Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Ah, okay, so here he does say in his email that the WIV was known to be conducting gain of function research.
Link

It is true that he should have disclosed that, but this is not what he was asked. He was asked if the NIH funded GoF research, which he said no to.

That is not a new email. As for who funded what, good grief it's all covered in this thread, ad nauseum.

To review:

New emails reveal that Dr. Fauci was aware of risky gain-of-function research occurring in Wuhan, China prior to the emergence of COVID-19.
Click on the Tweet for an enlargement of the email if you still have access to Twitter.



How long is the denial going to last in this thread before the evidence is honestly addressed?

Interesting!

I, angrysoba, get rebuked that "That is not a new email", and yet the Daily Caller is happily cited a few days later saying "New emails" while linking to EXACTLY the same tweet that I got told off for.

Intersting also that I was told not to post about the House hearings as they belong in US politics or CT, and yet here we have it. The exact same stuff is being posted as if it is perfectly cromulent.

Anyway, yes, Fauci probably needs to clarify what this is about.

Are we then going to go from there to saying that Fauci's NIH funded the emergence of the coronavirus with gain-of-function experiments?

I think that still requires a lot of steps such as what was the progenitor virus, the nature of the FCS and whether it involved serial passaging etc..., which lab it apparently leaked from and how it got to the Huanan Seafood Market.
 
To review:

New emails reveal that Dr. Fauci was aware of risky gain-of-function research occurring in Wuhan, China prior to the emergence of COVID-19.
Click on the Tweet for an enlargement of the email if you still have access to Twitter.



How long is the denial going to last in this thread before the evidence is honestly addressed?

The science evolves, interpretations change. Lots of ideas were thrown out at the beginning, like the idea that an HIV sequence or a human sequence was inserted. Further more careful study shows these ideas were wrong. The possibility of a synthesised virus was considered and discarded. To continue to rehash theories from the past and not understand that the understanding of SARS-Cov-2 has advanced is sad.

The problem with the term 'gain of function' is people throw it out as if that means that WIV could have synthesised SARS-CoV-2 because they did 'gain of function' work. The actual details of the genetic manipulation research could not have produced SARs-CoV-2. To have done so would have required years of research which would have been published because it would have involved a series of notable discoveries on coronavirus biology.

Much of the genetic manipulation done was legitimately done in BSL, producing chimeric viruses can be done safely in BSL2. Replication deficient viruses can be manipulated in BSL2.
 
:popcorn1

Plenty of evidence, more everyday.

From a week ago here's a source noting the GoF research that is at issue here. Baric has been under quite the onslaught of accusations that the virus emerged from his lab (it didn't):

Time: The U.S. Scientist At the Heart of COVID-19 Lab Leak Conspiracies Is Still Trying to Save the World From the Next Pandemic
Baric, who signed onto an open letter published in Science in 2021 demanding a thorough investigation of the origins of SARS-CoV-2, is still frustrated by its slow pace. While he remains unsure on the question, Baric finds particular fault with a joint investigation by the World Health Organization (WHO) and the Chinese government that was done in 2021, which dismissed the chance of a lab leak as “extremely unlikely.” That conclusion, Baric says, is premature, given the lack of conclusive data and China’s more relaxed laboratory standards; he points out that while the U.S. restricts gain-of-function work with dangerous pathogens to labs rated at a minimum of BSL-3 (like Baric’s), “the regulations in China are such that you can work with SARS-like bat coronaviruses in BSL-2 [Biosafety level 2] labs,” which require fewer safety features. ...
Backs up what I've said about the lab origin not being ruled out GoF research being done and the WIV working in BSL2 labs.

Baric considered chimeras as the best way to study deadly pathogens while maintaining a safe lab with low risk of leaks. Submitting live SARS and MERS viruses to gain-of-function tests—like pressuring pathogens to evolve new ways of infecting hosts—was too edgy for him. But doing the same experiment with a chimera that combined a piece of a human coronavirus with one that could only infect a non-human animal allowed Baric to test how coronaviruses evolve while avoiding the inadvertent creation of a pathogen with the capacity to replicate in human cells.


Except, whoops (and remember this is in a much safer lab than the ones at the WIV):
Despite his caution, one experiment raised eyebrows. In 2014, Baric’s team created a chimera that fused the spike protein of one of the SARS-related bat coronaviruses that Shi had harvested, known as SHC014, with the backbone of a mouse-adapted SARS virus; in principle, the chimera should only have been able to infect mice. Baric’s team then introduced the chimera into human cell colonies and found that, under pressure, it was able to replicate in human respiratory cells while also evading antiviral drugs protective against SARS. ...


When I spoke with him, Lipsitch readily acknowledged the value of Baric’s work, but also said that he believes the decision to introduce the SHC014 chimera into human cells crossed a line. “Ralph’s done a lot of different kinds of experiments,” says Lipsitch, “some of which I’ve publicly said should get funding and be allowed to continue, and some of which I think he should not continue, at least not without careful review.” For Lipsitch, the decision to run an ePPP experiment ultimately boils down to the urgency of the threat and whether alternative pathways exist. “I’m open to learning more,” he says, “but I have not yet heard an argument for why taking some part of a bat virus and recombining it with some part of a human virus, and assessing its ability to infect human cells, is an important part of pandemic preparedness.” ...

Baric rejects that easy binary. Instead, he points out that gain-of-function experiments, even the most controversial ones, such as the experiment done in 2011 that transformed an avian flu strain into a deadly airborne pathogen (which precipitated a broad shutdown of gain-of-function research by the NIH) are funded by governments. That, Baric says, makes governments, rather than scientists, primarily responsible for choosing which experiments to run and how closely to monitor them. A draft report from January 2023 by the U.S. National Scientific Advisory Board for Biosecurity, a federally-appointed committee advising the U.S. government on gain-of-function research, backs up that view: among their recommendations are that government be more open about why certain gain-of-function experiments that might be risky to humans are funded. ...

Lipsitch, for his part, sees greater transparency from everyone involved—funders and scientists alike—as the best way to move life-saving science forward and lower the temperature on the issue. “There have been some very crazy things said, and some very offensive things,” he says, “but it’s really in the scientific community’s self-interest to explain what they think the value of these studies is, to engage with the idea that some of them may be dangerous, and to admit that lab accidents happen.” ...
 
Last edited:
I don't see any evidence there.

I think what happens, is that a media report or media circus starts up and then there are a bunch of different people commenting on it.

It's as though #CovidOrigins trending is evidence of something. It is not.

All we have is a profile of Ralph Baric. That's it!
 
I don't see any evidence there.

I think what happens, is that a media report or media circus starts up and then there are a bunch of different people commenting on it.

It's as though #CovidOrigins trending is evidence of something. It is not.

All we have is a profile of Ralph Baric. That's it!

Perhaps I wasn't clear, it is yet another piece of evidence GoF research was being done on coronaviruses. But you all just keep denying this all you want. It doesn't change the facts.

I added some highlights for more clarity.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps I wasn't clear, it is yet another piece of evidence GoF research was being done on coronaviruses. But you all just keep denying this all you want. It doesn't change the facts.

I added some highlights for more clarity.

None of those highlighted refer to the WIV. Instead it says that the WIV worked with bat coronaviruses at BSL-2, which is not only something known about already but referred to in the Proximal Origins paper as well.

Baric, as we know, did perform gain of function experiments, although as we know these viruses are not the kind of viruses that were known to be pathonogenic to humans. Indeed, the gain-of-function definition that had been specifically banned was that which was pathonogenic to humans (things like flu, MERS, SARS etc...).
 
Your denial has reached the level of absurd.

I’ve already said twice that Fauci should clarify what he meant in that email.

Aside from that we have the same argument that has been going on since before the pandemic about what constitutes gain of function and what the dangers are. Ebright and Lipsitch have been two of the biggest proponents for banning gain of function because of the experiments which made flu more virulent.

Clearly it was a valid concern the WIV could have had viruses that GoF could have turned into SARS-CoV2, yet no evidence has emerged to show that it had such viruses. The closest we seem to have is RaTG13, mentioned in the Proximal Origins paper.

So where does that leave us?

Presumably we have to assert secret viruses or secret methods.

Who knows? Maybe that did happen. But to get there you have to keep widening the net. The conspiracy gets bigger.
 
Here is a Twitter thread in which an anonymous account is arguing that the DEFUSE proposal could never have become SARS-CoV2.

It sounds fine to me, but maybe someone like Capsid could weigh in... if you don't mind. :D

Link

Not sure what you want me to add. He argues that WIV would not have predicted how to make SARS-COV-2 before the pandemic due to the complex interactions of inserting or deleting furin cleavage sites with other parts of the spike and ultimately how the effect on viral fitness and it's pathology isnt obvious. Nature is far better at doing the experiment.
 
Not sure what you want me to add. He argues that WIV would not have predicted how to make SARS-COV-2 before the pandemic due to the complex interactions of inserting or deleting furin cleavage sites with other parts of the spike and ultimately how the effect on viral fitness and it's pathology isnt obvious. Nature is far better at doing the experiment.

If they could have predicted one would hope they wouldn't have gone through with the experiments they were doing.

I found it interesting and disturbing that Baric created a chimera which he thought would be harmless but found out it could infect human cells. And it was interesting and disturbing he had worked with coronaviruses for years under the belief they were relatively harmless to humans and certainly not a PPP.
 
Last edited:
If the article is correct and this research in BSL-2 labs where is the "coincidence" of Covid emerging in a City with a BSL-4 lab?

Part of my issue with the lab leak theory is that it hops from hypothesis to hypothesis.

We could also ask what the significance is of the claim that live bats were being taken back to the WIV.

Or the idea that lab workers got sick in November 2019 through their experiments but that the taking down of a database in September 2019 signaled the release of the virus, or that the Wuhan military games played a part.

Or that if not the WIV, the WCDC. Or maybe if not engineering, then serial passaging. And if not that then maybe catching a virus direct from the bat in a mine while wearing inadequate PPE.

They can’t all be true, but the LL seems to glom onto each of these when convenient and Gish Gallop away when not.

On the other hand, the zoonotic theory is relatively conserved. A virus emerging from a market likely through the wildlife trade. It predicted that susceptible mammals were likely sold and lo and behold they were.
 
Some related drama.

Jamie Metal publicly asserted that Andersen should have apologized for his wording on the Proximal Origins at the Select Committee hearing, then privately sent Andersen an email saying he thought he did a very good job at the hearing, before publicly declaring again that Andersen should distance himself from his paper in some way.

Andersen released the private email to Metzl’s chagrin.

Who can blame him?
 
Part of my issue with the lab leak theory is that it hops from hypothesis to hypothesis.
Nonsense. Not to mention I don't suppose you recognize the irony? Should I list all the spillover hypotheses to remind you just how many there are?

There was some speculation as to how the virus evolved but pretty much as the evidence accumulated it became clear a SARS-like CoV was manipulated by Shi and her team under inadequate safety precautions in a misguided effort to develop a universal coronavirus vaccine. You can't get much more straightforward than that.

There was one hypothesis it was possibly brought back via a WIV worker who got infected collecting specimens from Yunnan. There's no evidence that is what happened. The timing makes no sense in light of the evidence. No similar viruses have been found circulating in bats in Yunnan or elsewhere. This is not the lab origin hypothesis the evidence supports.

Which other hypotheses did you have in mind?


As for lomiller's claim:
If the article is correct and this research in BSL-2 labs where is the "coincidence" of Covid emerging in a City with a BSL-4 lab?
Is lomiller paying any attention at all? :confused: Anyone following the thread will know the evidence the WIV was using BSL2 to work on SARS-like CoVs was corroborated through multiple sources including Dr Baric's own statements that they weren't even using BSL3 like he was.


We could also ask what the significance is of the claim that live bats were being taken back to the WIV.
The significance is this was in direct contradiction to Shi's claim they had no live bats at the WIV and had no live cultures there. Do I need to spell it out that live bats at the WIV is evidence Shi lied? She denied there were any live bats there.


Or the idea that lab workers got sick in November 2019 through their experiments but that the taking down of a database in September 2019 signaled the release of the virus, or that the Wuhan military games played a part.
If China would release all the data they are refusing to release and if any of those military games attendees were tested and the results released, we might have some answers here. Do you not find it odd given the importance of tracing the spread of COVID that not one country, including Italy and the US, followed up on this?

You seem to think that every single piece of evidence discussed has to fit into the overall picture or the whole house of cards comes crumbling down. If that were true, boy do you have a lot of explaining to do about the multiple spillover hypotheses.

Or that if not the WIV, the WCDC. Or maybe if not engineering, then serial passaging. And if not that then maybe catching a virus direct from the bat in a mine while wearing inadequate PPE.

They can’t all be true, but the LL seems to glom onto each of these when convenient and Gish Gallop away when not.
Has this really been that hard for you to follow? I shouldn't be surprised given my long, well researched, well supported posts overwhelmed you as "gish galloping". I tried to write shorter posts. I summarized the evidence for and against more than once. I've repeated the evidence-based arguments over and over, and I've asked you and anyone else in this thread to address the evidence. It's a simple request. You can always try again.

How much time should we wait before concluding a crossover species will not be found?

Worobey ignored the fact dozens of the earliest cases of COVID were left out of his study.

Where in the WHO report are any other wet markets identified except in generalities? This was Worobey's explanation for cases not connected to the seafood market and his 'evidence' supporting 2 separate spillover events explaining lineages A & B.

Let's not forget Worobey claimed 2 spillover events occurred and that it explained the few nucleotide substitutions between A & B even though this supposedly occurred in the crossover species there is no genetic evidence for AT ALL.

Yet we can rule out this occurred while the virus circulated in humans because we don't have that evidence? That's nuts! Do we have all the earliest patient COVID genomes! No, we don't but we know they exist and China won't release the data. Do we have all the genomes circulating in the spillover species? No we don't and we have no evidence, none, zilch that there was any COVID or close to it genetically circulating in some animal species before humans were infected. ​
I don't know who you think is glomming on to what but that seems more like your confirmation bias like dismissing all the evidence that contradicts your POV with ad hominems about the sources rather than actually addressing the evidence.


On the other hand, the zoonotic theory is relatively conserved. A virus emerging from a market likely through the wildlife trade. It predicted that susceptible mammals were likely sold and lo and behold they were.
:sdl: OMG are you really that oblivious to what you are saying?
Captured wildlife?
Farmed wildlife?
Frozen food?
A wildlife handler or farmer?
Or someone who transported the animals?
Someone bringing it back directly from Yunnan?
​
So straightforward only if you post it that way. Here, let me show you:

Shi and her team manipulated SARS-like CoVs at the WIV under less than adequate biosafety precautions and one of the team unknowingly got infected and spread it to others.​
 
Some related drama.

Jamie Metal [Metzl] publicly asserted that Andersen should have apologized for his wording on the Proximal Origins at the Select Committee hearing, then privately sent Andersen an email saying he thought he did a very good job at the hearing, before publicly declaring again that Andersen should distance himself from his paper in some way.

Andersen released the private email to Metzl’s chagrin.

Who can blame him?
Is there a source for this so we can see the specifics instead of your interpretation?
 
Nonsense. Not to mention I don't suppose you recognize the irony? Should I list all the spillover hypotheses to remind you just how many there are?

There was some speculation as to how the virus evolved but pretty much as the evidence accumulated it became clear a SARS-like CoV was manipulated by Shi and her team under inadequate safety precautions in a misguided effort to develop a universal coronavirus vaccine. You can't get much more straightforward than that.

There was one hypothesis it was possibly brought back via a WIV worker who got infected collecting specimens from Yunnan. There's no evidence that is what happened. The timing makes no sense in light of the evidence. No similar viruses have been found circulating in bats in Yunnan or elsewhere. This is not the lab origin hypothesis the evidence supports.

Which other hypotheses did you have in mind?


As for lomiller's claim:Is lomiller paying any attention at all? :confused: Anyone following the thread will know the evidence the WIV was using BSL2 to work on SARS-like CoVs was corroborated through multiple sources including Dr Baric's own statements that they weren't even using BSL3 like he was.


The significance is this was in direct contradiction to Shi's claim they had no live bats at the WIV and had no live cultures there. Do I need to spell it out that live bats at the WIV is evidence Shi lied? She denied there were any live bats there.


If China would release all the data they are refusing to release and if any of those military games attendees were tested and the results released, we might have some answers here. Do you not find it odd given the importance of tracing the spread of COVID that not one country, including Italy and the US, followed up on this?

You seem to think that every single piece of evidence discussed has to fit into the overall picture or the whole house of cards comes crumbling down. If that were true, boy do you have a lot of explaining to do about the multiple spillover hypotheses.


Has this really been that hard for you to follow? I shouldn't be surprised given my long, well researched, well supported posts overwhelmed you as "gish galloping". I tried to write shorter posts. I summarized the evidence for and against more than once. I've repeated the evidence-based arguments over and over, and I've asked you and anyone else in this thread to address the evidence. It's a simple request. You can always try again.

How much time should we wait before concluding a crossover species will not be found?

Worobey ignored the fact dozens of the earliest cases of COVID were left out of his study.

Where in the WHO report are any other wet markets identified except in generalities? This was Worobey's explanation for cases not connected to the seafood market and his 'evidence' supporting 2 separate spillover events explaining lineages A & B.

Let's not forget Worobey claimed 2 spillover events occurred and that it explained the few nucleotide substitutions between A & B even though this supposedly occurred in the crossover species there is no genetic evidence for AT ALL.

Yet we can rule out this occurred while the virus circulated in humans because we don't have that evidence? That's nuts! Do we have all the earliest patient COVID genomes! No, we don't but we know they exist and China won't release the data. Do we have all the genomes circulating in the spillover species? No we don't and we have no evidence, none, zilch that there was any COVID or close to it genetically circulating in some animal species before humans were infected. ​
I don't know who you think is glomming on to what but that seems more like your confirmation bias like dismissing all the evidence that contradicts your POV with ad hominems about the sources rather than actually addressing the evidence.


:sdl: OMG are you really that oblivious to what you are saying?
Captured wildlife?
Farmed wildlife?
Frozen food?
A wildlife handler or farmer?
Or someone who transported the animals?
Someone bringing it back directly from Yunnan?
​
So straightforward only if you post it that way. Here, let me show you:

Shi and her team manipulated SARS-like CoVs at the WIV under less than adequate biosafety precautions and one of the team unknowingly got infected and spread it to others.​

Too much to respond to now but I will reiterate that there was not evidence of live bats at the WIV. If there were, these were not the bats being studied by Shi etc… so no, it doesn’t prove Shi lied. That’s an attempt at a short-cut to lab leak. If even you admit that it is unrelated to lab leak then it is merely a kind of lawyer’s trick to attempt to discredit the witness.

As for Worobey. You keep (mis)using the terms “ignore” when you talk about his “flawed” study in this Trumpian manner, but he cannot ignore data he doesn’t have. Scientists ALWAYS have to work with partial data. It’s just part of the LL claim that there is hidden data somewhere that we haven’t seen but which would definitely implicate the lab if found.

As for the zoonosis being a changing theory, it really is not. Nobody arguing the zoonosis has ever claimed frozen food. That is a theory from China aimed at implicating another country (probably the US - which some LL theorists actually seem to agree with BTW).

But you say the lab leak is simpler and say that it involved Shi and the WIV. Okay, except when you claim it might have been the WCDC. So even then it slips and slides. Oh, and when did the virus emerge? Zoonosis puts it around Nov 2019 according to Pekar et. al, I believe. Other analyses seem to agree more or less. So again it is pretty conserved. Captured or farmed is a meaningless distinction, so not a problem for zoonosis. But when it comes to LL, the question of gain of function goes to the heart of the claims. And some of the theories have been sketched out in detail.

It’s not so much a theory as a waggly accusatory finger pointing all over the place.
 
Is there a source for this so we can see the specifics instead of your interpretation?

Here we go...

Jamie Metzl...

[QUOTE_"Jamie Metzl in public"]Here’s what the Proximal Origin authors should say:

We screwed up. We are sorry. We knowingly overhyped our preferred #COVID19 origin hypothesis and undermined the real possibility of a research related origin because we thought this was in the interest of science and the public good. We now realize our actions undermined those and prevented the broader public dialogue regarding pandemic origins that was so urgently needed.[/QUOTE]

Here is what he said in private in an email to Andersen...

[QUOTE_"Jamie Metzl in private"]
Kristian - you comported yourself admirably and well in the hearings today.

As I have long said, everyone working in good faith to understand the pandemic origin issue and build a safer future for all is on the same side.

With best regards,

Jamie[/QUOTE]

Clearly Andersen was not in the mood for such smarm and posted the email with the words "Funny how it works".


Link

Metzl then said that the two things are not contradictory but clearly misses the point of how things look when people's correspondence is leaked and cherry-picked.

Link

Andersen then did the same for Alex Washburne who has been recently trying to make a name for himself with ever crazier nonsense about lab leak.

Link
 
Some related drama.

Jamie Metal publicly asserted that Andersen should have apologized for his wording on the Proximal Origins at the Select Committee hearing, then privately sent Andersen an email saying he thought he did a very good job at the hearing, before publicly declaring again that Andersen should distance himself from his paper in some way.

Andersen released the private email to Metzl’s chagrin.

Who can blame him?
The bolded is what you read into the exchange^. The released private email sounded like Metzl was trying to mend the fence, not denying what Metzl had posted.

Here is the actual exchange. You have the first quote correct:
Jamie Metzl in public said:
Here’s what the Proximal Origin authors should say:

We screwed up. We are sorry. We knowingly overhyped our preferred #COVID19 origin hypothesis and undermined the real possibility of a research related origin because we thought this was in the interest of science and the public good. We now realize our actions undermined those and prevented the broader public dialogue regarding pandemic origins that was so urgently needed.
So "knowingly" overhyped the spillover hypothesis and undermined public dialogue about the origin. IMO it's true but I can see how Metzl might want to reach out to Andersen after posting that.

The 2 men are/were friends and Metzl replied in private in an email to Andersen from your link:
Jamie Metzl in private said:
Kristian - you comported yourself admirably and well in the hearings today.

As I have long said, everyone working in good faith to understand the pandemic origin issue and build a safer future for all is on the same side.

With best regards,

Jamie
My interpretation is Metzl is telling Andersen that he wasn't accusing Andersen of lying the Proximal Origins paper, just overstating the evidence. And Metzl most certainly didn't contradict what he had posted.

But Andersen was still incensed, thus the "Funny how that works" comment.
Metzl in a reply to the Tweet said:
Kristian - It is ironic that you chose to post my message on Twitter rather than respond to my email. My email to you and my post are not at all at odds with each other. I actually have respect for you but sometimes wonder whether you are stuck in glue you yourself have created. It seems pretty obvious you overhyped your hypothesis in the Proximal Origin paper and then feared that reverting to a defensible position would be too dangerous for one reason or another. It’s totally fine for you to believe that zoonosis in the wild is the most likely cause of the initial spillover. It’s not fine to knowingly overstate your conclusions and to have actively suppressed the kind of robust public dialogue regarding #COVID19 origins that has been required. Jamie
I don't see the bolded part in there:
as said:
Metzl then said that the two things are not contradictory but clearly misses the point of how things look when people's correspondence is leaked and cherry-picked.
IWhere was anyone's correspondence leaked and cherry picked?

Seems perfectly clear to me, Metzl voiced his opinion, reached out to Andersen who replied something to the effect of 'stick it'. Metzl reiterated his opinion sans the peace offering.


As I have said many times in this thread, some people are defensive about their spillover origin support. Why? What are they afraid of if it becomes clear that is not the correct hypothesis?

The way I see it people become defensive when they aren't believed. If they could support their belief they wouldn't need to be defensive.

To outright deny evidence was posted over and over, however, I find odd.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom