Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Has inserting a furin cleavage site (FCS) into SARS-like CoVs been done and if so what happened? The point of this post is to document it was possible Shi and Daszak, being top virologists studying SARS-like CoVs, certainly had the capability of inserting those 12 nucleotides of the FCS into a SARS-like CoV and it wouldn't necessarily be detectable. And yes, I am repeating stuff already discussed in the thread as the evidence coalesces.

2022 The Emergence of the Spike Furin Cleavage Site in SARS-CoV-2; Yujia Alina Chan (1) and Shing Hei Zhan (2)
Focusing on CoVs, several groups have shown that introducing a cleavage site to enable promiscuous cleavage of the spike by different proteases can boost viral entry in different cell types. ...

... That same year, another group of scientists manipulated the S1/S2 FCS and a second cleavage site in the spikes of MERS-CoV and a MERS-related virus to show that these could enable the MERS-related CoV spike to become activated by human proteases and mediate viral entry into human cells (Yang et al. 2015). Scientists have also been introducing FCSs into the spike of SARS-CoV to gain a better understanding of how an additional FCS can alter membrane fusion and reliance on cellular proteases (Follis et al. 2006; Belouzard et al. 2009).
So it wasn't a novel technique to insert an FCS into a SARS-like CoV.

The Difficulty of Determining the Origin of the SARS-CoV-2 FCS

Jack Nunberg, whose group first inserted an S1/S2 FCS into the spike of SARS-CoV, said: “there is no way to know whether humans or nature inserted the site” in SARS-CoV-2 (Cyranoski 2020). ...
A group led by Gary Whittaker later showed that a substitution was sufficient when combined with the introduction of another FCS at the S2 region; this experiment in SARS-CoV was inspired by the observation of a similar setup in IBV strain Beaudette, which has efficient cleavage at both S1/S2 and S2’ (Belouzard et al. 2009). Whittaker recently (August 2021) published a comment describing the SARS-CoV-2 FCS as “highly unusual” (Whittaker 2021).
In September 2021, it was reported that an international group of scientists (including from the Wuhan Institute of Virology) had, in March 2018, proposed a roadmap for detecting novel proteolytic cleavage sites (including FCSs) in the spike sequences of novel sarbecoviruses and inserting these novel cleavage sites into the appropriate parental strain (Daszak 2018; Lerner and Hibbett 2021).
The virologist David Baltimore commented that “these features make a powerful challenge to the idea of a natural origin for SARS2,” later clarifying that “you can't distinguish between the two origins from just looking at the sequence” (Caltech Weekly 2021).
Therefore, an S1/S2 FCS emerging in a sarbecovirus is consistent with natural evolution. ...
I certainly don't deny this despite it's been missed by some reading my posts. The problem is, if the origin could be natural or from a lab one has to then look at the other evidence.

... Even so, the knowledge that scientists had a workflow for identifying novel cleavage sites in diverse SARSr-CoVs and experimentally characterizing these cleavage sites in SARSr-CoVs—likely in a manner that makes the resulting recombinant SARSr-CoV practically indistinguishable from a rare SARSr-CoV with a naturally emerging FCS—makes it challenging to rule out an artificial origin of the SARS-CoV-2 S1/S2 FCS (Daszak 2018; Lerner and Hibbett 2021).
 
Has inserting a furin cleavage site (FCS) into SARS-like CoVs been done and if so what happened? The point of this post is to document it was possible Shi and Daszak, being top virologists studying SARS-like CoVs, certainly had the capability of inserting those 12 nucleotides of the FCS into a SARS-like CoV and it wouldn't necessarily be detectable. And yes, I am repeating stuff already discussed in the thread as the evidence coalesces.

Please keep up to date on the literature. It's 4 nucleotides, still inserted out of frame. Top virologists would not have made the mistake of an out of frame insertion. Even beginner virologists would not make this error.

So it wasn't a novel technique to insert an FCS into a SARS-like CoV.

If they were using established techniques they would have inserted a full cleavage site based on the ones found in other viruses. They would have no way to know that these 4 nucleotides inserted out of frame would create a partial furin cleavage site so why would they bother to do such a thing?
 
Kristian Andersen's testimony in response to lazy and idiotic claims that he is part of a conspiracy to cover-up the lab leak.

Worth reading ahead of the forthcoming witch trial.

No doubt it will be extensively quote-mined with decontextualized passages held up as evidence that he and Fauci and Collins for reasons too complicated for anyone to fathom, were involved in wanting to cover-up the lab leak. :rolleyes:
 
Kristian Andersen's testimony in response to lazy and idiotic claims that he is part of a conspiracy to cover-up the lab leak.

Worth reading ahead of the forthcoming witch trial.

No doubt it will be extensively quote-mined with decontextualized passages held up as evidence that he and Fauci and Collins for reasons too complicated for anyone to fathom, were involved in wanting to cover-up the lab leak. :rolleyes:
Who said he was part of a CT coverup? No one in this thread. And we are not in the USA politics sub-forum.

There are lots of idiotic people claiming CTs re COVID origins. I specifically asked posts be sorted into the relevant sub-forums.

There are some people covering a few things up.
Daszak and Shi because they have a lot to lose
The Chinese government
Fauci was embarrassed any funding was tied to the NIH grants
​
Those can be sorted by citing supporting evidence which is what I've done. Extensive quote mining of the GOP House Oversight Committee does not belong in this thread.

Why do people keep insisting on bringing CT crap into the thread? No evidence based arguments, no worries, just throw ad hominems out and hope no one notices the lack of substance? :boggled:

Why are people so intent on supporting the spillover origin hypothesis instead of following the evidence? That's really the problem here.

ETA: Why don't you get ahead of the game and quote what you think is relevant out of Andersen's written testimony? I appreciate the link and will take a closer look myself.
 
Last edited:
There are some people covering a few things up.
Daszak and Shi because they have a lot to lose

​

So you just accuse people of something, then insist they must be covering it up because they "have a lot to lose" if the accusations are true?

You know this is classic CT right?


The Chinese government
​

As previously discussed the biggest thing the Chinese government wants to cover up are live animal markets and their inaction on shutting them down.


Fauci was embarrassed any funding was tied to the NIH grants
​

WTF. And you claim not to be influenced by the anti-vax crowd...

The NIH grants are irrelevant. Nothing in those proposals could possibly give rise to the Covid pandemic.
 
Last edited:
Who said he was part of a CT coverup? f.

The House Committee he is being hauled in front of. It is literally called “the Proximal Origins Cover-up”.

He is accused in the title of being part of a cover-up.

Whether you support that or not that is what is being alleged.
 
Kristian Andersen's testimony in response to lazy and idiotic claims that he is part of a conspiracy to cover-up the lab leak.

There are lots of idiotic people claiming CTs re COVID origins. I specifically asked posts be sorted into the relevant sub-forums.

There are some people covering a few things up.
Daszak and Shi because they have a lot to lose
The Chinese government
Fauci was embarrassed any funding was tied to the NIH grants
​
Those can be sorted by citing supporting evidence which is what I've done. Extensive quote mining of the GOP House Oversight Committee does not belong in this thread.


If claiming that Fauci is "covering a few things up" is appropriate for this thread, then rebuttals to such claims are also appropriate for this thread.

From Dr Anderson's written testimony before the Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic, with formatting as in the original:
Kristian G. Andersen said:
Importantly, on a January 31, 2020 call with Dr. Fauci, where I first outlined my concerns, he told me (I am paraphrasing, as I do not remember the exact words): "if you think this virus came from a lab, you should write a scientific paper on it". Not only is this not a 'prompt' to "disprove the lab leak theory", it was specifically predicated on our initial hypothesis, which was that of a "lab leak". Dr. Fauci followed up with an email that clearly shows how seriously he took my early concerns:
[size=-1]Fri, Jan 31, 2020 at 4:38 PM[/size]​
Jeremy:

I just got off the phone with Kristian Anderson and he related to me his concern about the Furine site mutation in the spike protein of the currently circulating 2019-nCoV. I told him that as soon as possible he and Eddie Holmes should get a group of evolutionary biologists together to examine carefully the data to determine if his concerns are validated. He should do this very quickly and if everyone agrees with this concern, they should report it to the appropriate authorities. I would imagine that in the USA this would be the FBI and in the UK it would be MI5. It would be important to quickly get confirmation of the cause of his concern by experts in the field of coronaviruses and evolutionary biology. In the meantime, I will alert my US. Government official colleagues of my conversation with you and Kristian and determine what further investigation they recommend. Let us stay in touch.

Best regards,

Tony​
[size=-1]January 31, 2020 email From Dr. Fauci to Dr. Farrar with me in Cc.[/size]
 
The House Committee he is being hauled in front of. It is literally called “the Proximal Origins Cover-up”.

He is accused in the title of being part of a cover-up.

Whether you support that or not that is what is being alleged.

Yeah but that's ******* politics. Surely you can discern the difference between that crap and an evidence-based discussion/debate that belongs in this thread.

Maybe because you are in Japan you don't see the idiocy of the GOP marginally-controlled House in this country that are acting like idiots. That committee has nothing to do with an evidence-based discussion.

I've said more than once you tend to vacillate between reasonable discussion in this thread and going off-the-rails into distinctly not evidence-based assertions. Just take all that political and CT crap somewhere else. I want to discuss the science. I hope Capsid isn't gone because he has pointed out a number of scientific issues that led me to look for support or refutation of the evidence I had found.

I am not challenged to move this debate forward by comments like GoF is fear mongering or more than 5 years ago Shi was working on detectible chimeras with Baric. I am not challenged by naive assertions "we blah blah blah ...*" from people who have proven they do not (and I don't care what credentials they have) have relevant expertise in infectious disease.

*For example not recognizing the difference between a super spreader event and an outbreak.


Address the ******* evidence; lalalalala tune the rest of that **** out.

Much as you can get annoying (I'm sure I annoy you) you are one of the few people in this discussion who has intermittent periods of honest discussion.

Other people with very worthwhile contributions have been driven away because the discussion requires the cats be herded out of the building on a regular basis. I am reminded just how much those non-cats have to contribute when they do make a much appreciated appearance in the thread (Looking at you Sherkeu).


This is an important discussion. Surely the skeptical community can discuss the evidence-based issues while leaving out all the rest.
 
Last edited:
Yeah but that's ******* politics. Surely you can discern the difference between that crap and an evidence-based discussion/debate that belongs in this thread.

Maybe because you are in Japan you don't see the idiocy of the GOP marginally-controlled House in this country that are acting like idiots. That committee has nothing to do with an evidence-based discussion.

I've said more than once you tend to vacillate between reasonable discussion in this thread and going off-the-rails into distinctly not evidence-based assertions. Just take all that political and CT crap somewhere else. I want to discuss the science. I hope Capsid isn't gone because he has pointed out a number of scientific issues that led me to look for support or refutation of the evidence I had found.

I am not challenged to move this debate forward by comments like GoF is fear mongering or more than 5 years ago Shi was working on detectible chimeras with Baric. I am not challenged by naive assertions "we blah blah blah ...*" from people who have proven they do not (and I don't care what credentials they have) have relevant expertise in infectious disease.

*For example not recognizing the difference between a super spreader event and an outbreak.


Address the ******* evidence; lalalalala tune the rest of that **** out.

Much as you can get annoying (I'm sure I annoy you) you are one of the few people in this discussion who has intermittent periods of honest discussion.

Other people with very worthwhile contributions have been driven away because the discussion requires the cats be herded out of the building on a regular basis. I am reminded just how much those non-cats have to contribute when they do make a much appreciated appearance in the thread.


This is an important discussion. Surely the skeptical community can discuss the evidence-based issues while leaving out all the rest.

If you don't like it, don't read it. Ignore it if you like, or report it. But it is completely on topic and I'm not posting just for your sake.

The fact that you and sherkeu have consistently implied that scientists who have produced papers on the origins of Covid are part of a cover-up completly undermines your claims that nobody is calling this a CT.

Oh, speaking of which, have you finished that Huff book yet? Did you actually find anything of value from that particular overt conspiracy theorist who has literally called for the hanging of people like Fauci and Daszak?
 
If you don't like it, don't read it. Ignore it if you like, or report it. But it is completely on topic and I'm not posting just for your sake.
If you think I said the link to Andersen's written testimony was off-topic, you didn't read what I said. It's the absurd House Oversight Committee that is off-topic. Comer is an idiot. What comes out of the committee's hearing is not evidence, it is politics.
Did your eyes just gaze right past what I said about Andersen's written submission to the committee or did you not see it because I edited to add the comment?
SG said:
ETA: Why don't you get ahead of the game and quote what you think is relevant out of Andersen's written testimony? I appreciate the link and will take a closer look myself.
Should I make that in giant font? :rolleyes:


The fact that you and sherkeu have consistently implied that scientists who have produced papers on the origins of Covid are part of a cover-up completly undermines your claims that nobody is calling this a CT.
Here's an example of the problem. You read all sorts of things into what has actually been posted. If you would quote people when you assert they said something that would be helpful.

On several occasions I have repeated the following:
SG said:
There are some people covering a few things up.
Daszak and Shi because they have a lot to lose
The Chinese government
Fauci was embarrassed any funding was tied to the NIH grants​
That is a far cry from your false assertion that I or anyone else in the thread has:
angrysoba said:
... consistently implied that scientists who have produced papers on the origins of Covid are part of a cover-up
Don't blame me for your fantasy. Either quote what I said that backs up your false assertion, or admit you can find no such quote that even remotely says any such thing.

angrysoba said:
Oh, speaking of which, have you finished that Huff book yet? Did you actually find anything of value from that particular overt conspiracy theorist who has literally called for the hanging of people like Fauci and Daszak?
At this point so far the first 2/3 of the book is about his history and credentials.
 
SG you are simultaneously saying you don't want me to post about the House Committee hearing because it is politics or CT and should be in its relevant sub-forum, then, in the very same post (as an ETA) thanking me for posting it.

That doesn't make a lot of sense.

Again, you can read it, ignore it or report it. I don't care which you do as I am not going to get involved in an impossible argument.
 
SG you are simultaneously saying you don't want me to post about the House Committee hearing because it is politics or CT and should be in its relevant sub-forum, then, in the very same post (as an ETA) thanking me for posting it.

That doesn't make a lot of sense.

Again, you can read it, ignore it or report it. I don't care which you do as I am not going to get involved in an impossible argument.
I said post about what Andersen submitted in his written testimony.

I will add here for clarification, post whatever evidence-based comments he's making.

I said the politics of the hearing itself is not evidence based. The GOP Oversight Committee hearing is a joke and it is most definitely not about any evidence.
 
There are lots of idiotic people claiming CTs re COVID origins. I specifically asked posts be sorted into the relevant sub-forums.
then please stop posting things like this:
There are some people covering a few things up.
Daszak and Shi because they have a lot to lose
The Chinese government
Fauci was embarrassed any funding was tied to the NIH grants
​

This is content that belongs in the CT forum and you need to leave it there.
 
This is an interesting thread on how the thinking of the Proximal Origins authors' thinking evolved.

https://twitter.com/K_G_Andersen/status/1679281345342865408?s=20

What this demonstrates is that a laboratory origin was seriously considered initially, but that after considering the evidence then available they concluded anatural origin was most likely.

I think he makes a good comparison with how the science around anthropgenic global warming and climate change was politicised, with the scientists being attacked rather than the science.
 
The House committee is not just politics. The House was able to get an unredacted version of the 2-1-2020 email from Fauci, to others that are at a greater level than Andersen, admitting that Wuhan University was performing Gain-of-Function. Fauci, under oath, said there was no GOF... he did not provide any qualifiers such as "... we don't perform GOF but the Wuhan University does..." He never said anything along that line, he just said NIH weren't doing this process.

Why did Fauci have that email redacted? No pangolin has been found but we have GOF being conducted on bat viruses in the same city where the pandemic started therefore the "nature" hypothesis looks better than anything else...
 
What this demonstrates is that a laboratory origin was seriously considered initially, but that after considering the evidence then available they concluded anatural origin was most likely.

How can you "conclude" on a "most likely"? Is this the lost lost cousin to "most likely maybe"? And when exactly after the outbreak did the science community come up with this conclusion?
 
How can you "conclude" on a "most likely"? Is this the lost lost cousin to "most likely maybe"? And when exactly after the outbreak did the science community come up with this conclusion?
They considered a number of scenarios; given the features of SARS-CoV-2 the group of evolutionary geneticists who wrote the paper concluded the most likely scenario was a natural cross over event / zoonotic origin. If you read the paper, then you will see how they came to that conclusion. If you think that the 'science community' comes up with any conclusions you misunderstand science. If you do not understand what 'most likely' means I cannot help you. I admit I do not understand what 'most likely maybe' means. 'Most likely' is not an exclusionary statement, it is if you hear hoofbeats think horse not zebra (unless you are in the Serengetti), and to think Unicorn would need pretty strong supportive evidence.

If you read the intelligence reports and analyses the suggestion that SARS-CoV-2 was the product of biowarfare research is a Unicorn. That SARS-CoV-2 was synthesised in the laboratory is pretty close to being a Unicorn, there is no known precursor virus and no one had the knowledge to create SARS-CoV-2 (having the technology to do something is different from having the knowledge to create something). That SARS-CoV-2 was a natural virus imported into a laboratory that subsequently escaped is a zebra, certainly possible, but lacking evidence. That SARS-CoV-2 was a natural cross over event is the most likely because that is what has happened multiple times previously. SARS, Ebola, MERS, Nipah, mPox, Flu, plague, HIV etc. Also because a natural cross over event by a coronavirus was expected, a new flu was thought slightly more likely as the next pandemic event, but a novel corona virus most likely from China, was second on the list.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom