re-read the link or continue on your merry way believing it said something it didn't.

Andersen seems to have bought into his own conclusions before the evidence was in and heck, why change now. I don't think he's necessarily lying so much as he's like a lot of these guys including you, confirmation bias is really interfering with your assessment of the evidence.

At some point you are going to have to stop saying both hypotheses are valid when you know you don't mean it. And then you are going to have to come to terms with the fact gone are the days when a country like China and people like Fauci can keep the facts away from the public.

Genetic research is too sophisticated and despite China not releasing the earliest data they are sitting on, the origin will come out. COVID is not going to be traced back to any animal spillover. There's already evidence piling up against that hypothesis.
No source animal, no related animal species the virus was circulating in
No closely related virus circulating in bats
No outbreaks from the beginning except in Wuhan and except within a dozen miles of where they just happened to be studying SARS-like CoVs in unsafe BSL2 conditions
Multiple paper trails and Daszak's interview before the pandemic that GoF research was going on with CoVs at the WIV
Evidence research was going on using humanized mice and human airway cells for cultures
China refusing to release key data or to let the WHO do a proper investigation
​

The picture is getting clearer and clearer.
 
When Worobey went to China in 2014, as 'gain of functiion' in the US was halted from funding, the CCDC took him to that exact market and and showed him some cages and pointed out the risk there. No need to cite them, or call in anyone to stop it as illegal. Just show him. He took photos.
BTW, the CCDC office is walking distance to the Huanan market. Just across a bridge from what I recall. The lab was a few miles to the east.

What a coincidence, right? (of the thousands of such markets in China)

Shall we continue to roll eyes?

Could you provide a citation for the highlighted?

Are you confusing him for Daszak? Or Holmes? Or both?

And again, you are just doing what I said people keep doing.

Skeptic has said it leaked from the WIV because that is where Shi was apparently doing GoF on coronaviruses and not the WCDC.

Now, suddenly you move the leak back to the WCDC because of its proximity to the market.

Do you not see how this lab leak theory slips and slides according to what is convenient?

Oh, and Skeptic Ginger conveniently believes everything she hears from George Gao of the WCDC such as when he says the market was not the locus of the outbreak because none of the animals tested positive for the virus.

:rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:
 
Give it up angrysoba. Insulting me and refusing to look at the actual evidence is not helping your case.

Worobey is full of himself, that doesn't make him a liar.

Fauci is a liar about lots of things. From the start of COVID I said so when he claimed masks didn't prevent the spread of COVID. Then later he claimed he never said that and knew about the airborne studies all along. You don't want to get me started on that because I was responsible for protecting health care workers at the time when there was a shortage of PPE. Fauci is no hero. And BTW, that goes back to him mishandling the HIV pandemic, another issue. People don't remember how many lives were lost due to his actions. Look it up. Anyone who thinks Fauci is some hero is a fool.

And here he is doing it again claiming all along he had an open mind about the lab origin.

No, the evidence is clear that man is a self-serving *******. You can re-read the link or continue on your merry way believing it said something it didn't.

Andersen seems to have bought into his own conclusions before the evidence was in and heck, why change now. I don't think he's necessarily lying so much as he's like a lot of these guys including you, confirmation bias is really interfering with your assessment of the evidence.

At some point you are going to have to stop saying both hypotheses are valid when you know you don't mean it. And then you are going to have to come to terms with the fact gone are the days when a country like China and people like Fauci can keep the facts away from the public.

Genetic research is too sophisticated and despite China not releasing the earliest data they are sitting on, the origin will come out. COVID is not going to be traced back to any animal spillover. There's already evidence piling up against that hypothesis.
No source animal, no related animal species the virus was circulating in
No closely related virus circulating in bats
No outbreaks from the beginning except in Wuhan and except within a dozen miles of where they just happened to be studying SARS-like CoVs in unsafe BSL2 conditions
Multiple paper trails and Daszak's interview before the pandemic that GoF research was going on with CoVs at the WIV
Evidence research was going on using humanized mice and human airway cells for cultures
China refusing to release key data or to let the WHO do a proper investigation
​

The picture is getting clearer and clearer.

Sorry, didn't mean to say your posts sound like something MTG or Trump would say.

I should have said more like something RFK Jr would say.

LOL!
 
When Worobey went to China in 2014, as 'gain of functiion' in the US was halted from funding, the CCDC took him to that exact market and and showed him some cages and pointed out the risk there. No need to cite them, or call in anyone to stop it as illegal. Just show him. He took photos.
I didn't know that though I have seen photos of live raccoon dogs in cages there. I'll have to add it to my criticism of Worobey list.

BTW, the CCDC office is walking distance to the Huanan market. Just across a bridge from what I recall. The lab was a few miles to the east.

What a coincidence, right? (of the thousands of such markets in China)

Shall we continue to roll eyes?
I'm particularly interested in George Gao, the retired head of CCDC, coming out and saying he thinks a lab origin should remain an active hypothesis.
 
Last edited:
Could you provide a citation for the highlighted?

Are you confusing him for Daszak? Or Holmes? Or both?

And again, you are just doing what I said people keep doing.

Skeptic has said it leaked from the WIV because that is where Shi was apparently doing GoF on coronaviruses and not the WCDC.

Now, suddenly you move the leak back to the WCDC because of its proximity to the market.

Do you not see how this lab leak theory slips and slides according to what is convenient?

Oh, and Skeptic Ginger conveniently believes everything she hears from George Gao of the WCDC such as when he says the market was not the locus of the outbreak because none of the animals tested positive for the virus.

:rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:

They are all in the same area and all in Wuhan. But ok. You havent seen where he mentioned his visit and photos of the raccoon dogs there? Just google it.
If you are incapable I will find it for you.
 
Could you provide a citation for the highlighted?

Are you confusing him for Daszak? Or Holmes? Or both?

And again, you are just doing what I said people keep doing.

Skeptic has said it leaked from the WIV because that is where Shi was apparently doing GoF on coronaviruses and not the WCDC.

Now, suddenly you move the leak back to the WCDC because of its proximity to the market.

Do you not see how this lab leak theory slips and slides according to what is convenient?
Just pointing out the CCDC (China CDC, not Wuhan CDC) also had labs in the area doesn't mean one is saying which lab the spill came from. The CCDC just so happened to have moved their Wuhan lab to another building only a short distance from the first one. There were opportunities for a lab leak during the move. And the CCDC and the WIV were working together on CoVs. So that nitpick doesn't fly.

There is no slipping and sliding except in your confirmation biased thinking. Seriously, a couple of miles vs a dozen miles, do you have no concept how big China is?

as said:
Oh, and Skeptic Ginger conveniently believes everything she hears from George Gao of the WCDC such as when he says the market was not the locus of the outbreak because none of the animals tested positive for the virus.
Now you are just getting silly and you are back to misstating what people post ... which is why you don't post quotes.
 
Just pointing out the CCDC (China CDC, not Wuhan CDC)s.

It’s the same goddamm place! Stop hypercorrecting (getting it wrong when you correct)

The CCDC administers a number of laboratories across China, including the biosafety level 2 facility at the Wuhan Center for Disease Control (sometimes confused with the nearby Wuhan Institute of Virology),[6] which received global media coverage during the COVID-19 pandemic for its research into SARS-like coronaviruses of bat origin.[7][8][9] On January 10, 2020, the CCDC uploaded the genetic sequence of SARS-CoV-2 to GISAID for global dissemination.[10] In 2022, the Center shared with GISAID a phylogenetic analysis of over 32 independent introductions SARS-CoV-2 from outside China that were identified in the first quarter of the year.[11]
 
You didn’t know it because it isn’t true. But don’t let that stop you from repeating it ad nauseum in future.

It is true. It is in an article, youtube videos and on his own friggen twitter. Just take 20 seconds to go look.
If I do it youll just say you want another confirmation,,,, so you do it

If you dont take a few seconds to look it means you just dont want to see it
 
Last edited:
They are all in the same area and all in Wuhan. But ok. You havent seen where he mentioned his visit and photos of the raccoon dogs there? Just google it.
If you are incapable I will find it for you.

It was Holmes who took pictures of the raccoon dog. He’s the one who has been working with the WIV as well. Not Worobey.
 
It was Holmes who took pictures of the raccoon dog. He’s the one who has been working with the WIV as well. Not Worobey.

ok yes...Holmes then. Whats the difference. Same scenario. Researcher goes, taken to market, takes photos.
They seem to be this trio. Any one of them will do.

My bad.

Love and hugs.
 
They are all in the same area and all in Wuhan. But ok. You havent seen where he mentioned his visit and photos of the raccoon dogs there? Just google it.
If you are incapable I will find it for you.

I found the connection:
MIT Tech Review: This scientist now believes covid started in Wuhan’s wet market. Here’s why.
In October 2014, officials at the Wuhan Centre of Disease Control and Prevention took Edward Holmes, a virologist at the University of Sydney, to visit the market, where people could buy live animals and have them slaughtered on site. Several restaurants nearby were famous for serving yewei (“wild taste”) from animals that weren’t just freshly killed, but wild. Holmes and his Chinese host strolled through rows upon rows of stalls that sold live animals—snakes, bamboo rats, raccoon dogs—kept in cages stacked on top of one another. It wasn’t a particularly busy day, but the place stank of urine, blood, and feces, Holmes says.
Then:
Science Insider
Worobey also attended the SAGO meeting with Andersen and virologist Edward Holmes of the University of Sydney, who captured a picture of a raccoon dog for sale in the Huanan market in 2014.
 
Last edited:
But anyway, the difference is that Worobey also gave the lab leak some credence (as he did for the OPV claim for HIV btw….)

He signed the latter to Science with Bloom and Chan and Lisitch and Baric.

Looking into it changed his mind.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom