Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

The House committee is not just politics. The House was able to get an unredacted version of the 2-1-2020 email from Fauci, to others that are at a greater level than Andersen, admitting that Wuhan University was performing Gain-of-Function. Fauci, under oath, said there was no GOF... he did not provide any qualifiers such as "... we don't perform GOF but the Wuhan University does..." He never said anything along that line, he just said NIH weren't doing this process.

Why did Fauci have that email redacted? No pangolin has been found but we have GOF being conducted on bat viruses in the same city where the pandemic started therefore the "nature" hypothesis looks better than anything else...

There is no evidence that 'gain of function' research was done at WIV on bat viruses. This is alleged but no evidence for this has been presented.

There is no evidence that the NIH funded 'gain of function' research on SARS-like viruses. This is alleged but no evidence for this has been presented.

Even if 'gain of function' research was carried out at WIV it could not have produced SARS-CoV-2. It is impossible for the proposed research to have produced SARS-CoV-2. If you do not understand why this is impossible then you need to read up on the virus and the proposed genetic manipulations.

You need to careful to distinguish claims that something might have happened or might have been done that are lacking in any evidence that they were done or happened, from evidence that something happened. A claim is not evidence.
 
Last edited:
The House committee is not just politics. The House was able to get an unredacted version of the 2-1-2020 email from Fauci, to others that are at a greater level than Andersen, admitting that Wuhan University was performing Gain-of-Function. Fauci, under oath, said there was no GOF... he did not provide any qualifiers such as "... we don't perform GOF but the Wuhan University does..." He never said anything along that line, he just said NIH weren't doing this process.

Why did Fauci have that email redacted? No pangolin has been found but we have GOF being conducted on bat viruses in the same city where the pandemic started therefore the "nature" hypothesis looks better than anything else...

I'm not sure what you are trying to say here. Fauci stated correctly that specific research wasn't gain of function.

Gain of Function research is important for anticipating future pandemics and developing targets for vaccines. It's performed in the US and elsewhere for these reasons. The research Fauci was discussing, however, was DID NOT involve GoF nor is there any evidence GoF research played any role in the origin of Covid
 
Last edited:
The House committee is not just politics.

Okay, well I was told it was.

The House was able to get an unredacted version of the 2-1-2020 email from Fauci, to others that are at a greater level than Andersen, admitting that Wuhan University was performing Gain-of-Function. Fauci, under oath, said there was no GOF... he did not provide any qualifiers such as "... we don't perform GOF but the Wuhan University does..." He never said anything along that line, he just said NIH weren't doing this process.

Do you mind finding the specific quotes here and show how there was some contradiction?

My understanding is that he was asked about what the NIH was funding. He cannot be held accountable for everything the WIV does, so he would hardly make any claims such as categorically denying the WIV conducts GoF. The only thing in his area that he could speak to was whether or not the NIH was funding proposals for gain of function. Rand Paul argued that certain papers fell under that definition, and Fauci argued that the specific research was judged NOT to be gain of function.

Why did Fauci have that email redacted?

What do you mean about Fauci having the email redacted? Was that his doing?

No pangolin has been found but we have GOF being conducted on bat viruses in the same city where the pandemic started therefore the "nature" hypothesis looks better than anything else...

"No pangolin has been found" is a red herring. It seems that the point here was that certain pangolin viruses had similar features to SARS-CoV2 which changed the calculation that some of the scientists had initially made about whether or not such a virus could be natural or engineered.

I earlier posted a link to Andersen's twitter thread in which he lays out the timeline of the changing estimates for the virus being natural or engineered.

My understanding is that initially the FCS and RBD looked highly unlikely to be natural and could have been engineered. Then investigation into it showed that there were no obvious signs of engineering. After that, there were no obvious clues for the FCS being inserted, and that the various methods that the WIV might have used for GoF either through engineering or serial passaging would not have led to the virus they were looking at. Also, there was no known progenitor virus available that could have been turned into SARS-CoV2.

In other words, as far as I understand, the WIV would have had to be using a virus that is otherwise not known to anyone, inserting an FCS that is not known to anyone, or using cell-lines unknown to anyone. The combination of unknowns is what makes this implausible, from what I understand.

On the other hand, it could have been a natural virus that got into the wild animal trade and ended up in a market which is known to have been the site of most of the earliest infections.
 
Here is a Twitter thread in which an anonymous account is arguing that the DEFUSE proposal could never have become SARS-CoV2.

It sounds fine to me, but maybe someone like Capsid could weigh in... if you don't mind. :D

Link
 
Okay, well I was told it was.



Do you mind finding the specific quotes here and show how there was some contradiction?

My understanding is that he was asked about what the NIH was funding. He cannot be held accountable for everything the WIV does, so he would hardly make any claims such as categorically denying the WIV conducts GoF. The only thing in his area that he could speak to was whether or not the NIH was funding proposals for gain of function. Rand Paul argued that certain papers fell under that definition, and Fauci argued that the specific research was judged NOT to be gain of function.



What do you mean about Fauci having the email redacted? Was that his doing?



"No pangolin has been found" is a red herring. It seems that the point here was that certain pangolin viruses had similar features to SARS-CoV2 which changed the calculation that some of the scientists had initially made about whether or not such a virus could be natural or engineered.

I earlier posted a link to Andersen's twitter thread in which he lays out the timeline of the changing estimates for the virus being natural or engineered.

My understanding is that initially the FCS and RBD looked highly unlikely to be natural and could have been engineered. Then investigation into it showed that there were no obvious signs of engineering. After that, there were no obvious clues for the FCS being inserted, and that the various methods that the WIV might have used for GoF either through engineering or serial passaging would not have led to the virus they were looking at. Also, there was no known progenitor virus available that could have been turned into SARS-CoV2.

In other words, as far as I understand, the WIV would have had to be using a virus that is otherwise not known to anyone, inserting an FCS that is not known to anyone, or using cell-lines unknown to anyone. The combination of unknowns is what makes this implausible, from what I understand.

On the other hand, it could have been a natural virus that got into the wild animal trade and ended up in a market which is known to have been the site of most of the earliest infections.

I'd reverse the wording a bit and say that investigation showed obvious signs of no engineering. Eg the nucleotides that make up the FCS are out of frame, something that wouldn't happen if it were engineered.
 
I'm not sure what you are trying to say here. Fauci stated correctly that specific research wasn't gain of function.
Gain of Function research is important for anticipating future pandemics and developing targets for vaccines. It's performed in the US and elsewhere for these reasons. The research Fauci was discussing, however, was DID NOT involve GoF nor is there any evidence GoF research played any role in the origin of Covid


Of course it was, and factually so. And he admitted it right before he...
He literally changed the words. The actual 'gain of function' words.
He IS the SCIENCE!!!

(but he also lied to all of us to manipulate public opinion. Also, factually so!)

ok. Thats all.
 
Ah, okay, so here he does say in his email that the WIV was known to be conducting gain of function research.

Link

It is true that he should have disclosed that, but this is not what he was asked. He was asked if the NIH funded GoF research, which he said no to.
 
Ah, okay, so here he does say in his email that the WIV was known to be conducting gain of function research.

Link

It is true that he should have disclosed that, but this is not what he was asked. He was asked if the NIH funded GoF research, which he said no to.

That is not a new email. As for who funded what, good grief it's all covered in this thread, ad nauseum.

The NIH stopped some GoF research funding, made a bunch of exceptions for ongoing work, did not approve of Daszak's 2018 grant proposal, the WIV almost certainly found other funding and just in the last month the US resumed all the GoF research they'd previously stopped funding.

Why does this red herring matter? Fauci claimed the NIH never funded GoF research, then admitted that wasn't true.

End of that aspect of the origin debate.
 
There is no evidence that 'gain of function' research was done at WIV on bat viruses. This is alleged but no evidence for this has been presented.

Fauci says Wuhan were investigating GoF on bat viruses. You've just seen that email, right?
Do you disagree with Fauci, and if so why are you in a better position to know more than him?
 
Of course it was,

This has been discussed in depth already. The research in question WAS NOT gain of function.

Ah, okay, so here he does say in his email that the WIV was known to be conducting gain of function research.



They are professional virologists working in a level 4 lab, it'd be surprising if they didn't do GoF research at some point. The relevant question is whether this could have played any role in the pandemic, and the clear answer is no. Covids closely related wild relatives don't need any alteration to be infectious to humans. There is also no known virus GoF could have acted on to create Covid.
 
Fauci says Wuhan were investigating GoF on bat viruses. You've just seen that email, right?
Do you disagree with Fauci, and if so why are you in a better position to know more than him?

This letter was from Feb 2020 long before there was any report on what GoF research had occurred where. This is the logical equivalent of 9-11 Truthers claiming that announcements that tower 7 "proves" a conspiracy because the news media announced it's collapse before the collapse actually occurred.

The fact is that early information is often inaccurate, and the fact that in Feb 2020 Fauci thought there may be GoF research occurring in Wuhan doesn't mean this is actually the case.


This whole discussion really belongs in the CT forum because there is no scintific basis for suggesting GoF had anything to do with Covid. In fact it's just the opposite, Covid was almost certainty already infectious to humans and there is no known virus that could give rise to Covid via GoF. If GoF couldn't be performed and Covid didn't need it anyway the logical conclusion is that it's irrelevant to the discussion.
 
Fauci says Wuhan were investigating GoF on bat viruses. You've just seen that email, right?
Do you disagree with Fauci, and if so why are you in a better position to know more than him?

You do understand this is an email sent at the start of the Covid-19 pandemic. No one even Fauci knew much about SARS-CoV-2 or Covid-19. Fauci was the director of NIH, not WIV. If the director of WIV expressed an opinion about research in an NIH laboratory how seriously would you take that? Fauci is not a coronavirus virologist he has no particular expertise in the area, we probably all know more about SARS-CoV-2 now than Fauci did then. There is no evidence to support his statement. I have said before opinions are not evidence.

I have said 'gain of function' is used perjoratively. If people did GoF research they are bad people, if Chinese did GoF research then they must have caused a pandemic. There is a definition of GoF research and as Alisa Chan said if genetic manipulation was done on a naturally occurring virus then this is not GoF research. We are best to avoid the term. It adds nothing. Just talk about the actual research done. My view is that none of the research done by WIV meets the strict definition of GoF research.

So with the advantage of time, I would say Fauci was wrong and no GoF research was done in WIV. What research was done could not have produced SARS-CoV-2.
 
Last edited:
:rolleyes: So predictable.

At some point you might just need to give up that denial you are harboring.
 
Last edited:
Let's see what we have here to add what is already in the thread.

The US Government Sent Millions of Grant Dollars to Alleged COVID ‘Patient Zero,' Documents Show

Yes yes, we know the sources have been dismissed while the latest US intelligence report was vague on the 3 sick WIV researchers. Keep in mind the FBI had a different finding the latest report did not override... but we've wasted enough thread space there, what's new here? The headline is an odd claim.

Interesting.
That the conversation on the origins of the virus is shifting from "preponderance of evidence" to "definitive answers" is itself evidence that we may be closer to answering the mystery of COVID's origins than many realize.


In November 2019, three lab researchers from the Wuhan Institute of Virology in China became severely ill, according to a U.S. intelligence report obtained by the Wall Street Journal in 2021. The researchers, whose identities were not disclosed, became so sick they were hospitalized, the report stated.
That report was contemporary to the actual event as opposed to 3 years after the fact.


The timing of the event is noteworthy. The three lab workers, the Journal noted, were hospitalized in November 2019, "roughly when many epidemiologists and virologists believe SARS-CoV-2, the virus behind the pandemic, first began circulating around the central Chinese city of Wuhan."

Two years later, the identities of the three lab workers allegedly hospitalized were revealed. US government sources identified the three lab researchers as Ben Hu, Yu Ping, and Yan Zhu, according to recent reporting from Michael Shellenberger, Matt Taibbi, and Alex Gutentag in Public.

The Atlantic notes the "extraordinary" nature of the findings, if true. ...
But gee, we can surely dismiss anything published in the Intercept. :rolleyes:


Except here's the problem, corroborating evidence.
"These proposed patient SARS-CoV-zeroes aren't merely employees of the virology institute; they're central figures in the very sort of research that lab-leak investigators have been scrutinizing since the start of the pandemic," writes Daniel Engber. "Their names appear on crucial papers related to the discovery of new, SARS-related coronaviruses in bats, and subsequent experimentation on those viruses."

Hu's name is especially important. The man many are dubbing "patient zero" didn't just work at the Wuhan Institute of Virology. According to documents published by the White Coat Waste Project obtained via a FOIA request, Hu was receiving US grant money to perform gain-of-function research on coronaviruses.
That sure sounds like a grant funded by the US (USAID & the NIAID) which specifically noted Hu as the lead researcher to carry out GoF research on SARS-related CoVs. And that research was being carried out in BSL2 at the time, not level3 not level4.

What utter nonsense to keep clinging to an unsupportable belief that somehow one could not get to COVID from this research. It's spelled out in plain language in the grants.

From the grant copy imaged right there in the article:
Pathogenicity Studies of two novel bat SARS-r CoVs on transgenic mice expressing human ACE2
Purpose:
Understanding the risk of bat coronavirus emergence
Funny that, it's exactly what Daszak said in his interview at the Nipah conference just before it was realized the virus had emerged.

"The funding came in three grants totaling $41 million, doled out by USAID and the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, or NIAID, the agency then headed by Dr. Anthony Fauci," the Intercept reports. "Hu is listed as an investigator on the grants."


Interesting:
And then there's the fact that unreleased intelligence reportedly says the sick lab workers lost their sense of smell-one of the telltale signs of COVID.
I suppose someone just made that up.:cool:


I dunno, let's read on:
"That doesn't medically prove that they had COVID but that's some pretty specific symptoms," Josh Rogin of the Washington Post noted in an interview with Bari Weiss.

Finally, as Science notes, Hu is an "appealing suspect" because he "was a lead author on a 2017 paper in PLOS Pathogens describing an experiment that created chimeric viruses by combining genes for surface proteins from bat coronaviruses that would not grow in cultures with the genome of one that did. This paper has received intense scrutiny because it was partially funded by the U.S. National Institutes of Health (NIH) … ."
A link to that paper is posted in this thread.


Of course Hu and the WIV deny everything.
"Denials of culpability and dismissals of evidence by a likely culpable person cannot be taken at face value," said Rutgers Professor Richard H. Ebright, a molecular biologist.
Oh, how can we possibly doubt Hu's, Shi's and Daszak's denials, don't look at those grants and published papers, that's not evidence they're lying.

Why would Fauci lie? Why would anyone lie?
There's little reason to believe the Chinese government would be forthcoming if their investigation determined they were responsible for COVID-19. Similarly, there's little reason to believe the US government, which was funding China's coronavirus research, would be eager to get to the truth either.

Let's not forget there was a serious effort by the US government to prevent Americans from even openly speculating about the lab-leak theory. In February 2021, almost certainly at the behest of federal agencies, which were working with social media platforms to combat COVID "misinformation," Facebook announced it would remove posts that suggested "COVID-19 is man-made or manufactured." Months later, after it became widely accepted that the lab-leak theory was not "a crackpot idea" after all, Facebook was forced to backtrack.


Just to be clear, lying to cover one's ass, and moves like Daszak misleading the WHO team or this other stuff about making the lab leak hypothesis look like a CT, all of which is well documented in this thread, does not make all this a CT. There is a difference whether people choose to recognize it or not. And if you read the initial Fauci/Andersen/et al emails (also cited in the thread) they clearly say to be careful with the implications of their discussions.


This was obvious.
... a similar Frankenstein-like hubris that lurks in gain-of-function research-which NIH continued to pursue despite warnings and pauses.
 
Last edited:
That report was contemporary to the actual event as opposed to 3 years after the fact.

It's also WRONG. It claims the timing of the illnesses "matches when epidemiologists think Covid was first circulating. Actual epidemiologists, however, say that's much to early to expect 3 hospitalizations given the timeline of other cases and how quickly Covid spreads.


Except here's the problem, corroborating evidence.

You're "corroborating evidence tells us this isn't GoF and isn't work that has any possibility of giving rise to Covid. Frankly it's more like proof your claim is false.


Of course Hu and the WIV deny everything.

Can you take the CT stuff to the CT forum. Hu has denied the rumors he had Covid in Nov, the fact that you refuse to believe him because he's a scientist who does research on Corona viruses is classic CT.


Just to be clear, lying to cover one's ass, and moves like Daszak misleading the WHO team

Again, the fact that you refuse to believe anyone with actual first hand knowledge "because they were involved" is classic CT. Please take all such accusations to the CT forums


Why would Fauci lie?

Again, classic CT. You believe Fauci when you want to then call him a liar when gives facts that you don't like.
 
This has been discussed in depth already. The research in question WAS NOT gain of function.





They are professional virologists working in a level 4 lab, it'd be surprising if they didn't do GoF research at some point. The relevant question is whether this could have played any role in the pandemic, and the clear answer is no. Covids closely related wild relatives don't need any alteration to be infectious to humans. There is also no known virus GoF could have acted on to create Covid.

This letter was from Feb 2020 long before there was any report on what GoF research had occurred where. This is the logical equivalent of 9-11 Truthers claiming that announcements that tower 7 "proves" a conspiracy because the news media announced it's collapse before the collapse actually occurred.

The fact is that early information is often inaccurate, and the fact that in Feb 2020 Fauci thought there may be GoF research occurring in Wuhan doesn't mean this is actually the case.


This whole discussion really belongs in the CT forum because there is no scintific basis for suggesting GoF had anything to do with Covid. In fact it's just the opposite, Covid was almost certainty already infectious to humans and there is no known virus that could give rise to Covid via GoF. If GoF couldn't be performed and Covid didn't need it anyway the logical conclusion is that it's irrelevant to the discussion.

Indeed.

There are two ways of looking at Fauci's role.

1.) he is a primarily an adminstrator who relies on underlings for specific detailed information as most people in his positions. It was of course known that the WIV was there in the city, and that they did work on coronaviruses. Given that at that stage of the pandemic, they were rightly concerned it could have come from a lab. One of the papers that began fears of engineering was claiming HIV inserts, for example. The GoF arguments had been a long-running issue with people like Richard Ebright and others. Questions of whether or not the work was gain of function depend on a specific definition which opponents dislike.

2.) Fauci is a master criminal orchestrating a massive cover-up of his own role by offering bribes to (in Richard Ebright's words) "stooges" and "scum".
 
Indeed.

There are two ways of looking at Fauci's role.

1.) he is a primarily an adminstrator who relies on underlings for specific detailed information as most people in his positions. It was of course known that the WIV was there in the city, and that they did work on coronaviruses. Given that at that stage of the pandemic, they were rightly concerned it could have come from a lab. One of the papers that began fears of engineering was claiming HIV inserts, for example. The GoF arguments had been a long-running issue with people like Richard Ebright and others. Questions of whether or not the work was gain of function depend on a specific definition which opponents dislike.

2.) Fauci is a master criminal orchestrating a massive cover-up of his own role by offering bribes to (in Richard Ebright's words) "stooges" and "scum".
Your false dichotomies are so creative.

You think Fauci as the NIAID director wasn't aware who the organization was awarding millions of dollars to? Do you imagine Fauci never sat in on meetings reviewing grant proposals? Or that he wasn't involved in the decisions the stop funding GoF research, who would be granted exceptions, and the decision to reinstate GoF funding grants?

Wouldn't such big organization decisions be something the director was personally involved in?


Edited to add, Fauci himself took back his initial assertion the NIH/NIAID never funded GoF research. Did you miss that?

Email Shows Fauci Privately Acknowledged Gain-Of-Function Research At Wuhan Lab
In an email to U.S. government public health officials in February 2020, Fauci wrote that “scientists in the Wuhan University are known to have been working on gain-of-function experiments … associated with bat viruses adapting to human infection,” according to an image of the document tweeted by the House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus. The email reveals that Fauci knew of the Wuhan Institute of Virology’s research into coronaviruses that mirrored COVID-19 prior to his claim that there was no evidence that the virus was produced in a laboratory.
 
Last edited:
To review:

New emails reveal that Dr. Fauci was aware of risky gain-of-function research occurring in Wuhan, China prior to the emergence of COVID-19.
Click on the Tweet for an enlargement of the email if you still have access to Twitter.
Fauci also wrote that “there were mutations in the virus that would be most unusual to have evolved naturally in the bats and that there was a suspicion that this mutation was intentionally inserted.” He claimed this was the conclusion of international physicians following a conference call on Feb. 1, 2020 — after which they wrote a now-controversial “proximal origins” paper that claimed the virus emerged naturally.


How long is the denial going to last in this thread before the evidence is honestly addressed?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom