Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Interview with Caltech's David Baltimore, president emeritus and Distinguished Professor of Biology, is a virologist who received the Nobel Prize for his research into viral genetics. ...

... Similar viruses before it have been shown to have jumped from animals to humans; yet this link has not yet been definitively found for SARS-CoV-2. ...
David Baltimore did not say that. Those are the words of the journalist Lori Dajose who interviewed David Baltimore.

Here are some of the actual words spoken by David Baltimore in that interview that Skeptic Ginger, in her cherry-picking, chose to omit:

Let me be clear, even though I used the phrase "smoking gun," I don't really think there's a smoking gun in the genome itself....

So where did it come from in SARS-CoV-2? There are other viruses that have furin cleavage sites, other coronaviruses, though not the family of beta-coronaviruses. So this sequence's nucleotides could have hopped from some other virus. No one has identified a virus that has exactly this sequence, but it could have come from something close, then evolved into the sequence that we see today....

More context:
Here’s the problem: Baltimore regrets using the phrase “smoking gun” to describe his conclusion, and doesn’t agree that it validates the lab-leak theory.

Baltimore told me by email that he made the statement to Wade, also by email, and granted him permission to use it in print. But he added that he “should have softened the phrase ‘smoking gun’ because I don’t believe that it proves the origin of the furin cleavage site but it does sound that way. I believe that the question of whether the sequence was put in naturally or by molecular manipulation is very hard to determine but I wouldn’t rule out either origin.”



Argument from ignorance by old white man.
Well, this 85-year-old man did win a Nobel Prize when he was 37 years old.

At the age of 48, however, he co-authored a paper with Thereza Imanishi-Kari and others that appears to have been fraudulent. At first, Baltimore refused to retract the paper and defended Imanishi-Kari's research. Baltimore eventually apologized, but the scandal led Baltimore to resign as president of Rockefeller University. One of the multiple investigations cleared Baltimore of misconduct but concluded the paper "is rife with errors of all sorts...some which, despite all these years and layers of review, have never previously been pointed out or corrected. Responsibility ... must be shared by all participants." So the guy is hardly infallible, and made well-publicized mistakes decades ago, when he was a much younger man.
 
Argument from ignorance by old white man.
An ignorant old white man? You mean this 'old' guy?
Caltech's David Baltimore, president emeritus and Distinguished Professor of Biology, is a virologist who received the Nobel Prize for his research into viral genetics.
He is old but not out of touch or suffering from negative mental aging. How can anyone have a reasonable discussion with you when you start with crap like that?


He says no beta coronaviruses have a Furin cleavage site therefore this is suspicious .
No, that's not what he said.

What Professor Baltimore actually did say which is why you should quote people and not paraphrase them:
I think we very much need to find out what was happening in the Wuhan Institute of Virology. I think that we can't say for sure yet whether the SARS-CoV-2 virus came from natural origins or if it was genetically manipulated somehow. ...

... Now, within the SARS-CoV-2 genome there is an insertion of 12 nucleotides that is entirely foreign to the beta-coronavirus class of virus that SARS-CoV-2 is in. There are many other viruses in this class, including the closest relative of SARS-CoV-2 by sequence, and none of them have this sequence. The sequence is called the furin cleavage site.
The interview was in June 2021 and your two links are more recent, 12/21 and 06/23. And as before there are still 2 competing hypotheses.

All the genetic components of COVID 19 have been found in the wild, And SARS-related CoVs are often the result of recombinant events. This is not new to this discussion.
This has been discussed in the thread, (you know, the one you haven't read).

We included a discussion of the possibility that rats might have been the intermediary species or they might have been involved in some way. One is looking at a recombinant event; one that still may or may not be distinguishable between natural evolution and lab created.


(I cleaned up your urls):
... this is invalidated by the subsequent discovery of a wild beta coronavirus with a Furin cleavage site.
It's not invalidated. The world is not so black and white.

First link:
Furin cleavage sites in the spike proteins of bat and rodent coronaviruses: Implications for virus evolution and zoonotic transfer from rodent species
... SARS-CoV-2, which is considered to be of bat origin, contains a cleavage site for the protease furin at S1/S2, absent from the rest of the currently known betacoronavirus lineage 2b coronaviruses (Sarbecoviruses). ...

... A notable difference between SARS-CoV-2 and RaTG13 (and all other Sarbecoviruses)is the insertion of a predicted cleavage site for a furin-like protease (P-R-R-A-R) between the S1/S2 regions of the spike protein of SARS-CoV-2 [[39], [40], [41]] with loss of this site associated with virus attenuation and decreased transmission [42,43]. ...
And with the addition of the nucleotides one finds increased virulence and transmission.

Utilizing two publicly available furin prediction algorithms (ProP and PiTou) and based on spike sequences reported in GenBank, we show that the S1/S2 furin cleavage site is typically not present in bat virus spike proteins but is common in rodent-associated sequences, and suggest this may have implications for zoonotic transfer. ...
Yep, we discussed the rat coronaviruses.

The second link was more definitive:
A novel bat coronavirus with a polybasic furin-like cleavage site
...The new beta CoV identified in this study is a distant relative of SARS-CoV-2 and harbors a polybasic furin-like cleavage site similar to SARS-CoV-2, strongly indicating that the SARS-CoV-2 furin cleavage site was naturally originated. How.
Just like the other components of COVID 19, still no direct precursor. Do you have a source showing a precursor virus in rodents in Yunnan or even in Wuhan that is a close relative of COVID-19? All the pieces can be found, but not in one precursor.


What was new in the discussion was Capsid bringing up the fact the furin cleavage site devolved rather than evolved when serially passed through VeroE6 cell cultures.
That's great because researchers can narrow the search now looking for a recombinant event or a lab insertion of the 12 nucleotides.


PG said:
This is a good review for various explanations of the origins on SARS-CoV-2.
https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/jvi.00365-23
At least two major hypotheses have been suggested: a natural origin through zoonosis followed by sustained human-to-human spread or the introduction of a natural virus into humans from a laboratory source. Here, we summarize the scientific evidence that informs this debate to provide our fellow scientists and the public with the tools to join the discussion in a constructive and informed manner. Our goal is to dissect the evidence to make it more accessible to those interested in this important problem. The engagement of a broad representation of scientists is critical to ensure that the public and policy-makers can draw on relevant expertise in navigating this controversy.

Got no argument there.

But I don't agree with this:
Since hypotheses 1 and 2 support the lab leak theory and hypotheses 3 and 4 are consistent with a zoonotic origin, the lab leak- and zoonotic-origin explanations are not equally probable, and the available evidence favors the latter. ...

... Science is also a key ally in addressing origin hypotheses. Given the currently available evidence, the two plausible possibilities for the origin of SARS-CoV-2 are not equally likely. Continuing to frame them as such does us all a disservice, dilutes our efforts, and misdirects resources—only serving to weaken our ability to respond to future pandemics.
It's not because we want someone to blame or that a natural occurrence is unsatisfying. It's because the lab origin hypothesis was initially swept under the rug and that doesn't lend itself to a science-based debate.
 
“But one must then ask how did COVID 19 acquire the furin cleavage site in the wild? And I'm not suggesting this counters the disappearance in serial passages I am however suggesting that serial passages might not have been the only thing being done to manipulate coronaviruses in the lab.”

I could imagine an infected rat was running around a raccoon dog farm and those raccoon dogs end up getting infected and end up in the fish market.

I'm not sure what manipulation that might be. The virus has to be cultured regardless, most labs were using Vero E6 before 2021.
 
Last edited:
“But one must then ask how did COVID 19 acquire the furin cleavage site in the wild? And I'm not suggesting this counters the disappearance in serial passages I am however suggesting that serial passages might not have been the only thing being done to manipulate coronaviruses in the lab.”

I could imagine an infected rat was running around a raccoon dog farm and those raccoon dogs end up getting infected and end up in the fish market.

I'm not sure what manipulation that might be. The virus has to be cultured regardless, most labs were using Vero E6 before 2021.

Thank you for sticking around because I would like to hear your response to a couple of things.

Yes a naturally occurring recombinant virus is certainly one possibility. The problem is no evidence can be found of a closely related virus progenitor circulating in rats, bats, raccoon dogs or any crossover species. It's possible, of course, that it was missed.

This is spelled out in detail in the WHO-convened Global Study of Origins of SARS-CoV-2 ... report on the search for the origin of the virus.

The WHO report makes the case for the pandemic to have started as early as Sept but most likely in Nov-Dec 2019 in Wuhan, China.


The report discussed the possible link to the seafood market.
No firm conclusion therefore about the role of the Huanan market in the origin of the outbreak, or how the infection was introduced into the market, can currently be drawn.
I have discussed my criticism of Worobey's epidemiological study in this thread.

The most recent release of the genetic analysis of swabbed specimens collected around the seafood market found genetic evidence of raccoon dogs and COVID 19 in one stall. However later comments noted the volume of COVID RNA was more consistent with contamination by humans shedding the virus around the market. It was not evidence raccoon dogs were infected with the virus. I posted the citation upthread.

So with no evidence of raccoon dogs carrying the virus in the market, that leaves a scenario of humans getting infected via rats directly? But there was no evidence of rats with a progenitor coronavirus. It's a bit of a stretch given bats were rarely if ever sold in that market. One cannot rule out that a recombinant event occurred in the market but then one would expect something more than hypothetical evidence that it was possible.

Rat specimens were collected by WIV teams at the caves. But that's hundreds of miles from the market.

Despite finding equivocal evidence, IMO, of a spillover or lab origin the report concluded:
The joint team’s assessment of likelihood of each possible pathway was as follows:
• direct zoonotic spillover is considered to be a possible-to-likely pathway;
• introduction through an intermediate host is considered to be a likely to very likely pathway;
• introduction through cold/ food chain products is considered a possible pathway;
• introduction through a laboratory incident was considered to be an extremely unlikely pathway.
It was at this point objections were raised by Tedros at the WHO and by other scientists that Daszak had a conflict of interest and unduly influenced the report. Tedros noted the lab origin was dismissed prior to any relative evidence even being collected. It was formally requested by members of the team that he not be allowed on the second team because of those conflicts of interest.

So far China has refused the second inspection team and has refused to release specific records (discussed ad nauseum with citations upthread).


As for live cultures at the WIV, wasn't that the point of using the humanized mice that Baric shipped to the WIV? And there is evidence live bats were also kept there.
If one wants more specific evidence, this is how Daszak worded the grant proposal after arguing certain manipulating of coronaviruses didn't constitute GoF, a semantic argument not worth having.

DARPA grant proposal 2018
We have now published direct evidence of spillover of novel SARSr-CoVs in people in Yunnan Province, China close to a cave complex where we have isolated strains that produce SARS-like disease in humanized mice but don't respond to antibodies or vaccination. ...
Clearly they have cultured SARSr CoVs in vivo in mice.

The plan in this proposal was to use SARSr-CoVs with recombinant spike proteins to infect bats in vivo in 3 caves (1 test cave; 2 control caves). So the plan was to mess around with the live cultures in Yunnan, not in Wuhan. How is releasing altered SARS-like CoV into the wild not crazy as hell?

The hubris here was Daszak drawing the untested conclusion they weren't making a more virulent coronavirus.
 
@SG. The mouse studies still need to start with a virus stock with which to infect the mice. This stock has to be titrated in the mice to determine the right amount to give them usually a does at which 50% are killed (LD50) or in this case where it infects 50%. The stock is grown in vitro and probably in Vero E6 cells.

Please help me with the Worobey study, how was the COVID RNA recovered from the market. RNA doesn't hang around long and I'm surprised any was found at all, it needs a special process to ensure it is able to be amplified by RT-PCR.

I'd need to read the grant proposal to understand why in vivo infection was considered ok.
 
About that furin cleavage insertion and the dishonesty of Daszak:
Real Clear Science: Has Peter Daszak Misled the Public?
On Sept. 30, a group of 10 scientists, historians, and other academics from around the world sent a letter calling for the ouster of Peter Daszak, a British zoologist, from his position as president of EcoHealth Alliance, a New York based nonprofit that works to thwart infectious disease outbreaks ... Soon after the Covid-19 pandemic began, Daszak led the charge in dismissing allegations that its viral cause, SARS-CoV-2, could have come from the lab.

The letter calling for his removal was addressed to EcoHealth's senior board members, top officials at the National Institutes of Health and the Department of Health and Human Services, and Daszak himself. It stated that Daszak, in his capacity as EcoHealth president, had “withheld critical information and misled public opinion by expressing falsehoods.” ...

While the "Paris group" remains a loose and apparently varying affiliation of researchers with no fixed membership, agenda, or constituency ... , experts associated with the title have been working since 2020 to influence the World Health Organization’s investigation of Covid origins. That process has been complicated from the start by a lack of access to crucial data from the Chinese government, and what the Paris group claims are unbalanced efforts to seek a zoonotic source for the pandemic that doesn’t fully consider competing scenarios. While scientists remain sharply divided over the plausibility of a lab leak versus a natural spillover, a leaked grant proposal, documents obtained under federal record act requests, and letters co-authored by Paris group members have raised questions about EcoHealth’s transparency and Daszak’s conflicts of interest ...

... Daszak sought to cast doubt on a lab leak, even as his comments and behaviors gave the impression that he was trying to deflect attention away from some of EcoHealth’s more controversial research in Wuhan. ...

Jamie Metzl, a nonresident senior fellow at the Atlantic Council, an international affairs think tank in Washington, D.C., a co-signer of the Paris group's letter, and a former member of the WHO’s expert advisory committee on human genome editing, counters that Daszak "leads this propaganda campaign, vilifying people who ask questions" that contradict a view that SARS-CoV-2 passed to humans from wildlife.


In January 2021, for instance, Daszak linked up with an investigative team convened by the WHO, which concluded after several weeks of hunting for evidence in Wuhan that a lab-related accident was "extremely unlikely." Noting that Chinese government officials had limited access to raw data, the WHO's director-general, Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, later recanted the team's conclusion, saying the push to rule out a lab-leak was premature.


Still, some continue to refer to those who suggest the possibility of a lab leak as conspiracy theorists, among them H. Holden Thorp, Science’s editor-in-chief, who used the term in a Nov. 11 editorial.

Scientists affiliated with EcoHealth and the Wuhan Institute of Virology experimented with dangerous bat coronaviruses in the years before Covid-19 arrived, and had at least proposed experiments that would alter the properties of such viruses to potentially make them better able to infect humans.


Did Daszak get caught in a lie? Yes, more than once then he made excuses about them. Who wouldn't? That's a natural response when one is caught in a lie.
For example, it cites a December, 2020 tweet in which the EcoHealth president claimed the Chinese labs he worked with had never kept live bats, even though by the Wuhan scientists’ own accounts, live bats were present at the facility since at least 2009, and that lab personnel had filed patents to breed the animals. That Daszak disputed what is so clearly evident in the records, Demaneuf says, "means there is an issue about his reliability.” (According to the Science article, Daszak has since admitted he was misinformed about the presence of bats in the facility.)
Of course he knew there were live bats at the WIV, that was his job to know.


And about that furin site:
DRASTIC posted the failed proposal online in September. Demaneuf, who is also affiliated with the group, says that DRASTIC grant reviewers were struck by the plans to put human-specific furin cleavage sites into the tell-tale spike proteins of SARS-related viruses. Furin cleavage sites enable the virus to efficiently infect human cells, potentially making it more transmissible among people (an outcome that reflects a microbial gain-of-function). Indeed, SARS-CoV-2 is unusual for having a furin cleavage site, which other coronaviruses in its class do not share.

Daszak told Science that he didn't remember the five sentences within the 43-page proposal that describe this experiment.
Really? Something as important as inserting the furin cleavage site into a bat SARS-r CoV and releasing the resulting virus into the wild but Daszak simply forgot that was in the grant proposal?
There's a lot more in the op ed, well worth reading.
 
@SG. The mouse studies still need to start with a virus stock with which to infect the mice. This stock has to be titrated in the mice to determine the right amount to give them usually a does at which 50% are killed (LD50) or in this case where it infects 50%. The stock is grown in vitro and probably in Vero E6 cells.
I addressed this above but I'll see what more details of the work I can find. They used live animal cultures and reverse engineering Shi learned from Baric.


Please help me with the Worobey study, how was the COVID RNA recovered from the market. RNA doesn't hang around long and I'm surprised any was found at all, it needs a special process to ensure it is able to be amplified by RT-PCR.
The swabs were collected ~Jan 2020. The Chinese government then sat on the results and only recently released them.

The Atlantic: A new analysis of genetic samples from China appears to link the pandemic’s origin to raccoon dogs.
The genetic sequences were pulled out of swabs taken in and near market stalls around the pandemic’s start. They represent the first bits of raw data that researchers outside of China’s academic institutions and their direct collaborators have had access to. A few weeks ago, the data appeared on an open-access genomic database called GISAID, after being quietly posted by researchers affiliated with the country’s Center for Disease Control and Prevention. By almost pure happenstance, scientists in Europe, North America, and Australia spotted the sequences, downloaded them, and began an analysis.

The original Chinese analysis of the Huanan market swabs, from February 2022, also stuck with China’s party line on the pandemic. One of the report’s graphs suggested that viral material at the market had been mixed up with genetic material of multiple animal species—a data trail that should have led to further inquiry or conclusions, but that the Chinese researchers appear to have ignored. Their report noted only humans as being linked to SARS-CoV-2, stating that its findings “highly” suggested that any viral material at the market came from people (at least one of whom, presumably, picked it up elsewhere and ferried it into the venue). The Huanan market, the study’s authors wrote, “might have acted as an amplifier” for the epidemic. But “more work involving international coordination” would be needed to suss out the “real origins of SARS-CoV-2.”
All along the seafood market was considered a super-spreader site. And the fact they sold live raccoon dogs has been known all along including pictures of the animals in cages at the market.

Make what you will of it, obviously the result is inconclusive. But it is not a smoking gun that raccoon dogs carried the virus to people at the market.


I'd need to read the grant proposal to understand why in vivo infection was considered ok.
It wasn't OK. The grant was denied. But Shi had other sources of funding.

https://peterdaszak.com/darpa.pdf

There is a link to an earlier DARPA grant proposal in the thread. I'll have to look for it. In that one Daszak was delinquent in providing ongoing documentation that was needed.
 
Last edited:
Yes a naturally occurring recombinant virus is certainly one possibility. The problem is no evidence can be found of a closely related virus progenitor circulating in rats, bats, raccoon dogs or any crossover species. It's possible, of course, that it was missed.

This is spelled out in detail in the WHO-convened Global Study of Origins of SARS-CoV-2 ... report on the search for the origin of the virus.

That's from 2021, 2 years old at this point and before the reporting on BANAL-52, Covid's closest know relative and has a particularly high identity in their spike proteins.
 
​
The interview was in June 2021 and your two links are more recent, 12/21 and 06/23. And as before there are still 2 competing hypotheses.

All the genetic components of COVID 19 have been found in the wild, And SARS-related CoVs are often the result of recombinant events. This is not new to this discussion.
This has been discussed in the thread, (you know, the one you haven't read).

We included a discussion of the possibility that rats might have been the intermediary species or they might have been involved in some way. One is looking at a recombinant event; one that still may or may not be distinguishable between natural evolution and lab created.

First link:
Furin cleavage sites in the spike proteins of bat and rodent coronaviruses: Implications for virus evolution and zoonotic transfer from rodent species
And with the addition of the nucleotides one finds increased virulence and transmission.
Yep, we discussed the rat coronaviruses.

The second link was more definitive:
A novel bat coronavirus with a polybasic furin-like cleavage site

Just like the other components of COVID 19, still no direct precursor. Do you have a source showing a precursor virus in rodents in Yunnan or even in Wuhan that is a close relative of COVID-19? All the pieces can be found, but not in one precursor.


What was new in the discussion was Capsid bringing up the fact the furin cleavage site devolved rather than evolved when serially passed through VeroE6 cell cultures.
That's great because researchers can narrow the search now looking for a recombinant event or a lab insertion of the 12 nucleotides.

Got no argument there.

But I don't agree with this:

It's not because we want someone to blame or that a natural occurrence is unsatisfying. It's because the lab origin hypothesis was initially swept under the rug and that doesn't lend itself to a science-based debate.

The role of the furin cleavage site in pathogenecity is complex. SARS has no furin cleavage site and is more virulent.

https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2211107119
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanmic/article/PIIS2666-5247(23)00144-1/fulltext
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8689951/

I think it is pointless to focus on a particular intermediate species. It took ten years of looking to identify the likely source of SARS. No direct bat virus ancestor of SARS was identified, but a cluster of viruses which through exchange of genetic material could create SARS. Evolution in coronaviruses means we are unlikely to find the ancestor to SARS-CoV-2 but descendants of a common ancestor. Similarly we are not going to find a common ancestor between man and apes, all we will find are descendants of the common ancestor between man and apes.

Your claim that the laboratory origin was swept under the carpet is not true. Shi said early how she checked to make sure that SARS-CoV-2 could not have originated from her lab. Early on WIV staff were tested to see if they had been infected with SARS-CoV-2 and tested negative. The proximal origins paper was published in March 2020, the result of a high level meeting to review the possible origins of SARS-CoV-2. That the conclusion differs from your opinion does not mean that the possibility of a laboratory leak was not considered.

https://www.nature.com/articles/S41591-020-0820-9
 
I don't see anything new there @Planigale that I haven't already replied to. You ignore evidence others post then expect us to waste time addressing your often poorly informed science.

For example you posted as if Shi was still collaborating directly with Baric when they hadn't worked together for over 5 years. You described Baric's easily identifiable chimeras then attributed the same work to Shi as if she were using the same backbone and ignoring reverse engineering techniques Shi learned from Baric.

That would be fine but you just plow on, never admitting your mistakes, never addressing the evidence that challenges your misled belief Shi hasn't lied one bit in all this.

Your denial that lab origin pandemics have ever occurred has been addressed, you ignore that as well. Yes, some labs are safer but there are also more labs in unsafe areas of the world and every one of them isn't working strictly without actual live viruses.

That's not a discussion. When you decide you want a back and forth actual exchange of information and ideas, start by addressing your mistakes.
 
Last edited:
In the meantime, here are the current key questions regarding the furin cleavage site:

One, could it have arisen naturally through a recombinant event? Yes, absolutely. But nothing close to the SARS-like CoVs that would have been present before this recombinant event have been found.

That leaves a most unlikely one-off event where a COVID 19 precursor finds its way to the seafood market and in a recombinant event it acquires that one 12 nucleotide segment in just the right place to increase the lethality of one virion that happens to jump species into humans at just the right time for a super spreader event to get the pandemic going. (Sorry for the run-on sentence there.)

Do we even know if a single virion is enough to start an infection? It's unlikely. I suppose a number of these recombinant virions could have resulted from a single event and only the ones with the furin cleavage acquisition went on to start the pandemic.

There are other scenarios where the precursor COVID 19 picks up the furin cleavage site. I don't deny that possibility, but where is the evidence any of these scenarios occurred? Not found yet. I've been asking how long until one gives up looking?

From SARS and MERS CoVs to their natural reservoirs may have taken years. But it was not a sterile trail without so much as the hint of a crossover species in sight.


*I say human adapted because there is no evidence SARS CoV2 needed more genetic variation before binding to the ACE2 receptor became optimized.

And yes, there are some citations in the thread where SARS CoVs appear to be generalist pathogens. I don't think that minutiae needs to be rehashed here. I'll accept it as a given. There is still the problem of no evidence of a well adapted SARS CoV 2 waiting around Wuhan for that one key 12 nucleotide long segment to be acquired. And there's no evidence rats were the proximal origin source that led to the pandemic.
Bottom line, an 'immaculate' spillover event has some pretty steep odds. It's easy for people to just say it was a spillover but the details in this case have not been provided.

Multiply by the odds this just so happened in the vicinity of the WIV, the CCDC labs and the seafood market all in Wuhan and this origin hypothesis becomes even less likely.



Two, could it have been inserted in a lab into an already enhanced SARS CoV? A 12 nucleotide sequence of genetic code, yes.

Three, if that was done would it be recognizable to virologists as being artificially inserted? Some sources cited in this thread say it might not be detectable others say it would be.

Daskin's grant proposals next.
 
Last edited:
One, could it have arisen naturally through a recombinant event? Yes, absolutely. But nothing close to the SARS-like CoVs that would have been present before this recombinant event have been found.

This makes the lab leak theory untenable. For there to have been a lab leak a Covid precursor MUST have been found. For natural spillover, however, it doesn't matter if the precursor has been found or not.

A very similar spike protein has been found as part of BANAL-52, something you keep ignoring. What's missing at this point is the rest of the virus is still too far removed from RATG-13 or even BANAL-52 to have been either engineered into Covid.
 
Re the DARPA Proposal:

Researchgate; quotes from the DARPA proposal are in italics, DRASTIC commentary is in normal text

Synthesis of Chimeric Novel SARSr-CoV QS: We will commercially synthesize SARSr-CoV2S glycoprotein genes, designed for insertion into SHC014 or WIV16 molecular clonebackbones (88% and 97% S-protein identity to epidemic SARS-Urbani). These are BSL-3,not select agents or subject to P3CO (they use bat SARSr-CoV backbones which areexempt) and are pathogenic to hACE2 transgenic mice.” (D1, p.9) ...

“This will be supplemented by characterization of isolated viruses under DEFUSE (at WIV),approximately 15-20 bat SARSr-CoV spike proteins/year (at UNC, WIV), and >180 batSARSr-CoV strains sequenced in our prior work and not yet examined for spillover potential.”(D1, p.12) ...

“We will validate results from chimeric viruses by re-characterizing full-length genome versions, testing whether backbone genome sequence alters full length SARSr-CoV spillover potential. QS for full-genome characterization will be selected to reflect strain differences in antigenicity, receptor usage, growth in human cells and pathogenesis.” (D1, p.13)“We will test growth in primary HAE cultures and in vivo in hACE2 transgenic mice. We anticipate recovering ~3-5 full length genome viruses/year.” (D1, p.13) ...
So not in Vero cells, or at least not only in those particular cell cultures.


Human protease-specific site insertion was proposed. The proposal does not specify exactly which protease, but does discuss Furin in the preceding text....

“We will analyze all SARSr-CoV S gene sequences for appropriately conserved proteolytic cleavage sites in S2 and for the presence of potential Furin cleavage sites74,75”.SARSr-CoV S with mismatches in proteolytic cleavage sites can be activated by exogenousTrypsin or Cathepsin L.Where clear mismatches occur, we will introduce appropriate human-specific cleavage sites and evaluate growth potential in Vero cells and HAE [Human Airway Epithelial] cultures.”(D1, p.13)
At that point they would not have known the success or not of the Vero cells but they also planned to use the HAE cell cultures.

More commentary:
No other sarbecovirus subgenus CoV including SARS-CoV possesses a Furin cleavage site, and as Furin cleavage sites have previously be inserted into coronaviruses in laboratories to increase tropism and pathogenicity (Cheng et al. 2019), the origin of the FCS has been widely debated (Wade2021). Wu and Zhao (2021) propose the FCS arose through natural insertion.

Wade, Segreto, Deigin are then cited in the commentary with notes on the insertion of the furin cleavage. The latter 2 sources have been discredited in this thread but it's only commentary here, not a cite that it's been done. It's predictable persons in this thread will discredit any and everything those names are mentioned no matter how incidental the reference is.

In this case the commentary goes on to reasonably note:
Given that we find in this EHA proposal, a discussion of the planned introduction of human-specific cleavage sites into novel SARS-r CoVs, a review by the wider scientific community of the plausibility of artificial insertion of an FCS into SARS-CoV-2 or a progenitor is warranted
The proposal notes planned work. It's not evidence that plan was or was not carried out.

"Low abundance micro-variations:We will structurally model and identify highly variable residue changes in the SARSr-CoV SRBD, use commercial gene blocks to introduce these changes singly and in combination into the S glycoprotein gene of the low risk, parental strain and test ACE2 receptor usage, growth in HAE and in-vivo pathogenesis”.(D1, p.13)



DRASTIC commenters further note:
THE PROPOSAL “SPILLOVER PROBABILITY” ASSESSMENT DOES NOT INCLUDE LAB-RESEARCH RELATED RISKS

Figure. 7 below (D1, p.14) documents an extensive sampling, and lab experimentation plan. It is quite astounding that the spillover probability calculation incorporates multiple ‘processes contributing to spillover’, all of which require extraction of viruses from bats and experimentation in laboratories, yet does not incorporate a risk factor for field sampling and laboratory experimentation to deliberately increase the pathogenicity of SARS-r CoVs.

There are more quotes from the proposal and more worthwhile comments that I could have quoted in this post but interested people can also read for themselves. The proposal more than presents a credible way the Furin cleavage site was introduced into COVID 19.



We have COVID 19 as evidence they were either successful or it was an incredibly unlikely coincidence this just so happened in the market within a dozen miles from the WIV at the very time this is what the EHA proposed creating.
It boggles my mind how easily it is for people to ignore this incredibly unlikely coincidence yet readily accept a study like Worobey's that leaves out a fair number of the earliest cases. How easily it is to accept that raccoon dog DNA found with a trace of COVID 19 RNA in a stall in the seafood market was evidence this animal was the crossover animal that first infected people.
 
Last edited:
In the meantime, here are the current key questions regarding the furin cleavage site:

One, could it have arisen naturally through a recombinant event? Yes, absolutely. But nothing close to the SARS-like CoVs that would have been present before this recombinant event have been found.

That leaves a most unlikely one-off event where a COVID 19 precursor finds its way to the seafood market and in a recombinant event it acquires that one 12 nucleotide segment in just the right place to increase the lethality of one virion that happens to jump species into humans at just the right time for a super spreader event to get the pandemic going. (Sorry for the run-on sentence there.)

Do we even know if a single virion is enough to start an infection? It's unlikely. I suppose a number of these recombinant virions could have resulted from a single event and only the ones with the furin cleavage acquisition went on to start the pandemic.

There are other scenarios where the precursor COVID 19 picks up the furin cleavage site. I don't deny that possibility, but where is the evidence any of these scenarios occurred? Not found yet. I've been asking how long until one gives up looking?

From SARS and MERS CoVs to their natural reservoirs may have taken years. But it was not a sterile trail without so much as the hint of a crossover species in sight.


*I say human adapted because there is no evidence SARS CoV2 needed more genetic variation before binding to the ACE2 receptor became optimized.

And yes, there are some citations in the thread where SARS CoVs appear to be generalist pathogens. I don't think that minutiae needs to be rehashed here. I'll accept it as a given. There is still the problem of no evidence of a well adapted SARS CoV 2 waiting around Wuhan for that one key 12 nucleotide long segment to be acquired. And there's no evidence rats were the proximal origin source that led to the pandemic.
Bottom line, an 'immaculate' spillover event has some pretty steep odds. It's easy for people to just say it was a spillover but the details in this case have not been provided.

Multiply by the odds this just so happened in the vicinity of the WIV, the CCDC labs and the seafood market all in Wuhan and this origin hypothesis becomes even less likely.



Two, could it have been inserted in a lab into an already enhanced SARS CoV? A 12 nucleotide sequence of genetic code, yes.

Three, if that was done would it be recognizable to virologists as being artificially inserted? Some sources cited in this thread say it might not be detectable others say it would be.

Daskin's grant proposals next.

I'll just address the highlighted. I think you forget this was not a one off event. Viruses are continually mutating. Papers you have quoted show that there are continual cross over events into humans. There are are of the order of 66,000 cross over events annually in Asia. Sars-CoV-2 was not a unique event, it was the one time after millions of infections that a sarbecovirus successfully crossed over and caused an outbreak (since SARS).

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-022-31860-w
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9981523/

The argument that any particular mutation is unlikely therefore evolution is unlikely is one widespread in creationist literature. The eye is often given as an example where mutations are so unlikely to result in a human eye that intelligent design is the only explanation. Essentilally it is this argument you are repeating here. It is so unlikely that a virus could have arisen through random mutation and natural selection that could exploit a novel ecological niche that the only explanation is intelligent design. The reality is that there are billions of bats with rapidly evolving viruses and we only know about a tiny proportion. We do know that some wild type sarbecoviruses have spike proteins with higher affinity for human ACE2 than SARS-CoV-2, SARS-CoV-2 was not well adapted, one lineage died out, the second underwent a number of mutations to result in it becoming more transmissible. The furin cleavage site does not increase lethality, but transmissibility. Evolutionarily transmission is important not lethality. SARS has no furin cleavage site and is far more lethal. This is not a known Sarbecovirus with a furin cleavage site added which is what one would expect from the CT that SARs-CoV-2 was created in a laboratory, but a previously unknown virus with an out of frame insertion of twelve nucleotides. Not how researchers would do it.

You keep on claiming that the wet market was a superspreader event. but you appear to be the only person to think this. Superspreader events are point events from a single highly infectious individual, event. The WIV out break happened over too long a period to be a superspreader event. Using 'super speader' is just a smoke screen to try and conceal the role of the wet market, just like the use of 'gain of function' as a pejorative term to make the WIV scientists look guilty of doing something nefarious despite the lack of evidence they actually did any gain of function research (as commonly defined). Avoiding the term 'super spreader', I think you are saying that you accept that the wet market was a likely common source for many early SARS-CoV-2 infections. Outbbreaks of infectious diseases are common, we do nt usually refer to then as superspreader events,
 
Last edited:
You totally missed the blatantly glaring in your face point. :rolleyes:

First, one correction: yes the COVID 19 pandemic was a one-off event. To assert spillovers happen or even Daszak's convenient reassessment of coronavirus spillovers in Yunnan is not relevant evidence. And not finding a direct link between lineages A&B (3 whole nucleotide differences IIRC) :rolleyes: is not evidence it must have happened in animals because there's no direct link there either. And we know some of the human cases' genomes are not in the data files.

Another correction of one of your mistakes: The market was identified as a super spreader location/event somewhere around Jan 2020 by multiple scientists and the Chinese themselves. It's bizarre you would make such a nonsensical claim that I'm the only one who noted it. If you would bother to look at posted citations .... And maybe look up the definition of a superspreader event before posting something a stupid as "Outbbreaks of infectious diseases are common, we do nt[sp] usually refer to then as superspreader events." "We?" :rolleyes:

Please please please read the beginning of the thread or at a minimum look this stuff up before wasting everyone's time.

LMGTFY How could you not be embarrassed? Seriously.



Back to the glaring point you missed. The issue is not, I repeat not, that it was impossible for COVID 19 to have arisen in the wild. Good grief! I have a whole post on just that.

The problem is just how big of a coincidence are people willing to accept? Because the number of things that would have had to have lined up is getting impossibly long.
 
Last edited:
Re the DARPA Proposal:

Researchgate; quotes from the DARPA proposal are in italics, DRASTIC commentary is in normal text


So not in Vero cells, or at least not only in those particular cell cultures.


That's a whole lot of jumping to unsubstantiated conclusions. Seriously, this is nothing more than "scientists did research, it must have produced Covid"

The lack of a suitably close Covid relative makes it impossible for this experiment to have produced Covid.

Wade, Segreto, Deigin are then cited in the commentary with notes on the insertion of the furin cleavage. .

Who cares what these three have to say? They have no retentive expertise in the field.


It boggles my mind how easily it is for people to ignore this incredibly unlikely coincidence yet readily accept a study like Worobey's that leaves out a fair number of the earliest cases. How easily it is to accept that raccoon dog DNA found with a trace of COVID 19 RNA in a stall in the seafood market was evidence this animal was the crossover animal that first infected people.

Or more likely the cases simply don't exist to begin with. At best you are talking about rumors of cases with no evidence the case actually exists and even if it does no evidence it's Covid. This is just another attack on respected scientist, which has been the playbook for DRASTIC all along, just like it's the go-to playbook for anti-vaxers, climate deniers, and every other purveyor of pseudo-science out there.
 
I do hope there are people in this thread still actually debating/discussing the science. Forgive me but I am going to ignore the clutter for the moment except for this:

'GoF or not' is not relevant except as it applies to funding and the politics that accompanies that discussion. It's a distraction and most certainly isn't anything I've ever posted because it sounded scary. :rolleyes:

A worldwide pandemic that has killed millions is scary enough it doesn't need any faux enhancing. It's important to honestly address the origin with neither a spillover nor a lab source being less scary per se. Why an honest discussion is needed re the origin is a no brainer.

It's especially important to not let some misplaced loyalty to fellow researchers or concern a lab origin might impact current ongoing but maybe unrelated research color the investigation.



Beyond those inherent biases we need to get back to the science of the origin discussion:

It's not hard to find sources that insist the furin cleavage site would be recognizable were it inserted artificially and other sources that say it wouldn't have been obvious. It's a wash at the moment so that needs to be set aside unless there is some relevant evidence about the ability for researchers to insert the 12 nucleotides into a SARS-like CoV.

We have the grant application that clearly states that is one of the intended planned actions. The use of cultures in humanized mice and cultures in human airway cells is noted in the proposal. Vero cells are not the only planned culture medium.

An examination of whether or not the insertion of the furin site is possible needs little supporting evidence.when one considers the history of both Daszak and Shi. These are top virus researchers. Shi worked with Baric, co-published papers, took back to the WIV both reverse genetics skills and humanized mice.

Where is the doubt here?
 
I do hope there are people in this thread still actually debating/discussing the science. Forgive me but I am going to ignore the clutter for the moment except for this:

'GoF or not' is not relevant except as it applies to funding and the politics that accompanies that discussion. It's a distraction and most certainly isn't anything I've ever posted because it sounded scary. :rolleyes:

A worldwide pandemic that has killed millions is scary enough it doesn't need any faux enhancing. It's important to honestly address the origin with neither a spillover nor a lab source being less scary per se. Why an honest discussion is needed re the origin is a no brainer.

It's especially important to not let some misplaced loyalty to fellow researchers or concern a lab origin might impact current ongoing but maybe unrelated research color the investigation.



Beyond those inherent biases we need to get back to the science of the origin discussion:

It's not hard to find sources that insist the furin cleavage site would be recognizable were it inserted artificially and other sources that say it wouldn't have been obvious. It's a wash at the moment so that needs to be set aside unless there is some relevant evidence about the ability for researchers to insert the 12 nucleotides into a SARS-like CoV.

We have the grant application that clearly states that is one of the intended planned actions. The use of cultures in humanized mice and cultures in human airway cells is noted in the proposal. Vero cells are not the only planned culture medium.

An examination of whether or not the insertion of the furin site is possible needs little supporting evidence.when one considers the history of both Daszak and Shi. These are top virus researchers. Shi worked with Baric, co-published papers, took back to the WIV both reverse genetics skills and humanized mice.

Where is the doubt here?

I think the problem is the use of pejorative terms, scary words rather than a rational discussion of the actual science, techniques and possible outcomes. 'Humanised Mice' is another example of scary terminology like 'gain of function'. The mice were not humanised, they had a single alteration so they expressed human ACE2 rather than murine ACE2. They were otherwise mice, they had mouse immune systems and mouse biochemistry. The key thing is that to infect mice they used a mouse virus, a murine SARS virus, but expressing spike proteins from newly discovered viruses. This is not gain of function because the mouse virus could only cause a pandemic in mice expressing a human ACE2 protein. you could not go from a murine SARS virus to SARS-CoV-2 through serial passage in mice expressing hACE2 or vero cells or tissue (airways) culture.

The problem is if someone was inserting a Furin cleavage site for research they would not do it by an out of frame insertion of an odd sequence of basic amino-acids. They would have inserted a standard Furin cleavage site at a standard position. What was not known at the time was the critical importance of upstream and down stream mutations for the Turin cleavage site to function. This is the sort of thing that billions of random reassortment may give rise to, but not a planned experiment.

The argument that a particular sequence of events or mutations is so unlikely that the only explanation is intelligent design is a recurrent them in creationist literature. None-the-less, eyes evolved, they were not designed in a divine lab, and SARS-CoV-2 was not designed in a mortal lab.

The experiments described (leaving aside pejorative terms like 'gain of function', and 'humanised mice'), could not give rise to SARS-CoV-2. it does not matter whether Shi carried out the experiments described but not funded (and there is no evidence she did), they could not result in SARS-CoV-2. Perhaps the research described was dangerous, perhaps it could have given rise to a pandemic virus, but it could not have produced SARs-CoV-2.

All the components to make SARS-CoV-2 are out there in the wild, not in WIV. The only bit unclear is how it leaked from the wild into Wuhan. The only bit missing in the natural cross over is the nature of the leak. the bit missing from the laboratory leak is both a precursor virus and the mechanism of the leak. only one event is unexplained in the natural cross over theory, two are unexplained for the laboratory leak. in the absence of new facts, a natural cross over event remains the most likely explanation for Covid-19.
 
'GoF or not' is not relevant except as it applies to funding and the politics that accompanies that discussion. It's a distraction and most certainly isn't anything I've ever posted because it sounded scary. :rolleyes:

A worldwide pandemic that has killed millions is scary enough it doesn't need any faux enhancing. It's important to honestly address the origin with neither a spillover nor a lab source being less scary per se.

GoF is a critical tool in identifying viruses that pose the risk of such a pandemic, and a critical tool in identifying vaccine targets when such pandemics occur. The people vilifying such important research could end up causing millions or even hundreds of millions of deaths from a future pandemic.


It's not hard to find sources that insist the furin cleavage site would be recognizable were it inserted artificially and other sources that say it wouldn't have been obvious. It's a wash at the moment so that needs to be set aside unless there is some relevant evidence about the ability for researchers to insert the 12 nucleotides into a SARS-like CoV.

It's not 12 nucleotide, it's 4 and those are insured out of frame. I've seen at least 1 virologist say that not even their worst grad student would make the mistake of inserting a sequence out of frame.

There are 2 simultaneous claims here that you are making, one that there is some supra-genius level Chinese scientist capable of constructing whole virus genomes and creating highly infectious structures no one has ever seen before. But at the same time this person is so incompetent they inserted their nucleotides out of frame.


We have the grant application that clearly states that is one of the intended planned actions.

Why do you keep referencing this grant application? It's work aimed at pandemic prevention and has nothing to do with the origin of Covid.
 
They're only scary in your mind, @Planigale. None of the sources I've cited use them in such a bizarre way.

Forgive me for not recognizing your asserted expertise in how COVID 19 originated. You have another post without any citations.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom