Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

:rolleyes:

Shi's teams retrieved specimens for a decade from bats and other sources in Yunnan. They didn't toss them in a week. We're not talking about specimens kept in a diagnostic lab be it commercial or in the hospital.



You need to review epidemiological investigations. This post suggests you don't know what you are talking about but you are trying to discredit a source anyway. Line listing on a spread sheet can be any number of variables, not just lab output. Every investigation is not done in a hospital.


ETA Here's a good resource for anyone interested:
CDC: Describing Epidemiologic Data

I have completed training for outbreak control / field epidemiology, and have been part of outbreak control teams, so am familiar with the process. As i said it may be a matter of terminiology, but line listings in the Uk typically refer to the output from laboratory data systems. An outbreak team will typically get the line listings of interest once or twice a day. What we would not do is term outputs from the outbreak database as line listings. What is generated would be summary epidemiological data.

UK data protection would prevent sharing raw data with outside bodies e.g. WHO. Obviously China will have its own regulations, but it is not reasonable for someone to think that they could just ask for raw data on individuals health and be given it.
 
Of course it's different! It's a separate issue. :rolleyes:

I have been posting repeatedly about this specific information. What that link adds is the total number of patients Worobey doesn't have in his data analysis and half of 174 having no link to the market is a larger number than I realized.

No *direct* link to the market. Nearly all of these 174 patients within half a kilometer of the market even the ones who hadn't been there and therefor had no direct link to it.

This is exactly what you would expect 4-6 weeks out from crossover events at the market. The market itself would make up most know cases but spread into the surrounding community should be happening by then as well.
 
That would be important evidence but you would still need the missing piece, how did it get from X to Wuhan? Without that it would not be a smoking gun.

No. The genetic evidence on it's own is the smoking gun. The pathway from wild animals to Chinese wetmarkets is long established as a very high risk vector for getting wild viruses into major population centers. We even have a recent example of it occurring With SARS.

Not being able to find the exact animals in traveled in 3 years ago before anyone was collecting samples from these animals is an absurdly high standard that would only be presented as "sensible" by someone who made up their minds and was actually trying advocate for a specific answer instead of letting the data guild them to an answer. If we use this standard every know virus in history must be a lab leak because we don't know the precise infected animal that caused the first human infection.
 
No. The genetic evidence on it's own is the smoking gun. The pathway from wild animals to Chinese wetmarkets is long established as a very high risk vector for getting wild viruses into major population centers. We even have a recent example of it occurring With SARS.

Not being able to find the exact animals in traveled in 3 years ago before anyone was collecting samples from these animals is an absurdly high standard that would only be presented as "sensible" by someone who made up their minds and was actually trying advocate for a specific answer instead of letting the data guild them to an answer. If we use this standard every know virus in history must be a lab leak because we don't know the precise infected animal that caused the first human infection.

That's no more than circumstantial evidence, easily dismissed as coincidence.
 
That's no more than circumstantial evidence, easily dismissed as coincidence.

Evolution is "circumstantial evidence, easily dismissed as coincidence"? That sounds like an extraordinary claim that needs to be supported by extraordinary evidence. Do you have any such evidence?
 
I have completed training for outbreak control / field epidemiology, and have been part of outbreak control teams, so am familiar with the process. As i said it may be a matter of terminiology, but line listings in the Uk typically refer to the output from laboratory data systems. An outbreak team will typically get the line listings of interest once or twice a day. What we would not do is term outputs from the outbreak database as line listings. What is generated would be summary epidemiological data.

UK data protection would prevent sharing raw data with outside bodies e.g. WHO. Obviously China will have its own regulations, but it is not reasonable for someone to think that they could just ask for raw data on individuals health and be given it.
Outbreak control? You mean a hospital investigation of an outbreak?:rolleyes:

None of your arguments re China not releasing data are valid. They didn't need to disclose personal identifiers.

And with that, I believe this bit has run its course.
 
Yeah I saw the click-baity headlines from NYPost and now the Fail. Koopmans says in the interview that she now thinks lab leak is about as likely as the cold-chain hypothesis. That is to say they are both unlikely, but not impossible.
Here you are dissing The Daily Fail after you used it as a source only a few posts upthread. :sdl:

BTW, I posted it because it referred to Lipkin, not because of anything it said about Koopmans. I should have made that more clear.

And another BTW, you reverted to your usual pattern, the information/evidence is no good because of the source, and if a source has a clickbait headline, same thing.

These guys are not the only ones coming around to the lab origin hypothesis. I don't have an exact count but it is more than were there originally (and there were a few like Tedros, head of the WHO) and the number has been growing steadily since.

Worobey got a few people excited he'd shown the market was the spillover source. But even that finding is being criticized by more and more people who recognize just how weak his study is.
 
Last edited:
Evolution is "circumstantial evidence, easily dismissed as coincidence"? That sounds like an extraordinary claim that needs to be supported by extraordinary evidence. Do you have any such evidence?

We're not talking about evolution, we're specifically talking about the possibility of spillover from the wild at a wet market. It's happened before, yep, so what? other viruses have mutated in the past, yep, so what? Neither is direct evidence for this occurance of covid spilling over from the wild in Wuhan. That's the definition of circumstantial evidence - it's possible but could just as easily be coincidence.

Consider the mass of circumstantial evidence for a lab leak - proximity to lab, people getting sick, databases vanishing, Dazak writing letters pointing away from the lab etc etc etc. I'm sure you know them all, having spent many pages of this thread handwaving them away as coincidence. That's ****ton of circumstantial evidence you airily dismiss, and the more you have to dismiss as coincidence the less likely they are coincidence at all.

So don't be surprised when others take your circumstantial evidence and dismiss it as coincidence.

A couple of further points;

I wonder which is the more damning criticism of the Chinese people, that the general population just can't stop eating wild animals despite the possibility of cross contamination by wild viruses, or that the CCP is unable to ensure biosecurity at their labs.


Lab security could be addressed, whilst the continued presence of wild animals at markets is unlkely to be addressable in the short or even the long term. Which would you prefer as the reason for the outbreak, an addressable mistake or one that is unlikely to be ever addressed?
 
We're not talking about evolution, we're specifically talking about the possibility of spillover from the wild at a wet market. It's happened before, yep, so what? other viruses have mutated in the past, yep, so what? Neither is direct evidence for this occurance of covid spilling over from the wild in Wuhan. That's the definition of circumstantial evidence - it's possible but could just as easily be coincidence.

You are grasping at straws. The key features of Covid have been shown to have evolved naturally in the wild. In in fact some features been shown to have evolved multiple times independently. This IS evidence that the virus originated in wild animal populations.

Consider the mass of circumstantial evidence for a lab leak

Please do, this should be good for a laugh...

proximity to lab
Proximity to which lab? Lab leak proponents keep changing their mind. The lab they started off blaming is 20 miles away from where ANY early cases were found so they started looking for other labs nearer to where the cases occurred.

The fact is that the cases were not in the proximity of a lab they were in the proximity of the wet market.

databases vanishing

You mean the one Chinese time travelers took offline before any humans were even infected? Or is it now some other database because the first one didn't pan out?


Dazak writing letters pointing away from the lab etc etc etc.

A scientist wrote letters saying it wasn't a lab leak? If that isn't damming evidence it must have been a leak I don't know what is. :rolleyes:

I'm sure you know them all, having spent many pages of this thread handwaving them away as coincidence.
These so called coincidences were not "hand waved away" they were debunked. Thoroughly.

If you want to talk about hand-waving away coincidence, try looking at what needed to happen from the lab leak side of things.
- Chinese scientists must have had a suitable precursor to SARS-CoV-2 in their labs, but never documented it's existence like they did with other related corona viruses.
- There must have been at least 2 lineages of this same virus in these labs
- 2 different scientist much have become infected with different liniages at exactly the same time
- these 2 scientists both must have travel to the Wuhan fish market without infecting anyone before or after they got there
- In spite of not infecting anyone before or after they BOTH must have infected people in the fish market
- Also, both must have only visited the parts of the market where animals were kept and only infected people in that part of the market.


Now THAT is a lot of coincidence...








I wonder which is the more damning criticism of the Chinese people, that the general population just can't stop eating wild animals despite the possibility of cross contamination by wild viruses, or that the CCP is unable to ensure biosecurity at their labs.

People eat wild meat in the west all the time. People regularly hunt and eat any number of wild animals and restaurants all over North America and Europe serve things like venison.

What China has and the west doesn't are live wet markets where customers are exposed on mass to live animals. This is where the risk comes in. China is incredibly sensitive about calls to shut down these markets because their continued existence can be attributed to the government itself on not passed on to some random scientist who can be used as a scapegoat.
 
You are grasping at straws. The key features of Covid have been shown to have evolved naturally in the wild. In in fact some features been shown to have evolved multiple times independently. This IS evidence that the virus originated in wild animal populations.



Please do, this should be good for a laugh...


Proximity to which lab? Lab leak proponents keep changing their mind. The lab they started off blaming is 20 miles away from where ANY early cases were found so they started looking for other labs nearer to where the cases occurred.

The fact is that the cases were not in the proximity of a lab they were in the proximity of the wet market.



You mean the one Chinese time travelers took offline before any humans were even infected? Or is it now some other database because the first one didn't pan out?




A scientist wrote letters saying it wasn't a lab leak? If that isn't damming evidence it must have been a leak I don't know what is. :rolleyes:


These so called coincidences were not "hand waved away" they were debunked. Thoroughly.

If you want to talk about hand-waving away coincidence, try looking at what needed to happen from the lab leak side of things.
- Chinese scientists must have had a suitable precursor to SARS-CoV-2 in their labs, but never documented it's existence like they did with other related corona viruses.
- There must have been at least 2 lineages of this same virus in these labs
- 2 different scientist much have become infected with different liniages at exactly the same time
- these 2 scientists both must have travel to the Wuhan fish market without infecting anyone before or after they got there
- In spite of not infecting anyone before or after they BOTH must have infected people in the fish market
- Also, both must have only visited the parts of the market where animals were kept and only infected people in that part of the market.


Now THAT is a lot of coincidence...










People eat wild meat in the west all the time. People regularly hunt and eat any number of wild animals and restaurants all over North America and Europe serve things like venison.

What China has and the west doesn't are live wet markets where customers are exposed on mass to live animals. This is where the risk comes in. China is incredibly sensitive about calls to shut down these markets because their continued existence can be attributed to the government itself on not passed on to some random scientist who can be used as a scapegoat.

Thanks for proving my point about handwaving.. ;)
 
Thanks for proving my point about handwaving.. ;)
picture.php
 
Last edited:
Here you are dissing The Daily Fail after you used it as a source only a few posts upthread. :sdl:

BTW, I posted it because it referred to Lipkin, not because of anything it said about Koopmans. I should have made that more clear.

And another BTW, you reverted to your usual pattern, the information/evidence is no good because of the source, and if a source has a clickbait headline, same thing.

These guys are not the only ones coming around to the lab origin hypothesis. I don't have an exact count but it is more than were there originally (and there were a few like Tedros, head of the WHO) and the number has been growing steadily since.

Worobey got a few people excited he'd shown the market was the spillover source. But even that finding is being criticized by more and more people who recognize just how weak his study is.

I didn’t “use the Fail as a source”. I pointed out that David Asher went to the Fail to spread the story of the researcher’s wife getting sick with Covid and dying. Now that we have the names we should be able to cross reference that claim. Did Asher tell the truth to the Fail or should we now be more skeptical?

That is the point.
 
I didn’t “use the Fail as a source”. I pointed out that David Asher went to the Fail to spread the story of the researcher’s wife getting sick with Covid and dying. Now that we have the names we should be able to cross reference that claim. Did Asher tell the truth to the Fail or should we now be more skeptical?

That is the point.
What do you think a source is? :boggled: It's a citation where you saw/read something. It doesn't matter if you went to that site to answer a question or not. It doesn't matter if the source supports one side or another. It doesn't matter if you posted the source to add a new fact to the discussion.

Who are you cross-referencing? Ben Hu is next in line after Shi according to one of jt523's links. Ben's name comes up elsewhere IIRC. we know he works at the WIV.

The other two are described as
Yu Ping, and Yan Zhu. All were members of the Wuhan lab suspected to have leaked the pandemic virus.
Is that what you are talking about? Do you just want evidence they work at the WIV? We can see if they coauthored anything which is where I think I saw Ben Hu's name.
 
Last edited:
USA Office of the Director on National intelligence has released their report:

https://www.dni.gov/files/ODNI/docu...logy-and-the-Origins-of-COVID-19-20230623.pdf

In March, the IC updated its analysis on core intelligence questions related to
COVID-19 origins, to include whether the first human infection with SARS-CoV-2—the virus that causes COVID-19—was the result of natural exposure to an infected animal or a laboratoryassociated incident. Variations in IC analytic views on the origins of the COVID-19 pandemic largely stem from differences in how agencies weigh intelligence reporting and scientific publications and intelligence and scientific gaps. All agencies continue to assess that both a natural and laboratory-associated origin remain plausible hypotheses to explain the first human infection.

Almost all IC agencies assess that SARS-CoV-2 was not genetically
engineered. Most agencies assess that SARS-CoV-2 was not laboratory-adapted;
some are unable to make a determination. All IC agencies assess that SARS-CoV-2
was not developed as a biological weapon.
 
Last edited:
USA Office of the Director on National intelligence has released their report:

https://www.dni.gov/files/ODNI/docu...logy-and-the-Origins-of-COVID-19-20230623.pdf
I find all that consistent with the evidence I have seen except this:
Most agencies assess that SARS-CoV-2 was not laboratory-adapted

It depends on if you are only looking at US agencies and in this case the author might even be referring to a smaller sample: DNI= Dept of National Intelligence.

It's fine as long as people looking at that report know what they mean by "most agencies" or they might be misled. And of course from my POV, once a group of individuals, or independent researchers, or an agency etc come from a certain position, they are naturally disinclined to reverse that position. That confirmation bias has been rather blatant after Daszak led them all around by the nose in the beginning for a full year.

The fact many of those previously held POVs are gradually shifting away from a spillover to a lab origin and not many if any at all are shifting from the lab origin to a natural spillover is important.


On top of that you have to add in the news media reporting that Worobey's study was a game changer supported quickly thereafter with the release of genetic sampling that found raccoon dog DNA in, gasp!, the same stall at the seafood market as COVID RNA was found and they were off to the races.

When caution was noted that the volume of genetic material found in that stall was more suggestive of contamination by infected humans than it was suggestive the animals were the source, it got much less attention.
 
Outbreak control? You mean a hospital investigation of an outbreak?:rolleyes:

None of your arguments re China not releasing data are valid. They didn't need to disclose personal identifiers.

And with that, I believe this bit has run its course.

TB: school, factory, pub.
Meningitis; school, university (x2)
Q fever; slaughterhouse

Occupational health (for staff) and infection control teams deal with nosocomial issues.
 
I find all that consistent with the evidence I have seen

Not this...

Several WIV researchers were ill in Fall 2019 with symptoms;
some of their symptoms were consistent with but not diagnostic of COVID-19. The IC continues
to assess that this information neither supports nor refutes either hypothesis of the pandemic’s
origins because the researchers’ symptoms could have been caused by a number of diseases and
some of the symptoms were not consistent with COVID-19. Consistent with standard practices,
those researchers likely completed annual health exams as part of their duties in a highcontainment biosafety laboratory. The IC assesses that the WIV maintains blood samples and
health records of all of their laboratory personnel—which are standard procedures in highcontainment laboratories.
• We have no indications that any of these researchers were
hospitalized because of the symptoms consistent with COVID-19. One researcher
may have been hospitalized in this timeframe for treatment of a non-respiratory
medical condition.
• China’s National Security Commission investigated the WIV in early
2020 and took blood samples from WIV researchers. According to the World Health
Organization's March 2021 public report, WIV officials including Shi Zhengli—who
leads the WIV laboratory group that conducts coronavirus research—stated lab
employee samples all tested negative for SARS-CoV-2 antibodies.
While several WIV researchers fell mildly ill in Fall 2019, they
experienced a range of symptoms consistent with colds or allergies with accompanying
symptoms typically not associated with COVID-19, and some of them were confirmed to have
been sick with other illnesses unrelated to COVID-19. While some of these researchers had
historically conducted research into animal respiratory viruses, we are unable to confirm if any
of them handled live viruses in the work they performed prior to falling ill.

Link
 
What do you think a source is? :boggled: It's a citation where you saw/read something. It doesn't matter if you went to that site to answer a question or not. It doesn't matter if the source supports one side or another. It doesn't matter if you posted the source to add a new fact to the discussion.

Of course it matters.

I am not posting The Daily Fail with the claim that it is a reliable source. I am posting it specifically as an example of an unreliable source. David Asher chose them to speak to. That's an important distinction.


Who are you cross-referencing? Ben Hu is next in line after Shi according to one of jt523's links. Ben's name comes up elsewhere IIRC. we know he works at the WIV.

Sigh! No one disputes he works there. What I want is evidence that he was sick with Covid. You can say "multiple sources", but who cares? We know one of those could be David Asher. We know another could be Miles Yu. That's multiple sources right there. Are they reliable? NO! Did the intel they saw convince the intelligence community? NO!


The other two are described as
Is that what you are talking about? Do you just want evidence they work at the WIV? We can see if they coauthored anything which is where I think I saw Ben Hu's name.

No! I want to have evidence they were sick with Covid!

Do you have any? No!
 
Not this...

Link

Maybe you meant to reply to Marting because your post is a non sequitur to my post. I was replying to the bolded below:
Marting said:
... Almost all IC agencies assess that SARS-CoV-2 was not genetically engineered. Most agencies assess that SARS-CoV-2 was not laboratory-adapted;....

If you want to discuss what the report confirms or refutes about the three ill WIV workers that's best addressed separately, without misleading by quoting me out of context.

I'll look over the link and get back to you.
 
Of course it matters.

I am not posting The Daily Fail with the claim that it is a reliable source. I am posting it specifically as an example of an unreliable source. David Asher chose them to speak to. That's an important distinction.




Sigh! No one disputes he works there. What I want is evidence that he was sick with Covid. You can say "multiple sources", but who cares? We know one of those could be David Asher. We know another could be Miles Yu. That's multiple sources right there. Are they reliable? NO! Did the intel they saw convince the intelligence community? NO!




No! I want to have evidence they were sick with Covid!

Do you have any? No!

So from the Director of National Intelligence report (declassified; obviously i cannot quote from the still classified version).

While several WIV researchers fell mildly ill in Fall 2019, they experienced a range of symptoms consistent with colds or allergies with accompanying symptoms typically not associated with COVID-19, and some of them were confirmed to have been sick with other illnesses unrelated to COVID-19. While some of these researchers had historically conducted research into animal respiratory viruses, we are unable to confirm if any of them handled live viruses in the work they performed prior to falling ill.

https://t.co/sOfsHtR9ty
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom