Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

I never understood "lab leak" being the same as "bioengineered" .. I understand "lab leak" as any lab having anything to do with the outbreak. Including person collecting samples for the lab getting infected in the wild, bringing the virus into "civilization".

Sure. But essentially that is zoonosis plus. A scenario is that the scientists go into a cave. A bat poos on a scientist not wearing proper gear and then the scientist goes back to Wuhan and drops in at the seafood market for a bit of raccoon dog and someone behind the scientist somehow breathes in a live virus and off we go….
 
No one "raised their eyebrow" because the outbreak started in a live animal market, just like SARS did. All the early cases either had a direct connection to the market or lived\worked near it. Such markets were already established as being extremely high risk for spreading Corona viruses into the general population.

I think it’s worth acknowledging that eyebrows have been raised and rightly so. One of the claims is that a lab origin was never considered and yet the emails show the opposite is the case. In fact a few virologists did indeed worry about it until the virus was looked at more closely.
 
Sure. But essentially that is zoonosis plus. A scenario is that the scientists go into a cave. A bat poos on a scientist not wearing proper gear and then the scientist goes back to Wuhan and drops in at the seafood market for a bit of raccoon dog and someone behind the scientist somehow breathes in a live virus and off we go….

I mean why do we even ask if it was lab or wet market ? To prevent it in the future (as much as possible).
If it came from the lab, or because of lab conducting its research, procedures must be improved. And some research possibly stopped. Scientific returns must be considered against next possible pandemic.
Same with wet market origin. But we would have to know what really happened.
Or maybe not. Better be safe than sorry .. maybe we should fix all possible paths.
Also to prepare better for the next pandemic .. but that's another topic .. also something nobody is interesting in. Already.
 
I started to answer this, put it aside then ended up replying to the answers to other posts. Here are a few points not covered or that need more clarification.

For goodness's sake! I am not cherry-picking "one"!
If that is the case then why act like the last report of the 3 ill workers was definitive?

So again, the report does not come down one way or another on the question. However,...

Then the sick workers comes up again...

Note that there seems to be a disagreement about how seriously to take the information, as I mentioned before.
Why add "however" in your assessment?

On 16 July 2021, CNN reported [snip]...

I think that was the Muddy Waters report. In the Muddy Waters report, they repeated what had been said in the previous intelligence assessment:
Of course it muddies the water, d'uh.

So that brings us to...

Wow! Now that's what I call cherry-picking!
I pointed out a contradictory report. Where do you see me saying the FBI report was the most credible? Please provide the quote, thank you.


All the intelligence assessments stated either that they were agnostic or came down on the side of natural origins except.... the FBI, and the Department of Energy, who had moderate and low confidence in lab leak respectively. I mean, that's all? It's pretty thin, isn't it?
If you think this is about majority opinion instead of the best evidence and you only look at these US State Department reports, ignoring all the rest of the evidence, and you fail to consider the 'lab leak is a CT' propaganda Daszak put out in early 2020 that has taken years to overcome, I would say your conclusion lacks a complete assessment of the evidence.
I would have thought that the smoking guns you are talking about from unnamed sources that get whispered to various Murdoch publications and Shellenberger and The Daily Mail, would have been available to the other intelligence agencies. If they saw something as damning as that which is claimed why would they not be all in on the lab leak?
You harp on a source of evidence that can be corroborated elsewhere by attacking Murdoch, The Daily Mail and Shellenberger, therefore trying to discredit the perfectly good evidence. Again it shows you cannot address the evidence. Not to mention you cited The Daily Mail and when I pointed out your hypocrisy you said, 'oh it's just where I got the information from.'

Well how does it differ when I do the same?
Again, you have to choose.

Either....

1.) the information about named WIV workers is not there, or not as damning. For example, maybe one of the workers went to hospital to have their appendix removed, who knows? Perhaps the intelligence is ambiguous leading to different people having different opinions.

2.) the intelligence agencies are completely incompetent and stupid. They looked at all the damning evidence but were too idiotic to understand that the WIV workers had Covid and that they were patients zero, one and two.

3.) the intelligence agencies are doing what they can to suppress the information for some reason. Option 3 is the conspiracy option, by the way.
A false tricotomy. :rolleyes: No you need not choose one of these three options.

First, your number 3 belongs in the bin. That you keep referring to this excuse for holding fast to your weakly supported spillover origin hypothesis once again shows you cannot debate on the evidence.
Re #1) The evidence suggests the rumor about 3 ill WIV lab workers was widespread early on. Shi withheld the data on her staff that could have cleared it up. That's nowhere near the same as your option that the evidence isn't there.

And #2) you're claiming because the US doesn't know everything about the Chinese means they are incompetent??:boggled:


Here's a bit of a summary of things I posted above:

It's not cherry picking to consider all the reports. It would be cherry picking to only consider one. I bring up the FBI report because it contradicts the report you have attached the most significance to.

I didn't see anything in the June 2023 report that said it superseded all the previous reports.

Second, just because the reports are not as definitive as you would like doesn't mean anyone is incompetent or stupid. There is still the problem the Chinese government and Dr Shi have withheld key information that might resolve the matter.

Third, I don't put the same amount of evidentiary weight as you seem to be putting on these 3 workers. Why is that? For now it seems to be equivocal, not conclusive one way or the other.

It's hardly a game changer just like it wasn't a game changer when the furin cleavage site was found in bats not in the same family as SARS CoV carrying Horseshoe bats, just like it wasn't a game changer when 2 separate lineages were found early on, just like Worobey's flawed study was not a game changer, and just like it wasn't a game changer when the finding of COVID RNA in the same market stall as some Raccoon Dog DNA turned out to be a nothing-berger.

In all of those cases contradictory evidence disproved the claims and I have posted that evidence.
 
Last edited:
I mean why do we even ask if it was lab or wet market ? To prevent it in the future (as much as possible).
If it came from the lab, or because of lab conducting its research, procedures must be improved. And some research possibly stopped. Scientific returns must be considered against next possible pandemic.
Same with wet market origin. But we would have to know what really happened.
Or maybe not. Better be safe than sorry .. maybe we should fix all possible paths.
Also to prepare better for the next pandemic .. but that's another topic .. also something nobody is interesting in. Already.

You can do both you know, keep looking for the origin and making safety improvements in labs and in the wild animal trade..

As it turns out these kinds of lab errors keep occurring and are never taken as seriously as they should be. Same with some deadly spillovers. By diluting the origin saying well it could have been this or the other, neither hazard is taken as seriously as it should be.
 
I think it’s worth acknowledging that eyebrows have been raised and rightly so. One of the claims is that a lab origin was never considered and yet the emails show the opposite is the case. In fact a few virologists did indeed worry about it until the virus was looked at more closely.
highlight mine. That hyperbole misrepresents the facts.

Yes, some researchers and Tedros from the WHO pointed out no evidence of the lab origin hypothesis was looked at before it was dismissed. And Daszak has gone to great lengths to steer people away from the lab origin, that was followed by news reporters unknowingly lining up behind the deception. I posted about this very recently.

Obviously "never considered" is a gross exaggeration.
 
... Yet clearly the intel did not convince the various agencies, suggesting that the stories were wrong (and probably put there by David Asher and maybe some other anonymous sources), OR the intelligence community is part of the cover-up OR they are all incompetent.

I asked you which of the three you think it is. I ask again.
And I answered your false options above.
 
I never understood "lab leak" being the same as "bioengineered" .. I understand "lab leak" as any lab having anything to do with the outbreak. Including person collecting samples for the lab getting infected in the wild, bringing the virus into "civilization".

If those samples then infect a person in the lab then it is a lab-leak origin. If a worker gets infected gathering the specimens in a cave and comes back as patient zero it's a grey area. It still means actions of the WIV teams failed to prevent such an occurrence.

But in this case, where is that specimen the worker collected? Shouldn't it be found among the WIV specimens? Or shouldn't it be circulating in people near the caves, or in a cluster of bats in the caves.

If this was a one-off virus that infected a one-off person who spread it to a single city at first, now you really are getting into near-impossible odds.
 
I think it’s worth acknowledging that eyebrows have been raised and rightly so. One of the claims is that a lab origin was never considered and yet the emails show the opposite is the case. In fact a few virologists did indeed worry about it until the virus was looked at more closely.

All the early reactions I heard were some version of "I can't believe we are still having the wild animal market problem".

Perhaps you are thinking of first reactions to seeing the furin cleavage site? A number of scientists have reported that raised their eyebrows when they first saw it, but of course those issues were subsequently addressed.
 
Yes, they did indeed raise their eyebrows high. That is essentially the reason for the phone calls and discussions between scientists about the virus and indeed their eyebrows were on the roof. Fauci, Francis Collins, Andersen, Jeremy Farrar, Patrick Vallance, Andersen, Garry, Holmes etc…..

From what I gather, they all were extremely concerned because indeed they knew about the lab and they were very surprised by the virus’s structure.

By Zhengli-Shi’a testimony, she too was concerned..

However, they all claim to have looked into it and changed their minds.
That's not true. Both Fauci and Collins hold to the don't rule it out POV. And Fauci's been on the defensive since it came out money from the NIH may have funded dangerous research.
Those emails were deleted or excused as meaning something else. Find one that says Fauci or Collins have changed their minds about those early emails. It would be nice if you could find them saying they changed their minds. But the emails mostly give excuses.

I'm not going to delve into the rest. You make assertions without citations when detailed discussions about this can be found upthread.

Now, how they did their workings is itself a question that I think anyone can reasonably have, but the Proxima Origins paper was the initial result where they argued that the virus did not look bioengineered.

Lab leak proponents claim that yeah, maybe it doesn’t look that way because the WIV did experiments to prevent it looking that way, etc…..
Did you not read any of this evidence? Gawd it was in the latest US intelligence report no less.
From the friggin report!!!!!!!!!
Some of the WIV’s genetic engineering projects on coronaviruses involved techniques that could make it difficult to detect intentional changes. A 2017 dissertation by a WIV student showed that reverse genetic cloning techniques—which are standard techniques used in advanced molecular laboratories—left no traces of genetic modification of SARS-like coronaviruses.

As for it being in a dissertation, the WIV is a university you know.
 
Last edited:
I never understood "lab leak" being the same as "bioengineered" .. I understand "lab leak" as any lab having anything to do with the outbreak. Including person collecting samples for the lab getting infected in the wild, bringing the virus into "civilization".

That scenario would be almost impossible to square with the 2 early lineages issue. Current thinking is that Lineage A and Lineage B had to arise shortly before the first human infection so they must have diverged while the virus was still in animal hosts.


The problem is that both these lineages were found in the Wuhan market. To get there, you need to have 2 different people, infected separately from different animals, then both go to the Wuhan wildlife market and spread Covid there without creating any outbreaks anywhere else.

On the other hand, if Covid got to the Wuhan market in infected animals like SARS did then there is no issue. The virus could spread and differentiate in animals then jump separately to humans in the market.
 
No. A summary would have been that if there had been good intelligence to support a lab leak then the spies would have been the ones to find it and they did not. Why not? Lack of evidence? If they did not find evidence of zoonosis, why not? Answer: because they are the wrong people to ask. You need to ask virologists. What do virologists say? Zoonosis (usually).
Usually? Tossed in for good measure. Whoops! :rolleyes:

There is NO consensus among these virologists the 'magical' spies are supposed to be asking.

You want the answer to come out 'spillover'. You are trying as hard as your confirmation bias will let you. What a disappointment not to get a definitive answer from the US intelligence report.

Step back from your certainty it was a spillover and start following the evidence.

Or at least debate the points I just posted discrediting the spillover evidence instead of this tiring repetition of debunked unsourced arguments.
SG said:
It's hardly a game changer just like

it wasn't a game changer when the furin cleavage site was found in bats not in the same family as SARS CoV carrying Horseshoe bats,

just like it wasn't a game changer when 2 separate lineages were found early on,

just like Worobey's flawed study was not a game changer,

and just like it wasn't a game changer when the finding of COVID RNA in the same market stall as some Raccoon Dog DNA turned out to be a nothing-berger.​

In all of those cases contradictory evidence disproved the claims and I have posted that evidence.
 
Last edited:
That's not true. Both Fauci and Collins hold to the don't rule it out POV. And Fauci's been on the defensive since it came out money from the NIH may have funded dangerous research.
Those emails were deleted or excused as meaning something else. Find one that says Fauci or Collins have changed their minds about those early emails. It would be nice if you could find them saying they changed their minds. But the emails mostly give excuses.

I'm not going to delve into the rest. You make assertions without citations when detailed discussions about this can be found upthread.

Did you not read any of this evidence? Gawd it was in the latest US intelligence report no less.
From the friggin report!!!!!!!!!


As for it being in a dissertation, the WIV is a university you know.

Yeah, but the friggin report doesn’t say that Covid was the result of those experiments. Try to understand the distinction between WIV has done experiment X and Covid is the result of experiment X.
 
I started to answer this, put it aside then ended up replying to the answers to other posts. Here are a few points not covered or that need more clarification.

If that is the case then why act like the last report of the 3 ill workers was definitive?

Why add "however" in your assessment?

Of course it muddies the water, d'uh.

I pointed out a contradictory report. Where do you see me saying the FBI report was the most credible? Please provide the quote, thank you.



If you think this is about majority opinion instead of the best evidence and you only look at these US State Department reports, ignoring all the rest of the evidence, and you fail to consider the 'lab leak is a CT' propaganda Daszak put out in early 2020 that has taken years to overcome, I would say your conclusion lacks a complete assessment of the evidence.

You harp on a source of evidence that can be corroborated elsewhere by attacking Murdoch, The Daily Mail and Shellenberger, therefore trying to discredit the perfectly good evidence. Again it shows you cannot address the evidence. Not to mention you cited The Daily Mail and when I pointed out your hypocrisy you said, 'oh it's just where I got the information from.'

Well how does it differ when I do the same?
A false tricotomy. :rolleyes: No you need not choose one of these three options.

First, your number 3 belongs in the bin. That you keep referring to this excuse for holding fast to your weakly supported spillover origin hypothesis once again shows you cannot debate on the evidence.
Re #1) The evidence suggests the rumor about 3 ill WIV lab workers was widespread early on. Shi withheld the data on her staff that could have cleared it up. That's nowhere near the same as your option that the evidence isn't there.

And #2) you're claiming because the US doesn't know everything about the Chinese means they are incompetent??:boggled:


Here's a bit of a summary of things I posted above:

It's not cherry picking to consider all the reports. It would be cherry picking to only consider one. I bring up the FBI report because it contradicts the report you have attached the most significance to.

I didn't see anything in the June 2023 report that said it superseded all the previous reports.

Second, just because the reports are not as definitive as you would like doesn't mean anyone is incompetent or stupid. There is still the problem the Chinese government and Dr Shi have withheld key information that might resolve the matter.

Third, I don't put the same amount of evidentiary weight as you seem to be putting on these 3 workers. Why is that? For now it seems to be equivocal, not conclusive one way or the other.

It's hardly a game changer just like it wasn't a game changer when the furin cleavage site was found in bats not in the same family as SARS CoV carrying Horseshoe bats, just like it wasn't a game changer when 2 separate lineages were found early on, just like Worobey's flawed study was not a game changer, and just like it wasn't a game changer when the finding of COVID RNA in the same market stall as some Raccoon Dog DNA turned out to be a nothing-berger.

In all of those cases contradictory evidence disproved the claims and I have posted that evidence.

Yawn!

Muddy Waters was the name of the Senate report.

Jeez!

Also, my quoting of the Daily Mail was not me claiming it was a good source. I was pointing out the BS that the BS source reported. It is tedious pointing out your errors and having you misunderstand every single time.

Reminder: Daily Mail reported a WIV worker’s wife died of Covid. The source is David Asher. how can I prove he said that? By linking to the Daily Mail piece where he claims it. You then say “ha ha! Look at you quoting the Daily Mail like a fool!” Jeeeeeeezus Friggin Christ!
 
Anyway, I’m taking a break from this thread because it is boring to have to try to explain how I am being misrepresented. I don’t know if it is deliberate or not, but either way it is tedious trying to correct the inaccuracies only to be misrepresented all over again.

I might come back if something interesting happens.
 
Yeah, but the friggin report doesn’t say that Covid was the result of those experiments. Try to understand the distinction between WIV has done experiment X and Covid is the result of experiment X.
Try to understand the distinction between they could have and they did? Are you serious? They didn't spell it out for you and you can't make the leap from it's done all the time to it's possible that COVID resulted from serial passages in the lab and one would not be able to detect it?

We're beyond an eye roll here. :crazy:

You posted:
... the initial result where they argued that the virus did not look bioengineered.

Lab leak proponents claim that yeah, maybe it doesn’t look that way because the WIV did experiments to prevent it looking that way, etc…..
Yes, that is exactly what was possible.

You post a non sequitur that they weren't talking about COVID specifically. Why would 'this happens all the time' somehow exclude coronaviruses?
You cannot look at the COVID 19 virus genome and declare it had to be from some natural evolution and couldn't have been 'engineered' in a lab.

So WTF are you not understanding about the intelligence report (and there are other sources corroborating this) that makes you imagine anyone can look at COVID 19 and say there's evidence there it had to have evolved naturally in the wild?

This is akin to Planigale making the absurd assertion because RaTG13 is too genetically distant from COVID 19 then COVID could not have been made at the WIV. As if the WIV was incapable of hiding all the coronaviruses they were working with. :rolleyes:
 
Anyway, I’m taking a break from this thread because it is boring to have to try to explain how I am being misrepresented. I don’t know if it is deliberate or not, but either way it is tedious trying to correct the inaccuracies only to be misrepresented all over again.

I might come back if something interesting happens.
You're not being misrepresented; you misunderstand what you are reading and when you are questioned about your misunderstanding something, or confronted with contradictory evidence, you switch to denial or confirmation bias mode.

Dodge all you want, it's tiring for me to keep posting over and over stuff that was discussed ad nauseum upthread.

It's only going to get worse for the spillover origin supporters. The evidence supporting the lab origin is accumulating.
 
If by coverup you mean a few key people covering up the mistake(s) they made and the Chinese government withholding information then the CT label would apply. It still doesn't fit the CT sub-forum as it's most often used on this board. CTs in the CT sub-forum on the board typically claim unsupported BS being covered up by various parties also without evidence.

By the measure any coverup is a CT, then one could make the argument the natural spillover origin is a CT. China insisted the virus came from imported frozen food sold at the market. Worobey's study of the origin centering on the market left out a significant number of the first cases.

The closest the lab origin hypothesis comes to a coverup/CT was when Daszak tried to get the WHO inspection team to claim a lab origin was unlikely.

Peter Daszak, Who Sought U.S. Funds for Wuhan Lab and Aided Cover-up, Faces Calls to Quit
That was in Oct 2021 when a second team was being prepared to do another inspection. The WHO had planned to not include Daszak on the team. The second inspection never took place. They don't have China's permission.

That was the letter sent to The Lancet, which later had a number of the signatories to take their names off of the letter after finding out about Daszak's deception.


Shi and Daszak both have been caught lying.
This is not a complaint by a bunch of loonies. It is recognized researchers and virologists who signed the letter.



What the Intelligence Community's Report Said About Lab Leak COVID-19 Theory

Given China is still withholding information, the latest US intelligence report is no more definitive than the previous reports.

None of the quotes said Shi lied let alone provided evidence. Shi says that SARS-CoV-2 did not originate from her laboratory, you disagree. Your opinion is not evidence Shi lied.
 
Last edited:
Was there GoF research going on? Yes despite the conclusion the virus wasn't adapted to humans. On this subject the report contradicts itself.Of course they have no information, the WIV and the Chinese government are withholding information needed to make the assessment.


By the end of 2019, the WIV maintained distinct teams focused on MERS and SARS related coronaviruses. Both teams separately used transgenic mouse models to better understand how the viruses infect humans ...

We assess that some scientists at the WIV have genetically engineered coronaviruses using common laboratory practices. The IC has no information, however, indicating that any WIV genetic engineering work has involved SARS-CoV-2, a close progenitor, or a backbone virus that is closely-related enough to have been the source of the pandemic.
• Scientists at the WIV have created chimeras, or combinations, of SARS-like coronaviruses through genetic engineering, attempted to clone other unrelated infectious viruses, and used reverse genetic cloning techniques on SARS-like coronaviruses ...

Nothing in your quote says there was gain of function research. Not all research on viruses even that involving genetic manipulation is gain of function research.

They say there is no evidence that any research was done that could have created SARS-CoV-2.
 
It's the cover you *** principle. If it's a lab leak that's not great for China's reputation, but it doesn't put any of the decision makers in a bad light, they can just scapegoat some scientist and move on.

Another zoonotic crossover in a live animal market after the SARS debacle on the other hand doesn't just make China look bad, it calls Chinese cultural practices into question and most of all it calls into question the government that allowed these markets to re-open and keep operating in a way that creates an extremely high risk of introducing diseases and Corona viruses specifically into the human population.

This is the thing they want to cover up most of all, and it's almost certainly why the first thing the Chinese government did when it got reports of a new outbreak was to kill and incinerated every animal in the Wuhan market without taking any samples for study.


What the Chinease government is proposing is that Covid came into China on frozen food. The WHO gives this is about as plausible as a lab leak because while there is no evidence for either, it's impossible to completely prove either.

I agree. A laboratory leak could have happened anywhere, and has done.

The mass importation of rare species from the wild for food and medicine is a Chinese peculiarity, a part of Chinese culture the Chinese government has been reluctant to put a stop to. After the near miss pandemic of SARS the Chinese government recognised the risk that these live markets with the importation of animals from the wild posed. They are banned. It was a direct failure by the Chinese communist party in Wuhan to enforce this ban that led to Covid-19 pandemic. I think this was a far more egregious failure. Since there were three live animal markets in Wuhan, and it was not a secret market, clearly the local party failed to act. The Chinese government knew this, hence early denials that live animals were there until DNA and photographic evidence showed this was untrue. They would have kept the DNA evidence secret except that some Chinese scientists 'slipped up' and posted the DNA to a public server.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom