Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Maybe you meant to reply to Marting because your post is a non sequitur to my post. I was replying to the bolded below:


If you want to discuss what the report confirms or refutes about the three ill WIV workers that's best addressed separately, without misleading by quoting me out of context.
I'll look over the link and get back to you.

Okay, first of all, what does it say about "three"?
 
For what it is worth, Ben Hu and Yu Ping both deny that they were ill in autumn 2019.

A scientist at China’s Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) who has recently faced media allegations that he was the first person with COVID-19 and his research on coronaviruses sparked the pandemic strongly denies that he was ill in late 2019 or that his work had any link to the emergence of SARS-CoV-2. Moreover, a newly released U.S. report of declassified information on COVID-19’s origin, from the Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI), fails to name him or substantiate that any WIV scientists had the initial cases of COVID-19.

“The recent news about so-called ‘patient zero’ in WIV are absolutely rumors and ridiculous,” Ben Hu emailed Science in his first public response to the charges, which have been attributed to anonymous former and current U.S. Department of State officials. A WIV colleague who has also been named as one of the first COVID-19 cases denies the accusation as well.

Link

I would hope that we can see this as a fork in the road.

If the intelligence community genuinely has information that these two were sick, and if they are supposed to declassify this information, and the claims that three scientists were sick is apparently known to US intel, and two of those deny it, then it would surely be a simple thing for the intelligence community (particularly the two branches that lean towards lab leak) to finally say outright that these two were named in the intel with some corroborating evidence.

For me we can make a choice:

a) accept that the claims of named scientists from WIV being sick is without a good foundation

OR

b) the US intel are part of the plot (even the ones who claim to lean lab leak).

Choose wisely!
 
For what it is worth, Ben Hu and Yu Ping both deny that they were ill in autumn 2019.

Link

I would hope that we can see this as a fork in the road.

If the intelligence community genuinely has information that these two were sick, and if they are supposed to declassify this information, and the claims that three scientists were sick is apparently known to US intel, and two of those deny it, then it would surely be a simple thing for the intelligence community (particularly the two branches that lean towards lab leak) to finally say outright that these two were named in the intel with some corroborating evidence.

For me we can make a choice:

a) accept that the claims of named scientists from WIV being sick is without a good foundation

OR

b) the US intel are part of the plot (even the ones who claim to lean lab leak).

Choose wisely!
Give me a break. Surely you know this is an absurd false dichotomy. :rolleyes:

The paragraph you quoted says a lot:
A scientist at China’s Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) who has recently faced media allegations that he was the first person with COVID-19 and his research on coronaviruses sparked the pandemic strongly denies that he was ill in late 2019 or that his work had any link to the emergence of SARS-CoV-2. Moreover, a newly released U.S. report of declassified information on COVID-19’s origin, from the Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI), fails to name him or substantiate that any WIV scientists had the initial cases of COVID-19.
So, du'h would you admit you were patient zero if you were responsible for a lab error that led to a worldwide pandemic? That's highly unlikely.

And second, that ODNI report doesn't name any of the three. Do keep in mind these 3 ill workers from the WIV are not the entirety of the lab origin evidence.

From page 6 of the report:
As of January 2019, WIV researchers performed SARSlike coronavirus experiments in BSL-2 laboratories, despite acknowledgements going back to 2017 of these virus’ ability to directly infect humans through their spike protein and early 2019 warnings of the danger of this practice. Separately, the WIV’s plan to conduct analysis of potential epidemic viruses from pangolin samples in fall 2019, suggests the researchers sought to isolate live viruses.


That said, I'll have to go hunt down more details about where these names came from since they did not come from this report. Initially the 3 were mentioned way back in early 2020. This report is from 2023. And the report was they sought care in a hospital (probably as outpatients as opposed to being hospitalized). I'm not sure where all that speculation has come from in the ODNI about the possible symptoms etc the three had.

From the ODNI report cited above, page 7:
The IC assesses that the WIV maintains blood samples and health records of all of their laboratory personnel—which are standard procedures in high containment laboratories.
• We have no indications that any of these researchers were hospitalized because of the symptoms consistent with COVID-19. One researcher may have been hospitalized in this timeframe for treatment of a non-respiratory medical condition.
• China’s National Security Commission investigated the WIV in early 2020 and took blood samples from WIV researchers. According to the World Health Organization's March 2021 public report, WIV officials including Shi Zhengli who leads the WIV laboratory group that conducts coronavirus research—stated lab employee samples all tested negative for SARS-CoV-2 antibodies.​
This would be the raw data the WHO team were not allowed to see.

And an important component:
some of them were confirmed to have been sick with other illnesses unrelated to COVID-19.
Why is the evidence of confirmed other illnesses not available? Shi said no one in her department was ill, something odd given surely some of them had influenza or other respiratory infections at that time.

Again from page 7, the complete paragraph:
While several WIV researchers fell mildly ill in Fall 2019, they experienced a range of symptoms consistent with colds or allergies with accompanying symptoms typically not associated with COVID-19, and some of them were confirmed to have been sick with other illnesses unrelated to COVID-19. While some of these researchers had historically conducted research into animal respiratory viruses, we are unable to confirm if an of them handled live viruses in the work they performed prior to falling ill.
Several, mildly ill, range of symptoms, some had confirmed other illnesses, unable to confirm any handled live viruses ... Good grief that's a lot of detail given at the same time it is so nonspecific.
 
Last edited:
Give me a break. Surely you know this is an absurd false dichotomy. :rolleyes:

The paragraph you quoted says a lot:
So, du'h would you admit you were patient zero if you were responsible for a lab error that led to a worldwide pandemic? That's highly unlikely.

We don't need to rely on Ben Hu or Yu Ping's say-so though, do we?

This is "the dog that didn't bark" evidence.

If they both say they were not sick, wouldn't it be trivially easy for the Intel Community to show declassified evidence that yes they were!?

Why have they not done so? Why are the intel community such a bunch of no-nothing dorks, in your opinion, that they haven't flagged this up as a lie?

Are they just not very good at their job? Possibly.

But we really have no good evidence that these were actually sick. Only gossip and hearsay.
 
Mike Pompeo really strainnig with this one....

Mike Pompeo said:
The declassified COVID origins report confirms what we knew from the beginning: the only logical explanation is that the virus came from the Wuhan lab.


Link

What does it actually, literally say?

Variations in IC analytic views on the origins of the COVID-19 pandemic largely stem from differences in how agencies weigh intelligence reporting and scientific publications and intelligence and scientific gaps. All agencies continue to assess that both a natural and laboratory-associated origin remain plausible hypotheses to explain the first human infection.

I have to wonder if Mike Pompeo was one of the "multiple sources" along with Miles Yu and David Asher who have been talking to people like Shellenberger and claiming they believe it was 100% lab leak. Miles Yu on the Fever podcast certainly seemed adamant that the intel says this, yet the BBC journalist (who seems to be pretty open to the idea of lab leak) then pointed out that the US intelligence community was not sufficiently persuaded.
 
We don't need to rely on Ben Hu or Yu Ping's say-so though, do we?

This is "the dog that didn't bark" evidence.

If they both say they were not sick, wouldn't it be trivially easy for the Intel Community to show declassified evidence that yes they were!?

Why have they not done so? Why are the intel community such a bunch of no-nothing dorks, in your opinion, that they haven't flagged this up as a lie?

Are they just not very good at their job? Possibly.

But we really have no good evidence that these were actually sick. Only gossip and hearsay.
No point in answering this directly, angrysoba. It hardly qualifies as debate when you claim there is no good evidence any of these lab workers were actually sick. And you base that on a single report which doesn't even say that when there are others of equal validity that clearly report on these ill workers.

Better if I backup to one of the first reports of these 3 ill workers that you've so intently focused on. This was in May 2021 after Biden ordered some of the intel released.

U.S. intel report identified 3 Wuhan lab researchers who fell ill in November 2019
This reporting adds a new level of detail to the information put out in a Department of State fact sheet last year, which said the United States had confirmed that researchers at the Wuhan Institute of Virology had fallen ill.

"The U.S. government has reason to believe that several researchers inside the WIV became sick in autumn 2019, before the first identified case of the outbreak, with symptoms consistent with both Covid-19 and common seasonal illnesses. This raises questions about the credibility of WIV senior researcher Shi Zhengli's public claim that there was 'zero infection' among the WIV's staff and students of SARS-CoV-2 or SARS-related viruses,” the fact sheet said.


I think there's a lot of evidence plus it's a logical conclusion Shi has not been truthful. IIRC you think Metzl is unreliable for ... reasons. Correct me if I'm wrong.
In April 2020, NBC News reported that the U.S. had indications as far back as November of a possible health crisis in Wuhan.

“The most important implications of this would be to show that Wuhan Institute of Virology director Shi Zhengli was not being truthful when she said that no one in the institute had been ill in that time period,” said Jamie Metzl, a senior fellow at the Atlantic Council and a former national security official in the Clinton administration, who has been calling for an investigation into the lab theory.

Reuter's also repeated what the WSJ reported. The WSJ is paywalled for most of us.

Wuhan lab staff sought hospital care before COVID-19 outbreak disclosed - WSJ ... May 23, 2021
Three researchers from China's Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) sought hospital care in November 2019, a month before China reported the first cases of COVID-19, the Wall Street Journal reported on Sunday, citing a U.S. intelligence report. ...

The newspaper said the previously undisclosed report - which provides fresh details on the number of researchers affected, the timing of their illnesses, and their hospital visits - may add weight to calls for a broader investigation into whether the COVID-19 virus could have escaped from the laboratory.


The Journal said current and former officials familiar with the intelligence expressed a range of views about the strength of the report's supporting evidence, ...

China's foreign ministry spokesman, Zhao Lijian, said on Monday that it was "completely untrue" that three members of staff at WIV had fallen ill.


A month later we had this:
Fauci says China should share the medical records of Wuhan lab staff who were ill in fall 2019: 'What did they get sick with?'
Three staff members at a lab in Wuhan fell ill with coronavirus-like symptoms in fall 2019.
The WHO said the staff tested negative for COVID-19 antibodies, but Fauci wants China to share the medical records.
"The WHO said"= as in the report on the situation when Daszak was directing the output of the WHO report, something that led to a number of researchers objecting to his being on the team. And Fauci is still treading lightly here given he's been accused of knowingly approving the funding of WIV GoF research.

You don't accept the names revealed by Taibbi et al so I'll wait for more reports on those specifics. But if Ben Hu wanted to support his denial he was ill during that time he could get Shi to release the specific COVID lab results on the WIV staff or other relevant medical records.
 
Mike Pompeo really strainnig with this one....

Link

What does it actually, literally say?

I have to wonder if Mike Pompeo was one of the "multiple sources" along with Miles Yu and David Asher who have been talking to people like Shellenberger and claiming they believe it was 100% lab leak. Miles Yu on the Fever podcast certainly seemed adamant that the intel says this, yet the BBC journalist (who seems to be pretty open to the idea of lab leak) then pointed out that the US intelligence community was not sufficiently persuaded.
Pompeo is a Trump sycophant who I believe is running for POTUS in 2024. He's not a scientific source.

As for anyone claiming they are 100% sure it was a lab leak, so what? The US agencies were divided between neutral or spillover, leaning slightly toward the lab and the FBI leaning more strongly toward the lab origin. No one in the scientific community that I'm aware of has officially stated the lab origin was conclusive.
 
Okay, first of all, what does it say about "three"?
You're going to go there? Really? :boggled:

Three ill workers from the WIV in Nov 2019 have been mentioned time and time again in the thread and in citations. Do you just blank out all previous discussions on the topic when you get a new one?
 
TB: school, factory, pub.
Meningitis; school, university (x2)
Q fever; slaughterhouse

Occupational health (for staff) and infection control teams deal with nosocomial issues.

I don't think you want me to bring up months ago when you didn't understand the difference between active TB disease and latent TB infection, do you?
 
No point in answering this directly, angrysoba. It hardly qualifies as debate when you claim there is no good evidence any of these lab workers were actually sick. And you base that on a single report which doesn't even say that when there are others of equal validity that clearly report on these ill workers.

A "single report"? This is the one you guys were waiting for! The declassification of the intel community's assessment? Suddenly the nothingburger is a nothingburger?

Better if I backup to one of the first reports of these 3 ill workers that you've so intently focused on. This was in May 2021 after Biden ordered some of the intel released.

U.S. intel report identified 3 Wuhan lab researchers who fell ill in November 2019



I think there's a lot of evidence plus it's a logical conclusion Shi has not been truthful. IIRC you think Metzl is unreliable for ... reasons. Correct me if I'm wrong.


Reuter's also repeated what the WSJ reported. The WSJ is paywalled for most of us.

Wuhan lab staff sought hospital care before COVID-19 outbreak disclosed - WSJ ... May 23, 2021


A month later we had this:
Fauci says China should share the medical records of Wuhan lab staff who were ill in fall 2019: 'What did they get sick with?'
"The WHO said"= as in the report on the situation when Daszak was directing the output of the WHO report, something that led to a number of researchers objecting to his being on the team. And Fauci is still treading lightly here given he's been accused of knowingly approving the funding of WIV GoF research.

You don't accept the names revealed by Taibbi et al so I'll wait for more reports on those specifics. But if Ben Hu wanted to support his denial he was ill during that time he could get Shi to release the specific COVID lab results on the WIV staff or other relevant medical records.

The WSJ is not paywalled for me as I somehow have an account for a university I used to work for that still allows me to access WSJ. Which is nice. I'll DM you the whole article if you like.

One thing people have noted is that one of the writers is of WMD in Iraq fame (Michael Gordon), but never mind that...

Current and former officials familiar with the intelligence about the lab researchers expressed differing views about the strength of the supporting evidence for the assessment. One person said that it was provided by an international partner and was potentially significant but still in need of further investigation and additional corroboration.
Another person described the intelligence as stronger. “The information that we had coming from the various sources was of exquisite quality. It was very precise. What it didn’t tell you was exactly why they got sick,” he said, referring to the researchers.

It's interesting that current and former intelligence sources have different levels of confidence about it.

As mentioned, people like Pompeo, Asher and Yu have been banging the drum for lab leak, and this could be seen, by cynics, as unsurprising for Trump officials keen to get their guy off the hook.

In other words, you are going back to a single report where a known stenographer of dodgy intel retells a story in which "current and former" operatives have a range of beliefs about the strength of evidence that three were sick. Oh and apparently "it didn’t tell you was exactly why they got sick"

What's the hold-up? Is the intel that names these WIV workers at Mar-e-Lago or something? Apparently some of these people claim to know exactly who was sick and yet none of them are going on the record? And you claim that China is keeping secrets!!!

Oh, by the way, just out of interest, do you know what the New York Post, The Wall Street Journal, Fox News, Sharri Markson's The Australian, Sky News and the UK's The Sunday Times all have in common? They are all owned by Murdoch. Why is it that almost all the lab leak discourse is coming out of Rupert Murdoch's press seemingly amplifying former Trump administration mouthpieces?
 
G
So, du'h would you admit you were patient zero if you were responsible for a lab error that led to a worldwide pandemic? That's highly unlikely.

There is another side to this coin that you don't seem to be giving much thought or concern to.

Would you want to be accused of starting a pandemic that killed millions?

Would you also willingly accuse someone of doing the same without hard evidence?

Taibbi and Shellenberger seem to be happy to make the accusations, but you give them a pass for not revealing their sources.

Apparenlty others seem happy to whisper in the ear of journalists, these accusations, but not to go on record themselves of having leaked the information.

Where is the whistleblower who will just stand up and tell the truth on the record? If someone knows that Ben Hu got infected and is patient zero, then why doesn't that person do so publicly?
 
A "single report"? This is the one you guys were waiting for! The declassification of the intel community's assessment? Suddenly the nothingburger is a nothingburger?
Who is "you guys"? And why would anything newly released somehow erase everything else in 3 years of posts?

I backtracked because you posted such a vague account of the WIV workers' illnesses in Nov 2019. And you dismissed the names of the workers so I'm looking for more information on that.


The WSJ is not paywalled for me as I somehow have an account for a university I used to work for that still allows me to access WSJ. Which is nice. I'll DM you the whole article if you like.
Only send it or quote from it if it adds anything to Reuters or NBC News.


It's interesting that current and former intelligence sources have different levels of confidence about it.
I don't think that's the case. There are 6 different agencies with their own investigative branches. It's not about current and former reports.


As mentioned, people like Pompeo, Asher and Yu have been banging the drum for lab leak, and this could be seen, by cynics, as unsurprising for Trump officials keen to get their guy off the hook.
Maybe it's the view you have from Japan but that's not how it looks from here. Trump's sycophants don't need to get him off the hook for anything except his criminal charges. His followers are not based in reality.

Trump's blaming China for his incompetence isn't something non-Trump cultists pay much attention to that I'm aware of.


In other words, you are going back to a single report where a known stenographer of dodgy intel retells a story in which "current and former" operatives have a range of beliefs about the strength of evidence that three were sick. Oh and apparently "it didn’t tell you was exactly why they got sick"

What's the hold-up? Is the intel that names these WIV workers at Mar-e-Lago or something? Apparently some of these people claim to know exactly who was sick and yet none of them are going on the record? And you claim that China is keeping secrets!!!
You've gone off the rails again here. I'm not replying to non-evidence based discussion.


Oh, by the way, just out of interest, do you know what the New York Post, The Wall Street Journal, Fox News, Sharri Markson's The Australian, Sky News and the UK's The Sunday Times all have in common? They are all owned by Murdoch. Why is it that almost all the lab leak discourse is coming out of Rupert Murdoch's press seemingly amplifying former Trump administration mouthpieces?
And here you are again dissing sources instead of addressing actual arguments against what is in those sources.


Are you not interested in weighing the evidence for each origin hypothesis?
 
SG:

I'll try to boil this down.

I don't think we have any good evidence about sick WIV workers that pushes the needle either way.

Maybe you find the reports to be believable, but it seems to me you are over-confident in how credible you find sources that mention specific workers by name.

I don't think there is much more to say on that topic.
 
This is a member of the Intelligence Committee who has apparently seen the intelligence saying that The Sunday Times article is not accurate when it claims that the Chinese military was working on a bioweapon with the Wuhan Institute of Virology.



The Intel report has effectively debunked many of the claims made by The Times and various right-wing politicians, saying there was no evidence of an incident, there was no apparent evidence of a progenitor virus in the WIV.

And there is an insider account that disputes that much of the claims about lab leak were based on any solid evidence.

There is a good account on Twitter by someone called everythingism who has been posting some of the interesting stuff that debunks the lab leak claims.

One thing he links to is an open letter by a former Trump official who was apparently very interested in the lab leak but became annoyed by some of his co-workers making up nonsense to try and sex-up the evidence.

He claims that there was something of a cadre of officials within the Trump administration spreading rumours. Some of the people he mentions are David Asher, Thomas Dinannio, Miles Yu and Mike Pompeo.

Link

Here is my bet. Shellenberger and Taibbi are recylcing these rumours about specific scientists getting sick from Covid-19 and from it being created in a lab from those sources.

The same sources have been whispering in the ear of journalists for the Wall Street journal and The Sunday Times.

If they really had good evidence then we would have seen it and someone should have blown the whistle.

The fact that the actual intel community's report fails to corroborate any of the claims that the lab leakers have been making, and the fact that politicians who have seen the intel have gone on record to say that the Time reporting is false, is good evidence that there is no good evidence for a lab leak.
 
This is a member of the Intelligence Committee who has apparently seen the intelligence saying that The Sunday Times article is not accurate when it claims that the Chinese military was working on a bioweapon with the Wuhan Institute of Virology.



The Intel report has effectively debunked many of the claims made by The Times and various right-wing politicians, saying there was no evidence of an incident, there was no apparent evidence of a progenitor virus in the WIV.

And there is an insider account that disputes that much of the claims about lab leak were based on any solid evidence.

There is a good account on Twitter by someone called everythingism who has been posting some of the interesting stuff that debunks the lab leak claims.

One thing he links to is an open letter by a former Trump official who was apparently very interested in the lab leak but became annoyed by some of his co-workers making up nonsense to try and sex-up the evidence.

He claims that there was something of a cadre of officials within the Trump administration spreading rumours. Some of the people he mentions are David Asher, Thomas Dinannio, Miles Yu and Mike Pompeo.

Link

Here is my bet. Shellenberger and Taibbi are recylcing these rumours about specific scientists getting sick from Covid-19 and from it being created in a lab from those sources.

The same sources have been whispering in the ear of journalists for the Wall Street journal and The Sunday Times.

If they really had good evidence then we would have seen it and someone should have blown the whistle.

The fact that the actual intel community's report fails to corroborate any of the claims that the lab leakers have been making, and the fact that politicians who have seen the intel have gone on record to say that the Time reporting is false, is good evidence that there is no good evidence for a lab leak.

Lab leak, or rather lab-related exposure is the best explanation so far. It was obvious at the start and there is no evidence moving away from it. Data from China is garbage. If it started in the US next to one of the virus labs here and they claimed it was natural Id have the same conclusion.

Where is the intermediate animal? WHERE? China? Laos? Vietnam? The wet market evidence showed only humans...no wild animals with the virus, though there was a hard push towards making such a connection. Did you fall for that narrative? Without evidence?

The fact that some have said portions of the virus can connect outside Yunnan bats just confirms it was almost certainly the lab. Everyone sent their virus samples to that specific 'bat' lab. Mix and match. Safety measures were not top notch.
Maybe a natural mix from live animals without manipulation, as has happened before (See Shi's paper on hantu infections). I happen to think it is more likely the result of actual experiments.
The French built it and the US partially paid for the work done there that was halted in the US for many programs. The quick apologists at the start who blared out that it must be natural all had a financial tie (even if just potantially governmental) and a cya motivation to deflect cause, before anything was really known. I happen to suppose the originators of that narrative KNEW.

Lean back and take a wide view of the events in totality.

So, angrysoba-- Knowing what you do now, what do you place the odds at*? Natural origin (not related at all to the lab) or Wuhan bat lab related?

*I realize we may never know for certain.
 
Lab leak, or rather lab-related exposure is the best explanation so far. It was obvious at the start and there is no evidence moving away from it. Data from China is garbage. If it started in the US next to one of the virus labs here and they claimed it was natural Id have the same conclusion.

Where is the intermediate animal? WHERE? China? Laos? Vietnam? The wet market evidence showed only humans...no wild animals with the virus, though there was a hard push towards making such a connection. Did you fall for that narrative? Without evidence?

The fact that some have said portions of the virus can connect outside Yunnan bats just confirms it was almost certainly the lab. Everyone sent their virus samples to that specific 'bat' lab. Mix and match. Safety measures were not top notch.
Maybe a natural mix from live animals without manipulation, as has happened before (See Shi's paper on hantu infections). I happen to think it is more likely the result of actual experiments.
The French built it and the US partially paid for the work done there that was halted in the US for many programs. The quick apologists at the start who blared out that it must be natural all had a financial tie (even if just potantially governmental) and a cya motivation to deflect cause, before anything was really known. I happen to suppose the originators of that narrative KNEW.

Lean back and take a wide view of the events in totality.

So, angrysoba-- Knowing what you do now, what do you place the odds at*? Natural origin (not related at all to the lab) or Wuhan bat lab related?

*I realize we may never know for certain.

I guess the US intelligence community are part of the conspiracy.

How is it that YOU are so confident of a lab leak to the extent that you think all virologists who believe otherwise are just worried about their funding?

Anyway, I have already stated what would persuade me of a lab leak, and not only has that not transpired, but it has been more or less refuted.

1.) I said if the three virologists who Shellenberger and Taibbi turn out to have been sick/hospitalized with something like Covid and that one of them had lost their wife to the disease or something very similar, that would be pretty much conclusively proven for me.

2.) Similarly, if it turned out that the progenitor virus had been in the WIV, that would persuade me, but nothing close has been shown.

If you could persuade me of 1 and 2 then I would change my mind.

But 1 is looking more like a rumour told to credulous reporters and 2 has not only not been shown, but the opposite has been shown as the sequences that people were worried might have been hidden prognenitor viruses were accounted for later and shown to not be close to SARS-CoV-2.
 
I guess the US intelligence community are part of the conspiracy.
There is no conspiracy, not in the sense we use the term here. :rolleyes:

There is a Chinese coverup and some people directly involved who aren't about to admit to the mistakes they have made.


How is it that YOU are so confident of a lab leak to the extent that you think all virologists who believe otherwise are just worried about their funding?
And here when you can't make an evidence based argument you revert to a repeat fallacy you are fond of, science by majority vote.


Anyway, I have already stated what would persuade me of a lab leak, and not only has that not transpired, but it has been more or less refuted.

1.) I said if the three virologists who Shellenberger and Taibbi turn out to have been sick/hospitalized with something like Covid and that one of them had lost their wife to the disease or something very similar, that would be pretty much conclusively proven for me.
IOW if patient zero can be identified and said pandemic started with patient zero from the WIV, that would be a smoking gun.


2.) Similarly, if it turned out that the progenitor virus had been in the WIV, that would persuade me, but nothing close has been shown.

If you could persuade me of 1 and 2 then I would change my mind.
Same thing, smoking guns.


But 1 is looking more like a rumour told to credulous reporters and 2 has not only not been shown, but the opposite has been shown as the sequences that people were worried might have been hidden prognenitor viruses were accounted for later and shown to not be close to SARS-CoV-2.
And here you've cherry picked a pretty small sliver out of all the evidence that has been cited in this thread.

Why these 2 things specifically? I can name a dozen other potential smoking guns.



You avoided the question you were asked.
Sherkeu said:
Lean back and take a wide view of the events in totality.

So, angrysoba-- Knowing what you do now, what do you place the odds at*? Natural origin (not related at all to the lab) or Wuhan bat lab related?
 
There is no conspiracy, not in the sense we use the term here. :rolleyes:

There is a Chinese coverup and some people directly involved who aren't about to admit to the mistakes they have made.


And here when you can't make an evidence based argument you revert to a repeat fallacy you are fond of, science by majority vote.


IOW if patient zero can be identified and said pandemic started with patient zero from the WIV, that would be a smoking gun.


Same thing, smoking guns.


And here you've cherry picked a pretty small sliver out of all the evidence that has been cited in this thread.

Why these 2 things specifically? I can name a dozen other potential smoking guns.



You avoided the question you were asked.

I've told you what would convince me.

Do you still believe Ben Hu was patient zero?

Do you think his wife died of Covid?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom