Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
Way to highlight a cherry-picked sentence ignoring the rest of the quote. Allow me to highlight the important bits you missed.Nothing in your quote says there was gain of function research. Not all research on viruses even that involving genetic manipulation is gain of function research.
No information =/= evidence against the finding. What do you suppose happened with all those specimens created with "reverse genetic cloning techniques on SARS-like coronaviruses"? Not GoF then WTF was the goal?We assess that some scientists at the WIV have genetically engineered coronaviruses using common laboratory practices. The IC has no information, however, indicating that any WIV genetic engineering work has involved SARS-CoV-2, a close progenitor, or a backbone virus that is closely-related enough to have been the source of the pandemic.
• Scientists at the WIV have created chimeras, or combinations, of SARS-like coronaviruses through genetic engineering, attempted to clone other unrelated infectious viruses, and used reverse genetic cloning techniques on SARS-like coronaviruses
How much more incriminating could the report have been than that?
Never fear, we have Daszak on video in an interview saying their goal was to create a manipulated coronavirus so they could use it to develop a vaccine ahead of the next coronavirus spillover. The ECA's grant application said the same thing. They didn't intend to make a more dangerous SARS-like CoV, that was an accident. An accident that was predictable which is one reason the grant application was denied. It's clear Shi got funding elsewhere.
The quote says there is evidence that genetic engineering research was commonly done on coronaviruses but no evidence COVID itself was lab created, so you can't make the leap either? Gee we have evidence research was being done on manipulated coronaviruses at the WIV but they didn't find any evidence of COVID itself in the lab. Must not have been any. Oh wait, the report only says the viruses were being manipulated but to what end isn't stated.
Do you imagine Spy Tom Cruise on a mission impossible sneaking into the WIV and finding the bit of evidence Shi had not gotten rid of?
Or is the fantasy that Shi was so honorable that despite fear of losing everything, going to jail, and the crushing public revelation her research killed millions she would have come clean if it were true.
Scientists are unable to be dishonest, none has ever once published fabricated evidence in a study. Whoops requires a leap to find that is relative to Shi and Daszak lying.
And Daszak, not greedy in the least, would have admitted what he knew and resigned immediately from the EHA. Sure.
You've ignored the evidence no matter how many times I've posted the citations of the evidence. An evidence supported conclusion is not one pulled out of one's ass. How can you tell?None of the quotes said Shi lied let alone provided evidence. Shi says that SARS-CoV-2 did not originate from her laboratory, you disagree. Your opinion is not evidence Shi lied.
My evidence is backed with citation after citation in this thread. I see almost no citations in your posts. And the cites you do post are seriously out of date like referencing the work Shi did at the UNC with Dr Baric without recognizing that was a few years before she took what she learned back to the WIV along with his humanized mice. What do you imagine Shi did with those humanized mice if they had no live cultures at the WIV?
I don't think everyone reading this thread has ignored the evidence.
Live bats, found at the WIV including pictures of the cages, an application for a special bat cage design, and a students request for someone to take care of the bats as he was going out of town
Live humanized mice sent to the WIV from Dr Baric
No live cultures claimed despite a paper as recently as 2019 and 2017 describing the in vitro research done at the WIV,
and despite Daszak saying on video in his own words how easy it was to manipulate coronaviruses in the lab
Claiming the miners in Yunnan died of a fungal infection when there is overwhelming evidence from multiple sources they died from a viral pneumonia
Collecting specimens from the mine and other caves in Yunnan for >10 years then claiming they had no cultures or frozen specimens, only genome records, and even those records have not been readily shared with other scientists, only one conveniently not very close to the COVID genome
Nope, Shi's denials of the above couldn't have been a lie. Live humanized mice sent to the WIV from Dr Baric
No live cultures claimed despite a paper as recently as 2019 and 2017 describing the in vitro research done at the WIV,
and despite Daszak saying on video in his own words how easy it was to manipulate coronaviruses in the lab
Claiming the miners in Yunnan died of a fungal infection when there is overwhelming evidence from multiple sources they died from a viral pneumonia
Collecting specimens from the mine and other caves in Yunnan for >10 years then claiming they had no cultures or frozen specimens, only genome records, and even those records have not been readily shared with other scientists, only one conveniently not very close to the COVID genome
But there was no specific finding of a COVID spillover. No finding of a closely related virus circulating anywhere in China. No initial outbreak of COVID outside of Wuhan, and more than that, no outbreak anywhere except close to the WIV.I agree [with Lomiller]. A laboratory leak could have happened anywhere, and has done.
The mass importation of rare species from the wild for food and medicine is a Chinese peculiarity, a part of Chinese culture the Chinese government has been reluctant to put a stop to. [snipped the rest of this argument].
Don't you think it's a bit hypocritical to claim an unsupported assertion with no evidence other than it happened in the past, but when it comes to the lab origin hypothesis, no amount of actual evidence matters because COVID wasn't found by our spies
Last edited:

