Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

as said:
Andersen then did the same for Alex Washburne who has been recently trying to make a name for himself with ever crazier nonsense about lab leak.

Link
Here's Andersen name-calling:
... bad faith these grifters and conspiracy theorists are acting in - they're gaslighting all of us, yet their ******** keeps doing the rounds.
But to be fair so was Washburne. Except it started off with Washburne Tweeting:
https://twitter.com/WashburneAlex
Pre-print:

Endonuclease fingerprint indicates a synthetic origin of SARS-CoV-2

A collaborative product by
@VBruttel
,
@tony_vandongen
, and myself.

Here's what we found:

https://biorxiv.org/cgi/content/short/2022.10.18.512756v1

1/
So why didn't Andersen just address the evidence in the preprint instead of claiming Washburne was a gaslighting grifter? And how did you come to the conclusion Washburne's paper was no more than "with ever crazier nonsense about lab leak?" Did you look at it?
Abstract
... The genome of SARS-COV-2 contains a peculiar pattern of unique restriction endonuclease recognition sites allowing efficient dis- and re-assembly of the viral genome characteristic of synthetic viruses. Here, we report the likelihood of observing such a pattern in coronaviruses with no history of bioengineering. We find that SARS-CoV-2 is an anomaly, more likely a product of synthetic genome assembly than natural evolution. The restriction map of SARS-CoV-2 is consistent with many previously reported synthetic coronavirus genomes, meets all the criteria required for an efficient reverse genetic system, differs from closest relatives by a significantly higher rate of synonymous mutations in these synthetic-looking recognitions sites, and has a synthetic fingerprint unlikely to have evolved from its close relatives. We report a high likelihood that SARS-CoV-2 may have originated as an infectious clone assembled in vitro.

Not seeing any issues here in the introduction:
... There are currently two hypotheses on the origin of SARS-CoV-2. The first hypothesis posits that SARS-CoV-2 has a natural origin and spilled over from animals to people at the Huanan seafood market (Pekar et al. 2022; Worobey et al. 2022). Research supporting a Huanan seafood market origin relies on analyses of early outbreak data suggesting the Huanan seafood market was an early epicenter of the COVID-19 pandemic. However, analyses of early case reports and phylodynamics are sensitive to assumptions about early case data. Such research assumes cases are ascertained at random, yet health authorities mounted extensive contact tracing and location tracing attempting to stop the early outbreak, and ties to the wet market were included as part of early case definitions (Washburne et al. 2022). Consequently, the wet market is believed to have been a site of transmission, it has not been conclusively shown to be the site of spillover.


Or here:
... The lab origin hypothesis primarily notices that CoV research was carried out in Wuhan and that SARS-CoV-2 is unique among sarbecoviruses in having a Furin cleavage site (FCS) between the S1 and S2 subunits of the Spike protein. In-vitro studies have found the FCS is key to SARS-CoV-2 pathogenesis (Johnson et al. 2021).The FCS may explain why SARS-CoV-2 has caused a pandemic, while the estimated 66,000 sarbecovirus spillovers every year (Sánchez et al. 2022) do not. The FCS in SARS-CoV-2 is highly similar to one found in α-ENaC, a human epithelial Na channel gene (Anand et al. 2020; Harrison and Sachs 2022), which would be unusual for a sarbecovirus evolving in an animal host.


Or here:
... Researchers would explore the relationship between viral genotypes & human-infectivity phenotypes by a variety of experiments, including introducing small alterations generating Furin cleavage sites (Li et al. 2015) or experimenting with different receptor binding domains (RBDs) (Hu et al. 2017).
Everything in this paper is supported with relevant citations.


And they look at more than one explanation for their findings:
We find this specific pattern in SARS-CoV-2. We examine if the restriction map of SARS-CoV-2 meets all criteria for IVGA and estimate the probabilities of observed patterns in wild type CoVs as well as the odds of such patterns evolving from the close relatives of SARS-CoV-2.


Past publications are full of implications:
A 2017 publication introduced two BsaI sites into a bat CoV (WIV1) to enable efficient introductions of spike genes from other viruses (Hu et al 2017)....

A 2008 publication describes that restriction sites of a new SARS-like virus reverse genetic system were aligned with restriction sites of SARS reverse genetic system (Becker et al 2008). This could allow for efficient substitutions of segments between the two systems.

There isn't one thing in that paper suggesting as Andersen says: "bad faith these grifters and conspiracy theorists are acting in - they're gaslighting all of us, yet their ******** keeps doing the rounds."

Andersen is bent out of shape insulting those that disagree with him. Is there some other link where Andersen actually addresses the evidence in the paper beyond childish insults? And on what basis did you jump on the bandwagon?
 
Tackling your denial one piece at a time: Live bats at the WIV.
Too much to respond to now but I will reiterate that there was not evidence of live bats at the WIV.
Have you really forgotten all the evidence that was posted? :boggled: You could look it up before making this embarrassing false assertion.

Yup, the Wuhan Institute of Virology Kept Live Bats within Its Walls
Sky News Australia has uncovered an official Chinese Academy of Sciences video from May 2017, marking the launch of the new biosafety-level-4 laboratory at the Wuhan Institute of Virology. Perhaps the most intriguing revelation in the video is the depiction of bats being held in a cage at the Institute, along with a scene of a scientist feeding a bat with a worm.
You like videos, here it is:


If there were, these were not the bats being studied by Shi etc… so no, it doesn’t prove Shi lied. That’s an attempt at a short-cut to lab leak. If even you admit that it is unrelated to lab leak then it is merely a kind of lawyer’s trick to attempt to discredit the witness.
Unrelated to the lab origin hypothesis? A lawyers' trick? Really? Seriously?

BTW, you have a lot of nerve talking about the tactic of discrediting a witness. That's what you've done time and time again here avoiding addressing at the evidence. Maybe that's why you are oblivious to the evidence there were live bats kept at the WIV.

How is it not relevant that both Daszak and Shi denied having any live bats, claiming they only had the genome data.

Daszak claimed in a Tweet they had no live bats in the WIV lab then realized that would be easily discredited so he deleted the Tweet.

More from the above link:
[Daszak] tweeted in December that, “No BATS ‘were sent to Wuhan lab for genetic analyses of viruses collected in the field’ That’s not how this science works. We collect bat samples, send them to the lab. We RELEASE bats where we catch them!” At some point, Daszak deleted his tweets making that assertion, but if he ever publicly admitted he was wrong, he was awfully quiet about it.
Click on the link for 5 embedded citations in this paragraph.
The Wuhan Institute of Virology reportedly filed patents for bat cages. Multiple accounts of WIV staff described bringing at least a handful of live bats back to the lab for further study. As one Chinese Academy of Science website described it, “Founded in 1956, Wuhan Institute of Virology is a comprehensive research institution specializing in basic virology research and related technological innovation.


WHO inspector's denial of bats in Wuhan lab contradicted by facts
Researchers have uncovered accounts from the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) scientists and applications for patents for bat breeding that refute World Health Organization (WHO) inspector Peter Daszak's claims that the lab does not house live bats captured in the wild. ...

... Chinese media reports that in fact the WIV scientists captured bats alive and kept them inside the lab. The lab has also filed two patents for cages to be used in bat breeding and one for lab accidents just before the start of the pandemic.
There's a capture of the Tweet.

There's a problem lying when one has published contradictory evidence in 2017.
Second China-U.S. Workshop on the Challenges of Emerging Infections, Laboratory Safety and Global Health Security - May 17-19 2017, Wuhan, China
Session 1 : Gain of function research, gene editing, targeting and delivery and other novel biotechnology
-Thoughts on Gain of function research, gene editing, targeting and delivery and other novel biotechnology

-The recent advances in technology and their applications
Chair –Yanyi Wang (Deputy Director General/ Principle Investigator, Wuhan Institute of Virology ,CAS)
I believe that is Wang who is/was Shi's boss.

Once again I post the same evidence:
The facility has 126 cages for Japanese white rabbits, 340 cages for SD and Wistar rats, inbred strains, closed groups, mutant strains, and genetically engineered mice. There are 3,268 cages, 12 ferrets, 12 bats, and 2 species of cotton bollworm and beet armyworm, totaling 52 strains.”

There's more evidence for anyone that wants to go further down the rabbit hole.
 
To outright deny evidence was posted over and over, however, I find odd.

IMO you haven't posted ANYTHING that reaches a standard that can be call evidence. NOT EVEN ONCE. All you have done is posted innuendo, baseless accusations of lies and coverups and a Gish gallop of things that are either annually contradictory, irrelevant or both.

If you feel you have posted real, positive, evidence for a lab leak then why don't you post your best 3 arguments again along with a complete description of why you think they are relevant.
 
Here's Andersen name-calling:
But to be fair so was Washburne. Except it started off with Washburne Tweeting:
https://twitter.com/WashburneAlex
So why didn't Andersen just address the evidence in the preprint instead of claiming Washburne was a gaslighting grifter? And how did you come to the conclusion Washburne's paper was no more than "with ever crazier nonsense about lab leak?" Did you look at it?


Not seeing any issues here in the introduction:



Or here:



Or here:Everything in this paper is supported with relevant citations.


And they look at more than one explanation for their findings:



Past publications are full of implications:


There isn't one thing in that paper suggesting as Andersen says: "bad faith these grifters and conspiracy theorists are acting in - they're gaslighting all of us, yet their ******** keeps doing the rounds."

Andersen is bent out of shape insulting those that disagree with him. Is there some other link where Andersen actually addresses the evidence in the paper beyond childish insults? And on what basis did you jump on the bandwagon?

Yes.

A recent preprint purported to show that SARS-CoV-2 is of synthetic origin, but it is so deeply flawed that it wouldn’t pass kindergarten molecular biology.

Below is an analysis with more relevant SARSr-CoV genomes, including the inferred recCA from
@jepekar
.
As is clear to anybody who knows a little bit about “restriction enzyme” analyses, we’re obviously looking at random noise.

Further, you will also notice that all BsmBI sites are preserved in the inferred ancestral recCA genome.

The ‘loss’ and ‘gain’ of BsaI and BsmBI happens across all genomes, typically due to synonymous transitions.

E.g., the ‘loss’ of a BsaI site in SARS2 and recCA ~10,440 is due to a single A>G transition at 10,447 - these occur frequently.

The study is a clear example of motivated reasoning with a heavy dose of technobabble to make it sound legitimate - but it’s nothing more than poppycock dressed up as science.

In plain language - this is uninformed nonsense and it’s simply not worth engaging with this ********.

By all means, analyses such as these are valuable and worth doing - I myself did a bunch back in Jan/Feb, 2020. However, let’s make sure we have an actual scientific approach to them and don’t make up complete nonsense ‘studies’ to try and bolster a preferred narrative.

If you want to take a closer look yourself, I have made the data behind my (very simple… 🙄) analyses available on GitHub.

https://github.com/andersen-lab/SARS-CoV-2_Evolution/tree/master/2022.10.20_restriction-analysis

Other examples of ‘loss’ of RE cutting sites in the alignment - all are (very commonly observed) transitions.

Seriously. 🤬

Another analysis here.

Is there any reason why this is still a pre-print and hasn't found a home in a journal yet?

As for my point about him spewing ever more crazy nonsense, may I ask what you think of the Great Barringron Declaration and their view that of letting the virus rip? Because he seems to be in that camp now as well as being generally down on vaccines, and more pro-GOP. I think he's gone towards climate change denial as well. Pretty much a typical trajectory for these types.

The presumed ascertainment bias that he brought up against Worobey was specifically looked at in Worobey's paper. This is the point of the finding that those cases of Covid-19 who had no connection to market were found, on average, to live closer to the market than those who did have a connection.

And yes, I know you will say Worobey "ignored" data, but he did not. He acknowledged that he did not have all the data. You cannot do anything with data you don't have except to acknowledge that it exists.
 
Not sure what you want me to add. He argues that WIV would not have predicted how to make SARS-COV-2 before the pandemic due to the complex interactions of inserting or deleting furin cleavage sites with other parts of the spike and ultimately how the effect on viral fitness and it's pathology isnt obvious. Nature is far better at doing the experiment.

Hi Capsid,

Sorry, I should have got back to you earlier on this.

Thanks for answering. It was not so much that I wanted you to add anything, but just to say whether or not you thought that the argument made sense.

Thanks again.
 
So what conclusion should we draw when people in the thread have trouble backing up their assertions with citations, misstate arguments both of other posters and of sources they are citing, and, keep repeating the lie that no evidence has been cited? They have to know they are consciously lying. The clincher evidence for that was in a reply to a challenge about Fauci's email.

Could it be denial?
Could it be that 't' word we aren't supposed to use?
Could it be incredible ignorance?

I think it's the same thing Andersen was resorting to on his Twitter feed, people in this thread simply can't debate the evidence so they resort to faulty debating practices. As the evidence for the lab origin mounts they have to fall back on 'lalalalalala I can't hear you" with fingers in their ears.
Must be hard when there is all that incriminating evidence turning up in past publications, grant proposals and leaked emails. And some pretty sophisticated evidence popped up like the TopHap genome mapping and now the Washburne paper. And the pictures, videos, tapes... oh Lordy there are tapes transcripts.


Ooooww, how about this for circular reasoning: Feb 2020 Fauci, Collins, and a half dozen other scientists get on a conference call where they discussed it looked like the virus came from a lab. Four days later they all changed their tune claiming there was new evidence but for which they have never provided that evidence. Fauci then 'commissions' the Proximal Origins paper and later cites the paper. That's like Daszak drafting the Lancet letter and getting others to sign it without saying Daszak wrote it.
On Sunday, the GOP-led House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic revealed that the nation’s leading epidemiologist in February 2020 directed and approved a paper titled, “The Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2,” which he later cited to cast the lab-leak theory as a myth.

“New evidence released by the Select Subcommittee today suggests that Dr. Fauci ‘prompted’ the drafting of a publication that would ‘disprove’ the lab leak theory, the authors of this paper skewed available evidence to achieve that goal, and Dr. Jeremy Farrar went uncredited despite significant involvement,” a memo from the committee read.

On February 1, 2020, Fauci, then director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, and Dr. Francis Collins, then director of the National Institutes of Health, held a call with several scientists to discuss the origins of the virus. A group of evolutionary virologists on the call informed Fauci and Collins that Covid may have stemmed from a lab accident and may have been genetically engineered, according to the memo. Three days later, four of the experts who attended that meeting drafted a research document, which was forwarded to Fauci upon completion for editing and approval. The paper, later published in Nature Medicine, argued that Covid had “mutations” that supported the explanation that it had been transmitted to humans from animals.

One of the four authors, Dr. Kristin Andersen, admits in a cover email sent to Nature that Fauci “prompted” the paper’s drafting in order to “disprove” the lab-leak theory.
So don't follow the evidence, fit the evidence to the desired outcome. And here's Andersen still defending a paper he knows was fudged. Well well well, no wonder he's so cranky.


Keep in mind here it was impossible anyone had ruled the lab origin out on the scant evidence that was available in Feb 2020.
 
Yes.

Another analysis here.
So argument by childish insult:
... it is so deeply flawed that it wouldn’t pass kindergarten molecular biology. ...

The study is a clear example of motivated reasoning with a heavy dose of technobabble to make it sound legitimate - but it’s nothing more than poppycock dressed up as science.

In plain language - this is uninformed nonsense and it’s simply not worth engaging with this ********.
That seems to be a pattern.


Andersen might have had more cred if he hadn't claimed the evidence for the market spillover was conclusive:
I'm going to bookend this with an earlier thread, showing the *actual* scientific evidence we *do* have, clearly showing that the start of the pandemic traces back to animal sales at a wet market.


As for preprints being published or not, the fact Worobey and all the related papers were published is good evidence it means little to nothing.


as said:
As for my point about him spewing ever more crazy nonsense, may I ask what you think of the Great Barringron Declaration and their view that of letting the virus rip? Because he seems to be in that camp now as well as being generally down on vaccines, and more pro-GOP. I think he's gone towards climate change denial as well. Pretty much a typical trajectory for these types.
I don't see a quote here I can address and given your history of misstating what others have said, I need a link and a quote.


as said:
The presumed ascertainment bias that he brought up against Worobey was specifically looked at in Worobey's paper. This is the point of the finding that those cases of Covid-19 who had no connection to market were found, on average, to live closer to the market than those who did have a connection.
No one can know that since China won't release the demographics of those earliest cases.


as said:
And yes, I know you will say Worobey "ignored" data, but he did not. He acknowledged that he did not have all the data. You cannot do anything with data you don't have except to acknowledge that it exists.
:boggled: The standard is to note in "limitations" in the paper that you were missing data. In addition you note in the limitations that if the market were a super spreader site it would also explain the data.
 
:boggled: The standard is to note in "limitations" in the paper that you were missing data. In addition you note in the limitations that if the market were a super spreader site it would also explain the data.

You mean like this?

Study limitations
There are several limitations to our study. We have been able to recover location data for most of the December-onset COVID-19 cases identified by the WHO mission (7) with sufficient precision to support our conclusions. However, we do not have access to the precise latitude and longitude coordinates of all of these cases. Should such data exist, they may be accompanied by additional metadata, some of which we have reconstructed, but some of which, including the date of onset of each case, would be valuable for ongoing studies. We also lack direct evidence of an intermediate animal infected with a SARS-CoV-2 progenitor virus either at the Huanan market or at a location connected to its supply chain, such as a farm. Additionally, no line list of early COVID-19 cases is available, and we do not have complete details of environmental sampling. However, compared with many other outbreaks, we have more comprehensive information on early cases, hospitalizations, and environmental sampling (7).

https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abp8715
 
So argument by childish insult:That seems to be a pattern.

You said...

So why didn't Andersen just address the evidence in the preprint instead of claiming Washburne was a gaslighting grifter?

He DID address the evidence at the time the pre-print came out.

The whole "gaslighting grifter" thing was written the other day. Washburne's pre-print was thoroughly raked over the coals last year when it was released.

Just because you are new to it and the acrimonious discussions around it, doesn't mean Andersen is. They have quite the history.

Remember of course that Andersen and co. have spent quite a lot of time getting hate and death threats as a result of the accusations that amount to an accusation of accessory to mass murder. Maybe he doesn't take too kindly to idle accusations or care for tone policing any more. I can't say I blame him.
 
So what conclusion should we draw when people in the thread have trouble backing up their assertions with citations, misstate arguments both of other posters and of sources they are citing, and, keep repeating the lie that no evidence has been cited? They have to know they are consciously lying. The clincher evidence for that was in a reply to a challenge about Fauci's email.

Could it be denial?
Could it be that 't' word we aren't supposed to use?
Could it be incredible ignorance?

I think it's the same thing Andersen was resorting to on his Twitter feed, people in this thread simply can't debate the evidence so they resort to faulty debating practices. As the evidence for the lab origin mounts they have to fall back on 'lalalalalala I can't hear you" with fingers in their ears.
Must be hard when there is all that incriminating evidence turning up in past publications, grant proposals and leaked emails. And some pretty sophisticated evidence popped up like the TopHap genome mapping and now the Washburne paper. And the pictures, videos, tapes... oh Lordy there are tapes transcripts.


Ooooww, how about this for circular reasoning: Feb 2020 Fauci, Collins, and a half dozen other scientists get on a conference call where they discussed it looked like the virus came from a lab. Four days later they all changed their tune claiming there was new evidence but for which they have never provided that evidence. Fauci then 'commissions' the Proximal Origins paper and later cites the paper. That's like Daszak drafting the Lancet letter and getting others to sign it without saying Daszak wrote it.
So don't follow the evidence, fit the evidence to the desired outcome. And here's Andersen still defending a paper he knows was fudged. Well well well, no wonder he's so cranky.


Keep in mind here it was impossible anyone had ruled the lab origin out on the scant evidence that was available in Feb 2020.

That seems like a massive distortion of what was said.

Andersen emphatically denies that Fauci "prompted" him to disprove the lab leak.
 

No, not like that which essentially downplays the lack of data as if it wasn't relevant.
with sufficient precision to support our conclusions.
No there was a significant % of missing early cases.

However, we do not have access to the precise latitude and longitude coordinates of all of these cases.
What does this mean except for an excuse claiming the missing data only lacked precision coordinates as if it was known they were somewhere close to the market. And when was that? Was it that they lived nearby? Worobey has nothing except his confirmation-biased assumptions tying those early cases to the market.

So what does he say next:
Additionally, no line list of early COVID-19 cases is available, and we do not have complete details of environmental sampling. However, compared with many other outbreaks, we have more comprehensive information on early cases, hospitalizations, and environmental sampling (7).
:rolleyes:

OMG, they have more data than in other outbreaks? That's crap. Did he include citations to and analyses of these other outbreaks justifying they were similar enough to extrapolate an analogy?

Puhleese! Talk about "wouldn’t pass kindergarten molecular biology..." to use Andersen's words. Even I can see that.

Is there a mention of the alternative explanation for the market cases being a super-spreader site?


Worobey is trying to relive his heyday when he mapped out HIV cases in Uganda.
 
That seems like a massive distortion of what was said.

Andersen emphatically denies that Fauci "prompted" him to disprove the lab leak.
He did? He denied he was persuaded to bend the truth even not overtly? How absurd that he didnt say otherwise and come clean about the whole thing.
Oh well, then I guess that ends it.
Spillover it is then. Never mind all the other evidence.
 
You said...

He DID address the evidence at the time the pre-print came out.

The whole "gaslighting grifter" thing was written the other day. Washburne's pre-print was thoroughly raked over the coals last year when it was released.

Just because you are new to it and the acrimonious discussions around it, doesn't mean Andersen is. They have quite the history.
:rolleyes:

A professional getting annoyed their previous argument wasn't taken seriously enough so they get frustrated and start tossing insults. I should try that. :cool:

as said:
Remember of course that Andersen and co. have spent quite a lot of time getting hate and death threats as a result of the accusations that amount to an accusation of accessory to mass murder. Maybe he doesn't take too kindly to idle accusations or care for tone policing any more. I can't say I blame him.
Yeah, Baric has had the same problem, death threats and all that. But Andersen chose to support the natural spillover hypothesis only a month or so into the pandemic. That might be fine if he actually had evidence and if he hadn't gone down the same path Daszak went down calling anyone who suggested looking at a lab origin hypothesis a CTer.
You all keep calling me a CTer as well despite the fact of all the people in this discussion I am one of the few sticking to the actual evidence.
 
That seems like a massive distortion of what was said.
Which part of my quote are you claiming is a distortion?

as said:
Andersen emphatically denies that Fauci "prompted" him to disprove the lab leak.
Fauci admitted he did. Those guys should get their stories straight.

Wait a minute, upon review of a quote I cited above:
Three days later, four of the experts who attended that meeting drafted a research document, which was forwarded to Fauci upon completion for editing and approval. The paper, later published in Nature Medicine, argued that Covid had “mutations” that supported the explanation that it had been transmitted to humans from animals.

One of the four authors, Dr. Kristin Andersen, admits in a cover email sent to Nature that Fauci “prompted” the paper’s drafting in order to “disprove” the lab-leak theory.

So Andersen can't make up his mind then? Or did you make up the part where Andersen "emphatically denies that Fauci "prompted" him to disprove the lab leak."


You should consider quitting while you're behind angrysoba.
 
Last edited:
No, not like that

Goalposts moving...

which essentially downplays the lack of data as if it wasn't relevant.
No there was a significant % of missing early cases.

What percentage? Be specifc now!

Puhleese! Talk about "wouldn’t pass kindergarten molecular biology..." to use Andersen's words. Even I can see that.

It was published in Science. Where was Washburne's analysis published? On Twitter?

Is there a mention of the alternative explanation for the market cases being a super-spreader site?

Yes. The paper that you definitely read says this...

We found at least 70 other markets throughout the city of Wuhan that received more social media check-ins than the Huanan market (Fig. 3). To extend this analysis beyond only markets, we also used a subsequently published list of known SARS-CoV-2 superspreader locations (34) to identify 430 locations in Wuhan that may have been at high risk for superspreader events and which received more check-ins than the Huanan market (Fig. 3, inset). The Huanan market accounted for 0.12% (120 of 98,146) of social media check-ins to markets in the dataset that received at least as many check-ins as the Huanan market. The market accounted for 0.04% (120 of 262,233) of all social media check-ins to the >400 sites in Wuhan identified as especially likely to be potential superspreader locations and which received at least as many social media visits as the Huanan market. Considering the number of check-ins to all four markets selling live wild animals in Wuhan (combined), they accounted for 0.21% (206 of 98,146) of market visits and 0.079% (206 of 262,233) of visits to the 430 potential superspreader sites, where a new respiratory disease might first be noticed in a large city.

And...

This, along with the lineage A cases that we report in close geographical proximity to the market in December 2019, challenges the suggestion that the market was simply a superspreading event, which would be lineage specific. Rather, it adds to the evidence presented here that lineage A, like lineage B, may have originated at the Huanan market and then spread from this epicenter into the neighborhoods surrounding the market and beyond.


Worobey is trying to relive his heyday when he mapped out HIV cases in Uganda.

:rolleyes: Nice mind-reading you got there!
 
Which part of my quote are you claiming is a distortion?

Fauci admitted he did.

Where does he "admit" this?


Those guys should get their stories straight.

Wait a minute, upon review of a quote I cited above:

So Andersen can't make up his mind then? Or did you make up the part where Andersen "emphatically denies that Fauci "prompted" him to disprove the lab leak."

You should consider quitting while you're behind angrysoba.

This is what Andersen says in his testimonial:

Importantly, on a January 31, 2020 call with Dr. Fauci, where I first outlined my concerns, he
told me (I am paraphrasing, as I do not remember the exact words): “if you think this virus
came from a lab, you should write a scientific paper on it”. Not only is this not a ‘prompt’ to
“disprove the lab leak theory”, it was specifically predicated on our initial hypothesis, which
was that of a “lab leak”.

https://oversight.house.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/Testimony-of-Dr.-Kristian-Andersen.pdf

So the claim that Andersen or Fauci "admitted" that Fauci prompted Andersen to dispove the lab leak is the exact opposite.
 
He did? He denied he was persuaded to bend the truth even not overtly? How absurd that he didnt say otherwise and come clean about the whole thing.
Oh well, then I guess that ends it.
Spillover it is then. Never mind all the other evidence.

See above.
 
Goalposts moving...
Did I say any meaningless version of limitations? I did not. Why would that be what I meant?


What percentage? Be specifc now!
I don't need to, you can look it up. But since I just came across it:
https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abm4454
Forty-one of the first known patients formed the basis of an influential study that reported that 66%—i.e., not all early cases—had a link to Huanan Market (4).
2/3, that can be a big issue when you are talking about small numbers.


It was published in Science. Where was Washburne's analysis published? On Twitter?
I posted the link. Are you annoyed?


Yes. The paper that you definitely read says this...
None of that addresses the problem. Worobey looked at the first cases in Wuhan and claimed they clustered around the seafood market. No one doubts some cases did.

That market also happens to be very close to the WIV. Why would it matter if any other markets had super-spreader events in whatever timeframe Worobey chose to compare? There were not super-spreader events all across the city.

You seem to forget, and I take it Worobey ignored, the fact that it was reported back in Dec 2019 that the seafood market was a super-spreader site. It's one reason the market was shut down. This is another one of those inconvenient facts that developed before China shut the whole information thing down about those earliest cases.

Here's another video for you from 3 years ago. It's only 38 seconds long.

video transcript said:
The Chinese Centre for Disease Control says the initial coronavirus outbreak did not come from wet markets.

The organisation reported the first cases of coronavirus had been traced back to the Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market, in the city of Wuhan.

However, after an investigation of the animals at the site, scientists from the United States and China concluded there was no evidence to suggest the jump between animal hosts occurred at the Seafood market.

The director of the Chinese Centre of Disease Control says the markets were a "victim" of the outbreak.

They believe it may have been the site of a 'super spreader' event where 41 of the first cases originated.


as said:
I addressed that lineage A&B multiple times. No need to repeat it. It doesn't prove Worobey's case and there's zero relevant evidence of one spillover, let alone 2.

as said:
:rolleyes: Nice mind-reading you got there!
Clearly an assumption on my part but it fits a pattern some researchers fall into, lots of ego.
 
Where does he "admit" this?

This is what Andersen says in his testimonial:

https://oversight.house.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/Testimony-of-Dr.-Kristian-Andersen.pdf

So the claim that Andersen or Fauci "admitted" that Fauci prompted Andersen to dispove the lab leak is the exact opposite.
If you go back to the initial conference call and the emails instead of relying on their testimony 3 years later when they've worked on rationalizing you get more reliable evidence

How Fauci and NIH leaders worked to discredit the COVID-19 lab leak theory
House of Representatives investigators just issued an interim report on Tuesday detailing a sophisticated effort by leaders at the National Institutes of Health and a select group of researchers—including those who had received substantial NIH grant funding—to disprove the hypothesis that COVID-19 originated in a Chinese research laboratory and push the narrative that it instead emerged from nature.

Republican staff of the House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic chaired by Rep. Brad Wenstrup, R-Ohio, have collected more than 8,000 documents, including emails and other communications, plus nearly 25 hours of witness testimony.

Their report details the January through March 2020 activities of Dr. Anthony Fauci and NIH Director Francis Collins in encouraging an international team of prominent scientists to attempt to debunk the notion that the pandemic could have originated in a lab.

Following a Feb. 1, 2020, conference call, Fauci and Collins “prompted” the scientists to act. According to the report:
You can read the rest yourself.


The problem you have here angrysoba is the evidence is stacked against you.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom