Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Not sure why I bother. :rolleyes:
I think it reasonable to respond to an opinion based non-evidence based post in a similar manner.

I note you cannot produce a quote from Shi to support your allegation she lied. I never said only anonymous sources were quoted in general, but specifically in relation to the claim that bats were kept at WIV.
This has all been supported in the thread with reliable citations. Just because you want it spoon fed back to you does not mean the evidence has not been posted. Claiming I can't produce something I produced is dishonest.
Why not be honest? Why do you need to resort to denying evidence was cited? Is it perhaps because you really can't debate honestly?

I think 'massive' is an appropriate adjective, since it appears to require the involvement of the Chinese government many scientists of many nations, WHO, western governments...
Why would "many scientists of many nations, the WHO, western governments ..." be part of a CT? That's a ludicrous straw man you've built there.

A few people in the Chinese government are withholding information that would help clear up the origin. Multiple researchers and agencies have requested China release the data on early cases. The WHO has asked formally. The request to see more data has held up China allowing a second WHO inspection team in. Dr Fauci asked China to release information on any ill workers at the WIV in Nov 2019. They did not. I recently posted citation links which you've ignored.

Again, why not be honest? Why do you need to resort to denying evidence was cited? Is it perhaps because you really can't debate honestly?


Do you deny that all previous pandemics have been the result of natural cross over events, but that nearly all recent pandemics and near pandemics have been alleged to be the result of a laboratory leak / bio engineering? Now I accept if people keep on crying wolf then one day they may get it right.
I listed the lab leaks that resulted in outbreaks and pandemics, so yes not all of them have been caused by natural spillovers. You could just look it up yourself. The information is not hard to find if you don't want to go a couple of posts back to see the citation I posted.

As for "nearly all recent ..." WTF? Not only is that a false dilemma, it's a blatant straw man. Again, people build straw men when they can't debate the point based on the actual evidence. You have done that a lot.


What new evidence post 2021 supports a laboratory leak?
:rolleyes: Circular reasoning is what you have here.

Shi said they had no viruses not disclosed and those disclosed, according to you, could not have been the precursor.
... The only discussion seems to be whether WIV had SARS-CoV-2 or a near precursor as a live virus in the laboratory prior to December 2019 or not.

Your answer to that is you take Shi's word for it they didn't. It's like asking a guilty person if they did it, they answer, no, so that's it, end of discussion, they didn't do it.


BTW, you should go back to that post and read Sherkeu's post again that you quoted. The point you missed with your dodge was this:
This is something that keeps getting repeated but holds marginal relevance for this specific virus.

You are quoting history as if the technology, the science, and the explosions of bio labs around the world, in countries with perhaps less regulation or ability to ensure high safety levels would not in any way affect a possible leak.
Of course, it makes a leak more likely.


Especially when countries like China wanted (and built, with help from int'l partners) more and more high tech labs as a sign of global scientific importance since SARS- and picked up the work the US banned via surrogate funding in 2014. Plenty of papers and articles warning about the danger of this well before covid appeared.
The world is not stagnant. The chance of a pandemic like we have with COVID 19 got closer and closer until, boom! It's not relevant that a pandemic of this proportion hadn't happened until now because all the ingredients were accumulating.

And please don't bother repeating the whataboutisms regarding other viruses. It's another one of those irrelevant arguments you keep repeating.
 
Not sure why I bother. :rolleyes:
This has all been supported in the thread with reliable citations. Just because you want it spoon fed back to you does not mean the evidence has not been posted. Claiming I can't produce something I produced is dishonest.
Why not be honest? Why do you need to resort to denying evidence was cited? Is it perhaps because you really can't debate honestly?


Why would "many scientists of many nations, the WHO, western governments ..." be part of a CT? That's a ludicrous straw man you've built there.

A few people in the Chinese government are withholding information that would help clear up the origin. Multiple researchers and agencies have requested China release the data on early cases. The WHO has asked formally. The request to see more data has held up China allowing a second WHO inspection team in. Dr Fauci asked China to release information on any ill workers at the WIV in Nov 2019. They did not. I recently posted citation links which you've ignored.

Again, why not be honest? Why do you need to resort to denying evidence was cited? Is it perhaps because you really can't debate honestly?



I listed the lab leaks that resulted in outbreaks and pandemics, so yes not all of them have been caused by natural spillovers. You could just look it up yourself. The information is not hard to find if you don't want to go a couple of posts back to see the citation I posted.

As for "nearly all recent ..." WTF? Not only is that a false dilemma, it's a blatant straw man. Again, people build straw men when they can't debate the point based on the actual evidence. You have done that a lot.


:rolleyes: Circular reasoning is what you have here.

Shi said they had no viruses not disclosed and those disclosed, according to you, could not have been the precursor.


Your answer to that is you take Shi's word for it they didn't. It's like asking a guilty person if they did it, they answer, no, so that's it, end of discussion, they didn't do it.


BTW, you should go back to that post and read Sherkeu's post again that you quoted. The point you missed with your dodge was this: The world is not stagnant. The chance of a pandemic like we have with COVID 19 got closer and closer until, boom! It's not relevant that a pandemic of this proportion hadn't happened until now because all the ingredients were accumulating. And please don't bother repeating the whataboutisms regarding other viruses. It's another one of those irrelevant arguments you keep repeating.
No I responded to it. I commented that virology laboratories have been around for nearly a century, biosafety is better than ever and far less live virus research is done than used to be done. The features that have changed are those increasing a likelihood of a natural spillover event. Those ecological changes are why people predicted that a pandemic due to a natural spill over event from a coronavirus was highly likely.

This is a good review of previous outbreaks (natural spill over events) and why they are more likely now (and it isn't due to virology laboratories).

https://www.pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073/pnas.2202871119
 
The fact that spillover is more and more likely doesn't mean virology laboratories are safe (especially Chinese ones), and it doesn't mean it was the case for covid.
 
The fact that spillover is more and more likely doesn't mean virology laboratories are safe (especially Chinese ones)

Plenty of western scientists have worked in Chinese labs without noting any particular safety issues.

it doesn't mean it was the case for covid.

"It's possible therefor it happened" isn't a valid argument. No actual evidence has been presented for anything other than zoonotic crossover in the Wuhan market.
 
Plenty of western scientists have worked in Chinese labs without noting any particular safety issues.

"It's possible therefor it happened" isn't a valid argument. No actual evidence has been presented for anything other than zoonotic crossover in the Wuhan market.

Agreed. But evidence was withheld. China IS hiding something. Might be just their default position on anything. Might be the way the outbreak was handled. Might be the fact, they actually don't have the data we ask them for. Or it might be .. you know .. lab origin.
 
No I responded to it. I commented that virology laboratories have been around for nearly a century, biosafety is better than ever and far less live virus research is done than used to be done.
Safer than ever? That's not a supportable conclusion given the expansion of viral research into multiple countries with variable safety records.

Less live virus research? That depends. Some diagnostic testing but more importantly a lot of viral research doesn't lend itself to only direct genetic analysis.


The features that have changed are those increasing a likelihood of a natural spillover event. Those ecological changes are why people predicted that a pandemic due to a natural spill over event from a coronavirus was highly likely.
Never denied. What you are missing however is the very research being undertaken by the WIV and Baric at the UNC was because of the risk of more human exposure to wild animals.

This is a good review of previous outbreaks (natural spill over events) and why they are more likely now (and it isn't due to virology laboratories).

https://www.pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073/pnas.2202871119
Yay a citation. Daszak is one of the authors and the article lists competing interests.
Competing Interests
Competing interest statement: Several authors have historic and/or current research collaborations with multiple countries in the course of their work on emerging infections, and for some, this includes Chinese institutions researching bat-associated coronaviruses.

It's not just that Daszak was on this team, he has a direct conflict of interest as he's implicated and he stands to lose millions in grant money if a lab origin is determined. And he was accused of penning a letter to the Lancet and dishonestly covering up the fact he wrote it when he asked other scientists to sign on.

A reason is discussed as to why no intermediate species or source of COVID has been found. Not enough time, not enough tests. Three years and counting but not only no COVID trail to Wuhan, no other outbreaks occurred anywhere that could not be traced directly back to Wuhan. It's been thoroughly discussed in this thread.

From the article:
The failure to detect the evolution of an FCS in closely related viruses from Laos after repeated passage in human cells in vitro suggests that it was unlikely to have evolved into SARS-CoV-2 during laboratory passage in cell culture (SI Appendix, Table S6).
So one experiment and we don't know if is applicable to the WIV. We do know Baric had success with serial passages of coronaviruses.
Everything else in the article has been directly addressed in this thread.


2016: SARS-like WIV1-CoV poised for human emergence
Vineet D. Menachery, Boyd L. Yount Jr., Amy C. Sims, +14, and Ralph S. Baric

a significant threat posed by WIV1-CoV. Both full-length and chimeric WIV1-CoV readily replicated efficiently in human airway cultures and in vivo, suggesting capability of direct transmission to humans. In addition, while monoclonal antibody treatments prove effective, the SARS-based vaccine approach failed to confer protection. Together, the study indicates an ongoing threat posed by WIV1-related viruses and the need for continued study and surveillance. ...

In this study, we describe an approach that combines existing metagenomics data with reverse genetics to engineer reagents to evaluate emergence and pathogenic potential of circulating zoonotic viruses.
And none of those authors had a conflict of interest.


Might SARS‐CoV‐2 Have Arisen via Serial Passage through an Animal Host or Cell Culture?

Although based on sequence analysis many prominent virologists and other eminent scientists have concluded that the novel coronavirus causing the current pandemic was not designed or manipulated in a laboratory and was the result of a natural zoonotic jump,[ 2 ] this assertion fails to fully account for all possible origins of two unique genomic characteristics found in SARS‐CoV‐2, and ignores the long history of serial passage as a method to manipulate viral genomes. The long‐standing practice of serial passage is a form of gain‐of‐function research that forces zoonosis between species, and requires the same molecular adaptations necessary for a natural zoonotic jump to occur within a laboratory, leaving the same genetic signatures behind as a natural jump but occurring in a much shorter period of time.

If your key argument is spillovers are more common that's not much of an argument.
 
Last edited:
Agreed. But evidence was withheld.

What evidence was withheld? I see lots of claims China isn't being open, and this may but true, but in terms of specific requests all I've seen is that China refused to turn over private medical records. Is there some other specific request you know of?

China IS hiding something.


I don't think they have successfully hidden anything, but what the Chinese government seem to want to hide is actually zoonotic crossover in the Wuhan market. This makes sense because the blame for the Pandemic would fall squarely of the Chinese government itself for not properly regulating, or even enforcing existing regulations for live animal markets. This would also call into question Chinese cultural practices, which again would be deeply embarrassing to China. These markets already known the be an extrema risk for the crossover of dangerous viruses into the human population, and it's a problem the Chinese government has allowed to grow to massive proportions.

In order to shift the blame from the live animal market the Chinese government China has continued to insist the pandemic started outside China and was carried to Wuhan on frozen food. The Chinese government has also a number of steps to hide the presence of infected animals in the Wuhan market.

For example the Chinese government incinerated every animal in the market without taking any samples that could be tested for the presence of the virus. China also tried to take down public data that included genetic sequences found in environmental samples taken at the market. Among other things these sequences allowed scientists to co-locate various animals with where virus samples were found.
 

a) neither of the authors had previously published a paper on virology.
b) outdated. The features they suggest "could" have arose from GoF work have subsequently been found in the wild demonstrating that they are naturally evolved features of Covid.



I don't see how this paper supports you claims. If anything it refutes everything you are trying to say about GoF research. The authors are using GoF research to identify wild Corona viruses with the potential to crossover to humans an cause a pandemic. They found one in horseshoe bats, the same species where Covid is though to have originated.
 
Elaborating on one subject at a time, a continuation of my previous post and a repeat of a citation I posted upthread ...

Might SARS-CoV-2 Have Arisen via Serial Passage through an Animal Host or Cell Culture?
Natural Origin, or Gain-of-Function Lab Escape?
Gain-of-function research on bat-borne coronaviruses has been ongoing for nearly a decade everywhere from the University of North Carolina to the Wuhan's Institute of Virology, which is supported by related facilities such as Wuhan's Center for Disease Control and Prevention as well as Wuhan University.
But wait, Shi denied doing GoF research on coronaviruses. Of course it's been claimed Shi never made such an assertion despite the fact it is easily confirmed from multiple sources including some cited in this thread.

A coronavirus that targets the ACE2 receptor like SARS-CoV-2 was first isolated from a wild bat in 2013 by a team out of Wuhan. This research was funded in part by EcoHealth Alliance,[30] and set the stage for the manipulation of bat-borne coronavirus genomes that target this receptor and can become airborne. Many more viruses have been collected in Wuhan over the years, and one research expedition captured as many as 400 wild viruses,[31] which were added to a private repository that has since grown to over 1500 strains of virus,[32] meaning that the Wuhan Center for Disease Control and Prevention has a massive catalogue of largely undisclosed viruses to draw from for experiments. And in subsequent years, EcoHealth Alliance received funding for project proposals outlining gain-of-function research to be done in Wuhan, hoping to use cell cultures and humanized mice as well as “[spike]-protein sequence data, infectious clone technology, in vitro and in vivo infection experiments and analysis of receptor binding”[33] to manipulate bat coronavirus genomes—all of which are consistent with the wet-work that would be needed to engineer this novel coronavirus in a laboratory. But for whatever reason, the Wuhan Institute of Virology has refused to release the lab notebooks of its researchers, which are ubiquitous in even the simplest laboratories and are expected to be meticulously detailed given the sensitive and delicate work that takes place in BSL-4 research labs intent on documenting their intellectual property, despite the fact that these notebooks would likely be enough to exonerate the lab from having any role in the creation of SARS-CoV-2.[34]
Why would they not want to be exonerated? :rolleyes: And how does this not support what I said that we don't know if there are more closely related precursor genomes when the evidence is Shi and company aren't disclosing all those genome files they have?


SARS-CoV-2's muddled origins are made even more Gordian by a study published March 2018 that examined people who live in villages about a kilometer away from bat caves. This study revealed that only 2.7% of those villagers had antibodies indicating any past exposure to bat coronaviruses. The authors also sampled people living in Wuhan, and found no evidence of exposure to SARS-CoV-like coronaviruses at all.[51]
Oh look, Daszak and Shi signed the 2018 letter:
This means there is very little serological evidence of any exposure to these coronaviruses even in Chinese villagers living in close proximity to bat caves, and at the epicenter of the current outbreak—no previous exposure was found at all. These data do not support the idea that SARS-CoV-2 was circulating in humans prior to the outbreak began in Wuhan in the early winter or fall of 2019, making a zoonotic jump even more unlikely since natural jumps leave wide serological footprints in their new host populations as early variants of a prospective virus make limited and unsuccessful jumps into individuals of the new host species, a trial-and-error that must occur before mutations that allow adaptation to a new host species are selected.[50]
Right out of the box, ready to go within a dozen miles of the WIV and hundreds of miles from the caves.


I wonder if Daszak didn't think anyone would look at this study when he later used it to support his claim that coronavirus spillover events were common?
The 2.7% seropositivity for the high risk group of residents living in close proximity to bat colonies suggests that spillover is a relatively rare event, however this depends on how long antibodies persist in people, since other individuals may have been exposed and antibodies waned. During questioning, none of the 6 seropositive subjects could recall any clinical symptoms in the past 12 months, suggesting that their bat SARSr-CoV infection either occurred before the time of sampling, or that infections were subclinical or caused only mild symptoms.
Lies damned lies and statistics.
Daszak and Shi added some speculative numbers to the letter's original conclusion.
A strategy to assess spillover risk of bat SARS-related coronaviruses in Southeast Asia
We then use probabilistic risk assessment and data on human-bat contact, human viral seroprevalence, and antibody duration to estimate that a median of 66,280 people (95% CI: 65,351–67,131) are infected with SARSr-CoVs annually in Southeast Asia.


Bottom line though inconclusive without further investigation:
Taken together, the available evidence does not point definitively toward a natural origin for SARS-CoV-2, rather, much of it is more consistent with what would be found if the novel coronavirus had arisen from serial passage of a “precursor” progenitor virus in a lab, or from bats infecting a commercial mink farm somewhere in China, which would also provide the conditions for serial passage. However, more evidence is required before a conclusive judgement can be made one way or the other.
No infected mink farm population has of yet been found.


I did overlap a bit to Daszak's documented dishonesty there. I may come back to that in another installment of "Stop Claiming the Evidence for a Lab Origin Is all Smoke and Mirrors that Will Disappear Like a Mirage."
 
Last edited:
Yay a citation. Daszak is one of the authors and the article lists competing interests.

It's not just that Daszak was on this team, he has a direct conflict of interest as he's implicated and he stands to lose millions in grant money if a lab origin is determined. And he was accused of penning a letter to the Lancet and dishonestly covering up the fact he wrote it when he asked other scientists to sign on.
That paper had 14 co-authors. If Daszak's co-authorship is reason to dismiss that paper, then we should apply similar criteria when considering other papers.

That paper was discussed here back in April. It has two co-authors: Karl Sirotkin and Dan Sirotkin.

The paper you quote seems to be from people in Florida with no back ground in virology. They just speculate, they provide no evidence of anything.
Although I have seen reports that Karl Sirotkin might have a background in genetics, all 7 of the publications listed on his ResearchGate page are related to the lab leak hypothesis. Under "Disciplines", he listed only one: "Linguistics", with "Composition Studies" as the specific topic.

Dan Sirotkin is Karl Sirotkin's son. Dan has said he attended Harvard and completed a bachelor's degree in political science. His employment history describes valuable experience as a janitor, waiter, and inmate.
 
Might SARS-CoV-2 Have Arisen via Serial Passage through an Animal Host or Cell Culture?
But wait, Shi denied doing GoF research on coronaviruses. Of course it's been claimed Shi never made such an assertion despite the fact it is easily confirmed from multiple sources including some cited in this thread.
As noted above, neither author had any previous experience in virology so they were not in any position to know who had and hadn't been conducing GoF research. They fail to cite any other source for their claims.

We do know that GoF research does occur, because it's a critical tool in identifying viruses which pose a pandemic risk. This doesn't tell us anything about whether Shi was doing this type of research, nor have you provided a legitimate source for claims she was.



Oh look, Daszak and Shi signed the 2018 letter:
Right out of the box, ready to go within a dozen miles of the WIV and hundreds of miles from the caves.

What exactly is this supposed to tell us? All it says is that people who live near bat caves become infected with various Corona viruses on some rare (2.7%) occasions. But so what?
 
Gain of function research is not synonymous with genetic manipulation. Calling it gain of function research does not make it so. The 'humanised' mice were genetically manipulated so they expressed human ACE2 rather than murine ACE2; was that gain of function? Replication deficient viral chimeras were produced expressing spike proteins from wild type sarbecovirus is that gain of function? Is a male Homo sapiens transfected with an adenovirus associated virus carrying a functional F8 gene gain of function?*

I think the term 'gain of function' has come to have a pejorative tone. It contributes nothing. We should just talk about the actual manipulation done in mechanistic terms.

I have quoted several papers where the research done with WIV has been reviewed and has been defined as 'NOT gain of function'. Arguing about whether research done by Shi was gain of function or not is fruitless instead we should just talk about the actual mechanics and consequences.

We have come to the point where calling the research 'gain of function' means that the researchers did something evil in their lair. I.m pretty sure that people imagine Shi sitting their stroking her cat (or perhaps bat), before unleashing a virus on the world. (Where was 007?)

As several experts have said with the techniques and knowledge available in 2019 no one could have created SARS-CoV-2. Whether you call it gain of function research or not is irrelevant, it just would not have been possible to create SARS-CoV-2 in a laboratory in 2019. The only viable laboratory leak hypothesis is the simplest one, that a laboratory had a virus imported from the wild that was SARs-CoV-2.

* Probably a gain for the individual but on a normative basis really restoration of function.
 
Last edited:
Gain of function research is not synonymous with genetic manipulation. Calling it gain of function research does not make it so. The 'humanised' mice were genetically manipulated so they expressed human ACE2 rather than murine ACE2; was that gain of function? Replication deficient viral chimeras were produced expressing spike proteins from wild type sarbecovirus is that gain of function? Is a male Homo sapiens transfected with an adenovirus associated virus carrying a functional F8 gene gain of function?*

I think the term 'gain of function' has come to have a pejorative tone. It contributes nothing. We should just talk about the actual manipulation done in mechanistic terms.

I have quoted several papers where the research done with WIV has been reviewed and has been defined as 'NOT gain of function'. Arguing about whether research done by Shi was gain of function or not is fruitless instead we should just talk about the actual mechanics and consequences.

We have come to the point where calling the research 'gain of function' means that the researchers did something evil in their lair. I.m pretty sure that people imagine Shi sitting their stroking her cat (or perhaps bat), before unleashing a virus on the world. (Where was 007?)

As several experts have said with the techniques and knowledge available in 2019 no one could have created SARS-CoV-2. Whether you call it gain of function research or not is irrelevant, it just would not have been possible to create SARS-CoV-2 in a laboratory in 2019. The only viable laboratory leak hypothesis is the simplest one, that a laboratory had a virus imported from the wild that was SARs-CoV-2.

* Probably a gain for the individual but on a normative basis really restoration of function.


Yeah, we get it. It's only gain of function if it's carried out in the Gaine de Function region of France.
 
Yeah, we get it. It's only gain of function if it's carried out in the Gaine de Function region of France.
Words are supposed to convey meaning.

Unfortunately the right wing blogosphere and right wing politicians have taken to erasing the meaning of words and phrases like Socialism, Woke, or critical race theory so they can use them as simple pejoratives and scare tactics to attack their political opponents.

Gain of Function is receiving the same treatment. This mainly seems to circulating in right wing the anti-science anti-vax crowd who are already familiar with and vulnerable to the technique. That is, erase the actual meaning so you can use it as a scare tactic to attack science and scientists who are simply trying to identify viruses with the potential to cause pandemics or identify targets for vaccines.

Gain of function research can have potential dangers but this needs to be weighed against the benefits. Coming off a pandemic that has caused 7 million deaths and counting it seems almost criminal to attack the research that could prevent the next major pandemic.
 
Regarding the serial passage issue in Shi’s lab. Her published work shows that the permissive cell line she used was Vero E6 which was later (2021) discovered to delete the furin cleavage site. Clearly this would not produce SARS-COV-2.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24172901/

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34140522/

This is great. I wish you would stick around long enough to discuss it. I found other sources that also showed the furin site disappeared when passed through VeroE6 cell cultures.

But one must then ask how did COVID 19 acquire the furin cleavage site in the wild? And I'm not suggesting this counters the disappearance in serial passages I am however suggesting that serial passages might not have been the only thing being done to manipulate coronaviruses in the lab.

Especially given no trail has yet been found of COVID 19 or anything close to it evolving in the wild and leaping from wherever that occurred into humans near the WIV in Wuhan? No closely related coronaviruses have a furin cleavage site.

The spike glycoprotein of the new coronavirus 2019-nCoV contains a furin-like cleavage site absent in CoV of the same clade
Since furin is highly expressed in lungs, an enveloped virus that infects the respiratory tract may successfully exploit this convertase to activate its surface glycoprotein (Bassi et al., 2017; Mbikay et al., 1997). Before the emergence of the 2019-nCoV, this important feature was not observed in the lineage b of betacoronaviruses. However, it is shared by other CoV (HCoV-OC43, MERS-CoV, MHV-A59) harbouring furin-like cleavage sites in their S-protein (Fig. 2; Table 1), which were shown to be processed by furin experimentally (Le Coupanec et al., 2015; Mille and Whittaker, 2014). Strikingly, the 2019-nCoV S-protein sequence contains 12 additional nucleotides upstream of the single Arg↓ cleavage site 1 (Fig. 1, Fig. 2) leading to a predictively solvent-exposed PRRAR↓SV sequence, which corresponds to a canonical furin-like cleavage site (Braun and Sauter, 2019; Izaguirre, 2019; Seidah and Prat, 2012). This furin-like cleavage site, is supposed to be cleaved during virus egress (Mille and Whittaker, 2014) for S-protein “priming” and may provide a gain-of-function to the 2019-nCoV for efficient spreading in the human population compared to other lineage b betacoronaviruses. This possibly illustrates a convergent evolution pathway between unrelated CoVs. Interestingly, if this site is not processed, the S-protein is expected to be cleaved at site 2 during virus endocytosis, as observed for the SARS-CoV.

Recombinate coronaviruses exist They don't all change by genetic drift. In influenza viruses genetic shift (recombinant) and genetic drift are detectable in the resulting viral clade.

Interview with Caltech's David Baltimore, president emeritus and Distinguished Professor of Biology, is a virologist who received the Nobel Prize for his research into viral genetics. ...

... Similar viruses before it have been shown to have jumped from animals to humans; yet this link has not yet been definitively found for SARS-CoV-2. ...

... But the fact that evolution might have been able to generate SARS-CoV-2 doesn't mean that that's how it came about. I think we very much need to find out what was happening in the Wuhan Institute of Virology. I think that we can't say for sure yet whether the SARS-CoV-2 virus came from natural origins or if it was genetically manipulated somehow. ...

Now, within the SARS-CoV-2 genome there is an insertion of 12 nucleotides that is entirely foreign to the beta-coronavirus class of virus that SARS-CoV-2 is in. There are many other viruses in this class, including the closest relative of SARS-CoV-2 by sequence, and none of them have this sequence. The sequence is called the furin cleavage site. ...

I'm perfectly willing to believe that happened, but I don't think it's the only way that that sequence could have appeared. The other way is that somebody could have put it in there. You can't distinguish between the two origins from just looking at the sequence. So, naturally, you want to know were there people in the virology laboratory in Wuhan who were manipulating viral genetic sequences? It's really a question of history: What happened?

When I first saw the sequence of the furin cleavage site—as I've said, other beta coronaviruses don't have that site—it seemed to me a reasonable hypothesis that somebody had put it in there. Now, I don't know if that's true or not, but I do know that it's a hypothesis that must be taken seriously.
 
Especially given no trail has yet been found of COVID 19 or anything close to it evolving in the wild and leaping from wherever that occurred into humans near the WIV in Wuhan?

The wildlife trade is a massive national scale industry in China, animals are shipped all over the country. There is absolutly no reason to think the wild virus came from anywhere near Wuhan. And yes a trail has been found in SE China, that's where BANAL-20-52 were found, and as noted above the Spike protein in this virus diverged from SARS-CoV-2 as little as 10 years ago.

But one must then ask how did COVID 19 acquire the furin cleavage site in the wild? And I'm not suggesting this counters the disappearance in serial passages I am however suggesting that serial passages might not have been the only thing being done to manipulate coronaviruses in the lab.

See below. Furin cleavage sites have evolved multiple times in the wild in Corona viruses. As for putting one there deliberately the there is strong evidence this didn't happen. Prior to seeing SARS-CoV-2 there was no reason to think such a site was important. the site itself is only a partial cleavage site not a full one you'd expect from a deliberate insertion, and the site is out of frame a basic mistake no virologist would make especially not one with the ultra level of genius required to intuit putting in such a site.


False and/or outdated information. Furnin cleavage site has evolved multiple times in Corona viruses.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1873506120304165
The spike protein is a focused target of COVID-19, a pandemic caused by SARS-CoV-2. A 12-nt insertion at S1/S2 in the spike coding sequence yields a furin cleavage site, which raised controversy views on origin of the virus. Here we analyzed the phylogenetic relationships of coronavirus spike proteins and mapped furin recognition motif on the tree. Furin cleavage sites occurred independently for multiple times in the evolution of the coronavirus family, supporting the natural occurring hypothesis of SARS-CoV-2.


SARS-CoV-2 furin cleavage site was not engineered

Alignment of the nucleotide sequence of the SARS-CoV-2
Spike gene with the closest known coronavirus Spike gene
from Laotian bat coronavirus BANAL-20-52 (5) clearly
shows that four extra amino acids (PRRA), not eight, were
added to the SARS-CoV-2 Spike protein (Fig. 1B).
• There was an insertion of 12 nucleotides into the Spike
gene (Fig. 1B, box) (6). This nucleotide insertion is out of
frame (6, 7).
• The insertion adds a proline not present in ENaC.
• Except for one codon (cgu that encodes arginine 685),
each of the codons for RRARSVAS is different in human
ENaC and SARS-CoV-2 (Fig. 1B).
• Five of eight amino acids (RSVAS; underlined in Fig. 1A,
red box in Fig. 1C) in or near the ENaC FCS sequence
shared with SARS-Cov-2 Spike are present in Spikes of
sarbecoviruses, such as BANAL-20-52. It would be illogi-
cal to use the FCS from ENac rather than from a FCS of
another coronavirus
 
Last edited:
This is great. I wish you would stick around long enough to discuss it. I found other sources that also showed the furin site disappeared when passed through VeroE6 cell cultures.

But one must then ask how did COVID 19 acquire the furin cleavage site in the wild? And I'm not suggesting this counters the disappearance in serial passages I am however suggesting that serial passages might not have been the only thing being done to manipulate coronaviruses in the lab.

Especially given no trail has yet been found of COVID 19 or anything close to it evolving in the wild and leaping from wherever that occurred into humans near the WIV in Wuhan? No closely related coronaviruses have a furin cleavage site.

The spike glycoprotein of the new coronavirus 2019-nCoV contains a furin-like cleavage site absent in CoV of the same clade


Recombinate coronaviruses exist They don't all change by genetic drift. In influenza viruses genetic shift (recombinant) and genetic drift are detectable in the resulting viral clade.

Interview with Caltech's David Baltimore, president emeritus and Distinguished Professor of Biology, is a virologist who received the Nobel Prize for his research into viral genetics. ...

Argument from ignorance by old white man.

He says no beta coronaviruses have a Furin cleavage site therefore this is suspicious .

this is invalidated by the subsequent discovery of a wild beta coronavirus with a Furin cleavage site.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2352771421000720
https://pdf.sciencedirectassets.com...457065c525255535101&rr=7e224133cd5976f9&cc=gb

This is a good review for various explanations of the origins on SARS-CoV-2.
https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/jvi.00365-23
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom