Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Lab leak, or rather lab-related exposure is the best explanation so far. It was obvious at the start and there is no evidence moving away from it. Data from China is garbage. If it started in the US next to one of the virus labs here and they claimed it was natural Id have the same conclusion.

Covid 19 didn't start next to a lab it started next to a live animal market.
 
I've told you what would convince me.
Obviously a smoking gun, this is not a new concept to the thread.

Do you still believe Ben Hu was patient zero?
It's not a religion, angrysoba. Do I think it's possible, yes. Do I think it's certain? Of course not.

Do you think his wife died of Covid?
What source is this from? I don't recall anything that specific.


You were asked about odds, not about what would convince you. Any reason you can't/won't answer Sherkeu's question?
 
Obviously a smoking gun, this is not a new concept to the thread.

It's not a religion, angrysoba. Do I think it's possible, yes. Do I think it's certain? Of course not.

What source is this from? I don't recall anything that specific.


You were asked about odds, not about what would convince you. Any reason you can't/won't answer Sherkeu's question?

I don’t know why you have some kind of problem with me stating the conditions that will persuade me. I gave two examples. Do you have any examples that would sway you?

As for the word “belief”, I think it is unfortunate that some skeptics have pushed the notion that “believe” is inherently a religious or faith-based word. It is not. “Believe” simply means to hold the idea that a particular proposition is true. That is all. But fine, do you think that the reports of the specific names researchers were sick with Covid-like symptoms are accurate (which is just another way of asking if you believe it.) And if you do think it is true, what justifies your psychological disposition to assume the truth of these propositions (see how many circumlocutions you have to go through when you try to dispense with the perfectly cromulent word “believe”?)

As for sherkeu’s question, the probability I assign to a natural spillover is 87.68725399258943655429%
 
I don’t know why you have some kind of problem with me stating the conditions that will persuade me. I gave two examples. Do you have any examples that would sway you?
Where in my post do you read "a problem with" when what I said was "a smoking gun"?

What I don't understand is, are you saying identifying 3 workers from the WIV who were sick in Nov 2019 with COVID is the only smoking gun you would accept? :boggled:

Why limit yourself to this one particular smoking gun? From what I see, you took one of several US State Department reports that confirmed your bias and ignored the other state department reports that didn't.

From my POV the report that 3 workers from the WIV were sick and maybe hospitalized (yes that is in some of the reports) remains unclear. It most certainly is not the only important bit of evidence here. What is more important are the excuses Shi is using for not releasing the specific COVID antibody lab results on the workers at the WIV in early 2020.

What is Fauci referring to here? Fauci says China should share the medical records of Wuhan lab staff who were ill in fall 2019: 'What did they get sick with?'

Could that be any more specific? Were the tests actually done? How comprehensive were the tests meaning which workers and students were tested? How sensitive and specific was the test used? Finally why not release such results given it leans toward exonerating the WIV? Obviously the results could be anonymized so that excuse doesn't hold water.


Moving on to other evidence, this thread is chock full of other evidence that lends support to the lab origin hypothesis. Evidence supporting the spillover hypothesis remains weak.


As for the word “belief”, I think it is unfortunate that some skeptics have pushed the notion that “believe” is inherently a religious or faith-based word. It is not. “Believe” simply means to hold the idea that a particular proposition is true. That is all. ... And if you do think it is true, what justifies your psychological disposition to assume the truth of these propositions (see how many circumlocutions you have to go through when you try to dispense with the perfectly cromulent word “believe”?)
I tend to use evidence supported conclusion rather than belief because it is more precise.

But fine, do you think that the reports of the specific names researchers were sick with Covid-like symptoms are accurate (which is just another way of asking if you believe it.)
Bolding mine.

Re the names of the 3 researchers who became ill in Nov 2019, I don't find their names to be the key piece of evidence. I think this late in the evidence collecting game the COVID genome history is more likely to hold the smoking gun.


As for sherkeu’s question, the probability I assign to a natural spillover is 87.68725399258943655429%
On what basis do you think the spillover evidence is that strong?
 
Last edited:
This specific IC report merely reiterates the same information from the other IC reports which each said they found no reason to consider the “sick WIV workers” as evidence of a lab leak. Not just one. All of them. So I am not cherry picking.

How do I come to that probability? Because the arguments for lab leak seem to fizzle out in a way similar to other claims over the years and I admit it is partly in response to Sherkeu’s claim she is 100% in her belief in a lab leak.

How about you? What odds do you give?
 
It looks like the Proximal Origins authors are going to be summoned to a Select Committee hearing in the US Congress...

WASHINGTON — Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic Chairman Brad Wenstrup (R-Ohio) will hold a hearing titled “Investigating the Proximal Origin of a Cover Up” to examine the potential conflicts of interest and suppression of scientific discourse by the National Institutes of Health surrounding the drafting, publication, and critical reception of the infamous “The Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2” (“Proximal Origins”) correspondence. Previous evidence uncovered by the Select Subcommittee directly revealed that Dr. Fauci prompted the drafting of “Proximal Origins” to disprove the lab leak theory in the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic.

WITNESSES (as invited):

Dr. Kristian Andersen

Professor

Scripps Research

Dr. Andrew Rambaut

Professor

University of Edinburgh

Dr. W. Ian Lipkin

John Snow Professor of Epidemiology

Columbia University

Dr. Edward Holmes

Professor of Virology

University of Sydney

Dr. Robert Garry

Professor

Tulane University School of Medicine

The hearing will be open to the public and press and will be livestreamed online at https://oversight.house.gov/.
 
This specific IC report merely reiterates the same information from the other IC reports which each said they found no reason to consider the “sick WIV workers” as evidence of a lab leak. Not just one. All of them. So I am not cherry picking.
Each department had their own investigative sections. You are cherry picking one.

The FBI's investigation found the lab origin to be the most likely. How do you square the discrepancy?


How do I come to that probability? Because the arguments for lab leak seem to fizzle out in a way similar to other claims over the years and I admit it is partly in response to Sherkeu’s claim she is 100% in her belief in a lab leak.

How about you? What odds do you give?
Not much lab origin evidence fizzled out. If you go back through your posts you discredit the evidence by arguing against the source, but you don't address the evidence itself.

For example, where's your evidence the WIV did not live bats and live cultures? Shi said so is not evidence. It's like asking a suspected murderer if they are guilty and counting the denial as evidence.

I lean more than 50% toward a lab origin.
 
Lab leak, or rather lab-related exposure is the best explanation so far. It was obvious at the start and there is no evidence moving away from it. Data from China is garbage. If it started in the US next to one of the virus labs here and they claimed it was natural Id have the same conclusion.

Where is the intermediate animal? WHERE? China? Laos? Vietnam? The wet market evidence showed only humans...no wild animals with the virus, though there was a hard push towards making such a connection. Did you fall for that narrative? Without evidence?

The fact that some have said portions of the virus can connect outside Yunnan bats just confirms it was almost certainly the lab. Everyone sent their virus samples to that specific 'bat' lab. Mix and match. Safety measures were not top notch.
Maybe a natural mix from live animals without manipulation, as has happened before (See Shi's paper on hantu infections). I happen to think it is more likely the result of actual experiments.
The French built it and the US partially paid for the work done there that was halted in the US for many programs. The quick apologists at the start who blared out that it must be natural all had a financial tie (even if just potantially governmental) and a cya motivation to deflect cause, before anything was really known. I happen to suppose the originators of that narrative KNEW.

Lean back and take a wide view of the events in totality.

So, angrysoba-- Knowing what you do now, what do you place the odds at*? Natural origin (not related at all to the lab) or Wuhan bat lab related?

*I realize we may never know for certain.

Every pandemic up to now has resulted from a virus that has spread from an animal into humans. The default explanation has to be a natural zoonotic origin. That does not mean the possibility of a laboratory origin needs to be excluded, merely that it requires evidence.

I accept that it seems a co-incidence that there was the world's leading institute fro coronavirus research in the city where a coronavirus pandemic started. But sometimes a coincidence is just a co-incidence. We had had a near miss pandemic for a coronavirus pandemic arising in China with SARS. We have had pandemic influenza arising in China. A coronavirus pandemic originating in China would have been a good bet.

Other than the co-incidence, all else is supposition. WIV might have discovered a novel coronavirus and kept it secret unlike other coronaviruses they had discovered. WiV might have carried out genetic manipulation on a secret virus. But the fact that these things might have happened doesn't mean they did.

SG says that because Shi and other virologists around the world deny these things are true are evidence that they are true, because they would have no reason to lie about them unless they are true. The possibility that people are telling the truth seems impossible for SG to accept.

The persons who are accused of being patient zero having acquired SARS-CoV-2 from work at WIV deny hey were ill. US intelligence reports say hey have no evidence they were working with live viruses nor that they had a SARS like illness. Yet SG claims that this is evidence they were ill else why would they lie about it.

We have entered a weird world in which if someone Chinese or China affiliated says black is not white, that must mean black is actually white. Because if they are Chinese they must be lying and the only reason to lie is if black is actually white.
 
Each department had their own investigative sections. You are cherry picking one.

The FBI's investigation found the lab origin to be the most likely. How do you square the discrepancy?


Not much lab origin evidence fizzled out. If you go back through your posts you discredit the evidence by arguing against the source, but you don't address the evidence itself.

For example, where's your evidence the WIV did not live bats and live cultures? Shi said so is not evidence. It's like asking a suspected murderer if they are guilty and counting the denial as evidence.

I lean more than 50% toward a lab origin.

I would say what credence would you put into the FBI's opinion on science? They investigate crime. their default is to find criminal activity. that is their bias. What is the CDC opinion on cybercrime or espionage? We never hear that. Yet it seems as relevant as the FBI (a domestic security agency) on an outbreak of infectious disease in a foreign country. Way beyond their remit or expertise.
 
Every pandemic up to now has resulted from a virus that has spread from an animal into humans.
You sure you don't want to look that up or change your search string?

The default explanation has to be a natural zoonotic origin. That does not mean the possibility of a laboratory origin needs to be excluded, merely that it requires evidence.
It also requires people look at the existing evidence. :rolleyes:


List of laboratory biosecurity incidents
This list of laboratory biosecurity incidents includes accidental laboratory-acquired infections and laboratory releases of lethal pathogens, containment failures in or during transport of lethal pathogens, and incidents of exposure of lethal pathogens to laboratory personnel, improper disposal of contaminated waste, and/or the escape of laboratory animals. The list is grouped by the year in which the accident or incident occurred and does not include every reported laboratory-acquired infection.
What hubris to think it has never happened.

But now that you see it can happen and has happened you should be able to strike this repeating false claim of yours as an argument for a spillover origin.


Note this warning from 2014 and also note reporting of accidents and cases is not that thorough in Russia and China: Threatened pandemics and laboratory escapes: Self-fulfilling prophecies
The risk of a manmade pandemic sparked by a laboratory escape is not hypothetical: One occurred in 1977, and it occurred because of concern that a natural pandemic was imminent. Many other laboratory escapes of high-consequence pathogens have occurred, resulting in transmission beyond laboratory personnel. Ironically, these laboratories were working with pathogens to prevent the very outbreaks they ultimately caused. For that reason, the tragic consequences have been called “self-fulfilling prophecies.” . ..

Human H1N1 virus reappeared in 1977, in the Soviet Union and China. Virologists, using serologic and early genetic tests soon began to suggest the cause of the reappearance was a laboratory escape of a 1949-1950 virus, and as genomic techniques advanced, it became clear that this was true. By 2010, researchers published it as fact: ...

The 1977 pandemic spread rapidly worldwide but was limited to those under 20 years of age: ...


And vaccine production failures have been an issue
... There were significant outbreaks of VEE, Venezuelan equine encephalitis, every few years from the 1930s to the 1970s. Modern analysis revealed most outbreaks were genetic matches to the original 1938 VEE isolation used in inactivated veterinary vaccines. It was clear that many batches of the veterinary VEE vaccines had not been completely inactivated, so residual infective virus remained.

From 1938 to 1972, the VEE vaccine caused most of the very outbreaks that it was called upon to prevent, a clear self-fulfilling prophecy.

In 1995 a major VEE animal and human outbreak struck Venezuela and Colombia. There were at least 10,000 human VEE cases with 11 deaths in Venezuela and an estimated 75,000 human cases in Colombia, with 3,000 neurological complications and 300 deaths. VEE virus was isolated from 10 stillborn or miscarried human fetuses. ...


It doesn't take vaccine production mistakes.
Genomic analysis identified the 1995 virus as identical to a 1963 isolate, with no indication it had been circulating for 28 years. It was another case of frozen evolution, but unlike the vaccine-related VEE outbreaks, the 1963 virus had never been used in a vaccine. Suspicion fell on an inadvertent release from a virology lab, either by an unrecognized infection of a lab worker or visitor, or escape of an infected laboratory animal or mosquito. The major scientific group working on VEE published a paper in 2001 stating the 1995 outbreak most likely was a laboratory escape, with considerable circumstantial evidence: The outbreak strain was isolated from an incompletely inactivated antigen preparation used on the open bench in the VEE laboratory located at the outbreak epicenter. ...


SARS and COVID: it only takes one infected lab worker.
Moreover, about five percent of SARS patients are “super-spreaders” who infect eight or more secondary cases. For instance, one patient spread SARS directly to 33 others (reflecting an infection rate of 45 percent) during a hospitalization, ultimately leading to the infection of 77 people, including three secondary super-spreaders. A super-spreader could turn even a single laboratory infection into a potential pandemic.

SARS has not re-emerged naturally, but there have been six escapes from virology labs: one each in Singapore and Taiwan, and four separate escapes at the same laboratory in Beijing.

... At least two primary patients had never worked with live SARS virus. Many shortcomings in biosecurity were found at the NIV, and the specific cause of the outbreak was traced to an inadequately inactivated preparation of SARS virus that was used in general (that is, not biosecure) laboratory areas, ...
Highlight mine. By those odds, a lab origin is more probable.


Are we safe yet? :rolleyes:
It is hardly reassuring that, despite stepwise technical improvements in containment facilities and increased policy demands for rigorous biosecurity procedures in the handling of dangerous pathogens, potentially high consequence breaches of biocontainment occur nearly daily: In 2010, 244 unintended releases of bioweapon candidate “select agents” were reported. ...
Note that the WIV was working with SARS-like coronavirus in BSL2. And BTW, why would they need to work in a biosafety area if they were not working anything viable.?


The evidence is not exactly piling up on the spillover origin team's side.
Brucellosis cases in China exceed 10,000 after vaccine factory accident


May 2020: SPECIAL REPORT: How China covered up the coronavirus crisis


I accept that it seems a co-incidence that there was the world's leading institute fro coronavirus research in the city where a coronavirus pandemic started. But sometimes a coincidence is just a co-incidence. We had had a near miss pandemic for a coronavirus pandemic arising in China with SARS. We have had pandemic influenza arising in China. A coronavirus pandemic originating in China would have been a good bet.

Other than the co-incidence, all else is supposition.
This is where I quit taking you seriously. I've posted dozens of citations as have others. Talk about supposition, look in a mirror for the exploding irony emoticon.


WIV might have discovered a novel coronavirus and kept it secret unlike other coronaviruses they had discovered. WiV might have carried out genetic manipulation on a secret virus. But the fact that these things might have happened doesn't mean they did.
The secrecy has been well documented. And there are some significant revelations in their published papers, grant proposals, Daszak's public interview, and refusals to disclose certain critical information using easily debunked excuses.


SG says that because Shi and other virologists around the world deny these things are true are evidence that they are true, because they would have no reason to lie about them unless they are true. The possibility that people are telling the truth seems impossible for SG to accept.
:rolleyes: I am here you know. Should I start referring to you in the third person?

Of course it's not what I said at all. I notice you don't quote me.
There is evidence Shi and Daszak both have lied.
They have very strong motivation to lie.
They are withholding information on the earliest cases using a faux excuse.
​


The persons who are accused of being patient zero having acquired SARS-CoV-2 from work at WIV deny hey were ill. US intelligence reports say hey have no evidence they were working with live viruses nor that they had a SARS like illness. Yet SG claims that this is evidence they were ill else why would they lie about it.

[snipped false accusation of racism]
One report, not all official reports. It would help if you could keep your facts straight.


I would say what credence would you put into the FBI's opinion on science? They investigate crime. their default is to find criminal activity. that is their bias. What is the CDC opinion on cybercrime or espionage? We never hear that. Yet it seems as relevant as the FBI (a domestic security agency) on an outbreak of infectious disease in a foreign country. Way beyond their remit or expertise.
Have you already forgotten this was addressed? You really are not moving forward here if you can't even remember these different US State Departments each have full biological investigative teams of their own. The FBI makes heavy use of biological evidence. And they certainly don't pull a Dukes of Hazard trope of stopping their investigations at the border.

We have entered a weird world in which if someone Chinese or China affiliated says black is not white, that must mean black is actually white. Because if they are Chinese they must be lying and the only reason to lie is if black is actually white.
Where are you quoting me from so we can all see how you've distorted what I actually said?

I would say what credence would you put into the FBI's opinion on science? They investigate crime. their default is to find criminal activity. that is their bias. What is the CDC opinion on cybercrime or espionage? We never hear that. Yet it seems as relevant as the FBI (a domestic security agency) on an outbreak of infectious disease in a foreign country. Way beyond their remit or expertise.
This is an odd statement. Perhaps it is because you are unfamiliar with US agencies. The CDC is fully involved in investigating cybersecurity as it can be a serious public health threat. And they occasionally delve into espionage like the claims of Havana Syndrome (secret attacks) on staff at our Cuban Embassy.

There's a lot of redundancy in security departments in the US.
 
Last edited:
Each department had their own investigative sections. You are cherry picking one.

For goodness's sake! I am not cherry-picking "one"!

Are you not keeping up to date and keeping the score.

Look at Wikipedia....

In April 2020, it was reported that the US intelligence community was investigating whether the virus came from an accidental leak from a Chinese lab. The hypothesis was one of several possibilities being pursued by the investigators. US Secretary of Defense Mark Esper said the results of the investigation were "inconclusive"

By the end of April 2020, the Office of the Director of National Intelligence said the US intelligence community believed the coronavirus was not man-made or genetically modified.

On 15 January 2021, US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said that to assist the WHO investigative team's work and ensure a transparent, thorough investigation of COVID-19's origin, the US was sharing new information and urging the WHO to press the Chinese government to address three specific issues, including the illnesses of several researchers inside the WIV in autumn 2019 "with symptoms consistent with both COVID-19 and common seasonal illnesses", the WIV's research on "RaTG13" and "gain of function", and the WIV's links to the People's Liberation Army.[114][115] On 18 January, the US called on China to allow the WHO's expert team to interview "care givers, former patients and lab workers" in the city of Wuhan, drawing a rebuke from the Chinese government. Australia also called for the WHO team to have access to "relevant data, information and key locations"

So as far as I know, this was the beginning of the claim about sick WIV workers. Please note that even the most lab-leak friendly claims at this time accepted that sick workers could have had seasonal illnesses. It is hardly a very firm foundation.

Back to later reports...

A classified report from May 2020 by the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, a US government national laboratory, concluded that the hypothesis that the virus leaked from the WIV "is plausible and deserves further investigation", although the report also notes that the virus could have developed naturally, echoing the consensus of the American intelligence community, and provides no "smoking gun" towards either hypothesis

The "consensus of the American intelligence community" then was to be agnostic with "no smoking gun".

On 13 February 2021, the White House said it had "deep concerns" about both the way the WHO's findings were communicated and the process used to reach them. Mirroring concerns raised by the Trump administration, National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan stated that it was essential that the WHO-convened report be independent and "free from alteration by the Chinese government".[119] On 14 April 2021, the Director of National Intelligence Avril Haines, along with other Biden administration officials, said that they had not ruled out the possibility of a laboratory accident as the origin of the COVID-19 virus.

So "not ruled out" the lab leak.

Okay...

On 26 May 2021, President Joe Biden directed the U.S. intelligence community to produce a report within 90 days on whether the COVID-19 virus originated from a human contact with an infected animal or from an accidental lab leak,[121] stating his national security staff said there is insufficient evidence to determine either hypothesis to be more likely.[122] On 26 August 2021, the Office of the Director of National Intelligence released an unclassified summary of their findings,[123] with the main point being that the report remained inconclusive as to the origin of the virus, with intelligence agencies divided on the question.

So again, the report does not come down one way or another on the question. However,...

The report also concluded that the virus was most likely not genetically engineered, and that China had no foreknowledge of the virus prior to the outbreak.

Then the sick workers comes up again...

On 23 May 2021, The Wall Street Journal reported that a previously undisclosed US intelligence report stated that three researchers from the Wuhan Institute of Virology became ill enough in November 2019 to seek hospital care. The report did not specify what the illness was. Officials familiar with the intelligence differed as to the strength to which it corroborates the hypothesis that the virus responsible for COVID-19 was leaked from the WIV. The WSJ report notes that it is not unusual for people in China to go to the hospital with uncomplicated influenza or common cold symptoms

Note that there seems to be a disagreement about how seriously to take the information, as I mentioned before.

The House Foreign Affairs Committee has investigated the origins of the pandemic, and heard classified briefings. The Republican minority issued a report in August 2021 that they believed the origin of the pandemic was an accidental lab escape.[131]

The resurgence of the theory of a laboratory accident was fueled in part by the publication, in May 2021, of early emails between Anthony Fauci and scientists discussing the issue, before deliberate manipulation was ruled out as of March 2020.

On 16 July 2021, CNN reported that Biden administration officials considered the lab leak theory "as credible" as the natural origins theory.[135] In October 2022, an interim report of a Republican member of a US Senate committee concluded that a lab origin was most likely, but offered "little new evidence", according to The New York Times[/QUOTE]

I think that was the Muddy Waters report. In the Muddy Waters report, they repeated what had been said in the previous intelligence assessment:

However, the Office of the Director of National Intelligence’s (ODNI) Updated Assessment on
COVID-19 Origins cautions that “information indicating that several WIV researchers reported symptoms
consistent with COVID-19 in autumn 2019 is not diagnostic of the pandemic’s origins. “Even if confirmed, hospital admission alone would not be diagnostic of COVID-19 infection.”325 While vague, this statement
suggests that ODNI believes the WIV researchers may not have been infected with COVID-19 or, if they
were infected, that the infections may have occurred as a result of human-to-human transmission in Wuhan
as opposed to a research-related infection. As of the date of this report, ODNI has declined to provide
further information supporting its assessment.

So that brings us to...

The FBI's investigation found the lab origin to be the most likely. How do you square the discrepancy?

Wow! Now that's what I call cherry-picking!

All the intelligence assessments stated either that they were agnostic or came down on the side of natural origins except.... the FBI, and the Department of Energy, who had moderate and low confidence in lab leak respectively. I mean, that's all? It's pretty thin, isn't it?

I would have thought that the smoking guns you are talking about from unnamed sources that get whispered to various Murdoch publications and Shellenberger and The Daily Mail, would have been available to the other intelligence agencies. If they saw something as damning as that which is claimed why would they not be all in on the lab leak?

Again, you have to choose.

Either....

1.) the information about named WIV workers is not there, or not as damning. For example, maybe one of the workers went to hospital to have their appendix removed, who knows? Perhaps the intelligence is ambiguous leading to different people having different opinions.

2.) the intelligence agencies are completely incompetent and stupid. They looked at all the damning evidence but were too idiotic to understand that the WIV workers had Covid and that they were patients zero, one and two.

3.) the intelligence agencies are doing what they can to suppress the information for some reason. Option 3 is the conspiracy option, by the way.
 
Thanks, if it's anything like the rest of their idiotic House hearings you can expect it to be a joke.

The Trump brigade is in charge. So you know I said ahead of time, they will attack Fauci, look for lab origin evidence and I wouldn't take anything they have to say without complete alternative corroboration. Though it might be fun to watch.
 
Thanks, if it's anything like the rest of their idiotic House hearings you can expect it to be a joke.

The Trump brigade is in charge. So you know I said ahead of time, they will attack Fauci, look for lab origin evidence and I wouldn't take anything they have to say without complete alternative corroboration. Though it might be fun to watch.

I don’t know to what extent they are obliged to show up. Holmes and Rambaut don’t live in the US. Maybe they can subpoena the others (Garry, Lipkin and Andersen). Apparently they have also subpoena’d Andersen’s Slack channel.
 
Every pandemic up to now has resulted from a virus that has spread from an animal into humans. The default explanation has to be a natural zoonotic origin. That does not mean the possibility of a laboratory origin needs to be excluded, merely that it requires evidence.

This is something that keeps getting repeated but holds marginal relevance for this specific virus.

You are quoting history as if the technology, the science, and the explosions of bio labs around the world, in countries with perhaps less regulation or ability to ensure high safety levels would not in any way affect a possible leak.
Of course, it makes a leak more likely.

Especially when countries like China wanted (and built, with help from int'l partners) more and more high tech labs as a sign of global scientific importance since SARS- and picked up the work the US banned via surrogate funding in 2014. Plenty of papers and articles warning about the danger of this well before covid appeared.
Then it appeared, in the premiere place the virus type in question was studied.

I'll posit, for your review, that it is not accurate to compare the likelihood of natural origin vs. gain of function causing an outbreak by going back in time - pre-2005 or so at least, to a time before gain of function research exploded and became much more sophisticated, published, funded, ....and in other ways less safe as it proliferated. Scientists were concerned...and said so at the time.

Ralph Baric, the lead researcher here in the US taught Shi the no-see-um way to combine viral elements in 2015. Together, they represent the 2 top global corona virus labs in the entire world. No one would know or be able to see the splicing in this technique he pioneered.

How many pandemic viruses did we have since 2015? Isnt is amazing that Baric taught the only other top coronavirus researcher on the planet, in Wuhan, about his gain of function technique- and then a human-adapted bat-related coronavirus started there? 800 miles away? Without an animal intermediary found? Not even one at that time...Or since.

I cannot give proof, obviously. You wont ever get something irrefutable.
Too much time has passed for good data to be collected.

Or else tell me, other than going back in time to how historical viruses came about, tell me how THIS one likely came about knowing what we know about the presence of many more virus labs post SARS and gain of function work on corona viruses, especially bat derived, with live animals, being centered in in Wuhan.
 
This is something that keeps getting repeated but holds marginal relevance for this specific virus.

You are quoting history as if the technology, the science, and the explosions of bio labs around the world, in countries with perhaps less regulation or ability to ensure high safety levels would not in any way affect a possible leak.
Of course, it makes a leak more likely.

Especially when countries like China wanted (and built, with help from int'l partners) more and more high tech labs as a sign of global scientific importance since SARS- and picked up the work the US banned via surrogate funding in 2014. Plenty of papers and articles warning about the danger of this well before covid appeared.
Then it appeared, in the premiere place the virus type in question was studied.

I'll posit, for your review, that it is not accurate to compare the likelihood of natural origin vs. gain of function causing an outbreak by going back in time - pre-2005 or so at least, to a time before gain of function research exploded and became much more sophisticated, published, funded, ....and in other ways less safe as it proliferated. Scientists were concerned...and said so at the time.

Ralph Baric, the lead researcher here in the US taught Shi the no-see-um way to combine viral elements in 2015. Together, they represent the 2 top global corona virus labs in the entire world. No one would know or be able to see the splicing in this technique he pioneered.

How many pandemic viruses did we have since 2015? Isnt is amazing that Baric taught the only other top coronavirus researcher on the planet, in Wuhan, about his gain of function technique- and then a human-adapted bat-related coronavirus started there? 800 miles away? Without an animal intermediary found? Not even one at that time...Or since.

I cannot give proof, obviously. You wont ever get something irrefutable.
Too much time has passed for good data to be collected.

Or else tell me, other than going back in time to how historical viruses came about, tell me how THIS one likely came about knowing what we know about the presence of many more virus labs post SARS and gain of function work on corona viruses, especially bat derived, with live animals, being centered in in Wuhan.

It seems pretty well agreed that SARS-CoV-2 was not a bio-engineered virus. The only discussion seems to be whether WIV had SARS-CoV-2 or a near precursor as a live virus in the laboratory prior to December 2019 or not. The gain of function research (and note there is no clear definition of what gain of function research is) is irrelevant because no one who knows about viruses thinks that SARS-CoV-2 was an engineered virus. Whether WIV had live animals is irrelevant. It is clear SARS-CoV-2 like viruses occur in the wild. All the talk about Furin cleavage sites was based on a false idea that Furin cleavage sites did not occur in SARS-CoV-2 like viruses in the wild, subsequently this has been shown to be untrue. The prescence or not of animals at WIV is irrelevant to whether a laboratory leak occurred, animals are entirely unnecessary requirement. A laboratory leak of SARS-CoV-2 could have occurred without the need of gain of function research or serial passage in animals. All it requires is for someone to have collected a sample containing that virus in the wild and for it to have been sent to WIV and for that virus to have 'leaked' from WIV into the human population.

None of the known viruses that WIV possessed could have benn turned into SARS-CoV-2 by engineering or serial passage. Gain of function research (and there is no evidence any gain of function research was done at WIV) could not have created SARs-CoV-2 from any known viruses in the possession of WIV. No animals could have created SARS-CoV-2 from known viruses.

What was required and all that was required is for WIV to have a previously unknown virus - SARS-CoV-2 collected somewhere in the wild sent into it. That is the one thing that there is no evidence for.

Do you really think virus research is new? It is over a hundred years old. Probably biosafety is better than it has ever been.The fact that pandemics have occurred fro thousands of years entirely naturally is evidence that a laboratory leak is unnecessary for a pandemic to occur. The fact that people have been warning that human behaviour, incursions into wild environments, rapid transport and connectedness and large metropolises are making the likelihood of a pandemic more likely is exactly why a pandemic was expected to occur by an entirely natural route.
 
Most of the recent pandemics seem to have had claims of a laboratory origin, SARS, HIV, Ebola, Flu. The only one I haven't seen a laboratory origin for is Mpox.

Of course laboratory leaks occur, the last cases of small pox were due to a laboratory leak in England (from a biscuit tin in the back of a fridge). Most pandemics outbreaks we do not know the intermediate animal vector. We do not know it for Mpox, for Ebola, we have not found SARS in wild bats, just related viruses.
 
Most of the recent pandemics seem to have had claims of a laboratory origin, SARS, HIV, Ebola, Flu. The only one I haven't seen a laboratory origin for is Mpox.

Of course laboratory leaks occur, the last cases of small pox were due to a laboratory leak in England (from a biscuit tin in the back of a fridge). Most pandemics outbreaks we do not know the intermediate animal vector. We do not know it for Mpox, for Ebola, we have not found SARS in wild bats, just related viruses.

There are lab leak theories for MPXV spreading on social media, one such is debunked here.

https://www.factcheck.org/2022/07/p...-creating-fragment-of-monkeypox-viral-genome/
 
This is something that keeps getting repeated but holds marginal relevance for this specific virus....
Not to mention it isn't true. See my post above documenting dozens of cases of escaped pathogens from labs. After seeing that post Planigale altered her version of never happened to admitting it happened once.My post included dozens of well documented times it happened.

Excellent post BTW.

Notice how Planigale ignored the points you made. She starts by ignoring all the work posted in this thread about Baric's work in North Carolina and everything Shi took back to China from that work.

Planigale said:
It seems pretty well agreed that SARS-CoV-2 was not a bio-engineered virus.
This is false.

Wuhan and US scientists used undetectable methods of genetic engineering on bat coronaviruses -- 20 May 2020
2020, this is well known, it's not some new concept that no one believes is true. Maybe in your head, Planigale, it seems pretty well agreed COVID wasn't bio-engineered. What that most often refers to is the virus is not a patchwork of genes cobbled together like Frankenstein's monster.

Where did the lie come from?
Evidence has emerged that researchers at the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) in China, working in collaboration with scientists in the USA, have been genetically engineering bat viruses for the past several years to investigate infectivity – using undetectable methods. ...

The evidence rebuts claims by journalists and some scientists that the SARS-CoV-2 virus responsible for the current COVID-19 pandemic could not have been genetically engineered because it lacks the “signs” or “signatures” that supposedly would be left behind by genetic engineering techniques.

Those making these claims cite as evidence a letter published in Nature Medicine in March by American microbiologist Kristian Andersen and colleagues. The article stated that there was no evidence that the virus had been genetically manipulated and concluded that it emerged through natural mutation and selection in animal and human hosts.[1]

Typical of the media response to the Nature Medicine letter was an article published in The Scientist, which stated, “there are no signs of genetic manipulation in the SARS-CoV-2 genome”. The BBC also reported that “the study of the coronavirus genome … found no signs it had been engineered”.

Other experts, however, have pointed out that there are well known ways of manipulating the genetic material of a virus without leaving any such signs. Now Dr Richard Ebright, an infectious disease expert at Rutgers University (USA), has alerted the public to evidence that WIV and US-based researchers were genetically engineering bat viruses to investigate their ability to infect humans, using commonly used methods that leave no sign or signature of human manipulation.
So much for "pretty well agreed". I expect this evidence to be ignored. The same false claim that it wasn't 'engineered' will be posted again.

The WIV scientists did this, Ebright points out, “using ‘seamless ligation’ procedures that leave no signatures of human manipulation”. This is noteworthy because it is a type of genetic engineering that Andersen and his team excluded from their investigation into whether SARS-CoV-2 could have been engineered – and it was in use at the very lab that is the prime suspect for a lab escape. ...

Dr Michael Antoniou, a London-based molecular geneticist, told us that these methods of genetic engineering have been commonly used for decades and do not leave any kind of “signature”. Commenting on Andersen and his team’s omission of these methods from their article in Nature Medicine, Dr Antoniou told us, “This shows that these authors’ conclusions about whether genetic engineering could have been involved are not justified by the available evidence.” ...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom