W.D.Clinger
Philosopher
David Baltimore did not say that. Those are the words of the journalist Lori Dajose who interviewed David Baltimore.Interview with Caltech's David Baltimore, president emeritus and Distinguished Professor of Biology, is a virologist who received the Nobel Prize for his research into viral genetics. ...
... Similar viruses before it have been shown to have jumped from animals to humans; yet this link has not yet been definitively found for SARS-CoV-2. ...
Here are some of the actual words spoken by David Baltimore in that interview that Skeptic Ginger, in her cherry-picking, chose to omit:
Let me be clear, even though I used the phrase "smoking gun," I don't really think there's a smoking gun in the genome itself....
So where did it come from in SARS-CoV-2? There are other viruses that have furin cleavage sites, other coronaviruses, though not the family of beta-coronaviruses. So this sequence's nucleotides could have hopped from some other virus. No one has identified a virus that has exactly this sequence, but it could have come from something close, then evolved into the sequence that we see today....
More context:
Here’s the problem: Baltimore regrets using the phrase “smoking gun” to describe his conclusion, and doesn’t agree that it validates the lab-leak theory.
Baltimore told me by email that he made the statement to Wade, also by email, and granted him permission to use it in print. But he added that he “should have softened the phrase ‘smoking gun’ because I don’t believe that it proves the origin of the furin cleavage site but it does sound that way. I believe that the question of whether the sequence was put in naturally or by molecular manipulation is very hard to determine but I wouldn’t rule out either origin.”
Well, this 85-year-old man did win a Nobel Prize when he was 37 years old.Argument from ignorance by old white man.
At the age of 48, however, he co-authored a paper with Thereza Imanishi-Kari and others that appears to have been fraudulent. At first, Baltimore refused to retract the paper and defended Imanishi-Kari's research. Baltimore eventually apologized, but the scandal led Baltimore to resign as president of Rockefeller University. One of the multiple investigations cleared Baltimore of misconduct but concluded the paper "is rife with errors of all sorts...some which, despite all these years and layers of review, have never previously been pointed out or corrected. Responsibility ... must be shared by all participants." So the guy is hardly infallible, and made well-publicized mistakes decades ago, when he was a much younger man.