Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Most of the recent pandemics seem to have had claims of a laboratory origin, SARS, HIV, Ebola, Flu. The only one I haven't seen a laboratory origin for is Mpox.

Of course laboratory leaks occur, the last cases of small pox were due to a laboratory leak in England (from a biscuit tin in the back of a fridge). Most pandemics outbreaks we do not know the intermediate animal vector. We do not know it for Mpox, for Ebola, we have not found SARS in wild bats, just related viruses.
You do know what a red herring is, right. It's also a non sequitur fallacy.

It's not relevant in the least that CTs arose around other virus origins. This is the thread for scientific evidence and discussion, not the thread to discuss unsupported assertions about other virus origins. If that's the rack you are hanging your hat on, you will be sorely disappointed.
 
Last edited:
Not to mention it isn't true. See my post above documenting dozens of cases of escaped pathogens from labs. After seeing that post Planigale altered her version of never happened to admitting it happened once.My post included dozens of well documented times it happened.

Excellent post BTW.

Notice how Planigale ignored the points you made. She starts by ignoring all the work posted in this thread about Baric's work in North Carolina and everything Shi took back to China from that work.


This is false.

Wuhan and US scientists used undetectable methods of genetic engineering on bat coronaviruses -- 20 May 2020
2020, this is well known, it's not some new concept that no one believes is true. Maybe in your head, Planigale, it seems pretty well agreed COVID wasn't bio-engineered. What that most often refers to is the virus is not a patchwork of genes cobbled together like Frankenstein's monster.

Where did the lie come from?

So much for "pretty well agreed". I expect this evidence to be ignored. The same false claim that it wasn't 'engineered' will be posted again.

The research on Chimeric viruses was done in the US not in China. The problem remains that all that this technique does is add one piece of virus A into virus B. You still have a sequence from virus A inserted into virus B sequence. SARS-CoV-2 is a novel coronavirus. The spike sequence is not derived from any known coronavirus, the backbone is not derived from any known back bone. either there is a novel coronavirus originating in the wild (which we know is continually occurring), or you have to imagine that WIV have two previously unknown coronaviruses that they combined. That is not the research that was done. The coronavirusbackbone was an attenuated mouse SARS virus. The spike sequence was from known coronaviruses expressing a spike protein that would potentially bind to human ACE2.

The whole discussion about gain of function and animal passage is just smoke and mirrors. It is just mud throwing. Neither technique could create SARS-coV-2, they are irrelevant. If there was a laboratory leak it was of a novel coronavirus from the wild. All the stuff about gain of function research is irrelevant, gain of function research cannot produce an entirely novel virus, all it would do is produce a chimera of known viruses and people would immediately have identified that it was constructed from sequences from known coronaviruses. It also requires WIV to have more than one secret coronavirus, whilst the 'simple' escape only requires one.
 
The research on Chimeric viruses was done in the US not in China. [snipped the rest of this misinformation]
Which is interesting history but has no direct relevant evidence to the current lab origin evidence.

It's so tiring to reply to your posts because you continually present out of date information off the top of your head or wherever you get this crap from.

READ THE BLOODY THREAD!


The whole discussion about gain of function and animal passage is just smoke and mirrors. It is just mud throwing. Neither technique could create SARS-coV-2, they are irrelevant. If there was a laboratory leak it was of a novel coronavirus from the wild. All the stuff about gain of function research is irrelevant, gain of function research cannot produce an entirely novel virus, all it would do is produce a chimera of known viruses and people would immediately have identified that it was constructed from sequences from known coronaviruses. It also requires WIV to have more than one secret coronavirus, whilst the 'simple' escape only requires one.
Oh for pity ******* sake! It's no wonder you have no citations for this misinformed garbage.
 
Last edited:
Spies just killed the lab leak theory (for now) - The theory is dead. Long live the conspiracy theories. (The Racket, June 26, 2023)

The reception of this new ODNI report sounds much like how the 'Havana Syndrome' report was received in March.
There is no analogy whatsoever to Havana Syndrome. Please don't drag that crap into this discussion. Thanks.

As for the article, they could have summed it up in a couple sentences:

US releases one more report with little to no new evidence. It provides an inconclusive description of the 3 ill WIV lab workers in Nov of 2019. It doesn't clear anything up about that information. [I could go on about that but it's already being discussed in other posts.]
 
Spies just killed the lab leak theory (for now) - The theory is dead. Long live the conspiracy theories. (The Racket, June 26, 2023)

The reception of this new ODNI report sounds much like how the 'Havana Syndrome' report was received in March.

Wow! Nice article. It seems to square with a lot of my assumptions and sources that I have been looking at as well. In particular, it seems to “corroborate” ;) what I said about David Asher who has been doing various tours of the tabloids and Murdoch press and spreading the rumours of the sick WIV workers and dying wife (yes, SG, the “exquisite” Times reported that one, LOL!)

Also, nice to see the Decoding the Gurus pod get a shout-out for the interview they did with Holmes, Andersen and Worobey. For the open-minded about a zoonosis, it is a really interesting interview to listen to where they explain their reasons for why there are really few places that a progenitor virus could have been stashed.

And, of course, the new ODNI report blows up the entire “sick lab workers” story — a story that has been in circulation since national security reporter (and former Iraq WMD rumormonger) Michael Gordon put it in the WSJ in May 2021. It’s worth noting here that the sources of that story almost certainly included David Asher, a former Bush and Trump State Department official and longtime hawk on Iran, North Korea, and China; he was identified as such by Sharri Markson, a Murdoch apparatchik from Australia who pushed the lab-leak theory in a book. It seems likely that Asher was also the source of the now-discredited Taibbi/Shellengberger/Gutentag story. If so, I have to wonder if he (or whoever talked to them) did so because he knew the latest version of “sick workers” story was about to be discredited by the rest of the intelligence community, and was hoping to get it out there anyway. If that was the plan, I guess it worked.
 
There is no analogy whatsoever to Havana Syndrome. Please don't drag that crap into this discussion. Thanks.

As for the article, they could have summed it up in a couple sentences:

US releases one more report with little to no new evidence. It provides an inconclusive description of the 3 ill WIV lab workers in Nov of 2019. It doesn't clear anything up about that information. [I could go on about that but it's already being discussed in other posts.]

No. A summary would have been that if there had been good intelligence to support a lab leak then the spies would have been the ones to find it and they did not. Why not? Lack of evidence? If they did not find evidence of zoonosis, why not? Answer: because they are the wrong people to ask. You need to ask virologists. What do virologists say? Zoonosis (usually).
 
You do know what a red herring is, right. It's also a non sequitur fallacy.

It's neither. The fact that all past pandemics have come from natural spillover and all recent pandemics have spawned conspiracy theories about a lab leak is strong circumstantial evidence that suggests that this pandemic was natural spillover and that claims of a lab leak are CT.

At the very least it means claims of a lab leak require extraordinary evidence to back it up. Not only is there no strong evidence, evidence of any form is noticeably lacking.
 
Lab leak is automatically CT, because it requires cover up. On the other hand, cover up and conspiracy is default mode of operation of China's government.
The fact that lab leak would be a CT doesn't make it more probable, or less probable. It's irrelevant.
And it's not true that evidence of any form is lacking. The outbreak happened near the lab. Not just outside, sure .. but I don't doubt people who knew the lab is there raised their eyebrows quite high when they learned about the outbreak.
It's pretty weak evidence .. but that's why we even talk about possible lab leak.
 
Lab leak is automatically CT, because it requires cover up. On the other hand, cover up and conspiracy is default mode of operation of China's government.
The fact that lab leak would be a CT doesn't make it more probable, or less probable. It's irrelevant.
And it's not true that evidence of any form is lacking. The outbreak happened near the lab. Not just outside, sure .. but I don't doubt people who knew the lab is there raised their eyebrows quite high when they learned about the outbreak.
It's pretty weak evidence .. but that's why we even talk about possible lab leak.

I agree. It is quite a co-incidence that a coronavirus pandemic began in the same city as a leading coronavirus research laboratory. Certainly enough to justify asking the question could this have been a laboratory leak. But sometimes a co-incidence is just that. It certainly isn't evidence. So far I have seen no evidence to support a laboratory leak.
 
Lab leak is automatically CT, because it requires cover up. On the other hand, cover up and conspiracy is default mode of operation of China's government.
The fact that lab leak would be a CT doesn't make it more probable, or less probable. It's irrelevant.
And it's not true that evidence of any form is lacking. The outbreak happened near the lab.

Which lab? Wuhan has a few of them and the one being blamed changes depending narrative being pitched at the time. The fact is there are labs in every really large city in the world and given the threat of Corona viruses in China a large number of them will have some involvement studying this family of viruses.

Not just outside, sure .. but I don't doubt people who knew the lab is there raised their eyebrows quite high when they learned about the outbreak.

No one "raised their eyebrow" because the outbreak started in a live animal market, just like SARS did. All the early cases either had a direct connection to the market or lived\worked near it. Such markets were already established as being extremely high risk for spreading Corona viruses into the general population.

There is some suggestion that maybe someone was infected in a lab and then spread it to the Wuhan fish market but consider the incredibly unlikley chain of events required.

1 or 2 (depending on the version of the lab leak story) completely unknown viruses were being studied in a lab without anyone ever having documented their existence.

These would need to be live viruses unlike the genetic samples WiV and other researchers normally collect.

The virus would need to exist in the lab in multiple lineages so there must be a large number of samples of live virus.

2 different scientists would need to be infected with 2 different lineages of the virus.

Each would need to travel to the Wuhan fish market without infecting anyone either before or after their visit to the market.

Each would need to visit the live animal area of the market where Covid shows up in environmental samples.

There and only there, in the part of the market where animals were kept do they infect other people. Not their family, not on the train there, not their co-workers, not on the street, not in any other part of the market.

Now remember that this exact series of already unlikely events would need to have occurred twice with 2 different scientists to explain why there were 2 virus lineages at the market.


The far more parsimonious explanation is that an infected animals was taken from the wild and spread among infected animals either at the distribution center or in the market itself. This spread among animals gave rise to the second lineage and both lineages then made the jump to humans in the part of the market where live animals were stored.
 
Lab leak is automatically CT, because it requires cover up. On the other hand, cover up and conspiracy is default mode of operation of China's government.
The fact that lab leak would be a CT doesn't make it more probable, or less probable. It's irrelevant.
And it's not true that evidence of any form is lacking. The outbreak happened near the lab. Not just outside, sure .. but I don't doubt people who knew the lab is there raised their eyebrows quite high when they learned about the outbreak.
It's pretty weak evidence .. but that's why we even talk about possible lab leak.
If by coverup you mean a few key people covering up the mistake(s) they made and the Chinese government withholding information then the CT label would apply. It still doesn't fit the CT sub-forum as it's most often used on this board. CTs in the CT sub-forum on the board typically claim unsupported BS being covered up by various parties also without evidence.

By the measure any coverup is a CT, then one could make the argument the natural spillover origin is a CT. China insisted the virus came from imported frozen food sold at the market. Worobey's study of the origin centering on the market left out a significant number of the first cases.

The closest the lab origin hypothesis comes to a coverup/CT was when Daszak tried to get the WHO inspection team to claim a lab origin was unlikely.

Peter Daszak, Who Sought U.S. Funds for Wuhan Lab and Aided Cover-up, Faces Calls to Quit
That was in Oct 2021 when a second team was being prepared to do another inspection. The WHO had planned to not include Daszak on the team. The second inspection never took place. They don't have China's permission.

Scientists have called for Peter Daszak, the president of U.S.-based research organization EcoHealth Alliance (EHA) to quit, accusing him of concealing conflicts of interest, witholding critical information, and misleading public opinion during the COVID pandemic. ...

A Freedom of Information Request has shown that Daszak organized a letter to squash rumors that COVID leaked from a lab, in a way that did not link back to collaborations between WIV and EHA. Before his organizing role was revealed, Daszak called the lab leak theory terms such as "preposterous," "baseless," and "pure baloney," and claimed the WIV wasn't culturing viruses similar to SARS-CoV-2. ...
That was the letter sent to The Lancet, which later had a number of the signatories to take their names off of the letter after finding out about Daszak's deception.


Shi and Daszak both have been caught lying.
It later emerged that WIV had been working with RaTG13, one of the closest know relatives of SARS-CoV-2. Daszak had denied WIV had been actively working on RatG13, telling Wired: "We thought it's interesting, but not high-risk... So we didn't do anything about it and put it in the freezer." ...

The letter criticizes Daszak for claiming in May 2020 that there was "zero evidence" for the COVID lab leak theory, which is now widely considered to be plausible after being considered a conspiracy theory at that time.

It also accuses him of wrongly claiming that EHA's Chinese collaborators did not keep live bats when evidence shows they did. The letter also said he had "gone a step too far" by allowing the EHA to propose making "human-optimized virus constructs" under the rejected DARPA proposal.

The letter reads: "Dr. Daszak has now been proven to have concealed several extreme situations of conflict of interest, withheld critical information and misled public opinion by expressing falsehoods."
This is not a complaint by a bunch of loonies. It is recognized researchers and virologists who signed the letter.
Among the letter's signatories are Jamie Metzl, who was formerly on the World Health Organization'sExpert Advisory Committee on Developing Global Standards for Governance and Oversight of Human Genome Editing; Rolan Wiesendanger, a nanoscience researcher at the University of Hamburg; and Milton Leitenberg, an arms control and bioweapons researcher at the University of Maryland.


What the Intelligence Community's Report Said About Lab Leak COVID-19 Theory
At least one agency that contributed to the report said it had "moderate confidence" the pandemic began as a laboratory-associated incident, likely stemming from the Wuhan Institute of Virology. Four other agencies said they felt the pandemic was naturally occurring and three were unable to side with either hypothesis because some analysts favored one origin or the other and some thought both were equally likely.

To reach a "conclusive assessment" of the origin of COVID-19, the Intelligence Community said it would likely need China's cooperation. However, the report noted China's resistance to further investigations, as well as its reluctance to share information and blame the United States for the outbreak. ...
World Health Organization Director-General Dr. Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus noted the team had issues accessing data while in China and some raised concerns that the report was based on information China provided.
Given China is still withholding information, the latest US intelligence report is no more definitive than the previous reports.
 
On the other hand the fact that China hides something also doesn't mean it was lab leak. China always hides something. Most likely they don't know either. They are just making sure nobody ever knows.
 
No. A summary would have been that if there had been good intelligence to support a lab leak then the spies would have been the ones to find it and they did not. Why not? Lack of evidence? If they did not find evidence of zoonosis, why not? Answer: because they are the wrong people to ask. You need to ask virologists. What do virologists say? Zoonosis (usually).
You are confusing "lack of evidence" with "lack of access to evidence". It says so right in the report:

Potential links Between the WIV and the Origin of COVID 18
This report does not address the merits of the two most likely pandemic origins hypotheses, nor does it explore other biological facilities in Wuhan other than the WIV. ...

Variations in IC analytic views on the origins of the COVID-19 pandemic largely stem from differences in how agencies weigh intelligence reporting and scientific publications and intelligence and scientific gaps. All agencies continue to assess that both a natural and laboratory-associated origin remain plausible hypotheses to explain the first human infection

Four agencies plus this one conclude there was most likely a spillover origin. The Dept of Energy and the FBI find the lab origin to be the most likely. And:
... • The Central Intelligence Agency and another agency remain unable to determine the precise origin of the COVID-19 pandemic, as both hypotheses rely on significant assumptions or face challenges with conflicting reporting.
• Almost all IC agencies assess that SARS-CoV-2 was not genetically engineered. Most agencies assess that SARS-CoV-2 was not laboratory-adapted; some are unable to make a determination. ...
Nothing in the latest report says it resolved the question.


Was there GoF research going on? Yes despite the conclusion the virus wasn't adapted to humans. On this subject the report contradicts itself.
By the end of 2019, the WIV maintained distinct teams focused on MERS and SARS related coronaviruses. Both teams separately used transgenic mouse models to better understand how the viruses infect humans ...

We assess that some scientists at the WIV have genetically engineered coronaviruses using common laboratory practices. The IC has no information, however, indicating that any WIV genetic engineering work has involved SARS-CoV-2, a close progenitor, or a backbone virus that is closely-related enough to have been the source of the pandemic.

• Scientists at the WIV have created chimeras, or combinations, of SARS-like coronaviruses through genetic engineering, attempted to clone other unrelated infectious viruses, and used reverse genetic cloning techniques on SARS-like coronaviruses ...
Of course they have no information, the WIV and the Chinese government are withholding information needed to make the assessment.


Here's one of the key points:
Some of the WIV’s genetic engineering projects on coronaviruses involved techniques that could make it difficult to detect intentional changes. A 2017 dissertation by a WIV student showed that reverse genetic cloning techniques—which are standard techniques used in advanced molecular laboratories—left no traces of genetic modification of SARS-like coronaviruses.


Lab safety was lax.
As of January 2019, WIV researchers performed SARS-like coronavirus experiments in BSL-2 laboratories, despite acknowledgements going back to 2017 of these virus’ ability to directly infect humans through their spike
protein and early 2019 warnings of the danger of this practice. ...


The report does not address the missing information and only states "Shi said the tests were negative" re the blood tests of the staff at the WIV.

As I cited above:
Fauci says China should share the medical records of Wuhan lab staff who were ill in fall 2019: 'What did they get sick with?'
 
On the other hand the fact that China hides something also doesn't mean it was lab leak. China always hides something. Most likely they don't know either. They are just making sure nobody ever knows.
We can only guess at the reasons China is withholding information. We can say their excuse of patient privacy doesn't hold water as it's common practice to share information on anonymized patient records. And we can certainly wonder why in the hell would they withhold information that might have exonerated the labs involved?
 
Shi and Daszak both have been caught lying.

This is not a complaint by a bunch of loonies. It is recognized researchers and virologists who signed the letter.

No a bunch of pseudo-scientits wrote a letter accusing jim of lying. This isn't the same thing.
This is not a complaint by a bunch of loonies. It is recognized researchers and virologists who signed the letter.

From what I can find on google scholar not one of the signatories has ever published a paper on virology. Only 5 of them have published paper on any topic at all while only 3 have published papers on biology. These were on things like mice and rice genetics. Others have titles like "futureist" and "PHD Candidate"

Given the vast gap in credentials between these people and Daszak or Shi on the subject, I'm going to go out on a limb and say yes they are in fact loonies.
 
On the other hand the fact that China hides something also doesn't mean it was lab leak. China always hides something. Most likely they don't know either. They are just making sure nobody ever knows.

It's the cover you *** principle. If it's a lab leak that's not great for China's reputation, but it doesn't put any of the decision makers in a bad light, they can just scapegoat some scientist and move on.

Another zoonotic crossover in a live animal market after the SARS debacle on the other hand doesn't just make China look bad, it calls Chinese cultural practices into question and most of all it calls into question the government that allowed these markets to re-open and keep operating in a way that creates an extremely high risk of introducing diseases and Corona viruses specifically into the human population.

This is the thing they want to cover up most of all, and it's almost certainly why the first thing the Chinese government did when it got reports of a new outbreak was to kill and incinerated every animal in the Wuhan market without taking any samples for study.


What the Chinease government is proposing is that Covid came into China on frozen food. The WHO gives this is about as plausible as a lab leak because while there is no evidence for either, it's impossible to completely prove either.
 
Lab leak is automatically CT, because it requires cover up. On the other hand, cover up and conspiracy is default mode of operation of China's government.
The fact that lab leak would be a CT doesn't make it more probable, or less probable. It's irrelevant.
And it's not true that evidence of any form is lacking. The outbreak happened near the lab. Not just outside, sure .. but I don't doubt people who knew the lab is there raised their eyebrows quite high when they learned about the outbreak.
It's pretty weak evidence .. but that's why we even talk about possible lab leak.

Yes, they did indeed raise their eyebrows high. That is essentially the reason for the phone calls and discussions between scientists about the virus and indeed their eyebrows were on the roof. Fauci, Francis Collins, Andersen, Jeremy Farrar, Patrick Vallance, Andersen, Garry, Holmes etc…..

From what I gather, they all were extremely concerned because indeed they knew about the lab and they were very surprised by the virus’s structure.

By Zhengli-Shi’a testimony, she too was concerned..

However, they all claim to have looked into it and changed their minds. Now, how they did their workings is itself a question that I think anyone can reasonably have, but the Proxima Origins paper was the initial result where they argued that the virus did not look bioengineered.

Lab leak proponents claim that yeah, maybe it doesn’t look that way because the WIV did experiments to prevent it looking that way, etc…..
 
I never understood "lab leak" being the same as "bioengineered" .. I understand "lab leak" as any lab having anything to do with the outbreak. Including person collecting samples for the lab getting infected in the wild, bringing the virus into "civilization".
 
You are confusing "lack of evidence" with "lack of access to evidence". It says so right in the report:

Potential links Between the WIV and the Origin of COVID 18


Four agencies plus this one conclude there was most likely a spillover origin. The Dept of Energy and the FBI find the lab origin to be the most likely. And:
Nothing in the latest report says it resolved the question.


Was there GoF research going on? Yes despite the conclusion the virus wasn't adapted to humans. On this subject the report contradicts itself.Of course they have no information, the WIV and the Chinese government are withholding information needed to make the assessment.


Here's one of the key points:



Lab safety was lax.



The report does not address the missing information and only states "Shi said the tests were negative" re the blood tests of the staff at the WIV.

As I cited above:
Fauci says China should share the medical records of Wuhan lab staff who were ill in fall 2019: 'What did they get sick with?'

It is not “four agencies plus this one”. The report I am citing, the one we were all waiting for, is the combined estimates of ALL the agencies. They all had access to the same information. They just have a different methodology when it comes to assessing it.

If the people Shellenberger had claimed were infected were known to have been infected with exactly similar symptoms to Covid including the specific pneumonia and furthermore that we could confirm that one of them lost a wife to Covid as David Asher claimed to Sharrri Markson, the Daily Mail and which was repeeated by the Sunday Times then don’t you think that the intelligence agency would have put the likelihood much higher? In fact YOU claimed that would be a smoking gun when I said it would convince me. Yet clearly the intel did not convince the various agencies, suggesting that the stories were wrong (and probably put there by David Asher and maybe some other anonymous sources), OR the intelligence community is part of the cover-up OR they are all incompetent.

I asked you which of the three you think it is. I ask again.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom