Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Nothing in your quote says there was gain of function research. Not all research on viruses even that involving genetic manipulation is gain of function research.
Way to highlight a cherry-picked sentence ignoring the rest of the quote. Allow me to highlight the important bits you missed.
We assess that some scientists at the WIV have genetically engineered coronaviruses using common laboratory practices. The IC has no information, however, indicating that any WIV genetic engineering work has involved SARS-CoV-2, a close progenitor, or a backbone virus that is closely-related enough to have been the source of the pandemic.

• Scientists at the WIV have created chimeras, or combinations, of SARS-like coronaviruses through genetic engineering, attempted to clone other unrelated infectious viruses, and used reverse genetic cloning techniques on SARS-like coronaviruses
No information =/= evidence against the finding. What do you suppose happened with all those specimens created with "reverse genetic cloning techniques on SARS-like coronaviruses"? Not GoF then WTF was the goal?

How much more incriminating could the report have been than that?

Never fear, we have Daszak on video in an interview saying their goal was to create a manipulated coronavirus so they could use it to develop a vaccine ahead of the next coronavirus spillover. The ECA's grant application said the same thing. They didn't intend to make a more dangerous SARS-like CoV, that was an accident. An accident that was predictable which is one reason the grant application was denied. It's clear Shi got funding elsewhere.

The quote says there is evidence that genetic engineering research was commonly done on coronaviruses but no evidence COVID itself was lab created, so you can't make the leap either? Gee we have evidence research was being done on manipulated coronaviruses at the WIV but they didn't find any evidence of COVID itself in the lab. Must not have been any. Oh wait, the report only says the viruses were being manipulated but to what end isn't stated. :rolleyes:

Do you imagine Spy Tom Cruise on a mission impossible sneaking into the WIV and finding the bit of evidence Shi had not gotten rid of?

Or is the fantasy that Shi was so honorable that despite fear of losing everything, going to jail, and the crushing public revelation her research killed millions she would have come clean if it were true.

Scientists are unable to be dishonest, none has ever once published fabricated evidence in a study. Whoops requires a leap to find that is relative to Shi and Daszak lying.

And Daszak, not greedy in the least, would have admitted what he knew and resigned immediately from the EHA. Sure. :rolleyes:


None of the quotes said Shi lied let alone provided evidence. Shi says that SARS-CoV-2 did not originate from her laboratory, you disagree. Your opinion is not evidence Shi lied.
You've ignored the evidence no matter how many times I've posted the citations of the evidence. An evidence supported conclusion is not one pulled out of one's ass. How can you tell?

My evidence is backed with citation after citation in this thread. I see almost no citations in your posts. And the cites you do post are seriously out of date like referencing the work Shi did at the UNC with Dr Baric without recognizing that was a few years before she took what she learned back to the WIV along with his humanized mice. What do you imagine Shi did with those humanized mice if they had no live cultures at the WIV?
I don't think everyone reading this thread has ignored the evidence.
Live bats, found at the WIV including pictures of the cages, an application for a special bat cage design, and a students request for someone to take care of the bats as he was going out of town

Live humanized mice sent to the WIV from Dr Baric

No live cultures claimed despite a paper as recently as 2019 and 2017 describing the in vitro research done at the WIV,

and despite Daszak saying on video in his own words how easy it was to manipulate coronaviruses in the lab

Claiming the miners in Yunnan died of a fungal infection when there is overwhelming evidence from multiple sources they died from a viral pneumonia

Collecting specimens from the mine and other caves in Yunnan for >10 years then claiming they had no cultures or frozen specimens, only genome records, and even those records have not been readily shared with other scientists, only one conveniently not very close to the COVID genome​
Nope, Shi's denials of the above couldn't have been a lie. :rolleyes:


I agree [with Lomiller]. A laboratory leak could have happened anywhere, and has done.

The mass importation of rare species from the wild for food and medicine is a Chinese peculiarity, a part of Chinese culture the Chinese government has been reluctant to put a stop to. [snipped the rest of this argument].
But there was no specific finding of a COVID spillover. No finding of a closely related virus circulating anywhere in China. No initial outbreak of COVID outside of Wuhan, and more than that, no outbreak anywhere except close to the WIV.

Don't you think it's a bit hypocritical to claim an unsupported assertion with no evidence other than it happened in the past, but when it comes to the lab origin hypothesis, no amount of actual evidence matters because COVID wasn't found by our spies ;) in the labs at the WIV?
 
Last edited:
No finding of a closely related virus circulating anywhere in China.

The lack of a candidate virus is more damning for a lab leak than it is for zoonosis. It often takes decades to find the wild progenitor of a virus, if it can be found at all. On the other hand a lab leak REQUIRES such a virus to have already been found.

In any case very close relatives of SARS-CoV-2 have been found, including 1 with a spike protein that diverged from Covid 19 as little as 10 years ago.

no outbreak anywhere except close to the WIV.
The outbreak was close to the Wuhan fish market, not any lab run by the WiV.

The presence of both A and B lineages in the Wuhan fish market precludes any sustained human outbreak anyplace else. There was, of course, and animal outbreak that preceded the zoonotic crossover to humans.
 
You may have noticed I don't answer many of your posts but I thought I would address a couple falsehoods here because they are so odd.

The lack of a candidate virus is more damning for a lab leak than it is for zoonosis. It often takes decades to find the wild progenitor of a virus, if it can be found at all.
Pay attention: no circulating virus close to COVID, not in an intermediate species, not circulating in any bat populations, no other outbreaks in China initially or even in Wuhan for that matter. What was this the immaculate infection? Appeared out of the blue in some wild animal sold in the seafood market but didn't find its way to any other market? Didn't infect any animal handlers along the way to the market?


On the other hand a lab leak REQUIRES such a virus to have already been found.
This is what I mean by an odd statement. It has been found: it's called COVID 19. What were you expecting to see? :boggled:


... In any case very close relatives of SARS-CoV-2 have been found, including 1 with a spike protein that diverged from Covid 19 as little as 10 years ago.
(*bold is mine) Diverged from COVID 19? :confused: Is that an inadvertent error?

Spike proteins are found in all coronaviruses. It's what the "corona" in coronavirus refers to.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coronavirus_spike_protein
Spike (S) glycoprotein (sometimes also called spike protein, [2] formerly known as E2 [3]) is the largest of the four major structural proteins found in coronaviruses.[4] ... The distinctive appearance of these spikes when visualized using negative stain transmission electron microscopy, "recalling the solar corona",[6] gives the virus family its main name.[2]


The outbreak was close to the Wuhan fish market, not any lab run by the WiV.
The CCDC lab was within a mile of the seafood market and the WIV was within a dozen miles of the Market, relatively very close depending on the scale you want to use. You think no one from the WIV ever shopped at the seafood market or lived near it? :boggled:

Have you ever looked at a map of the city of Wuhan? You should.

Scroll up to the beginning of the article, there is a map near the top that shows something quite different from Worobey's map. (Ignore the article's reference to the Chinese military working closely with the WIV as I think there is evidence of that but it needs more exploring.)


The presence of both A and B lineages in the Wuhan fish market precludes any sustained human outbreak anyplace else. There was, of course, and animal outbreak that preceded the zoonotic crossover to humans.
Seriously? :confused:

No it doesn't. Some virologists have seen the evidence and they find genetically lineage A occurred early and the closely related lineage B variant occurred later. Lineage B soon dominated the early cases and IIRC lineage A found its way to parts of Asia. I'd have to review those findings but it was something like that.
 
You may have noticed I don't answer many of your posts but I thought I would address a couple falsehoods here because they are so odd.

Pay attention: no circulating virus close to COVID, not in an intermediate species, not circulating in any bat populations, no other outbreaks in China initially or even in Wuhan for that matter. What was this the immaculate infection? Appeared out of the blue in some wild animal sold in the seafood market but didn't find its way to any other market? Didn't infect any animal handlers along the way to the market?


This is what I mean by an odd statement. It has been found: it's called COVID 19. What were you expecting to see? :boggled:


(*bold is mine) Diverged from COVID 19? :confused: Is that an inadvertent error?

Spike proteins are found in all coronaviruses. It's what the "corona" in coronavirus refers to.


The CCDC lab was within a mile of the seafood market and the WIV was within a dozen miles of the Market, relatively very close depending on the scale you want to use. You think no one from the WIV ever shopped at the seafood market or lived near it? :boggled:

Have you ever looked at a map of the city of Wuhan? You should.

Scroll up to the beginning of the article, there is a map near the top that shows something quite different from Worobey's map. (Ignore the article's reference to the Chinese military working closely with the WIV as I think there is evidence of that but it needs more exploring.)


Seriously? :confused:

No it doesn't. Some virologists have seen the evidence and they find genetically lineage A occurred early and the closely related lineage B variant occurred later. Lineage B soon dominated the early cases and IIRC lineage A found its way to parts of Asia. I'd have to review those findings but it was something like that.

By definition if there was a laboratory leak, then SARS-CoV-2 or a precursor virus would have had to have been found prior to the pandemic. The nature of coronaviruses would suggest it would be found with a cluster of related viruses due to divergence and exchange of genetic material. A natural cross ver event does not require any prior knowledge of SARS-CoV-2.

The spike protein evolves / mutates. It is important in host specificity and in immune escape. The degree of relatedness of spike proteins is one factor in determining time since virus isolates underwent evolutionary divergence.

Distribution of the inferred recombination events is nonrandom with evidence that Spike, the main target for humoral immunity, is beside a recombination hotspot likely driving antigenic shift events in the ancestry of bat sarbecoviruses. Coupled with the geographic ranges of their hosts and the sampling locations, across southern China, and into Southeast Asia, we confirm that horseshoe bats, Rhinolophus, are the likely reservoir species for the SARS-CoV-2 progenitor. By tracing the recombinant sequence patterns, we conclude that there has been relatively recent geographic movement and cocirculation of these viruses’ ancestors, extending across their bat host ranges in China and Southeast Asia over the last 100 years. We confirm that a direct proximal ancestor to SARS-CoV-2 has not yet been sampled, since the closest known relatives collected in Yunnan shared a common ancestor with SARS-CoV-2 approximately 40 years ago. Our analysis highlights the need for dramatically more wildlife sampling to: 1) pinpoint the exact origins of SARS-CoV-2’s animal progenitor, 2) the intermediate species that facilitated transmission from bats to humans (if there is one), and 3) survey the extent of the diversity in the related sarbecoviruses’ phylogeny that present high risk for future spillovers.
https://academic.oup.com/gbe/article/14/2/evac018/6524630

This is an example of ongoing work producing chimeric viruses (not not called gain of function). The group identified a novel Russian coronavirus studies showed that it would bind to human ACE2, that chimeric viruses were pathogenic and antibodies from people with natural covid-19 infection or those vaccinated against covid-19 did not protect against infection with this virus.
This flags up the need (as was in the Ecohealth research plans) to try and develop a pan-coronavirus vaccine as the risk of a pandemic from a novel corona-virus arising in Africa or the Americas or Europe remains.
https://journals.plos.org/plospathogens/article?id=10.1371/journal.ppat.1010828

Using similar methodology (but not 'gain of function') this group shows that there are closely related viruses to SARS-CoV-2 in pangolins and that at least one was potentially infectious in humans. In contrast to the distantly related Russian virus there was apparent cross immunity with SARS-CoV-2.

Virus spillover remains a major challenge to public health. A panel of SARS-CoV-2-related coronaviruses have been identified in pangolins, while the infectivity and pathogenicity of these pangolin-origin coronaviruses (pCoV) in humans remain largely unknown. Herein, we comprehensively characterized the infectivity and pathogenicity of a recent pCoV isolate (pCoV-GD01) in human cells and human tracheal epithelium organoids and established animal models in comparison with SARS-CoV-2. pCoV-GD01 showed similar infectivity to SARS-CoV-2 in human cells and organoids. Remarkably, intranasal inoculation of pCoV-GD01 caused severe lung pathological damage in hACE2 mice and could transmit among cocaged hamsters. Interestingly, in vitro neutralization assays and animal heterologous challenge experiments demonstrated that preexisting immunity induced by SARS-CoV-2 infection or vaccination was sufficient to provide at least partial cross-protection against pCoV-GD01 challenge. Our results provide direct evidence supporting pCoV-GD01 as a potential human pathogen and highlight the potential spillover risk.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41421-023-00557-9
 
By definition if there was a laboratory leak, then SARS-CoV-2 or a precursor virus would have had to have been found prior to the pandemic. The nature of coronaviruses would suggest it would be found with a cluster of related viruses due to divergence and exchange of genetic material. A natural cross ver event does not require any prior knowledge of SARS-CoV-2.


https://academic.oup.com/gbe/article/14/2/evac018/6524630

This is an example of ongoing work producing chimeric viruses (not not called gain of function). The group identified a novel Russian coronavirus studies showed that it would bind to human ACE2, that chimeric viruses were pathogenic and antibodies from people with natural covid-19 infection or those vaccinated against covid-19 did not protect against infection with this virus.
This flags up the need (as was in the Ecohealth research plans) to try and develop a pan-coronavirus vaccine as the risk of a pandemic from a novel corona-virus arising in Africa or the Americas or Europe remains.
https://journals.plos.org/plospathogens/article?id=10.1371/journal.ppat.1010828

Using similar methodology (but not 'gain of function') this group shows that there are closely related viruses to SARS-CoV-2 in pangolins and that at least one was potentially infectious in humans. In contrast to the distantly related Russian virus there was apparent cross immunity with SARS-CoV-2.


https://www.nature.com/articles/s41421-023-00557-9
I find all this interesting, I was listening to Sarah Haider and Meghan Daum, two kind of clever contemporary Podcasters, one of whom said 99% was a low number for the lab leak probability. They even cited that "gain of function" as a term could lead to censure, job loss etc. to spice it up some.
So I checked back here thinking to update to the new reality.
Surprisingly, or not, you and SG seem to have not shifted one iota.
I am never sure if facts are more interesting than the notion we all have our own facts.
I back you Planigale, because your dominoes seem to be set nicely from premise to conclusion, but I could be wrong.
 
Last edited:
I find all this interesting, I was listening to Sarah Haider and Meghan Daum, two kind of clever contemporary Podcasters, one of whom said 99% was a low number for the lab leak probability. They even cited that "gain of function" as a term could lead to censure, job loss etc. to spice it up some.
So I checked back here thinking to update to the new reality.
Surprisingly, or not, you and SG seem to have not shifted one iota.
I am never sure if facts are more interesting than the notion we all have our own facts.
I back you Planigale, because your dominoes seem to be set nicely from premise to conclusion, but I could be wrong.

Thanks, but I think it important to emphasise that it is entirely reasonable to consider a laboratory leak, and it is possible that evidence to favour this might appear. However, I come from the default that what we expected to happen and so the most likely to happen was a cross over event. This was a highly likely event. The most parsomious explanation for a laboratory leak is the leakage of newly discovered virus that was an immediate precursor to SARs-CoV-2, but there is o evidence that WIV had this. Also it is fairly clear that so little virus is found in the samples that were collected that it would be extremely unlikely that an infectious quantity of viable virus would be in any sample.

Then you have to get onto conspiracies of secret research and scary sounding 'gain of function' research and a secret bat lab where bats were kept together with the bat mobile (a rapid response bat collecting vehicle). I am not sure of the relevance of the bat laboratory, perhaps the idea is that a wild bat was brought in that carried SARS-CoV-2 but then this becomes a cross over event and not really a laboratory leak. The problem then is whether you believe anonymous internet posters who claim they have pictures of bays at WIV or those who worked and visited the WIV lab and say that these are false. Who is more likely to be lying an anonymous internet poster or several named and well known virologists who are of a variety of nationalities.

The evidence for the laboratory leak theory is all smoke and mirrors, when you look into it, it vanishes like a mirage. It is all anonymous quotes in newspapers or internet sites. It is all hypothetical if this happened then this happened then WIV might have created a novel coronavirus, then they would lie about it. They deny they did any of those things, so they must be lying, why would they lie if they had nothing to hide? Since they deny creating the virus they must have done so. We are really into the Spanish Inquisition model, you are guilty, but we will torture you until you confess as that is the only way to save your eternal soul.
 
Pay attention: no circulating virus close to COVID, not in an intermediate species, not circulating in any bat populations, no other outbreaks in China initially or even in Wuhan for that matter.

False. Environmental samples show that 2 different Covid lineages were circulating in the animals kept at the at the Wuhan fish market.

wrt outbreaks anyplace else: The first successfully jump from animals to humans occurred at the Wuhan Fish Market, why would you expect to outbreaks anyplace else?



(*bold is mine) Diverged from COVID 19? :confused: Is that an inadvertent error?

Spike proteins are found in all coronaviruses. It's what the "corona" in coronavirus refers to.

Are you being deliberately obtuse or do you not realize that proteins are created from DNA\RNA and their evolution can be tracked and even timed with genetic clocks. The RNA that codes for the Spike protein in SARS-CoV-2 is thought to have diverged from that of BANAL-52 approximately a 10 years ago.



The CCDC lab was within a mile of the seafood market

So the "leak" came from the CCDC not the WiV? If so why have you wasted so much of our time accusing scientist from the WiV?

Every major city in the world has multiple labs, so there will always be a nearby lab regardless of which city an outbreak starts in.



the WIV was within a dozen miles of the Market, relatively very close depending on the scale you want to use.

And all the early cases were in people who visited the market or lived within 1Km of the market.



You think no one from the WIV ever shopped at the seafood market or lived near it?
And somehow carried it to the market without spreading it to anyone else, and didn't spread it to anyone else the entire time they were sick? I think the chances are pretty low already.

Factor in the fact this exact sequence of events needed to happen twice with different lineages of the virus and you are claiming something that seems nearly impossible.



Seriously? :confused:

No it doesn't. Some virologists have seen the evidence and they find genetically lineage A occurred early and the closely related lineage B variant occurred later. Lineage B soon dominated the early cases and IIRC lineage A found its way to parts of Asia. I'd have to review those findings but it was something like that.


What is relevant is that the divergence between the two seems to be before epidemiological evidence says the first human infection occurred. This is difficult to explain if it were a lab leak, because you would need not just 1 but 2 separate leaks both of which got carried to the market and no place else along the way.

For a zoonotic event it's easy to explain as the divergence occurring in animals before the first human infections occurred.






The CCDC lab was within a mile of the seafood market and the WIV was within a dozen miles of the Market, relatively very close depending on the scale you want to use. You think no one from the WIV ever shopped at the seafood market or lived near it? :boggled:

Have you ever looked at a map of the city of Wuhan? You should.

Scroll up to the beginning of the article, there is a map near the top that shows something quite different from Worobey's map. (Ignore the article's reference to the Chinese military working closely with the WIV as I think there is evidence of that but it needs more exploring.)


Seriously? :confused:

No it doesn't. Some virologists have seen the evidence and they find genetically lineage A occurred early and the closely related lineage B variant occurred later. Lineage B soon dominated the early cases and IIRC lineage A found its way to parts of Asia. I'd have to review those findings but it was something like that.
 
I find all this interesting, I was listening to Sarah Haider and Meghan Daum, two kind of clever contemporary Podcasters, one of whom said 99% was a low number for the lab leak probability. They even cited that "gain of function" as a term could lead to censure, job loss etc. to spice it up some.

Who are these people and what are their credentials that make their opinions on the subject more valuable than any random person on the street?

IMO if you want a podcast that covers this issue you should look at the "This Week in Virology" series where they have virologists and infectious disease experts discussing many different issues, but obviously Covid is a recurring one. Here is a special panel they conducted discussing Covid origins.

 
Thanks, but I think it important to emphasise that it is entirely reasonable to consider a laboratory leak, and it is possible that evidence to favour this might appear.
Of course. :rolleyes:

Probably a good idea considering your current POV is a couple of years out of date.

May 2021: Top researchers are calling for a real investigation into the origin of covid-19 -- A group of prominent biologists say there needs to be a “safe space” for asking whether the coronavirus came out of a lab.
A year ago, the idea that the covid-19 pandemic could have been caused by a laboratory accident was denounced as a conspiracy theory by the world’s leading journals, scientists, and news organizations.

But the origin of the virus that has killed millions remains a mystery, and the chance that it came from a lab has become the theory that cannot be put to rest.

Now, in a letter in the journal Science, 18 prominent biologists—including the world’s foremost coronavirus researcher—are lending their weight to calls for a new investigation of all possible origins of the virus, and calling on China’s laboratories and agencies to “open their records” to independent analysis.
“We must take hypotheses about both natural and laboratory spillovers seriously until we have sufficient data,” the scientists write.
Not anonymous sources from a news article. Not a group of fringe scientists. Not smoke and mirrors.

Here's the letter.

Here are the signatories:
JESSE D. BLOOM, YUJIA ALINA CHAN, RALPH S. BARIC, PAMELA J. BJORKMAN, SARAH COBEY, BENJAMIN E. DEVERMAN, DAVID N. FISMAN, RAVINDRA GUPTA, AKIKO IWASAKI, MARC LIPSITCH, RUSLAN MEDZHITOV, RICHARD A. NEHER, RASMUS NIELSEN, NICK PATTERSON, TIM STEARNS, ERIK VAN NIMWEGEN, MICHAEL WOROBEY, AND DAVID A. RELMAN
Bloom has remained neutral all along. Baric Knows the WIV and Shi well. Worobey has gone back to thinking he proved the market origin. He didn't.​

The letter, which was organized by the Stanford University microbiologist David Relman and the University of Washington virologist Jesse Bloom, takes aim at a recent joint study of covid origins undertaken by the World Health Organization and China, which concluded that a bat virus likely reached humans via an intermediate animal and that a lab accident was “extremely unlikely.”

That conclusion was not scientifically justified, according to the authors of the new letter, since no trace of how the virus first jumped to humans has been found and the possibility of a laboratory accident received only a cursory look. Just a handful of the 313 pages of the WHO origins report and its annexes are devoted to the subject.
Concluding it was a spillover and excluding the lab origin hypothesis "was not scientifically justified".

It seems some people in this thread missed that memo.


Marc Lipsitch, a well-known Harvard University epidemiologist who is among the signers of the letter, said he had not expressed a view on the origin of the virus until recently, ... “I stayed out of it because I was busy dealing with the outcome of the pandemic instead of the origin,” he says. “[But] when the WHO comes out with a report that makes a specious claim about an important topic … it’s worth speaking out.”
That would be the specious claim Daszak led the WHO investigation team to conclude.

Several of those signing the letter, including Lipsitch and Relman, have in the past called for greater scrutiny of “gain of function” research, in which viruses are genetically modified to make them more infectious or virulent. Experiments to engineer pathogens were also ongoing at the Wuhan Institute of Virology, China’s leading center for studying bat viruses similar to SARS-CoV-2. ....
Experiments? GoF? Ongoing at the WIV? But Shi and Daszak deny that. Fauci denies the NIH funded any GoF research at the WIV.

They weren't really doing GoF research. Call it something else, why not? Fauci used that semantic tap dance. It's a distraction from implicating NIH funding that had found its way to the WIV.

That's all a separate political issue.
 
Of course. :rolleyes:

Probably a good idea considering your current POV is a couple of years out of date.

May 2021: Top researchers are calling for a real investigation into the origin of covid-19 -- A group of prominent biologists say there needs to be a “safe space” for asking whether the coronavirus came out of a lab.
Not anonymous sources from a news article. Not a group of fringe scientists. Not smoke and mirrors.

Here's the letter.

Here are the signatories:
Bloom has remained neutral all along. Baric Knows the WIV and Shi well. Worobey has gone back to thinking he proved the market origin. He didn't.​

Concluding it was a spillover and excluding the lab origin hypothesis "was not scientifically justified".

It seems some people in this thread missed that memo.


That would be the specious claim Daszak led the WHO investigation team to conclude.

Experiments? GoF? Ongoing at the WIV? But Shi and Daszak deny that. Fauci denies the NIH funded any GoF research at the WIV.

They weren't really doing GoF research. Call it something else, why not? Fauci used that semantic tap dance. It's a distraction from implicating NIH funding that had found its way to the WIV.

That's all a separate political issue.

The campaign against gain of function research has co-opted the covid-19 pandemic to support their argument. This is despite the fact that none of the genetic manipulation carried out on SARS related viruses would meet the definition of gain of function.

There is no evidence that SARS-CoV-2 was the product of gain of function research. There is no way given current state of technology and science that SARS-CoV-2 could be the product of gain of function research. But the argument goes; gain of function research might cause a bad thing to happen, a bad thing happened, therefore gain of function research is to blame, therefore gain of function research should be banned.
 
Of course. :rolleyes:

Probably a good idea considering your current POV is a couple of years out of date.

May 2021: Top researchers are calling for a real investigation into the origin of covid-19 -- A group of prominent biologists say there needs to be a “safe space” for asking whether the coronavirus came out of a lab.
Not anonymous sources from a news article. Not a group of fringe scientists. Not smoke and mirrors.

Here's the letter.

Here are the signatories:
Bloom has remained neutral all along. Baric Knows the WIV and Shi well. Worobey has gone back to thinking he proved the market origin. He didn't.​

Concluding it was a spillover and excluding the lab origin hypothesis "was not scientifically justified".

It seems some people in this thread missed that memo.


That would be the specious claim Daszak led the WHO investigation team to conclude.

Experiments? GoF? Ongoing at the WIV? But Shi and Daszak deny that. Fauci denies the NIH funded any GoF research at the WIV.

They weren't really doing GoF research. Call it something else, why not? Fauci used that semantic tap dance. It's a distraction from implicating NIH funding that had found its way to the WIV.

That's all a separate political issue.

You do realise you are quoting a non-peer reviewed letter from 2021? I think it is you that is arguing based on articles on web sites (not journals), or newspapers that are two or more years old. I have referenced 2023 papers in journals. You are the one quoting outdated arguments. This letter was based on research available in early 2021, things have moved on.

You are doing the exact opposite of what the letter says, you are concluding that a laboratory leak theory is the explanation for Covid-19 pandemic.

'"We must take hypotheses about both natural and laboratory spillovers seriously until we have sufficient data"
 
[snipped irrelevant speculation] ... Then you have to get onto conspiracies of secret research and scary sounding 'gain of function' research and a secret bat lab where bats were kept together with the bat mobile (a rapid response bat collecting vehicle). I am not sure of the relevance of the bat laboratory, perhaps the idea is that a wild bat was brought in that carried SARS-CoV-2 but then this becomes a cross over event and not really a laboratory leak. The problem then is whether you believe anonymous internet posters who claim they have pictures of bays at WIV or those who worked and visited the WIV lab and say that these are false. Who is more likely to be lying an anonymous internet poster or several named and well known virologists who are of a variety of nationalities.

The evidence for the laboratory leak theory is all smoke and mirrors, when you look into it, it vanishes like a mirage. It is all anonymous quotes in newspapers or internet sites. It is all hypothetical if this happened then this happened then WIV might have created a novel coronavirus, then they would lie about it. They deny they did any of those things, so they must be lying, why would they lie if they had nothing to hide? Since they deny creating the virus they must have done so. We are really into the Spanish Inquisition model, you are guilty, but we will torture you until you confess as that is the only way to save your eternal soul.
(bold is mine) The typical go-to in this thread when folks can't produce convincing evidence supporting the spillover hypothesis is to dismiss evidence of the lab origin as if no virologists, no other researchers, no other investigators have been cited, as if all the citations posted in this thread are to anonymous news sources.

Evidence of the lab origin is nothing but smoke and mirrors? How would you know when you apparently, as of yet, have not even read the whole thread.

You cited papers when Shi worked with Baric back in 2013-2014. She hasn't worked directly with Baric since. They've been described as competitors after that time. Do you think Shi went home to the WIV and twiddled her thumbs for 5 years?
MIT Technology Review: Inside the risky bat-virus engineering that links America to Wuhan -- China emulated US techniques to construct novel coronaviruses in unsafe conditions. -- By Rowan Jacobsen -- June 29, 2021

That refers to Shi emulating Baric's techniques. It's not a secret. It's not hard to find multiple sources supporting this fact.

Is MIT Tech Review just a news paper and not a reliable source? I don't see a single anonymous source referred to in that paper.
In 2013, the American virologist Ralph Baric approached Zhengli Shi at a meeting. Baric was a top expert in coronaviruses, with hundreds of papers to his credit, and Shi, along with her team at the Wuhan Institute of Virology, had been discovering them by the fistful in bat caves. In one sample of bat guano, Shi had detected the genome of a new virus, called SHC014, that was one of the two closest relatives to the original SARS virus, but her team had not been able to culture it in the lab.
Before the COVID pandemic Shi was trying to pinpoint the original source of SARS in bats and eventually was credited with finding it.

"not been able to culture it" Keep that in mind because that changes and Shi denies any cultures were done at the WIV. It's called lying. :cool:

While Baric’s study was in progress, the National Institutes of Health announced that it would temporarily halt funding for “gain of function” research—experiments that make already dangerous viruses more virulent or transmissible—on SARS, MERS (which is also caused by a coronavirus), and influenza until the safety of such research could be assessed. The announcement brought Baric’s work to a standstill. ...
But not Shi's.


His 2015 paper, “A SARS-like cluster of circulating bat coronaviruses shows potential for human emergence,” was a tour de force, utilizing bleeding-edge genetic technology to alert the civilized world to a looming danger on its periphery. It also revived concerns about gain-of-function experiments, which Baric had known it would.
There's that pesky GoF research that has been denied in this thread.


In the paper, [Baric] spelled out the extra precautions he’d taken and held up the research as a test case. “The potential to prepare for and mitigate future outbreaks must be weighed against the risk of creating more dangerous pathogens,” he wrote. ...

The NIH decided the risk was worth it. In a potentially fateful decision, it funded work similar to Baric’s at the Wuhan Institute of Virology, which soon used its own reverse-genetics technology to make numerous coronavirus chimeras.


Shi learned the reverse-genetics techniques from Baric. But safety was traded for speed in researching SARS-like coronaviruses at the WIV that might develop in the wild and actually spillover.
Unnoticed by most, however, was a key difference that significantly shifted the risk calculation. The Chinese work was carried out at biosafety level 2 (BSL-2), a much lower tier than Baric’s BSL-3+.


Baric sent the transgenic mice with human lung receptors to Wuhan.
Why did Shi want these, no cultures were done at the WIV? :rolleyes:

The claim no cultures were done at the WIV is one of the more preposterous lies Shi has told, along with claiming the miners in Yunnan died of a fungal infection.
But after their initial collaboration, the two centers were more like competitors. They were in a race to identify dangerous coronaviruses, assess the potential threat, and develop countermeasures like vaccines.
Daszak made no secret of this. He said it in an interview at the Nipah conference in Dec 2019 just before he was aware a pandemic was beginning. He wrote it up in a grant proposal to DARPA.

How is it you or anyone else in this thread dismiss that very concrete evidence, claiming it's smoke and mirrors from anonymous sources in news articles? Willful blindness? Confirmation bias out of control?

These people are named, there is a video of Daszak saying how easy it was to manipulate coronaviruses in the lab, there is the DARPA grant application spelling out the intent of the research at the WIV, there are papers written in 2019 and earlier describing the work being done at that WIV.


By then, examples of such dangers were already being discovered by Shi’s team, which had spent years sampling bats in southern China to locate the origin of SARS. The project was part of a global viral surveillance effort spearheaded by the US nonprofit EcoHealth Alliance. ... The WIV was its crown jewel, and Peter Daszak, president of EcoHealth Alliance, has been a coauthor with Shi on most of her key papers.
Again this isn't from anonymous sources. It is directly from Shi and Daszak's own records.

By taking thousands of samples from guano, fecal swabs, and bat tissue, and searching those samples for genetic sequences similar to SARS, Shi’s team began to discover many closely related viruses. In a cave in Yunnan Province in 2011 or 2012, they discovered the two closest, which they named WIV1 and SHC014.

Shi managed to culture WIV1 in her lab from a fecal sample and show that it could directly infect human cells, proving that SARS-like viruses ready to leap straight from bats to humans already lurked in the natural world. This showed, Daszak and Shi argued, that bat coronaviruses were a “substantial global threat.” Scientists, they said, needed to find them, and study them, before they found us.
There's another pesky reference to culturing coronaviruses at the WIV. And keep in mind this is documented as being done in a BSL2 lab.

But Shi denied they had any live cultures in the WIV lab. :confused: Did she and Daszak lie about having live cultures at the WIV? Did Shi acknowledge the genomes of all those viruses they found in the caves in Yunnan? Where are they?


But it wasn't GoF research, riiight. Just a gain of more transmissibility. :rolleyes:

If there is any smoke and mirrors it is all the playing around with the GoF definition to get around the restrictions on GoF research. Call it whatever you want, Shi and her team manipulated SARS-like CoVs. They wrote papers about it, a research grant proposal about it was submitted to DARPA, and Daszak spoke about it at an interview at the Nipah conference. The evidence has not vanished like a mirage.


No GoF here, look over there, a squirrel!
When the chimera [Baric] made using SHC014 proved able to infect human cells in a dish, Daszak told the press that these revelations should “move this virus from a candidate emerging pathogen to a clear and present danger.”

To others, it was the perfect example of the unnecessary dangers of gain-of-function science. “The only impact of this work is the creation, in a lab, of a new, non-natural risk,” the Rutgers microbiologist Richard Ebright, a longtime critic of such research, told Nature.
Ah, but only anonymous news sources .... whoops, where did this pesky evidence come from?

[Baric's lab] was probably one of the safest BSL-3 facilities in the world. That still wasn’t enough to prevent a handful of errors over the years: some scientists were even bitten by virus-carrying mice. But no infections resulted.
Another whoops! But it was a near miss so it's unimportant.


Moving right along to the not GoF research in the not unsafe BSL2 lab:
In 2017, Daszak and Shi followed with another study, also at BSL-2, that one-upped Baric’s work in North Carolina. The WIV had continued to unearth dozens of new SARS-like coronaviruses in bat caves, and it reported making chimeras with eight of them by fusing the spikes of the new viruses to the chassis of WIV1. Two of them replicated well in human cells. They were, for all intents and purposes, brand-new pathogens.
Cultured in the lab again. Whoops! Shi said that didn't happen.


Yes minds have changed:
The revelation that the WIV was working with SARS-like viruses in subpar safety conditions has led some people to reassess the chance that SARS-CoV-2 could have emerged from some type of laboratory incident. “That’s screwed up,” the Columbia University virologist Ian Lipkin, who coauthored the seminal paper arguing that covid must have had a natural origin, ... My view has changed.”
Whoops! Lipkin must be a flake, his first paper was valid but his changed view was ignored.


As for the chimeras that should be identifiable as opposed to serial passages, that is described in other citations. And where are the genomes of those chimera? Did Shi share those with anyone so we can see how closely related or not they are to COVID 19?
 
To respond to individual points.

"not been able to culture it" Keep that in mind because that changes and Shi denies any cultures were done at the WIV. It's called lying.

You repeatedly claim Shi lied. Now provide the evidence; where is the quote from Shi denying any viruses were cultured at WIV? Remember Shi was co-author on a paper reporting the first successful recovery of a live SARS like virus from bats. Subsequent papers Shi co-authored reported the successful recovery of a handful of other SARS like viruses. So where is the evidence she lied having published papers on culturing wild viruses.

What I think is misunderstood is you don't keep viruses in culture. Having cultured a virus, the virus will spun down from the cell culture and deep frozen. The fact that at some point in the past these viruses had been cultured does not mean there were any SARS like virus cultures at the time that SARS-CoV-2 emerged. I think the misunderstood quote is Shi saying that they had no virus cultures - present tense - not that they had never had virus cultures.

Most virus research is genetic or done using pseudo-viruses or chimeric viruses. This is not gain of function research because the products are not pathogenic in humans. For instance Shi used a mouse SARS virus with a spike from novel viruses, not a human virus backbone.
 
There's that pesky GoF research that has been denied in this thread.

Since you like MIT review - not a scientific journal - by the same author but subsequent.
https://www.technologyreview.com/20...on-research-coronavirus-ralph-baric-vaccines/

Baric released a statement clarifying that according to the NIH, the research in question did not qualify as gain-of-function, none of the SARS-like coronaviruses he’d used in the experiments were closely related to SARS-CoV-2

Q: Now that Rand Paul has announced on the floor of the Senate that you’re creating superviruses and performing gain-of-function experiments, this seems like a good time to talk about your work.
Ralph Baric: Well, let me start off by saying that we’ve never created a supervirus. That’s a figment of his imagination and obviously being used for political advancement. Unfortunately, the way social media works today, this fabrication will be repeated many times.
Certainly we see that this fabrication is repeated here.

Well, the SARS coronavirus parental strain could replicate quite efficiently in primary human cells. The chimera could also program infection of human cells, but not better than the parental virus. So we didn’t gain any function—rather, we retained function. Moreover, the chimera was attenuated in mice as compared to the parental mouse-adapted virus, so this would be considered a loss of function.
 
Same old ****. I post the evidence, you pretend I didn't. :rolleyes:

Those who want to keep to the narrative, which was lies at the start, and are still lies, obfuscate and drill down to dishonest levels of absurd wordsmithing to try to keep some semblance of scientific truth on the side of natural spillover (unrelated to the lab). I wont say it is deliberately lying though as it probably is not.

Some people here still think Amanda Knox is a murderer despite there being overwhelming reasons that emerged in the investigation to think the opposite at a 99.999999999 percent level. I learned that otherwise intelligent people can, and do , believe things that are simply not supported with logical consistency. it is perhaps emotional reasoning. Tribal lines in the sand that dont allow for an open mind?

So be it. Just pure ignorance and clinging to the narrative of a perceived-to-be-righteous 'side' that shrinks in support as time goes on. Remember when thinking it was from the lab was racist? and a CT?
And I blame politics for this. It's the only reason anyone (without a science grant or tenure in peril) would be this obtuse about the facts at hand and the likelihood of what is pretty obvious at this point in time (though not proven and may never be).

I admire your tenacity SG.

Many here will find this post offensive. They can suck it up. The push back on this affected the entire world- the only one we have- in a very negative way and they are part of that- intentional or not.
They can address the actual evidence without the constant sidestep or mealy mouthed diatribes better suited to a faith healing preacher with an ever shrinking chorus of believers and give SG a break from having to repost things a dozen times.
 
Last edited:
Those who want to keep to the narrative, which was lies at the start, and are still lies, obfuscate and drill down to dishonest levels of absurd wordsmithing to try to keep some semblance of scientific truth on the side of natural spillover (unrelated to the lab). I wont say it is deliberately lying though as it probably is not.

Some people here still think Amanda Knox is a murderer despite there being overwhelming reasons that emerged in the investigation to think the opposite at a 99.999999999 percent level. I learned that otherwise intelligent people can, and do , believe things that are simply not supported with logical consistency. it is perhaps emotional reasoning. Tribal lines in the sand that dont allow for an open mind?

So be it. Just pure ignorance and clinging to the narrative of a perceived-to-be-righteous 'side' that shrinks in support as time goes on. Remember when thinking it was from the lab was racist? and a CT?
And I blame politics for this. It's the only reason anyone (without a science grant or tenure in peril) would be this obtuse about the facts at hand and the likelihood of what is pretty obvious at this point in time (though not proven and may never be).

I admire your tenacity SG.

Many here will find this post offensive. They can suck it up. The push back on this affected the entire world- the only one we have- in a very negative way and they are part of that- intentional or not.
They can address the actual evidence without the constant sidestep or mealy mouthed diatribes better suited to a faith healing preacher with an ever shrinking chorus of believers and give SG a break from having to repost things a dozen times.

Lots of opinion, no consideration of the science. This was exactly the problem with the case against Amanda Knox. People went with the initial headlines, they believed poor science from those with poor expertise. Once people get an idea in their head it is difficult to get them to review the facts and challenge their own precobceived notions. We see this in those who insist old data, old news paper reports are somehow justification for finding innocent people guilty whether that is Knox or Shi. People here have convicted Shi of mass murder, of genocide, all based on headlines and misunderstanding science.

I have said that if there is evidence to support a laboratory leak I would accept it. I have said that in the absence of definitive evidence either way my bias is to assume innocence, to assume a natural event rather than a massive conspiracy. To assume that what has happened multiple times before has happened again. I do not assume that an unlikley series of events, hidden by a mass conspiracy, that has never previously caused a pandemic is the likliest explanation. I do note that multiple previous pandemics have been alleged to be the result of laboratory leaks, but this has not been shown to be true. Cumulative evidence since 2020 has favoured (but not proven) a natural cross over event, no new evidence has emerged to favour a laboratory leak, it is all old slanders.
 
Last edited:
Most virus research is genetic or done using pseudo-viruses or chimeric viruses. This is not gain of function research because the products are not pathogenic in humans. For instance Shi used a mouse SARS virus with a spike from novel viruses, not a human virus backbone.

And even if it is, gain of function is a critical tool in cataloging viruses and traits in the wild that have the potential to cause human pandemics. This is research that NEEDS to be done.

Per Kristian Andersen on one of his TWiV appearances, historically the the biggest issues with GoF have come from private labs in the US. This, because they haven't needed to follow the same types of rules and practices around GoF research that government run labs do.
 
Lots of opinion, no consideration of the science. This was exactly the problem with the case against Amanda Knox. People went with the initial headlines, they believed poor science from those with poor expertise. Once people get an idea in their head it is difficult to get them to review the facts and challenge their own precobceived notions. We see this in those who insist old data, old news paper reports are somehow justification for finding innocent people guilty whether that is Knox or Shi. People here have convicted Shi of mass murder, of genocide, all based on headlines and misunderstanding science.

I have said that if there is evidence to support a laboratory leak I would accept it. I have said that in the absence of definitive evidence either way my bias is to assume innocence, to assume a natural event rather than a massive conspiracy. To assume that what has happened multiple times before has happened again. I do not assume that an unlikley series of events, hidden by a mass conspiracy, that has never previously caused a pandemic is the likliest explanation. I do note that multiple previous pandemics have been alleged to be the result of laboratory leaks, but this has not been shown to be true. Cumulative evidence since 2020 has favoured (but not proven) a natural cross over event, no new evidence has emerged to favour a laboratory leak, it is all old slanders.
Bold is mine pointing out all the unsupported assertions I can find in this post, still not actually addressing the evidence and no supporting citations noted.

The fall back recurs that accusing the 'innocent' Shi and Daszak of lying is bad form, supporting direct evidence they have actually been lying is ignored

The post asserts the author has an open mind, asserts the evidence can be dismissed as a CT padding that with straw adjectives, "mass" and "massive", for good measure. The post asserts there is no evidence without actually addressing any of the evidence specifically.

It was claimed in the previous post only anonymous sources were cited. When specifics names were cited, I see that assertion is not addressed, but conveniently absent. How many future posts will be written before "only anonymous sources" returns to the list?

The irony/hypocrisy here is mind boggling. :id:
 
Bold is mine pointing out all the unsupported assertions I can find in this post, still not actually addressing the evidence and no supporting citations noted.

The fall back recurs that accusing the 'innocent' Shi and Daszak of lying is bad form, supporting direct evidence they have actually been lying is ignored

The post asserts the author has an open mind, asserts the evidence can be dismissed as a CT padding that with straw adjectives, "mass" and "massive", for good measure. The post asserts there is no evidence without actually addressing any of the evidence specifically.

It was claimed in the previous post only anonymous sources were cited. When specifics names were cited, I see that assertion is not addressed, but conveniently absent. How many future posts will be written before "only anonymous sources" returns to the list?

The irony/hypocrisy here is mind boggling. :id:

I think it reasonable to respond to an opinion based non-evidence based post in a similar manner.

I note you cannot produce a quote from Shi to support your allegation she lied. I never said only anonymous sources were quoted in general, but specifically in relation to the claim that bats were kept at WIV.

I think 'massive' is an appropriate adjective, since it appears to require the involvement of the Chinese government many scientists of many nations, WHO, western governments...

Do you deny that all previous pandemics have been the result of natural cross over events, but that nearly all recent pandemics and near pandemics have been alleged to be the result of a laboratory leak / bio engineering? Now I accept if people keep on crying wolf then one day they may get it right.

What new evidence post 2021 supports a laboratory leak?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom