Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
Not sure why I bother.
Why not be honest? Why do you need to resort to denying evidence was cited? Is it perhaps because you really can't debate honestly?
A few people in the Chinese government are withholding information that would help clear up the origin. Multiple researchers and agencies have requested China release the data on early cases. The WHO has asked formally. The request to see more data has held up China allowing a second WHO inspection team in. Dr Fauci asked China to release information on any ill workers at the WIV in Nov 2019. They did not. I recently posted citation links which you've ignored.
Again, why not be honest? Why do you need to resort to denying evidence was cited? Is it perhaps because you really can't debate honestly?
As for "nearly all recent ..." WTF? Not only is that a false dilemma, it's a blatant straw man. Again, people build straw men when they can't debate the point based on the actual evidence. You have done that a lot.
Circular reasoning is what you have here.
Shi said they had no viruses not disclosed and those disclosed, according to you, could not have been the precursor.
Your answer to that is you take Shi's word for it they didn't. It's like asking a guilty person if they did it, they answer, no, so that's it, end of discussion, they didn't do it.
BTW, you should go back to that post and read Sherkeu's post again that you quoted. The point you missed with your dodge was this:
And please don't bother repeating the whataboutisms regarding other viruses. It's another one of those irrelevant arguments you keep repeating.
This has all been supported in the thread with reliable citations. Just because you want it spoon fed back to you does not mean the evidence has not been posted. Claiming I can't produce something I produced is dishonest.I think it reasonable to respond to an opinion based non-evidence based post in a similar manner.
I note you cannot produce a quote from Shi to support your allegation she lied. I never said only anonymous sources were quoted in general, but specifically in relation to the claim that bats were kept at WIV.
Why not be honest? Why do you need to resort to denying evidence was cited? Is it perhaps because you really can't debate honestly?
Why would "many scientists of many nations, the WHO, western governments ..." be part of a CT? That's a ludicrous straw man you've built there.I think 'massive' is an appropriate adjective, since it appears to require the involvement of the Chinese government many scientists of many nations, WHO, western governments...
A few people in the Chinese government are withholding information that would help clear up the origin. Multiple researchers and agencies have requested China release the data on early cases. The WHO has asked formally. The request to see more data has held up China allowing a second WHO inspection team in. Dr Fauci asked China to release information on any ill workers at the WIV in Nov 2019. They did not. I recently posted citation links which you've ignored.
Again, why not be honest? Why do you need to resort to denying evidence was cited? Is it perhaps because you really can't debate honestly?
I listed the lab leaks that resulted in outbreaks and pandemics, so yes not all of them have been caused by natural spillovers. You could just look it up yourself. The information is not hard to find if you don't want to go a couple of posts back to see the citation I posted.Do you deny that all previous pandemics have been the result of natural cross over events, but that nearly all recent pandemics and near pandemics have been alleged to be the result of a laboratory leak / bio engineering? Now I accept if people keep on crying wolf then one day they may get it right.
As for "nearly all recent ..." WTF? Not only is that a false dilemma, it's a blatant straw man. Again, people build straw men when they can't debate the point based on the actual evidence. You have done that a lot.
What new evidence post 2021 supports a laboratory leak?
Shi said they had no viruses not disclosed and those disclosed, according to you, could not have been the precursor.
... The only discussion seems to be whether WIV had SARS-CoV-2 or a near precursor as a live virus in the laboratory prior to December 2019 or not.
Your answer to that is you take Shi's word for it they didn't. It's like asking a guilty person if they did it, they answer, no, so that's it, end of discussion, they didn't do it.
BTW, you should go back to that post and read Sherkeu's post again that you quoted. The point you missed with your dodge was this:
The world is not stagnant. The chance of a pandemic like we have with COVID 19 got closer and closer until, boom! It's not relevant that a pandemic of this proportion hadn't happened until now because all the ingredients were accumulating.This is something that keeps getting repeated but holds marginal relevance for this specific virus.
You are quoting history as if the technology, the science, and the explosions of bio labs around the world, in countries with perhaps less regulation or ability to ensure high safety levels would not in any way affect a possible leak.
Of course, it makes a leak more likely.
Especially when countries like China wanted (and built, with help from int'l partners) more and more high tech labs as a sign of global scientific importance since SARS- and picked up the work the US banned via surrogate funding in 2014. Plenty of papers and articles warning about the danger of this well before covid appeared.
And please don't bother repeating the whataboutisms regarding other viruses. It's another one of those irrelevant arguments you keep repeating.